Alternate History of TURKEY if the OTTOMANS Didnt Join WW1 (1914-2023)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 151

  • @lionheartmapping
    @lionheartmapping  Рік тому +19

    Our discord server: discord.gg/DaZNbttZhC
    What should be the next country?

    • @NicolausCopernicus-vs1cw
      @NicolausCopernicus-vs1cw Рік тому +3

      What if hungary got independence from Austria in 1848?

    • @ThatEzekielGuy
      @ThatEzekielGuy Рік тому +1

      Alternate History of The United Kingdom if they Kept Hanover?

    • @kirbydaclan4285
      @kirbydaclan4285 Рік тому

      Sweden

    • @SquarePancakes
      @SquarePancakes Рік тому

      What if the Ching Dynasty traded with Europe? (The other lead to the opium wars)

    • @Gert09
      @Gert09 Рік тому

      Alternate History Of Netherlands
      But The Batavian Republic still exists?

  • @realbaron5714
    @realbaron5714 Рік тому +181

    Best timeline in some case: No partition of Middle East, No Arab-Israeli wars, No extremists groups, No 9/11, No war of Terror. But bad for Armenia their country dissapeared.

    • @JustCallMeMA
      @JustCallMeMA Рік тому

      9/11 is nothing compared to what your "peace-keeping" forces did to civilians in the middle-east, so the arabs sees it as a wonderful retaliation from an opressed civiliazation.
      Despite everyone knowing that 9/11 was done by the US as a justification for declaring war.
      And the terror position is already occupied by savages who exterminated entire continents (North and south America) and enslaved entire other continents, A.k.a It's obvious who the terrrorists are.

    • @TVmantitan779
      @TVmantitan779 Рік тому +55

      Actually, there is no Armenian genocide since the Ottomans aren't in WW1.

    • @amongdrip8073
      @amongdrip8073 Рік тому +1

      Wasn't there a Zionist Terrorist Group operating in Ottoman Palestine?

    • @noone33736
      @noone33736 Рік тому +4

      If 9/11 happens in other realities that happens here too

    • @andorraball1253
      @andorraball1253 Рік тому

      the genocide happened since the ottomans thought the armenians would help russia

  • @mohad2760
    @mohad2760 11 місяців тому +23

    If the ottomans had an industrial revolution and political development maybe they would’ve had a chance and survived the war

  • @James-cq2bj
    @James-cq2bj Рік тому +46

    I like that you are now showing internal conflicts inside of the topic country instead of giving them plot armor

  • @NicolausCopernicus-vs1cw
    @NicolausCopernicus-vs1cw Рік тому +65

    2:50 typical americans taking the oil

    • @Arpads_Legacy
      @Arpads_Legacy Рік тому +12

      "Peacekeeping forces"

    • @xeno9889
      @xeno9889 Рік тому +3

      bruh arpad didnt think id see you here

  • @paulinalevina9690
    @paulinalevina9690 8 місяців тому +47

    US peacekeeping forces: ❌
    US oilsearching forces: ✅

    • @CCozyt
      @CCozyt 6 місяців тому +3

      Boring and overused joke, if they were oilsearching they’d annex the land.

    • @cenk.3467
      @cenk.3467 5 місяців тому +7

      @@CCozyt Look at the map at the end of the video, they created an "ally" in the region.

    • @epic_guy01
      @epic_guy01 4 місяці тому +3

      ⁠@@CCozythow can you deny such a fact

    • @PrussianWander
      @PrussianWander 4 місяці тому +2

      The reality 😂

  • @Scenariania
    @Scenariania Рік тому +34

    when you thought everything was going fine for "the sick man of europe.... _sudden civil war_
    but yea, i liked how the ottomans eventually adopt liberal policies and exponential growth throughout the 20th century. in a way, they fill the spot of saddam. gg dude, this was great

  • @ayyybob
    @ayyybob 3 місяці тому +4

    If the Ottomans stayed neutral Britain would have given them kuwait as there were plans to sell it before the war

  • @ahmedas424
    @ahmedas424 Рік тому +7

    If the Ottomans didn't join, they would have fallen to revolutions first by Iraqis in Najaf, Basra and Baghdad later Syrian Peasants in the Syrian plains and Lebanon finally the Hashmites in Hejaz
    Luristan place was wrong because that is Ahwaz and Jordan wouldn't exist it will probably be Syrian or Palestinian

  • @MohammedYounis5491
    @MohammedYounis5491 12 днів тому +1

    Great video love the lore

  • @wilhelmgundersen5542
    @wilhelmgundersen5542 Рік тому +7

    Great video love the lore

  • @thegreatestoctopus9739
    @thegreatestoctopus9739 Рік тому +13

    I don't get why the ottomans would have to fall into a Civil War this late or why they wouldn't win it, given that they woykd be supported by the west, but still the video was great and its a better ending for turkey that OTL

    • @histo6651
      @histo6651 Рік тому

      cuz they prob wouldnt be supported by the west? wdym man? every other country wanted the ottomans to fail so they could get their lands. did u ever look at how the empire was planned to be shared? a slice of istanbul and anadolu thats it. and the ww2 times are over now. no human can put an entire race beneath them via force. u need political power or the races need to have a history together. example
      georgians osetians
      turks kurds
      austrians germans
      japanese koreans
      azeris turks
      british scotish
      russian ukranian
      they are the brother races. they have similar past similar blood thats why the stick together.
      a race union is possible like in the end the turkish federation. but a muslim union is impossible.

    • @georgios_5342
      @georgios_5342 5 місяців тому +1

      The west would simply care for itself and take all the oil lmao

  • @greekrevoltontheway
    @greekrevoltontheway Рік тому +4

    Nice vid bro

  • @startitaliano3366
    @startitaliano3366 Рік тому +53

    What If qing dinastia survived?

    • @althereq3656
      @althereq3656 Рік тому +3

      In inglese si scrive dinasty

    • @Myprobable952
      @Myprobable952 Рік тому +2

      *Dynasty*

    • @no1dea261
      @no1dea261 9 місяців тому

      ​@@Myprobable952Not everyone speaks English fluently, dinastia is a word of dynasty, if someone simply dosen't know how to spell a word in English you don't have to be a asshole about it

    • @maximsmolin-uc8pw
      @maximsmolin-uc8pw 4 місяці тому

      ​@@althereq3656А по русски пишется династия

  • @Newstrategies2191
    @Newstrategies2191 5 місяців тому +2

    3:32 wtf he wants to split country

  • @junmisugi545
    @junmisugi545 Рік тому +9

    What if Venice discovered America instead Spain?

    • @kadircanyldran1849
      @kadircanyldran1849 Рік тому +1

      there is no discovery there was already people what did u find empty place? wtf

    • @junmisugi545
      @junmisugi545 Рік тому +2

      @@kadircanyldran1849 discover isnt go first, is show something unkwon to certain people, that's the logic

    • @kadircanyldran1849
      @kadircanyldran1849 Рік тому

      @@junmisugi545 so u couldnt discover anything to natives and vikings.. its all about your mine unknowladge brains..People shouldnt destroy and fuck what they discover right?

  • @Simon_SM
    @Simon_SM Рік тому +11

    Could you do a Serbian one, Hungarian, Greek, and possibly if Assyria became a thing after ww1 (choose the borders either from irl proposals or your own one)

    • @Mraggourakigames
      @Mraggourakigames Рік тому +1

      He has made one for Greece Serbia would be great to see

  • @ayyybob
    @ayyybob 4 місяці тому +1

    In this timeline there would be multiple videos called something like: "how the ottomans disrespected their arab population" or "how america snuffed the oil out of arabia" you know those types lol

  • @dragonking4999
    @dragonking4999 Рік тому +3

    Actually, I think that if the ottomans hadn’t joined ww1 Russia wouldn’t have its civil war due to the straights being open and allied shipment being able to send guns and other weapons to bog down Germany

    • @kamalamy
      @kamalamy 7 місяців тому

      No saying the Ottomans continue to keep the straits open unfortunately, unpredictable factor considering the many factions of the Ottomans were pro-Central Powers

    • @Juan-qu4oj
      @Juan-qu4oj 5 місяців тому

      The Ottomans would never allow shipments to Russia

  • @mohammadashfaquealam6157
    @mohammadashfaquealam6157 Рік тому +4

    What if Mughal Empire survive

  • @عمارالصافي-ج6م
    @عمارالصافي-ج6م Рік тому +3

    The Iraq movie is like an Italian flag

  • @dedjustded9527
    @dedjustded9527 Рік тому +1

    mighty interesting scenario but how do the arabs get the manpower, weapons and expertise to launch their own independent nations without being quickly snuf out by the ottomans?

  • @gssalternatehistory
    @gssalternatehistory Рік тому +1

    cool video

  • @andrewmathewson341
    @andrewmathewson341 Рік тому

    Always love a good LionHeart video!

  • @bneyigido
    @bneyigido Рік тому +7

    Yes thanks for this video greetings from Turkiye!!! ❤️

  • @Smelliot2214
    @Smelliot2214 8 місяців тому +2

    Hejaz instead of saudi arabia is cursed 💀

  • @Minato_Akiyama03
    @Minato_Akiyama03 12 днів тому

    What if German Reich never invaded Soviet Union but allowed alliance just for WW2 until Cold War arrived between USA, Germany and Soviet Union?

  • @ilipopilipop6491
    @ilipopilipop6491 Рік тому +8

    Very unrealistic as The Ottoman Empire would probably go to absolute monarchy or the Rashidun system of the best islamic scholars voting for the most competent leader and would probably become more islamistic, the only reason turkey today is largely secularised is because of Ataturk but he never gained power here.

    • @crpse-qf6rh
      @crpse-qf6rh Рік тому +2

      i disagree.
      what ever path the Ottomans would take they would still try to reform and revolutionize their judicial and political systems.
      we were trying that sinds 1839 but sadly Abdulhamid II revoked and turned the reforms back which ended in his own demise.
      Atatürk yes played a massive role in secularisation but you’re forgetting that Atatürk was not the only one with these ideals like shown in the video Ismet Inönü was also a huge forestander of Secularisation as it offers a more equal law amongst each religious group

    • @gb4206
      @gb4206 Рік тому

      @c2rpse.198
      Passing reforms is fine until you try to take away key religious freedoms like atatürk did with his copy-pasted concept of laicité. Banning scarfed women from schools and politics is a good way to get the more religious folk to revolt against you. This applies especially in the Ottoman empire. If the Ottomans decide to ditch the caliph, ban headscarves, close mosques and arrest imams under the guise of "secularism" (more like, laicité), they will never EVER keep the empire united.
      The ottoman empire needed military, bureaucratic and educational reforms yes. They also needed to industrialize. What they didn't need was to crack down on religion and force everyone to wear western attire.

    • @histo6651
      @histo6651 Рік тому

      ye deffff bro every middle eastern country going absolute or extreme. the turan/turk nationalism idea existed for very long and with the loss in the russian war it was gone. if the russian war was a victory(like here) the nationalism and turan would remain, which in the end would mean we would go the path we took irl, we would try reforms with the turan ideas which prob angered the arabs and when the revolt happened and they won it the turks would unite and make it come true. And how do you know atatürk didnt gain power? he was the MAIN turk nationalist. his ideas would be shining bright with the victory. the new turkey would be based on his ideas. so basically
      russian war won = turkish nationalism
      turkish nationalism = arab revolt
      arab revolt = oppurtunity to get rid of the old ottoman system and create a turkey based on turan.
      getting rid of the ottoman system = no ottoman nationalism, no extremist beliefs, fair justice system, reformed laws.
      so basically the same thing but this turkey wouldnt go back to the ottoman times like irl

  • @tavi_knight
    @tavi_knight 11 місяців тому

    Some notes-
    Population of the Confederation: 142,000,000 [10th]
    GDP: 4,402,000,000,000$ [4th]
    GDP per Capita: 31,000$ [37th]

    • @gengarzilla1685
      @gengarzilla1685 8 місяців тому +1

      Assuming the civil war somehow didn't gut their pre-war population and economic power.

  • @L4B055
    @L4B055 Рік тому

    what editing software do you use? since the animation is really smooth

  • @obi-wankenobi1149
    @obi-wankenobi1149 Рік тому +2

    Brooo how did Selahattin Demirtaş become president?

  • @han_edits142
    @han_edits142 6 місяців тому

    Turkish flag shall never change, because the Turkish flag carries the symbol of independence and Turkishness

  • @Face-mo4lz
    @Face-mo4lz 9 місяців тому

    if the Ottomans had not gotten involved in the First World War, the Ottoman Empire could have survived and become one of the richest states thanks to oil

  • @nikitamoshnyagul5248
    @nikitamoshnyagul5248 Рік тому +1

    Ottomans could have captured Crimea in 1918

  • @RedozuIsChilling
    @RedozuIsChilling Рік тому +2

    1:21 Best part

  • @Abdullah_0083
    @Abdullah_0083 3 місяці тому

    the good ending we never got...

  • @Otaibi_ball
    @Otaibi_ball 6 місяців тому +1

    Although this history is illogical, it is good

  • @sofeaail
    @sofeaail 20 днів тому

    Bro you Have many mistakes
    1st) The Ottomans won't and will never be that secular and US pupets like the arabs.
    2nd) If the caliphate survived, Islamism will be peaceful movement since the absence of extremism(that Allah damned Iranian part).
    3rd) The empire will directly change to republic instead of formation of Turkey since there isn't Kemalism.
    4th) If they didn't join the ww1, this means the young turks simply never exist and Abdulhamid and his guys had already reached the secret of European renaissance. Which means ;
    a, Ottomans will truly modernize.
    b, The empire wont lose its european lands.
    c, The empire will acknowledge that it will share it's caliphate with other muslim states and the caliphate will be kind of confederation despite the Ottomans still have the sovreignty over the caliphate.
    d, aNOtHEr ISlaMiC GolDeN AgE!!!!!!!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
    5th) Many letter errors bro.

  • @Estel_98
    @Estel_98 Рік тому +1

    Selahattin Demirtaş as a prime minister ??????????????????

  • @Volva-f8h
    @Volva-f8h 6 місяців тому

    Well, there are a lot of unrealistic things, but that's okay

  • @Demon-Dasher
    @Demon-Dasher 4 місяці тому

    Great scenario!

  • @f.s.1429
    @f.s.1429 5 місяців тому

    Why should the Sultan appoint someone as Primeminister who wanted to abolish Islam? Also, if WW1 didn't took place, then Ismet Inönü was just an officer like many others. He became prominent during the greek war and only because he was Kamal's close friend.
    The crumble began at 1909 with deposing of the last true caliph Abdul Hamid II. The sultans no longer had power. The Ottoman empire was ruled by masonic CUP.

  • @yusuftale
    @yusuftale 5 місяців тому +1

    İttihat ve Terakki olmasaydı osmanlı

  • @ThatOneCatto
    @ThatOneCatto Рік тому +4

    Very interesting concept, though I struggle to believe a few things:
    1. The Ottomans would likely not be successful in their invasion of White Russia- Denikin's southern offensive would've leapt into action at that time, and considering the mild success that the Moscow had over the Soviets, the ottomans would stand little to no chance at an offensive over the Caucasus.
    2. The Zionist movement, however weakened by the lack of government support, would still expand. Under the Ottomans, the Zionist movement has risen as the primary Jewish movement, outshining Bundism. It would grow exponentially, especially after World War 2. The region would however, likely still remain under a Muslim majority, though a significant Jewish minority. A flipped version of the current situation, if you will.
    3. Decolonialization. With few exceptions, it is likely that without any "Iron Fisting", the ottomans would be forced to give up _some_ authority to their minorities during the cold war. Autonomy to some, independence to others, you get the jist.
    This is _not_ a criticism, just a few points for thought. I like this video nonetheless. I especially compliment your animation, which is phenomenal.

    • @gb4206
      @gb4206 Рік тому +5

      Then why did Denmin's southern offensive not stop the Ottomans in our original timeline? I struggle to see how a battered white army (due to fighting a world war for 5 years) can stand up to a fresh and numerically advanced Ottoman army. Especially when the Ottomans do not have to worry about any other fronts, unlike the whites, who were being attacked from all sides.
      If you look at the latest Ottoman census on Palestine, it becomes evident that jews were overwhelmingly outnumbered by Arabs. Contrary to popular belief, jewish mass-migration did not start during Ottoman era. It started after. Very few jews actually migrated to Palestine before the Ottoman collapse, and this is evidenced by the census. Now, coming back to this alt history scenario, it seems unlikely that the Ottomans would accept mass jewish migration towards Palestine. Why would they? They had refused jewish requests to annex Palestine before, and Palestine was considered an important place for the muslims of the empire. It's doubtful the Ottomans would have allowed a significant ethnic change in favor of the jews. The jews would have to settle somewhere else, probably Kenya or Madagascar or the Jewish Oblast.
      For your last point, iron fisting would definitely happen. The Ottomans would pursue a policy of trying to unite the empire through democratic/islamist means, while also cracking down on any nationalist sentiment. This is what the current Turkey is doing to Kurds. Kurds are allowed to vote, allowed to become governors, mayors, MPs etc, but if any of them start supporting separatist movements, they will be iron fisted. Theres nothing contradictory about that, and if the ottomans wish to survive it is what they have to do.

  • @немецкийаоцкер

    very beautifully done . and by the way , where do you get these maps from Google ?

  • @hadesentertainment5704
    @hadesentertainment5704 Рік тому +1

    Was it really the good ending though?

    • @jacktophono1
      @jacktophono1 Рік тому

      Yes

    • @gb4206
      @gb4206 Рік тому

      Absolutely. No israel is already a massive plus. Same with the lack of extremist iranian government.

    • @histo6651
      @histo6651 Рік тому +1

      just becouse turks got rightful lands doesnt mean its bad. the ottomans didnt die as a sick man they died while with his family. armenians and turks have a lot of history together kurds and azeris too. thats why the union exists and the arab countries never went extreme. the only reason they ever turned out extreme was becouse they rejected the ottoman rule and with no ottoman support they were colonised and they went extreme. this is a balanced world where instead of the ottomans getting murdered they fulfilled their time and passed away and got replaced with nationalism. never try to murder a country it leads to decades of problems. every country must die and be replaced by its own.

  • @chasepup8591
    @chasepup8591 Рік тому

    Do a remastered alternate history of the us

  • @grimlemngr2605
    @grimlemngr2605 Рік тому

    Nice video, shame there wasn't an ethnic map in the end

  • @shirkam3657
    @shirkam3657 Рік тому

    3:11 ZAZA??????????????

  • @tasiepolegaming100yearsago3
    @tasiepolegaming100yearsago3 Рік тому +1

    Great ending

  • @rokball4892
    @rokball4892 Рік тому +2

    Please do Korean Empire too. 😊

  • @LoveSkating0
    @LoveSkating0 5 місяців тому

    3:33 Selahattin Demirtaş ☠️☠️

  • @georgios_5342
    @georgios_5342 Рік тому +4

    When did the genocides happen in this timeline? The young Turks?

    • @Goofyahhgamer.
      @Goofyahhgamer. Рік тому

      There are no genocides dumb bitch

    • @titanicbigship
      @titanicbigship Рік тому

      @@Goofyahhgamer. there would be no genocide because they couldn't blame it on the Russian

    • @ars8223
      @ars8223 Рік тому +2

      It wouldnt make sense to genocide happen, as ottomans didnt entered w1

    • @yazovgaming
      @yazovgaming Рік тому +1

      @@ars8223 No it can still happen, mainly on the idea of ''Turkish Monoethnic state'' which they had. Still i have no proof to back these claims because there was no ethnic map at the end of the video.

  • @DBall-h2k
    @DBall-h2k Рік тому

    ottoman has sadam fusain as
    general

  • @the.turkic-hunter
    @the.turkic-hunter Рік тому

    So What Happened To Atatürk In This Alternative Universe?

    • @TURKMUSCLE
      @TURKMUSCLE Рік тому

      THE EVIL SULTANATE EXECUTES HIM AFTER FINDING OUT ABOUT HIS GOALS TO MAKE TURKEY A NON DICTATORSHIP SECULAR STATE😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲☪☪☪☪☪☪☪

    • @Goofyahhgamer.
      @Goofyahhgamer. Рік тому

      Probably remained his position being a commander or some type of goverment worker like who looks over what happens inside the country or outside
      However he wouldnt be famous a lot i think cuz he was recognized in ww1 and war of independence so yeah

    • @histo6651
      @histo6651 Рік тому

      still tho in the end ottomans died and turkish nationalism took over which prob atatürk was very important for the new rule

    • @bakrdemir8656
      @bakrdemir8656 Рік тому

      he would make movies in hollowytd

  • @georgios_5342
    @georgios_5342 5 місяців тому

    Great ending!

  • @startitaliano3366
    @startitaliano3366 Рік тому

    Pera aí o iraq é a bandeira da Itália invertida?

  • @MohamedMahdi-xf4vx
    @MohamedMahdi-xf4vx 5 місяців тому

    What th name müzik

  • @agermanmappertyna479
    @agermanmappertyna479 Рік тому

    great video and next nation russia

  • @TheRandomicGuy41
    @TheRandomicGuy41 8 місяців тому

    Cool

  • @GhostRider-iq8zp
    @GhostRider-iq8zp 3 місяці тому

    Ottoman empire come back

  • @Ayakyalamasampiyonu
    @Ayakyalamasampiyonu Рік тому

    I did that video 1 day before you in my channel :D

  • @hishamalaker491
    @hishamalaker491 Рік тому

    I am Palestinian-Syrian Arab and i dont know how i feel about this, I mean its not good but its much better than our world since no I*rael, Syria is more stable i guess and there is less war so one one hand its better for the levant and Iraq but on the other hand gulf states would never be rich because of constant war so we would never have Cities like Dubai, Abudhabi, Doha and Saudi in this timeline or I guess ''Hejaz'' would be a poor unstable country unlike in this time line with the Saudi Arabia who are rich, stable and also in this timeline its easier for Muslims to do Hajj since Mecca is in safe hands under the Saudis (Like them or not they did a great job in perserving the holy cities of Mecca and Medina) while in this timeline it would be much harder to go to either mecca or Medina plus these cities would be in a poor backwater country so I really dont know how to feel about this, I guess its slightly better but not great.

  • @safiuddinhanafy2014
    @safiuddinhanafy2014 Рік тому

    Hey,at least no Israel!

  • @ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273
    @ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273 Рік тому +1

    Return the Ottoman glory
    🇲🇷❤️🇹🇷☝️😭

  • @vincentbj84
    @vincentbj84 Рік тому

    Great war slide

  • @Korankrem_1
    @Korankrem_1 5 місяців тому

    العثمانين 😂😂😂

  • @Квасян-п19
    @Квасян-п19 5 місяців тому

    Kurdistan?

  • @Goofyahhgamer.
    @Goofyahhgamer. Рік тому

    I wish you would give the north of syria to turkiye back :(

    • @hishamalaker491
      @hishamalaker491 Рік тому

      Well no because Aleppo is an Arab city not Turkish also the Areas around it is Arab not Turkish there are even more Kurds in the Area than Turks so no, ''Turkiye'' absolutely shouldn't have northern Syria since its majority Arab and part Kurdish not Turkish even the few Turkmen have little to no relation to the Turks in ''Turkiye'

    • @Goofyahhgamer.
      @Goofyahhgamer. Рік тому

      @@hishamalaker491ever heard of misali milli?
      It was proposed during independence wars
      Aiming to claim all turkish areas that included aleppo and mosul

    • @AyushRaj-cb6ny
      @AyushRaj-cb6ny 5 місяців тому

      @@hishamalaker491 If you are talking about modern day, yes there aren't many Turks in Northern Syria anymore. But in ottoman times the area was much more Turkish. I'm not saying that they were a majority but they made at least 30 percent of the population

  • @randomperson3500
    @randomperson3500 Рік тому

    First

  • @SultanVMehmed
    @SultanVMehmed 5 місяців тому +1

    BEN ORDA SELİHATİN DEMİRTAŞMI GÖRDÜM

  • @Geniussco
    @Geniussco Рік тому

    The best mapper