As a French, i know this can really happen in real life we have a superpower of overthrowing everything against our living goods VIVE LE ROI ⚜️, VIVE LA FRANCE 🇫🇷
And the French will throw him out. Who knows, the French might restore the Capets whether the Bourbons or the Orleans, then there is the Bonapartes. There is always Marine Le Pen. She would be the first Queen 👑 Regnant of France.
This guy: "I am NOT endorsing the political beliefs present in this video." Me, glancing nervously at my fleur-de-lys flag and picture of Louis: "Yeah...no...me neither of course..." 🤞😉🤫😌😇🙏
I have a flag with a fleur-de-lys, but thats because my home county (Lincolnshire) has a fleur-de-lys on it (Ironically, its not only a British county, but an English one at that).
my dude, you seriously underestimate the French's ability to absolutely go apeshit with their current government. There is a reason why the right parties cannot get together
Actually de Gaulle briefly considered restoring Henri d'Orleans from around 1958-early 1960's. Charles de Gaulle came from a family of Legitimists, who begrudgingly supported the Orleanists with the Senior House of Bourbon's extinction following Chambourd's death. de Gaulle was sympathetic to the Orleanists and had regular correspondence with the likes of Charles Maurras, the head of Action Francais, the far right, Catholic centric, monarchist group. de Gaulle was quite friendly with d'Orleans and the two regularly discussed the topic. Charles invited d'Orleans to join him in London as part of Free France. And in 58' he got rid of the laws barring royal pretenders and permitted them to run for President. The idea was the Henri who was well liked by many Republicans and many monarchist types would gain the presidency and put France on the path to a monarchical restoration, but those plans were shelved by the 60's when the left started getting more agitated as France's own "Sexual revolution" started getting off the ground leading to the end of his presidency. Prior to 58' Charles was having d'Orleans act as a more public figure acting as one of his representatives to the French mandate in Syria, essentially putting him out there in the French public sphere. Had d'Orleans joined de Gaulle in London in 1940, it might have led to de Gaulle being more open and overtly supportive of the idea of a monarchical restoration. Then again, if you change up some of the post war politics like having the army instead lead a coup against the Fourth Republic, that might destabilize France or lead to a dictatorship where d'Orleans could have taken over in a manner similar to how Juan Carlos succeeded Franco. Considering how d'Orleans was okay with the left, he might have allied with opposition figures against such a dictatorship, leading a coup against it.
As a Belgian Walloon, I indeed only can the annexation of Wallonia in France only and truly only in this kind of scenario. Longue vie au roi! (Videntis, what will happen to my beloved Belgian's royal family in this scenario?)
The constitutional council controle the procédure of the référendum and the act which is convoquing the electors to the référendum. BUT he does not controle the content of the référendum. He's considering that the référendum . It considers that the referendum falls within the general expression of the nation. Consequently, he refuses to control it (Decision No. 92-313 DC of 23 September 1992)
I think it's horrible. How can we act like being a meritocratic society if there are people who hold a position of power literally just by the randomness of birth. Why is a King Felipe more deserving of representing the Spanish people than any other of 48 million people? I think the people should be able to o directly choose who is going to represent them. Representative Monarchs also hold power in popularity and influence just before anyone wants to disagree.
@@derdude6214 I don't see it that way. Constitutional monarchs don't have any power nor should they as they're just figure heads with a fancy but traditional title. I think the PM is the representative of the masses elected through a democratic process which is why a PM is considered the most powerful person in a country with parliamentary system of government with Monarchs or Presidents aa merely titular heads.
Based French monarchy! They would most likey keep the tricolor because that has become the most recognizable symbol of France besides the Eiffel Tower.
That's (for modern day Germany) completely impossible. The German constitution in Article 20 states that the German Republic is a democratic and social federal state and that all state power shall come from the people. And every German has the right to resist anyone trying to change this status quo if needed even with violence. This article 20 (together with article 1) are also even protected by the eternity law that states that those two article and there described principles can never be removed or changed. The only party that openly wants to dissolve this eternity law is the far right extremist AfD. And up to now there is no way they will get the majority it needs to change anything in the constitution. I'm okay with unrealistic scenarios but it then has to be something as the eternity law not existing instead of cheesing some weird majorities.
A frenchman talking about building a society on the lifelong covenant between a man and a woman has got to be the most no french thing ever. Also nice vid
Fundamental Laws of the Crown of France never stated that the king had to be born in France, as the modern Orleanists fantasize. Therefore Count of Paris might only become another Louis Philippe, he can never come to be a legitimist monarch, unless the Spanish line goes extinct.
Tiny corrections: The Parti Socialist goes from slighly to the right of LFI to strait up right. Olivier Dussopt, minister of work is from this party and his reforms where far from anything someone remotly leftist could do. Glucksman is not the leader of the PS, but it's figurhead. Also, the RN is not socialist at all, eaven in the economic field. I'll come back to this comment but they voted agains't many social law.
Olivier Dussopt isnt part of the PS anymore since 2017 lol, the PS is a leftist party. For the RN, yes, economically speaking they are more socialists than liberals
2:58 well, the second highest office is technically the presidency of the senate, since the president of the senate is the one who replaces the president of the republic if he dies or if he is unable to go through with his term.
Ya que eres puertoriqueño te lo escribire en español. En una encuesta del 2021, el 15% de los frances querian una restauracion de la monarquia porque les parecia que la republica habia dejado ser frances con medidas socialistas que ya habian hecho perder la confianza en la gente, esto hizo resurgir el movimiento pro-monarquia que nunca habia desaparecido.
@@fredelboricua_5676The guy above you is definitely biased. The truth is that today no one cares about the monarchy besides a few people here and there. The wording of that 15% poll he’s talking about was « would you mind a monarchist restoration », not « do you support a monarchist restoration ». There’s a big difference. In 2019, a single monarchist party tried to run in the elections and got 0,01% of the votes.
Nobody really wants it. Some nostalgic think of Napoleon or Louis XIVth and go "those were the days" but present them with nowadays options and they'll stick to republic.
It would be interesting to know how this would affect Spain. Felipe is too conservative for the leftists and too idle for the right and Louis is already loved by the Spanish right and especially by serious Spanish Catholics. Maybe one of his sons might become king, since Felipe only has female heirs and this was enough to cause a Carlist war the first time, so it could cause tensions this time around also. Also how would Karl and George Habsburg use this opportunity Maybe these could be used for a future scenario?
It would be interesting to see if France remains in the eu or nato perhaps due to the immigration forced on them by the eu causes FRExit? From the European Union
Could you make a similar video talking about Italy? Obviously the real contender for the Italian throne is His Royal Highness Aimone of Savoy-Aosta! Anyway, nice video, congratulations!
Hello, I'm a French legitimist and I'd just like to correct the errors in the video. Before I start, I'd like to make it clear that I'm not criticising your video negatively, but I just want to inform you. To begin with, Louis XX was certainly in favour of a constitutional monarchy in the 2010s, but today he is in favour of the old regime. Secondly, our king says that he is "available to the French", which means that he will not work on his own to re-establish the monarchy (I'm talking about concrete actions here) and that he will respond to the call of the French if they want to re-establish the monarchy, but he does support our legitimist movement and makes numerous appearances. As for an alliance with Action Française, this is totally unimaginable, although many AF members are not Orleanists, the irrigante class is attached to their master Charle Maurass and does not advocate religion as a priority (which for the legitimists is totally unimaginable) not to mention the very many differences in doctrine, so although a merger between the Orleanist and legitimist movements would be wonderful it remains highly unlikely.
Italian socialist here, so I do not fully know the modern french monarchist area, is it more realistic a legitimist or a orleanist reinstauration in France? I mean, the orleanists already have active groups (Action Française, Alliance Royale and Nouvelle Action Royaliste). Also, just out of curiosity, why would you support a monarchy and in particular why would you support either dinasty? Why not a Bonaparte or an Orleans for example?
@@historicalitalianmemer8495 Hi, as things stand, restoration is out of the question due to the lack of support from the population. As for which branch to choose, to cut a long story short, legitimism is based on the society of the ancien régime with a monarchy of divine right, orleanism is based on the July monarchy with a constitutional monarchy and, finally, bonapartism, which is not a royal dynasty but an imperial one, is based on a regime with democratic but authoritarian foundations. If you have another question, let me know
Probably wouldn't do much. If anything Louis would be used as an example of why Monarchys should die unfortunately his views would not sit well with people.
Alright so let me, a frenchman, explain how this scenario is LARPY AF: -RN has 184 (also you forgot the 1 in 184) and PC has 31 seats and are in a coalition... It's not a majority... They can't pass anything. -France = Republic so good luck for anyone to actually believe in monarchism. Why do you think we say "Vive la France et vive la République!"? -Why did you ignore the laïcité? French secularism is VERY strong and will not be easy to get rid of, if you even can. -Socialism is not when the government does stuff -RN is very much conservative Overall completely delusional.
yeah not the most realistic scenario. I was working with a French socialist from my server for most of the political stuff. His english isnt amazing so we had some difficulties communicating so my apologies if any of the numbers are incorrect. Obviously France wouldn't restore the monarchy, this is more of a thought experiment on what would change if Louis Alphonse actually took power in France. I'm trying to learn more about France's politics so if you know the system well, i'm all ears
If FRANCE of all countries would turn monarchist within 10 years, then Montenegro and Serbia will be the first ones to immediately switch back to monarchy, with monarchist parties being in other countries
The French is unique in this kind of situation where the people cannot decide whether or not they are in for a monarch. I think it is better to have a monarch. Just to have someone be a figurehead, not an administrative, policy-making entity but somebody to look on to, someone to fight for and to unite with. I think it will give France a steady direction.
I'm an history fan so i'm like "Oh I like the fleur de lys" but then i'm also trans and living my life and the part where I basicly become illegal made me think "yea I remembered why I dont want conservatives deciding for me what is best for my life". This is why I would prefer a bonapart house, more liberal and carry more of the spirit of the french revolution
I desire with all my heart a return of the legitimate Bourbons, after they were punished by God when failing to consecrate France to the Sacred Heart as requested by our Lord through St. Margaret Mary Alacoque. But it will come in the future, they will be back, the Great King will come.
I am French and even if the scenario is not very realistic it was very funny, in fact it is especially the attitude of the National Rally which is doubtful, the rest is rather well tied up even if it would surely have caused lots of other problems , but great video !
This channel isn't exactly realistic alternate history, it's more hypothetic interesting scenarios. Look at Byzantium: Part 2 for example. If you want some sort of realism try Possible History for example.
@@thenamesianna i dont think there really is a realistic alt hist channel. He has videos on Soviet zombie armies. The most realistic video I think I've done is probably Athens winning the Peloponnesian War.
I’ve just seen a pretty major mistake here so I’d like to point it out : France has actually undergone two Restauration(s) already (one before les Cent-Jours, while Napoléon was in Elba, and then the second one, after Waterloo), so that would actually make la Troisième Restauration (9:09)
Thanks to History World: Educational for the Louis XX edit. youtube.com/@historyworld1826?si=kDcquCf2536Zb2e5
I find it insane that such a edit exsist ha ha.
Thanks buddy! Bless you 😉
It was a pleasure to be the part of your vid
@@HistoryWorld1826 you actually did it! Wow I actually saw that on the discord. It was great man!
What if napoleon became a Piedmontese general? Genoese?
eric ciotti has been approved by the law and is still in command despite the attempt to demote him.
France: doing a revolution to overthrow the King and install a democracy
Also France: democraticly electing a King of the same bloodline
Reconquête is Bonapartist and proud of it so I always vote for them.
@@AixlaachenPax1801traitor
@@lollo_Cnot a traitor to the French people
@@MrBUCKET-gt5og he is tho
@@lollo_C have France ruled by and for the French people than Algerians or to just eat cake
Bro Made a Tutorial on how to Restore the monarchy
Based
time to create my own monarchy gentlemen all tips have been noted 😆
We're going back to the 1700s with this one 🇬🇧🤝🇫🇷
Is it me or are there an influx of history nerds with mari pfp?
France is still there
As a French, i know this can really happen in real life we have a superpower of overthrowing everything against our living goods VIVE LE ROI ⚜️, VIVE LA FRANCE 🇫🇷
🤔 tu est vraiment fr
@@Phryge2024JO bah oui frr
@@luckyFrenchy t'en a mis du temps a répondre je t'avais oublié bref en vrai je sais pas si c'est une bonne idée sinon le roi va finir comme en 1789 😅
We all know the real reason he dissolved parliament; he’s going to proclaim himself the Emperor of the French.
And the French will throw him out. Who knows, the French might restore the Capets whether the Bourbons or the Orleans, then there is the Bonapartes.
There is always Marine Le Pen. She would be the first Queen 👑 Regnant of France.
@@carterbentonjr399 Too late, Marie de Medici already made that.
@@AndreaMoletta-s3cbut she wasn’t the one who led, she was just married to the leader
This guy: "I am NOT endorsing the political beliefs present in this video."
Me, glancing nervously at my fleur-de-lys flag and picture of Louis: "Yeah...no...me neither of course..." 🤞😉🤫😌😇🙏
Anarcho-monarchism with attractive charateristics
I have a flag with a fleur-de-lys, but thats because my home county (Lincolnshire) has a fleur-de-lys on it (Ironically, its not only a British county, but an English one at that).
Idea: Monarchist revival across Europe
my dude, you seriously underestimate the French's ability to absolutely go apeshit with their current government. There is a reason why the right parties cannot get together
Did you watch the video where the entirety of France revolts constantly
imagine the spanish king dies in this world and they look to the french king, uniting both nations
The treat of utreacth make it imposible
@@LuisGuillermoWongVelez well that can always change in scenarios like these
@@michealsoh8432 well you want to produce a new world war? Haha
@@LuisGuillermoWongVelez more like nuclear wasteland lmao
Personal Union gonna go hard
A video like this but with the German monarchy restored in 2024 would be interesting
maybe as a second part in the same universe?
"Wish we could turn back time,
to the good old days"
A return of the Kaiserreich would be nice
19:11 I imagine him rebuilding the Tuileries Palace than restoring Versailles to its original function.
Yes, he would order the demolition of the Louvre pyramid and put the new Tuileries palace in its place.
As a Catholic, I wouldn't mind such a new kingdom and a return to sound Catholic values.
Actually de Gaulle briefly considered restoring Henri d'Orleans from around 1958-early 1960's. Charles de Gaulle came from a family of Legitimists, who begrudgingly supported the Orleanists with the Senior House of Bourbon's extinction following Chambourd's death. de Gaulle was sympathetic to the Orleanists and had regular correspondence with the likes of Charles Maurras, the head of Action Francais, the far right, Catholic centric, monarchist group. de Gaulle was quite friendly with d'Orleans and the two regularly discussed the topic.
Charles invited d'Orleans to join him in London as part of Free France. And in 58' he got rid of the laws barring royal pretenders and permitted them to run for President. The idea was the Henri who was well liked by many Republicans and many monarchist types would gain the presidency and put France on the path to a monarchical restoration, but those plans were shelved by the 60's when the left started getting more agitated as France's own "Sexual revolution" started getting off the ground leading to the end of his presidency.
Prior to 58' Charles was having d'Orleans act as a more public figure acting as one of his representatives to the French mandate in Syria, essentially putting him out there in the French public sphere.
Had d'Orleans joined de Gaulle in London in 1940, it might have led to de Gaulle being more open and overtly supportive of the idea of a monarchical restoration.
Then again, if you change up some of the post war politics like having the army instead lead a coup against the Fourth Republic, that might destabilize France or lead to a dictatorship where d'Orleans could have taken over in a manner similar to how Juan Carlos succeeded Franco. Considering how d'Orleans was okay with the left, he might have allied with opposition figures against such a dictatorship, leading a coup against it.
Suggestion:
What if the good relations of the USA and Russian empire turned into a full on alliance after the sale of Alaska?
The Railroad could be an icing on the cake now that I think of it.
Supremely based France? Yes please
Royalist France would be wonderful
What if the Bonapartists were restored?
Pro Napoleonic faction or a memeber of house Boneapart?
That's technically already the case because centrists
non merci
@@pharell366 Countries with constitutional monarchies are more stable than those that don't. Plus, there are many benefits to such a monarchy.
@@thinkwithaportallike what?
As a Belgian Walloon, I indeed only can the annexation of Wallonia in France only and truly only in this kind of scenario.
Longue vie au roi!
(Videntis, what will happen to my beloved Belgian's royal family in this scenario?)
My guess is they become the Flemish Royal Family.
@@jamestown8398 hardly, the flemish are more republican than thier walloon counterpart
@@jamestown8398hippety hoppety the Flemish crown is now Dutch property
What if the Hungarian revolution of 1956 succeeded
Thats a good one
The constitutional council controle the procédure of the référendum and the act which is convoquing the electors to the référendum. BUT he does not controle the content of the référendum. He's considering that the référendum . It considers that the referendum falls within the general expression of the nation. Consequently, he refuses to control it (Decision No. 92-313 DC of 23 September 1992)
Flagwise, I can see the French keeping the iconic tri-color and then the King can use the old Royal Standard for official purposes.
I could see France adopting the tricolor with the coat of arms in the center like the flag of Henri the Count of Chambord.
Constitutional pro-family French Monarchy? Yes please.
Magnificent ⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️
Louis Alphonse is THE traditional Catholic monarch (he even attends the Chatres pilgrimage)
Personally I like the idea of all European countries being Constitutional Monarchies.
I think it's horrible. How can we act like being a meritocratic society if there are people who hold a position of power literally just by the randomness of birth. Why is a King Felipe more deserving of representing the Spanish people than any other of 48 million people? I think the people should be able to o directly choose who is going to represent them.
Representative Monarchs also hold power in popularity and influence just before anyone wants to disagree.
@@derdude6214 I don't see it that way. Constitutional monarchs don't have any power nor should they as they're just figure heads with a fancy but traditional title. I think the PM is the representative of the masses elected through a democratic process which is why a PM is considered the most powerful person in a country with parliamentary system of government with Monarchs or Presidents aa merely titular heads.
I'm seriously freaking out with our current situation, it feels like a real-life game of HOI4. Thanks for the video.
Thanks For this as always! Suggestion: What if Louis II of hungary won the battle of mohacs?
Thats a good idea
Based French monarchy! They would most likey keep the tricolor because that has become the most recognizable symbol of France besides the Eiffel Tower.
The Eiffel Tower is an eyesore, Notre Dame is the true icon of Paris.
Pls pls pls pls do a whole serie about this, it was frankly amazing ❤❤
what if america had an emperor in 2024
Emperor Trumpious I the Orangeborn.
@@user-sz3cu8jh3s lol!!! 😂😆
mmm dragonborne lore
I would vote for a right-wing monarchist that isn't Trump.
Julius Bidenus I
part 2 about a restoration of monarchies across europe
Great video, I would like to see this scenario continue with different countries, like Germany, Austria, Czechia or Poland.
Love your content man! Thanks For this 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
He has such great content
France the good timeline
That reminds me, have you done a video on “what if Germany restored their monarchy?”
kinda, its the video on the kaiser overthrowing hitler
That's (for modern day Germany) completely impossible. The German constitution in Article 20 states that the German Republic is a democratic and social federal state and that all state power shall come from the people. And every German has the right to resist anyone trying to change this status quo if needed even with violence. This article 20 (together with article 1) are also even protected by the eternity law that states that those two article and there described principles can never be removed or changed. The only party that openly wants to dissolve this eternity law is the far right extremist AfD. And up to now there is no way they will get the majority it needs to change anything in the constitution.
I'm okay with unrealistic scenarios but it then has to be something as the eternity law not existing instead of cheesing some weird majorities.
@@derdude6214 🤓
@@loganpaschedag8829 It's alternative history stop acting like we aren't all nerds
as a French moarchist, this is all I could dream of
Do you have a preferred royal house? Or would you support whichever seems to be faring better?
@@hugoferreira7992bourbon. They’re the rightful heirs
@@borginburkes1819, but if you had to choose between the republic and the Bonapartes?
@@borginburkes1819 Rightful heir is House Bonaparte
@@hugoferreira7992 Bourbon is my first choose. But if I had to choose between the republic and the Bonaparts, I choose Bonaparte.
What if Napoleon won?
A frenchman talking about building a society on the lifelong covenant between a man and a woman has got to be the most no french thing ever. Also nice vid
Fundamental Laws of the Crown of France never stated that the king had to be born in France, as the modern Orleanists fantasize. Therefore Count of Paris might only become another Louis Philippe, he can never come to be a legitimist monarch, unless the Spanish line goes extinct.
Tiny corrections: The Parti Socialist goes from slighly to the right of LFI to strait up right. Olivier Dussopt, minister of work is from this party and his reforms where far from anything someone remotly leftist could do. Glucksman is not the leader of the PS, but it's figurhead.
Also, the RN is not socialist at all, eaven in the economic field. I'll come back to this comment but they voted agains't many social law.
Olivier Dussopt isnt part of the PS anymore since 2017 lol, the PS is a leftist party. For the RN, yes, economically speaking they are more socialists than liberals
Olivier Dussopt isnt part of the government anymore
2:58 well, the second highest office is technically the presidency of the senate, since the president of the senate is the one who replaces the president of the republic if he dies or if he is unable to go through with his term.
As a puerto Rican I would like to hear the opinions of Frenchmen about there thoughts on the monarchy.
Ya que eres puertoriqueño te lo escribire en español. En una encuesta del 2021, el 15% de los frances querian una restauracion de la monarquia porque les parecia que la republica habia dejado ser frances con medidas socialistas que ya habian hecho perder la confianza en la gente, esto hizo resurgir el movimiento pro-monarquia que nunca habia desaparecido.
@@LuisGuillermoWongVelez Ohh ok, eso me parece lógico. ¡Muchas gracias por su opinión!
@@fredelboricua_5676The guy above you is definitely biased. The truth is that today no one cares about the monarchy besides a few people here and there. The wording of that 15% poll he’s talking about was « would you mind a monarchist restoration », not « do you support a monarchist restoration ». There’s a big difference. In 2019, a single monarchist party tried to run in the elections and got 0,01% of the votes.
Bonapartist Head of State or Generals for a monarchy, not useless out of touch nobles.
Nobody really wants it.
Some nostalgic think of Napoleon or Louis XIVth and go "those were the days" but present them with nowadays options and they'll stick to republic.
If you have any questions on the timeline or want the songs, leave a comment.
if i may propose a what if scenario. id like to see what if poland became a monarchy after the first world war good sir.
what if hanover unified germany
It would be interesting to know how this would affect Spain.
Felipe is too conservative for the leftists and too idle for the right and Louis is already loved by the Spanish right and especially by serious Spanish Catholics. Maybe one of his sons might become king, since Felipe only has female heirs and this was enough to cause a Carlist war the first time, so it could cause tensions this time around also.
Also how would Karl and George Habsburg use this opportunity
Maybe these could be used for a future scenario?
It would be interesting to see if France remains in the eu or nato perhaps due to the immigration forced on them by the eu causes FRExit? From the European Union
Whats the song at the Wallonia part 16:19
Damm, the curent bourbon decendant sounds based.
King Emmanuel is crazy
Imagine the dynasty on that man
He is not the King, but the buffoon of the King. And I say that as a French.
Yeah, bro thinks he's Napoleon cause he won a reelection
Mais non, Le Roi Emmanuel est le stupid!
p.s. I hope that I said this correctly in French.
@@carterbentonjr399It's just "stupide" without the "le", but other than that you're correct
the king guy looks like henry cavill
Could you make a similar video talking about Italy?
Obviously the real contender for the Italian throne is His Royal Highness Aimone of Savoy-Aosta!
Anyway, nice video, congratulations!
Hello, I'm a French legitimist and I'd just like to correct the errors in the video. Before I start, I'd like to make it clear that I'm not criticising your video negatively, but I just want to inform you. To begin with, Louis XX was certainly in favour of a constitutional monarchy in the 2010s, but today he is in favour of the old regime. Secondly, our king says that he is "available to the French", which means that he will not work on his own to re-establish the monarchy (I'm talking about concrete actions here) and that he will respond to the call of the French if they want to re-establish the monarchy, but he does support our legitimist movement and makes numerous appearances. As for an alliance with Action Française, this is totally unimaginable, although many AF members are not Orleanists, the irrigante class is attached to their master Charle Maurass and does not advocate religion as a priority (which for the legitimists is totally unimaginable) not to mention the very many differences in doctrine, so although a merger between the Orleanist and legitimist movements would be wonderful it remains highly unlikely.
Italian socialist here, so I do not fully know the modern french monarchist area, is it more realistic a legitimist or a orleanist reinstauration in France? I mean, the orleanists already have active groups (Action Française, Alliance Royale and Nouvelle Action Royaliste).
Also, just out of curiosity, why would you support a monarchy and in particular why would you support either dinasty? Why not a Bonaparte or an Orleans for example?
@@historicalitalianmemer8495 Hi, as things stand, restoration is out of the question due to the lack of support from the population. As for which branch to choose, to cut a long story short, legitimism is based on the society of the ancien régime with a monarchy of divine right, orleanism is based on the July monarchy with a constitutional monarchy and, finally, bonapartism, which is not a royal dynasty but an imperial one, is based on a regime with democratic but authoritarian foundations. If you have another question, let me know
Blessed
this needs a part two, mainly showing how other countries shift more to monarchism a bit
Probably wouldn't do much. If anything Louis would be used as an example of why Monarchys should die unfortunately his views would not sit well with people.
@@Carpediem357 true but it could be a rally cry for monarchists
@@Ziafiz true
What if Bismarck wasn't fired
Alright so let me, a frenchman, explain how this scenario is LARPY AF:
-RN has 184 (also you forgot the 1 in 184) and PC has 31 seats and are in a coalition... It's not a majority... They can't pass anything.
-France = Republic so good luck for anyone to actually believe in monarchism. Why do you think we say "Vive la France et vive la République!"?
-Why did you ignore the laïcité? French secularism is VERY strong and will not be easy to get rid of, if you even can.
-Socialism is not when the government does stuff
-RN is very much conservative
Overall completely delusional.
yeah not the most realistic scenario. I was working with a French socialist from my server for most of the political stuff. His english isnt amazing so we had some difficulties communicating so my apologies if any of the numbers are incorrect. Obviously France wouldn't restore the monarchy, this is more of a thought experiment on what would change if Louis Alphonse actually took power in France. I'm trying to learn more about France's politics so if you know the system well, i'm all ears
I started laughing my ass off at first because when I read PC, I thought PCF 🤣
le cope de malade mdrr, détend toi c'est un scénario tout sauf sérieux
French republic doesn't even look French anymore. It looks like your football team. Anything but French. Overall delusional.
RN is absolutely NOT conservative : they are for abortion, gay mariage, ART for gay couples and alone women…
If only this could happen.
I don’t want you doing politics or future althis. Please continue to do what you’re doing, no changes!
Really enjoy this content. Both for the recaps of IRL, but also for the alternate timeline. Keep it up!
Le roy louis go hard in the background!
If FRANCE of all countries would turn monarchist within 10 years, then Montenegro and Serbia will be the first ones to immediately switch back to monarchy, with monarchist parties being in other countries
The French is unique in this kind of situation where the people cannot decide whether or not they are in for a monarch. I think it is better to have a monarch. Just to have someone be a figurehead, not an administrative, policy-making entity but somebody to look on to, someone to fight for and to unite with. I think it will give France a steady direction.
I'm an history fan so i'm like "Oh I like the fleur de lys" but then i'm also trans and living my life and the part where I basicly become illegal made me think "yea I remembered why I dont want conservatives deciding for me what is best for my life". This is why I would prefer a bonapart house, more liberal and carry more of the spirit of the french revolution
Love you man, God bless and continue posting
Bold of you to assume the king would be a Bourbon
No matter what, the French will never let the Bourbons rule over them
Centuries of manipulation and brainwashing are difficult to undo, but not impossible.
France president:*becomes king*
French People:looks like we have to do a third revolution
A q&a video would be great
This is a better world!
No
C’est un très bon scénario ✝️✝️🇫🇷🇫🇷🦅🦅⚔️⚔️
Vive la France 🦅🦅🇫🇷🇫🇷
It is
Umm…
Very epic, big if will happen, I will probably try to become a French citizen then
I’m French and I wanted to say that you video is actually very good, you seem to know French politics better than a lot of Frenchs content creators 😂
Love this
Best future for France
4:27 wow this guy sounds very coo-
5:02 oh
😬 this ain’t the channel for you
@@ash_11117 nah idc about the Channel political opinion It the content Is good
Love tour content
The legitimate King of France is Louis XX (of Bourbon)
Third French Empire when?
new videntis upload, time to drop everything
Real
Facts
If only 🙏
The French King Supports some pretty good things if I was a French citizen I would support him.
VIVE LE ROI!! ⚜️⚜️⚜️🔵🔵🔵✝️
I desire with all my heart a return of the legitimate Bourbons, after they were punished by God when failing to consecrate France to the Sacred Heart as requested by our Lord through St. Margaret Mary Alacoque. But it will come in the future, they will be back, the Great King will come.
Day 1 of asking if you can make a video on if Kenya west could save help save Napoleon and help him beat the 7th
Coalition
Do another video like this, but instead of the House of Bourbon, make it the House of Bonaparte.
I am French and even if the scenario is not very realistic it was very funny, in fact it is especially the attitude of the National Rally which is doubtful, the rest is rather well tied up even if it would surely have caused lots of other problems , but great video !
Here is a interesting video idea what if john of gaunt did manage to become king of castile he did claim to be king from his wife
We need this badly
This was a really interesting video. Can you make more videos like this? I’d like to see a video similar to this one for Hungary 🇭🇺
"France is in political chaos once more"
oh boy is it Saturday already?
What a nightmarish scenario
Also there is literally no possibility that France votes to become a monarchy
This channel isn't exactly realistic alternate history, it's more hypothetic interesting scenarios. Look at Byzantium: Part 2 for example. If you want some sort of realism try Possible History for example.
@@thenamesianna i dont think there really is a realistic alt hist channel. He has videos on Soviet zombie armies. The most realistic video I think I've done is probably Athens winning the Peloponnesian War.
@@Videntis.History I mean, you'd have to convince the bacteria behind the plague not to travel to the city.
3:19 Colorado you ain't slick.
Vive le Roy de France Louis XX !!🏳⚜️🏳
ngl the attempt at french accent made me loose it
I’ve just seen a pretty major mistake here so I’d like to point it out : France has actually undergone two Restauration(s) already (one before les Cent-Jours, while Napoléon was in Elba, and then the second one, after Waterloo), so that would actually make la Troisième Restauration (9:09)
I would love to live in that kind of france
I think keep the tri-colour, if you must, as a battle-flag. I do not think it would be necessary though.
False…
imagine louis taking notes while watching this
This is a worse world!
No
It’s a better world.
Agreed.
Yeah, it very much is.
Yes. Very much so.
This video is really well made and really interesting. That's basically a tuto of how to take the power.
I would prefer a Bonaparte restoration but a Bourbon king is better than the current situation in France
congrats, you made me a fan of Louis Alphonse
17:58 He forgot that he lives in France ☠️.
What if Bulgaria return to Tsardom