Editorial With Sujit Nair | New Criminal Laws: Will It Help Politicians Or People? | Amit Shah
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лип 2024
- In this episode of 'Editorial,' HW News Managing Editor Sujit Nair delves into the new criminal laws, known as the Bharat Nyay Sanhita 2023. He raises a crucial question: will these laws benefit the politicians or the people? The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), which were passed in Parliament last December, are set to replace the Indian Penal Code (IPC) of 1860, the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) of 1973, and the Indian Evidence Act of 1872, respectively.
#BharatiyaNyayaSanhita #BNS #NewCriminalLaws #PMModi #AmitShah #POCSO #BSYediyurappa #HemantSoren #PrajwalRevanna #HDRevanna #AjayMishraTeni #AshishMishraTeni
#HWNews
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
Support independent journalism by subscribing to HW News English Premium Newsletter: hwnews.in/subscribe-us/
To Join UA-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Vad9...
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Excellent presentation 👏 This new reform law protects the ruling party! Politicians can do anything and everything. Policeman is being used as a shield! God bless our great nation 🙏
The new Bill's were passed without any discussions in parliament will have more shortfall.
It will bounce back to those concern people who passed it.
This is what frustrates me about my country. There are obvious disparities and even outright injustices happening and even actively being carried out, many times in the name of "politics". Why, why don't our people understand this? Why must they be blinkered and still vote unquestioningly for a particular party without actually trying to understand what is being done to our country. How different are we from states that masquerade as real functioning countries? Forget about democracies. To use your words, "My point is", why? Why?
For money and blind faith.
Michael !! step 1 to not to be frustrated is to understand who the people are of this country. assuming that everyone has a similar exposure as us commenting on this video is false. there are two India , one is online the other is offline. 1.4 billion people, 80 crore people on free ration, rest just getting by, its a battle for survival, no one cares about law. the poor are used to be ill-treated, and the rest pay their way through police stations. law reforms is not what we need, we need psychic reforms.
Dude migrate to another country if U feel this way .
Sujit every word of yours speaks the truth. I love the passion with which you have presented this very important situation. Ci just hope the powers that be are listening to u.
Even 15 days is too long for so-called police custody. Custodial deaths and torture are rampant. Further, the BNS has made many provisions even more draconian. Full police state.
Nailed it !!
You are right.
Like demonitization this BNS is going to be a havoc.
How can it be posible to arrest and dentent a person for 90 days in police custody without warrant is obnoxious!
Salute to you sir.
You are absolutely right,Sir.
Police custody for 90 days horrible
Every day by day judicial system also. Goes under the footsteps of politicians... & sound parties.. So sad😢... To say..
India shining....keep the people hungry and poor...and uneducated. frighten the educated with litigation.....
What to do....open your eyes citizens... become passionate about having a good just Govt.
Just as you are passionate about having a good cricket team
Thank you Mr Sujit! A very good episode. Firstly, the President of India has made a big mistake by giving her assent to the laws knowing that almost 152 opposition MPs were suspended when the laws were passed. There was no discussion and debate on the laws. Secondly, why was the government very keen to introduce these? Are the laws suited to those who are in power? What is the point of extending the police remand period from 15 days to 90 days. If a person is in the police remand for 90 days , do you think that the police will keep feeding him/her and behave with them politely? I don't know why we are allowed to happen all these?
Good analysis sir
As a citizen of India I can safely tell you that I never mess with IPC or BNS. The process is the punishment. That's why we Indians are corrupt. Jugaad and Bakshish is the jumla.
Well said sir
Mr Nair. Section 69 of BNS. One man promises one lady in total privacy and dosnt fullfill and covered under section 69 of BNS. Where as the so called GODMAN promise lakhs of innocent people who live on HOPE and TRUST nothing is fulfilled this bigger decet. SHOULD all God man be coverd under section 69 too.
Any promises then All political leaders will be in jail....
Again, We can't expect justice as long as amit shah is the Home minister. Already his hands are beguiled, everybody knows how n when. He's no sympathy nor empathy for the people.
Police n politicians can do any kind of manmani. This is not for common people at all.
Excellent presentation.
Neither it will help the public nor the politicians. It will boost the collections (हफ्ता वसूल) for sure.
With political backing it may prove to be the deadliest.
Should reform it again, the sooner it is possible.
Good editorial, as a tamilian I cannot pronounce the three names that replaces the indian colonial-era Penal Code which is in effect.
Jurist and legal pundits had questioned the clarity and transparency of these laws. Also they say it is a cut and paste from original document sprinkled with few Hindi words.
An example, the present law would allow an accused to kept in police custody for 90 days where is the question of bail. This would be a nightmare. Hope the LS would revisit the entire criminal penal code with strong opposition ready to swing to action with iron fist.
Exactly 💯
Why are they using such names 🤔
Dude just use the acronyums of the names. Next you will say that you will not study Maths, Chemistry and Biology cause the names are in Greek and Latin. Thats a dumb argument.
@@Vij367 Cause 90% of the countrys population uses languages originated from Sanskrit, as compared to less than 1% which use languages based on English and Latin
@@jonron3805 why are you doing this argument in English? Why are the rules of the law framed in English? Why are the arguments in the country's top court going in English? Yet, why are these 3 laws named in Sanskrit?
@@Vij367 You already gave 2 incorrect statements
*why are you doing this argument in English*
1) I am responding in a language the show is in as I know the language. Its called general good manners you know if you know a language and respond in that rather than not for ego sake
*Why are the rules of the law framed in English*
2) Rules for ALL laws are framed in ALL official languages. So your statement itself is incorrect
*Why are the arguments in the country's top court going in English*
3) One can argue in any language though most people end up in English. Cause of a colonial rule made.
*Yet, why are these 3 laws named in Sanskrit*
4) Cause 90% of the population in India speaks languages which originated in Sanskrit. Infact your name itself, if correctly written, is a Sanskrit origin name.
Fantastic debate sir, plz do like this more videos 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Worse law than british law
Police custody 90 days Unfair
Please send this video to CJI
He would not cause the CJI will find holes in this. Only naive people will fall for the nonsense he is speaking here. His basis is that cause 100 cannot be done do not do 80 for a start 🙂
Sometimes it may react to the Law Makers too, as every action has its own reaction.
The Supreme Court should have decreed these 3 criminal law "Reforms" as "Unconstitutional" since they were passed after the Opposition was suspended from Parliment.
The SC can still review these laws, if they want to, even though their hands are full at the moment. 6:53
This was new normal under BJP-led NDA government. This law was the crowning glory to Modi and Shah duo, because it was an expression of the way they were functioning, and passing laws with out any discussion, and debates in the parliament. They endured that no law-makers will raise questions about their pet laws by putting almost 140 out Parliament by the Speaker. This is how these two great Gujratis will go down in history.
God may help our nation and do away with the dictator lord
Mr. Nair. The new laws will be good for everyone if we all behave and act lawfully.
Mr... If everyone behave nicely, there is no need for law. Dont be foolish. Law is needed to protect those who behave well from those who dont (including the govt). This law opens gaps where this is not ensured.
Hey u really lack any sense! Pity you bhaskaran
Things have to change we just cannot go on like this please some one show the way
Shameful reforms without allowing a proper debate in parliament of the elected members, this was the modern emergency implemented inside the parliament. Can we speak and compare the 1973 emergency
Your stand is absolutely meet & just ; it portends shocking threat to polity in general as well as the politicians in the oppositions!
Absolutely excellent editorial. All this laws are window dressing what BJP did in 10 years. Unfortunately if the opposition party is not strong enough we Indians will be facing injustice always. Especially who don't have Godfather.😢😢😢😢😢
Yeh an opposition is busy showing pictures of religious figures instead of getting these issues to floor. Shows their priorities.
@@jonron3805you must be watching some godi media..stupid ..may be you start watching other channel
Mr Nair, I totally agree to your factual analysis...
unless and until, We have upright, honest people in power in Parliament both at Center and States, things won't change, nobody is bothered about common citizens of the Country, injustices, exploitation will keep happening, So it's the duty and responsibility of every citizens to send elected representative based on MERIT and NOT on the basis of religion, castes, class and gender.
We have a sick hateful, communal ideology in the country who on the name of nationalism is spreading falsehood, false fears, hateful narratives and is trying to spread poison in the society, doing divisive politics, hateful propaganda to divide fellow countrymen, which is not good for the Country nor for fellow citizens.
Most People has realised these serious issues and understood the modus operandi of Divide and rule...
The most effective antidote against these hateful poisonous ideology is our Unity.
Unity in Diversity...
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
But in a country where people vote
Its painful after knowing how India is becoming into because of some crooked arrogant people. Oppressor will oppress us, so does the deliverer who will deliver us. Its just matter of time.
I agree 💯 with this editorial.
Is there any possibility of the SC stepping in and protecting fundamental rights that may be violated by the BNS?
People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it - GBS
For too long these laws were hanging above our head with no attempt to enact laws to suit our needs -
Great research
Did any political party made rules in favour of public interest? I don't think so.
Colonial laws have to go at sometime or other -
The law is the last result of human wisdom acting upon human experience for the benefit of the public -Er S J
Sir, Amit Shah has clarified, that police custody is still 15 days, but it can be taken in parts, over a period of 60 days. There is nothing called 90 days.
Please read the new laws first, and go through it in detail.
You are going by the interpretation of word by a politician who passed the law.
If you ever been to court for criminal cases, you will know what the actual law interprets.
You got a point yet now it’s like chasing a goose as in almost all big states, the same is implemented
I agree 100 percent.
I like your Job. UA-cam University News Reader.
As you sow so shall you reap ! May face taste of their own medicine ..
If politicians are really interested and want to amend the law , legal framework first change protection, cover in parliament. MPs are not first citizens but are representing certain sections of geographical areas and must come forward in the interest of the nation. Parliament sessions are now live and behaviour of MPs are seen by the public at large. Needs courage by politicians.
Pls see what is going on in Goa. P olic e a_narchy! Its a small state and ignored. But it needs national attention.
That's our judiciary of our country
It help people... But the ruling class will misuse the provision to bring distress on the masses....
Reforms should be by consensus after wider discussion among the parliamentarians and legal experts.
Sujith Sir , bail is only for politicians.
NC got PSA in JK State ultimately it used their opponent against them...whatever party comes in power in the country should bring of they want to replace the law should be reformed one in the interest of people of the country...
This govt plays the empathy card ,with its citizens , incognito
What could be done such corrup situation? There's no justice . How can one change such situation?
There is no justice in today's India
People will be going to jail only politicians will have a gala time, what a waste ,are these Leaders ? They are like out for revenge towards aam janta
Shahs new criminal laws put to the test in Gujrat and Odeisha
Section 125 - sedition has been misused by various govt at state and centre by all as you rightly say. But I think court has protected and defended the accused in such cases. Again, the intent is important.
Said that last year, whenever you made such videos, I always supported the govt. Clearly election seems to echo what you have been reporting. So I shall just listen and see what happens
Looks like pure mockery of the system to help themselves who are in power. When shall our nation will get better and who will do it???
Who will implement justice?
In the rodattion of party government in our Indian Democracy , has to change or passed any laws in every new government? Instate of developing undeveloped place. Country should not run by in the mindset of one person. Without poor people u can't lieve down to earth not only on mouth.
Sir please do the video on Amaravathi capital destruction by Jagan
Soon it will be built by gujuratis and will be collapsed in some months. Money will be looted and safe in gujurat. 😂
The world is full of hypocrisy and pretence.
So, the LAW is only meant for the "Common Man", not Politicians who belong to the Ruling Party, or People who are connected to Ruling Party Politicians?????????
Definitely seems so, and what kind of so called Courts do we have in this country????
The law is established by trial and error by the legal system of the world, countries and changing norms of society. It is legal luminaries to ponder on it. It is not correct to politicise for the Indi Alliance! Please wait, patient. As BNS is applied by courts, with legal minds working, it will be refined. Please note,the CJI very wisely did not comment on BNS. You are quoting single cases and generalising!!! .At least Modi ji after 75 years of Independence did a beginning, though not perfect, but appreciable. Why did the Congress party not in their 50 years rule😢
Criminals aur,Garibi Rashtr First ka marg ka baadhaayem hai.
Get rid of shah !
I confess I am no authority on the new criminal laws not having read them. I new the old laws. A TEOTENIC shift I opine needed not only inclusion of 1. Today's crimes 2. Provision tor crime investigators in police ranks 3. Confession before these designated crime investigators valid and acceptable 4. Evidence of forensic experts becoming valid subject to their x examination. Are these provisions there?
வல்லான் வகுத்ததே வாய்க்கால்; whoever takes
People lost faith in the Indian Government.
Criminals making criminal laws. Sad and worrying.
All the states should throwout the new sanskrit bill without any delay because BJP govt will punish the opposition for their debacle in the gen elction
A.P ex Chief Minister Mr. Jagan Reddy case will solve in New Criminal Law.
our legal system is CRAP. The system needs to be reorganised not law changes. FIRST leasure time court system. All else is bunkum
I think it's better to frame separate for rich people and poor people directly ...why unnecessary just lawyers feed
Sa N hitha
90 days of free ration,housing😅 I think the government should invite the public to a simple live and each should spent a time in jail .the public should go to the police station and arrest themself confessing not able to live according to Kim Modi S.west Jong 😅 standard. Just awaiting the day the whole public in unison becomes the goonda all other type of goonda raj will stop. Jai Republic goonda😂
Law will bend for rich
Who then will reverse this law?
9:40 Dear Mr Nair... yes there is by increasing the custody to 90 days... you are against that. But when power is given to the police they will hold on custory for such cases.
You can be held for 90 days too, if the police are not happy with you.
Please read the new laws. You will get the picture
@@abhishekraj-jb6zx Yes so based on the intensity of the case some human has to make the decision rt? That was ANY human who is given that power is subject to be misused. So YOU tell me who should have that power?
@@jonron3805 just a question for you!
with the older laws.
who was having that decision making power?
@@abhishekraj-jb6zx First YOU answer my question. I know the answer but also am aware of manipulation techniques used by people like you ans Sujit Nair, like diverting the topic. So YOu please answer my question first. Then I will answer your question. Thats a known fact so the answer will not change
@@jonron3805 my answer would contradictory to your answer.
I am okay with the judges having that power not the cops.
Is there any positive thing in the new criminal laws?
Wolfe in a Sheep skin.
what goes around comes around
BAS
Such draconian measures with little or no provisions for civic rights and liberties are agonisingly and alarmingly most antagonistic so far the principles of freedom and civilised liberal outlook are concerned. Passed in a peremptory manner with a sneering disregard for the urgency of threadbare debates and deliberation by the opposition and the legal bodies these laws lake comprehensiveness. When the matters relate to the questions of life and death., the confidence and the collective wisdom and the will of the nation must not be bypassed. The inordinate secrecy , hurry and haste and the ever increasing autocratic impulses and instincts of the regime of non- biological pretence make the most slippery ground for the formulation of laws with strict adherence to the very purpose and spirit of jurisprudence. Such laws may be a tribute to autocracy but certainly not to democracy as defined by the Father of the Nation.
All Indians
Where is our country heading?
Do you mean, currently whatever happening is perfect? Meaning police ate not afraid of ministers and they take bold dedisions based on evidence? Do you eman ministers dont select police ?
12:19 The like button is not working on this channel. Sabotage????? It is stuck at 571.
Politicians make the law.. period. They are Gods. The rest are prisoners in the making
These debates r nice. But V r back to square one when U show ur helplessness. Plz let ur channel challenge this law which u will never able to do. Sir V know the motives of UTUBERS who sometimes are selfish.
I wonder what exactlly were the so called colonial laws that were replaced.. The BJP and our esteemed PM are good at repackaging 'things' and this seems another case. Massive re-education of the police and judiciary mechanusm needed as BNS changes all the codes numbers
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
It is only for the middle class😂😂😂😢😮😊🎉😂
Has Amit and Modi ever done anything for the peoples benefit. Without reading further, or hearing any more , I know for sure it's not in these 2 people to do anything good.