CLEAR! Dr Murphy's Gender-Affirming Care | The Good Doctor

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 бер 2023
  • Dr Murphy (Freddie Highmore) expresses his medical curiosity in his young, trans patient.
    #trans #medical #drama #hospital #drama #freddiehighmore #tv #classics #tvshow
    Season 1 Episode 13 - As Shaun and Jared debate how to treat a twelve-year-old transgender girl’s cancer, Claire and a competitive new resident must work together to save a single father from a drug-resistant super bug.
    Watch Now!: play.google.com/store/tv/show...
    Shaun, a young doctor, joins a renowned hospital in San Jose, California, but his colleagues do not socialise with him. He uses his skills to treat patients and prove his abilities to his co-workers.
    Subscribe to Rapid Response to be on the frontlines: / @rapid-response

КОМЕНТАРІ • 299

  • @Aarin_5555
    @Aarin_5555 Рік тому +164

    As someone who has had a testicular torsion I can confirm that the pain can be so bad that you start throwing up. Shit was not fun👍

    • @Meilio69
      @Meilio69 11 місяців тому +7

      My dad had that when he was 14. He still somehow had two children ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    • @f1nnyeditss566
      @f1nnyeditss566 11 місяців тому

      ❤❤❤🥰🥰🥰

    • @clevelandbrown6947
      @clevelandbrown6947 10 місяців тому +3

      ​​@@Meilio69it usually affects only one testicle, my dad also has testicular torsion and he thought it's "normal" and kept telling me it's just "puberty" when i started exhibiting symptoms as a young man unknowing of this condition. well here i am reminiscing on the time i literally threw up and started hypersalivating all over my desk and my dad still said "that's normal" IT'S OBVIOUSLY NOT DAD but it goes away as your testicle dies off from lack of blood supply and you get a life threatening condition and die

    • @my_broda_8424
      @my_broda_8424 9 місяців тому

      Dose it start with something wired appearing on ur balls?
      I think I have it

    • @annikenlittle9644
      @annikenlittle9644 3 місяці тому

      @@Meilio69 Glad Am A Girl Then. Funny I Am Not A Boy Doctors

  • @TheRealMamaBee
    @TheRealMamaBee Рік тому +103

    I didn't like the good doctor when I watched the first episode. I related too much with dr Murphy and that made me sit in another room while it was playing. I don't hate dr Murphy, he's a good guy I just relate too much to him and that scares me,

    • @TheRealMamaBee
      @TheRealMamaBee Рік тому +14

      I'm not used to seeing people who are similar to me on tv so it was a lot,

    • @sakshinandan261
      @sakshinandan261 Рік тому +6

      It can feel weird and kinda scary going from feeling like nobody understands who you are, to realizing that there are people like you in the world. People who know how it feels to be like you. It probably feels like it shouldn’t be real.
      …I guess I don’t know exactly what that may feel like to you, but I can try to understand

    • @TheRealMamaBee
      @TheRealMamaBee Рік тому +6

      @@sakshinandan261 exactly I have gone my entire 17 years of life feeling like no one gets me and then here's this character who's neurodivergent and no one understands him as it's alot

    • @TheLastLivinGameCube
      @TheLastLivinGameCube Місяць тому +1

      @@TheRealMamaBee Hey, I went through the exact same feelings of isolated individuality that Shawn felt in this show. Granted it was through different experiences, but I still know how it feels to be different, and yet I am perfectly fine with it, I always have been.

  • @JoseGonzalez-ei1kb
    @JoseGonzalez-ei1kb 9 місяців тому +65

    I feel like Shaun was Quinn's biggest ally through this. "Quinn doesn't like pink." "She's more of a purple girl."

    • @hypernova9363
      @hypernova9363 Місяць тому +4

      Exactly! It feels as if Shaun was trying to understand Quinn at first and asked her a shit ton of questions to understand her

    • @Jakob_23
      @Jakob_23 Місяць тому +2

      @@hypernova9363Shaun does nothing but say what’s true no matter how someone feels, he doesn’t care about someone’s feelings on the matter he will say the cold heart reality of something. And that is exactly what he did right away after meeting “ her” he found it absurd and even funny and asked questions to figure out how someone could be so delusional and be so out of touch with reality and think they way they do.

  • @10thing7
    @10thing7 8 місяців тому +28

    Imagine Dr house.😂

  • @user-hz6ht8ov9z
    @user-hz6ht8ov9z 11 місяців тому +22

    I think this episode should’ve a learning experience instead of fireing him

  • @Molotovvv
    @Molotovvv Рік тому +34

    Does anybod know what it's like to be anything other than themselves?

    • @groetaer
      @groetaer Рік тому +3

      i do, in my dreams.. it's crazy

    • @DemetriusJamal-he1uy
      @DemetriusJamal-he1uy Рік тому +3

      That makes absolutely no sense. That’s like asking somebody if they know what dying feels like

    • @puppyresidue
      @puppyresidue 11 місяців тому

      Nope. And that’s why anti-trans people legislating our lives and healthcare based on the fact that they themselves don’t need it is such a sick thing to do

    • @strategygalactic
      @strategygalactic 10 місяців тому

      Yes. I feel like I am a king.

    • @Molotovvv
      @Molotovvv 10 місяців тому +1

      @@strategygalactic well you feel like your king-like self, but do you know what it feels like to be a slave ?

  • @JordanF26
    @JordanF26 Рік тому +32

    I'm surprised the actress that plays Lou on Heartland is doing guest appearances on shows these days

  • @majorpropane
    @majorpropane Рік тому +31

    he do be a surgeon tho

    • @Cyberfox2271
      @Cyberfox2271 Рік тому +2

      He is a surgeon

    • @AWA2K
      @AWA2K Місяць тому

      @@Cyberfox2271HE IS A SURGEON

    • @Cyberfox2271
      @Cyberfox2271 Місяць тому

      Damn Bro sebt that like a year ago 💀

    • @majorpropane
      @majorpropane Місяць тому

      @@AWA2K maybe the real surgeon is the friends we made along the way

    • @sardonicus76
      @sardonicus76 18 днів тому

      He isn’t *actually* a surgeon, per se. But he *is* like a surgeon, cuttin’ for the very first time.
      Here’s a waiver for you to sign. 📝

  • @mikee7241
    @mikee7241 10 місяців тому +48

    The problem with doctors affirming gender ideology is that medications, surgeries, and signs and symptoms are completely different amongst the sex’s. Doctors need to have that very difficult conversation such as a biological male transitioning to female showing up to a doctor with a positive pregnancy test sorry you are not pregnant you may have testicular cancer.

    • @OctavKitty
      @OctavKitty 8 місяців тому +4

      So as long as the doctor knows the patient is trans, and as long as they're competent, they'll be able to know that the patient's case must be considered with the facts the patient may take hormonal medication (which doctors already do) and that the risk factors and pathologies involved can come from male and female cases.
      As for the patient potentially not telling they're trans, it's yet again something doctors deal with all the time, when patients forget, dismiss or intentionally hide information.

    • @NickNickoso
      @NickNickoso 8 місяців тому

      No one is questioning that. Diagnosis won't change because a patient is transgender. The problem is how the patient is addressed. This is what the episode is about. You're just a scumbag. And an idiot, on top of that.

    • @natsurusenou131
      @natsurusenou131 7 місяців тому

      There is no such thing as "gender ideology".

    • @ccshumshum8104
      @ccshumshum8104 2 години тому

      @@OctavKitty or you can just avoid these issues altogether by teaching the "trans" patient how to distinguish between man and woman

  • @mOki.i
    @mOki.i 4 місяці тому +5

    He
    Is
    A
    Surgeon.

  • @snorlaxativess
    @snorlaxativess 11 місяців тому +3

    does anyone know what season and episode this is

  • @SquidXR638
    @SquidXR638 4 місяці тому +4

    What season and episode is this in

    • @serqion
      @serqion 25 днів тому

      Season 1 Episode 14 “She”

  • @gregorykeithmorris3970
    @gregorykeithmorris3970 6 місяців тому +4

    The grand Sophia Giannamore was a stellar guest star.

  • @GreyHowler528
    @GreyHowler528 4 дні тому

    They grandma was a real one

  • @blackswan1983
    @blackswan1983 Рік тому +169

    Sounds like Jazz Jennings. Nothing like an extra 100lbs, 20 daily medications, and 2 mental breakdowns to say "I'm happy!"

    • @genshikashmir
      @genshikashmir Рік тому +25

      Imagine how torturous it must feel without those things then.

    • @trollprincess
      @trollprincess Рік тому +33

      Oh, honey, I have depression and anxiety, take have a dozen different pills every day, have a serious breakdown at least once a year, but feel WAY happier than I did before I got on meds and signed up for therapy. Sometimes what makes you the happiest comes with downsides. You know, like jerks on the internet deciding the validity of your own life.

    • @GaySatanicClowns
      @GaySatanicClowns Рік тому +1

      That's not how it works at all. You know that.

    • @Lara-zb4ok
      @Lara-zb4ok Рік тому +12

      yeah people who are medicated can be happy brian :)

    • @sekaiyoru01
      @sekaiyoru01 Рік тому +25

      ​@@trollprincess That is some massive cope right there

  • @santanadavis950
    @santanadavis950 Рік тому +1

    Which episode is this

  • @FukYu-ng4do
    @FukYu-ng4do 8 місяців тому +19

    Really? Cut the video before they find out the “girl” has testicular cancer? Someone want to explain to me how you do testicular cancer surgery on a female?

    • @dasaho1019
      @dasaho1019 8 місяців тому +7

      She’s transgender

    • @FukYu-ng4do
      @FukYu-ng4do 8 місяців тому +19

      @@dasaho1019 right. Which means he is a male with testicles.

    • @rileegarcia437
      @rileegarcia437 7 місяців тому

      @@FukYu-ng4doshe’s male, correct, but her gender is a girl.

    • @golden-tea56
      @golden-tea56 6 місяців тому +2

      She has testicular cancer,is even said in the episode,the fact you even get yoruself in your own dilusion is surpricing,you geted hear for a reason so listen to the video a last time please..and understand how precius is that finally some one understand you,thing i asume you never did to trans persone

    • @professorpengu502
      @professorpengu502 3 місяці тому

      ​@@FukYu-ng4dono it means she's a transgender wan what part of that didn't you understand

  • @fupoflapo2386
    @fupoflapo2386 Рік тому +1

    Odin ???

  • @realteamwall
    @realteamwall Рік тому +15

    i dont understand

    • @lukasloen4659
      @lukasloen4659 Рік тому +10

      What are you confused about?

    • @GaySatanicClowns
      @GaySatanicClowns Рік тому

      Do you have any specific questions? Certified trans guy here, lol.

    • @phillapple8260
      @phillapple8260 Рік тому +4

      the patient is a transgender girl (meaning born male but identifying as female). The doctor performed unrelated medical care in a previous scene and now is asking questions about her transness because he is curious.

    • @fro_e
      @fro_e Рік тому

      ​@@phillapple8260 Aren't they female to male?

    • @Seven-vn6qi
      @Seven-vn6qi Рік тому +8

      @@fro_e no a transgender man is female to male and a transgender woman is male to female

  • @manumons100
    @manumons100 Рік тому +51

    Eh kids Don’t know what they want. My child can decided to do all that shit after 18, I’d recommend for them to do it later but as of 18 they’re an adult. Prior, they will act how they were born. This is one of the reason I don’t want to have a child in the US… y’all try to corrupt and confuse kids into thinking they’re something they’re not.

    • @unknownindividual6323
      @unknownindividual6323 Рік тому +2

      Long comment ahead
      You forget that we're a diverse nation, fifty states all with their own beliefs and history and nobody except a few are actually corrupting kids. If you think teaching kids about what lgbt people are is corrupting them then you're just a crazy possibly closet bigot or unknowingly a bigot.
      They should be able to choose as soon as they're a teenager simply because of the fact if they do it later most of their body is already set in stone.

    • @manumons100
      @manumons100 Рік тому +10

      @@unknownindividual6323 a human beings brain isnt developed until they’re early 20’s. They’re incapable of knowing right from wrong, much else what permanent change they want for themselves. Thinking a teenager already knows what they want for the rest of their life is just ignorant

    • @unknownindividual6323
      @unknownindividual6323 Рік тому +3

      @manumons100 That's why it's required, at least in Washington state, for you to go to therapy and live your life as a woman for 2 years or 1 I forget before you're even allowed to transition and even then it's expensive to do. I'm pretty sure you can get the government to cover the cost for the hormones, not certain about bottom or top surgery.

    • @unknownindividual6323
      @unknownindividual6323 Рік тому +1

      @manumons100 Also because you say a human beings brain doesn't develop fully until they're in their twenties then do you think they deserve to have the right to vote at 18 in most countries and 16 or 17 in other countries?

    • @manumons100
      @manumons100 Рік тому +10

      @@unknownindividual6323 government shouldn’t fund any of this, the government isn’t made to accommodate your comfort. If you’re an adult you shouldn’t be required to do anything, you should just be able to do it. If you’re a minor, it’s a whole different deal

  • @jennaramos1229
    @jennaramos1229 Рік тому +27

    I’ll never understand the argument that we’ll they might want to have children… like them not having bio kids is not the worst thing in the world lol too many kids in the world anyways

    • @9ubgy90bohbhhyuiyug9y
      @9ubgy90bohbhhyuiyug9y Рік тому +1

      You are whats wrong with the world.
      1. Children do not have sound mindsets and are prone to fads.
      2. As they get older they may realise that their biological gender is what it was assigned as at birth.
      3. Took many kids in the world? What? You do understand how repopulation works right?
      Get educated before speaking.

    • @knightofcarrion7358
      @knightofcarrion7358 11 місяців тому +21

      Still not a decision that a child should make.

    • @pimppimpproductions6497
      @pimppimpproductions6497 11 місяців тому +1

      Too many biological kids? Bruh there are too few in this country, so many poor and lonely elderly people, if they had more kids to support them their lives would be a great deal better. Social security isn’t livable as is and it’s future prospects don’t look great, believe it or not, kids are an investment, like they were before the Industrial Revolution, you can’t depend on the government to save you, you can depend on your own kids (especially if you have a lot of them, so each kid needs to only make small contributions of time or money)

    • @jordyschnaitman501
      @jordyschnaitman501 11 місяців тому +9

      ​@@knightofcarrion7358And also not a decision that any adult should make for a child

    • @cooleKinder
      @cooleKinder 11 місяців тому +9

      @@jordyschnaitman501 so the child should be allowed to decide to cut off body parts because they don’t like it when they don’t even know what ice cream flavor they want?

  • @Gohan218
    @Gohan218 11 місяців тому +87

    I dont agree with this at all. Instead of helping someone they just cave in to their delusion.

    • @courtneykensington8190
      @courtneykensington8190 9 місяців тому +12

      Your opinion is your opinion, it’s what you do with that opinion towards others that counts.

    • @bilalpop777
      @bilalpop777 9 місяців тому

      Facts that's modern society idiots

    • @ttvghostspecter4202
      @ttvghostspecter4202 9 місяців тому

      The delusion is thinking it would be ok in the first place for a child to even be shown in that light. This generation and centery is screwd

    • @emmascripted4515
      @emmascripted4515 9 місяців тому +17

      but u do realize that the latter is the kid being unhappy and possibly ending their life? theres a saying that goes i prefer a living daughter than a dead son

    • @Gohan218
      @Gohan218 9 місяців тому +3

      @@emmascripted4515 If it’s that easy for them to do that then they aren’t gonna go that far in life when they don’t have their yes men by their side.

  • @trobertw
    @trobertw Рік тому +117

    Corporate network TV propaganda

    • @Rebcap05
      @Rebcap05 Рік тому

      You are so brain-dead that I don't even have respect for you to debunk your delusions.

    • @puppyresidue
      @puppyresidue 11 місяців тому

      if you live a life where you think loving your kid for who they are is propaganda I pray you never reproduce because you are going to be VERY lonely in that dark, moldy assisted living facility

    • @This-is-a-commentt
      @This-is-a-commentt 5 місяців тому +20

      Bro watches too much geeks and gamers

    • @No-Hope.
      @No-Hope. 2 місяці тому +4

      Bro watches too much nerdrotic

    • @trobertw
      @trobertw 2 місяці тому +6

      @@No-Hope. You watch too many bros pretending to be broads

  • @easyhistory1508
    @easyhistory1508 25 днів тому

    L br

  • @MostBeautifulMe
    @MostBeautifulMe Рік тому +20

    Let the grandmother mourn her grandson so she can accept her granddaughter.

    • @puppyresidue
      @puppyresidue 11 місяців тому +6

      Her grandson did die, he never existed. She doesn’t need to mourn.

  • @TheDreamOfATree
    @TheDreamOfATree Місяць тому +9

    Anyone who mutilates their child with transgender surgery should be in prison for child abuse.

  • @Fresnoripper
    @Fresnoripper 3 місяці тому +1

    W grandma

  • @user-oy7yq6qt9y
    @user-oy7yq6qt9y 10 місяців тому +5

    Soo messed up fr

  • @alexhaynes7220
    @alexhaynes7220 22 дні тому +1

    I don’t know what is more bad and wrong and messed up that he is a kid and or a boy still and the parents allowing this

  • @alexhaynes7220
    @alexhaynes7220 22 дні тому +1

    The family is messed up

  • @AMatos-dq6cj
    @AMatos-dq6cj 11 місяців тому +38

    This is wrong. Period. Repent and come to our Lord and savior, Jesus Christ. He loves each one of you no matter what you have done. He is there always to fill that emptiness you feel. God is our creator. Don’t be deceived by the lies of this world. This world doesn’t give us happiness. We didn’t came here to be “ happy “. We came to serve God, for then be in Eternity with Him. This world is temporary. In Matthew 6:33 says: But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you.
    *What you need he will give it to you if you seek Him first; and nothing will take from you the Joy and grace that He gives. Nothing. Because this world doesn’t give it like God does. God bless you and have a nice day.

    • @dudu_rdm
      @dudu_rdm 11 місяців тому +36

      I apologize to what I'm about to say, but if you want to spread the God's word for saying someone is wrong, you should go to the church or a religious online community, not a video about trans identity, especially to claim it as something wrong.

    • @chadj2320
      @chadj2320 10 місяців тому +2

      It’s either right or wrong though. Besides, telling someone that he/she is wrong is not always a bad thing. Correction can be out of love, not out of spite. Especially if you’re just trying to lead people to the truth.
      God’s word is not black and white. It’s clear and bright as day. Preaching the gospel should not be limited to churches. Because it’s hypocrisy to say that it is while pride parades are being done every where, any day, at any time.
      The Bible is offensive to people who believes in their own selfish ways. I know, I was one of those offended before. Please, listen and repent before it’s too late. And to you who’s reading this comment, know that this is not an accident. You are loved by God, the one who created you for who you are. God made you either a male or female for a purpose. Don’t try to change yourself. Don’t listen to this broken world.
      Praying for each and everyone who gets to read this comment.

    • @dudu_rdm
      @dudu_rdm 10 місяців тому +3

      @@chadj2320 I don't think the correction is out of hate, being wrong is not bad, very far from it, but if someone wants to live as they wish they should have the right of doing so.
      Of course pride parades can happen in every place at any time, just like preaching, but at the same time, pride parades don't try claiming different religions and beliefs are wrong, instead they claim for justice or equal rights. Sometimes people just don't want to change their beliefs, and this is completely okay :)).
      We live in a world where everyone is different, everyone has their own perspective about things y' know, of course you can always leave your head open for knowing other people's thoughts, but that doesn't mean they need to live with the same ideals and religions.
      My english is kind of bad so maybe what I wanted to say is not clear! But I hope I didn't say anything offensive, take care tho! :)

    • @dudu_rdm
      @dudu_rdm 10 місяців тому +3

      @@chadj2320 I just realized I said something with the wrong words lmao, sorry for the miscommunication thing, I meant that if you want to spread the God's words you should try doing it to people who would want to listen to it for changing!! Everyone can have their space to expressing their things but there are certain places it's better to not do so.
      Just like you don't see pride parades interrupting a preaching moment inside a church y' know.

    • @chadj2320
      @chadj2320 10 місяців тому

      @@dudu_rdm I get you. But you see, God is not for the righteous, He is for the lost. It’s selfish to keep God’s truth to yourself while letting others go down the path of destruction. Also, it’s not about what you want to hear, it’s about what you need to hear. I appreciate you conversing with me. I hope this gives you something to think about.
      Have a good day!

  • @michaelingram7844
    @michaelingram7844 Рік тому +229

    As a father of a trans daughter, my daughter is the same person she was before her transition. Only her gender has changed.
    We supported her, and we grow with her. She is now happily married and successful in her career.
    Her being a trans woman is only a small part of her character.
    Nice clip, appreciated!

    • @death_herself
      @death_herself Рік тому +10

      That's so awesome! 🏳️‍⚧️

    • @michaelingram7844
      @michaelingram7844 Рік тому +28

      @1978 32
      Why say; young man, small cat, old woman? It's a declarative or descriptive statement. Der.

    • @michaelingram7844
      @michaelingram7844 Рік тому +12

      @Pyro Hut Ah, the old distraction from what is being discussed, to a strawman of the discussion.
      We are talking about respect for trans men and trans women, not some specific sexual definition about a sex. (Yes, i can define words scientifically and in a moden way, can you?)
      What you seem to want to distract from is that you have no respect for your fellow human beings. Perhaps, rather than spouting your TERF ideology, come over to where the air is less foul and just live with the fact that trans people (& the whole LBGTQI+ spectrum) are real, are part of us, and have been so throughout history. Look around and smile with pride at the diversity of humans. Or is that your problem?

    • @dolebludger
      @dolebludger Рік тому +13

      ​@@iscuit Female is genetic, biological, it's an absolute.
      Women is a mental and spiritual belief.
      As long as they were old enough they deserve the same respect. Just let people be happy without fighting to promote your personal beliefs

    • @michaelingram7844
      @michaelingram7844 Рік тому

      @@dolebludger correct 😀