The Battle of Belleau Wood Begins I THE GREAT WAR Week 202
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
- The German Army is still threatening Paris and the situation for the Allies looks dire. Reluctantly, General Pershing agrees to put some of the American troops into action at Belleau Wood and Château-Thierry.
» HOW CAN I SUPPORT YOUR CHANNEL?
You can support us by sharing our videos with your friends and spreading the word about our work.You can also support us financially on Patreon: / thegreatwar
You can also buy our merchandise in our online shop: shop.spreadshir...
Patreon is a platform for creators like us, that enables us to get monthly financial support from the community in exchange for cool perks.
» WHERE CAN I GET MORE INFORMATION ABOUT WORLD WAR I AND WHERE ELSE CAN I FIND YOU?
We’re offering background knowledge, news, a glimpse behind the scenes and much more on:
reddit: bit.ly/TheGreat...
Facebook: bit.ly/WW1FB
Twitter: bit.ly/WW1Series
Instagram: bit.ly/ZpMYPL
» CAN I EMBED YOUR VIDEOS ON MY WEBSITE?
Of course, you can embed our videos on your website. We are happy if you show our channel to your friends, fellow students, classmates, professors, teachers or neighbours. Or just share our videos on Facebook, Twitter, Reddit etc.
We are also happy to get your feedback, criticism or ideas in the comments. If you have interesting historical questions, just post them and we will answer in our OUT OF THE TRENCHES videos. You can find a selection of answers to the most frequently asked questions here: bit.ly/OOtrenches
» CAN I SHOW YOUR VIDEOS IN CLASS?
Of course! Tell your teachers or professors about our channel and our videos. We’re happy if we can contribute with our videos. If you are a teacher and have questions about our show, you can get in contact with us on one of our social media presences.
» WHAT ARE YOUR SOURCES?
Videos: British Pathé
Pictures: Mostly Picture Alliance
Background Map: d-maps.com/cart...
Literature (excerpt):
Gilbert, Martin. The First World War. A Complete History, Holt Paperbacks, 2004.
Hart, Peter. The Great War. A Combat History of the First World War, Oxford University Press, 2013.
Hart, Peter. The Great War. 1914-1918, Profile Books, 2013.
Stone, Norman. World War One. A Short History, Penguin, 2008.
Keegan, John. The First World War, Vintage, 2000.
Hastings, Max. Catastrophe 1914. Europe Goes To War, Knopf, 2013.
Hirschfeld, Gerhard. Enzyklopädie Erster Weltkrieg, Schöningh Paderborn, 2004
Michalka, Wolfgang. Der Erste Weltkrieg. Wirkung, Wahrnehmung, Analyse, Seehamer Verlag GmbH, 2000
Leonhard, Jörn. Die Büchse der Pandora: Geschichte des Ersten Weltkrieges, C.H. Beck, 2014
If you want to buy some of the books we use or recommend during our show, check out our Amazon Store: bit.ly/AmazonTGW
NOTE: This store uses affiliate links which grant us a commission if you buy a product there.
» WHAT IS “THE GREAT WAR” PROJECT?
THE GREAT WAR covers the events exactly 100 years ago: The story of World War I in realtime. Featuring: The unique archive material of British Pathé. Indy Neidell takes you on a journey into the past to show you what really happened and how it all could spiral into more than four years of dire war. Subscribe to our channel and don’t miss our new episodes every Thursday.
» WHO IS REPLYING TO MY COMMENTS? AND WHO IS BEHIND THIS PROJECT?
Most of the comments are written by our social media manager Florian. He is posting links, facts and backstage material on our social media channels. But from time to time, Indy reads and answers comments with his personal account, too.
The Team responsible for THE GREAT WAR is even bigger:
- CREDITS -
Presented by : Indiana Neidell
Written by: Indiana Neidell
Director: Toni Steller & Florian Wittig
Director of Photography: Toni Steller
Sound: Toni Steller
Mixing, Mastering & Sound Design: www.above-zero.com
Editing: Toni Steller, Julian Zahn
Motion Design: Christian Graef
Research by: Indiana Neidell
Fact checking: Markus Linke
The Great War Theme composed by Karim Theilgaard: bit.ly/karimyt
A Mediakraft Networks Original Channel
Based on a concept by Spartacus Olsson
Author: Indiana Neidell
Visual Concept: David van Stephold
Producer: Toni Steller & Florian Wittig
Social Media Manager: Florian Wittig
Contains licenced Material by British Pathé
All rights reserved - © Mediakraft Networks GmbH, 2018
I still can't believe how far this channel's gone. The dedication and hard work put in by the team is really awesome.
Margaret Adams lmfao
Hope to see a WW2 version!!
They ended the german version :(
My great uncle, 1st Lt. Orlando C. Crowther, USMC, led his men in on the morning of the first day of battle at Belleau Wood. He was one of the casualties and now rests in the cemetery there.
Rip to your uncle and bless him
You're uncle's service has not been forgotten 🇺🇲
Captain Lloyd W. Williams, 2nd Battalion, 5th Marines: ""Retreat? Hell, we just got here".
It was the Marine 5th Regime. There's a difference between the 5th Marines and the 5th Regime. I know, I was a member of the 5th Regime and we'll versed in our history.
Rah.
@@oldreprobate2748 I spent over 9 years in the Marines 68-77. I have never heard of the 5th Regime. The 5th and 6th Marines were awarded the French Fourragère at Belleau Wood, which they still wear today, or at least they did when I was in the Corps. Please enlighten me as to where I can find out more about the 5th Regime, I can not seem to find anything on Google.
These were part of the WW1 Marines who earned all Marines the the name Devil Dogs.
Thank you.
The 5th later became part of the 1st Marine Division 20 years later
@@jbb9643 they do still wear it today
"He was right."
biggest plot twist
FOR ONCE
Those US Marines at Belleau Wood were hard charging violent warriors who halted numerically superior and battle hardened force with devestatingly accurate rifle fire and sheer grit. Semper Fi to the 5th and 6th Marines.
Men to angry to lose
@@fearxhusky114 oorah
Tfw you have many more men but the enemy is a bunch of pissed marines with aimbot
@@aregularinternetuser339 I once heard a saying, there is nothing more dangerous than a 19 year old pissed off Marine
Many forget that the Marines were battle hardened as opposed to the army. They had just fought in the banana wars. Gunny Daly was already a 2 time MOH recipient
"No way, José."
-John Pershing
Sam Huddy Yup. No way we're mixing our white boys with the black american troops you've integrated in your divisions and are treating as equals, while there's segregation at home. No way, folks, no way.
You enjoy looking stupid, right?
@@canicheenrage bruh what'd I just read?
@@Wortlethal what that means. French divisions had integrated colonial recruits and american black ones in their troops. French officer manuals stressing that not only should colonials be treated the same as metropolitans, but also that steps have to be taken so they've no reason to even think they're not treated the same.
The US armed forces didn't follow such a policy, and having together under french command troops treated equally could have been hazardous to segregation in the US.
@@canicheenrage Okay, but what made you feel the need to type this under..
"No way, José"
--John Pershing
Omg the war is going to end in 5 months.....I've been on this channel since grade 9. I'll be starting university in the fall. I can't believe how fast time has flown. I'm going to miss you guys
John Smith they are doing ww2 starting in September. It's on a separate channel they can't affiliate with this because of the coorperate sponsors or something like that.
What nooo it'll probably be over by Christmas next year. Yes.
You still on the channel?
As a US Marine, I have waited for three years for this video. This is my favorite Marine History lesson. Thank you, Thank You, Thank you.
Funnily enough, George Clemenceau speech about defending Paris was the inspiration for Churchill´s We Shall Fight Them on the Beaches speech.
Source?
Cmon Indy! You wanna live forever?!
BJ Blaskovich He's already been around for over 100 years, so probably?
Heilein was an absolute genius.
French: The Germans are too well fortified, retreat!
Americans: *COWABUNGA IT IS*
As a former Marine I can't express the joy of this video! I've been waiting months for this video! Great job and Semper Fidelis
There is NO FORMER MARINERS.
EITHER YOU ARE OR YOU ARE NOT,
A MARINE !
ONCE A MARINE,
ALWAYS A MARINE !!
unless you are a officer of Marines. Then the you earn the title from your MARINES and only by their say do you get the title of MARINE.
SEMPER FI !!!
@@knutdergroe9757 aha
My mother's father fought in Belleau Wood. He was the victim of a poison gas attack. For years after the war, he would suffer violent fits of coughing.
Having double pneumonia can damage your lungs for life. Can't imagine what poison gas would do.
Yes, Verdun was a vast meat-grinder. It was a miracle that anyone survived that battle.
Roger Rabbit my great-grandfather also fought in the verdun but for the german empire
Roger Rabbit yeah mine died by A poison gas attack at the battle sadly
Isn't it amazing that 100 years later, that the grandsons and granddaughters from both sides are now talking on youtube discussing what their great grandfathers did and how they died? Absolutely amazing.
Hacksaw Ridge brought me here. The Dad in that movie said he fought in the Battle of Belleau Wood.
Belleau Wood, Guadalcanal, Chosin Reservoir, Khe Sanh and Fallujah were USMC's finest hours, the toughest times the Marines has to face.
Can’t forget Iwo Jima
Iwo and the sad Exit of Afghanistan!
😱 Do not forget "Battle for Hue City." The Latin motto “Saepius Exertus, Semper Fidelis, Frater Infinitas” translates to “Often Tested, Always Faithful, Brothers Forever
Don’t forget Bladensburg! 😎
@@robertcottam8824why?
As a veteran of the 5th Marine Regiment, 1st Marine Division, we memorized a simplified version of belleau wood. Cool to get a legit breakdown of it!
Yep they later became part of the old breed
.....I still feel like they missed out HUGE on a Belleau Wood map for battlefield 1.....
They missed out on a WHOLE lot in Battlefield 1. It was a fun online game and honestly got me into the history of world war 1, but it was terrible at actually encompassing the war.
Indiana Neidell You do know that the French themselves, not just the Marines, see the defense of Belleau Wood as the crucial defense of Paris and the first real impacts that the Americans made to German troops.
I attended the centennial on May 27th at the Aisne-Marne American Cemetery and heard a Marine General say, "The Battle of Belleau Wood's historical significants does not rest in its strategic importance nor did it weigh greatly into the outcome of the war however, it was were the U.S. Marine Corp learned what it meant to be a U.S. Marine..." That in itself has everlasting importance and significance and should be remembered as a major event in global military history. I agreed with the general.
@@chrisaxberg9444 That seems like an overly emotion fueled reason to have a map for it in a game that's about the overall scope of World War 1.
It would’ve just been somme but in a wooded area
7:38 Back then Goring was only half the man he would become.
Saddam Hussein literally.
LOL
lol
Savage!
If he was he would never have fit into that tiny cockpit! 😁
My great great uncle was a fresh-off-the-boat immigrant from Norway who served at Belleau wood. This made me wonder, what was the role that various immigrant populations played in WWI? I know in the Polish-Soviet War, many American Poles went off to fight alongside their Polish brethren against the Soviets, so there must be something similar to that in this war right?
Been watching since 1916 (I know 102 years) Question for Out of the Trenches, when the United States entered the war were the Americans as enthusiastic about joining the military as British and French were in 1914? It’s alright if you don’t answer since there’s not enough time for every question.
Pretty sure we weren’t cause the wars been going on for 3 years and everyone knows of the horrors of the Great War
Indiana Jones We Americans did go war crazy. Before the there was a large German presence in the Midwest and there was a heavy German influence in our culture. This German influence disappeared over night. This dose not mean very one was excited to go to war.
I hope it gets answered just so Indy can mention Indy.
Indyception
Daniel yeah that would be funny
"Come on rough necks, you wanna live forever?!"
Ricos rough necks
Orah!
They fought so hard that Germans called them devildogs
@@anzehrastnik4388 Unlikely, a term like this doesn't exist in German - they would have called them either "Teufelskerle" (devils guys) or something like tolle Hunde (mad dogs). A combination of devil and dog not only doesn't exist in the language, but if you look at the posters of the time they also write it wrong (Teufelhunden instead of the correct Teufelshunde), which leads me to believe the thing was more of a propaganda effort.
Ahhh man! I'm so happy I rediscovered this channel! I'm gonna have to go back and watch everything since I last binge watched in December! You guys do great work, I hope you continue on after this.
This channel is indeed the epitome of dedication and hardwork. I have been getting tired merely by watching the videos, let alone producing them. You guys are inspirational,
Thank you!
I don´t think i can handle hearing about the Treaty of Versailles again
Well, it's key to everything going forward.
When they divided up the M.E., Armenia was offered to America, but Wilson rejected it, unfortunately.
I haven't ever heard of that before. That is a shame that we didn't do that for the sake of the Armenian people.
Johnnyc drums what does M.E. stand for?
Middle east
lonnie dean thanks
if its one thing you get from this series is that the french fought valiantly and terribly miss managed by pig headed generals who bad mouthed their own troops instead of critical thinking about their own plans.
Sadly, it wasn't just the French. The Italians were as bad off. In fact, your statement is pretty well applicable to most of the leadership from all the participating countries. All we have to do is look at the body count to see that.
All these years and no one learned any lesson despite the millions of dead.
Survival of the Fittest obviously does not depend on intelligence.
The popular image of the Great War as "lions led by donkeys" has a kernel of truth to it.
Its very easy with hindsight to judge these men are incapable individuals, but often it was a case of them simply not knowing better.
Lions led by donkeys definitely applies to other nations in the war besides Britain.
My grandpa was in the Army Air Corps in France 1917-1918 as an airplane mechanic working on SPAD 13's. He told me his stories when I was a young boy about having to drop his tools and grabbing a rifle/bayonet to defend the airfield regularly. On more than one occasion he worked on Eddie Rickenbacker's SPAD 13 as they were both in the 94th Aero Squadron.
His stories and upright character played a big part in my joining the Marines as an infantryman (yes, on purpose, lol) where I learned about 'teufel hunden', the nickname given to Marines at Belleau Wood because they tossed their shovels down, grabbed their rifles & bayonets and drove the Germans back changing the battle, and effecting the war for freedom.
Must... resist... Sabaton reference!
Hello Indy and crew, I have a question for OOTT.
What was the influence of American Enterprises during the war?
I'm talking about Ford, Winchester, Springfield, and pretty much any company that can provide war materiel for a war.
Thanks for having such a nice hair.
Of course, Indy can go into more detail, but I do know that Springfield made most of the US Army's rifles, the Model 1903 Springfield.
Nate Kaufman In actuality the primary service rifle for the Expeditionary Force was not the 1903 Springfield Rifle but, rather, the 1917 Enfield produced by Remington and Winchester. When Sergeant York singlehandedly killed 25 Germans it was with a 1917 Enfield and a Colt 1911pistol.
zoperxplex I didn't know that. Always been told it was the Springfield. The 1903 Springfield was the primary rifle before the War.
DawnOfTheDead991 What happened was that Remington and Winchester were both contracted by the British government to produce the Pattern 1913 Enfield rifle chambered for a new caliber called the .276. It did not take long, however, for the British to realize that switching to a new rifle and caliber imposed insurmountable bottlenecks in production especially considering the enormous demands being made by the unprecedented magnitude of the war and, as a result, the conclusion reached was to keep production of the Lee Enfield rifle and the attendant .303 caliber unimpeded.
When the United States finally decided to enter the war the total number of 1903 Springfield Rifles was simply too small to supply an army envisioned for the war. The Springfield Armory was incapable of manufacturing the numbers of rifles required and since Remington and Winchester had already acquired the tooling to produce the Pattern1913 Enfield the decision was made to simply rechamber that rifle for the .30-06 caliber used by American armed forces. Thus the 1917 Enfield was born.
Neptune The Lewis Gun was of American design and gave the British LMG fire superiority against the Madsen.
A question to the great war team ~ what is your thinking...if Germany reaches Paris what would be the French response - would they have turned it into a Stalingrad type fight or would they ended up with the same result of what happened in WW2?
"I will fight infront of Paris, I will fight in Paris, I will fight behind Paris" Foch
In ww2, Paris was considered an open city, and fight continued around and behind it. No "result".
@Jonathan Williams With over a million allied troops in France, surrender would be meaningless. All parts of France behind Allied lines would not answer to the German government and the French Government had the time to evacuate the capital anyway. If German troops could march under the Arc de Triomphe, it would be a massive blow to morale, but too many American, British, Canadian and Indian troops were in France to make the French capital relevant. Even if French leadership was decapitated, the French armies could continue fighting on under British command.
WW2? Stalingrad? what on earth are you talking about, been reading too much fiction i think.
I think someone not reading enough history to understand the question
Germany was like Richard III at the end of the battle of Bosworth Field. Minimal chances of victory, but doing his best...
And later vilified by the victors. I see the parallels. Lol. Also No horses!
A horse! A horse! My kingdom for a horse!
And just like Richard III are in fact guilty of doing some legitimately evil things to get power.
" -Northumberland- Other Germans! Help me! "
Actually Richard had the advantage in Bosworth, and Henry only won because Thomas Stanley switched sides seeing Henry as a better opportunity for more power
"The thing is, sometimes those numbers come up." - Indy knows what's up
Our president recently said the brave Americans who died in this battle are "losers" and "suckers" for dying in war
These men are badass, along with the French men who fought
I hope the ghosts of those that died in that battle haunt him forever
@@ranelgallardo7031 I just cant believe the Canadian prime minister had more respect for the fallen then our own commander in chief, I hope the fallen Americans there know that at least some leaders are intelligent enough to remember them
I’m Canadian and I can’t believe that so much of the American military supports a president who questions why they should try to recover a fallen comrade, calls their dead losers and suckers, wants to hide their wounded fellow soldiers and clearly doesn’t understand the concept of honour, duty or sacrifice. Many of his supporters flatly disbelieve any word or reports against him. Amazing.
Liar.
Matt King Rube.
I'm glad you got around to this. I was with 2nd Bn 6th Marine Regiment and we stressed the importance of our history and this battle was a huge part of it.
Roger Rabbit Maybe maybe not but it's a huge part of history as a Marine and especially one in that unit
Correct me if I’m wrong but doesn’t your Marine Regiment get a special French arm Cord for you uniforms.
Suhdude Yes that is correct
Thomas Copeland oh wow that’s pretty cool
@@thomascopeland5111 and the French renamed the forest "Bois de la Brigade de Marine" in recognition of their heroism.
Finally I waited four years for this episode, Rah to my fellow Devil Dogs. Semper Fi
The Great War, is a priceless treasure! Thank you for all of your Most Awesome work!
About freaking time. I've been waiting for this epsiode since 2018 started. Marines stacking bodies.
Jacob Stewart it wasn't marines dumbarse read a book, you are a sucker for your propaganda.
"Fix Bayonets!" is a great read, real perspective from real Marines.
John Brewington a read that a yank wrote haha stupid propaganda.
Brooke Whittle It definitely was Marines, no one doubts that. The Army was there too but they couldn’t hold the line like the Marines could because they were inexperienced and were only relieving 2/5 and 2/6 Marines.
James Geddes hahaha listen to these stupid yanks falling for their propaganda, where's your citations? I couldn't really care about belleau wood, it was only a skirmish compared to the other battles up north near the Somme, and is virtually unknown in Australia an New Zealand. Unlike the battle of Meddigo in the Sinai and Palestine Campaign which destroyed the Ottoman Empire's Yildirim (Thunderbolt) army group.
Kill, Fight, Die that's what a soldier should do
Top of the game, earning the name
They were the Devil Dogs
In a warmachine
They were the USA Marines
Belleau wood. The greatest moment in the USMC
They should have landed the marines behind the Germans and cut them off.
That and the chosin reservoir
Thought That was Iwo Jima?
I completely forgot this comment existed. Well.
@@saharafox8209 Marines fought hard and raised a flag at Iwo Jima. Marines absolutely fucked the krauts & earned the name Teufelhunden at Belleau Wood
I checked the channel about 20 times yesterday hoping for this episode and now it's here!
Belleau Wood: A Battle so well known it does not even share the video title with another war development.
William Desmond yeah sorry over in Australia belleau wood is completely irrelevant and is never talked about same as in NZ.
Last time I checked, sass is unnecessary.
William Desmond Here Belleau Wood is not talked about at all.
Just kidding, I live in Southeast Asia, barely anyone talks about WWI at all.
When you’re a German and the woods start speaking Marine
Spencer Callister
When a 19 year old Marine jumps into your trench with a war crime stick, slam fires 5 rounds in the general direction of your comrades, and prepares to vibe check you with a load of buckshot.
@@woodrowcall3158 were shotguns really war crimes? Especially when their opposition was using mustard gas and flamethrowers?
@@JDP2104
The only war crime is failing to enforce the will of the body politic.
Nice that you mentionned "Desperate" Francky =)
Interesting to know that because he was commanding the whole Group of the Armies of the North, which the 6th Army was part of, and because of his conduct he was blamed for the German breaktrough and sacked. He was moved to Greece to command the Army of the Orient as a punishment but turned this disgrace into a huge triumph after the victory at the battle of Dobro Pole leading ultimately to the surrender of Bulgaria and the Ottoman Empire, and the liberation of Serbia.
Could you do a special episode about him when the time comes please ? ^_^
Of all the videos I've watched over the Battle of Belleau Wood, not a single one mentioned how far it was across the wheat fields from the Marine positions to Belleau Wood. I have heard (and read) many guesses that the distance was 400, 500, 600, 700, or 800 yards. This is something I have been researching for some time now and no one seems to know how far the Marines had to attack across the wheat field. I would appreciate hearing from anyone who has been there and knows the distance.
Pershing said:"No way, Jose !" :D
That should of been 'No way Renee'.
Jim Benson The Harlem Hellfighters consisted of Hispanics and African Americans. Just to let ya know
Extremely well done, no matter what your interest level in history might be, this series is excellent entertainment and you may just learn something while your at it.
Great work Indie and crew. I love the show, and I think it's very sad that it's ending in november this year.
two thumbs 👍up (props) to Siskel & Ebert....dude....U REALLY bring the history..(the back-story is ALWAYS more interesting than the actual conflict)....some of us 🇺🇸want to know more about why...than the when & where...and U outshine all.....
Retreat?!? Hell, we just got here!
I really go think the Germans are gonna be able to pull it off! Long live the Kaiser!
THE AMERICANS ARE HERE!
@@MattMerica76 SHIEßE NOT THE YANKS
Hi guys! Will you do an episode about Theodore Roosevelt and his sons? Next October will mark the 100th year of his famous article for Metropolitan magazine. Reflecting about America's participation in WW1, he coined his well known phrase, still much quoted nowadays: "In this country there is room for but one flag and for but one language."
Thanks!
Hate to burst your bubble but the USA has never been and will never be 1 language nation.
Hate to add to the bubble bursting, but TR was an enthusiastic advocate for driving the war until literally up to the day his son was killed. He had been speaking to war bond rallies several times a week until that day. After his son died he never again spoke publicly in support of the war, and he died a year later.
Wyatt Earp, You need to go back and study your US History again. Multiple languages have always been spoken inside the boarders of the US.
Keep deluding yourself.
According to the US 1910 census, 10% of Americans spoke German as their primary language, and there were over 500 German-language newspapers in the country as well.
Here's what gets me about World War I. It started when Austria-Hungary declared war on Serbia. But in 1918 they're not even fighting each other. Austria is fighting Italy and Serbia is fighting Bulgaria
01:45 awesome photo I've never seen before!
I was waiting for this episode for a long time
My Grandfather fought in WW1 in France. He was a Master Gunnery Sgt. for the US Army. I still have his helmet he wore in battle...
The army doesnt have master gunnery sergeants
Everytime I get a notice about a new episode I imidiatly think of the point in time you decided that this series is going to eat four years of your time...and you still go strong. Thanks.
Question for OotT (Hey! Got it right this time!) I sometimes go back to the earlier episodes, and I'm always captivated by the early advances of the German army, especially the first battle of the Marne. Where you say the entire future of the 20th century hangs in balance. I definitely get the feeling that this was the best shot for the Central Powers to win. But at what moment would you say that the war was (spoilers) beyond winning for them? With the manpower and supply shortage we hear about now, no matter what the gains are, it seems they are destined to lose. I know this is gonna take some alternative-ish history and personal opinion to answer. But I think we'd all like to know. Tack för alla avsnitt din jänkare! ;)
I still can't wrap my head around the fact that there's only 5 months left until we get to the Armistice. Like, seriously, it's been a wild ride with Indy and co. and TGW has been an essential part of my Thursdays (well, really early Fridays because time zone shenanigans.)
My Great great uncle Enoch Allen fought here, may he rest in peace
Great channel!!! Thank you for all the work and research you put into these videos. I have always loved history, your videos make it easier and enjoyable to learn more of the details. Again, thank you very much!
Question for Out of the Trenches: First I have to say, Love the show. Guys, you did amazing job, I been watching all your episodes. Would you be so kind and talk about Polish Legions in France or in Russia ? How Polish soldier were treated in Prussian or Austro-Hungarian army? They fought in every army in every front, there is a lot to talk about. Greetings from Kraków!
My Great Grand father fought in that battle. 2nd Div, 1st field signal, company c. He was attached to the US Marines as a lineman.
08:13 how tiny is that guy on the right? :D
This channel is awesome,hard working, full of documentarys and full details of each battle👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Indy I am a huge fan. I love your show more than ottoman generals love sending their troops into Russia with summer uniforms.
Great episode! This was yet another great episode in the history of our USMC:-)
Vote Blue
Man! I love this! Wish of found you 1st day out but... Better later than never!!!
Hoorah
Hey Indy, I was wondering since all 3 of the Caucasian countries claimed independence in late May, how did they draw up their boarders? Did all 3 of them claim all of Caucasia? Are the boarders they drew back then similar to what the boarders are Today?
the same question is causing our animator nightmares at the moment
The Great War 😂 good to know I am not the only one who was wondering this, thanks for constantly upping the production value of the show, the animations help a lot!
I doubt they claimed the whole thing, but Nagorno-Karabakh probably caused the same problems then that it does today (particularly since both sides would probably want continuous territory, rather than exclaves).
Hey Indy i did some digging and found this website which has detailed maps of various countries/territories throughout history including the Caucasus: www.edmaps.com/html/caucasus.html
These two maps show in detail what the boarders of the three countries would look like: upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/43/The_First_Armenian_Republic_1918-1920.gif
www.conflicts.rem33.com/images/Armenia/restoration%20and%20terr%20issue/KARTEN/MAP_5_transcaucasus_1919_B.JPG
i thought your animator could use the help 😃
Yeah the borders where a bit of a mess, allot of claims on each other and disputes, however they roughly looked like what you see in the modern day.
Excellent programing by Indy and Crew!
My great grandfather was in this battle
Mine was at Argonne forest who told my grandfather to join the Navy that the Navy seemed to have it a bit easier my grandfather took his advice was on leave from the West Virginia on the Hawaiian mainland when Pearl harbor happened
My Uncle Paul Menschel fought in this war USA. We so proud of him
6:00 here come the devil dogs
6:31 cleaned up in a certain sci fi book: "Come on you apes, do you want to live forever!".
The Americans aren't doing bad so far. They won their first real battle last week, and this week they successfully repelled a German attack.
Devil Dogs, we earned the name Devil Dog during Belleau Wood. Semper Fi'!
FlyingVaultDweller tell me who gave you that name? Haha cause it definitely Wasn't the Germans or any one else thar I recall haha are you sure your not dreaming?
Regardless of how the name came to be, or if it was given by the Germans or was made up. It is a name that was earned and has stood for over two hundred years of Marine Corps tradition. So I am 100% certain, it's not a dream. If it's providence is in so deep a dispute, please forward all concerns to Headquarters Marine Corps, Arlington, Virginia. Though I don't see the name going away anytime soon.
FlyingVaultDweller how do you earn a nick name when you give it to yourself haha. That doesn't make any sense what so ever.
@@gunslinger1911a1 lols how can you earn something that you give to yourself? "Devil Dogs" was taken from an article printed in over 100 US newspapers published 14th April 1918, that's 6 weeks before Belleau Wood.
I love thursday.
Semper fi!!! Love you Indy I waited for this weeks episode
Oorah!!!
ilocosmetro YUUUUUUTT!
👍👌👏
You guys are doing some phenomenonal work!
Thanks for the time and your efforts....I truly enjoy your videos!
I love how this shows up on my feed 3 days after trumps insults come out. Hopefully now more people will learn about these “Suckers” and see what they really went through.
Belleau was saved by the Marines. Ooh Rah! 🇺🇸😍
Could we have a "Who did what in WWI" on some of the later leaders during WWII like Carl Mannerheim, Miklos Horthy, Ion Antonescu and Charles de Gaulle?
De Gaulle actually spent 32 months in a German prisoner of war camp after being taken prisoner as a company commander at Douaumont in march 1916. But before that he did more than his fair share in WW1.
Thanks to Gunnery Sgt. Daly for saying that phrase, because the Devs of Verdun (the game) put it as the rally call for the USMC faction. First time I heard it I did a jig. Fuckin bad ass
How much larges were the Americans daily rations compaired to the Germans at this point?
Significantly larger. Not just more food, better quality also. The average German soldier was hungry by this point. That's why they stopped to loot captured Allied depots full of food.
I love how he said , ''treaty of pEace and friendship ''
No suckers or losers at Belleau Wood. Teufel Hunden!!! Semper Fidelis
the term "Teufel Hunden" does not exist in the German language, neither does any combination of Teufel and Hund, really. Only "Teufelskerl" (the devils guy) is used.
@@bezahltersystemtroll5055 ok fritz Marines don’t care! 😉. Yut!!!
Semper Fidelis!
Joined the war since late 1917 as the Americans joined. Great show as always!
Vize Kommandant Reiner Braun
Best way to minimize your own casulities is to let your allies do most of the dirty work
What else would you call it?
Christian - it is their war, after all. On their continent.
Was rilly disappointed you didn't give more details about Belleau wood
Here come the Marines boys!
It's so nice to see that skinny pilot get a wonderful medal! I'm sure he has a bright future ahead of him.
It seems the German Army has a tradition of fighting the Yanks in the Woods and Forests of Europa. They also inflicted huge casualties on The American Army in The Infamous Hurtgen Forest Battle in the Autumn/Winter of 1945!
It´s vice versa, Germans have fought everyone in large woods since the Romans at Teutoburger.
U mean 1944?
Trunks Hunter
1944 !!!
As a foot note to the above if Hitler had continued to fight a full defencive battle plan in this forest area of Germany and had Not launched his Ardennes "Battle of The Bulge" offensive on The 16 th December 1944 . Which greatly depleted his remaining man power / fuel reserves / Lufwaffe strength along with stripping his best Panzer divisions from The Eastern Front. WW 2 might have continued on until the Autumn / Winter of 1945 , combined with his vaunted Wunderwaffen of Course !
9 A.D.
Desmond Doss's father, William Thomas 'Tom' Doss, fought in WW1 and in the movie was portrayed saying he was at Belleau Wood.
I didn't find any actual reference to where he served, except that he was awarded a silver star (technically silver citation star I guess but maybe later upgraded) but not what for.
Would be interesting to hear what is known of his actions
Just finished playing Age of Empires 3 with the Germans as my ally when my notif showed up, we've won against 6 civs, is this a foreshadow who would win the Great War? LOL
Angelo Cortez age of empires 3? Nah I'm always Swedish I love wrecking the Dutch
So you love Swiss Pikemen mate? Let me counter that with Gendarme Cuirassier haha
Angelo Cortez you love them do you? Let me counter yours with 10 gatteling guns
No match, my Cuirassiers has 0 training time (all cavalry-enhancement shipments delivered) Ha!
I clicked on this so fast you have no idea.
I've been waiting for Belleau Wood to come up for weeks.
The Devil Dogs are here! (Soon) Will you be doing an episode on the Lost Battalion Indy?
TheAboveAverageWar who called them devil dogs?
Brooke Whittle The Germans
@@heavypupper1219 Hi there. There was an article in "Leatherneck" magazine last year or maybe two years that discussed this subject. There seems to be some doubt among historians on who called the Marines "devil dogs". Their contention was that it was a American newspaper reporter who came up with the name through his very bad understanding of German. As for me, I'm going to go with one hundred years of Marine Corps tradition. Semper Fi!
I love how Petain in 1918 was insisting on defense in depth against opposition from more powerful figures, & then in 1940 he was given supreme power & was like "well now, I'm not doing it!"
Vive L'Amerique!
Gaslight Studios Merci!
Et vous avez dû attendre des années pour nous aider
French Imperial Eagle -Sorry we didn't want to rush into a giant, despicably destructive war that you Europeans started.
Jordan Dewey and yet you guys still joined the war anyways
@@wood4058 Yep, and we lost over 100,000 men helping you guys. We lost hundreds of thousands more helping to liberate your asses 20 years after that. Sorry, I guess.
Dan Daily was USMC. How could you miss that?
With all respect due to the Americans and their engagement during the war, their battles at Belleau Wood and Chateau Thierry look like skirmishes if you compares their losses to the French ones in general during the numerous battles they fought in the 3 previous years of the war (same could be said for the British, Russians etc)
I understand these battles have been very symbolic of the American sacrifice and totally respect the soldiers who fought and died there, but I think they were more useful for allied propaganda to say "Look Guys, the Americans are really in it now!". They were important for morale etc
But their limited numbers and action makes me think they did not make the most strategic and vital contribution among the allies, a bit like the BEF in 1914.
What you just stated is the view held by everyone. The real impact of the Americans, besides their contribution in supplying the allies with various resources over the previous three years, was the threat of their military involvement on German strategy before they ever actually entered the western front. Germany made one last all-out push towards knocking France out of the war before the US could arrive with their numerically superior troops. It ultimately failed of course and proved too costly to rebound from. Had the US never been of any threat in joining the allies, Germany wouldn't have performed such a risky campaign and thus wouldn't have lost such catastrophic numbers of troops. It's very likely they could have won or at least ended the war as indecisive and on much more equal terms.
i love how this is like a Sports Center recap of historical events, it's really cool ;)