@@danielawesome36 My lord, the great houses are sending six spoiled children who refuse to acknowledge your ascention. What are your orders? "GOOD DAY SIR!"
Gurney is like a ronin of ancient Japan, when he saw his master's ring once more in Paul's hand you can tell from the facial expression he doesn't consider himself a masterless ronin anymore but a samurai warrior ready to defend his master and house again. Josh Brolin did great in this role!
I know Chani was changed for cinema from the books to be more of a voice of reason to Paul's jihad, which I like since you don't get as much subtext from the character's inner monologues. But even like you said, Gurney being loyal stopping Chani from challenging paul is a huge moment. If he didn't stop her, and she challenged them right there, I don't think he would have been able to kill her in a duel.
@@edwinmoy1402 His tears of pride when Paul puts on the Atreides signet ring 💪 He knows that Duke Leto and all his brothers in arms will finally be avenged.
@@OddlyIncredible That's actually a good paraphrase of what Frank Herbert said: “I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health." One of the most dangerous presidents we had in this century was John Kennedy because people said "Yes Sir Mr. Charismatic Leader what do we do next?" and we wound up in Vietnam. And I think probably the most valuable president of this century was Richard Nixon. Because he taught us to distrust government and he did it by example.”
It's a pity they downplayed how insanely dangerous Paul is. They mostly only showed him in his role as leader but in the books it was factually true that no one could stand against him. It got to the point that he had killed so many challengers to his rule that Chani killed at least one person who tried to challenge him stating that it would be a waste of his water to spend it killing such a trivial opponent. Canonically Paul is the most dangerous person on the planet by a considerable margin. He taught all the fremen around him how to fight which itself is ridiculous considering the Fremen were already far more dangerous than the sadukar. In the book during the confrontation with the emperor the emperor commands the empires greatest assassin in all of history (And the last attempt at creating the KH) to kill Paul. The assassin did no fighting, and looks at paul who is exhausted from an invasion injured and poisoned. And concludes it's possible he could kill Paul, but not guaranteed. This wasn't communicated well in this movie so I hope it gets shown in the next because by the end of the emperors reign he can kill anyone who comes after him. Even his children (Yes he has children in the book) are too dangerous for the sadukar to stop. Capturing his 8 year old cost several lives and she tells the emperor she let herself get captured in the end she could have kept killing them.
Wow that is very terrifying to think about. So I guess in the end, it was always Feyd, the Harkonnens and Sardaukar who were the good ones, while Paul and the Fremen were the evil ones. We can only hope the Great Houses can put a stop to this madness and save the Known Universe in the 3rd installment of the series.
@@MangleZTNA Yeah, the books go much farther into just how dangerous Paul actually is. At this point in the story he _could_ easily kill everyone in that room and that's like multiple thousands of armed Fremen. The amount of power he was radiating with the Voice alone was just absurd.
Every scene, shot, moment in this film for me is just perfection. Everything had a purpose, even the little mannerisms and inside jokes had a purpose or made the world feel alive and grounded. This scene, opening scene, gladiator fight, ending fight, work ride, etc. are classics scenes at this point.
I've watched Dune part 1 about 5 times, but like you said, Dune part 2 is just one good non stop scene; I think it is calling to me to watch it for a 10th time. :)
That squat down by Paul to make the dude think Paul is on his level, then the rise up by Paul as he continues talking to let the dude know he has no real chance of beating Paul is good directing.
I cannot think of many films in the last 10 years that gave me a scene like this, at this point in the movie, that literally made my draw drop. The acting, the cinematography, the dialogue, the tension... watching it back now and it's still great, but at this point of the film and seeing it in the cinema with the additional surround sound... probably top 3 favourite moments of cinema history for me
Its all girl bosses now, but women just can't radiate the same kind of power and masculinity without looking fake. They managed it in Game of thrones but they also fucked it up later. Its very rare and ironicly was more common in the 90's with characters like Sarah Connor than in the modern times of so many more girl bosses but most just 0 charisma.
Jessica wants him to slow down because her Bene Gesserit teachings preach patience and slow manipulation over decades. They need to do things slowly and carefully. Because they can only access the feminine side of their genetic memory, this is all they know. Paul can see what they can't. He can see the exact path he needs to take to get where he needs to be, so he takes it, caution be damned.
There’s something about the CGI of Dune that just hits different. I’ve seen many movies with more advanced CGI than Dune like Avatar, Endgame but Dune’s CGI looks and feels real.
It's cause they used it the right way. They didn't try to show off the CGI they used it to build a lot of the world and enhance the story but weren't afraid to cover it in sand explosions or dust so that you couldn't really see the art of it. They also used it consistently with the same logic the whole time.
A lot of practical effects were used to enhance environments, especially the lighting
10 днів тому
They used it as good as they did in the Lord of the Rings. Just an add-on to the practical effects and not the main thing. Avatar and Marvel suck at that.
For me it’s since across the spiderverse 😊not long ago I know but in terms of live action probably since la la land and that’s a top 10 for me of the 2010s.
in fairness, I intentionally believe the internet now belongs to undeveloped brains. That's not meant to be a direct insult. It's your right to be young and undeveloped and enjoy whatever fulfills the egos need to self identify lol. But idk man/woman/whatever-you-need-to-be-called, if across your spider verse is your "oh shit, there really are great movies" moment, then good lord lol.
Love the directing and editing in this scene, how the movement of each shot leads into the next, holding a surprise after every cut, building to Paul's speech which almost feels chaotic at first while all the dramatic threads are fighting to sync up, until the end of the scene when all the main characters have solidified their motivations and positions for the rest of the film as it leads to the climax. This movie better get some oscars.
Yah - I've never gone this overboard for a movie in my life ..... although in the 90's, when for a couple of years I was into cocaine, I think I watched the first Predator movie about a dozen times. :) I'm almost at a dozen times now with Dune 2 , and no stimulants involved. :)
@@keshavchauhan6290you can like both of them, they are just fictional world, stay chill. I read the 6 Dune books and seen al adaptation. The books are în the most part dull, with some higlights there and there, not as complex and genial as some people say they are. The God-Emperor of Dune...that's the book who I skipped the most, boring AF
When Paul said i won't deprive myself of the best of us...his father said the same thing in the first movie when his guard wanted to acquit himself for not finding that spy who tried to kill Paul
With respect... I gave Dune Part 2 - 9/10. I thought the movie took liberties with Chani's character, she did not act like this in the book. Also, the politics in the confrontation with the Emperor was far too simplified. The movie did not mention the Guild or CHOAM at all, which, along with the Landsraad, are the three struts on which the entire Imperial system rests, so I was disappointed with Part 2 in that regard. Feyd was built up too much, and other characters like Alia, and the Bene Gesserit Reverend Mother were underplayed too much. But Paul and Jessica's acceptance by the Fremen was masterfully handled, and scenes like these are stupendous, I could watch this scene alone 100 times and still be awed.
@@edhoughton2609my only quarrel with the movie is the portrayal of Chani as a rebellious character that doesn’t understand the prophecy and is against Paul as Lisan al Gaib when in the books she is docile and never questions it! I don’t know why they needed her to be like this in the script. The guild and CHOAM have little relevance in the first book (Dune, Muad’Dib and the prophet) and I can see why Denis didn’t include them as it would take up significant movie space, not including Alia as a living being I think it was smart because it would’ve been a nightmare to have a 4 yo acting like a reverend mother, look at the 1984 adaptation and how that turned out! Having her as a woken up and conscious being in Jessica’s womb was very smart on Denis’s part! Bit sad about Thufir’s disappearance and not portraying him as Harkonnen’s new mentat, also not having count fenring in the movie was a letdown but I understand it would be hard to include everyone in a 2 part, 5 hour long movie
@@alexsenciuc8910 with the greatest respect....I agree with you concerning Chani, but the parasitic Guild is everything and everywhere in Dune, Lynch understood this in the 1984 movie and, it was, in my opinion, a major mistake to omit the Guild from Dune Part 2. Alia should have been present, she is the Abomination, but I can see there are time pressures in having her born and develop as far as the movie is concerned. Yes - Thufir should have been there at the end, I agree. Lady Fenring had sent a secret message, a warning, to Lady Jessica earlier in the book, I did not understand her liaison with Feyd in the movie, other than to test him. It would seem there will be a third movie - perhaps the Guild, along with Princess Irulan and the Bene Tleilax, will be more accurately portrayed.
Indeed, the scene is quite remarkable. The manner in which he makes his entrance, demonstrating his value, and presenting an enticing vision of paradise to his followers is truly captivating. While it is true that none of us have personally witnessed the arrival of a messiah-like figure in our lifetime, it is plausible that some of those who existed in the past may have possessed a similar level of charisma and allure as the character portrayed by Chalamet. It is evident that Chalamet possesses exceptional acting skills, and his performance in the film makes him a proper Dune.
Why is the audio mix on this clip so weird? The music is dialed way back, barely audible once he enters the conclave. It's such a big part of the overall scene, it's weird to hear it sounding like a bunch of voices recording background murmurs in a sound studio.
With a good set of headphones on, and the volume up, when the sand worm first plows into the dune he is on, it sounds like a 100 freight trains ripping past your face.
LOVE this scene as he walks through the crowd into the building. The music, the look on his face, the clothing, is perfection. He displays that power that he now possesses. Excellent. I just can't stand her mumbling to slow down any more than I can stand him looking at Chani to get the nod to do anything.
It should win more than that. Best actor for Timothée Chalamet, best actress for Rebecca Ferguson, best supporting actor for Austin Butler, best costumes, best editing, best director and why not best picture too? I can't think of another film this year that surpassed this masterpiece.
“I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health." -Frank Herbert
if i’m being honest, up until this scene i had this image in my head of chalmet being this one dimensional pretty boy actor. but jesus christ, the way he commands this scene is as good as anyone has ever done it. if he continues on his this trajectory he will go down as one of the best to ever do it.
When Quentin Tarantino said he doesn't need to watch this version of Dune. He is wrong! This is the best UA-cam clip of this scene as all the others bypass the beginning.
I like old Gurney, a fierce old soldier loyal to his Lord, and even if Paul's speech went wrong, Gurney would charge in to defend him to the death. We have such old warrior's here, who would defend our King, the chosen of a great Queen, to the death if necessary, Long live the King!
The shot of him waking through the crowd :30 is very reminiscent of GOT from both Jon and Danny both of which represent their rise to power wouldn’t be surprised if they took inspiration from it
It’s visual language that goes back further than GoT. Like Lawrence of Arabia or Matrix 2 which really hammered the idea that the protagonist is special with the crowd shots.
Maybe cinema wise, but most people don’t realize that Dune is the inspiration and predecessor to almost all big name fantasy series. Such as Game of Thrones and even Star Wars.
Frank Herbert confirmed he took a great deal of Arabic and Islamic elements to integrate it into this story. For example.... - "Lisan Al-Gaib" means "tongues of the unseen realms". - "Madhi" is the name given to the individual who appears at end times to rid the world of evil and injustice (Mahdi, incidentally, isn't the same individual as the Messiah, in Islam) - "Mu'addib" is a "teacher" - "Jihad" (unlike what "Team America" says) is actually a fight against injustice, so from the perspective of the Fremen, they're fighting their oppressors.
Powerful scene as there is in any movie or story. What incident like about this version of Dune is how the character of Chani was changed. She is Fremen. All Fremen are religious to a fault. A people of prophecy. Indoctrinated for the arrival of the Mahdi. In the book, there were distinction between fanatics and somewhat fanatics. The Fremen were all fanatics. That’s what made them the perfect counter to the Shaddukar. Elite fanatical warriors that were more extreme than even those terror troops. A people willing to charge Shaddukar as civilians, old men & women, children… again extreme fanatics.
This scene is superb bcoz the build up to this moment was given the best detail possible..imagine having a directors cut with another 1 hour worth of scenes? 😅
Very good scene! The thing is... it was a set up - role that was perfectly played. Chani was 100% right. We have the same thing today - for example US elections.
To highlight the danger of messianic figures and illustrate Pauls doubts without having him monologing the entire time. Monologues work in books, less in movies.
@@DundGIt would be impossible to even try to convey Paul’s monologuing in the way the book does it. One thing that interested me the most was the basically multidimensional thoughts that he has in the books. He truly does see “all” and the books do a good way of conveying that.
Absolutely amazing, but I was so confused first time I saw it as to how that guy's grandmother died 9 moon ago when she was only 12. Feels like there's a pause missing between those sentences.
I loved it Frank Herbert's books and his intentions was to warn people from messiah's and false prophets but he made his very examples extremely cool extremely charismatic and just really awesome lol Paul atreides and Leto atreides the god Emperor
A general comment. Not all messiahs and/or charismatics want to lead. Notice “Paul” said, “I’m POINTING the way.” He DID NOT say, “I AM the way.” HUGE difference. #tetragrammaton
He was in a damned if you do damned if you don't situation if ever there was one. The most damned would have been the emperor maintaining control of Arrakis and spice, the Fremen enslaved or wiped out, and Paul and every last remnant of House Atreides removed from existence. The least damned, galactic Jihad and the death of billions. It was a hard call, but the right one.
Haha. Have you read the books? Just wait till the next movie. This movie is pushing the same agenda you are complaining about I bet. Just to blind to see it.
@sammonsalve5657 Of course it's pushing an agenda. The Dune series was never subtle in it's social commentary. The difference is the story and world built up in the books is more than good enough to support said commentary.
Dear lord possibly the most powerful scene in cinema I have ever seen, and Chalamet just freaking CHEWS UP that dialogue. Incredible.
Man, I do agree. It gives me the chills every time.
Yes you say it right - the power of religious fervour, words delivered with the conviction to move a terrifying people, their Mahdi spoke it well
This went over my head when I saw the film. This scene is mind blowing! The reactions of everyone realizing he is the one.
I would say ride of the rohirrim in return just inches this one over. Excellent nevertheless
It's powerful, but honestly I think the surrender of Jerusalem in Kingdom of Heaven was more so.
Slow down...
THERE IS NO ONE IN THIS ROOM THAT CAN STAND AGAINST ME!
an average DotA player entering mid lane
@@stepanserdyuk4589 Truth
LEROOOOOOOOOY JEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENKIIINS
Friends: Slow down
Me drunk: HERE IS NO ONE IN THIS ROOM THAT CAN STAND AGAINST ME!
she underestimates his power and his sight. He doesnt need to slow down he literally is pointing the way.
Mom: Slow down
Paul: *INCITES GALACTIC JIHAD*
Mom After: "Well i mean this was gonna be my second answer though, he he..."
The most underrated comment! 😂😂😂
Galactic Jihad is absolutely fucking wild 💀
part III is exactly that.
lolllllllllllllllllll
Bro was shooting Willy fuckin Wonka while doin all this badass shit too. Unreal versatility.
and i mean the guy weighs like 130 pounds soaking wet even after all that chocolate
MY NAME IS WILLY WONKA, FOUNDER OF THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY. I PROMISE YOU CHOCOLATE BEYOND YOUR DREAMS. A CHOCOLATE PARADISE.
@@danielawesome36 HE IS THE KICKSTAND HATRACK!
@@danielawesome36 My lord, the great houses are sending six spoiled children who refuse to acknowledge your ascention. What are your orders?
"GOOD DAY SIR!"
I cant believe people would even question is talent because of his age. This whole speech raises the hairs on my neck.... he is a great actor.
Jessica: Slow down
Paul: *Slams foot on the gas*
💀💀💀💀
😂😅
HE points the way.
and drives like a MOTHERFUCKER
In the book Paul is using the voice on the Fremen. That could be why in this scene The Lady Jessica whispers slow down. Telling him he’s rushing it
Gurney is like a ronin of ancient Japan, when he saw his master's ring once more in Paul's hand you can tell from the facial expression he doesn't consider himself a masterless ronin anymore but a samurai warrior ready to defend his master and house again. Josh Brolin did great in this role!
I know Chani was changed for cinema from the books to be more of a voice of reason to Paul's jihad, which I like since you don't get as much subtext from the character's inner monologues. But even like you said, Gurney being loyal stopping Chani from challenging paul is a huge moment. If he didn't stop her, and she challenged them right there, I don't think he would have been able to kill her in a duel.
@@edwinmoy1402 His tears of pride when Paul puts on the Atreides signet ring 💪 He knows that Duke Leto and all his brothers in arms will finally be avenged.
@@edwinmoy1402 Yes, he did 👍.
@@pataflafla-patapaul never kills chani?
Fills me with pride and anger tho I know it is fiction but it came from a man who face blood and destruction
Jessica: "Slow down"
Paul: "King Kong ain't got SHIT ON ME"
😂
ai format, are you real
@@incrediblystupid9244 AI trained on me
🤣🤣
this is the best one XD
"Messiahs and charismatic leaders are a walking disaster for any culture... but sometimes they do look REALLY fucking cool." -Frank Herbert, probably
There's a lot of "beware of who you choose as your leader" throughout Herbert's writings...
@@OddlyIncredible That's actually a good paraphrase of what Frank Herbert said:
“I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health." One of the most dangerous presidents we had in this century was John Kennedy because people said "Yes Sir Mr. Charismatic Leader what do we do next?" and we wound up in Vietnam. And I think probably the most valuable president of this century was Richard Nixon. Because he taught us to distrust government and he did it by example.”
@@georgeghleung And now I look to the new US president and how people react to him if they "believe" in him ... think about that.
Trump just proved that.
@@coronastern BINGO
His skinny little scrawny ass conveyed such power. His confidence was true acting genius
It's a pity they downplayed how insanely dangerous Paul is. They mostly only showed him in his role as leader but in the books it was factually true that no one could stand against him. It got to the point that he had killed so many challengers to his rule that Chani killed at least one person who tried to challenge him stating that it would be a waste of his water to spend it killing such a trivial opponent.
Canonically Paul is the most dangerous person on the planet by a considerable margin. He taught all the fremen around him how to fight which itself is ridiculous considering the Fremen were already far more dangerous than the sadukar. In the book during the confrontation with the emperor the emperor commands the empires greatest assassin in all of history (And the last attempt at creating the KH) to kill Paul. The assassin did no fighting, and looks at paul who is exhausted from an invasion injured and poisoned. And concludes it's possible he could kill Paul, but not guaranteed.
This wasn't communicated well in this movie so I hope it gets shown in the next because by the end of the emperors reign he can kill anyone who comes after him. Even his children (Yes he has children in the book) are too dangerous for the sadukar to stop. Capturing his 8 year old cost several lives and she tells the emperor she let herself get captured in the end she could have kept killing them.
Wow that is very terrifying to think about. So I guess in the end, it was always Feyd, the Harkonnens and Sardaukar who were the good ones, while Paul and the Fremen were the evil ones. We can only hope the Great Houses can put a stop to this madness and save the Known Universe in the 3rd installment of the series.
@@MangleZTNAholy shit
@@costco_pizza It's not "good" versus "evil" so much as "be _very_ careful who you follow - cults of personality tend to have very dark end results."
@@MangleZTNA Yeah, the books go much farther into just how dangerous Paul actually is. At this point in the story he _could_ easily kill everyone in that room and that's like multiple thousands of armed Fremen. The amount of power he was radiating with the Voice alone was just absurd.
Every scene, shot, moment in this film for me is just perfection. Everything had a purpose, even the little mannerisms and inside jokes had a purpose or made the world feel alive and grounded. This scene, opening scene, gladiator fight, ending fight, work ride, etc. are classics scenes at this point.
I definitely see what you mean. It doesn't feel like a single moment of the movie was wasted or padded.
Tarantino doesn't know what he's missing! 😂
I've watched Dune part 1 about 5 times, but like you said, Dune part 2 is just one good non stop scene; I think it is calling to me to watch it for a 10th time. :)
if you listen to the last few words, you can hear Paul is using the Voice on everyone in that room
HOLY COW. I re-watched it and you're right.
That's crazy detail.
That’s also why it pans to Rebecca when he starts talking in the voice 🙏
You sure it's not just the echo of the room?
in the book, the entire speech was done in the voice, so it was a nice detail to have in the film.
Why didn’t it seem to affect Chani then?
That squat down by Paul to make the dude think Paul is on his level, then the rise up by Paul as he continues talking to let the dude know he has no real chance of beating Paul is good directing.
Jessica: "Slow down"
Paul: starts biggest war in human history
That was Paul’s son.
"The hand of god be my witness, i am the voice from the outer world" god dam this part always gives me goosebumps
Long live the warriors
Dune 2 was a masterpiece, best film adaptation by far
Yea, after Lord of the rings
Maybe since the Return of the King, I haven't felt scenes that moved me so much.
Oh and don’t forget The Ringer of Power!
@@tylermcnair4921 sure sure hahaha
this is not like the book
The cinematography alone is breath taking
Just fyi this movie cost the same as Joker 2. I am not even kidding.
Wow... Wikipedia lists both as 190 mil $ budget. That's a crazy high number for Joker 2.
And joker 2 is a steamy pile of excrement compared to Dune 2.
@@KonaLife You got that right . . .
Wtf...
@@KonaLife copared to Freddy got fingered its still shit
I cannot think of many films in the last 10 years that gave me a scene like this, at this point in the movie, that literally made my draw drop. The acting, the cinematography, the dialogue, the tension... watching it back now and it's still great, but at this point of the film and seeing it in the cinema with the additional surround sound... probably top 3 favourite moments of cinema history for me
Its all girl bosses now, but women just can't radiate the same kind of power and masculinity without looking fake. They managed it in Game of thrones but they also fucked it up later. Its very rare and ironicly was more common in the 90's with characters like Sarah Connor than in the modern times of so many more girl bosses but most just 0 charisma.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 So women just can't do something, except when they can? Lol
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 Because they try to do it out of fake feminism and not genuine love for the role they are playing i think
Jessica wants him to slow down because her Bene Gesserit teachings preach patience and slow manipulation over decades. They need to do things slowly and carefully. Because they can only access the feminine side of their genetic memory, this is all they know.
Paul can see what they can't. He can see the exact path he needs to take to get where he needs to be, so he takes it, caution be damned.
thats sick
Men are brave.
The Bene Gesserit will wait for the ice to thaw, but Paul, Duke of House Atreides, mentat, Kwisatz Haderach, and the Lisan al-Gaib, will smash the ice
bro literally speedrunning the Fremen
No need for caution when you know for a fact that you're right
There’s something about the CGI of Dune that just hits different. I’ve seen many movies with more advanced CGI than Dune like Avatar, Endgame but Dune’s CGI looks and feels real.
It's cause they used it the right way. They didn't try to show off the CGI they used it to build a lot of the world and enhance the story but weren't afraid to cover it in sand explosions or dust so that you couldn't really see the art of it. They also used it consistently with the same logic the whole time.
Well Avatar also looks super good, but i know what u mean. dune is just one of he best movies for me
A lot of practical effects were used to enhance environments, especially the lighting
They used it as good as they did in the Lord of the Rings. Just an add-on to the practical effects and not the main thing. Avatar and Marvel suck at that.
Its the lighting ... always has been with villeneuve. Simple things like Explosions casting shadows. Those make the biggest difference.
Best movie I've seen since Interstellar and Inception, 10/10.
For me it’s since across the spiderverse 😊not long ago I know but in terms of live action probably since la la land and that’s a top 10 for me of the 2010s.
That's for damn sure!
Also Arrival
@@Afr095 lmfao the times we live in.. Despite the beautiful animation and good voice acting, what tf are you actually on about? lol
in fairness, I intentionally believe the internet now belongs to undeveloped brains. That's not meant to be a direct insult. It's your right to be young and undeveloped and enjoy whatever fulfills the egos need to self identify lol. But idk man/woman/whatever-you-need-to-be-called, if across your spider verse is your "oh shit, there really are great movies" moment, then good lord lol.
Love the directing and editing in this scene, how the movement of each shot leads into the next, holding a surprise after every cut, building to Paul's speech which almost feels chaotic at first while all the dramatic threads are fighting to sync up, until the end of the scene when all the main characters have solidified their motivations and positions for the rest of the film as it leads to the climax. This movie better get some oscars.
Gives me chills every time I watch it.
long live the fighters!
@@jforozco12 Ya hya chouhada!
Still the best movie of the year. One of the best theatre experiences I’ve ever had.
Men, I've watched part 2 so many times, loved it from start to finish. Long live the fighters.
Yah - I've never gone this overboard for a movie in my life ..... although in the 90's, when for a couple of years I was into cocaine, I think I watched the first Predator movie about a dozen times. :) I'm almost at a dozen times now with Dune 2 , and no stimulants involved. :)
I remember when I read this part in Dune, They definitely did it justice
Watched this scene more than 20 times, don't know why??
It keeps getting better
On my 13th time right now.
Because masculinity was more or less banned in Hollywood.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115true
0:45 That might be the best shot in the entire movie.
This is by far better than Star Wars and marvel
Of course lol, it’s a no brainer
How can you compare star wars to this?
Fuck Marvel but the initial two star wars at least compare equal to this movie. Considering the times.
@@keshavchauhan6290 how could you not? They’re both intergalactic franchises 😂
@@keshavchauhan6290you can like both of them, they are just fictional world, stay chill. I read the 6 Dune books and seen al adaptation. The books are în the most part dull, with some higlights there and there, not as complex and genial as some people say they are. The God-Emperor of Dune...that's the book who I skipped the most, boring AF
When Paul said i won't deprive myself of the best of us...his father said the same thing in the first movie when his guard wanted to acquit himself for not finding that spy who tried to kill Paul
Easily the best moment in both films. I wasn't sure on Chalamet until this moment and it changed everything.
the music in the dunes movies. Just perfect. The best movies since LOTR imo.
Beast. This movie was 10/10 Masterpiece.
With respect... I gave Dune Part 2 - 9/10. I thought the movie took liberties with Chani's character, she did not act like this in the book. Also, the politics in the confrontation with the Emperor was far too simplified. The movie did not mention the Guild or CHOAM at all, which, along with the Landsraad, are the three struts on which the entire Imperial system rests, so I was disappointed with Part 2 in that regard.
Feyd was built up too much, and other characters like Alia, and the Bene Gesserit Reverend Mother were underplayed too much.
But Paul and Jessica's acceptance by the Fremen was masterfully handled, and scenes like these are stupendous, I could watch this scene alone 100 times and still be awed.
@@edhoughton2609my only quarrel with the movie is the portrayal of Chani as a rebellious character that doesn’t understand the prophecy and is against Paul as Lisan al Gaib when in the books she is docile and never questions it! I don’t know why they needed her to be like this in the script. The guild and CHOAM have little relevance in the first book (Dune, Muad’Dib and the prophet) and I can see why Denis didn’t include them as it would take up significant movie space, not including Alia as a living being I think it was smart because it would’ve been a nightmare to have a 4 yo acting like a reverend mother, look at the 1984 adaptation and how that turned out! Having her as a woken up and conscious being in Jessica’s womb was very smart on Denis’s part! Bit sad about Thufir’s disappearance and not portraying him as Harkonnen’s new mentat, also not having count fenring in the movie was a letdown but I understand it would be hard to include everyone in a 2 part, 5 hour long movie
@@alexsenciuc8910 with the greatest respect....I agree with you concerning Chani, but the parasitic Guild is everything and everywhere in Dune, Lynch understood this in the 1984 movie and, it was, in my opinion, a major mistake to omit the Guild from Dune Part 2. Alia should have been present, she is the Abomination, but I can see there are time pressures in having her born and develop as far as the movie is concerned. Yes - Thufir should have been there at the end, I agree. Lady Fenring had sent a secret message, a warning, to Lady Jessica earlier in the book, I did not understand her liaison with Feyd in the movie, other than to test him.
It would seem there will be a third movie - perhaps the Guild, along with Princess Irulan and the Bene Tleilax, will be more accurately portrayed.
3:16 me asserting dominance at my court ordered anger management course
LOL
00:10 the Mahdi comes from the desert, with Shai-Hulud behind, even a terrifying race like the Fremen gave him respect and allowed him through
If Chalamaladingdong gets nominated for Best Actor, they should use this clip starting at 5:18.
This is the best version of this speech. Especially with the chokasba added. Chamlate WAS PAUL
"You think I'm stupid enough to deprive myself of the best of us?
Do you smash a knife before battle?"
It’s incredible how Paul resembles to Timothy Chalamet
Indeed, the scene is quite remarkable. The manner in which he makes his entrance, demonstrating his value, and presenting an enticing vision of paradise to his followers is truly captivating. While it is true that none of us have personally witnessed the arrival of a messiah-like figure in our lifetime, it is plausible that some of those who existed in the past may have possessed a similar level of charisma and allure as the character portrayed by Chalamet. It is evident that Chalamet possesses exceptional acting skills, and his performance in the film makes him a proper Dune.
How can such a voice rise from one so small as he? Chalamet owned this scene.
he is actually very tall, he is just skinny
@@lauraalves001no, he only 5"10 (175cm) which is not that tall
@@nguyennam1945 well i am 5ft 11 and I am quite tall ;)
@@nguyennam1945He's almost 5 11 which is179-180 cm. Noway he's 175. And yah. He's taller than Zendaya.
Mother: “slow down”
Paul: “I’m about to go ape shit on this speach”
I just noticed she started yelling right next to Gurney! How convenient! I Love this movie though lol
goosepumps all over my body. what an epic power speech
Why is the audio mix on this clip so weird? The music is dialed way back, barely audible once he enters the conclave. It's such a big part of the overall scene, it's weird to hear it sounding like a bunch of voices recording background murmurs in a sound studio.
Two words: copyright.
WTF DID THEY DO?? I kept thinking this doesn't even come close to the original!!
Yup, the real scene is way better
Disappointed that the dune 2 soundtrack wont be in oscars this yr😭 the epic music when he rode the sandworms gives me chills.
With a good set of headphones on, and the volume up, when the sand worm first plows into the dune he is on, it sounds like a 100 freight trains ripping past your face.
@@mrzoinky5999 experienced it in the imax cinema with blasting speakers and it was immaculate! Yes! headphones would be more ethereal!
Stilgar:"muaddib, what do you see for us"
Paul: "green paradise"
Fremen: "Password accepted"
LOVE this scene as he walks through the crowd into the building. The music, the look on his face, the clothing, is perfection. He displays that power that he now possesses. Excellent. I just can't stand her mumbling to slow down any more than I can stand him looking at Chani to get the nod to do anything.
Holy shit, Timothée, what a performance! He had me ready to go wipe out Harkonnens with that speech, and they're fictional . . .
so cay
This is my favorite scene... so far in the Dune Saga
If this movie doesn't win the best vfx, cinematography, soundtrack and best sound at next year's Oscars then the Oscars is not worth watching 😅✌️
It should win more than that. Best actor for Timothée Chalamet, best actress for Rebecca Ferguson, best supporting actor for Austin Butler, best costumes, best editing, best director and why not best picture too? I can't think of another film this year that surpassed this masterpiece.
Jessica: "Paul, slow down."
Paul: "MY MOM SAYS IT'S A SHOW DOWN!"
Underrated comment
This is literally my favorite scene in cinema history now.
This is fucking cinema, chills everywhere
The sounds in this movie make you feel like you are there.
“I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health."
-Frank Herbert
This is the most EPIC scene EVER
“In your nightmares, you give water to the dead. And it brings joy to your heart!”
Honestly one of my favorite lines ever
This movie was 10/10 to see in Imax
if i’m being honest, up until this scene i had this image in my head of chalmet being this one dimensional pretty boy actor. but jesus christ, the way he commands this scene is as good as anyone has ever done it. if he continues on his this trajectory he will go down as one of the best to ever do it.
love this scene, always gives me goose bumps. goes from the dukes son to galatic badass.
When Quentin Tarantino said he doesn't need to watch this version of Dune. He is wrong!
This is the best UA-cam clip of this scene as all the others bypass the beginning.
Stop giving the foot sniffer any more importance by mentioning him.
It's just jealousy
I like old Gurney, a fierce old soldier loyal to his Lord, and even if Paul's speech went wrong, Gurney would charge in to defend him to the death.
We have such old warrior's here, who would defend our King, the chosen of a great Queen, to the death if necessary, Long live the King!
Most powerful scene from a movie I have ever seen. Goosebumps and shivers whenever I watch this. Amazing truly
The shot of him waking through the crowd :30 is very reminiscent of GOT from both Jon and Danny both of which represent their rise to power wouldn’t be surprised if they took inspiration from it
It’s visual language that goes back further than GoT. Like Lawrence of Arabia or Matrix 2 which really hammered the idea that the protagonist is special with the crowd shots.
Maybe cinema wise, but most people don’t realize that Dune is the inspiration and predecessor to almost all big name fantasy series. Such as Game of Thrones and even Star Wars.
this was peak cinema
The first 30 seconds of this sequence are insane
The most ”who tf wants some” scene ever
Ol' Tim O'Tay quietly becoming probably this generations best male dramatic actor
Timmy's best acting performance!! 👍👍👏👏♥️
Frank Herbert confirmed he took a great deal of Arabic and Islamic elements to integrate it into this story. For example....
- "Lisan Al-Gaib" means "tongues of the unseen realms".
- "Madhi" is the name given to the individual who appears at end times to rid the world of evil and injustice (Mahdi, incidentally, isn't the same individual as the Messiah, in Islam)
- "Mu'addib" is a "teacher"
- "Jihad" (unlike what "Team America" says) is actually a fight against injustice, so from the perspective of the Fremen, they're fighting their oppressors.
Arabic jihād, literally ‘effort’, expressing, in Muslim thought, struggle on behalf of God and Islam
Powerful scene as there is in any movie or story. What incident like about this version of Dune is how the character of Chani was changed. She is Fremen. All Fremen are religious to a fault. A people of prophecy. Indoctrinated for the arrival of the Mahdi. In the book, there were distinction between fanatics and somewhat fanatics. The Fremen were all fanatics. That’s what made them the perfect counter to the Shaddukar. Elite fanatical warriors that were more extreme than even those terror troops. A people willing to charge Shaddukar as civilians, old men & women, children… again extreme fanatics.
This scene is superb bcoz the build up to this moment was given the best detail possible..imagine having a directors cut with another 1 hour worth of scenes? 😅
excellent movie I have watched twice in less then 3 weeks . I hope the third installment is as great as the firt 2
Jessica: "Slow down . . . "
Muad'Dib: "I'M HIM. I'VE BEEN HIM. I WILL CONTINUE TO BE HIM."
goosebumps...most authentic world created and recreated in movie. with acting from boy but from different world.
Very good scene! The thing is... it was a set up - role that was perfectly played. Chani was 100% right.
We have the same thing today - for example US elections.
It does defy reasoning; the choice was simple - Vote for any Democrat for democracy, vote Trump for a dictatorship.
@@mrzoinky5999So funny how susceptible to propaganda you are
One of my favourites scenes from the movie. So f*cking epic!
props to the sound effect brooo that gave me chiiiiillssssss
Why did they change Chani’s character so much?
To highlight the danger of messianic figures and illustrate Pauls doubts without having him monologing the entire time. Monologues work in books, less in movies.
@@DundGIt would be impossible to even try to convey Paul’s monologuing in the way the book does it. One thing that interested me the most was the basically multidimensional thoughts that he has in the books. He truly does see “all” and the books do a good way of conveying that.
Absolutely amazing, but I was so confused first time I saw it as to how that guy's grandmother died 9 moon ago when she was only 12. Feels like there's a pause missing between those sentences.
She died 9 moons ago, she lost her eye when she was 12
One of the greatest masterpiece I've experienced in theatre, totally blown away! It's the ultimate LORT of last decade or since the lort
-how many times have you watched this scene?
-YES
I loved it Frank Herbert's books and his intentions was to warn people from messiah's and false prophets but he made his very examples extremely cool extremely charismatic and just really awesome lol Paul atreides and Leto atreides the god Emperor
One of the best scenes in all of cinema
Slow Down...
Now watch this drive
“Beware of heroes.” - Frank Herbert
Worm : someone's walking casually~ dinner time!
@0:11 Worm realized its Lisan Al Gaib : oops, we have a badass over here... dips away
A general comment. Not all messiahs and/or charismatics want to lead. Notice “Paul” said, “I’m POINTING the way.” He DID NOT say,
“I AM the way.” HUGE difference. #tetragrammaton
He was in a damned if you do damned if you don't situation if ever there was one. The most damned would have been the emperor maintaining control of Arrakis and spice, the Fremen enslaved or wiped out, and Paul and every last remnant of House Atreides removed from existence. The least damned, galactic Jihad and the death of billions. It was a hard call, but the right one.
The Dune movies have restored my faith in cinema. There have been some dark times in the last decade of just weird agenda pushing nothing burgers.
Haha. Have you read the books? Just wait till the next movie. This movie is pushing the same agenda you are complaining about I bet. Just to blind to see it.
@ eh I really enjoyed the first two. If the third one sucks that’s okay. The first 2 were great. I’ll take what I can get.
@sammonsalve5657
Of course it's pushing an agenda. The Dune series was never subtle in it's social commentary.
The difference is the story and world built up in the books is more than good enough to support said commentary.
Best scene ever.....and personage is not a hero but a destroyer and a warning to us all.
i was sweating during this scene. incredible cinematography.
Ironically making Dune a green paradise would eliminate sandworms and the spice and the entire Dune universe.
Doesn't matter. It's what the Fremen want to hear,so they follow the prophecy.
@@DundG HE IS THE KICKSTAND HATRACK!
@KayGee-r5o THE NISSAN ALL GAMING
@@KayGee-r5o LOL No, "For he is the Cuisinart Hacky Sack!" :)
@@mrzoinky5999 The Laserium al-Dilah, the Bright Light of the Italian Love Song! (National Lampoon's Doon)
Great Delivery. I don't know what you're fighting for but Im joining.
Greatest film of the year.
IM POINTING THE WAY!!!
Perfect scene, if only Chani was also faithfully adapted by the movie, the only negative
Their language is interesting, it sounds so fluid but rough, aggressive, and strong.
I came before you. As King.