Steamboat Institute
Steamboat Institute
  • 475
  • 4 072 994
Should the U.S. Reinstate a Draft for Mandatory Military Service?
Watch General Stan McChrystal, former Commander of U.S. and International Forces in Afghanistan, and William Ruger, former U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan and recipient of the Defense Meritorious Service Medal, debate this topic. Moderated by Tony Blankley Fellow Brad Polumbo.
00:00 - 6:52 - opening remarks from New Collage and The Steamboat Institute.
6:52 - 10:44 - Pre-debate poll
10:44 - 21:00 - Opening remarks by General Stan McChrystal
21:00 - 29:00 - Opening remarks by William Ruger
29:00 - 32:00 - Can mandatory military service be moral?
32:00 - 36:00 - The cost of mandatory military service
36:00 - 38:00 - If it was necessary, would it be considered more moral?
38:00 - 42:00 - Does an undedicated society deserve to be defended?
42:00 - 46:50 - Has the 21st Century made conscription something of the past?
46:50 - 51:00 - Would a mandatory military draft bring a national sense of unity?
51:00 - 55:00 - What is the strongest argument of the opposing side?
55:00 - 58:00 - Are there ways to avoid the system for certain groups of people?
58:00 - 1:01:00 - Would people gaming the system cause societal problems?
1:01:00 - 1:08:20 - Are there other things we could do to improve recruitment?
1:08:20 - 1:12:20 - Are there benefits to expanding the draft?
1:12:20 - 1:14:00 - Does the history of the military show a volunteer army is beneficial?
1:14:00 - 1:18:00 - Does the broader public understand modern conflicts?
1:18:00 - 1:20:40 - Are there existential threats that make mandatory military service needed?
1:20:40 - 1:24:00 - Closing remarks
1:24:00 - 1:26:45 - Post-debate poll and closing credits.
Переглядів: 109

Відео

Does the U.S. Need More Democracy?
Переглядів 73День тому
Watch Hélène Landemore, Ph.D., Professor of Political Science at Yale University, and Jason Brennan, Ph.D., Professor of Public Policy at Georgetown University debate the concept of democracy in the US at our Campus Liberty Tour debate. Moderated by Hadley Heath Manning. 00:00 - 03:20 - Introduction/opening remarks 3:20 - 9:00 - Introduction of debate by Hadley Heath Manning and pre-debate poll...
Will Taxing Unrealized Capital Gains Create a Fairer Economy?
Переглядів 18028 днів тому
Will Taxing Unrealized Capital Gains Create a Fairer Economy?
Does Harvard Support Free Speech and Intellectual Diversity?
Переглядів 928Місяць тому
Does Harvard Support Free Speech and Intellectual Diversity?
Are Electric Vehicles Good For the Planet?
Переглядів 2,6 тис.Місяць тому
Are Electric Vehicles Good For the Planet?
Do open borders benefit humanity by reducing poverty and boosting the economy?
Переглядів 765Місяць тому
Do open borders benefit humanity by reducing poverty and boosting the economy?
Exclusive interview with John Bolton!
Переглядів 153Місяць тому
Exclusive interview with John Bolton!
Exclusive interview with Vivek Ramaswamy!
Переглядів 231Місяць тому
Exclusive interview with Vivek Ramaswamy!
Should the US Use its Diplomatic and Military Power Around the Globe to Ensure America’s Security?
Переглядів 2,8 тис.Місяць тому
Should the US Use its Diplomatic and Military Power Around the Globe to Ensure America’s Security?
Harris's Plans for Your HealthCare!
Переглядів 1382 місяці тому
Harris's Plans for Your HealthCare!
The True Cost of Raising a Child
Переглядів 1112 місяці тому
The True Cost of Raising a Child
Thank you Donors!
Переглядів 662 місяці тому
Thank you Donors!
Dr. Patrick Moore - Carbon and Climate Catastrophe
Переглядів 81 тис.2 місяці тому
Dr. Patrick Moore - Carbon and Climate Catastrophe
Steven E. Koonin, Ph.D.-- What Climate Science Tells Us, What it Doesn't and Why it Matters.
Переглядів 6 тис.2 місяці тому
Steven E. Koonin, Ph.D. What Climate Science Tells Us, What it Doesn't and Why it Matters.
Bjorn Lomborg-- The Cost of Climate Alarmism
Переглядів 3,1 тис.2 місяці тому
Bjorn Lomborg The Cost of Climate Alarmism
Jonathan Turley
Переглядів 2472 місяці тому
Jonathan Turley
Sage Steele
Переглядів 2542 місяці тому
Sage Steele
Michelle Bekkering
Переглядів 612 місяці тому
Michelle Bekkering
Carter Mateer, ELC Roundtables
Переглядів 302 місяці тому
Carter Mateer, ELC Roundtables
Carol Swain, Ph.D.
Переглядів 762 місяці тому
Carol Swain, Ph.D.
Michael Oren
Переглядів 9812 місяці тому
Michael Oren
Catherine Herridge
Переглядів 2402 місяці тому
Catherine Herridge
Courage in Education
Переглядів 262 місяці тому
Courage in Education
The Future of Media/Predicting the 2024 Election Outcomes
Переглядів 742 місяці тому
The Future of Media/Predicting the 2024 Election Outcomes
Elya Baskin
Переглядів 1942 місяці тому
Elya Baskin
Protecting Women’s Rights in Sports and Society
Переглядів 1972 місяці тому
Protecting Women’s Rights in Sports and Society
Kyle Mann
Переглядів 802 місяці тому
Kyle Mann
“Stories from the States on Preventing Energy Policy Disasters”
Переглядів 1082 місяці тому
“Stories from the States on Preventing Energy Policy Disasters”
Daniel J Mitchell
Переглядів 752 місяці тому
Daniel J Mitchell
Presenting the 2024 Tony Blankley Fellow!
Переглядів 562 місяці тому
Presenting the 2024 Tony Blankley Fellow!

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @leemanwilliams4405
    @leemanwilliams4405 9 хвилин тому

    Not anymore!!!!!!

  • @robertwzell4078
    @robertwzell4078 18 хвилин тому

    And in top of all that, now Commiefornia wants to put a special tax on EV drivers!!! Im not totally sure about the details, but i think it's by the mile. Makes no sense.

  • @MarlandaLynae778
    @MarlandaLynae778 Годину тому

    Exactly! So many things they omit and will flat out lie about.

  • @jefferybuckner7998
    @jefferybuckner7998 Годину тому

    You can thank a Democrat for all this stupid shit.

  • @matt6250
    @matt6250 Годину тому

    Petro dollar. We had to make nothing and import nothing for them to keep up their money printing scam. It’s over.

  • @JanStefanSchrøderJørgensen
    @JanStefanSchrøderJørgensen 3 години тому

    Bolton is a War Criminal, and a ennemy of the humanity.

  • @georgemartigani2214
    @georgemartigani2214 4 години тому

    Like Trump's college,fake charities,gold shoes,gold watches gotta love Fox News

  • @TraciWatson-x6c
    @TraciWatson-x6c 4 години тому

    DEI destroyed several companies and if left alone they would take us all down with them. I believe its purpose is simply, get people into areas in a company that they literally don’t know anything about, then they are just used as a fall guy so to speak. This only allows the opportunity for people/ companies to break laws. It does sound crazy but let’s look at who we’re dealing with 😮.

  • @Michelle-kj7wv
    @Michelle-kj7wv 4 години тому

    Another billion dollar hoax😂

  • @GreggGiblin-sy5og
    @GreggGiblin-sy5og 5 годин тому

    Wait.. what? Fossil fuels from the grid? Explain. What this guy said makes zero sense.

  • @harlemchef120
    @harlemchef120 6 годин тому

    I have been aware of this issue since the announcement of the increased number of electric vehicles on the roadways. It is important to note that these vehicles still rely on fossil fuels, as they require electricity generated from fossil fuel sources to charge their batteries.😮😅😊

  • @ken.matinale
    @ken.matinale 9 годин тому

    Uh, what happened to the electricity created from the sun during the day? It's either still there after sundown or it was used during daylight to reduce the need for fossil fuel. What the heck?

  • @colinstewart1432
    @colinstewart1432 12 годин тому

    Everything woke turns to shit.

  • @mrpointy123
    @mrpointy123 14 годин тому

    86 BILLION?!?! PMSL! She really is a batshit dumb as she actually looks!! She got that job on her knees, end of.

  • @garyhall8308
    @garyhall8308 15 годин тому

    Needless to say the pollution when EVs catch on fire that can't be put out

  • @JeremyHubbardTX
    @JeremyHubbardTX 16 годин тому

    Leftards!!

  • @DoraReynolds-p9o
    @DoraReynolds-p9o 16 годин тому

    Someone did there homework good for you now keep spreading the facts out there the green energy is bunk it’s a power play to control

  • @danmeadows3859
    @danmeadows3859 17 годин тому

    THAT MAKES PERFECT SENSE. To a Liberal 🤪

  • @Sean-e4q
    @Sean-e4q 19 годин тому

    Ohh Snap 🫰🏼😮😂

  • @RustymaeBlassman
    @RustymaeBlassman 20 годин тому

    It's not they (californians). it's Newsum.

  • @sheepdog1102
    @sheepdog1102 20 годин тому

    California is run by idiots and those idiots are elected by idiots!

  • @talk2kev
    @talk2kev 21 годину тому

    DEI Didn't Earn It, needs to be over it is a waste of money in a nation that has no money. The most qualified person regardless of any matrix needs to be employed. If you are hiring someone just to check a box we all lose. But capital hill has been operating like this way too long, it's time to get back on track. Otherwise we are dragging dead weight.

  • @bonnizan1
    @bonnizan1 21 годину тому

    So they are effectively making thrmselves & their future children poor

  • @alisonknox1747
    @alisonknox1747 21 годину тому

    I have always questioned if everyone in the UK had an electric car where the f£%k are they getting the electricity from 😅 i will not drive an electric car ever...absolute nonsense 😂😂😂

  • @charleshare6840
    @charleshare6840 22 години тому

    Get rid of DEI NOW!!!

  • @normsky5504
    @normsky5504 22 години тому

    CO2 is not very important regarding climate. However it is very important for plants

  • @normsky5504
    @normsky5504 22 години тому

    Plastic is not toxic, we wrap our food in it.

  • @robertaelkins6937
    @robertaelkins6937 22 години тому

    Thats why gas cost $4.50+ a gallon here in Southern California

  • @normsky5504
    @normsky5504 23 години тому

    Britain is completely crazy for refusing to adopt the nuclear power option.

  • @DickDebonaire
    @DickDebonaire 23 години тому

    Sounds like another case of California "Dreaming"

  • @steves2445
    @steves2445 День тому

    Send me a million dollars to prevent my whiite rage

  • @williamadams1235
    @williamadams1235 День тому

    I want the best of the best and I do not care what that color is.

  • @RobertPierce-ix5mn
    @RobertPierce-ix5mn День тому

    Didn't earn it. That's what it means does the American people

  • @patrickguerra4053
    @patrickguerra4053 День тому

    Corruption

  • @ThomasRogan-gc5pi
    @ThomasRogan-gc5pi День тому

    Makes perfect sense! Well if you're Gavin Newsom 😢

  • @applicanttangoblues4636
    @applicanttangoblues4636 День тому

    Hypocrisy!!!!!

  • @ericadler9680
    @ericadler9680 День тому

    Then what about the German automobile industry, which is being outflanked by the Chinese? International free trade without protection of your own country's industry is lethal.

  • @winfriedkloeser3244
    @winfriedkloeser3244 День тому

    There is no racism in the military. There is no black and white just green.

  • @robertaaugustini4091
    @robertaaugustini4091 День тому

    Listening to this podcast in 2024. Trump is going to be president in january 25we have dpoken. Too bad The outgoing president J. BIDEN is getting us into a dogfight with Russia they never learn and the world pays the price

  • @andreelove9635
    @andreelove9635 День тому

    It's about to stop, all these jobs 😒

  • @iroquois7550
    @iroquois7550 День тому

    I've served before, but I won't again as long as Donald Trump is Commander-in-Chief.

  • @Pam-u9g
    @Pam-u9g День тому

    This guy is a liar. He is full of it. He is an example of how dumb the younger people are and how corrupt their thinking is.

  • @juliezug9855
    @juliezug9855 День тому

    Environmental standards seem designed not to benefit the home state but the foreign states from which they must now import. Keep payin’ yer taxes…

  • @MILC0M
    @MILC0M День тому

    OH my F... here is the Biast You Tube warning under the title of this video again !!!! Hope Elon Musk buys You Tube out and fire all the staff.

  • @chooselove2553
    @chooselove2553 День тому

    😂😂 of course. Why am I not surprised?

  • @AntonGrusovnik
    @AntonGrusovnik День тому

    Simply stupid huh??? Libs never think things through.

  • @jimwilder5578
    @jimwilder5578 День тому

    Clean house To where we can hold the 1 person accountable for their crimes and their bad decisions... Nobody's over held accountable in Washington..

  • @jimwilder5578
    @jimwilder5578 День тому

    You mean there's stealing 86 billion dollars of taxpayers money and doing an absolutely nothing for it except getting richer.. Off the Americans backs😡😡😡🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • @howardtidwell
    @howardtidwell День тому

    He is a pig

  • @leomengel4776
    @leomengel4776 День тому

    Iran and Venezuela??? Two countries we should never buy from!! What happened to Canada and Mexico?? They should only buy from our neighbors! California is totally screwed up!!