Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Who are the Indians? Debunking the Aryan Invasion Theory | Dr. Raj Vedam |
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 сер 2024
- About the Talk:
In this talk, Dr. Raj Vedam systematically breaks down the various accounts, both internal and external on the Aryan invasion theory. Multiple scientific facts have been presented in this articulate talk which in turn would help the viewers uncover deeper truths about a spurious theory promoted to break the unity of Bharat. Perspectives from genetics, genealogy, astronomy, history have been expressed in a simple yet impactful way in this lecture.
About the Speaker:
Dr. Raj Vedam, MSEE, Ph.D., works at the confluence of applied mathematics, engineering, algorithms, and computer science. Using tools of Archeo-Genetics, archeo- astronomy, and archaeology, and evidence of knowledge transfers from ancient India, the speaker has put forward a strong thesis with verifiable facts, on the antiquity of the Indian Civilisation, and the many discoveries made by the ancients. Dr. Raj Vedam is a co-founder of the think-tank, Indian History Awareness, and Research, and resides in Houston, Texas.
He can be reached at rajvedam@yahoo.com
Topics covered:
00:00 Introduction
00:32 Internal Accounts of Indian History
05:35 External Accounts of Indian History
11:25 Understanding Historiography
22:30 Rebutting enforced Historiography
25:52 Human Presence in India
41:26 Antiquity of Indian Astronomy
01:04:00 Rebuttal to AIT through Astronomy
1:07:30 Conclusion
1:10:42 QnA
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @sangamtalks
Join our UA-cam channel to get updated on new video releases:
Hindi : / sangamhindi
English : / sangamtalks
Tamil : / @sangamtamizh
Punjabi : / @sangampunjabi
Bhojpuri : / @sangamtalksbhojpuri
Marathi : / @sangammarathi
Malayalam : / @sangammalayalam
Shorts : / @sangamtalkstv
Bangla : / @sangambangla
For updates you may follow us on:
Facebook : / sangamtalks
Instagram : / sangamtalks
Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
Twitter : / sangamtalks
Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va95...
Linkedin: / sangamtalks
Koo : www.kooapp.com/profile/sangam...
Website : www.sangamtalks.org
Donate : www.sangamtalks.org/donate
I love this man!
Thanks so much for all this mind opening, and blowing, information.
I have accepted the entire Western party line, regarding the Aryan invasion, language dating and all, for my entire adult life--and I am old!
But clearly, there's so much more than what has been shoved down our collective throats for all these decades, centuries even.
I shall seek out more of Raj ji's lectures. Great job, sir! Mahalos! 🤙🇮🇳🪷
Aloha and Pacific Breezes back at ya, amidst another 'reset' planned and concurrently being fostered.
Thank you Dr Raj Vedanta for this wonderful information. You made me proud to be an Indian. My ancestors left India in the early 1800 and settled in Malaya. We lost all trace. Thank you
Dr Raj Vedam ji thank you so much for this full evidenced based history. Dandavat Pranam to you.
I ama freethinking American who enrourages Indians to contnue being the awesome selves they a;ready aer and strive for free thought and study. Strive for truth whether people like you a ir not, and i love you. naanri.
Dr. Raj Vedam is a treasure house of knowledge. May Saraswati continue to bless him. Jai Saraswati Sindh
This is outstanding work. It is a great lesson at many levels. It is the conquerors that write history. It gives them a sense of superiority. They feel they are right. It entitles them to dominate, destroy and dictate the documentation of their actions.
Islam treated knowledge with contempt. Nothing could be better than what it had to say. Books and tradition of debates were seen as a challenge. Nalanda was burnt to ashes. Culture and knowledge receded.
Christians came with the same outlook of a believer. They respected science and facts. The age of reason had set in. However, they felt their knowledge was recent and superior. They wrote history of Indians for the Indians. It served their belief in their superiority and allowed them to shape the minds of their lesser subjects - the Indians.
India became free. But electoral vote bank politics ensured a minority and the Communist parties to dictate. Indian governments adopted socialism as the path forward. Support of the communists was necessary for Congress to remain in power. Marxist historians were authorized to write history.
Islam, Christians and Marxists - all three - write with the bias and prejudice of the victorious. Indians (Hindus, Sikhism Buddhists, Jains ) are considered inferior. These people are ignorant, primitive and holding on to ancient practices and traditions. They deserve to be uplifted and enlightened. This is beyond patronizing. It is offensive.
Even today, all three are united, with the help of self hating liberals. They feel threatened. They keep us from our culture and history. But a resurgent India shall overcome. Our dharmic culture is rich and timeless. Let us unite and change what we are taught.
well said!
Its a shame to see only 68k views on this masterpiece
partly due to today's culture of instant gratification. Any video longer than a few minutes is just too long! :-\
Dr. Vedam should be given Bharat’s highest award. He’s bringing our rich civilization to light from a pure scientific approach like never seen before
We are Bharat-in-(re)Making. Padma Sri is fine for now, as 2 more Padma awards above that are mostly "reserved" 😅
Verywell said. The Christian British killed our heritage. But sir what our Govt is doing to changeable this. We must correct the history. Jayaram
Great insights 😊 lot of hard work 👏
What a brilliant podcast! India's rays are reaching us finally!
God job sir ji 💯💯💯
TKNR TKNR FROM SRI LANKA THANKS TO THE DR,RAJ VERDANTA FOR PROVIDING A CLEAR EXPLANATION WHICH IS A WONDERFUL EDUCATED SCIENTIFIC ADVANCED TECHNOLOGICAL THAT COMMUNITIES AND FUTURE GENERATION'S SHOULD LEARN, ❤❤❤😊
now you suddenly gets the information which was not available in the past and sounds totally alien, till you hear this couple of times.. Amazing!! thank you!!
Thank you Dr Raj Vedam, very well reserched , information hope the government take note and make the necessary changes
Outstanding! I cannot wait. Please provide a bibliography so that viewers can examine the evidence for themselves. I have always believed that India's culture originated far earlier than some "Aryan invasion."
Yes isn’t there a story of monkeys that could tell in India and they ran along a land bridge to another island or continent or something like MU.
@@koltoncrane3099they were vanar , which means human of forest who uses Kapidwaja ( flag of monkey )
Just like pandya kingdom used fish flag that does not mean they are fish race
And about Hanuman god , valmiki mentioned Hanuman as Vedic god marut ( companion of indra , form of related to rudra ) not monkey god
@@greaterbharat4175 They were not "humans of the forest", they were much more than that. This whole "vanar" means "people of the forest" is just modern day copium. Valmiki clearly mentions they are monkeys i.e. ape-like! Scientifically speaking it's very much possible they were just another species of Humans who possibly went extinct at the end of the last ice age.
Yes@@greaterbharat4175
the aboriginal culture of Australia talk about a time 10,000 years ago when you could walk from India to Australia. Geologically that would have been at the peak of the most recent Ice Age. At that time sea levels would have been much lower and one could indeed walk from India to Australia.
SIMPLY AMAZING THANKS
Incredible information by Dr. Raj Vedam. How do we imbibe this in the next generation?
Maybe take it to non-congress government, education ministry, to upgrade curriculum. Last 20 years, the education system is being adjusted in Canada from the Indigenous ( native) peoples view.
So good. Is there a good actual history of India text at the advanced university level? thanks
This is a great summary to share with young Indians. 🙏🙏
Very nice sir. Central Govt didn't do anything in last many years. Time to change History Books with 'facts' and not with 'opinions'.
❤How much hidden historical treasure is to be given full exposure to our own people. ❤
Arya and Dravida are not race names and not opposed to each other. Arya is a title for the educated and powerful leader. Dravida indicated Southern Peninsula-with Ocean on three sides. They indicate the Brahmins, those in the North were called Pancha-Gaura (Pancha-Gauda) and those in the South were called Pancha-Dravida - five groups in each. The western rulers used it to divide India and rule as Dravidian race and Aryan race just to rule over the land. Most recent genetic study on Asians show that Indians (South-Asians) has a mix of Homo-Sapien genes along with a mix of Homo-Neanderthal genes in more than 80% of the population - while the Europeans have it only among 20%. Indians also have a large portion of Denisovan Genes mixed. This mix is seen all over India. This is the racial and genetic structure in India. Just think about this. Homo-Sapien Genes which is dominant all over is originally from Central Africa. Neanderthal race is from Europe, and Denisovan is a genetic group or race from Central Asia. There is no such thing as Aryan language and Dravidian Language. They all evolved from the same root.
I’ve seen charts I thought that said aryan language and their derivatives. Aryan is another term for Indo European I read.
And idk if aryan is a race or not. I know the U.S. government treats the fictional race called Latino as a race that they created. If you’re Latin American you’re racially now Latino and no longer Native American or African American or white. Think about it. If Latino was not created a huge portion of immigrants coming from Latin America would have made it so the African American population in the U.S. of the demographics percentage would have gone way up. Same with Native American and probably would have increased whites too.
But if aryan isn’t a race it does make me suspicious. Why then have I seen old pictures of buddhas having blue eyes? It’s like there’s some old paintings or objects that makes me think there were some different races there in India.
Also look up Easter island off of Latin America. Academics will say native Americans built it. But the statues on the island have beards! Like native Americans today don’t have beards.
And if ya look up the Paiute Native American tribe in Nevada, U.S., their oral history says they wiped out a redheaded tribe. Surely a redheaded tribe would have been a different race than the normal Native American that exists today.
Blue eyes indicate eyes of wisdom. Colours means nothing. Brahma has red body,Vishnu has blue body, Lord Shiva has milk white body @@koltoncrane3099
Exactly 💯
Jokes
Sadly India continues to believe the education of McCauley, despite the west recognising these theories were outdated 50 years ago, yet even today as this lecture shows, India is hanging on to these long discredited assumptions. It's great to see you bring this teaching forward to be in line with current western thinking on the Aryan invasion. Thanks
Shat shat pranam 🙏 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ prof. Shri RajVedam ji
Thanks!
Well done, Dr Raj.....amazing presentation backed by facts, evidence and logic. Unfortunately, even the present dispensation not able to change the ecosystem.
Brilliant❤Salute you Dr. Vedam 🙏 for presenting a correct evidence based perspective.
Loved the talk. glad that people like you are here fighting for us. I am very much grateful to you.
Really well said
Thank you for the truth!🙏🙏
Sir, great research truth you have told. And I have supporting theory, which I have written in 2014. That ancient human originated in India too. I want to contact and mention this theory of origin of man. Please let know how I can contact you, sir. I am from Mysore.
Please email him..
If you check description, his email is given there...
The most, the most exhaustive, knowledgeable
Great talk by Dr Vedam as always! I am also interested in looking at the slides during the presentation, along with looking at the speaker. One earnest request I have is to have the slide take up most of the screen of the video presentation, and the speaker could be an insert in a corner - something I have seen with Nilesh Oak's presentations on Sangam talks. A lot of context is lost when slides are not seen, or when the speaker is pointing out something on the slide during the talk. Are the slide packs available to view online?
Beautifully described our vedangs
Excellent Sir
Great talk Dr. Raj Vedam. Although I do not fully agree with what you say, Its great to see places documented and mapped, along with citations and literature to come up with chronology. However, I believe that the buck stops with genetics (R1A and specifically Indian R1A1 present in higher blends amongst North India and its relation to Iranians and Europeans means we quite definitely know of two major mutations within the subcontinent).
Occam's Razor tells us this is highly unlikely in a mostly contiguous landmass south of the Himalayas.
Occam's Razor also tells us based on the spread of the genes that it should have originated somewhere in between.
Furthermore, our history has very little to say of conquerors, travelers and lands beyond the subcontinent. Also a generally insular description of the Mlecchas across our borders. Going to other kingdoms has not been with us due to an isolated and unique culture along with agroeconomic opulence (tribals at best known to have migrated are Romanis from a not so recent past).
Taking all into consideration, Out of India is highly implausible.
Sir genetics is a complex subject to understand but you are correct. Best verification is genetic data snd patterns in it. For a rookie, what's a good starting point to learn genetics especially to better verify historical and archaelogical theories or findings?
Hoping to hear and learn more.
Nice to see you and listen 🎶 you all
Truth is coming out bit by bit ❤
Great piece of eye opener, your lecture is...Sir...
Thank You very much and Pronam....
Excellent talk
Hope Indian education system rewrites our history books in collaboration with Indian historians who have expertise on our glorious past
Good job guru ji 🙏🙏
Yes. You are correct. Late His Holiness Shri Chandrasekaranda Saraswathi (Maha Periyavar) had also expressed doubts over Chandra Gupta era. His Holiness has mentioned that Megathenes has written when Samudragupta was in power and not Chandragupta Maurya.
Thanks Dr. Raj Vedam. why NCERT still not revamped when we have these kind of intelligent people around which can fix the whole system.
Is the Aryan- Dravidian nonsense being teached in schools in India?
Yes
Sadly yes. Fuck modi. Doesn't do anything.
Unfortunate lies embedded to retain the colonial mindset after independence. Psychologically we became free in 2014.
@@saurabhsurve9247we got a little freedom under Indira Ghandi and Atal buhari Vajpaye
@@Bellx1-f4d lol under Indira gandhi 😂😂...
I am a proud Tamil , proud of my culture and tradition . You must also be proud of yours . Don’t give up your own traditions even for showing patriotism.
YES, WE INDIANS MUST STICK TOGETHER, THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN NORTH AND SOUTH WE ARE ALL INDIANS!
@@Blastizor you just must tell this to PM who had said “the keys of Ratna Bhandar, the inner chamber of the Shri Jagannath Temple in Puri, had been taken to Tamil Nadu.”
Very useful talk. Does Dr. Raj vedam provide source links that he has referred to in this talk.
20:25 perfect!
superb.
Very nice topic.
what ?? u are a muslim and agree with debunking of Aryan Invasion theory
Thanks
Thanks a ton for all this information 🙏
The people, whether hunterers, food gatherers or farmers had always been moving from densely populated areas to other places in search of better opportunities. Population of India is many times than that of Iran and Central Asia. It must have been like that only thousands of years ago. The simple logic shows that our ancestors must have travelled to other area and not the vice versa.
Even Europeans at that time were not as white as we see them today, they were kind of olivish colour
Even Europeans at that time were not as white as we see them today, they were kind of olivish colour
Excellent
Amazing explanation
Great Sir scholarly explanation of painful subject in simple language 👏
In what world is this simple are u dumb ?
@@dJ.HuMaPhoenix111u are dumb women here if u can't understand what he's saying just go doing your dehati reels
Absolutely true
I don’t know why he hasn’t done a PHD on it and prove his point.
And why Tamil is the oldest language in the world out dating Sanskrit, but don’t have any similarities with it?
Tamil texts dont refer to any of this aryan invasion theory nor does ancient sanskrit texts. Come our of your Dravidianism mindset
Excellent sir...my pranaams..
Thankyou sir for doing such research and opening our eyes to the whitewashing of our history.
Really hope you publish a book providing all the evidences just like you did in this video to increase your reach 😊
Sir you are great ❤❤❤💯💯💯💯💯thanks for giving this information ❤❤❤❤
Thank you sir for giving this talk and putting it here on youtube!
The British are the worst thing that has happened to India. Well, okay, maybe 2nd worst. Turkik invasions are arguably the worst. Not only did the Turks kill millions and destroy hundreds (thousands?) of temples, but they also burned libraries, thru erasing India's records of the past. Thanks to your work, Dr. Vedam, and the work of others, India's magnificent history is being rediscovered, and the deliberate rewriting of history by the arrogant fools from England--who believed the world was only 6000 years old and therefore had to change India's history to make it fit their fantasy--is being corrected.
Thank uamillionbutwillthe gh ov take steps to change the his education in bharat
Mahaperiyava has discussed how in the Vedas itself it is mentioned that the world is portioned into different regions. Rishis travelled to these regions and spread the Vedas so Sanskrit spread. Southern Russian dialects have more Sanskrit loanwords and sounds than Northern dialects because the Rishis went first to the South and only then, a fewer number of them expanded to the North. You may ask, why do western scholars not point to this fact if it in the Vedas? The answer is that, nobody today even knows whether the translations of people such as Max Mueller of Indian texts are complete because texts have been lost over time. Mahaperiyava is most knowledgable in the Vedas. If you respect knowledgable geneticists when discussing genetics, trust people who have learned the Vedas in the proper way such as Mahaperiyava, not those who translate it with a simple degree in Sanskrit. No way they will understand the nuances and intricacies of the Vedas.
❤❤❤
World before 🌎 and after 🌎you prove or disprove this Aryan theory .
So just preach and promote the ideals of Vedas and upnishads/ vedanta then only we can stop our people from conversion as vedas and our Rishis are so scientific that we can even convert atheists who believe in science .
But we are lacking large population of people who understands vedas and upnishads and indian philosophical schools in exact terms in which they were written by our rishis.
This will hit rational hindus. Western propaganda directly hit at out faith by proving false discontinuity in our culture. Any rational people would have these doubts thinking did people in 3500 bce worshipped lord krishna and all that..world will change for those people who are having doubts
@@baebae3373what’s your point ?
Aryan invaders from euresia destroyed 3 lakhs Buddhist viharas and stupas and adopted every Buddha and bodhi sattava statue into devis and devtas.
😂😂😂😂😂 bimte spotted
ye mat bhul Buddha ar br Ambedkar dono Aryan hi h
maxplank institute and heggarty et al has now agreed that vedic sanskrit was in india by atleast 4000 bce.
Please add subtitles
As Modi said: काल चक्र बदल रहा है
Things will change
The question is: Are we ready for change?
If Indians migrated out of India where are the South Asian genetics in the European populations? Has a study already been done?
I didn't find intelligent student questions unfortunately 😞. I wished much more intriguing interesting questions from the young students
My book rewrites world history
🙏🙏🙏
Dr. Raj, the British coined the term India! I feel you should use the term Bharat! Also if you have a presentation in video-cast, please leave it longer for the viewers, we can hear your voice even when we see the presentation.
Most of the currently living Indians have Harappan ancestry. The so called Dravidians are fighting over a small percentage of the ancestry.
They just want some sympathy I guess
1:58 Indians went outside of Bharat 🇮🇳
Yes , they went outside as IT professionals !
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg 💯 agree, history repeats.
@@tm-vg8rx But not as propagaters of sanskrit from india to outside !
Why not Mr. Raj Vedam publish a peer revioewed research paper then ?
Hello, You have so many followers and viewers. I have a request. Indian citizens are planning domestic and international holidays during summer vacations. I know that its hot and holiday is a required reprieve especially for children. Please request them to not be complacent but to caste their votes before they leave! Thank you
Thank you for publishing this info on YT . Very helpful
Mexicans do not claim Spanish came from Mexico or that Christianity originated in Mexico. And Mexicans know that Russian, for example, is linguistically closer to Spanish than either is to Mayan or Nahuatl. Likewise Russian is closer linguistically to Hindi than either is to Tamil.
30,000/- years before ICE age, the pure Tamils were only lived in all around asia. During ICE age period those tamils were modified lingual genetically due to cold weather. Then the sounds of tamil words like sa, ka, pa, been changed to Jha, gha, bha. Later 5000 years before there were major cross breed marriages happened at Egypt, Israel and Iran accordingly the total modified Tamil language then converted to Sanskrit, Arabic, Iranian, Afghan upto Malayalam. Those cross breeds were from Iran israel are called now as Aryans.
What is the basis and evidence for your claims?
Tamil doesn't even have enough alphabets to support it's pronounciations 😅😅😅. Why would anyone with a sane mind accept that language.
You just have some extreme kind of superiority complex
Languages are normally spread by conquest and / or genocide. Recently Indian scholars have made the claim that all Indo-European languages originated in the Indian subcontinent, citing such things as similarities between Lithuanian and Sanskrit.
So here’s the problem. Did the original people of India, those who spoke an Indo-European language, engage in conquest and perhaps genocide in Asia, in order that Indo-European languages are now predominant in Europe and Asia?
I did listen to one documentary talking about how Arabs invaded India which is why there’s Islam there. Then there also was the mongols that invaded India which is interesting. It’s like if Iran means land of the Aryana which might have been Persians back in the day maybe a group from Iran did invade India.
Isn’t there also sites in India with nuclear radiation suggesting potential nuclear warfare thousands of years ago? A lot of things may have happened that aren’t talked about. Look at Easter island with statues with beards. Native Americans don’t have beards but were told there was no global trade. Or there’s the Chinese story of China sending ships to the East or one story of Chinese fleeing China due to genocide and coming to the Americas. Some people say the Olmec may have been Africans but once I heard the Chinese story I think Chinese being the Olmec makes more sense. Look at the big wide stone faces carved by the Olmec. The facial structure looks wider like an Asian than African.
Yes - the entire world's history has been systematically destroyed by "centralized education". But what Indian will ever even contemplate not sending their child to centralized education to be indoctrinated into a cult member of "modernism" - with the dream that maybe one day i can be exported to their country and contribute more to their culture and leave behind india.
We have all been fooled and are like the frog being ever so slowly cooked and anyone who says so is given a pejorative label of some sort.
🙏🙏🙏🙏
When ravanas body was brought his wife cried calling aryaputra
Puranas were written at the time of Akbar Emperor your analysis is wrong, there was no Devanagari in those days
7200 back people moved West from Genga river bank.
They call as Nabataean dynasty.
All I hope is.... he is not trying to divide India...
nobody is superior nobody is inferior....all Indians are one and same yet diverse...respecting and celebrating our differences
And not just trying to disprove Aryan invasion theory only
I have a doubt when did continental drift happened ?
Now they have also started spreading a new hypothesis indo-european language family
Sanskrit is the closest language to the PIE language, and it developed in India. The Yamnaya people of the Steppe region who went to Europe and killed all the men, and took the women as partners, they were Indians, you see it in their appearance with brown skin and black hair. They were either kings who lost wars in India and had to leave the land and find a new home, or they were exiled criminals from India who went to Europe and made it their new home. I believe the first one better because our texts talk about this.
@@Blastizor proof trust me bro
The trading and flow of ideas is wild. How like skipping record the same rinse repeat seems to occur well into our own times.
Self awareness movements 500bc ,year 1 ,again in 500ad 1300 -1500s ad a long spell till 1700s-1800s. Suppressed all through the 1900s and now finally 2024 everyone seems to be catching on to this hierarchy trick again. Lol
Please show inscriptions.
Who is living in 3 said water is dravida.
Aryan means Europe,
Aryan brahmins are Muslims(refer Halal) and Christians(refer caderism)
Aryan invasion is mere illegal immigrant and refugees from Europe
During 10 to 18 th century there was constant communal violence in Europe between various fractions of the christian communities, and wars between Christian and Islamic communities.
So there was a inflow of refuges into middle east, Persian region(a hindu country at that time), into India and to indochina regions.
This massive human migration totally altered the world order and after that the new world took over and the human civilization met with the great wars destroying the old world order.
😂😂
You are funny 😂😂
This is right.
@@YinYanUzumaki
This is not my own views madam,
If you study european history and contemporary history of indian subcontinent, from 6th to 18th centurary, we can find evidence.
Even archeology evidence are there. google and check the facts for your self.
@@user-pl6up6tv3q I have infact googled to no end and as per scientists and evidences till date it has not been proved . Watch the reports on Rakhigarhi evidence .
There is also archaeological evidence of horse cart that has been found in sinhauli .
Please don’t get carried away . There is no scientific evidence of Aryan invasion or even migration for that matter .
Yes true lot of damage was done but fairly they cannot change our base
Brilliant! Enjoy Dr. Vedam no matter how many times I hear him. He speaks with passion and conviction!
A very enlightening discussion.. a great insight in to time and instants .
but today’s humanity is a single cluster want to live in peace.. another cluster bent on destroying happiness and peace .
Today’s humanity’s targets are different.. particularly it’s now divided into very rich and very poor.. Babylon and Kashi hold some scars and used in text books as knowledge but that knowledge is not brave enough to think of past for a foundation .. but that’s is only knowledge and fuel for debates.. it will not take the civilisation to a better place than the times of MB or today’s BJP / DMK ..
it’s of very little , no use in alleviating the pain felt by the innocents in the hands of the strong , tricky politicians .and business communities.
Humans are humans’ foes. Humans hate humans.. All countries’ history is derived from this friction between humans..
so….
Yada yada hi dharmasya glanirbhavati Bharatha
Abhyuththaanam adharmasya thathaatmaanam srujamyaham
Seasons come seasons go
Please believe there are people live in the same wavelengths all over the world..
They keep praying for the redemption of human souls ..
Unfortunately now a days Nationalism dominates science. If everything thing is there in veadas and puranas why we we are depending on others for almost all things? Learning from others ,adoption from others is the essence of every civilisation.
This opinion is itself coming from centralised educational doctrine/darshanas and not based in empirical evidence.
India is depending on others to become like them. India has successfully been brainwashed and now turned against itself.
Then what is jathi is it not cast?