With A Lot Of Karma, Is Liberation Possible?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025
  • www.eckharttol...
    In this Q&A sample clip, the mind is our obstacle, not the past. Sign up for a free trial and watch the full video here: www.eckharttoll...
    Subscribe to find greater fulfillment in life:
    www.youtube.co...
    Interested in diving deeper into Eckhart Tolle's work? Enjoy a FREE 10-DAY TRIAL to Eckhart Tolle Now: bit.ly/ET10Day
    Check out some of our other playlist:
    Meditation - bit.ly/2QkG5uU
    Our True Identity - bit.ly/2COKGTo
    Supporting Awakening - bit.ly/2O4M6dW
    Daily Life - bit.ly/2O70SRp
    Conversations with Guests - bit.ly/2MiB2Ig
    Connect with us elsewhere:
    www.EckhartToll...
    / eckharttolle
    / eckharttolle
    / eckharttolle
    / eckharttolle
    Eckhart Tolle is widely recognized as one of the most original and inspiring spiritual teachers of our time. He travels and teaches throughout the world.
    Eckhart is not aligned with any particular religion or tradition, but excludes none. His profound yet simple and practical teachings have helped thousands of people find inner peace, healing and greater fulfillment in their lives. At the core of his teachings lies the transformation of individual and collective human consciousness - a global spiritual awakening.
    Eckhart Tolle is the author of The Power of Now, a #1 New York Times Bestseller, which has been translated into 32 languages and become one of the most influential spiritual books of our time.
    In his most recent book, A New Earth, he shows how transcending our ego-based state of consciousness is not only essential to personal happiness, but also the key to ending conflict and suffering throughout the world.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 102

  • @BriaLafayette20
    @BriaLafayette20 9 років тому +233

    That made me tear up. "Thank you. I wish you well. You are on your way."

    • @itsmia5902
      @itsmia5902 7 років тому +14

      Bria Lafayette I'm teared up too. A great question and a perfect answer from Eckhart 💗

  • @Jayskiallthewayski
    @Jayskiallthewayski 6 років тому +133

    2 men involved in a moment of pure beauty. Faith in mankind restored. Thanx guys.

  • @yunyoung1111
    @yunyoung1111 6 років тому +102

    What a liberating message! The traditional concept of karma can make one powerless and trapped by egoic thinking. Thank you eckhart for this beautiful freeing message.

  • @thebotanicalmind
    @thebotanicalmind 9 років тому +79

    Eckhart you are a gift to the world. Thank you.

  • @sacredlight7667
    @sacredlight7667 4 роки тому +14

    This made me cry. What a blessing for this veteran to be liberated from guilt and shame by this master. ✨🙏✨

  • @NemeanLion-
    @NemeanLion- 4 роки тому +25

    I’m a casual follower and from experience I can say Eckhart is completely right. Suffering is the great “awakener”. It puts you on an accelerated path to who you truly are.

  • @kymduncan7031
    @kymduncan7031 8 років тому +70

    What you have suffered can become an extremely helpful thing in your life, because it is the great awakener. Find gratitude for this accelerated awakening experience. The Universe gave that to me because I needed it and it wanted me to awaken quickly. Surrender now to the unknown which is Liberation and Awareness in one. Thank you again for your wisdom Eckhart.

  • @burmanhands
    @burmanhands 9 років тому +84

    In my experience, awakening or self realisation can be gradual, 30 years plus of transcending in meditation changed me even without me realising it, I found compassion and peacefulness melting my stone heart. And also it can be sudden as in a 'mini death' when you step away from your egoic mind. For example if your personal life seems to utterly fail - you want to die but not as in suicide. So at that time you spontaneously let go your minds ability to make decisions about your fate - you surrender to the unknown - which is liberation, in one big jump. You are not the same after this, something has collapsed. This is possible in moments of extreme suffering, it cannot be faked or learned like a technique.
    I think conscious liberation really only starts when you understand this process has happened. I suppose liberation will continue infinitely and I love Being in the midst of doing.

    • @JD..........
      @JD.......... 9 років тому +3

      It varies astronomically...

    • @DanielNekvasil
      @DanielNekvasil 9 років тому +3

      +John Burman extreme suffering, or extreme love...

  • @kimmyqueen8009
    @kimmyqueen8009 4 роки тому +13

    I don’t know how it works for everyone I’m sure it differs from person to person, but it’s a work in progress you don’t just wake up one day feeling like you just had an epiphany. Maybe some people do but for me I’m not there I’m making conscious efforts to be present and happy. It’s not easy to not get upset sometimes I’m just learning to let it slide off of me. I’m focusing on my workouts trying to turn them into a routine. Also not easy! But it’s for my own good. I already feel like I’m at least on the latter working my way up 👍🏻 💪🏻 Eckhart Tolle and Jordon Peterson I can listen to all day 🙏🏼

  • @sophismpress
    @sophismpress 9 років тому +96

    Brilliant, beautiful response.

  • @1234kingconan
    @1234kingconan 9 років тому +146

    Man, I really feel his pain. Powerful video.

    • @rosisunny9302
      @rosisunny9302 7 років тому +2

      1234kingconan I Know you meant well,but it is not helping the Universal development,be joyfully and be thankful you did not need to go true this,as he has!!Im sure you have your challenges other wise, as we all do!!Lots off blessings to you from Germany.

  • @comjaunatne
    @comjaunatne 4 роки тому +11

    This could be titled as 'The Most Beautiful Video on UA-cam' and - it wouldn't even be click-bait

  • @kiwi007
    @kiwi007 7 років тому +12

    What a powerful person Eckhart Tolle is. Transforming lives.

  • @marionskinner4168
    @marionskinner4168 6 років тому +31

    My awakening came after a suicide attempt when I was 25. I can fully see how severe pain and suffering can lead to liberation. My nephew (age 25) committed suicide 7 weeks ago. Did I not have good karma that I heard the right words at the right time or that I was ready to be liberated? Why are some people ready, where others are literally destroyed by their identification with mind and circumstances?

  • @lulumystery
    @lulumystery 9 років тому +21

    Looking at you makes my heart sing, your words fill my soul, thank you.

  • @yawnyyellyglowyfloaty
    @yawnyyellyglowyfloaty 8 років тому +186

    The guy with the question is so brave. Hooray for that man! What an inspiration!

  • @corpuscallosum4677
    @corpuscallosum4677 9 років тому +13

    Beautiful Q and A. Both are needed for this brilliant interaction. One taught with revealing his negative propelling force while the other is leading us into the deep and impartial reality. Love you all.

  • @CosmicJonas
    @CosmicJonas 7 років тому +46

    Damn. Eckhart, you are the man. Haha that was so beautiful. Thank you thank you

  • @PutereaPrezentului
    @PutereaPrezentului 10 місяців тому

    A precious gift. I thank the Universe for bringing me here🙏

  • @Requiredfields2
    @Requiredfields2 9 років тому +12

    This is one of the best things I've seen in my life. I don't believe the universe wants me to do anything though. But it doesn't take away from the power of what I've seen just now.

    • @scutty4022
      @scutty4022 7 років тому

      don't believe anything

  • @jeffbilyeu884
    @jeffbilyeu884 9 років тому +18

    Very helpful reframe, Eckhart. Thank you

  • @lorettaharris978
    @lorettaharris978 9 років тому +9

    eckhart thank you so much i feel great everytime i listen you

  • @prabha5822
    @prabha5822 7 років тому +3

    Bold, precise & straight forward question.... Very Blessful , peaceful, loving, caring ... (n what's not.... words are always limited) answer by Sir Echkartt Toll ...
    Namste done at end is full of gratitude n satisfaction...
    Worth watching this for multiple times (especially if one is in Pain n suffering)
    Thanks

  • @beautifierwoman7957
    @beautifierwoman7957 9 років тому +1

    Eckhart... Vielen Dank für Ihre Bücher. Sie sind ein Engel.
    Grüße aus Indien.

  • @Loveee216
    @Loveee216 7 років тому +27

    This video I may watch milion times..so beautiful❤💕

  • @norexe1
    @norexe1 9 років тому +9

    Amo tanto a este hombre!!! Gracias infinitas!!! 😍

    • @SpiritualReform
      @SpiritualReform 9 років тому

      +Norexe exe Leave some love for me, will you? ;)

  • @datretranscripts9533
    @datretranscripts9533 9 років тому +26

    Datre said in one of their transcripts:
    ..."There are no 'accidents'. You plan 'everything' for whatever reason you 'want' to plan it. Then they'll say, 'I don't know why some people have so many problems?'. Because, your 'learning' process is to learn certain lessons that 'you' decided that 'you' wanted to learn - for your own evolution. Then they'll say, 'well, this tragedy and that tragedy and another tragedy keeps happening to that person all the time'. Well, if that person 'learned' from the 'first' tragedy, as it is called, there wouldn't have to be a second. It’s that simple"...
    That is similar to what Eckhart is pointing out when he says, " it was not by chance"

    • @nixlanas5528
      @nixlanas5528 9 років тому +1

      This makes a lot of sense. Thank you for sharing this.

    • @SpiritualReform
      @SpiritualReform 9 років тому

      +datre transcripts But..........there is nothing to learn from.

    • @burmanhands
      @burmanhands 9 років тому +4

      +datre transcripts Bentinho Massaro says something like, 'we made the present in the past and are making the future now - we must imagine a better future, to get one.' Otherwise if we live in a small box then we will keep on reproducing it for the future.

  • @MarcelinRuth
    @MarcelinRuth 7 років тому +3

    Thanks to be who you are !

  • @BlondeManNoName
    @BlondeManNoName 9 років тому +12

    Another great video from Tolle, acceptance and forgiveness stops the wheel of karma.

  • @Tobias_Kevorkazito
    @Tobias_Kevorkazito 7 років тому +10

    My body is shaking after seeing this.

  • @minimalista2023
    @minimalista2023 6 років тому +2

    So wundervoll, lieber Meister Eckhart!!! 💛

  • @frazerburns91
    @frazerburns91 9 місяців тому

    Loving encouragement. Unreal

  • @Kain1231
    @Kain1231 9 років тому +11

    Wonderful talk,it helps a lot to listen.
    Got to point out the very emotional lady at 5:08 on the right ;-D

    • @xelavs3654
      @xelavs3654 7 років тому +6

      I think it's the wife of the guy who asked the question.

  • @ninavirmani6662
    @ninavirmani6662 9 років тому +4

    Always the best!

  • @fabiolatgg
    @fabiolatgg 7 років тому +3

    En un momento sentí que me hablaba a mi, y empecé a llorar pero con liberación y gozo.

  • @bluesky6028
    @bluesky6028 6 років тому +2

    Great question! Thank you so much Eckhart for that wonderful reply ! Very inspirational!

  • @andreabertozzi8199
    @andreabertozzi8199 7 років тому +2

    Love you Ekchart

  • @wonka4
    @wonka4 7 років тому +3

    So Powerful

  • @IolandaAdinolfi
    @IolandaAdinolfi 7 років тому +29

    Did you notice the blonde woman in the back, on the right?

  • @josief8053
    @josief8053 6 років тому

    Thank you so much Eckhart Tolle 💞🙏👏👍👍👏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @orlandocontreras4768
    @orlandocontreras4768 5 років тому +3

    You're on your way. :)

  • @la1negrita
    @la1negrita 9 років тому +5

    always amazing!

  • @PerseusSagittarius
    @PerseusSagittarius 6 років тому

    Thank you, master. I love you Eckhart!

  • @hermelindazepeda5627
    @hermelindazepeda5627 5 років тому

    Beautiful. Just so Beautiful

  • @manyhumbles
    @manyhumbles 9 років тому +4

    I think the questioners "karma" is what might have been a catalyst and blessing to his awakening. Karma is simply discordant energy that can be integrated through awareness of everything being pure and divine. It is that simple and we have remembered it is that simple through those that have walked before us and allow us the 'assumption' of the same.

    • @emu.2219
      @emu.2219 8 років тому +2

      +gentle deer 'discordant energy'... I like that. Thank you for this comment it's given me greater insight.

  • @talmage_ur
    @talmage_ur 4 роки тому

    Thank you for this accelerated awakening. I have no complaint. ; )

  • @saraaime4732
    @saraaime4732 6 років тому

    You are wonderful Elkhart 🙏

  • @factsfun1688
    @factsfun1688 5 років тому +1

    Love you Eckhart ❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍

  • @Heidilambach
    @Heidilambach 6 років тому +1

    So powerfull and so beautiful! THANK YOU

  • @mounirbaroudi5890
    @mounirbaroudi5890 6 років тому

    3:55 great!

  • @malikattar9439
    @malikattar9439 6 років тому +4

    and it is precisely at the worst time the opportunities are the Greatest

  • @bluebird5584
    @bluebird5584 5 років тому

    Thankyou so much🙏🙏🙏

  • @ectogroupcanada850
    @ectogroupcanada850 7 років тому +1

    Beautiful.

  • @julienx1
    @julienx1 5 років тому

    Great question. Thank you

  • @Simon0
    @Simon0 7 років тому +9

    i love the guys clear eyes. (not Eckhart the questioner)

  • @Liz-vm8kb
    @Liz-vm8kb 6 років тому

    Thank you so much for this.

  • @cumiral
    @cumiral 9 років тому

    Indeed, a very good reminder . Thank you both of you :)!

  • @carlosantuckwell
    @carlosantuckwell 8 років тому

    Wonderful advice, and perception!

  • @jamescontactyelena
    @jamescontactyelena 7 років тому

    Awakening makes me happy :)

  • @carmiiioi57
    @carmiiioi57 5 років тому

    Beautiful smile. 😊

  • @TheOmnipresent12
    @TheOmnipresent12 9 років тому +2

    Deep.

  • @yodhakei
    @yodhakei 6 років тому

    Beautiful video..

  • @stevemueller4703
    @stevemueller4703 6 років тому

    ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ This.

  • @TrevorMarty69
    @TrevorMarty69 9 років тому +3

    This is hard for me too.

  • @umeshgurjar4304
    @umeshgurjar4304 4 роки тому

    I respect echart but there is next level when indian englitened pepole like OSHO,j krishanamurti, ramkrishnan paramhansa , vevikanda and a lot many ,they are at another level . ❤️

  • @malikattar9439
    @malikattar9439 6 років тому +7

    to have a good karma is not a liberation because you are not free of the conditioning of the mind

  • @malikattar9439
    @malikattar9439 6 років тому +3

    the universe did that to you because you needed it, and to awake you quickly.

  • @yogidevimaat9304
    @yogidevimaat9304 6 років тому +3

    A true Buddha. This man was completely transformed

  • @infinity401
    @infinity401 8 років тому +1

    Does anyone know the music at the end?

  • @sarvgrover
    @sarvgrover 4 роки тому

    Gradual improvement comes with time

  • @2000longleaf
    @2000longleaf 9 років тому +1

    Please read the story of greatist tibetan yogi Milarepa.

  • @aytanguluzade5093
    @aytanguluzade5093 4 роки тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @nightanday9376
    @nightanday9376 7 років тому +6

    I like this person the more I hear him. I wish I never got involved in christianity, and wish I had went to teachings like this. Christianity brought me nothing but misery and fear, by my own choosing.

    • @depressionbeard9882
      @depressionbeard9882 6 років тому +5

      nightan day why create drama by wishing for things in the past to be different. After all, the misery and fear that Christianity has caused you brought you to Eckhart. Now. Listen again to the lesson in this video. It pertains exactly to you. Don’t let the mind misinterpret the past or that will be your biggest obstacle. Exactly what Eckhart told that soldier.

  • @eric5r
    @eric5r 9 років тому +2

    0:59-1:01 that voice crack tho

  • @ricardosancheztellez9245
    @ricardosancheztellez9245 7 років тому

    Alguien me puede hacer un resumen en español?? Porfavorrrr

  • @gretanavarauskaite2904
    @gretanavarauskaite2904 4 роки тому

    ❤️

  • @_thechosen
    @_thechosen 8 років тому +4

    I am not sure his real question was answered. I think he actually wanted to know about reincarnation cycle and whether it can be stopped with a lot of karma.
    People seem to think of karma as a bad thing because it will increase your time being on earth as you accumulate more of it. However the speaker seems to imply that karma is necessary for evolution of your soul. So would that mean that whole reincaranation cycle is important as well for your soul to evolve to its ultimate destination as if caterpillar would evolve into butterfly?
    Are we here to experience cycle of reincarnations with that purpose and we should surrender to the fact that our being here may last more than we would want and be content that this is only for the better?

    • @xelavs3654
      @xelavs3654 7 років тому +1

      His question was: Can liberation be stopped by too much karma? And Tolle answered: you can break out of the karma cycle at any given moment, and become liberated....He steps away from the popular belief that you need to wait for a moment in the future to be liberated, as time does not exist, only the now.

    • @mariagricius6378
      @mariagricius6378 7 років тому

      thechosen I wonder how many life times you asked that question? Did you remember your last life? Perhaps that is solely the ego asking? What if the answer is that you are here or wherever your higher self puts you, as long as you have lessons to learn and new things to experience and only your higher self, which is you, your very highly evolved self only knows that answer? But, alas, we do have free will, to a point, here.

    • @turiya9526
      @turiya9526 7 років тому +1

      I had the same thoughts when I watched the video. In eastern philosophy lot of spiritual teachers talk about working out one's karmas. Serve, love, and create good karmas so you are born in an environment and body that is conducive to taking up Yoga (any path of Yoga) for your liberation. Sometimes I wonder is it as simple as finding presence at one moment, what about all the years of unconscious living, negative evil thoughts. What is the best way I can burn my karma. So many questions :p

  • @malikattar9439
    @malikattar9439 6 років тому +1

    woow

  • @3506Dodge
    @3506Dodge 7 років тому +2

    Why doesn't the universe give us enlightenment now? Why does it make us wait?

    • @GBoysEntertainment
      @GBoysEntertainment 7 років тому +11

      3506Dodge , you are the universe and it’s always now. So there is no separate universe to give you anything and there is no time to wait. You are everything in this moment.

  • @AXharoth
    @AXharoth 9 років тому

    this funny woman

  • @3506Dodge
    @3506Dodge 7 років тому

    He doesn't believe in chance?

    • @depressionbeard9882
      @depressionbeard9882 6 років тому +2

      3506Dodge no spiritual teacher I know believes in chance. Everything is exactly as it’s supposed to be. Or else it would not be so.

  • @thelifeofsantiii
    @thelifeofsantiii 9 років тому +1

    lol some people shouldnt ask questions, more of lettting the questions go.

  • @maninajena
    @maninajena 9 років тому +1

    En français , il y'a personne qui peu faire la tranditions en français

    • @mard9802
      @mard9802 9 років тому +1

      manina jena Mon francais c'est terrible mais >>>L' homme etais en Afghanistan (militaire) et il veut savoir si est possible obtenir la liberation avec beaucoup de karma dans ca vie. Il a lire le livre The Power of Now et on a changer ca vie. Tolle a dire que aucunne personne croire che le bon karma c'est une progression d'une vie a une autre vie, mais non est vrai. Durante des moments avec la souffrance tres intense c'est une opportunite de outrepasser le karma. Ca souffrance a porter cet homme ici et c'est importante de non interpreter ce que il a fait dans ca vie comme un forme d' identite de deculpabilite. L'homme a participe dans un grand forme de inconscience durante la guerre et il a repondu a cette situation avec yoga, meditation et a trouve le livre de Tolle. Tolle a dire che cet homme est dans un chemin d'eveil accelere est che l'experience de intense souffrance a commencer son chemin et il peut avoir gratitude pour qui est arrive dans le passe. Tolle a dit d'etre reconnaissants et permettre le presense de fusion par lui. L'univers donne cela a-t'il parce-qu'on a besoin qu'il reveiller rapidment.

  • @thaiboxer8047
    @thaiboxer8047 7 років тому

    Sorry but to disidentify yourself from your egoic mind doesn't delete your bad karma, the guy was a soldier and perhaps has killed many people and he'll pay for that either in this lifetime or the next cycle.