Nuances & complexities as PM Modi speaks to Putin but addresses the world, friendly & sceptical West
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- #CutTheClutter #modiputin #indiarussiarelation
As the world closely watches PM Modi's visit to Russia, and India's shifting role in geopolitics, PM Modi gave subtle yet noteworthy statements in his joint meeting with Russian President Putin. Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta in Episode 1477 of Cut The Clutter decodes these statements as he explains the nuance in them and what they signal to the world.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
05:40 Modi's statement of solidarity
08:10 India's imports from Russia
10:20 Zelesnkyy's reaction & Western skepticism
14:00 Candid discussion on Ukraine and need for peace
16:20 Statement to the West
19:10 Trade imbalance and delayed arms trade
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch PM Modi speaks to Putin full conversation here: • 'Innocent children dyi...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Foreign Secretary Vinay Mohan Kwatra Briefing here: ua-cam.com/users/li...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
India should get technology to locally manufacture s400
Audio quality is bad
MODI is ANTI TAMIL , he should be removed
I'm sorry, but This baby bottle you constantly suck on of "nations act only in their own interest, not out of charity" is wholly uninterrogated drivel.
The Marshall Plan alone makes nonsense of this claim. And no, you don't get to make the No True Scotsman appeal to secondary benefits of charity to pretend that there's no distinction between giving more than you receive and not doing so. Various religiously motivated geopolitical events throughout history are enough to end the debate entirely, not that you ever had the courage to put this cliche to debate in the first place, and it's obvious why: because of how obviously flaccid and parasitic it is.
This line convinces no one outside of India. Not even Japan recognizes this pathetic dictum, the same Japan which gave away tens of millions to foreign tsunami victims. Literal charity from a literal nation. And they too have enforced sanctions against Russia at the cost of their investments in Siberia.
There's literally no effective distinction between this claim and "we get to do whatever we want to do, and still be treated like those who do otherwise."
And what you're doing is not just being silent, but actively inoculating a direct, one-to-one analogy of Adolf Hitler's Anschluss of Czechoslovakia. No getting around that. Ever.
Shekhar ji you missed a major fact. What PM Modi was saying wasn't immediately translated to prez putin. After Modi completes the sentence then translators do their work. So the foot movement is actually for the previous comment Modi made.
Being a seasoned KGB spy, putin may understand hindi expressions
@@abhinav05252 He didn't work in/on India.
Shekhar ji don't have that much brain capacity to fathom that. He is here to do his propaganda.
What is knowledge? If you want to support Modi, knowledge will spread...
@@abhinav05252
What is knowledge? If you want to support Modi, knowledge will spread...
I dont support all BJP's policies except some but when I saw the leader of a superpower driving for Modi, I felt very proud as an Indian 🔥🔥
Very bold and brave move in the den of Putin. Modi is showing he has leverage that he even can say blunt and straight to Putin. That no one else can dare to do.
Whats the use Putin is not going to listen to him
Actually Putin has a lot of respect for Modi. He isn't like the back stabling US/EU leaders.
@@srinivasrao369 you do the right thing. Putin is doing what he thinks is right for his nation. It's up to him whether to listen or not
What does it actually do? Leverage means you have control over someone's actions.
This is all just for show. Mr. Modi has zero influence on policies of Moscow.
@@firstworldorder6072 There was a time when many countries dictated terms to our government. Now tell me, which country dictates terms to India after Modi came to power?
“Nations run foreign policy for their own benefits & not on Morality. For too many decades India ran diplomacy on morality & it didn’t benefit India very much”. Yes I completely agree & support new India’s position on this.
The main thing is you can see how intelligent putin is, he gave modi escape from western criticism and at the same time he can tell Russian people that many countries are with him.
Escape from western criticism? 😂 Bro see any Western news channel 😂. And you'll going to see western criticism through international rankings now..
What nonsense!
Please improve the audio quality.
+1
Modi Visited Russia, Russia honoured Modi with their highest Civilian award.
Now Indians must get ready for :-
Happiness index 192/192
Press Freedom 180/180
Global Hunger Index 134/134
Democracy Index 166/166
.
West can only do this to show their protests against India
Western media is crying we are having fun 😂😂😂.
I have to wonder was cheap gas worth financing this atrocity Use of the ruppes for the blood on your hands
@@RaviChaudhary-ys2rethe russians just bombed where the children receive education in a war torn country fianced by the ruppes buying cheap gas
@Habik87_29 ghadfierr iranerr putin
@@MynesallMynesMyneallMyne Where is that morality when West did not help India and instead sided with Pakistan in 1971 war when Pakistan attacked India ?
Please make cut the clutter on 187 crore SC fund scam in Karnataka and Land allocation scam to wife of Karnataka CM
And also neet scam
The bhakts are again resorting to age old tactics. If there is a scam then where is your ED, CBI. With bhakts like you it's always something you can't just shut up. Go to Tushar Mehta and tell him to file a case in Supreme Court he can go to Bela Trivedi in Supreme Court and get the order that says CBI can investigate the alleged scam. The fact that none of it is happening is proof itself that there is no scam.
Bhakt spotted
@@DataCrusade1999ask a question against Congress ? Boom : andhbakt name calling
@@MrAbhitv
It's best to use common sense once a while.Tell Tushar Mehta to file a case against Karnataka Government in Supreme Court.
Tushar Mehta also manages the assignment of cases CJI is master of roster in name only.
Mehta should be able to assign this case to Bela Trivedi and she will rubber stamp whatever Mehta wants like directing CBI to probe.
As Karnataka has revoked CBI general consent so after Bela Trivedi gives her rubber stamp Mehta can begin an inquiry through CBI at some point Mehta can wedge Money Laundring then ED will enter with SV Raju.
Now you have 2 lawyers whose allegiance is to Hindutva 1 Supreme Court Judge and 2 Delhi High Court judges S.K Sharma and Kaveri Baweja.
So when Modi has a whole system in place why he isn't filing the case and taking action.
Peak Indian diplomacy
Friend of our enemy is still our friend !!! wow, what a diplomacy !!!👏👏👏
India payed for missiles that kill children And families. History is watching
@@sameersheriff7078 it looks the same from the other side.
@@sameersheriff7078 There is no friend or enemy in geopolitics.. Only national interest.
@@sameersheriff7078 there are no permanent friends or foes in international diplomacy mate 👍🏼
Rahul Gandhi congress party looted 187cr ST board funds in Karnataka ,they poached 5 MLAs of BRS, this is democracy of congress.
Congress is the future for India.🇬🇲🇬🇲🇬🇲
BJP biggest poacher in the history of india
How many did BJP poach from congress again? Leave that, how many parties have they broken?
I don’t care about BJP, I care about my state , congress looted 187 crores of ST board funds .
@@fawaaza.7743
Well BJP isn’t doing a realty show carrying a red colored pocket book , portraying themselves as protectors of the constitution.. Walk the Talk
A classic balancing act. India wants Russian cheap oil and arms and at the same it cannot risk access to western markets.
millions civilians dying, with your so called “balancing act”🤡. Let’s call it truly what it is, it’s simply being miser and spineless!!
Really feel proud the way our PM Modi conducted himself in the meetings with Putin and how he could articulate even not so nice things to Putin in person. It requires lot of guts, conviction and reasoning.
My only grievance is why doesn't he articulate on burning issues within India whether it was Manipur or Neet Scam or Agniveer. By not doing timely, he is giving political space to clowns like Rahul Gandhi who does not know what he is speaking.
Friend in need, is friend indeed.
Thank You, Russia 🙏🏻
For being considerate and mature.
🙏🏻🇮🇳🇷🇺🙏🏻
It is exceptional foreign policy to find a way through so much of conflicting interests.
Applaud 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@Habik87_29 Just want to Thank You, as well
I want to thanks Russia🇷🇺 for being understanding and having large heart for a friend.
I personally support war on Ukraine, Russia had no option as corrupt war profiteer Zelensky was hell bent joining NATO. Russia has shown great courage and determination that suits great power. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
But, we have to balance a very tricky situation. We are a 140 crore population democratic country, and our Prime Minister is duty bound to look after present and future needs of such a large populace.
As PM Modi said , Russia has partnered with us in our good or bad times (has always supported us in good or bad times).
I hope India play it's part in making world understand the importance and eventual benefits to world at large, of Russia being given its importance, particularly the West and US.
Thank You, Russia 🇷🇺 ❤️🙏🏻
More than 99% of indian immigrants choose to live in decayed, corrupted and overall bad "Western" civilization. And much smaller than 1% choose to live in Russia, Iran, etc. It makes me wonder if 99% of Indian who choose West over russia are plain stupid, although here, in the West I haven't met such individuals. Paradox.
Really love 'cut the clutter', in depth and unbiased analysis ❤
Its good but wouldn’t go as far as unbiased. Shekhar is cleverly bias.
Good to have you back Mr Shekhar Gupta.
Thank you, Rahul. That's very kind of you. I hope you liked this episode. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
What Modi said, only he could say ...... working tirelessly to get Permanent UNSC seat
Bhaiya, Modi won't be there if China decides to throw missiles at us as Russia will be neutral and the US would distance themselves as well !!! Wake up!!!! Don't be a blind supporter at least now !!!!
Some pointers :
1) Terrorism finds a mention in nearly every joint statement in recent years, but no mention of Chinese aggression.
2) Putin is indeed a weak leader desperate for some positive optics and friends. He sees India as a card against Chinese from dominating them.
3) India understandably is bargaining hard with the Russians and expect this to continue. Joint development programs for military, investments in Indian markets will take priority.
4) Modi & India are aware of the optics. This is also India bargaining really hard with the West and the West knows India’s ability to influence Russia and to limit the war.
5) Visit to Europe immediately shows India’s flexibility and autonomy which many thought would be hard to continue with. India is flexing itself here.
We need this bargaining to show results in the near future.
China is only military alliance and biggest trade partner of russia..you can't expect talks of chinese aggression with Russia
All excellent points, Hari, and sharply made. I hope you found the episode insightful. Do keep watching and writing in as you always do...best wishes, Shekhar
I want Rahul Gandhi as Prime Minister. He will have a bilateral summit with Kim Jong Un while Priyanka hangs out with his sister Kim Yo Jong
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
😂😂
Imagine Rahul giving advise to Kim Jong..how to do x-ray of korea and redistribute wealrh😂
Self interest Fantastic SG. Modi is a master in matters of national importance
Shekhar, that was an important episode. It was crisp and nuanced. Thank you.
Shekharji is such a journalist, and he is very good in showing what Bharath's weakness and strength are to his beloved friends across the LIne. He is very diligent and informative in explaining everything to others so they can know all and screw us from the back. He didn't mention anything about the number of grenade attacks on our solders and infiltration of peaceful people and the bombing of bus and innocent lives lost during the pilgrimage.
Nice to see Shekar ji back…….hope you are in good health 💐💐
This is the reason why we should be self reliant.😏
Why are you giving the impression that India has to kiss up to the west? Don't you believe in the Indian growth story? It will be a 10 T $ economy in 10 yrs. Being so, India has to have its own independent Foreign policy that suits its people and its growth and not side with the west or the east.
Maybe all those Indian workers in the West funneling billions back to India?
🤷♂️
This episode is so full of “Log kya kahenge…”
Thanks!
Dear Arko,
Your generous contributions and unwavering support is invaluable.
Thanks Shekar for the elaborate update ❤❤❤❤
Do you think rahul can make such subtle dialogues
Rahul is a crook, but also an idiot luckily for us
Not even in dream
Don't ask andh chamchas of the prince this question. Because they can digest even shit of the Prince, so speech and all is clearly digestible, however bad.
Russia is very opportunistic in every sense. For India it is a long standing relationship where we both have benefitted immensely. There is scope for India to take some export advantages.
Terrorism is something that needs to be eliminated and Russias support will go a long way. The western should view this as an only internal Bern India -Russia. No detriment to their relationships.
Use the RODE wireless microphone Guptaji. Anything other than that is painful to hear.
Indo russia friendship is time tested.
EXCELLENT jolly WORLD TOURS & TRAVELS
BEAUTIFUL jolly FOREIGN TOURS & TRAVELS
bharath mata ki jai
Right foot says ‘NO I don’t agree’ left foot says ‘YES Agree’
Excellent.... Bharath's Foreign policy is always inclusive....My Mother Land has never cheated in any Country and always helped all the countries when they needed.... 🙏🙏
6 nuclear power plant along with floating power plant is big. For India
Please fix your audio
Good hearted, honest reporting.
Thank you shekar sir.
and people compare modi with manmohan era when it was not even clear who was the pm
Putin's facial expressions are like when will this guy stop talking nonsense. I am so bored 😂😂😂😂
Coping hard?
Shuru ho gya Guptaji ka modi modi, har har modi.
Andh Chamchas are such idiots that the PM of India going on an important bilateral visit is seen only through narrow domestic prism!! No wonder dynastic slaves destroyed Indian foreign policy since independence!! Italian chatukars still fellatiating the prince after defeat.
West should not dictate our PM how to conduct with other world leaders. You are closely conducting your business with our enemy nations such as Pakistan and china etc. and we don't complain about it.
Shekar, India needs to be wary of such ruthless leaders!
Ok
Great content Shekhar, as usual. However, the S-400 part, I think you have got the battery and battalion/regiment interchanged. Please pardon me, if I am wrong.
There is a certain degree of respect among criminals. They legitimize each other.
Now India is boldly transparent in its foreign policy. Gone are the days of trysts, and hypocrisy of moral lectures from podiums combined with jee huzoori at back stage.
Modi, once again lectured Putin on the need for peace and condemned senseless loss of lives, especially the loss of children's lives. It would have been horrible if Modi did not say that, especially after that all that hugging.
The difference between America and countries like China and Russia is that America takes takes and takes while the others take and give something back right now Mody is the best world leader India is lucky
I am sure many of us would also like a CTC episode on significance of PM Modi's Vienna visit, could you please oblige SG sir?
Shekarji, you are a good foot reader try for palm reading (palmistry)also and then face reading.
Can't understand why chakra program is not disclosed?
Moldy joined Quad, stepping on two boats. Is it possible for Moldy to keep himself stable on it. Do not worry, the US is increasing its speed with more sanctions. Will he loose his balance and fall into the sea or keep himself stable with his chamaeleon acrobat?
Would be a great diplomatic coup if Modi next does an impromptu visit to Ukraine to try and work on a mid point solution ..
😂 that's gonna be sick af
Congrats for a very good analysis
Putin said you can say anything as long as you buy my oil😂😂😂 and my military equipments 😂
India wants to be manufacturer and technolgy development hub.
Supply of S-400 batteries and Russian aggression in Ukraine may be the biggest reason for the enhanced Indian dependence on American and French armaments...beyond the optics the Indian establishment has so far, managed to do the tightrope walking and trying to manage the tilt that Putin has on Jinping, but while both Putin and Jinping are running autocratic regimes, PM Modi still has the weight of a functional democracy to manage
Not a SG fan but great episode.
Team, there was some issue with today's audio quality.
Apologies for that. We are looking to fix it. Thank you for writing in.
Regards
ThePrint Team
Modi is very happy to meet Putin.
Good morning Sir
Please buy a new mic, the audio was clearly not upto the mark.
RIP Democracy India under BJP Modi. RIP secularism.
This is where the Ling Convoluted Negoriations hurt --- India now has a Huge Gap in its Air Defence - No S400 and neither arf there Sufficient Rafael Aircraft - Now the Delay for the Air Strips in Andamans and Lakshadweep will add to the Defence woes in the South !!!
We have excellent ideas but execution is terrible !!!
1. putin in power almost 25 years, is not a "russian phenomenon". This "phenomenon" is part of russian culture for centuries.
2. Modi, talking about innocent children dying was NOT referring to Krokus attack in Moscow. Even in russsia noone was making a point that during that horrific attack children were killed. The point was that innocent people got killed. So OP is wrong on that occasion too.
Weak analysis, very biased (and I know why).
Why not an episode on France election
Especially on Paris violence
What are hidden things in this meeting
Shekar modi. Also spoke about India before 2014
It was a Ukrainian Aerial defense missile that hit children's hospital and not Russian missile.
SG is making mockery of himself in reading between the lines of Modi communication to Putin.
Shekhar ji, you need to invest in a better microphone set. It's not pleasant to hear this over headphones.
Can you do a video on the rising educational costs in the country across all levels?
Love CTC i hope consistentcy
No doubt Modi asked Potin what he would be allowed to say, and how much it would cost India. Nuanced, and complex.
The talk of deplomacy can only begin after the debri of direspect is disposed of in the battleground.
Please say Russians become Indias friend only after 2014 .
Last week putin set out his demands for a ceasefire. Which included such things as ukraine seeding its territory including the territory that is currently under ukranian control. How is that acceptable to any government? Or an internationally law abiding state. Pathetic if you think Modis empty words is nothing other than cynical rhetoric
Make india the manufacturer of technology.
India' relationship with Russia is a challenging for the west. It's not challenging for India at all.
If India is asked to choose between US and Russia, that's a pretty easy choice to make, we will choose Russia everytime.
We like America from a distance and have no problems with it, but we love Russia. Even a child in India knows that Russians have been our friends. There is nothing US can do to break India Russia friendship.
Nothing good ever comes from joining the American Empire, they will just drag you in an unnecessary war and expect fealty from you, like they did it with Britian and Tony Blair in the Iraq War.
World has everything for everyone' needs but doesn't have enough for America' greed.
Some Indians have this weird colonial hangover to be liked by The West and The West have constantly chosen Pakistan over India.
1) Did they like India when (Mahatma) Gandhi was around? No.
(They called him half naked fakir)
2) Did they like India when Nehru was around? No.
(They chose Gen Ayub Khan on one side and Chairman Mao on the other side)
3) Did they like India when Indira Gandhi was around? No.
(We have heard the Richard Nixon tapes)
4) Did they like India when Manmohan Singh was around? No.
(They had a huge problem with India buying oil from Iran, they were upset with india in the UN for position on Syria and for non intervention position in Libya, The civil nuclear deal with US has gone nowhere)
5) Do they like India when Modi is around? No.
When you have 35 security agencies, that' not a sign of secure country but a sign of an insecure country.
At the heart of America' insecurities about Russia, is actually the thought, that the Americans didn't win the world war(on thier own as sometimes they'd like to portray), or atleast they couldn't do it without Russia' help, actually the Soviets have a much bigger contribution in ending the Nazi regime than the Americans, Maybe that's why Americans feel the need to equate everything to world war 2 and draw some kind of a parallel storyline, where their enemies are Hitler and they are Captain America in the movie, they are trying to convince themselves that they had won the war but in thier minds they know it is the Russians who sacrificed a lot more and thier contribution is much more greater.
And Yes! Americans were on the winning side but thier main contribution was mainly of weapons supply, which is what they do best, they are the largest supplier of weapons in the world.(Lend lease agreement is thier main contribution).
America is a country that has not faced a war on it's shores till Japan attacked pearl harbour, and they have a pretty skewed view of what a land war to protect it's borders looks like.
Instead, America fights pre emptive wars, you can say that the war they have against Donald Trump is actually a pre emptive war.
They see him as Hitler and are fighting a pre emptive war against him.
Even the ardent American leftist will tell you that basically the Donald Trump ruled a bit like the Romney Ryan model.
Jan 6 was unique event, but the country that argues that second amendment is for protection against government tyranny, it's unusual that somehow the Jan 6 protestors never brought thier Guns to that fight!
In the end it was just bad behaviour by Trump supporters.
There are defensive wars and there are offensive wars. Like the Iraq war and the Vietnam wars are just preemptive defensive wars and Afganistan war was a offensive war.
In the end these are nothing but "Area of Influence wars" , against countries that the Americans perceive to be in the area of influence of Russia. They are often attacked directly or indirectly by The US or they are coerced into following the American Dictats by sanctions or Global financial system of IMF or World Bank.
The Americans have no war against Saudi Arabia or Qatar or Pakistan which are in the area of influence of America.
Bad foreign policy by the Government, going to Russia 🇷🇺
If it's for cheap oil atleast pass on benefits to the Indian customer
Government filling their coffers thru oil diplomacy.
Is it one of those things whose fruits / consequences will be felt much much later?
Please get a decent condenser mic
At 7:39, why two summit meetings ?
What is the Point if we cannot even NAME the obvious.
Sad.
Only words. Obvious words.
To know, IS to not help care...
Words of Shashank....
Respect?
Does a biased
Speaker in parliament
Deserve respect?
Does an unruly
Parliamentarian
Deserve respect ?
Does a Divisive
Stupid prime minister
Deserve respect?
Does a foolish
Low intelligent opposition
Deserve respect ?
Does an immoral
Unethical doctor
Deserve respect ?
Does an abusive
Irresponsible father
Deserve respect ?
Does an ill prepared
Uncaring teacher
Deserve respect ?
Does a corrupt
Valueless IAS officer
Deserve respect ?
Should we respect
The person or position?
High time we
Get this right
If our society
Needs to Improve ...
Good Night.
Shashank
Morality is a petit bourgeoisie concept
You disappearing and coming back with a sorry is just utter unprofessional. this is exactly the reason Im not taking subscription - unreliability
India sail 2 boats in 1 river
Pls keep hands steady they’re moving all over
Stop your paid promotion
16:18 maasoom bache is not ukraine hosp attack. Its the coded message for reasi.
Its not a contradiction
Modi's got balls going to Moscow and saying it to his face.
I appreciate this post but what will it take for India to push Russia to end their aggression. I don't see how Putin's views can be repsected. This guy makes it sound like a budgetary consideration not innocent people dying. People should matter
Disappointing. Mr Gupta has gone increasingly pro-West and pro-Modi. Very little objectivity and the pro-West/pro-Modi bias is painfully obvious. It’s been like that for a while now.
And why not????
Sounds like you crying is a good thing
What should have been said?
Clifltons of this country...are naturally against modi.
I understand
Let him address Manipur issue first .
No ssn , brahmos 2 and su 57 deal.
I think Putin understands Hindi
Putin full-on poker face 😄