Javed sb.is one of the greatest scholar of Islam. His each and every proof and instant are outstanding. No any real intellectual can refuse his dalil. He is not arguing in air.
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
I wish him to be here in his own country where a person like me and many others can meet him in person .. but sadly these kinda people have moved to other countries.... may he live long .. we need his guidance we really do need
He moved because of the unsuitable conditions and fear for his safety and his near and dear ones. Allah SWT can only save Pakistan. He may be right or wrong, but no one has ANY RIGHT to hurt someone due to their views. It's a shame.
ما شا اللہ ۔ مجھے یقین ہے اس کمنٹ سیکشن میں تمام لوگ دین پر غوروفکر کرنے والے موجود ہیں ۔ باتوں کی ترتیب اسطرح ہے ۔ خالق کا تصور ہماری جبلت میں ہے اس لئے جب ہمیں خالق کی پہچان کروائی جاتی ہے تو ہم اسے فورا تسلیم کر لیتے ہیں ۔ خالق کا تصور انسانی تاریخ میں ہمیشہ سے ہے ۔ کوئی تہذیب و تمدن ایسا نہیں گزرا جہاں لوگ خالق کے تصور سے خالی ہوں ۔ ایک بات بہت دلچسپ بیان کی غامدی صاحب نے ۔ اللہ کریم نے آدمی علیہ السلام کو دنیا کے ایک باغ میں رکھا ۔ اس پر کوئی بھائی وضاحت فرمائیں گے ؟
🎉جزاک الله غامدی صاحب 🎉اگر کوئی ملحد سے ملحد بھی یہ 4 پروگرام غور سے سن لے تو میرے خیال میں پھر کوئی وجہ نہیں کہ وہ شخص اللّه کے فضل سے دائرہ اسلام میں داخل نہ ہو جائے۔🎉KA🎉
he never said that.. rather he said " inner feeling of thirst is quenched by drinking the water " signifying a natural relation between these two variables and by no means he is postulating that thirst is a proof of water's existence.. in relation to God it translates as " our consciousness of being a creation (thirst) accepts (quench) the idea (drinking) of God (water) when presented to us"
God is the " instinct " found at birth of human being and it is the curiosity to search out the creater of the world for human being .The God has faciliated man to become believer of Him and those facilities and sources are the following : (1) Think of soul and birth of animated organs in man or in animal.(2) send His messangers to the world and all of them said the same and were tortured by his people on the same way .(3) In the begining all the prophets were all alone , and have very small jamat but mentally and morrally higher and distinguished from others , progressing and spreading all the cor-ners of the world .(4) Natural Laws are also great proof of the existence of God and no man can voilate the natural laws.(5) Ilham and Wahie means Revelation and prophecies shown by His prophets are always fullfilled on the fix time . (6)The determination mind of the human being .The more determination of making higher goal of life , the more success of achieving that goals . Like such people are sadique , or Shuhadha , or Mujadadeen , or prophets . (7) Every man possesses concience and God makes him free to go on the right path or on the wrong way . Instead of that many incidents come in the life which approving the existence of God .
بہت علمی گفتگو رہی ماشاءاللہ. ایاز بھائی کا سوال اینکر برابر انٹرپریٹ نہیں کر پایا دونوں بار. اسٹوڈنٹ بار بار جزئیات میں الجھ جا رہے ہیں. مجموعی طور پر بہت عمدہ رہا.
Based on ghamidi sahab knowledge I can say that he is a scientist in the field of science, philosopher in field of philosophy and a great intellect scholar wise man. according to me he is far better than einstein newton Stephen hawking etc.
غامدی صاحب بہترین طریقہ سے وضاحت کر رہےہیں طلباء کے سوالات زیر بحث موضوع کے معیار کے مطابق نہیں ہیں لگتا ہے کہ طلباء انگریزی کی چند اصطلاحات میں الجھے ہوئے ہیں اور بات سمجھ نہیں پا رہےہیں
Sab abhi tk ghamdi sahab ki bat ko samj he nai pa rehe . Sab ki brain se basic cheze he gyab he . Thbi ghamdi sahab ko bar bar ak chez bata rehe he . But ghamdi sahab great patients and great tolerance
The surprising thing that Ghamdi sb is doing is that he is not diverted by the host's questions. Even host and students do not know they are asking irrelevant or confused question. Amazing.
4. Kisi cheez ko aapne ek source se dekh liya bas baat sabit jo gayi. Like aapne ankh se suraj ko dekh liya and kuch cheezo ke liye do teen ya jyada source ki jaroorat hoti hai. Let's understand ki Intuition ka ehsas kya cheez hoti hai. Vizdan(intuition) ki tasdeek ya gawahi. Ek to wo cheeze hoti hai jo ki bahar ki duniya dekhte hi ham satisfy ho jate hai ki ye cheeze aisi hi hongi. Jaise ham paas aur door ka tasawwur rakhte hain. Ki cheeze paas hai ki door hai. Ishi tarah ham ye ehsas rakhte hai ki ye cheez aadhi hai ki puri hai Isse pehle hamne maa ki mamta ko dekha. Ishi tarah rishto ko dekhe. Jaise ek hota hai insani rishta hai jaise sabhi log hamare bhai aur behen hai. Ab ek sadak hadse me 40 log maare gaye to insaani level par hame dukh hota hai. Ki ye to bohot bura hua. Lekin ye dukh us level ka nahin hota ki maanlo agar ye hua ki ishi hadse me hamara koi bohot kareebi bhi marr gaya. Ab us shiddat ki noiyyat ekdum badal gayi. Iska matlab hai ki aapke Intuition, inner sense ya hassa e batini ne aapko rishto ka ek tasawwur diya hua hai. Ab hua kya hai, rishte wajood me aaye hai aur uska jahoor ho gaya. Ab dekhiye ye jo maa aur baap hai, ki ye hamari maa hai ye hamare baap hai itna kareebi rishta jisko ham log fakar batate bhi hai, jab paida ho rahe the to ham me se kisine usko nahin dekha.
The inductive argument that the anthropologists present regarding the evolution from polytheism to monotheism is not entirely correct. Established history shows that the Israelites had a monotheistic conception of god and then their offshoot, Christianity developed certain polytheistic notions within that monotheistic paradigm. Observing this evolution, why can't we infer in a similar fashion that the original idea of god was monotheistic and then gradually people introduced polytheistic elements? At the end of the day, all we are doing is inferring what could have happened in the past based on the available data at the present. It is not understandable to me why the reverse scenario (mono--->poly) can't be equally justified in the academic sense, given the gradual evolution of Judaic monotheism to Christian trinity?
So imaan ka taqaza ye hai k agr ap k zain ma ye question haey to Allah ki in nehamtoon ko yaad kro jo insaan k tasawur sy b door hein aor Prophets k miracles ko yaad kro insaan ka paida hona aor insaan ka marna yaad kro to ap k zain ma Allah ki zaat ka tasawur rahy ga aor ye question ap ko satisfy kre ga
whoever created whole galaxy can't be same God we talk about as our god is too much busy in awarding and punishing the the people in this life and some people say he has to look after the afterlife department also.
Yea, they are studying textbooks, memorizing them and basically spitting it out. They can't 'THINK' on their own and come up with original thought. Sad.
Anker or mehman ghmadi Sahab ki point ko pick nai Ker p rehe bar bar Ak he bat bar bar poch rehe hen liken ghmdi Sahab ne bhot he tolerance ,Sabar se Sab sawalo Ka bar bar Jawab dia Jo ki bhot Bari khobi he Jo sabt Kerti he ki ghmdi Sahab bhot bare personality hen .
ye host awr jin logo ko sawal karne keleye betaya gaya hai pata nahi kaha se aye hai . Ghamdi saaab mashriq ki baat karta hai to wo maghrib ke question karta hai . wo jawab b deta hai ke ham abhi maghrib ke tarap ja rahe hai . wait karo, lekin phir b awr ye jo host translate kar raha wo b question Kehath paw torh deta hai .............. ?
Ghamdi sahab didn't answer Ayaz's question. Ayaz asked twice that anthropological evidence show that concept of God wasn't there at first, it went through a period of genesis. It is against what Ghamdi sahab asserts that the concept of God has been there right from start.
These evidences are diverse.. They address religions as products of human culture along with human nature, not as manifestations of anything transcendental, supernatural, or otherwise sui generis. And i guess this evidence or theory or theories is a form of knowledge to know about creator... unhi 5 senses mn say aik ... ... the conclusion can be different but the practice is same to get the knowledge... he has answered brilliantly.. he is getting to the answer in steps... he cant jump to last step without addressing initial points. I am just giving my point of view... I found out that the vocabulary of ghamdi sahab is very difficult for people to get his meaning... otherwise he is a brilliant mind.. and i respect him with all my heart. Host must be aware of certain concepts along with students asking questions... seems to missing here! Questions could be more reasonable
Khuda ko kis ne paida kia? Agr aisa hota k khuda ko kisi ne paida kia hota to phir usko bhi kisi ne paida kia hota aur phir usko bnane wala bhi koi hota aur phir usko bhi kisi ne banaya hota... Is trah aap aik "Infinite regress" me phans jaenge aut phir apki takhleek hee nhi poaegi.... Lkn aap jante hain aap jeete jagte insan hain jiska mtlb yeh he k apko takhleek me achuke hain aur yeh apko takhleek me laane wala maamla aik jaga jaakr ruk rha he .. aur woh he Khuda.. who can create something out of nothing jesa k uske 99 names me se aik naam he
میں غامدی صاحب کا فین ہوں۔۔مگر غامدی صاحب یہ اسٹیبلش کرنے میں ناکام رہے ہیں کہ پہلے ایک خدا کا تصور تھا۔۔اور لوگوں نے اس کے ساتھ شریک ٹہھرائے۔۔۔۔ سٹوڈنٹ یہ کہہ رہے ہیں پہلے لوگوں نے اپنے اپنے متعدد خدا کھڑے کیے پھر ان میں سے ایک خدا کا تصور نکلا
Bhai ye Question hi non sense hai k Allah kesay paida hua iss question ka jawab koi ni dy sakta agr jawab ho to phir Allah ki zaat ki sifaat hi ni rahain gy q k wo zaat insaan ki ponch sy door hai insan Allah ko approach ni kr sakta Hazrat Musa a.s ny b Allah ko daikhne ki khawash ki thi to wo sirf Noor ki aik jalak b bardashat ni kr sakay thy
سید بھائی ، اس پروگرام کا موضوع یہ نہیں ہے کہ اللہ کیسے پیدا ہوا ۔ موضوع ہے انسانی عقل کے ایسے کونسے دلائل ہیں جن کی بنیاد پر وہ خالق پر یقین رکھتا ہے ۔
Allah does not need to be proved,Allah being sure of His being Allah allows such silly debates.They know the stories of his Azab and Inam.Here as well as Hereafter.
Ashraf Choudhry the debates are needed for ppl leaving religion.. they need to be explained and there questions (even if stupid) need to be answered to bring thm Back to reality of allah and islam
If you don't prove it to people, young generation is leaving religion en masse, we have many munafiq youngsters who are mulhid but don't show it. I'm sure that one of the 3 people in audience are actually mulhid.
Ghmdi Sahab basic ki bat Ker rehe hen ye log jazbati or kuvh or he sawal poch rehe hen Jo ghmdi Sahab ne Abhi bat he Nai ki abhi tk liken wo yehi bar bar poch rehe hen . Ghmdi Sahab Ka Sabar , bardast , pyr or mohbaat se bar bar Jawab dena in ki bare personality ki TRF ishara Kerti he .
Ghamidi is I feel sometimes inconsistent, even though his rationalist approach is to be appreciated as he has been able to explain most of the things described in Qur'an by using this approach but sometimes I feel he loses the plot in trying to justify his standing, if you read his books or listen to some other interviews where he's asked about the beginning of life he doesn't refer to Adam (a.s) as a single human being but he says that it was a race more or less that came into existence at once but here you can hear him argue that both Adam and Hawwa used to commute with God therefore refering to them as only 2 human beings.
Absolutely wrong!! He nvr said tht, i hve watched every single of his video, the video was abt human like species which darwin theory presents and many other. He clarified to tht Question... nvr ever said Adam was a “race”!
After listening tothe hundreds of religious preachers i have come to this conclusion god has very little or hardly anything new to offer to the mankind as it is said if he is happy with you then in return you will get lots of beautiful women to fulfill your Carnal desire to the fullest extent and if he is unhappy then you will face cruelest form of torture.the intresting thing is that all this will happen when you die but till date almighty has not provided any proof of afterlife.the point i am putting forward is that one can easily get beautiful girls in this earthly life and as far as torture is concerned we see almost every day in possibly cruelest form one can imagine.one more funny thing that in the name of so called almighty every types of debauchery and crimes against humanity are being committed
چوں کہ اللہ نظر تو آتا نھی اس لئے آنکھ سے دیکھنے کو گولی ماریں اللہ کو ماننے کے لئے وجدان ھی کافی ھے بس یہ میرا اللہ ھے۔ اوئے غامدی عربی زبان کے لفط کی تعریف ھی کر دے آدھے عقلمند اللہ کے وجود سے انحراف کر دیں گے۔
![[3/4] Existence of God Proved by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Tsh5t56_Qlw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[3/4] Existence of God Proved by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](/img/tr.png)
![[1/2] Kiya Mazhab aur Science Mutasadum hain - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ca3eJZ3h7dc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4/4] Existence of God Proved by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1qrXrKvCErA/mqdefault.jpg)
Who is watching this masterpiece in 2024 March
.Naveed from gujranwla Pakistan
Excellent series, found 11yrs after but found at least ❤
Amazing, it is hard to find discussion like this in our Urdu world specially with Islamic scholars. jazakallah
جاوید احمد صاحب واقعی ایک بہت بڑے عالم ہیں
May Allah keep this great person on right path in his whole life and increase his knowledge.
He is person of knowledge but secular thoughts
Javed sb.is one of the greatest scholar of Islam. His each and every proof and instant are outstanding. No any real intellectual can refuse his dalil. He is not arguing in air.
Exactly
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
A very intellectual discussion
The sequence through which he delievered his points
I wish him to be here in his own country where a person like me and many others can meet him in person .. but sadly these kinda people have moved to other countries.... may he live long .. we need his guidance we really do need
He moved because of the unsuitable conditions and fear for his safety and his near and dear ones. Allah SWT can only save Pakistan. He may be right or wrong, but no one has ANY RIGHT to hurt someone due to their views. It's a shame.
JAWED SAHAB. AS EXCELLENT AS ALWAYS.
ما شا اللہ ۔ مجھے یقین ہے اس کمنٹ سیکشن میں تمام لوگ دین پر غوروفکر کرنے والے موجود ہیں ۔
باتوں کی ترتیب اسطرح ہے ۔
خالق کا تصور ہماری جبلت میں ہے اس لئے جب ہمیں خالق کی پہچان کروائی جاتی ہے تو ہم اسے فورا تسلیم کر لیتے ہیں ۔
خالق کا تصور انسانی تاریخ میں ہمیشہ سے ہے ۔ کوئی تہذیب و تمدن ایسا نہیں گزرا جہاں لوگ خالق کے تصور سے خالی ہوں ۔
ایک بات بہت دلچسپ بیان کی غامدی صاحب نے ۔ اللہ کریم نے آدمی علیہ السلام کو دنیا کے ایک باغ میں رکھا ۔
اس پر کوئی بھائی وضاحت فرمائیں گے ؟
Bhai commentary on adam and eve sunein Ghamidi sahab ki kafi detail sa ha
Qissa aadam UA-cam pay sun len... Ghamidi Sahab nay bht detail m discussion ki hay
Ase log roz roz nai paida hote great personality in Muslim civilization.
🎉جزاک الله غامدی صاحب 🎉اگر کوئی ملحد سے ملحد بھی یہ 4 پروگرام غور سے سن لے تو میرے خیال میں پھر کوئی وجہ نہیں کہ وہ شخص اللّه کے فضل سے دائرہ اسلام میں داخل نہ ہو جائے۔🎉KA🎉
Watching this in Sep 2024 and wondering this really aired on geo tv. And now all we get is naatiya kalamat etc... we used to be a proper nation
The premise of Dr. Saheb's case is that 'Thirst entails the existence of water'. Quite becoming.
he never said that..
rather he said " inner feeling of thirst is quenched by drinking the water " signifying a natural relation between these two variables and by no means he is postulating that thirst is a proof of water's existence.. in relation to God it translates as " our consciousness of being a creation (thirst) accepts (quench) the idea (drinking) of God (water) when presented to us"
JAVED IQBAL .. You didn't get it.
@@AsadAli-jc5tg oh i didnt get your point of view right or Ghamidi sahb's?
@@AsadAli-jc5tg apologies in advance if i have misread you sir
As per audience javed Ahmed ghamidi is great scholar.
A very very great scholar.
Fantastic argument Ghamidi Sahib
God is the " instinct " found at birth of human being and it is the curiosity to search out the creater of the world for human being .The God has faciliated man to become believer of Him and those facilities and sources are the following : (1) Think of soul and birth of animated organs in man or in animal.(2) send His messangers to the world and all of them said the same and were tortured by his people on the same way .(3) In the begining all the prophets were all alone , and have very small jamat but mentally and morrally higher and distinguished from others , progressing and spreading all the cor-ners of the world .(4) Natural Laws are also great proof of the existence of God and no man can voilate the natural laws.(5) Ilham and Wahie means Revelation and prophecies shown by His prophets are always fullfilled on the fix time . (6)The determination mind of the human being .The more determination of making higher goal of life , the more success of achieving that goals . Like such people are sadique , or Shuhadha , or Mujadadeen , or prophets . (7) Every man possesses concience and God makes him free to go on the right path or on the wrong way . Instead of that many incidents come in the life which approving the existence of God .
Best explanation
I would like to listen repeatedly
Salute for gamdi sahab
❤جزاک الله غامدی صاحب ❤خان احمد سراے عالمگیر ❤
بہت علمی گفتگو رہی ماشاءاللہ. ایاز بھائی کا سوال اینکر برابر انٹرپریٹ نہیں کر پایا دونوں بار. اسٹوڈنٹ بار بار جزئیات میں الجھ جا رہے ہیں. مجموعی طور پر بہت عمدہ رہا.
Based on ghamidi sahab knowledge I can say that he is a scientist in the field of science, philosopher in field of philosophy and a great intellect scholar wise man.
according to me he is far better than einstein newton Stephen hawking etc.
Jazzak Allah ❤
Never fail to disappoint us ghamdi sahib - an amazing man , very under-utilised and under exposed
Never fail to disappoint????
Gamdi jasa rooz paida nahi hota impressive amazing fabulous....
غامدی صاحب بہترین طریقہ سے وضاحت کر رہےہیں
طلباء کے سوالات زیر بحث موضوع کے معیار کے مطابق نہیں ہیں
لگتا ہے کہ طلباء انگریزی کی چند اصطلاحات میں الجھے ہوئے ہیں اور بات سمجھ نہیں پا رہےہیں
Sab abhi tk ghamdi sahab ki bat ko samj he nai pa rehe . Sab ki brain se basic cheze he gyab he .
Thbi ghamdi sahab ko bar bar ak chez bata rehe he .
But ghamdi sahab great patients and great tolerance
Buhat khoobsurat ❤️
The surprising thing that Ghamdi sb is doing is that he is not diverted by the host's questions. Even host and students do not know they are asking irrelevant or confused question. Amazing.
He has an unbelievable knowledgeable
4. Kisi cheez ko aapne ek source se dekh liya bas baat sabit jo gayi. Like aapne ankh se suraj ko dekh liya and kuch cheezo ke liye do teen ya jyada source ki jaroorat hoti hai.
Let's understand ki Intuition ka ehsas kya cheez hoti hai. Vizdan(intuition) ki tasdeek ya gawahi.
Ek to wo cheeze hoti hai jo ki bahar ki duniya dekhte hi ham satisfy ho jate hai ki ye cheeze aisi hi hongi. Jaise ham paas aur door ka tasawwur rakhte hain. Ki cheeze paas hai ki door hai. Ishi tarah ham ye ehsas rakhte hai ki ye cheez aadhi hai ki puri hai
Isse pehle hamne maa ki mamta ko dekha. Ishi tarah rishto ko dekhe. Jaise ek hota hai insani rishta hai jaise sabhi log hamare bhai aur behen hai. Ab ek sadak hadse me 40 log maare gaye to insaani level par hame dukh hota hai. Ki ye to bohot bura hua. Lekin ye dukh us level ka nahin hota ki maanlo agar ye hua ki ishi hadse me hamara koi bohot kareebi bhi marr gaya. Ab us shiddat ki noiyyat ekdum badal gayi. Iska matlab hai ki aapke Intuition, inner sense ya hassa e batini ne aapko rishto ka ek tasawwur diya hua hai. Ab hua kya hai, rishte wajood me aaye hai aur uska jahoor ho gaya.
Ab dekhiye ye jo maa aur baap hai, ki ye hamari maa hai ye hamare baap hai itna kareebi rishta jisko ham log fakar batate bhi hai, jab paida ho rahe the to ham me se kisine usko nahin dekha.
بہت شاندار
Quran revealed as it should have been long long ago
jazakallah qairun
Wow amazing 🤩
Please someone save me I am being drowned by ghamidi Sahab in his sea of knowledge 😂
Ye french cut 'I mean' wala shakhs bahut khatarnak hai😂
“I mean” wala waqayi khatarnaak hai. Lol
The inductive argument that the anthropologists present regarding the evolution from polytheism to monotheism is not entirely correct. Established history shows that the Israelites had a monotheistic conception of god and then their offshoot, Christianity developed certain polytheistic notions within that monotheistic paradigm. Observing this evolution, why can't we infer in a similar fashion that the original idea of god was monotheistic and then gradually people introduced polytheistic elements? At the end of the day, all we are doing is inferring what could have happened in the past based on the available data at the present. It is not understandable to me why the reverse scenario (mono--->poly) can't be equally justified in the academic sense, given the gradual evolution of Judaic monotheism to Christian trinity?
extraordiary
طلبا بات سمجھنے کی کوشش ہی نہیں کر رہے، وہ بس اعتراض برائے اعتراض کر رہے ہیں
Sahi baat ki
Saii kaha
وہ طلباء ہیں ہی نہیں۔ وہ اعتراضات بتا کر بیٹھائے گئے ہیں۔ وہ آگر سمجھ بھی جاتے ہیں تو پروگرام کی ضرورت کے مطابق انکو سوال کرنا ہی ہے۔
Great
So imaan ka taqaza ye hai k agr ap k zain ma ye question haey to Allah ki in nehamtoon ko yaad kro jo insaan k tasawur sy b door hein aor Prophets k miracles ko yaad kro insaan ka paida hona aor insaan ka marna yaad kro to ap k zain ma Allah ki zaat ka tasawur rahy ga aor ye question ap ko satisfy kre ga
whoever created whole galaxy can't be same God we talk about as our god is too much busy in awarding and punishing the the people in this life and some people say he has to look after the afterlife department also.
Three non sense students
Koi bhi questions standard level ka nhi pucha...
Haha very funny and very true comment.. agreed
bhai questions choro... ap baithny ka parha likha tareeka daikh lain..
How they get chance of asking questions .. unfortunately we were never given chance ...
what even?
❤😮
It would have been better if details of students panel had been given,like what they are studying and from which universities.
Yea, they are studying textbooks, memorizing them and basically spitting it out. They can't 'THINK' on their own and come up with original thought. Sad.
Not satisfied with these comments
غامدی از گریٹ
Anker or mehman ghmadi Sahab ki point ko pick nai Ker p rehe bar bar Ak he bat bar bar poch rehe hen liken ghmdi Sahab ne bhot he tolerance ,Sabar se Sab sawalo Ka bar bar Jawab dia Jo ki bhot Bari khobi he Jo sabt Kerti he ki ghmdi Sahab bhot bare personality hen .
Breaks are very disturbing.
The students who are asking questions are so lost - they look like Kindergarten kids in front of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi's logical arguments.
Ghamidi saheb ko isi subject per individual program banana chahiye ..
Saamne jo log baithe hai unko hakaalkar..
@Faisal Masood, kadi koi chaag di gaal kiti aey? Koi haal nahi tuwada..baba g!
This isnt a place for u man.. go back to ur cave
Students ko pata hi nhi kon sa sawal kab pochna h aur wo bus pochi ja rehy han jasy k onho ny sawal likh ker rekhy han ya likh ker diay han
وجدان، عقلی تقاضے، علمی تواتر، شہادت انبیاء، تجربتی دلائل
Sir G don't do such programs with the people who are not interested to understand the issue but are interested to show off.
did he also prove how the sun sets in a muddy pond
@Jasmine are you dumb ? hhahahhahaha
Bablu bhai k question bhut disturb krty hn
ye host awr jin logo ko sawal karne keleye betaya gaya hai pata nahi kaha se aye hai . Ghamdi saaab mashriq ki baat karta hai to wo maghrib ke question karta hai . wo jawab b deta hai ke ham abhi maghrib ke tarap ja rahe hai . wait karo, lekin phir b awr ye jo host translate kar raha wo b question Kehath paw torh deta hai .............. ?
Ghamdi sahab didn't answer Ayaz's question. Ayaz asked twice that anthropological evidence show that concept of God wasn't there at first, it went through a period of genesis. It is against what Ghamdi sahab asserts that the concept of God has been there right from start.
Asif Mehmood can u give me a link for the study pls
What anthropological evidence? Ayaz brought this out of the blue without any reference, and you did too. Please provide references of such evidence.
These evidences are diverse.. They address religions as products of human culture along with human nature, not as manifestations of anything transcendental, supernatural, or otherwise sui generis.
And i guess this evidence or theory or theories is a form of knowledge to know about creator... unhi 5 senses mn say aik ... ... the conclusion can be different but the practice is same to get the knowledge... he has answered brilliantly.. he is getting to the answer in steps... he cant jump to last step without addressing initial points. I am just giving my point of view...
I found out that the vocabulary of ghamdi sahab is very difficult for people to get his meaning... otherwise he is a brilliant mind.. and i respect him with all my heart.
Host must be aware of certain concepts along with students asking questions... seems to missing here! Questions could be more reasonable
Khuda ko kis ne paida kia? Agr aisa hota k khuda ko kisi ne paida kia hota to phir usko bhi kisi ne paida kia hota aur phir usko bnane wala bhi koi hota aur phir usko bhi kisi ne banaya hota... Is trah aap aik "Infinite regress" me phans jaenge aut phir apki takhleek hee nhi poaegi.... Lkn aap jante hain aap jeete jagte insan hain jiska mtlb yeh he k apko takhleek me achuke hain aur yeh apko takhleek me laane wala maamla aik jaga jaakr ruk rha he .. aur woh he Khuda.. who can create something out of nothing jesa k uske 99 names me se aik naam he
Insan ki jibilat tabdeel hoti rahi he want k sath sath evolutionary
Instincts don't change.However habits may change by passage of time.
kya insan ko waqt k sath pyas lgna bnd ho gai ya bhuk lgna bnd ho gai...??
Non sense comment
میں غامدی صاحب کا فین ہوں۔۔مگر غامدی صاحب یہ اسٹیبلش کرنے میں ناکام رہے ہیں کہ پہلے ایک خدا کا تصور تھا۔۔اور لوگوں نے اس کے ساتھ شریک ٹہھرائے۔۔۔۔ سٹوڈنٹ یہ کہہ رہے ہیں پہلے لوگوں نے اپنے اپنے متعدد خدا کھڑے کیے پھر ان میں سے ایک خدا کا تصور نکلا
پہلے ایک خدا نہیں خدا کے تصور کی بات ہو رہی ہے جو تصور ہمیشہ سے چلا آرہا ہے.
saad mahmood yahan yeh baat her nhi hoo thi jo ap bol rahe hoo
Bhai ye Question hi non sense hai k Allah kesay paida hua iss question ka jawab koi ni dy sakta agr jawab ho to phir Allah ki zaat ki sifaat hi ni rahain gy q k wo zaat insaan ki ponch sy door hai insan Allah ko approach ni kr sakta Hazrat Musa a.s ny b Allah ko daikhne ki khawash ki thi to wo sirf Noor ki aik jalak b bardashat ni kr sakay thy
سید بھائی ، اس پروگرام کا موضوع یہ نہیں ہے کہ اللہ کیسے پیدا ہوا ۔
موضوع ہے انسانی عقل کے ایسے کونسے دلائل ہیں جن کی بنیاد پر وہ خالق پر یقین رکھتا ہے ۔
Jo cheez kabhi shuru hoi nhi thi, toh uski paidawar pe sawal betuka he. Kuda hamesha se tha aur hamesha rhega. Peda toh woh cheez hoti he jo pehle nhi toh aur fir peda hokar wajood me aati he. Aap apne aqeede ko sahi karle.
مزہ نہیں آیا
لفظوں سے کھیلنا
اور
ثبوت
نوری سال کا فاصلہ ھے
Ghamdi Sahab ko samjne ki lie us level per ana or hona perta he werna dekh le 4 ka haal. 😂
Allah does not need to be proved,Allah being sure of His being Allah allows such silly debates.They know the stories of his Azab and Inam.Here as well as Hereafter.
Ashraf Choudhry the debates are needed for ppl leaving religion.. they need to be explained and there questions (even if stupid) need to be answered to bring thm
Back to reality of allah and islam
If you don't prove it to people, young generation is leaving religion en masse, we have many munafiq youngsters who are mulhid but don't show it. I'm sure that one of the 3 people in audience are actually mulhid.
Ghmdi Sahab basic ki bat Ker rehe hen ye log jazbati or kuvh or he sawal poch rehe hen Jo ghmdi Sahab ne Abhi bat he Nai ki abhi tk liken wo yehi bar bar poch rehe hen .
Ghmdi Sahab Ka Sabar , bardast , pyr or mohbaat se bar bar Jawab dena in ki bare personality ki TRF ishara Kerti he .
Break break 🤣🤣
Ye khatoon to pata nahi kyon hain.
Poor students
Always irrelevant question
Intehai bongy or chwal students or host... irritating
Yh Pakistani hai.😄
Ye larki bilkul duffer hai... Parchi
😂😂😂😂😂 u are a joke
Ghamidi is I feel sometimes inconsistent, even though his rationalist approach is to be appreciated as he has been able to explain most of the things described in Qur'an by using this approach but sometimes I feel he loses the plot in trying to justify his standing, if you read his books or listen to some other interviews where he's asked about the beginning of life he doesn't refer to Adam (a.s) as a single human being but he says that it was a race more or less that came into existence at once but here you can hear him argue that both Adam and Hawwa used to commute with God therefore refering to them as only 2 human beings.
can you bring links of those interview where he says Adam a.s. is race as per Ghamidi Sb.
I also want to listen his stance regarding adam and eve..
Absolutely wrong!! He nvr said tht, i hve watched every single of his video, the video was abt human like species which darwin theory presents and many other.
He clarified to tht Question... nvr ever said Adam was a “race”!
@@papskhan5541 u got or still want the link?
Duffer students saray.. inko kuch samjh ni aa rai ghamdi sb ki.. na unko topic ka pata.m
Haha😀
After listening tothe hundreds of religious preachers i have come to this conclusion god has very little or hardly anything new to offer to the mankind as it is said if he is happy with you then in return you will get lots of beautiful women to fulfill your Carnal desire to the fullest extent and if he is unhappy then you will face cruelest form of torture.the intresting thing is that all this will happen when you die but till date almighty has not provided any proof of afterlife.the point i am putting forward is that one can easily get beautiful girls in this earthly life and as far as torture is concerned we see almost every day in possibly cruelest form one can imagine.one more funny thing that in the name of so called almighty every types of debauchery and crimes against humanity are being committed
اے ہوسٹ بڑا کمینہ ہے, بات کو اور سائیڈ پے لے جاتا ہے, غامدی صاحب کی دلیلیں سمجھ سے باہر ہیں
چوں کہ اللہ نظر تو آتا نھی اس لئے آنکھ سے دیکھنے کو گولی ماریں اللہ کو ماننے کے لئے وجدان ھی کافی ھے بس یہ میرا اللہ ھے۔
اوئے غامدی عربی زبان کے لفط کی تعریف ھی کر دے آدھے عقلمند اللہ کے وجود سے انحراف کر دیں گے۔
Ap abi zinda ha yae mar gy hae🥺