Dr Kaiser Bengali: We will have to revise our foreign and defense policies
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 чер 2023
- Dr. Kaiser Bengali is one of the most prominent economists in Pakistan. He is widely known for his outspoken views. He says that the state of Pakistan has never been run for the people. It is a state for the elite. It is an unfair state. He was born in Surat and then his family moved to Calcutta. His family migrated to Pakistan in 1968.
He says that we treated Balochistan as an economic colony. Our foreign policy has to undergo a paradigm shift.
In an earlier interview, he said that Pakistan's economy was on a ventilator. The state is unable to pay salaries to its officers. Pakistan is an agricultural country but it has become a food-deficit country. He believes that Pakistan's foreign policy needs a paradigm shift. It should cut its non-combat defense spending by 80%. He is also critic of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CEPEC). He does not agree with the popular Pakistani view that it is a game changer. He says that Pakistan will get 9% of the Gwadar Port revenue. China will get 91% of the revenue. Pakistan will bear all the expenses for security. He did his master's economics at Boston University. Subsequently, he earned his doctoral degree at Karachi University.
His family is originally from Surat, which is located in the Indian state of Gujrat. His great-grandfather moved to Calcutta in a bullock cart caravan in the good old days. That's how his family members came to acquire the last name Bengali.
He has taught and conducted research at prestigious institutions in Pakistan such as the Applied Economics Research Centre, University of Karachi, Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology, and was Managing Director of the Social Policy and Development Centre, Karachi.
His areas of research interest include issues in planning and development and macro-economic and fiscal policies, particularly relating to inter-personal and inter-regional inequality, poverty, unemployment, and social justice, urban and regional planning, decentralization and local government and finance, education, and ethnic, sectarian and religious militancy and violence. His areas of expertise and experience include political management of planning and development, management of institutions, personnel and finance.
He has also served in a number of government positions. Till recently, he was Consultant for Economic Affairs and Head of the Chief Minister’s Policy Reform Unit, Government of Balochistan. Earlier, he was Advisor to the Chief Minister of Sindh for Planning and Development. He was also the first head of the Benazir Income Support Program and designed the program. He was also Sindh’s representative on the 7th National Finance Commission, which gave a successful Award. He has now been nominated on the 8th NFC to represent Balochistan.
His international teaching, research and consultancy experience includes work at the Institut Universitaire d’Etudes du Development, University of Geneva and the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex, UK, and with international organizations in Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Eritrea and Kenya.
He has over 35 research publications in national and international journals and conferences and he is the author/editor of 8 books on subjects ranging from unemployment, inequality and poverty to education, water, gender, and regional development. He has regularly contributed articles on economic and political issues to newspapers and appears in TV talk shows.
He has been politically active since his student days. Upon joining the University of Karachi in 1972, he co-founded the Pakistan Liberal Students, which ended the Islami Jamiat-e-Talaba’s decade and a half rule in the university’s Student Union elections in 1975. He has worked with trade unions for workers’ rights and co-founded the Pakistan Institute of Labor Education and Research. He has also been part of all campaigns for democracy, human rights, media freedom, women’s rights, and the rights of the under-privileged. He co-authored the Pakistan Peoples Party White Paper “How an Election was Stolen”, which documented the rigging of the 1990 general election.
****************************************************
Shakil Chaudhary attended Government College, Lahore, Quaid-i-Azam University Islamabad and the London School of Economics. He has worked for several English-language newspapers.
He has written a critically acclaimed bilingual book, Handbook of Functional English (Ferozsons), to help those who wish to improve their English skills.
If you want to see his most popular videos, here are the links to them.
• Why didn't Jinnah impl...
• Prof. Hoodbhoy: Pakist...
• Shahid Siddiqui: The p...
• Muslims started the 19...
You are welcome to follow him on Facebook and Twitter.
/ shakil.chaudary
/ shakchaudhary
Dear Friends,
If you like my find my videos worthwhile, please share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel.
I welcome your comments, but please use civil language. Uncivil langue does not make you more convincing. There is no problem if you want to disagree with me or the guest, but please do so without being disagreeable. If you wish to give an opposing view, please send me your contact details.
If you want to see my most popular videos, here are the links to them.
ua-cam.com/video/hWJugbilQd8/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/hRDiEe90z6Y/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/sqHGMhJkygc/v-deo.html
You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter.
facebook.com/shakil.chaudary
twitter.com/ShakChaudhary
This is the best platform in our country for the intellectual
Kaiser Sir is sincere but the problem is that your elite does not really care about Pakistan. You know why? Because you don't respect your true history and land. You have developed a culture that is only interested in looting the nation from the top to the bottom.
Hello sir. Good discussion. Bahoot kam sensible loog aate hai aapke show mein. Sakil sir agar koi facts pe IND ko criticise kare we r ready to listen but propaganda nhi hona chahiye jo aapke jyadatar guest karte hai maybe knowledge nhi hai. Anyways today's show n guest is good. Kolkata mein aaj bhi communal problem hai.
Pakistan must put aside ISLAM and then look at Pakistan for solution. A druggist cannot think with clarity !!
Pakistan and Bangladesh problem is MAZHAB. Fortunately Bangladesh did not abondon their roots - culture and language . If Bangladesh remove Islam - it can be South Korea of Asia .
The city of birth of Mr. Bengali is a microsom of the Indian story.
In 1998, the city (Surat) had to be nearly evacuated due to unhygienic conditions and a plague outbreak.
Today road, airport, educational, port, industrial and entertainment infrastructure is world class in Surat. It's going to be a station on the Mumbai - Ahmedabad bullet train.
We'll have to revise:
- Preamble of Our Constitution( Sovereignty doesn't belong to Allah)
- Article 295(Blasphemy Law)
- Article 124(Sedition)
- Land Reforms
- Education Policy(Duniyavi Taleem)
- Separation of Mullah & Military,
Separation of Domain of Legislature & Uniformed Services,
Accounting of Defence Expenditure through Civilian Govt.( in absence of it, humay zaleel hona parta hay at global institution because 'Wardi Walay' suppress the actual figures)..
- (Last but not the least) Keeping religion at your "Home" & to yourself only..!!
lol
So, Blasphemy Law is OK ???
That is asking the moon out of Pakistan....
@@amoldurve1295 No way Sir.. that's why I mentioned Article 295(reg. Blasphemy 🤬), without which no further reforms are possible..😣
I am a great fan of yours, Dr Siddiqua!
What a joy to listen to a man, not just wise, but honest. He is the best man ever came out from the Indian subcontinent. It’s one of the great mysteries of this mankind that such a man found himself stranded in Jinnah’s failed experiment aka Pakistan. “Ideas have consequences.” A very bad idea of Pakistan has to result in evil consequences.
I liked this guest. Talked sense. Of course, I am in disagreement for his over the cuff remark about Pakistan having controlled COVID better than India. COVID, where it spread, is something we will know about in the future. Right now we are happy it is mostly in control around the world. Jai Hind.
'handled better than India' koi data architecture hai nahi, forensics paper shows massive fudging of data. yet these chutiye are confident
@@NoBS-md9wb they controlled the Covid data better, not Covid itself
F
@@AKumar-co7oendia mei log oxygen ke tanks ke liye marr rahey the, apne ghar walo ko bachanay ke liye. Log oxygen na honey ki wajah se India me zyaada marray hai.
Pakistan mei aisa koi scene nahi tha. Balkay hum nay Oxygen bhej nay ki offer di thi India ko.
Jaa kay articles pardh le tab kay, aur on the ground reporting be dekh le. Is ko massive fudging of data forensic papers de rahey hai, leiken eik simple Google nahi maar sakhta, wah.
@@muhammadhaque3448 haan, pakistan mein bas youtubers ke relatives suddenly marr gaye aur kisi ne sawal bhi nahin poochha ki poori population ko immunity kaise ho gayi xD
Qamar cheema ke maa, baap bhai mar gaye par usne sawal nahin pooccha govt se
Ese jahil log professor ho Pakistan ka khuda hi hafij hai
I enjoyed listening to the views of Mr.Kaiser Bengali. His thoughts and analysis were quite balanced. I disagree with his off the cuff remarks related to mishandling of COVID in India. If he feels it was mishandled then he should have substantiated it with facts, figures and data.
Kaiser towards the end says Pakistan is richer than India and has more resources on a per capita, per square kilometer and per square mile basis. Again, absolutely no hard factual data furnished to prove this claim. If this is the knowledge of a professor teaching for 40+ years, then no wonder Pakistan is in such shape.
In 1990, India and Pakistan had almost identical per-capita GDPs, a little under US$370 per person. But by 2021, India’s had surged to $2,277, about 50% higher than Pakistan’s.
Wow a prof doesn't know this. 😮
Dr Bengali is an erudite person and i have alrways liked his comments on Pakistan economy. I only hope he just made a loose comment about India's Cobid handling. He should.know India's handling has been praised by WHO. And all the world.😊
सुरत से पाकिस्तान जानेका दर्द ईनके चेहरे पर दिखाई देती है
The country is running by begging from the first day, it is saying that before 77, the condition of Pakistan was fine, whenever there is more begging, it starts telling that the economy has improved.
Two gem at one place... Salaam Respect Namaste to hosts guests and viewers.What a realistic analysis.
Compare everything with India???😂 Like women telling her husband how the neighbours live.
Even older people never grew up intellectually.
Kaiser Bengali is living under a rock.
This man isn’t a liar, good viewing it,, love and respect
Data fudging is birth right of Pakistan and expecting them to speak truth on COVID is asking too much.😅
Kaisar sir ki baat Aankhein kholne wali hai.sir COVID ke baad hi India ne progress full form me Kiya.
Kolkata may India ka sabsay jyada dangay aur goonda gardhi hoti hai..Aaj bhi.. Bimaru communist state hai..
Don't make frivolous comments.
Right veeru
@@biswajitdutta7338 He is saying right....few decades back Kolkata was booming metropolitan city and now bengal has lost it charm despite being costal state and that too near ASEAN nations and east asian nations
Mazhab nahi sikhata - education dilana. Mazhab hi education hai!!!
Good guest. Keep walking. Regards.
Very good analysis: Qaiser Bengali and Shakeel Chaudhry Sahib
The biggest obstacle to the development of Pakistan is the establishment of Pakistan
Dr Kaiser Bengali has highlighted the real situation of the Pakistan
Such Persons are an Asset for Pakistan and rightly admitting responsibility of present conditions by someone of his stature .
Wish all such Experts who have the capacity to make the difference will come forward to serve the people and Country , with all expertise they have developed during their life long engagements in their respective fields .
Let's Join Hands to make History 🙌
When Pakistani talk India while discussing Pakistan you should know he is making up
So you are saying two nation theory didn't suit you.... 😅
Nice guftagoo - learned guest Shakeel Saab ❤ Very realistic presentation by Dr Bengali 💐
It’s a treat to listen to both of you, Dr Bengali and Shri Shakeel.
Pakistani Economists (including Dr. Bengali) should analyze economy in TWO parts for clarity and understanding. 1. up to 197? 2. After 197? - today. Bangladesh economists say up to 197?, Bangladesh was exporting more but getting peanuts in return. 🙃🙃🙃
Very knowledgeable guest. His ideas are very unique. Govt. should listen to him.
As usual very good show.
I was in Costa Rica couple of years ago. It’s true that they don’t have military but they have large number of police. Every few hundred meters I saw police. In cities I saw at every 20-30 meters. Crime is high. Not a single house I saw which was not blocked by floor to ceiling iron grid covers. They have good tourism, some agriculture export. Being a tiny country they can manage. Nicaragua is drug infested drug mafia country.
Hats off. Sir, jabardast Shandaar
Your Guest intelligent Respect shakll sahib ❤from California
My sincere gratitude to Dr. Kaiser Bengali for his sincere struggle for justice in Pakistan. Jazakallah!
I'm regular watcher of your intellectual webinar
Pakistan Main kittne tourism hotta hai As Compare to India ?
COVID-19
"PAKISTAN NE BOHUT ACHAA KAAM KIYA AS COMPARES TO INDIA".
SERIOUSLY!!
WHAT YOU MEAN?
May be you should be
THINK AGAIN & AGAIN...
Yes, he sits in Karachi and talks about india which fed millions of people and produced vaccine and gave it free to the world.
Sc sir... ishtiyaq sir ki India visit par discussion kare..thnx ♥️🙏
1963 kalcutta riots is reacton of east pakistan riots and maassecare of hindus in bangladesh dhakka
great interview
Well experienced and well read professor… he knows much better about the internal and international politics than the “ Cambridge “ professor who came to your previous show Shakil ji👍
Shakeel sir, I have a request for you please bring Dr. Ishtiyaq ahmad sir. He is on India visit at this moment.
Showed his true character on his covid views.Facts are blazing across the sky,ie in Terroristan every man woman child from president to pm to a sweeper is a terrorist .Theirin lies the problem. 38:10
My Opinion is Afghanistan handled covid better than Pakistan, most mishandled places were in the west by having too many old people
Look like a honest man who does not share anti india and anti hindu feelings.
Honest discussion
Covid spread only in those countries where foreign travel was frequent and in high volume. No one was traveling to Pakistan and even today hardly many travel. Some small countries never got covid bcoz hardly ppl travel there. So don’t confuse Pakistan management with lack of spread.
Mr Bengali’s face says it all. He is very unhappy and miserable.
Perhaps , he is seriously constipated.
Shakil Ji, i always thought you'd never get around to interviewing a pakistani, who speaks realworld; again ! Thanks anyway.
Der aaye durust aaye.
Hindus and Muslims are separate civilizations- ma jinnah
Nice
Health of labor force is important for productivity in extreme weather.
Dr Bengali is one of the best economist in Pakistan
Chaudhary sahib thanks for having interaction with an experienced economist. But you seem to have missed very important question from a learned economist and that is - what measures should Pakistan take to repay the mounting debts from China with huge rate of interest ? And what immediate measures should Pakistan take at this dwindling financial position to bring the economy on right track ? However your interaction was informative.
Stay safe doctor sahab
1946...ke hasdse ki shuruat kisne ki thi?..
Hamein toh Bangladesh ke achhe yaadein nahin hai.
The person is quite knowledgeable.
Appreciate mr shakil chaudhary's continuing efforts to help pakistan come out bad policies.
The price of dairy products is very high and very few variety, price of cooking oil and ghee is very high.
Very sensible Economist...!! And fyi..Kolksata is finished...! It is just a mega city...Nothing else...Communist mentality.
Will Dr. Bengali he like to elaborate how India mishandled Covid
Shakeel saab AOA.
Sorry to ask this question as bit irrelevant to the content of this video. Kindly recommend a Urdu book on Islamic history apart from asbaaq e tareekh by molana waheed ud din sahab. I mean something not distorted Thanks in advance.
انگریزی میں تو کافی چیزیں مل جاتی ہیں۔ آپ کی انگریزی کی استعداد کیسی ہے؟ اسے بہتر بنائیں اور کم از کم وکی پیڈیا سے استفادہ کرنے کے قابل ہو جائیں۔ اس کی انگریزی ویسے بھی اتنی مشکل نہیں ہوتی۔
I think steel technology specially cryogenic steel and high temperature steel technology transfer to India by a secret visit of Indian embassy.
🎉
मान्यवर! हमारे वेद शाश्त्रोँ के वशुधैव कुटुंम्बकम् के सिद्धांत के आधार पर हमेँ सभी पाकिस्तानियोँ के लिये दुःख होता है लेकिन वहीँ कौटिल्य का सिद्धांत हमेँ शत्रु को शमूल नष्ट करने का निर्देश देता है।
हम आपको कुटुंम्ब समझेँ या शत्रु ये इस पर निर्भर करता है कि आप अपने आप को हमारे सामने कैसे प्रस्तूत करते हैँ।
He jas always been part of elite
Shakeel Bhai namaskar interview badhiya Laga bhai Kesar Bengali Sabko mein bahut din se Jaanta hun: interview Dekha thoda mere ko Dukh hua Ye Janab bhi Parde Me Rahana Chahte Hain Itna padha likha aadami Hath Mein phone internet hai India ke bare mein kya Nahin Jaanta daily report Ban Jaati Hai: Fir Bhi aadami masumiyat Dekhe raha hai Jyada Nahin maloom Mujhe India ke bare mein aapko bahut bahut dhanyvad jahil se to Ek padhe likhe aadami ka interview Achcha lagta hai Kuchh aadami Ijjat ki baat kar raha Kesar Bengali is a financial professional of Pak god bless you Jay Hind Vande Mataram aapke kam ko Puri model nikal Jana once again Jai Hind
Hi lighting the problems without giving solution is more dangereous.
Rahi baat COVID ki.. toh Pakistan ko na COVID samjha na uss sey nikal gaye hai... Aaj bhi Pakistan me mar rahey hai COVID se.. jo china ka bhi haal hai.. thoda homework toh kar letey
Wow his solution is to not give money to districts where performance is bad. Really? Do you realize that it means those areas further deteriorate.
India too have some areas to need be strengthened.
The best solution for population control is women's education and that is why taliban is always against women's education 🤣🤣🤣🤣
So Kaiser Bengali is another MOHAJIR. eh? No wonder he's got a chip on his shoulder viz, India. Good luck to him and to Jinnah's Utopia.
Jab tak aap ye 3 cheeje nahi karenge, pakistan can't improve 1.Do your land reforms. 2.close the Fauji faundation (it effecting the local industry ) 3.send Army in their Barracks...none of these you can't do..... Then there is no point to discuss anything..
Karachi k bare bhi Kuch ferma den
What is the fact behind surname "BENGALI " ? Please
Pakistan ka nam hi kashmir rakh lo pakistaniyo
Ďr. Kaiser bengali is not a bengali speaking person , then why is he using bengali with his name ? He is a resident of karachi city , what he has done for improvement of this city although he served as a adviser of CM sindh for a long period ?
Can anybody name a single politician or an influential person in Pakistan , who is not closely related to an (ex) Army general, land holding rich family or otherwise rich/influential politician/judge/person?
replica of bangladesh is baluchistan
Wasael sey Maalamaal mulk......Pak studies ki logic dey rahey hain guest
Good conversation but only conversation not.....
India is able to Land on moon because of cryogenic steel.
Shakeel Bhai Ek Sher hai masjidon ke liye Mila Pakistan awaam comedy gulami ashrafia ko Mili Dalali Shaitan ko Mili hukmarani
your expiry date is over....
Every single guy is a lair.
Ab samajh me aya ki pahle tees sal kha se paise aa rahe the.
Apko apne karma ka fal milega. Apne mujahid paida karke ussr ko torane me islam ka istemal kiya hai aaj wahi islam ka churan aapki barbadi ki kahani likhega.
Pakistan was made by the Ashrafs for the Ashrafs. The rest of the natives serve as host for supporting their parasitic lifestyle and medieval philosophies.
Pakistan enabled the Ashrafs to regain control of the newly formed nation's revenue, bureaucracy, and discourse using religion as a cover. Their goals have been achieved. The non Ashrafiyas are paying through their nose for the lifestyles and megalomania of the Ashrafiyas similar to what the majority in India, i.e the Hindus faced at the hands of the Ashrafiya Muslims during their rule.
Ask any Syed, Siddique, Farooqui or high caste Muslims of Pakistan and he will vouch that nothing is wrong with Pakistan. Surprisingly ask any Syed, Siddique or Farooqui in India and they will say that nothing is right in India even today. The orginal Punjabis, Sindhis, Baloch and Pashtuns needs to figuratively throw these Urdu speaking Ashrafiyas and their collaborators in to the Arabian sea without which Pakistanis will not be able to bring their nation back on tracks.
lal chi ànd kamjot bengali
Ek se ek jhooth bolney waaley maujud hai Pakistan me... 1947 se 1977 tak kaunsi factories shuru thi? Jara hame bhi samjhana... Aur agar nahi proove kar paye toh channel PE maafi maang lena.. joh bhi factories thi woh east Pakistan me thi.. joh ab Bangladesh kehlata hai.
Ye kya Bengali hai??
@14:25 Why should Pakistanis compare the number of engineers rather than the number of tanks? Does the Quran speak about war and the military more or about education and engineers??
Why doesn't Pakistanis manufactur any thing? Did the Quresh tribe manufacture or produce anything and export?
The Quresh tribe made use of their geo strategic location of being in the Trade route and collected tax just like Pakistan did in the Afghan war, and in future using CPEC.
All questions, problems, and solutions that Pakistan is facing now can be found in the Quran.
Bhai bengoli, aap bohot salo se IND nahi aaye, aapko tarraki ke bare me kuch nahi pata
Sir, pak ke saath problem kya hai ye bolnewale to sekdon hain. Masla tab aata hai ke inpar Amal karne ki himmat kisme hain? Discussion ka time kab ka nikal chuka. Kya kisi main fauz ko streamline karne ki himmat hai?. Do din main PTI deh gayi. Kya koi mullaon ko kaabu kar sakta hai? Kya koi jihadi camps ko ukhad sakta hai? Kya koi religious radicalisation ko rok sakta hai? Answer- Big no. Now pak fate is sealed.
Kaisar bangali lives in fools paradise😂
Balochistan pak ka nahi hai
Free balochistan
With American sponsorship,
will India go the Pak way ???
Gdp per capita of India is 2256 USD and Pakistan is 1505 USD. India gdp growth rate in 2023 is 7.2% and Pakistan is 0.6 %. What is this fellow talking about.
22 cr papulation me corona . Fir bhi awam ko unke haal pr chhod diya. Hospitals me kuchh thabhi nahi. Pakistan kya krta. Alla ke bharose chhoda. Herd immunity kaam kr gai.
Vo paw paw atom Bomb wala roya tha ki 2 - 2 lakh ke injection mushkil se mile or bacch gaya.
Pakistan me koi record hi nahi kitne mare 😂😂😂