Thank you Rami. Excellent! Humans just can not seem to help themselves from causing so much unnecessary suffering, isolation, shame and physical and soul pain to so many innocent beings in so many ways and on so many levels; it's really exhausting, the undeveloped consciousness, is exhausting - I hope I will not have to reincarnate among them again.
El.punto.de la homosexualida no debe jusgarse y señalarse como.algo malo o diabolico es algo normal entre 2 seres humanos que se aman al final cuando mueramos nadie sabra nada de ambos pero les isieron la vida un infierno vive y deja vivir saludos desde mexico 🇲🇽 muy guapo el.hijo gay .
the short doesn't need to be so literal, it's for an adult audience, so instead of a fairy-tale narrative with a jubilant happy ending, it chooses to be subtle, and more realistic. The family's bond and love is remarked in the last scene...as if nothing really changed in the 3 men's dynamic., and love. Men do not explicit their sentiments, especially in macho culture. But they have already chosen to defend the youngest of the family, no need for forgiveness.
It has been 33 years since my husband and I have been together.... him much younger..... his Dad still does not accept him, but once every 4 years might tell him that he loves him..... He gave up on his dad 25 years ago..... just an ass to all.... a "poor" me guy..... it can be hard in America, but I cannot imagine over in the Mid East..... cultures..... They (folks everywhere) always act as if they are saints...... just gotta live life..... and love who you are...... Yes, It is hard at times.
les Etats d'Amérique ne sont pas tous pareils , mais ça n'a rien de comparable avec les arabes ou les pays à l'Est de l Europe, pourtant dieu sait quel nombre incalculable de musulmans se paient des hommes , donc c'est une vraie foutaise , une mascarade !!
Parents, have this notion. Once they have children. They have the right to control. And dictate their lives forever. Even as adults. Loving someone of the same sex. Isn't a crime. But they treat them like criminals. Because, they don't want to live. The life their parents demand. Do not" they understand" they chose the person they married. Why" can't I chose, the person I ❤☮️
The movie is from Israel. It is filmed in Haifa. The actors are all Israelis. Very interesting portrait of their culture. I thought Israel was open minded
A very good short film that is much better than a lot of what I have seen from Brazil, India or China/Japan. The young man wants to fly and his wings were cut off by his brother and father - clearly visible in the last scene. All three wear black, like a uniform. He was brought into line and now no longer wears a pink shirt, nor does he have a motif with a rifle that shows him to be peaceful and at the same time fighting for his cause. How ridiculous is the family's fear of what others say. The young man should separate from her and emigrate to a country where he can not only study medicine and dance, but also live an openly gay life. He shouldn't stay in the Middle Ages. There is something wrong with the person who says God is enough for me.
For the family, I don't think societal ostracization is something to shake a stick at, especially in really anti-gay cultures. For me, the ending of this film has to be taken in social, cultural, etc. context. The wearing of black by all can be seen different ways. Now the family knows about him at least, and he's still accepted (hasn't been kicked out), but they also have to balance the reality of his identity with a need for all of them to exist in a society that is oppressive about sexual nonconformity. He's a part of the family, but he has to also fit in for their sake. The reality is it requires some compromise, but it's not necessarily a defeat for him. But again, that's just one possible interpretation of the ending. All that said, you're probably right. I think he also got a text at the end that he had to ignore, so clearly being controlled. Also, after looking up the word "Mlukhiye," I see that it is an ancient traditional vegetable-based dish, I guess representing tradition/familial tradition, but also just food for sustenance - what is needed for survival. But so what is the point in that case? Doesn't sound hopeful.
@@ayejay8862 you are spot on in everything, i am from the same culture. There is compromise on both sides but in the end, no real solutions....which makes the film pointless and just exposes closeted gays that may be blending in under cover. Because the filmmakers are Christian Arabs trying to depict the plight of Muslim gays when they could never understand it because closeted Muslims are also in conflict internally, not sure what route to take. This film does nothing but threaten to out people faster than they can process what they want in life themselves. selfish, reckless, and treacherous if you really knew the agony of a true closeted religious Muslim LGBT person. They have Quranic verses in the film on the wall to depict a Muslim family but the director and probably the actors are nonMuslim Palestinians, or at least nonreligious people in general
The next thing you come to know is that the infuriated jilted Catfisher tries to accuse the guy for robbing something from him. On one side is the homophobic society while on the other, is the dark side, within the community, where there are people who make it unsafe.
الحقيقة المرة، لو كانت هذه الحقيقة لا كان العالم كله جميل، نحن المثليين لانتفاهم ما بيننا كيف حابيت الاخر بيفهمك المهم انشاء الله نلحق كل إنسان يجب أن يكون حر في نفسه On doit apprendre à ne pas juger l'autre, chaque individu est libre. la vie n'appartient à personne, c'est dieu qui gouverne, alors pourquoi les individus impose des lois et des concepts créer par eux même ??
i am from the same culture. There is compromise on both sides but in the end, no real solutions....which makes the film pointless and just exposes closeted gays that may be blending in under cover. Because the filmmakers are Christian Arabs and Jews trying to depict the plight of Muslim gays when they could never understand it because closeted religious Muslims are also in conflict internally, not sure what route to take, or what the meaning of their plight is. There is a huge difference between being gay and being sexually active in Islam. Society can understand orientation but will not be sympathetic to sexual exploration. This film does nothing but threaten to out people faster than they can process what they want in life themselves. selfish, reckless, and treacherous if you really knew the agony of a true closeted religious Muslim LGBT person. They have Quranic verses in the film on the wall to depict a Muslim family but the director and probably the actors are nonMuslim Palestinians, or at least nonreligious people in general. A true gay person would never wish agony on a fellow LGBT. It really helps noone, whether you're out or not...just gives the homophobes the clues to stomp out loopholes gay Arabs/allies use to find each other. which is why i find this so disheartening and foolish I do admire the courage, I just can't see the conservative societies being accepting anytime soon.
رهيب جدا 😢الفيلم بمثل واقع كل مختلف بمجتمعنا
يب😢
انا مثلي
@@MohamedMeherhera-b3h courage , pas évident chez les musulmans
@@mpyndur2552 merci bisous
Very good film! Sitting down together to share a meal, break bread, is always a place to start understanding each other.
Thank you Rami. Excellent! Humans just can not seem to help themselves from causing so much unnecessary suffering, isolation, shame and physical and soul pain to so many innocent beings in so many ways and on so many levels; it's really exhausting, the undeveloped consciousness, is exhausting - I hope I will not have to reincarnate among them again.
I am all too familiar with this heart-breaking situation for all concerned. Thank you for this film.
Music on stairs IS fantastic 😂❤❤❤ zah zah hamou 😂😂😂
At least the young man didn't get beat up or maybe something worse by his father and brother. Showing some civility. I suppose that's a good start.
Because it's in Chaifa, in Israel, he doesn't get raped and he doesn't get slaughtered.
Yes Love & respect ❤
@@Diamond18116 as if there was such a thing in Arab culture.
The way they sat at the end casually eating is quite amusing 😂
Well done! More please.
😍
Love from Assam, India, Barpeta
ردة فعل الأب " ناعمه " كثير 😮😮 لا تشبه الواقع العربي و نهاية فيلم مش مفهومه يعني في الآخر تقبلوه مثل هو ولا صار مثلهم straight!!
فيلم مضلل
@@ahmedbo9755 فيلم سخيف وتافه
Sometimes a film isn't about what is, but what we hope will be.
واضح ان الفيلم في الاراضي المحتلة واقع عربي ايه 😂 هذا النوع من الافلام هي افلام الاحتلال يوجد منها في الجزائر ايام الاحتلال الفرنسي
بقدر اتواصل مع المخرج
Rami.director on instagram
Hii@@ramif567
How I get your number @@ramif567
More of this please 😊❤❤❤
A good short film ❤
Food brings family together no matter what is going on. ❤
El.punto.de la homosexualida no debe jusgarse y señalarse como.algo malo o diabolico es algo normal entre 2 seres humanos que se aman al final cuando mueramos nadie sabra nada de ambos pero les isieron la vida un infierno vive y deja vivir saludos desde mexico 🇲🇽 muy guapo el.hijo gay
.
It doesn't show the love that typically wins after a couple of years. Too bad.
the short doesn't need to be so literal, it's for an adult audience, so instead of a fairy-tale narrative with a jubilant happy ending, it chooses to be subtle, and more realistic. The family's bond and love is remarked in the last scene...as if nothing really changed in the 3 men's dynamic., and love. Men do not explicit their sentiments, especially in macho culture. But they have already chosen to defend the youngest of the family, no need for forgiveness.
לא הבנתי מה קטע,בגלל הערבית.אבל אהבתי מאוד.❤
Use subtitles
Ce jeune homme est très charmant mais pour vivre sa sexualité dans son pays cela doit être très difficile
@Rami Fahel me gustaría tener la posibilidad de poder verla subtitulada en español
if you want to translate it hit me up
It has been 33 years since my husband and I have been together.... him much younger..... his Dad still does not accept him, but once every 4 years might tell him that he loves him..... He gave up on his dad 25 years ago..... just an ass to all.... a "poor" me guy..... it can be hard in America, but I cannot imagine over in the Mid East..... cultures..... They (folks everywhere) always act as if they are saints...... just gotta live life..... and love who you are...... Yes, It is hard at times.
In the EAST they must STOP thinking that homosexuality is a sin! It is NOT a sin 🙏
les Etats d'Amérique ne sont pas tous pareils , mais ça n'a rien de comparable avec les arabes ou les pays à l'Est de l Europe, pourtant dieu sait quel nombre incalculable de musulmans se paient des hommes , donc c'est une vraie foutaise , une mascarade !!
Nice try, Satan.
@@lorenzolozzigallo2589ain't real the Catholic Church added him to the story later on.
2:24 what is the name of the Song ??
Yasmine Hamdan - Da
Beautiful and shatteringly sad. May a free Palestine bring change for all who live within it. 🍉🌈
They’re not Palestinian. The movie is Israeli, it’s filmed in Haifa.
@@WorldEye88 Palestinians living in occupied Palestine. any other questions?
@@ramif567 It was not a question. This is an Israeli movie with Israeli actors. I know it is occupied Palestine.
Parents, have this notion. Once they have children. They have the right to control. And dictate their lives forever. Even as adults. Loving someone of the same sex. Isn't a crime. But they treat them like criminals. Because, they don't want to live. The life their parents demand. Do not" they understand" they chose the person they married. Why" can't I chose, the person I ❤☮️
مافي جزء ثاني؟
The movie is from Israel. It is filmed in Haifa. The actors are all Israelis. Very interesting portrait of their culture. I thought Israel was open minded
Do you have a prove?
@@zxzxzxzx53 yes. you look it up..
A very good short film that is much better than a lot of what I have seen from Brazil, India or China/Japan. The young man wants to fly and his wings were cut off by his brother and father - clearly visible in the last scene. All three wear black, like a uniform. He was brought into line and now no longer wears a pink shirt, nor does he have a motif with a rifle that shows him to be peaceful and at the same time fighting for his cause.
How ridiculous is the family's fear of what others say. The young man should separate from her and emigrate to a country where he can not only study medicine and dance, but also live an openly gay life. He shouldn't stay in the Middle Ages.
There is something wrong with the person who says God is enough for me.
For the family, I don't think societal ostracization is something to shake a stick at, especially in really anti-gay cultures. For me, the ending of this film has to be taken in social, cultural, etc. context. The wearing of black by all can be seen different ways. Now the family knows about him at least, and he's still accepted (hasn't been kicked out), but they also have to balance the reality of his identity with a need for all of them to exist in a society that is oppressive about sexual nonconformity. He's a part of the family, but he has to also fit in for their sake. The reality is it requires some compromise, but it's not necessarily a defeat for him. But again, that's just one possible interpretation of the ending. All that said, you're probably right. I think he also got a text at the end that he had to ignore, so clearly being controlled. Also, after looking up the word "Mlukhiye," I see that it is an ancient traditional vegetable-based dish, I guess representing tradition/familial tradition, but also just food for sustenance - what is needed for survival. But so what is the point in that case? Doesn't sound hopeful.
@@ayejay8862 you are spot on in everything, i am from the same culture. There is compromise on both sides but in the end, no real solutions....which makes the film pointless and just exposes closeted gays that may be blending in under cover. Because the filmmakers are Christian Arabs trying to depict the plight of Muslim gays when they could never understand it because closeted Muslims are also in conflict internally, not sure what route to take. This film does nothing but threaten to out people faster than they can process what they want in life themselves. selfish, reckless, and treacherous if you really knew the agony of a true closeted religious Muslim LGBT person. They have Quranic verses in the film on the wall to depict a Muslim family but the director and probably the actors are nonMuslim Palestinians, or at least nonreligious people in general
Finally.....
The next thing you come to know is that the infuriated jilted Catfisher tries to accuse the guy for robbing something from him.
On one side is the homophobic society while on the other, is the dark side, within the community, where there are people who make it unsafe.
الحقيقة المرة، لو كانت هذه الحقيقة لا كان العالم كله جميل، نحن المثليين لانتفاهم ما بيننا كيف حابيت الاخر بيفهمك
المهم انشاء الله نلحق كل إنسان يجب أن يكون حر في نفسه
On doit apprendre à ne pas juger l'autre, chaque individu est libre. la vie n'appartient à personne, c'est dieu qui gouverne, alors pourquoi les individus impose des lois et des concepts créer par eux même ??
Qué guapos los hombres de medio oriente ❤,sus mujeres también muy bellas ➕ los hombres son muy varoniles
et comme ils sont pédés aussi , ne croit pas , ils sont nombreux à avoir des relations homos , mais ils se cachent !!
الأب يجنن فحل رسمي
Love from Assam, Barpeta 😊😊😊❤❤
The judgment 2023 film upload please
نزللنا ترجمة للمشاهد العبرية ما منفهم لو سمحت
في ترجمة انجليزي
Too sad. Being gay in a country like this, must be a nightmare.
It’s Israel
i am from the same culture. There is compromise on both sides but in the end, no real solutions....which makes the film pointless and just exposes closeted gays that may be blending in under cover. Because the filmmakers are Christian Arabs and Jews trying to depict the plight of Muslim gays when they could never understand it because closeted religious Muslims are also in conflict internally, not sure what route to take, or what the meaning of their plight is. There is a huge difference between being gay and being sexually active in Islam. Society can understand orientation but will not be sympathetic to sexual exploration. This film does nothing but threaten to out people faster than they can process what they want in life themselves. selfish, reckless, and treacherous if you really knew the agony of a true closeted religious Muslim LGBT person. They have Quranic verses in the film on the wall to depict a Muslim family but the director and probably the actors are nonMuslim Palestinians, or at least nonreligious people in general. A true gay person would never wish agony on a fellow LGBT.
It really helps noone, whether you're out or not...just gives the homophobes the clues to stomp out loopholes gay Arabs/allies use to find each other. which is why i find this so disheartening and foolish
I do admire the courage, I just can't see the conservative societies being accepting anytime soon.
let's talk
Please what's the name of the movie
Ridiculous from start to end. As an older Palestinian gay man i find this film unintentionally funny.
I agree with you. The movie is made in Israel with Israeli actors. They don’t really capture the Arab culture.
تعا نحكي
@@ramif567 تقصد تحكي معي انا؟
@@ramif567 لو حابب نحكي قللي
Iran?
Israel. It’s filmed in Haifa.
منو يعرف اسم الأب عجبني 😊
❤
❤❤❤
Habibi❤
@yasyr95 Hii nic your dp good looking handsome i am interest me
لو من غير عبري كان هيبقى احلى بس للاسف مش قادر اكمل
is a good message
I wished if the movie discussed how Palestinians are miss treated in the colony too!
You will not be able to see it. Bcs it won’t be allowed.
Was it Arabic or other Islamic language can anyone translate it please?
There's nothing such as Islamic language 💀
1. no such thing as islamic language 2. uhhh subtitles????
Hebrew. It’s in Israel.
Arabic and hebrew - there are English subtitles
Which country this story'is based?
palestine
@@ramif567 thanks
Hiiii ❤❤❤❤love you too baby 👶 😘 ❤️ 💕 💖 💓
❤❤❤❤
😂ملوخيه ناعمه حسبي الله
😊😊😊❤❤❤
Hum bhi single hai 😊😊😊
Ini.bagus.ya.
حرام
🌈🖤🤞
schon schwierig,
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Risky Game 😮😮😮😮😮😮
Why did you make such misleading and propagandistic films? Don’t taint Palestine with the vile messages in this film.
It’s because it’s an Israeli movie with Israeli actors
Que porqueria
فيلم مضلل
At what point did they throw him off of the roof? This is too short a story, there's no way it would have ended that way.
most of stories and just like that, the film is actually show the most cases. not the few violent ending you hear about.
Racist troll
💖
❤❤❤❤