Victor Davis Hanson- The Loss of American Deterrence

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 150

  • @jbudd032003
    @jbudd032003 6 місяців тому +13

    Brilliant man. His messages are always come in time.

  • @craigmartin5484
    @craigmartin5484 5 років тому +55

    This is fascinating on deterence vs appeasement. VDH, you are truly brilliant.

    • @kloschuessel773
      @kloschuessel773 4 роки тому +4

      Craig Martin we had this experience in germany too.
      We had appeasers and the soviets got worse.

    • @deansicking7132
      @deansicking7132 Рік тому

      Okc toll system

  • @shalevedna
    @shalevedna 2 місяці тому +8

    This lecture is from 7 years ago?!?!?! It is so bloody relevant it is frightening.

    • @deborahcadabra-w5z
      @deborahcadabra-w5z 2 місяці тому +1

      I’m watching this 2024 oct. and thought it was recent too. This man is awesome. What he said about Europe is so true. Frightening. It’s a shame people like this don’t want to go into politics.

    • @erickaufmancustomguitars1351
      @erickaufmancustomguitars1351 Місяць тому

      ​@@deborahcadabra-w5z
      Its even more a shame the ones in power will not listen to a word of it.

  • @chitrungkim
    @chitrungkim Рік тому +14

    Always great learning listening to the professor

  • @michaelthomasgraham7769
    @michaelthomasgraham7769 3 місяці тому +6

    Well Done VDH!

  • @MichaelSlattery-sh8vl
    @MichaelSlattery-sh8vl Рік тому +12

    Thank you! Dr. Hanson!

  • @rezzer7918
    @rezzer7918 Рік тому +8

    Exciting. Magnificent. Stirring. Revivifying.

  • @gulfcoastpinebelt8600
    @gulfcoastpinebelt8600 4 роки тому +34

    Just recently discovered Victor and I'm floored by his was of explaining history and current world events. He's worth listening to for the 1:30:00 minute lectures

  • @chuckcribbs3398
    @chuckcribbs3398 8 років тому +121

    Dr. Hanson is a national treasure.

    • @dtbbull4222
      @dtbbull4222 2 роки тому +2

      I absolutely agree. I can listen to him all day long.

    • @onaleeshipstead
      @onaleeshipstead Рік тому +1

      @@dtbbull4222 yes,I agree.

    • @davidclark573
      @davidclark573 5 місяців тому

      YHanson tries but he keeps missing the mark.

  • @rakadus
    @rakadus Місяць тому +5

    Listening in 2024. So prescient. Vision.

  • @gilguthrie9494
    @gilguthrie9494 5 років тому +25

    Dr.Hanson for Governor!

  • @Josh-pe5pl
    @Josh-pe5pl 4 роки тому +12

    U r the epitome of a great, proud and grateful American, a
    profound gift to our country for your time.
    One could say you're a re-booted and updated version of a thinking founder.
    Warm appreciation for educating via YT. Signed,
    A fellow concerned American, also from a CA family as old as yours.

  • @cynthialocher393
    @cynthialocher393 5 місяців тому +4

    So amazing he's so spot on I didn't hear this before I hope people will listen now that you're more known😮

  • @grantarnold1815
    @grantarnold1815 Рік тому +16

    The old adage, peace through strength. We need a leader who understands this and needs to be able to verbalize it effectively and without regret.

    • @johngill8407
      @johngill8407 5 місяців тому +1

      Hanson I saw this lecture in summer of 25 and I have a question. In view of this deterrent speech. Are you really a hawk? ; totally in favor of US advancing itself to a world empire through aggressive conflict?

    • @LARRYANIEL-dz9zz
      @LARRYANIEL-dz9zz 4 місяці тому +1

      E-1Q71 UNO ANIEL LARRY

    • @shalevedna
      @shalevedna 2 місяці тому +1

      Definitely not Kamala…

  • @dtbbull4222
    @dtbbull4222 2 роки тому +11

    VDH is a giant! I love hearing him speak.

  • @marcelmagi4600
    @marcelmagi4600 7 років тому +20

    VDH is next level!

  • @johnpick8336
    @johnpick8336 4 місяці тому +1

    Martin Armstrong is a0lways informative. Thank you for posting.

  • @carolyncunningham3847
    @carolyncunningham3847 5 років тому +8

    Victor Hanson for President!!

  • @keithpennock
    @keithpennock 2 місяці тому +2

    Small correction: It was Adelai Stevenson not Dean Acheson who said South Korea was outside of the security cordon prompting the Korean War.

  • @juansenaranjo
    @juansenaranjo 3 роки тому +8

    Victor should be the candidate on 2024!

  • @thomassmestead6424
    @thomassmestead6424 5 років тому +24

    VDH is absolutely correct: In the long run, appeasement costs far more than deterrence. Historical FACT.
    A misconception is that deterrence equates with aggression. They are not the same.

    • @Bob-fz7pd
      @Bob-fz7pd 5 років тому +6

      From the school yard to international relations bullies will take your stuff and kick your butt if you try to appease them. Non violence bought us WW2.

    • @pamphelps3243
      @pamphelps3243 Рік тому

      1:46 😅

    • @pamphelps3243
      @pamphelps3243 Рік тому

    • @alexanderlightstone3539
      @alexanderlightstone3539 Місяць тому

      ⁠​⁠@@Bob-fz7pd😢😮😮😢😢😢😢😢

  • @davissae
    @davissae Рік тому +10

    VDH and Sowell are our true conservative intellectuals.

    • @douglemay7989
      @douglemay7989 4 місяці тому

      Which is an oxymoron. Sowell is a sellout.

  • @grantarnold1815
    @grantarnold1815 Рік тому +6

    Walk softly and carry a big stick!!!!!

  • @Theseus9-cl7ol
    @Theseus9-cl7ol 7 років тому +2

    You were spot on with the last phrase of your speech Mr. Hanson, ......prophetic.

  • @leanthom4825
    @leanthom4825 5 місяців тому +3

    He doesn’t realize but he actually hit on the real problem. Back in the day quality education was more valuable than student satisfaction! Now a bad but like able professor will be valued above a stronger teacher!

  • @michelleg4346
    @michelleg4346 5 років тому +5

    Spot on!

  • @shawnmclean7932
    @shawnmclean7932 Місяць тому +1

    Great man.

  • @stanleykalapana8276
    @stanleykalapana8276 2 місяці тому +1

    We have his lectures are the mandatory in every high school, United States of America

  • @AnaxofRhodes
    @AnaxofRhodes 7 років тому +10

    I'd pay to hear a debate between Hanson and Peter Hitchens. Diametrically opposed on war with very good reasons on both sides.

  • @cpawp
    @cpawp 7 років тому +5

    To which list of terms/ knowledge is VDH referring?

  • @PS-sg1lz
    @PS-sg1lz 7 років тому +31

    Can somebody please bring this man to the White House! Trump needs to pick this brilliant brain! MAGA depends on you VDH!

    • @Theseus9-cl7ol
      @Theseus9-cl7ol 7 років тому +1

      I'm sure he knows of him. Rush Limbaugh has had him on his show, and Rush knows Trump......Oh plus, VDH personally knows Steve Bannon. So yeah, Trump knows him.

    • @robertblake1032
      @robertblake1032 5 років тому +1

      P S
      I’m not so sure they do. VDH has a great perspective and historical outlook but the big T has a great team around him. He’s doing a great job considering his background.
      Imagine what could be done if the collusion fiasco had not happened and the Dems were the Dems of old.
      Based on our current status it’s said that the US has 10 to 20 yrs until collapse. Might want to have some food and ammo stashed. When the urban areas free money dries up things will get very interesting.
      Good luck to us.

    • @johnbascietto5338
      @johnbascietto5338 5 років тому +2

      Yes I agree VDH should have conversations with our president ASAP

    • @Gweidemann
      @Gweidemann 5 років тому +3

      P S • "Make America Great Again" depends upon far, far more than a few amidst the many. In his September '96 newsletter to the audience of the Billy Graham Evangelist Association, Mr. Graham said "...If America is to be spared and to avoid the horrors of a dying nation, we must rediscover what it means to love God and one another." Without widespread repentance of our sins against God, there is no forgiveness. Without forgiveness, there is no Holy Spirit revival to arouse the church from 'her' deadly spiritual slumber. Without repentance and revival, America continues to evolve into a nationwide holocaustic nightmare. As Anglo American Patriot Daniel Webster is quoted to us from 1823 "...If God and His Word are not known and received, the Devil and his works will gain the ascendancy." For vengeance is mine, sayeth the Lord. I will repay, sayeth the Lord.

    • @Gweidemann
      @Gweidemann 5 років тому +3

      @@robertblake1032 It took far more than "luck", for the settlers of this nation to carve a civilization out of a wilderness, sir. Storing up food and weapons is advised by survivalists, for us to prepare for potential disaster before disaster strikes, as you suggest. General Douglas MacArthur so insightfully said "There had never been a single precedent in history where nations subject to moral decay have not passed into political and economic decline. There either has been a spiritual awakening to overcome the moral lapse or a progressive deterioration leading to national disaster."

  • @stephens1950
    @stephens1950 Рік тому +5

    Incompetentence is expensive

  • @stubryant9145
    @stubryant9145 9 днів тому

    We have not only learned that history repeats itself, VDH illustrated how those who have paid attention to history to the point of integrating motives and culture can see the possibilities of what may be coming with surprising accuracy.

  • @ruthgoldbergives6945
    @ruthgoldbergives6945 Рік тому +6

    How perverse is it that the major denominations - so-called Christian denominations in our country - affirm homosexuality, ordain homosexuals, ordain lesbians, marry men to men and women to women? Even the Quakers - and I quote - say, “Homosexuality is no more deplorable than left-handedness.” The Episcopalians have led the parade with a well-known bishop, for the whole of the United States of America, who is a sodomite. A local Methodist church not far from here, the pastor says, “A homosexual is welcome in this congregation and will have all the rights and privileges.” That’s hate speech. If you love that man, you’ll confront his sin and tell him about the gospel so his soul can be saved.

  • @kzoo4053
    @kzoo4053 Рік тому +3

    This is the second time I watched this video. Now I know whoever is behind Biden must watch it NOW!

    • @kzoo4053
      @kzoo4053 Рік тому +1

      But then they might disagree with what many of us think.

    • @garybulwinkle82
      @garybulwinkle82 Рік тому +2

      The forces behind Biden do not have America's best interests at heart! Since you don't know that, you have a lot to learn before you can even comprehend what is occurring. Ignorance is bliss!!

  • @stanleykalapana8276
    @stanleykalapana8276 2 місяці тому +2

    OK, it’s seven years later. What the hell we’re gonna do about it prayers just won’t do it no more.

  • @johnlohr5435
    @johnlohr5435 5 років тому +6

    Brilliant

  • @rodriffel6570
    @rodriffel6570 5 років тому +6

    VDH for president!

  • @susanarsoniadou
    @susanarsoniadou Рік тому +7

    Deterrence works if there is CERTAINTY of punishment.

  • @colemanadamson5943
    @colemanadamson5943 4 роки тому +6

    @53:45 the question asked is that of an appeaser. A.K.A. Coward....fool....or both. VDH gently tries to educate him on the nature of man which most believe is good.....WRONG. Man tends to one degree or another towards evil and that is a fact. VDH told him "humans are no damn good" and that is correct. Questions like that make my blood boil because I hate both cowards and fools.

    • @richardsmith1799
      @richardsmith1799 Рік тому +2

      🎉This is why conservatism matters. Fantasists let monsters off the leash.

    • @nomadmarauder-dw9re
      @nomadmarauder-dw9re 10 місяців тому

      An experiment in human nature: take a gaggle of 3 year olds. Put them in a room full of toys and snacks. Walk away. The point is that 3 year olds haven't been conditioned to not act in their own interests. Monitor but do not interfere.

  • @afathersdevotions
    @afathersdevotions 4 місяці тому +2

    7 years ago, and look at us now. How much longer will the USA remain sovereign.

  • @dmonarredmonarre3076
    @dmonarredmonarre3076 Рік тому +2

    Deterrence is roundabout (Austrian School of Economics term for achieving long-term gains)
    Concessions is immediacy.

  • @VidaMace
    @VidaMace 3 місяці тому +1

    Peace means not choosing to kill someone, even if you can😊

  • @michaelwoodsmccausland5633
    @michaelwoodsmccausland5633 Рік тому +5

    The Gentleman Scholar Farmer ! MWM

  • @cynthialocher393
    @cynthialocher393 5 місяців тому +2

    👏👏👏👏👏😊❤

  • @michaelbroadbent4639
    @michaelbroadbent4639 2 місяці тому +1

    This is so relevant today with the possible advent of Trump.

  • @cynthialocher393
    @cynthialocher393 5 місяців тому +1

    Well at least we have a bunch of people that hate America making some comments and I saw him pretty quick😮

  • @kzoo4053
    @kzoo4053 Рік тому +1

    I finally caught Dr Hanson making a mistake: he mentioned US M1 carbine but I know he meant to say M1 Garand rifle.

  • @johnfranklin8319
    @johnfranklin8319 2 роки тому +3

    These people make a 3 minute statement before they ask a question!

  • @kevinweinberger8446
    @kevinweinberger8446 Рік тому +5

    How could we get the professor to run for the president of the United States?

  • @pieter5466
    @pieter5466 Рік тому +5

    17:38 the argument that Obama lost deterrence for America

  • @wmffmw
    @wmffmw Рік тому +3

    That did't go to well for the Morlock's once a High Tech Barbarian showed up in the neighborhood.

  • @stevebryan2710
    @stevebryan2710 5 місяців тому +4

    WHY is this man not president???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  • @PaulWaterman-hi2eg
    @PaulWaterman-hi2eg 2 місяці тому +1

    How long have you been looking for yourself?!!

  • @stumorrow8835
    @stumorrow8835 11 місяців тому

    I agree with everything he says but have little idea of what he’s talking about

    • @Thomas-d2z8o
      @Thomas-d2z8o 3 місяці тому +1

      At least you know the truth when you hear it....

  • @michaelbroadbent4639
    @michaelbroadbent4639 Рік тому

    You should have kept your question short. There was no need for a diatribe. People were there to listen to Hanson.

  • @billhardaway8727
    @billhardaway8727 Рік тому

    Send to Thomas wessle

  • @jacksonlamme
    @jacksonlamme 7 днів тому

    Experience in the military has exactly 0% influence on my perception of a persons authority to speak on military related matters.

  • @FBLA605
    @FBLA605 5 місяців тому

    For God sakes people put your damn cutlery down

  • @hanselito2416
    @hanselito2416 Місяць тому

    Obama had drone "deterrence" for a small while. Air defenses caught up and now people are making them work for it but "deterrence" clingers dont win wars. You have to elect a fighter to finish what they start in their complacency ;)

  • @GETJUSTICE4U
    @GETJUSTICE4U Рік тому +1

    Germany had the most advanced weapons in the world during WWII. They had produced the first cruise missiles (Doodle Bugs), the first supersonic missiles (rockets), the fleet of giant submarines that were automated to fire six massive torpedoes in less than half a minute. The largest calibre guns in the world and the first squadron of jet fighters, it took three US or UK tanks to take out a single Panzar. After the war ended thousands of Nazi scientists were taken to America along with all this technology.
    The "Gass Station Posing as a Country" defeated this technological superpower. It also put the first satellite in space, the first man in space, built the first space station all while cut off from the rest of the world. To lie/hide about these historical facts benefits only the 1% mega wealthy at the expense of every one else.

  • @N4bpp1
    @N4bpp1 5 років тому +1

    When ever you listen to Dr. Hanson Orin person. Bring a dictionary .

  • @ДмитрийДепутатов
    @ДмитрийДепутатов 3 місяці тому

    Jackson Melissa White Gary Smith Barbara

  • @barnii8
    @barnii8 10 днів тому

    Victor has some excellent points but he is erratic and the point is lost. Keep it simple, Victor. Maybe it's his age but he seems addled, like Biden.

  • @mikepotter5718
    @mikepotter5718 7 років тому +1

    The one thing Mr. Hansen left out was that "deterers" will always find a war to fight. The reason doesn't have to be valid they just end up in places like Vietnam or Afghanistan.

    • @ZedRange
      @ZedRange 7 років тому +3

      Yes, that is unfortunately the downside... but it is as VDH would put it "better then the alternative"
      Reality never lets us relax...

  • @edtoomey433
    @edtoomey433 3 місяці тому

    Putin is a changed Man. He’s been through the worst of times and he has had enough! He is the Leader and President of Russia. We have to RESPECT him because of his position. Work with him and monitor his ongoing behavior and we will be great allies with Mother Russia. We need to get along in order to survive. We both, together put Hitler in his place. It is only right to move on together and also include 🇨🇳.
    Otherwise Peace ✌️ cannot be sustained. Amen 🙏.

  • @hectorgarcia6098
    @hectorgarcia6098 4 роки тому

    yoloquebeoudesgursedemaquonarasdeguerra

  • @jonoon27
    @jonoon27 Рік тому +1

    Obviously Dr. Hansen is not a supporter or even likes presidents Carter and Obama but obviously a big supporter of Ronald Reagan, regardless of Reagan’s stupid logic and comments such as trees cause pollution and catsup is a vegetable. Too bad Carter and Obama are not there to have a chance to explain the reasoning behind their policies. Talking about one sided discussion and self righteousness.

  • @ssebitaabawamala6861
    @ssebitaabawamala6861 Рік тому

    You are dangerous yourself

  • @jerryklooster438
    @jerryklooster438 Рік тому +1

    Hansen is a knowledgeable historian and a good public speaker. Unfortunately, some in our "youtube" society have elevated his stature, his significance, and his analysis of 21st century politics far above their rightful places in public discourse. He draws conclusions based on personal feelings masked in carefully selected facts, and has knowingly (or unknowlingly) become a shill for the neocons.

  • @davidtrindle6473
    @davidtrindle6473 4 роки тому +1

    RUSSIAN BOT WARNING

  • @juno1597
    @juno1597 Рік тому

    Now with the privilege of hindsight we can understand that Dr Hanson was incorrect about his perspective of the future possible president administrations, with Trump being more passive than the Obama administration overall. It seems Dr Hanson is politically partisan and as it pains you're taking with a huge grain of salt.

  • @goodmorning6827
    @goodmorning6827 Рік тому +1

    No doubt Hanson is a descent guy, nevertheless his conservatism is as tedious as every other form of conservatism.

  • @dannysullivan3951
    @dannysullivan3951 Рік тому

    Weak right wing pundit. Who’s failing on deterrence right now? G.O.P. presidential candidates Trump and DeSantis.

  • @palois2022
    @palois2022 5 років тому

    I dislike his commentary on POTUS's ability to "connect" with the average man. It's called charisma and con artistry. Trump wasnt a Republican, he was a Democrat. Trump appeals to the average man bc he speaks like a mobster from a movie which are very popular amongst these males. Stop acting as if dishonesty is fascinating. Jeez! It's called being duped. Obama won by bigger margins so plzzzz stop blowing smoke. All of these easy points. Deception from a liar cheater and a thief shouldn't be celebrated. Goodness!

  • @Odysseus88
    @Odysseus88 2 місяці тому +1

    Have no fear ladies and gentlemen, the 60 million migrants will save us 2024-25!

  • @JohnDoe-fu3lw
    @JohnDoe-fu3lw Рік тому +1

    At 4:08 Mr Hanson I feel is well aware of the true catalyst that caused Germany to go into czechoslovakia. Chamberlain did the right thing.

  • @6663000
    @6663000 3 роки тому +4

    Brilliant