@@danielawesome36 My lord, the great houses are sending six spoiled children who refuse to acknowledge your ascention. What are your orders? "GOOD DAY SIR!"
It's a pity they downplayed how insanely dangerous Paul is. They mostly only showed him in his role as leader but in the books it was factually true that no one could stand against him. It got to the point that he had killed so many challengers to his rule that Chani killed at least one person who tried to challenge him stating that it would be a waste of his water to spend it killing such a trivial opponent. Canonically Paul is the most dangerous person on the planet by a considerable margin. He taught all the fremen around him how to fight which itself is ridiculous considering the Fremen were already far more dangerous than the sadukar. In the book during the confrontation with the emperor the emperor commands the empires greatest assassin in all of history (And the last attempt at creating the KH) to kill Paul. The assassin did no fighting, and looks at paul who is exhausted from an invasion injured and poisoned. And concludes it's possible he could kill Paul, but not guaranteed. This wasn't communicated well in this movie so I hope it gets shown in the next because by the end of the emperors reign he can kill anyone who comes after him. Even his children (Yes he has children in the book) are too dangerous for the sadukar to stop. Capturing his 8 year old cost several lives and she tells the emperor she let herself get captured in the end she could have kept killing them.
Wow that is very terrifying to think about. So I guess in the end, it was always Feyd, the Harkonnens and Sardaukar who were the good ones, while Paul and the Fremen were the evil ones. We can only hope the Great Houses can put a stop to this madness and save the Known Universe in the 3rd installment of the series.
@@MangleZTNA Yeah, the books go much farther into just how dangerous Paul actually is. At this point in the story he _could_ easily kill everyone in that room and that's like multiple thousands of armed Fremen. The amount of power he was radiating with the Voice alone was just absurd.
Gurney is like a ronin of ancient Japan, when he saw his master's ring once more in Paul's hand you can tell from the facial expression he doesn't consider himself a masterless ronin anymore but a samurai warrior ready to defend his master and house again. Josh Brolin did great in this role!
I know Chani was changed for cinema from the books to be more of a voice of reason to Paul's jihad, which I like since you don't get as much subtext from the character's inner monologues. But even like you said, Gurney being loyal stopping Chani from challenging paul is a huge moment. If he didn't stop her, and she challenged them right there, I don't think he would have been able to kill her in a duel.
@@edwinmoy1402 His tears of pride when Paul puts on the Atreides signet ring 💪 He knows that Duke Leto and all his brothers in arms will finally be avenged.
My wife almost hopped out of our seats in the theater, this scene was so well done, just as good if not better than the speech Paul gives to the emperor in the original dune movie.
That squat down by Paul to make the dude think Paul is on his level, then the rise up by Paul as he continues talking to let the dude know he has no real chance of beating Paul is good directing.
It’s also very similar to the crouched position (waiting in ambush, ready to pounce) that we see from several of the Fremen in the first part when Paul first encounters them in the desert. Not only is your assessment correct, but it also shows Paul using the Fremen’s own body language to convey a point.
This is one of the greatest lines because the "hand of god" references the claw-print on the moon of Arrakis and the smaller moon is known as "Muad Dib" as well. Paul is hitting all the skill checks in charisma by referencing some of the most iconic symbols of their religion.
Paul's prescience is a result of genetic engineering, training, and spice consumption, not divine intervention. He is aware that his role as a prophet is partly a construct, and he struggles with the moral implications of using it to wield power. Paul is a deeply conflicted figure who understands the dangers of messianic leadership. His story explores themes of manipulation, destiny, and the unforeseen consequences of fulfilling prophecy, making him a "prophet" in a complex and ambiguous sense.
@@OddlyIncredible That's actually a good paraphrase of what Frank Herbert said: “I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health." One of the most dangerous presidents we had in this century was John Kennedy because people said "Yes Sir Mr. Charismatic Leader what do we do next?" and we wound up in Vietnam. And I think probably the most valuable president of this century was Richard Nixon. Because he taught us to distrust government and he did it by example.”
@@jonathanstone4878 Leto didn’t start a war tho. He ruled the galaxy as a tyrant for thousands of years. There were probably some small rebellions here and there, but there was literally no power in the universe capable of standing against him, let alone waging war. Paul's Jihad tho, per wiki, "caused 61 billion casualties, the sterilization of ninety planets, the demoralization of five hundred additional worlds, and the eradication of forty different religions along with their followers. Ten thousand worlds were subsumed into his new Empire."
@@severussnapeus3607 The books state that he surpassed his father by a large margin as it involved every planet in the imperium. He also rationed Spice which shortened almost every regular citizen's life. It's WAY beyond 61 billion.
@@realspiderman-u6g according to lore, Leto 2 caused measurably more death due to famine and rationing or removal of Spice (Spice extends life). Paul only had a couple of decades while Leto had more than 3,000 to amass his record. No number is given afaik but it is said to have dwarfed Pauls.
@ in the culture of the Fremen it is effectively a sin to give water to the dead. The dead are drained of their water because they have no use for it. The notion of “giving water to the dead” is their way of saying “weeping for the dead”, which is a sort of taboo in the desert as it wastes precious water. He’s effectively calling the priests out on this, saying that it’s their secret desire to live in a world where they can freely mourn their dead, thus he offers to bring them “Green Paradise”, a terraformed Arrakis where water is abundant. He’s basically using their deepest hidden desires to encourage them to follow him
@@Heating56 he's talkin about crying for the dead, Chani wiped away a tear once in the first movie. Paul simply sees that the Naib he is talking to is crying tears over the death of the people he loved in his dreams and that this gives him relief. But these are undoubtedly thoughts that he keeps secret, probably because he is ashamed of them. By revealing such secret thoughts, Paul demonstrates the extent of his powers. For this Naib, only the Mahdi, sent by God, can thus know his intimate thoughts.
@@Heating56 Interesting, I thought it meant they were giving their lives for "Green Paradise" because that was the custom to return their water to the pool.
@@Heating56 true, but he didn't speak metaphorically. That Fremen elder really did have such dreams in his sleep, he wasn't just wishing it, and Paul knew it with his superpower, just as he knew the warrior's thoughts and past. This awed the Fremen into submission.
When Paul said i won't deprive myself of the best of us...his father said the same thing in the first movie when his guard wanted to acquit himself for not finding that spy who tried to kill Paul
I just realized the significance of the great worm's appearance at the beginning of this scene: Paul is walking without using the weirding way, he was walking normally - the technique that tends to one swallowed by sandworms. Paul did that, yet the sandworm refused.
In the books the Fremen will ride a worm until it's too tired to go after a person and just dig down into the sand to rest. It was probably just running off after Paul rode it to exhaustion.
“Your mothers warned you about my coming” is so powerful of a quote that I remain in awe. Basically laying down why he is to lead the Freemen: “I’m Fate Made Manifest”. He projected and positioned himself (very much making the best out of that Bene Gesserit propaganda of course) not as a leader but as a force of nature. It’s an intoxicating power… And it’s the scariest trait any person can possess. Literally the stuff monsters are made of. Specially because that power is something the human heart is eager to follow - Not to aspire to possess necessarily, but to aspire to encounter and align with.
Paul is a Kwistaz Haderach... literal "Force of Nature" who can see the Past & all Future possibilities. What Herbert fuck up and made him spazz out in nerd rage to ruin Paul character (like Todd Phillips did in Joker 2 as well) is that Paul IS the promised Messiah... you can't try to tell the story about the dangers of false Messiahs when you have written a true Messiah that is everything he was promised to be.
@criticalbil1 except Paul IS the promised Messiah... the literal manifestation as the Bene Gesserit seeded every one of the million worlds in the Imperium with a culturally tailored religion since the Bene Gesserit didn't know where the Kwizatch Haderach would be born when they started 10,000 years before. It's beyond dumb that Herbert used a real messiah who had achieved apotheosis into godhood... to try to be cautionary tale about fake "messiahs." It's why normal people had the normal human reaction of totally siding with Paul when it was released... it's taken a half century of preaching your Transhumanist Liberal religion to amplify your unnatural position that Paul shouldn't be followed.
as someone explained he is the real messiah of a fake religion. Yes the whole prophecy is fake and yet it was Paul that set the golden path into motion allowing humanity to survive and scatter further into the stars despite the attrocities he and his son commited. So if fate is a real thing in this universe then he really was the one.
@sultankebab1587 can't even call the religion "fake" regardless if it was manufactured since was manufactured for the Kwizatch Haderach that the Bene Gesserit spent 10,000 years trying to manufacture. A feat that the Chief Navigator talked long shit to the Mother Superior for doing as the Navigator Guild had already created their own Kwizatch Haderach thousands of years previously using Spice to do a forced evolution (a much more extreme version of what Paul did to jump the last bit himself to apotheosis as he was supposed to be the mother of the Kwizatch Haderach not the actual Kwizatch Haderach himself) but the Navigator Guild kept their Kwizatch Haderach under containment and almost immediately destroyed him when they realized what a colossal fuck up they did in creating one. Calling the religion fake is very ignorant and shows a deep lack of understanding... since the Bene Gesserit seeded all the million worlds of the Imperium with culture specific religions for their Kwizatch Haderach, they didn't know where it was going to be needed when they start the project 10,000 years previously so they just did it everywhere so that there would be a million prophecies for him to fulfill regardless of which specific one he would need to fulfill. Since Paul is a God who can perceive Linear Space-Time then the religion which teaches that their god is going to arrive is by definition a true religion when their god arrives... the Lisan Al-Gaib (Voice from the Outer Worlds) is there as the foriegn "Voice" to lead them in his vision.
Every scene, shot, moment in this film for me is just perfection. Everything had a purpose, even the little mannerisms and inside jokes had a purpose or made the world feel alive and grounded. This scene, opening scene, gladiator fight, ending fight, work ride, etc. are classics scenes at this point.
I've watched Dune part 1 about 5 times, but like you said, Dune part 2 is just one good non stop scene; I think it is calling to me to watch it for a 10th time. :)
There’s something about the CGI of Dune that just hits different. I’ve seen many movies with more advanced CGI than Dune like Avatar, Endgame but Dune’s CGI looks and feels real.
It's cause they used it the right way. They didn't try to show off the CGI they used it to build a lot of the world and enhance the story but weren't afraid to cover it in sand explosions or dust so that you couldn't really see the art of it. They also used it consistently with the same logic the whole time.
A lot of practical effects were used to enhance environments, especially the lighting
2 місяці тому+5
They used it as good as they did in the Lord of the Rings. Just an add-on to the practical effects and not the main thing. Avatar and Marvel suck at that.
I cannot think of many films in the last 10 years that gave me a scene like this, at this point in the movie, that literally made my draw drop. The acting, the cinematography, the dialogue, the tension... watching it back now and it's still great, but at this point of the film and seeing it in the cinema with the additional surround sound... probably top 3 favourite moments of cinema history for me
Its all girl bosses now, but women just can't radiate the same kind of power and masculinity without looking fake. They managed it in Game of thrones but they also fucked it up later. Its very rare and ironicly was more common in the 90's with characters like Sarah Connor than in the modern times of so many more girl bosses but most just 0 charisma.
@@Andre_APM Just ignore me then, posting on my comments only makes me talk more I'm free to complain about what I don't like, you are free to complain about me complaining
The way he uses the voice to stress parts of his speech is amazing. He emphasises “Lisan al Ghaib” and “Paradise” to really resonate who he is to the Fremen and win their hearts and minds.
in the book it says during this speech he’s using a subtle version of the voice, not complete mind control, but exaggerated influence, hence why his voice sounds deeper during this part.
Jessica wants him to slow down because her Bene Gesserit teachings preach patience and slow manipulation over decades. They need to do things slowly and carefully. Because they can only access the feminine side of their genetic memory, this is all they know. Paul can see what they can't. He can see the exact path he needs to take to get where he needs to be, so he takes it, caution be damned.
It was at this moment, Paul and the Fremen were finally ready to take on the Sardaukar. It was at this moment, they finally surpassed even the Sardaukar’s abilities after years of being hopelessly outmatched and outclassed by them. 😱
Nah. It's visible at the edges they didn't make moving figures. I will do you one better - the ride to battle on the worms later on from the pov of the Saudarkar soldiers.
For me it’s since across the spiderverse 😊not long ago I know but in terms of live action probably since la la land and that’s a top 10 for me of the 2010s.
in fairness, I intentionally believe the internet now belongs to undeveloped brains. That's not meant to be a direct insult. It's your right to be young and undeveloped and enjoy whatever fulfills the egos need to self identify lol. But idk man/woman/whatever-you-need-to-be-called, if across your spider verse is your "oh shit, there really are great movies" moment, then good lord lol.
Love the directing and editing in this scene, how the movement of each shot leads into the next, holding a surprise after every cut, building to Paul's speech which almost feels chaotic at first while all the dramatic threads are fighting to sync up, until the end of the scene when all the main characters have solidified their motivations and positions for the rest of the film as it leads to the climax. This movie better get some oscars.
With respect... I gave Dune Part 2 - 9/10. I thought the movie took liberties with Chani's character, she did not act like this in the book. Also, the politics in the confrontation with the Emperor was far too simplified. The movie did not mention the Guild or CHOAM at all, which, along with the Landsraad, are the three struts on which the entire Imperial system rests, so I was disappointed with Part 2 in that regard. Feyd was built up too much, and other characters like Alia, and the Bene Gesserit Reverend Mother were underplayed too much. But Paul and Jessica's acceptance by the Fremen was masterfully handled, and scenes like these are stupendous, I could watch this scene alone 100 times and still be awed.
@@edhoughton2609my only quarrel with the movie is the portrayal of Chani as a rebellious character that doesn’t understand the prophecy and is against Paul as Lisan al Gaib when in the books she is docile and never questions it! I don’t know why they needed her to be like this in the script. The guild and CHOAM have little relevance in the first book (Dune, Muad’Dib and the prophet) and I can see why Denis didn’t include them as it would take up significant movie space, not including Alia as a living being I think it was smart because it would’ve been a nightmare to have a 4 yo acting like a reverend mother, look at the 1984 adaptation and how that turned out! Having her as a woken up and conscious being in Jessica’s womb was very smart on Denis’s part! Bit sad about Thufir’s disappearance and not portraying him as Harkonnen’s new mentat, also not having count fenring in the movie was a letdown but I understand it would be hard to include everyone in a 2 part, 5 hour long movie
@@alexsenciuc8910 with the greatest respect....I agree with you concerning Chani, but the parasitic Guild is everything and everywhere in Dune, Lynch understood this in the 1984 movie and, it was, in my opinion, a major mistake to omit the Guild from Dune Part 2. Alia should have been present, she is the Abomination, but I can see there are time pressures in having her born and develop as far as the movie is concerned. Yes - Thufir should have been there at the end, I agree. Lady Fenring had sent a secret message, a warning, to Lady Jessica earlier in the book, I did not understand her liaison with Feyd in the movie, other than to test him. It would seem there will be a third movie - perhaps the Guild, along with Princess Irulan and the Bene Tleilax, will be more accurately portrayed.
@@edhoughton2609 I saw the change for Chani is for the audience. They needed her to not want to go along with Paul's plan to telegraph that it's not a good path. It's sad but a lot of people need it literally spelled out for them to understand.
@@edhoughton2609 Indeed your assessment of the Chani character is spot on. I do agree. In the book, she was staunchly supportive of Paul as being the Lisan al Giab. I am hyped to see what the third film will entail. I imagine the Spacing guild and the conflict between Salusa Secundus and the banishment of Emperor Shaddam IV. I won't discuss spoilers, but I can't wait for the next film.
This is such a powerful moment when you think about it. Imagine you’ve been praying your whole life for someone to come and help you, and this one guy comes in breaks your tradition and says he’s gonna lead you into PARADISE and he’s the very thing you’ve been praying for.
Indeed, the scene is quite remarkable. The manner in which he makes his entrance, demonstrating his value, and presenting an enticing vision of paradise to his followers is truly captivating. While it is true that none of us have personally witnessed the arrival of a messiah-like figure in our lifetime, it is plausible that some of those who existed in the past may have possessed a similar level of charisma and allure as the character portrayed by Chalamet. It is evident that Chalamet possesses exceptional acting skills, and his performance in the film makes him a proper Dune.
Yah - I've never gone this overboard for a movie in my life ..... although in the 90's, when for a couple of years I was into cocaine, I think I watched the first Predator movie about a dozen times. :) I'm almost at a dozen times now with Dune 2 , and no stimulants involved. :)
Bought both movies last Friday, I watched the second one 4 times already 🤣 will probably watch them again this weekend. These movies are some of the best I've ever seen, literal cinéma/storytelling orgasm for me 👌🏾
I remember reading this very scene from the book, and I was literally on the edge of my seat from how epic it was. But when I saw the film, I was literally on my hands and knees crying from how insane they knocked this scene out of the park. Chalamet demolished his role as Paul Atreides and in this one scene, he went from being a boy to a man in no time at all. And I kid you not, either it was make-up, CGI, or just a change in his hairstyle, but from the moment he woke up after The Agony, he looked like he aged ten or twenty years in the span of a few days. It wasn't just his voice that became deeper, his whole face and appearance changed. It was like he truly transformed into something in that moment, and we all know what this means for the universe.
Such an amazing scene, Paul completely pacifies a figure the fremen regard as one of their leaders and greatest warriors by seeing him completely. Paul simply reaches out and lays bare his past, present, and the future he prays for. Even though he is supposed to be this monumental being, this prophesized deity, he makes it clear that he see's into each and everyone of the fremen. Just like that he tames an entire society with simple truths.
@@keshavchauhan6290you can like both of them, they are just fictional world, stay chill. I read the 6 Dune books and seen al adaptation. The books are în the most part dull, with some higlights there and there, not as complex and genial as some people say they are. The God-Emperor of Dune...that's the book who I skipped the most, boring AF
That skinny kid played the lead role in The King... that's when I was hooked on his acting ability, he was The King and in Dune he's done the same for me. Not many actors can make you believe and feel like Timothee can.
We're the same, The King is Chalamet's first movie I saw and it convinced me on his acting, that's why I could feel I would love dune and damn did it surpassed all of my expectations
When Quentin Tarantino said he doesn't need to watch this version of Dune. He is wrong! This is the best UA-cam clip of this scene as all the others bypass the beginning.
When I first saw him in the first film I remember thinking "holy moly, could not have casted a a better actor for Paul" same with Javier, he doesnt get as much praise but he embodied stilgar to an absolute T, I can only picture him when I reread the books now
I love that throughout the movie and this scene, whenever anyone else refers to Paul as Lisan Al-Gaib, it leaves it untranslated, but when Paul says it at the end, it translates to Voice from the Outer World. Something about that little detail feels significant!
The interesting thing about this is paul came first and was an inspiration for Anakin. He already has done. Dune is based off of a book that existed way before Star wars.
Why is the audio mix on this clip so weird? The music is dialed way back, barely audible once he enters the conclave. It's such a big part of the overall scene, it's weird to hear it sounding like a bunch of voices recording background murmurs in a sound studio.
Perhaps the most perfect movie scene I've ever scene? It's not about special effects or action, just dialogue and it's measured to all the right beats. I can only remember a couple scenes from The Godfather or Shawshank Redemption that come close to this one.
I took my parents to see this movie bc they each thought they had already seen Part I. Turns out my mom fell asleep 30 mins in and my dad had no idea what Dune was somehow. They were confused as fuck but when this scene came around they were locked tf in. Good shit
It should win more than that. Best actor for Timothée Chalamet, best actress for Rebecca Ferguson, best supporting actor for Austin Butler, best costumes, best editing, best director and why not best picture too? I can't think of another film this year that surpassed this masterpiece.
Mom: Slow down
Paul: *INCITES GALACTIC JIHAD*
Mom After: "Well i mean this was gonna be my second answer though, he he..."
The most underrated comment! 😂😂😂
Galactic Jihad is absolutely fucking wild 💀
part III is exactly that.
lolllllllllllllllllll
Jessica: "Slow down"
Paul: "King Kong ain't got SHIT ON ME"
😂
ai format, are you real
@@incrediblystupid9244 AI trained on me
🤣🤣
this is the best one XD
Bro was shooting Willy fuckin Wonka while doin all this badass shit too. Unreal versatility.
and i mean the guy weighs like 130 pounds soaking wet even after all that chocolate
MY NAME IS WILLY WONKA, FOUNDER OF THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY. I PROMISE YOU CHOCOLATE BEYOND YOUR DREAMS. A CHOCOLATE PARADISE.
@@danielawesome36 HE IS THE KICKSTAND HATRACK!
@@danielawesome36 My lord, the great houses are sending six spoiled children who refuse to acknowledge your ascention. What are your orders?
"GOOD DAY SIR!"
I cant believe people would even question is talent because of his age. This whole speech raises the hairs on my neck.... he is a great actor.
Stilgar:"muaddib, what do you see for us"
Paul: "green paradise"
Fremen: "Password accepted"
Stilgar told Jessica that the Mauddib would turn Dune into a green paradise when they collected enough water.
hahahahaha this is underrated bro 100k likes
@@naritahhamu1192 Paul knew about the terraforming plan long before that (the “I’ve seen your dream” line from part 1)
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
@@naritahhamu1192 tbf he delivers his promise and terraforms Dune into a green paradise.
Slow down...
THERE IS NO ONE IN THIS ROOM THAT CAN STAND AGAINST ME!
an average DotA player entering mid lane
@@stepanserdyuk4589 Truth
LEROOOOOOOOOY JEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENKIIINS
Friends: Slow down
Me drunk: HERE IS NO ONE IN THIS ROOM THAT CAN STAND AGAINST ME!
she underestimates his power and his sight. He doesnt need to slow down he literally is pointing the way.
Jessica: "Slow down . . . "
Muad'Dib: "I'M HIM. I'VE BEEN HIM. I WILL CONTINUE TO BE HIM."
He is Him even in Messiah when *SPOILRRS* he gets banished to the desert.
Mother fucker becomes a legend LITERALLY
lol!!!!
😂😂😂😂 love this
lmfaoo
Paul at the end of Dune Messiah: "idgaf if i go blind, i don't need to see the price tag anyway"
His skinny little scrawny ass conveyed such power. His confidence was true acting genius
It's a pity they downplayed how insanely dangerous Paul is. They mostly only showed him in his role as leader but in the books it was factually true that no one could stand against him. It got to the point that he had killed so many challengers to his rule that Chani killed at least one person who tried to challenge him stating that it would be a waste of his water to spend it killing such a trivial opponent.
Canonically Paul is the most dangerous person on the planet by a considerable margin. He taught all the fremen around him how to fight which itself is ridiculous considering the Fremen were already far more dangerous than the sadukar. In the book during the confrontation with the emperor the emperor commands the empires greatest assassin in all of history (And the last attempt at creating the KH) to kill Paul. The assassin did no fighting, and looks at paul who is exhausted from an invasion injured and poisoned. And concludes it's possible he could kill Paul, but not guaranteed.
This wasn't communicated well in this movie so I hope it gets shown in the next because by the end of the emperors reign he can kill anyone who comes after him. Even his children (Yes he has children in the book) are too dangerous for the sadukar to stop. Capturing his 8 year old cost several lives and she tells the emperor she let herself get captured in the end she could have kept killing them.
Wow that is very terrifying to think about. So I guess in the end, it was always Feyd, the Harkonnens and Sardaukar who were the good ones, while Paul and the Fremen were the evil ones. We can only hope the Great Houses can put a stop to this madness and save the Known Universe in the 3rd installment of the series.
@@MangleZTNAholy shit
@@costco_pizza It's not "good" versus "evil" so much as "be _very_ careful who you follow - cults of personality tend to have very dark end results."
@@MangleZTNA Yeah, the books go much farther into just how dangerous Paul actually is. At this point in the story he _could_ easily kill everyone in that room and that's like multiple thousands of armed Fremen. The amount of power he was radiating with the Voice alone was just absurd.
Jessica: Slow down
Paul: *Slams foot on the gas*
💀💀💀💀
😂😅
HE points the way.
and drives like a MOTHERFUCKER
In the book Paul is using the voice on the Fremen. That could be why in this scene The Lady Jessica whispers slow down. Telling him he’s rushing it
Dear lord possibly the most powerful scene in cinema I have ever seen, and Chalamet just freaking CHEWS UP that dialogue. Incredible.
Man, I do agree. It gives me the chills every time.
Yes you say it right - the power of religious fervour, words delivered with the conviction to move a terrifying people, their Mahdi spoke it well
This went over my head when I saw the film. This scene is mind blowing! The reactions of everyone realizing he is the one.
I would say ride of the rohirrim in return just inches this one over. Excellent nevertheless
It's powerful, but honestly I think the surrender of Jerusalem in Kingdom of Heaven was more so.
Gurney is like a ronin of ancient Japan, when he saw his master's ring once more in Paul's hand you can tell from the facial expression he doesn't consider himself a masterless ronin anymore but a samurai warrior ready to defend his master and house again. Josh Brolin did great in this role!
I know Chani was changed for cinema from the books to be more of a voice of reason to Paul's jihad, which I like since you don't get as much subtext from the character's inner monologues. But even like you said, Gurney being loyal stopping Chani from challenging paul is a huge moment. If he didn't stop her, and she challenged them right there, I don't think he would have been able to kill her in a duel.
@@edwinmoy1402 His tears of pride when Paul puts on the Atreides signet ring 💪 He knows that Duke Leto and all his brothers in arms will finally be avenged.
@@edwinmoy1402 Yes, he did 👍.
@@pataflafla-patapaul never kills chani?
Fills me with pride and anger tho I know it is fiction but it came from a man who face blood and destruction
Me: *charismatic leaders got nothing on me
*Paul delivers his speech
Me: *galactic Jihad it is
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
My wife almost hopped out of our seats in the theater, this scene was so well done, just as good if not better than the speech Paul gives to the emperor in the original dune movie.
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
I swear everyone in the cinemas would have marched into that galactic jihad. I had my hands up with them as they were shouting lisan al gaib. 😆
Me: "I simply would not be swayed by a charismatic messiah figure."
Paul: *exists*
Me: "I may have been too hasty."
That squat down by Paul to make the dude think Paul is on his level, then the rise up by Paul as he continues talking to let the dude know he has no real chance of beating Paul is good directing.
It’s also very similar to the crouched position (waiting in ambush, ready to pounce) that we see from several of the Fremen in the first part when Paul first encounters them in the desert. Not only is your assessment correct, but it also shows Paul using the Fremen’s own body language to convey a point.
It's how you might talk to a small child, not an equal. Brilliant little detail
kinda like he can see what is going to happen huh?
"The hand of god be my witness, i am the voice from the outer world" god dam this part always gives me goosebumps
Long live the warriors
*damn
This is one of the greatest lines because the "hand of god" references the claw-print on the moon of Arrakis and the smaller moon is known as "Muad Dib" as well. Paul is hitting all the skill checks in charisma by referencing some of the most iconic symbols of their religion.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 the Fighters!#
Paul's prescience is a result of genetic engineering, training, and spice consumption, not divine intervention. He is aware that his role as a prophet is partly a construct, and he struggles with the moral implications of using it to wield power.
Paul is a deeply conflicted figure who understands the dangers of messianic leadership. His story explores themes of manipulation, destiny, and the unforeseen consequences of fulfilling prophecy, making him a "prophet" in a complex and ambiguous sense.
"Messiahs and charismatic leaders are a walking disaster for any culture... but sometimes they do look REALLY fucking cool." -Frank Herbert, probably
There's a lot of "beware of who you choose as your leader" throughout Herbert's writings...
@@OddlyIncredible That's actually a good paraphrase of what Frank Herbert said:
“I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health." One of the most dangerous presidents we had in this century was John Kennedy because people said "Yes Sir Mr. Charismatic Leader what do we do next?" and we wound up in Vietnam. And I think probably the most valuable president of this century was Richard Nixon. Because he taught us to distrust government and he did it by example.”
@@georgeghleung And now I look to the new US president and how people react to him if they "believe" in him ... think about that.
Trump just proved that.
@@coronastern BINGO
Jessica: "Slow down"
Paul: starts biggest war in human history
That was Paul’s son.
@@jonathanstone4878 Didn't Leto II only rule like a tyrant? I feel like the whole war aspect was more attributed to Paul than it was Leto.
@@jonathanstone4878 Leto didn’t start a war tho. He ruled the galaxy as a tyrant for thousands of years. There were probably some small rebellions here and there, but there was literally no power in the universe capable of standing against him, let alone waging war.
Paul's Jihad tho, per wiki, "caused 61 billion casualties, the sterilization of ninety planets, the demoralization of five hundred additional worlds, and the eradication of forty different religions along with their followers. Ten thousand worlds were subsumed into his new Empire."
@@severussnapeus3607 The books state that he surpassed his father by a large margin as it involved every planet in the imperium. He also rationed Spice which shortened almost every regular citizen's life. It's WAY beyond 61 billion.
@@realspiderman-u6g according to lore, Leto 2 caused measurably more death due to famine and rationing or removal of Spice (Spice extends life). Paul only had a couple of decades while Leto had more than 3,000 to amass his record. No number is given afaik but it is said to have dwarfed Pauls.
Jessica: "Paul, slow down."
Paul: "MY MOM SAYS IT'S A SHOW DOWN!"
Underrated comment
hahahahhahahaha
I burst out laughing🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
:) A lot of wars have been started by misunderstandings I'm sure.
😂😂😂
“In your nightmares, you give water to the dead. And it brings joy to your heart!”
Honestly one of my favorite lines ever
@ in the culture of the Fremen it is effectively a sin to give water to the dead. The dead are drained of their water because they have no use for it.
The notion of “giving water to the dead” is their way of saying “weeping for the dead”, which is a sort of taboo in the desert as it wastes precious water.
He’s effectively calling the priests out on this, saying that it’s their secret desire to live in a world where they can freely mourn their dead, thus he offers to bring them “Green Paradise”, a terraformed Arrakis where water is abundant.
He’s basically using their deepest hidden desires to encourage them to follow him
@@Heating56 he's talkin about crying for the dead, Chani wiped away a tear once in the first movie. Paul simply sees that the Naib he is talking to is crying tears over the death of the people he loved in his dreams and that this gives him relief. But these are undoubtedly thoughts that he keeps secret, probably because he is ashamed of them. By revealing such secret thoughts, Paul demonstrates the extent of his powers. For this Naib, only the Mahdi, sent by God, can thus know his intimate thoughts.
@@Heating56 Nice analysis
@@Heating56 Interesting, I thought it meant they were giving their lives for "Green Paradise" because that was the custom to return their water to the pool.
@@Heating56 true, but he didn't speak metaphorically. That Fremen elder really did have such dreams in his sleep, he wasn't just wishing it, and Paul knew it with his superpower, just as he knew the warrior's thoughts and past. This awed the Fremen into submission.
When Paul said i won't deprive myself of the best of us...his father said the same thing in the first movie when his guard wanted to acquit himself for not finding that spy who tried to kill Paul
*mentat. Thufir Hawat wasn't just a guard. He was basically the Atreides' supercomputer.
@Leonidas04052 i know. I couldn't remember his actual name at the time 😂
Holy crap great detail
I didn't clock that. Awesome spot.
Thanks for pointing this out, it adds even more depth to an already deep and super well done scene!
if you listen to the last few words, you can hear Paul is using the Voice on everyone in that room
HOLY COW. I re-watched it and you're right.
That's crazy detail.
That’s also why it pans to Rebecca when he starts talking in the voice 🙏
You sure it's not just the echo of the room?
in the book, the entire speech was done in the voice, so it was a nice detail to have in the film.
Why didn’t it seem to affect Chani then?
I just realized the significance of the great worm's appearance at the beginning of this scene: Paul is walking without using the weirding way, he was walking normally - the technique that tends to one swallowed by sandworms.
Paul did that, yet the sandworm refused.
I always assumed he just rode that worm like an Uber and hopped off
Yo like Shai hulud actually understood and recognized that he is the Lisan al gaib
I never realized that before! I just thought it was meant to add to the coolness of the scene. I guess my artistic analysis skilled failed there.
Or it wasn't worm territory
In the books the Fremen will ride a worm until it's too tired to go after a person and just dig down into the sand to rest. It was probably just running off after Paul rode it to exhaustion.
“Your mothers warned you about my coming” is so powerful of a quote that I remain in awe. Basically laying down why he is to lead the Freemen: “I’m Fate Made Manifest”. He projected and positioned himself (very much making the best out of that Bene Gesserit propaganda of course) not as a leader but as a force of nature.
It’s an intoxicating power… And it’s the scariest trait any person can possess. Literally the stuff monsters are made of. Specially because that power is something the human heart is eager to follow - Not to aspire to possess necessarily, but to aspire to encounter and align with.
Paul is a Kwistaz Haderach... literal "Force of Nature" who can see the Past & all Future possibilities. What Herbert fuck up and made him spazz out in nerd rage to ruin Paul character (like Todd Phillips did in Joker 2 as well) is that Paul IS the promised Messiah... you can't try to tell the story about the dangers of false Messiahs when you have written a true Messiah that is everything he was promised to be.
Indeed. We should be wary, even amid intoxication.
@criticalbil1 except Paul IS the promised Messiah... the literal manifestation as the Bene Gesserit seeded every one of the million worlds in the Imperium with a culturally tailored religion since the Bene Gesserit didn't know where the Kwizatch Haderach would be born when they started 10,000 years before. It's beyond dumb that Herbert used a real messiah who had achieved apotheosis into godhood... to try to be cautionary tale about fake "messiahs." It's why normal people had the normal human reaction of totally siding with Paul when it was released... it's taken a half century of preaching your Transhumanist Liberal religion to amplify your unnatural position that Paul shouldn't be followed.
as someone explained he is the real messiah of a fake religion.
Yes the whole prophecy is fake and yet it was Paul that set the golden path into motion allowing humanity to survive and scatter further into the stars despite the attrocities he and his son commited.
So if fate is a real thing in this universe then he really was the one.
@sultankebab1587 can't even call the religion "fake" regardless if it was manufactured since was manufactured for the Kwizatch Haderach that the Bene Gesserit spent 10,000 years trying to manufacture. A feat that the Chief Navigator talked long shit to the Mother Superior for doing as the Navigator Guild had already created their own Kwizatch Haderach thousands of years previously using Spice to do a forced evolution (a much more extreme version of what Paul did to jump the last bit himself to apotheosis as he was supposed to be the mother of the Kwizatch Haderach not the actual Kwizatch Haderach himself) but the Navigator Guild kept their Kwizatch Haderach under containment and almost immediately destroyed him when they realized what a colossal fuck up they did in creating one.
Calling the religion fake is very ignorant and shows a deep lack of understanding... since the Bene Gesserit seeded all the million worlds of the Imperium with culture specific religions for their Kwizatch Haderach, they didn't know where it was going to be needed when they start the project 10,000 years previously so they just did it everywhere so that there would be a million prophecies for him to fulfill regardless of which specific one he would need to fulfill. Since Paul is a God who can perceive Linear Space-Time then the religion which teaches that their god is going to arrive is by definition a true religion when their god arrives... the Lisan Al-Gaib (Voice from the Outer Worlds) is there as the foriegn "Voice" to lead them in his vision.
Every scene, shot, moment in this film for me is just perfection. Everything had a purpose, even the little mannerisms and inside jokes had a purpose or made the world feel alive and grounded. This scene, opening scene, gladiator fight, ending fight, work ride, etc. are classics scenes at this point.
I definitely see what you mean. It doesn't feel like a single moment of the movie was wasted or padded.
Tarantino doesn't know what he's missing! 😂
I've watched Dune part 1 about 5 times, but like you said, Dune part 2 is just one good non stop scene; I think it is calling to me to watch it for a 10th time. :)
This isn't new. Every Villeneuve's movie isl Ike this.
Almost, the chani scenes were anti book and ruined many moments.
There’s something about the CGI of Dune that just hits different. I’ve seen many movies with more advanced CGI than Dune like Avatar, Endgame but Dune’s CGI looks and feels real.
It's cause they used it the right way. They didn't try to show off the CGI they used it to build a lot of the world and enhance the story but weren't afraid to cover it in sand explosions or dust so that you couldn't really see the art of it. They also used it consistently with the same logic the whole time.
Well Avatar also looks super good, but i know what u mean. dune is just one of he best movies for me
A lot of practical effects were used to enhance environments, especially the lighting
They used it as good as they did in the Lord of the Rings. Just an add-on to the practical effects and not the main thing. Avatar and Marvel suck at that.
Its the lighting ... always has been with villeneuve. Simple things like Explosions casting shadows. Those make the biggest difference.
Just fyi this movie cost the same as Joker 2. I am not even kidding.
Wow... Wikipedia lists both as 190 mil $ budget. That's a crazy high number for Joker 2.
And joker 2 is a steamy pile of excrement compared to Dune 2.
@@KonaLife You got that right . . .
Wtf...
@@KonaLife copared to Freddy got fingered its still shit
0:07 If i saw a man , walked with normal steps in a worm territory , he's definitely the messiah
The cinematography alone is breath taking
3:16 me asserting dominance at my court ordered anger management course
LOL
I barked aloud at work
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
I cannot think of many films in the last 10 years that gave me a scene like this, at this point in the movie, that literally made my draw drop. The acting, the cinematography, the dialogue, the tension... watching it back now and it's still great, but at this point of the film and seeing it in the cinema with the additional surround sound... probably top 3 favourite moments of cinema history for me
Its all girl bosses now, but women just can't radiate the same kind of power and masculinity without looking fake. They managed it in Game of thrones but they also fucked it up later. Its very rare and ironicly was more common in the 90's with characters like Sarah Connor than in the modern times of so many more girl bosses but most just 0 charisma.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 So women just can't do something, except when they can? Lol
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 Because they try to do it out of fake feminism and not genuine love for the role they are playing i think
@mcmarkmarkson7115 Can the rest of us just enjoy this movie without you needing to complain?
@@Andre_APM Just ignore me then, posting on my comments only makes me talk more
I'm free to complain about what I don't like, you are free to complain about me complaining
"You think I'm stupid enough to deprive myself of the best of us?
Do you smash a knife before battle?"
The way he uses the voice to stress parts of his speech is amazing. He emphasises “Lisan al Ghaib” and “Paradise” to really resonate who he is to the Fremen and win their hearts and minds.
He just emphasizes Or is he using his Voice over the people ?
in the book it says during this speech he’s using a subtle version of the voice, not complete mind control, but exaggerated influence, hence why his voice sounds deeper during this part.
5:23“This is my Father's Ducal Signet”, his voice here is soooooooooooooooooooo heavy and beautiful.
Dune 2 was a masterpiece, best film adaptation by far
Yea, after Lord of the rings
Maybe since the Return of the King, I haven't felt scenes that moved me so much.
Oh and don’t forget The Ringer of Power!
@@tylermcnair4921 sure sure hahaha
this is not like the book
How can such a voice rise from one so small as he? Chalamet owned this scene.
he is actually very tall, he is just skinny
@@lauraalves001no, he only 5"10 (175cm) which is not that tall
@@DivineApparition well i am 5ft 11 and I am quite tall ;)
@@DivineApparitionHe's almost 5 11 which is179-180 cm. Noway he's 175. And yah. He's taller than Zendaya.
@@DivineApparition Average height worldwide is 5'8" so he is, in fact, tall.
One of the greatest movie scenes of all time it cannot be denied
Jessica wants him to slow down because her Bene Gesserit teachings preach patience and slow manipulation over decades. They need to do things slowly and carefully. Because they can only access the feminine side of their genetic memory, this is all they know.
Paul can see what they can't. He can see the exact path he needs to take to get where he needs to be, so he takes it, caution be damned.
thats sick
Men are brave.
The Bene Gesserit will wait for the ice to thaw, but Paul, Duke of House Atreides, mentat, Kwisatz Haderach, and the Lisan al-Gaib, will smash the ice
bro literally speedrunning the Fremen
No need for caution when you know for a fact that you're right
This is the best version of this speech. Especially with the chokasba added. Chamlate WAS PAUL
0:45 That might be the best shot in the entire movie.
Hands down, in terms of cinematic beauty, one of the best ever
I dare say one of the best. But still, I hope someone can do better. It was too brown and too quick.
But it's not!
It was at this moment, Paul and the Fremen were finally ready to take on the Sardaukar. It was at this moment, they finally surpassed even the Sardaukar’s abilities after years of being hopelessly outmatched and outclassed by them. 😱
Nah. It's visible at the edges they didn't make moving figures.
I will do you one better - the ride to battle on the worms later on from the pov of the Saudarkar soldiers.
Best movie I've seen since Interstellar and Inception, 10/10.
For me it’s since across the spiderverse 😊not long ago I know but in terms of live action probably since la la land and that’s a top 10 for me of the 2010s.
That's for damn sure!
Also Arrival
@@Afr095 lmfao the times we live in.. Despite the beautiful animation and good voice acting, what tf are you actually on about? lol
in fairness, I intentionally believe the internet now belongs to undeveloped brains. That's not meant to be a direct insult. It's your right to be young and undeveloped and enjoy whatever fulfills the egos need to self identify lol. But idk man/woman/whatever-you-need-to-be-called, if across your spider verse is your "oh shit, there really are great movies" moment, then good lord lol.
Gives me chills every time I watch it.
long live the fighters!
@@jforozco12 Ya hya chouhada!
Easily the best moment in both films. I wasn't sure on Chalamet until this moment and it changed everything.
"It is the only way"
"I'M POINTING THE WAY!!!"
Chills, literal chills
Whenever someone is pissing me off, I tell them "Im about to return your water to the well"
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
Love the directing and editing in this scene, how the movement of each shot leads into the next, holding a surprise after every cut, building to Paul's speech which almost feels chaotic at first while all the dramatic threads are fighting to sync up, until the end of the scene when all the main characters have solidified their motivations and positions for the rest of the film as it leads to the climax. This movie better get some oscars.
Beast. This movie was 10/10 Masterpiece.
With respect... I gave Dune Part 2 - 9/10. I thought the movie took liberties with Chani's character, she did not act like this in the book. Also, the politics in the confrontation with the Emperor was far too simplified. The movie did not mention the Guild or CHOAM at all, which, along with the Landsraad, are the three struts on which the entire Imperial system rests, so I was disappointed with Part 2 in that regard.
Feyd was built up too much, and other characters like Alia, and the Bene Gesserit Reverend Mother were underplayed too much.
But Paul and Jessica's acceptance by the Fremen was masterfully handled, and scenes like these are stupendous, I could watch this scene alone 100 times and still be awed.
@@edhoughton2609my only quarrel with the movie is the portrayal of Chani as a rebellious character that doesn’t understand the prophecy and is against Paul as Lisan al Gaib when in the books she is docile and never questions it! I don’t know why they needed her to be like this in the script. The guild and CHOAM have little relevance in the first book (Dune, Muad’Dib and the prophet) and I can see why Denis didn’t include them as it would take up significant movie space, not including Alia as a living being I think it was smart because it would’ve been a nightmare to have a 4 yo acting like a reverend mother, look at the 1984 adaptation and how that turned out! Having her as a woken up and conscious being in Jessica’s womb was very smart on Denis’s part! Bit sad about Thufir’s disappearance and not portraying him as Harkonnen’s new mentat, also not having count fenring in the movie was a letdown but I understand it would be hard to include everyone in a 2 part, 5 hour long movie
@@alexsenciuc8910 with the greatest respect....I agree with you concerning Chani, but the parasitic Guild is everything and everywhere in Dune, Lynch understood this in the 1984 movie and, it was, in my opinion, a major mistake to omit the Guild from Dune Part 2. Alia should have been present, she is the Abomination, but I can see there are time pressures in having her born and develop as far as the movie is concerned. Yes - Thufir should have been there at the end, I agree. Lady Fenring had sent a secret message, a warning, to Lady Jessica earlier in the book, I did not understand her liaison with Feyd in the movie, other than to test him.
It would seem there will be a third movie - perhaps the Guild, along with Princess Irulan and the Bene Tleilax, will be more accurately portrayed.
@@edhoughton2609 I saw the change for Chani is for the audience. They needed her to not want to go along with Paul's plan to telegraph that it's not a good path. It's sad but a lot of people need it literally spelled out for them to understand.
@@edhoughton2609 Indeed your assessment of the Chani character is spot on. I do agree. In the book, she was staunchly supportive of Paul as being the Lisan al Giab. I am hyped to see what the third film will entail. I imagine the Spacing guild and the conflict between Salusa Secundus and the banishment of Emperor Shaddam IV. I won't discuss spoilers, but I can't wait for the next film.
This is such a powerful moment when you think about it. Imagine you’ve been praying your whole life for someone to come and help you, and this one guy comes in breaks your tradition and says he’s gonna lead you into PARADISE and he’s the very thing you’ve been praying for.
*and what if he actually brings you there? I charge of a country that was taken away from you?
I mean you’re describing Jesus Christ. That’s exactly what he did
@@dcparadise3401 I don't recall Jesus personally leading a holy war
@@djhuckfield His was more of a spiritual war, thankfully. If he'd rode to battle with 10000 angels, Earth would be nothing but dust.
Watched this scene more than 20 times, don't know why??
It keeps getting better
On my 13th time right now.
Because masculinity was more or less banned in Hollywood.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115true
Because the hardest coldest dialogue of all time.
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
the music in the dunes movies. Just perfect. The best movies since LOTR imo.
Indeed, the scene is quite remarkable. The manner in which he makes his entrance, demonstrating his value, and presenting an enticing vision of paradise to his followers is truly captivating. While it is true that none of us have personally witnessed the arrival of a messiah-like figure in our lifetime, it is plausible that some of those who existed in the past may have possessed a similar level of charisma and allure as the character portrayed by Chalamet. It is evident that Chalamet possesses exceptional acting skills, and his performance in the film makes him a proper Dune.
''none of us'' huh
Still the best movie of the year. One of the best theatre experiences I’ve ever had.
“In your nightmares you give water to the dead and it brings joy to your heart!!!”
Men, I've watched part 2 so many times, loved it from start to finish. Long live the fighters.
Yah - I've never gone this overboard for a movie in my life ..... although in the 90's, when for a couple of years I was into cocaine, I think I watched the first Predator movie about a dozen times. :) I'm almost at a dozen times now with Dune 2 , and no stimulants involved. :)
Same never in my life have a rewatched a movie so many times. At least 30 times now. Flawless
Bought both movies last Friday, I watched the second one 4 times already 🤣 will probably watch them again this weekend. These movies are some of the best I've ever seen, literal cinéma/storytelling orgasm for me 👌🏾
So far I have seen three of Timothee’s movies and he is superb in all of them
I remember reading this very scene from the book, and I was literally on the edge of my seat from how epic it was. But when I saw the film, I was literally on my hands and knees crying from how insane they knocked this scene out of the park. Chalamet demolished his role as Paul Atreides and in this one scene, he went from being a boy to a man in no time at all. And I kid you not, either it was make-up, CGI, or just a change in his hairstyle, but from the moment he woke up after The Agony, he looked like he aged ten or twenty years in the span of a few days. It wasn't just his voice that became deeper, his whole face and appearance changed. It was like he truly transformed into something in that moment, and we all know what this means for the universe.
I also saw that change in him! I think its amix of the hair and Timothéé's expresion.
“Your mothers warned you about my coming,” is the coldest hardest line of all time.
Not surprised it’s in the greatest film of all time.
Such an amazing scene, Paul completely pacifies a figure the fremen regard as one of their leaders and greatest warriors by seeing him completely. Paul simply reaches out and lays bare his past, present, and the future he prays for. Even though he is supposed to be this monumental being, this prophesized deity, he makes it clear that he see's into each and everyone of the fremen. Just like that he tames an entire society with simple truths.
My favorite scene of the entire year. I've watched it maybe 100 times by now. Just incredible.
00:10 the Mahdi comes from the desert, with Shai-Hulud behind, even a terrifying race like the Fremen gave him respect and allowed him through
This is by far better than Star Wars and marvel
Of course lol, it’s a no brainer
How can you compare star wars to this?
Fuck Marvel but the initial two star wars at least compare equal to this movie. Considering the times.
@@keshavchauhan6290 how could you not? They’re both intergalactic franchises 😂
@@keshavchauhan6290you can like both of them, they are just fictional world, stay chill. I read the 6 Dune books and seen al adaptation. The books are în the most part dull, with some higlights there and there, not as complex and genial as some people say they are. The God-Emperor of Dune...that's the book who I skipped the most, boring AF
In IMAX with booming bass this scene was incredible.
Holy shit, Timothée, what a performance! He had me ready to go wipe out Harkonnens with that speech, and they're fictional . . .
so cay
"echoes in eternity"
That's because you're a follower and easily manipulated
I don't think any other scene in the history of cinematography gave me so much constant goosebumps.
3:16 when you’re 8 beers deep at Chili’s.
If Chalamaladingdong gets nominated for Best Actor, they should use this clip starting at 5:18.
😂😂😂haha
Exactly the worst part of this whole video
Lisan Al-Ghaib!
That skinny kid played the lead role in The King... that's when I was hooked on his acting ability, he was The King and in Dune he's done the same for me. Not many actors can make you believe and feel like Timothee can.
We're the same, The King is Chalamet's first movie I saw and it convinced me on his acting, that's why I could feel I would love dune and damn did it surpassed all of my expectations
"In your nightmares you give water to the dead and it brings joy to your heart"....icing on the already frosted cake
Jessica: *Slow down.*
Paul: “We’re reshaping the universe brick by brick.”
I remember when I read this part in Dune, They definitely did it justice
bro tihis scene in the cinema got me like ˇ" m' kay bro where is my kris knife i sign up for the fedaykins"
1:50 That is some SpongeBob style snatching.
This movie was 10/10 to see in Imax
When Quentin Tarantino said he doesn't need to watch this version of Dune. He is wrong!
This is the best UA-cam clip of this scene as all the others bypass the beginning.
Stop giving the foot sniffer any more importance by mentioning him.
It's just jealousy
It’s incredible how Paul resembles to Timothy Chalamet
When I first saw him in the first film I remember thinking "holy moly, could not have casted a a better actor for Paul" same with Javier, he doesnt get as much praise but he embodied stilgar to an absolute T, I can only picture him when I reread the books now
This is the scene that made me believe Timothy Chalamet was indeed a great actor
When he yells Hand of God be my witness. My godddd I still get chills.
He doesn't steal the scene, he creates the scene.
Something you can truly call peak cinema, without being hyperbolic.
Zhoniin what are you doing here?!
Jessica: Slow down...
Paul: I mix Coca Cola with Pepsi!
"AND I DRINK IT FROM A DR PEPPER BOTTLE!!!"
Abomination.
I love that throughout the movie and this scene, whenever anyone else refers to Paul as Lisan Al-Gaib, it leaves it untranslated, but when Paul says it at the end, it translates to Voice from the Outer World. Something about that little detail feels significant!
Paul giving off big “Anakin marches on the Jedi Temple” vibes.
You just know something awful is about to happen.
The interesting thing about this is paul came first and was an inspiration for Anakin. He already has done. Dune is based off of a book that existed way before Star wars.
I feel like he imbued his voice with the Voice to give it more power and influence
Chills when he puts on the ring. CHILLS.
Why is the audio mix on this clip so weird? The music is dialed way back, barely audible once he enters the conclave. It's such a big part of the overall scene, it's weird to hear it sounding like a bunch of voices recording background murmurs in a sound studio.
Two words: copyright.
WTF DID THEY DO?? I kept thinking this doesn't even come close to the original!!
Yup, the real scene is way better
This is the best scene in Dune and Chalamet is a great actor
I just noticed she started yelling right next to Gurney! How convenient! I Love this movie though lol
They know each other.
This is the most EPIC scene EVER
Mom: slow down
Paul: THROW DOWN? AIGHT, BET!!
Perhaps the most perfect movie scene I've ever scene? It's not about special effects or action, just dialogue and it's measured to all the right beats. I can only remember a couple scenes from The Godfather or Shawshank Redemption that come close to this one.
“Beware of heroes.” - Frank Herbert
-how many times have you watched this scene?
-YES
Jessica: "slow down"
Paul "Are you not entertain???"
4:39 he said! He said the name of the movie !
It's Duning time
That build up,that acting,that music 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
“Your mothers warned you about me”. Sun glasses, solo guitar
Jessica: 'slow down' ....a subliminal instruction to Paul as she tries to influence him further. Utterly brilliant scene.
This is my favorite scene... so far in the Dune Saga
4:15 the way the Fremen warrior's face went from anger to confusion to reverence before fully submitting to Paul!
I took my parents to see this movie bc they each thought they had already seen Part I. Turns out my mom fell asleep 30 mins in and my dad had no idea what Dune was somehow. They were confused as fuck but when this scene came around they were locked tf in. Good shit
one of the new generations best actors glad to see him grow and improve so quickly
If this movie doesn't win the best vfx, cinematography, soundtrack and best sound at next year's Oscars then the Oscars is not worth watching 😅✌️
It should win more than that. Best actor for Timothée Chalamet, best actress for Rebecca Ferguson, best supporting actor for Austin Butler, best costumes, best editing, best director and why not best picture too? I can't think of another film this year that surpassed this masterpiece.
one of the illest acting jobs of all time - his voice COMMANDED that scene goose bumps