Were GM Syed, Bacha Khan Traitors? | Dr Mubarak Ali
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 вер 2024
- #NayaDaur #bachakhan #GMSyed #mubarakali #history #pakistan
Pakistan's history has always been seen through the Muslim League's lens. Historian Dr Mubarak Ali says that most of Muslim League leaders had migrated from India and didn't have their roots in the masses and, therefore, they'd accuse anyone who they considered as threat of treason. Two of these 'traitors' are Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's Khana Abdul Ghaffar Khan aka Bacha Khan and Sindh's GM Syed.
In this interview with Zafar Khizer, Dr Mubarak Ali is explaining the politics of these two nationalist politicians and why they were accused of being traitors
-----------------------------------------------
nayadaur.tv/do...
Listen On Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Subscribe our channel: / nayadaurpk
Follow Naya Daur Media on Facebook: / nayadaurpk
Follow Naya Daur Urdu on Facebook: / nayadaururdu
Follow Naya Daur Media on Twitter: / nayadaurpk
Follow Naya Daur Urdu on Twitter: / nayadaurpk_urdu
Follow Naya Daur Media on Instagram: / nayadaurpk
Visit www.thefridaytimes.com
Bacha khan was an icon who not only won vote of right for all in general and pakhtuns in particular. He dedicated his whole property for social well-being of common man, launched first Pashto newspaper, established schools and propagated urge for non violence and interfaith harmony. He was a saint , a selfless humanist bigger than Mandela but today Urdu media has totally neglected his contributions. Thank you for this vlog.
Dr Mubarak Ali ek Zindah tareekh hain
Great service to the nation . Suggestion. Naya Daur should launch lessons 101 on history, constitution , econ with reference to Pakistan. We need to be educated.
Please stop re-writing history. Bacha Khan's Khudai Khidmatgars joined hands with Congress Party which had opposed granting any political protection to the provinces where Muslims were in majority. Their members refused to swear allegiance to Pakistan and did not attend the flag-raising ceremony in Peshawar on 14th August 1947. Bacha Khan asked not to be buried in Pakistan and was laid to rest in Afghanistan instead. His nephew, Yunus Khan who was also his secretary, left Pakistan to join the Indian Foreign Service and died in India claiming he had 'come home'.
The case of G. M Syed was different. He had been the President of Sind Muslim League and its council. At the time of the elections in 1946, he had developed differences with some of the candidates nominated by the Muslim League in Sind and chose to field his own candidates in opposition, all of whom lost. It was a personal grudge against Jinnah and the Muslim League that he nurtured until his death. To the best of my memory, Jinnah never called him a 'traitor'.
Ghaffar Khan aka Bacha Khan was larger than life hero of the land.
100% agreed.
1947 say Jo be HAQ Sach aur Asool ke baat karay ga. Woh GHADDAR ho ga
That's end of news
Very good talk on historical perspective of da two great leaders.indeed informative nd da nation has da right to know abt.their leaders.
Important lecture ❤
نہ تو آپ نے چوہدری رحمت علی کے بارے میں پوچھا اور نہ صوبہ ہزارہ اور دیگر صوبوں کا مطالبہ نہیں کیا یہ شخص واقعی اینٹی اسلام ہے
We must listen to everybody & try to understand their perspective also, only & only than we'll be able to find the commonalities between us & them & will be able to bring some workable solutions otherwise opposition for the sake of opposition will bring disasters.
جی ایم سید اور باچا خان جیسے اچھے لوگوں کی بات اگر ہمارے عقل کے اندھے غدار وطن حکمران سن لیتے تو آج پاکستان اس حال میں نہ ہوتا۔
1:20
Flag raising ceremony
"MY FOOT" this is SHIRK.
After 18th amendment province's are more pawarful then central government
But those powers have not been tranferred to the provinces yet.A BLOODY JOKE
Still they are nit because army engineers election and not also Sindhi nationalist parties. India allows regional nationalist parties and their cms are more powerful than PM
اگر میں جی ایم سید کی جگہ ہوتا تو میں بھی سندھو دیش کا حامی ہوتا۔
Yeh Pakistani bhaiya ki glat sonch Hai Ki Mohammad ibney Qashim Rahmtullah alaih valiullah umyad khilafat devlopment Key liye aye Allah ki rahmat thi Jo Mohammad ibney Qashim Rahmtullah alaih India aye Aur allahapak ka din failaney Key liye APNI Jaan kurban kardi 712ce Mohammad ibney Qashim sindh Rahmtullah alaih 711tariqe ibney Jiyad And Moosa ibney Nasir Hasbaniya (Spain)Qatiba ibney muslim was conquered Central Asia if these Army general was not killed by Suleman bin Abdul Malik Today World map differ Allahapak Yese muslim KO jannateyfirdaus ATA fermaye Ameen
جناب مبارک صاحب شعوری لا شعوری طور پر بھول گئے کہ جی ایم سید جناح صاحب کے رائیٹ ھینڈ تھے ، وہ سندھ مسلم لیگ کے صدر تھے اور یے ان کا کمال تھا کہ سندہ اسیمبلی نے پاکستان کے حق میں قرار داد پاس کروائی تھی۔ بنگال اور سندھ واحد مملکتیں تھیں جنھوں نے پاکستان کو بننے کی بنیاد رکھی۔ جی ایم سید کی جناح سے اختلاف بھی پاکستان ریزولیشن پر عمل نہ کرنے کی وجہ سے ھوا۔ انھوں نے ۷۱ تک باقائدہ قومی و صوبائی اسیمبلی کی سیاست کی لیکن بنگال پر فوج کشی کے بعد وہ پاکستان کی سیاست سے کنارہ کش ھوئے اور سندھ کی آزادی یا سندھودیش کی تحریک شروع کی۔ اگر وہ کانگرس چھوڑ کر مسلم لیگ میں شامل نہ ھوتے تو شاید قصہ مختلف ھوتا۔ دُکھ ھوتا ھے جب پڑھے لکھے انسان بھی تاریخ کو ڈنڈی مار جا تے ھیں۔
Please stop re-writing history. Bacha Khan's Khudai Khidmatgars joined hands with Congress Party which had opposed granting any political protection to the provinces where Muslims were in majority. Their members refused to swear allegiance to Pakistan and did not attend the flag-raising ceremony in Peshawar on 14th August 1947. Bacha Khan asked not to be buried in Pakistan and was laid to rest in Afghanistan instead. His nephew, Yunus Khan who was also his secretary, left Pakistan to join the Indian Foreign Service and died in India claiming he had 'come home'.
The case of G. M Syed was different. He had been the President of Sind Muslim League and its council. At the time of the elections in 1946, he had developed differences with some of the candidates nominated by the Muslim League in Sind and chose to field his own candidates in opposition, all of whom lost. It was a personal grudge against Jinnah and the Muslim League that he nurtured until his death. To the best of my memory, Jinnah never called him a 'traitor'.
koi re write nhi kr rha he history...................................................... ye such he jo pakistan studies me prhaya jata he wo jhut he.............. apko to ye tk nhi pta hoga sir syed non muslim tha.............. or pro british tha.................
history prho please
Who is this narrator
Interviewer a bit too opinionated!
Baywaqoofi Aadmi, Ghaddar to woh Hota hay Jo side A say side B ki taraf Chala jay, Ghaffar Khan Gandhi Aur Nehroo ka sathi Aur wafadar tha woh kartay dam Tak in ka wafadar Raha hay lehaza Ghaddar Khan ko Ghaddar kehna ghalat Aur bewaqoof Kay elawa Kuch NAHI, albatta GM Sayed woh Shakhs tha Jo Pakistani tha, sindoo Desh Kay baray lagata tha Ghaddar baharhal NAHI tha. Ghaddar Khan Meri maloomat Kay mutabeq musalman ya Pakistani NAHI tha Hindoon ka karnay baad bhi wafadar tha Aur Pakistan main dafan bhi NAHI hooa
Punjabi ki itni awqat nhi ka o sach ka samna karsaka, Ghulam bagirat
@@comradehasnainkhan1247 zu pakhtun yemma, jaisay kunna ma warkawa
@@sadiqmalik869 za pa kona ki di gota owam, pakhtun naye , da millat ghaddar aw dalal e
@@comradehasnainkhan1247 oqat pushtuno ki nhi,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, isi lie jis punjabi ko dushman mante he usi k qabza me khush ho.................... agr gerat hoti to kab ka afghanistan ka part bn jate....................
@@comradehasnainkhan1247 pushtun aj tk is such ko nhi man ska k us ka soba or us k log punjab k paisa se pal rhe he....................1 city to aj tk bna nhi ske or bate krte ho chilli khan bnne ki
They are actually humanist it's ريئلٽي
Please stop re-writing history. Bacha Khan's Khudai Khidmatgars joined hands with Congress Party which had opposed granting any political protection to the provinces where Muslims were in majority. Their members refused to swear allegiance to Pakistan and did not attend the flag-raising ceremony in Peshawar on 14th August 1947. Bacha Khan asked not to be buried in Pakistan and was laid to rest in Afghanistan instead. His nephew, Yunus Khan who was also his secretary, left Pakistan to join the Indian Foreign Service and died in India claiming he had 'come home'.
The case of G. M Syed was different. He had been the President of Sind Muslim League and its council. At the time of the elections in 1946, he had developed differences with some of the candidates nominated by the Muslim League in Sind and chose to field his own candidates in opposition, all of whom lost. It was a personal grudge against Jinnah and the Muslim League that he nurtured until his death. To the best of my memory, Jinnah never called him a 'traitor'.