My thoughts on Sabbat PCs

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 74

  • @johnwalsh4857
    @johnwalsh4857 3 роки тому +2

    due to current events, Sabbat got smashed bad, the old structure is kaput. what replaced it is a mish mash of domains or packs not connected or barely connected to each other, there is now no overarching command and control power structure that before the fall was made up of the Regent, the cardinals and the Serpaphs of the black hand. now most of them are kaput. and even if they survived I dont think they have teh same command and pull in the past, Sabbat command and control has become much decentralized and devolved to the local level. So like a Archbishop of an area would laugh if a former Cardinal tried to give orders(in this case monomancy duel would come in).

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      Pretty much, yeah. I really like the idea of senior pack members being forced into "retirement" and becoming bishops and archbishops to baby sit a domain. I see a lot of Status Quo attempting to get the position.

    • @daviga1
      @daviga1 3 роки тому +2

      Shovelheads: 9/10 die in a matter of days or weeks, the 10th that survive become True Sabbat. Darwinian. after a few decades, that pack has 1 out of 10 original members left, there's your Bishop, Darwin again.

    • @johnwalsh4857
      @johnwalsh4857 3 роки тому

      @@daviga1 and yah he still probably has to struggle to go up, in fact these days , the sabbat packs are mostly domestic they dont really recognize those pre 2nd inquisition titles anymore. So former Bishop to assert his authority will probalby have to do monomancy with the local sabbat pack leader.

  • @michaelblackett8195
    @michaelblackett8195 3 роки тому +8

    The way V5 is going, it's growing...call of London and Chicago by Night are great
    The Sabbath V5 gives me a near dark vibe, which is what I got when reading the 1e Storytellers handbook to the Sabbat. Which is a good thing.

    • @michaelblackett8195
      @michaelblackett8195 3 роки тому +1

      Am pretty sure the Sabbat are still using Manchurian candidates to infiltrate camarilla.

    • @michaelblackett8195
      @michaelblackett8195 3 роки тому +2

      Fall of London, not Call

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      I completely agree.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      I love infiltration storylines. Gonna have to play with that at some point.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      I picked up what you were putting down, lol.

  • @simonward244
    @simonward244 3 роки тому +3

    Good video as usual. I Think this was a business decision to avoid the controversy from earlier. They know we have the information to change and convert as we wish. The Sabbat been Sabbat and the " oh they are encouraging such behaviour bleat." They will face. They can just say they are not.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +2

      I can see that. Makes a lot of sense. People are just being so bitchy about it.

  • @silentcomedyW5
    @silentcomedyW5 3 роки тому +3

    Hey man so glad to see this video! i just got led here by the storyteller who asked you the question at the beginning of the vid. They just accepted me into a sabbat game they intend to run. if it was not for this video i would not be getting to play in this game! You have made my whole day bro! thank you. (i used to be That One Guy: changed my username to fit my discord and my twitch name)

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      It makes me so happy to hear that!

    • @silentcomedyW5
      @silentcomedyW5 3 роки тому

      @@VoivodeMekhet could actually use another player if your interested

  • @simpleroleplay2136
    @simpleroleplay2136 3 роки тому +1

    Wow i’m truly honoured to pout on UA-cam I don’t what to say but thank you if you ever wish to join a game I do online let me konw

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      You are so welcome. That was a thank you to you for such a great idea.
      I'm always curious about online games. I've never found one I can stick with because I suck at online play. I'd love to hear about it though. If you're on facebook drop me a line.
      facebook.com/groups/341268120563714
      I'm the admin for the Our World of Darkness facebook group.

  • @michaelblackett8195
    @michaelblackett8195 3 роки тому +3

    If creating V5 series of stories, think I would adapt the stories in the back of the Old storyteller handbook. Taking the players from showerhead and into creation rites under a storyteller controlled lack priest. Eventually have them run into a competing pack, and then chase down Bartholomew the image uncanny who has seized assets from deep South change after blood sorcery fell into its current state.

  • @michaelblackett8195
    @michaelblackett8195 3 роки тому +1

    The Black Hand - Sabbat has been in the past off called that, with elders in salons in the sessions I took part in referring as such to frighten neonates/childer.into
    Caine 's Chosen/lost tribe/Black Hand (still don't have my pre-order) was a secret cult within the Sabbat outsiders were dimly aware of. From my perspective, The Beckoning gripped the Lost tribe and drew them into the Middle East, perhapsc1 or 2 members still acting in clandestine. When they return, if, they will be perceived a threat...
    As for the Tal'mahe'Ra, conflicting and shrouded in secrets is best how I like. Them After a showdown in Montrealwith the false hand as detailed in Beckets it has diary, think the hid in the shadows and Caines Chosen think they won, not knowing the true grandeur of the monster of the True Black Hand...

  • @yugimofo
    @yugimofo 2 роки тому +2

    My biggest problem with this book is the previous book is, “here’s a ton of cults and how anyone could fall for it and there might be parts of it that are actually right, everyone’s truth yo.” Then comes sabbat, evil cult, not human, bad

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  2 роки тому

      It is built off the perception though. I see only half the story here and for the idea, it works for me.

  • @otakuofmine
    @otakuofmine 3 роки тому +2

    some nice ideas. just made me think of one my own - what if you start the story by having your PCs being created by creation rite, and not necessarily the same. as it isnt a flawless experience you could just pick or throw dice at random to determine the disciplines or even if thinblood or not. of course that takes the decision but can also be fun for roleplay and experiementation.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      I think that's a great idea. I think I'll stick with mine though just because I love the idea of the blood influencing them even if they deny it. But I could totally see doing it your way.

    • @otakuofmine
      @otakuofmine 3 роки тому

      @@VoivodeMekhet ah I am glad you do. If I get to do my own (just not in a place currently), I leave it to my players but will definitivly offer it.
      also thx for the response!
      your channel was recommended to me and I had only time to skip thru this one, but so far I like it quite. :)

  • @thegoodolddays9193
    @thegoodolddays9193 3 роки тому +3

    I think there's enough in the current content to run a sabbat game without much extra work. I'm also not opposed to filling out the thin areas of v5 sabbat with stuff from older versions, where applicable and with some light modification.
    Lore wise, I'm still apprehensive but its not bad or anything. Just personal taste.
    I do agree that packs should most often rally around the same path, but I think you could have extenuating circumstances to justify one or two PCs being from a different path.
    If you can answer why an NPC wants to be around a bunch of people with a totally different ideology, mindset and lifestyle, and why they would accept them, I think its okay.
    I like your interpretation of the road of humanity vs humanity as a system.
    Definitely agree that its better for blush of life's effectiveness to be tied to humanity, rather than an on/off thing. The lower your humanity, the more "off" you look. Human interaction is VERY complicated, far more than we're ever conscious of. Our brains are constantly studying every detail of the people we talk to. Even things like eye movements are taken into account.
    If you've ever met somebody that just gave you "bad vibes", chances are there was something in their mannerisms and body language that you found abnormal - even if you didn't consciously notice it.
    A low humanity vampire isn't going to remember to take all of those factors into account, and honestly, they wouldn't care. They're a predator and they take pleasure in intimidating their potential victims. So long as they're human looking enough not to raise immediate alarm everywhere they go, who cares?
    So, I think blush of life works, but a low humanity vampire simply can't keep up with human interaction well enough to make it very effective.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      Very nice insight. I love the "bad vibes" thing. Spot on.

  • @claytonwhitacre1752
    @claytonwhitacre1752 2 роки тому +1

    I'm thinking of using Rudi's story from the Anarch supplement, with what's going on leading to a recruiting front for the Sabbat. I wanna see a play group and how they handle the whole situation as it unfolds. Hopefully they escape the prison(as mortals) to either get embraced by a group of Anarchs, or fail and get shovelheaded for their trouble.

  • @rocklee5231
    @rocklee5231 3 роки тому +1

    Great content

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks. I love the game so I don't shut up, lol

    • @rocklee5231
      @rocklee5231 3 роки тому

      @@VoivodeMekhet haha I’m just getting into it so I’m binging right now. Definitely appreciate your work!

  • @adamrivas4553
    @adamrivas4553 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent video. Thank you as always. You are correct, it’s massively controversial and really should not be. I feel like older players have many emotional attachments to the game and change is hard for them. I myself feel that way about clan disciplines. I live the new discipline trees, however I feel like we lost something in clan identity with the removal of “unique” disciplines per clan. That said, I do love the predator type mechanic and the diversity it offers, but I feel amalgams could have been optional not mandatory.
    Vicissitude is my primary example here. That’s such a key component to the Tzimische. While I can see amalgams offering the chance to learn it, I feel like it (and all the others) should have stayed a unique discipline.
    That’s a minor gripe though, and not a bug hang up.
    Over all I love V5 and look forward to more.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      Funny enough I love Vicissitude better now. No more of that "is it an alien virus crap", I like the idea of the Tzimisce being badass enough to dominate their own beast.

    • @adamrivas4553
      @adamrivas4553 3 роки тому

      I agree on that story aspect, I just miss the identity of the clan part. Was always something I keyed in on when I first got into the game. That said, I do love the new system and it brings me back to my point; there are minor gripes to be had which will vary by the person, but overall V5 is awesome

    • @daviga1
      @daviga1 3 роки тому

      Possibly relevant is that, on table, Mekhet doesn't permit you to learn the amalgams outside your 'lineage' without instruction; ie, a Gangrel has Protean, but can only learn the Viccissitude amalgams [Viccissitude, Fleshcrafting, Horrid Form] by qualifying AND having an instructor who knows the relevant Amalgams [generally, a Tzimisci based on this example]; so it kinda works that there's a "Tzimisci" track to Protean that may be available-but you are in no way compelled to take. Other licks can get into it as well, but you'd need to find a way to beg, bully, blackmail, or whatever a tutor.

  • @ThisisnotTwitter
    @ThisisnotTwitter 3 роки тому +2

    If Antediluvians are really behind the beckoning, which is what many sabbat believed as they followed the elders East, then what would it truly be like to try and track something so powerful down? The day they actually find one awakened is probably the day that chronicle ends, or they also walk out with faded memories believing they won their war. Previous to that they might be chasing and fighting vampires that have been dominated etc from hundreds of miles away. Antediluvians playing their childer against each other. Conspiracies within conspiracies, often unintentionally the pack ending up serving the very being they are trying to fight/kill. Like an investigative cat and mouse conspiracy thriller all while trying to avoid the gaze of the SI, which may well be being directed by higher powers at times.
    Equally what could the beckoning be if not the Antediluvians? Some major Mage plot? Something Pentex is up to? What would a pack of sabbat do if they discovered it was not what they thought?
    I see many interesting story hooks surrounding the sabbat packs of V5.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      Very, very much. I don't know why but in my mind I always picture the antediluvians making huge bon fires and throwing vampires onto them. The smoke wafting into the air, attracting anyone of high enough generation to smell it. I guess presence "summon" works too but I just love the idea of how terrifying that would be.

    • @ThisisnotTwitter
      @ThisisnotTwitter 3 роки тому +2

      @@VoivodeMekhet That does sound pretty intense to have all those ancient vampires being burned like that.
      Would their purpose be part of a ritual? Thousands of millennia of experience of vitae being sacrificed in order for some dark purpose?

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      @@ThisisnotTwitter Personally I think they want it over. I think that they believe , if the Cain story is true that if they burn enough it will summon Cain himself.

    • @ThisisnotTwitter
      @ThisisnotTwitter 3 роки тому +1

      @@VoivodeMekhet Or even Lilith? Hehe.
      I always enjoy imagining all of what might actually have gone on in the most ancient of times in the WOD despite what the popular vampire Bible says. My favourite ideas often involve Mage. Imagine the book of nod being a really badly told story about an ancient Mage conflict that the Bible is also based on.

  • @antuanyammine1537
    @antuanyammine1537 3 роки тому +4

    I'm in love with everything you said in this video and now I want to play a Sabbat game. My only question it's about the touchstone thing... If the Sabbat don't have any touchstone, how they gonna heal aggravated willpower damage? What gives them that kind of peace?

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +5

      Truthfully they probably don't have "peace", they probably heal it out of spite. It sounds strange and I'm working on my homebrew mechanics for it right now but yeah, I thing it's spite.

    • @antuanyammine1537
      @antuanyammine1537 3 роки тому +4

      @@VoivodeMekhet i know that your touchstones don't need to be something nice, for example one touchstone from my Caitiff was a 2 dot enemy, he utterly despised them; and the way he interacted with them to heal willpower was trying to ruining their life in every way he can (of course, not harming them directly, and also trying to maintain their relationship in a constant conflict in which my Caitiff always had the upper hand).
      He effectively heal himself hurting his touchstone; because for my Caitiff, his touchstone represents everything he hates, and hurting them it's a (pretty toxic but effective) way to sublimate his feelings, and it's a constant reminder of the time when he was alive.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      That's intense and I like the fact that you might actually end up gaining stains as you heal your willpower.
      I think the method I'm leaning toward is Vaulderie. I think that my Sabbat will heal their Aggravated Willpower based on their highest Vaulderie rating. This rating, being a watered down Bloodbond will shift back and for regularly so they will have this internal need to keep doing the ritual. It also makes sense because as they do the ritual their willpower strengthens making them able to shatter regular blood bonds.

  • @simpleroleplay2136
    @simpleroleplay2136 3 роки тому +1

    Here is my idea of a chronicle I get the players to destroy they Touchstones as part of they initiation to the sabbat I would love to push my player to a Point of True darkness and what it means to be vampire yes I do a Second zero to get everyone to agree one path and basically the sabbat players will one try to recruit or make themselves stronger for the war they are going to face with the powerful vampire make the group travel location to location into they get to the east were the campaign end

  • @VindensSaga
    @VindensSaga 3 роки тому +1

    VTM 5th at the start I didn't like it at all because it assumed that you were playing an anarch. It is good that a new team is on it and that the people who did the mess never touches WoD again.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      I'm just glad they tried because we wouldn't have what we have now.

  • @daviga1
    @daviga1 3 роки тому +1

    I think Sabbat should have touchstones, but no, not necessarily human touchstones showing a connection to humanity - if Sabbat have touchstones, they are people or kindred who remind them of their connection to their path's ethics. I see many Sabbat having no touchstones at all [paths always devolved more easily than humanity in older editions], and for most of those that do, I think their touchstone is the pack priest (your first connection to your path after all, and an ongoing 'moral compass' to you on how to behave as a Cainite.
    Mechanically, a touchstone reduces the moral dissonance of being a vampire with human ethical ideas, shoring up your ability to resist stains and maintaining the illusion to yourself that you are still a person and not a monster. If a Sabbat fails to act in a manner that aligns with the alien ethics of their path, who else but his priest can give him a sense of forgiveness or absolution for failing to drown a sack of kittens or whatever it is that Sabbat do.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      I can see that. I'm really leaning to the Sabbat having no touchstones, like you said. "paths always devolved more easily than humanity in older editions", I think this shows that. The idea that the creation rites in the Sabbat are designed around disconnecting you from your touchstones seems fun and a great way to create personal horror in this new system.

  • @clairestark9024
    @clairestark9024 3 роки тому +1

    Have you seen anyone of the storyteller vault sabbat pc books?

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      I have not yet. I do need to look into that stuff. I've been going back and forth on submitting some stuff myself.

  • @socio9807
    @socio9807 3 роки тому +1

    Hey, so since you recorded the video because of a suggestion, would you mind delving into the 'crossover' territory, and maybe discuss why kindred would deal with other supernatural beings? Like demons, for example. Infernalists are really infamous, but by looking at the 'cost' of infernal dealings, I don't really see why would anyone bother

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +1

      I'd be happy to. How about this Monday? :)

    • @socio9807
      @socio9807 3 роки тому

      ​@@VoivodeMekhet That'd be awesome, thank you!

  • @socio9807
    @socio9807 3 роки тому +1

    Is Gehena still canon? I saw heard a few people saying it was retconned?

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому +2

      The Gehenna books (time of judgment) were retconned. The idea and concept is still out there and the Sabbat obsess over it.

  • @badrdawn8786
    @badrdawn8786 3 роки тому +1

    يجب ان تلعب على طريق خصة باك

    • @VindensSaga
      @VindensSaga 3 роки тому +1

      What did you write bro?

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      لا أعتقد أن هناك ترجمة إنجليزية جيدة جدًا لهذا.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      Badr Dawn and I write back and forth together in Arabic.

  • @tylerzerbe6861
    @tylerzerbe6861 5 місяців тому +1

    ive been running a sabbat campaign since the late 90s....its still going. we use what we call "3.5" its 3rd edition with all the 3rd edition books leading up to gehenna, but we never make it out of the 90's. every year is 199x. Bill Clinton's still the president, 9/11 hasnt happened and the world exists as it did when i was an edgy teenager. http 1 internet exists, schreknet's still around. early cellphones exist (nokia 8110), texting exists, but it takes longer because you have to spell everything using the 12-key, also there are pagers and payphones. our nosferatu even has a weird cobbled-together motorcycle helmet with nokia guts wired into it and it has a text-based web browser.
    im not super happy with the direction that v5 has taken sabbat so we'll just continue to use the old system... besides, what the heck am i gonna do with all these regular d10s? interestingly enough, i was not even aware that they did anything past gehenna in the lore because the next book i got was requiem and it was a reboot. i sort of noped out and told my players we'd continue using the old system. i didnt know they even did a release before v5 going back to the old lore. its funny, players move in and out of the campaign as the years go by. players that have quit the hobby are immortalized as npcs. some of my current players were not even alive yet when the campaign started. we're nearing a time where the children of the original cast of vampires will run into the npcs of the characters their parents played. in our little bubble, though the storyteller and original cast have aged, their characters, like the true vampires they are, will never grow old.
    not sure how much this pertains to the video, but thought i'd share.

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  5 місяців тому

      That is absolutely beautiful. Thank you for sharing that with us. I whole heartedly believe that we should play the systems that we prefer. If you don't like a thing, why would you adopt it? Your decades spanning story sounds amazing and the fact that you have legacy players is wonderful. My 17 (18 is a few months) son and my godson (also at an appropriate age) have now joined my table and seeing them interact with storylines I've been running for years is an amazing feeling. Thicker Than Water was created back in 2005 and they weren't even a thought yet.
      I'm so happy you have that kind of living story and thank you again for sharing it. I hope your game keeps going and the stories you provide continue to entertain.

  • @badrdawn8786
    @badrdawn8786 3 роки тому +1

    يجب ان تلعب على طريق خصة باك

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      ما زلت لا أستطيع أن أفعل ذلك تمامًا. هل هذه لعبة على الانترنت؟

  • @badrdawn8786
    @badrdawn8786 3 роки тому +1

    يجب ان تلعب على طريق خصة باك

    • @VoivodeMekhet
      @VoivodeMekhet  3 роки тому

      لست متأكدًا تمامًا مما تعنيه بذلك.