Drum Teacher Reaction: Black Sabbath - 'Heaven and Hell'
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 лис 2022
- SUBSCRIBE! ► ua-cam.com/users/RooneyDr...
DRUMEO 30 - Day Trial ► www.drumeo.com/andrewrooney/
DONATE | REQUEST a Reaction via PAYPAL ► www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_...
SUPPORT | BLOCKED VIDEOS | Join My Community and hit the PATREON ► / andrewrooneydrums
SWEETWATER Latest Drum and Percussion Deals ► imp.i114863.net/EaqZz2
MERCH STORE ► andrew-rooney-drums.creator-s...
BUSINESS INQUIRIES ► email | andrewrooneydrums@gmail.com
REACTION PLAYLIST ► • Drum Teacher Reaction ...
Web ► andrewrooneydrums.com/
NZ Drummer Podcast ► andrewrooneydrums.com/nz-drum...
Get My ORIGINAL 'Drums & Coffee' COFFEE MUG! ► andrew-rooney-drums.creator-s...
DRUM GEAR!
USA fans: Find the best deals on Drums and Percussion at SWEETWATER!
CURRENT DEALS! ► imp.i114863.net/EaqZz2
SWEETWATER DRUMS ► imp.i114863.net/BXKy00
NEW ARRIVALS ► imp.i114863.net/DVLeLb
Electronic Drums | Roland V-Drums TD-17KVX ► imp.i114863.net/kjZ0ev
My BUDGET THREE-MIC SETUP | • Affordable Drum Record...
4 Mic set up | • Recording Drums | 4-Mi...
My BUDGET 4-MIC RECORDING Gear list |
Vic Firth American Classic DRUMSTICKS - 5A - Wood Tip | imp.i114863.net/mg2kd7
HEADPHONES | Sony MDR-7506 | imp.i114863.net/KexGOx ($99!)
Focusrite Scarlett 18i8 3rd Gen USB Audio INTERFACE | imp.i114863.net/ZdrzKq ($419)
SNARE | Shure SM57 | imp.i114863.net/oenvLb ($99)
OVERHEAD (right side) | Audio Technica AT2020 | imp.i114863.net/EaDxZW ($99!)
OVERHEAD | Audio Technica AT2035 | imp.i114863.net/yRrvbV ($149)
KICK | Sennheiser E902 | imp.i114863.net/6bG1dK ($199)
Camera GoPro | imp.i114863.net/jWzeXM
- RING LIGHT | imp.i114863.net/vnZgaW
Additional Highly Recommended MICS:
- TOMS | Sennheiser e 904 Dynamic Drum Microphone | imp.i114863.net/a15O1N
- OVERHEADS | Shure KSM32 Large-diaphragm Condenser Microphone - Champagne | imp.i114863.net/JrJKr2
Extras Required To RECORD:
- Tama Boom Mic Stand | imp.i114863.net/x9ykA3
- XLR Cables | imp.i114863.net/VyZxa6
VOICE GEAR!
Vocal / Podcast:
Shure SM57 | imp.i114863.net/oenvLb
Shure SM7B | imp.i114863.net/Ea9EaW
Shure Beta 87A | imp.i114863.net/b3GO3g
DRUMS / CYMBALS:
Snare 1 (Recording Custom Aluminum) | imp.i114863.net/ORnr6K
Snare 2 (Ludwig Supraphonic) | imp.i114863.net/2rj1GM
Snare 3 (Ludwig Acrolite) | imp.i114863.net/3PjeVy
Yamaha Stage Custom Drum Kit | imp.i114863.net/Ea9K59
Yamaha Recording Custom Drum Kit | imp.i114863.net/NKzknP
Zildjian 22 inch K Dark Medium Ride Cymbal | imp.i114863.net/ZdXQ00
Zildjian K 14 Hi Hats | imp.i114863.net/AomWLJ
Zildjian 18 inch A Zildjian Thin Crash Cymbal | imp.i114863.net/zayN6x
DRUM HEADS:
SNARE: Remo Controlled Sound Coated Drumhead - 14 inch - with Black Dot | imp.i114863.net/yRyqRN
TOMS: Remo Emperor Coated 4-piece Tom Pack - 10/12/14/16 inch | imp.i114863.net/LPnKPV
KICK: Remo Powerstroke P3 Clear Bass Drumhead - 20 inch with 2.5 inch Impact Pad | imp.i114863.net/x9yL9x
DRUM HARDWARE (Yamaha Lightweight) | imp.i114863.net/Xx1AOa
Vic Firth American Classic DRUMSTICKS - 5A - Wood Tip | imp.i114863.net/mg2kd7
VIDEO:
Camera (Playing) GoPro | imp.i114863.net/jWzeXM
Teaching/Talking: iPhone (11)
Podcast ► andrewrooneydrums.com/nz-drum...
FREE Transcriptions ► andrewrooneydrums.com/drum-ch...
FB ► / andrewrooneydrums
Instagram ► / andrewrooneydrums
Podcast Instagram ► / nzdrummerpodcast
Podcast FB ► / newzealanddrummerpodcast
ONLINE TEACHING SETUP:
- WEBCAM | Logitech HD Pro Webcam C925e | imp.i114863.net/a1WZoq
- MIC | Audio Technica AT2035 | imp.i114863.net/yRrvbV
- Focusrite Scarlett 18i8 | USB Audio INTERFACE | imp.i114863.net/ZdrzKq
- HEADPHONES | Sony MDR-7506 | imp.i114863.net/KexGOx
- USB HUB | imp.i114863.net/EaZYDW
- RING LIGHT | imp.i114863.net/vnZgaW
- Tama Boom MIC STAND | imp.i114863.net/x9ykA3
- XLR Cables | imp.i114863.net/VyZxa6
#drummer #band #song
I think I might get in trouble for my thoughts on this one...
Thoughts and prayers for me please.
🙏 …..for you.
It's a reaction and analysis, your thoughts are your thoughts. Your honest opinion is not tainted by preconceptions.
✌️❤️🤗
The drummer on this song and the whole album is Bill Ward.
Tony, Geezer, Bill, & Dio all considered this a new band, & weren’t intending on being called Black Sabbath, because, as you say, it doesn’t sound like Black Sabbath.
But the record deal that Tony had was under the Black Sabbath name, so the record company insisted they use it.
Best to think of it as a different, but also awesome, band.
Worth noting that the different production sound (like the toms) is a lot to do with Producer Martin Birch. Who produced most of Iron Maiden’s classic albums, Deep Purple’s Machinehead, & a host of others. Was probably the biggest producer in rock music at the time
Great music but sadly not Black Sabbath hence Bill left Andrew .
Just for correct credits, Bill Ward did the studio work on this album and it's him you're listening to on this studio recording. Appice came along as the tour drummer after Ward dropped out. He then served as the drummer from that point on. Other drummer's with Sabbath were the late Cozy Powell and Bev Bevin. "Children of the Sea" is worth a listen.
Ohhh. I thought it was the other way round.. guess I was wrong 😬
I think Bill Ward left because Dio wanted him to sound like a normal rock drummer. Heaven and hell, in terms of drums, sounds like a lot of other bands, it doesn't sound like Bill Ward. I assume this made Bill Ward not work with Dio.
It's worth noting that after the Dio line up broke, Bill Ward returned and again did the studio work for "Born Again". A much under appreciated album.
@@gabrielgibson9081 love the Born Again album Andrew needs to review Bill Ward's drumming on trashed! Lol.
It's all good but I lean towards " Zero the Hero". The two song's together represent music at 190 miles per hour from start to finish.
Bill recorded the album, but left during the tour in support of the album. He was replaced by Vinnie who went on to record Mob Rules, Dehumanizer and The Devil You Know.
Ronnie is one The best rock/metal vocalists ever, Fact!
Love the Ronnie James Dio era, tons of great songs. I would also suggest you check out Dio's previous band called Rainbow. Rainbow was a creation by Ritchie Blackmore (from Deep Purple). Blackmore brought on drummer Cozy Powell for their second album and the trio was such a mix of talent. Highly suggest checking out the song "Stargazer", "Kill the King", "Light in the Black and "Gates of Babylon". Rainbow live concerts were magical, check out their 1977 Munich concert footage with songs like "Mistreated", "Man on the Silver Mountain", "Catch the Rainbow" and "Still I'm Sad" which features a Cozy Powell solo doing the "1812 Overture"
Bill Ward was on drums for the album and left the band August 21, 1980 due to severe alcoholism. Both his parents had died previously that year. He was out until 1989 when he made his first solo album.
He did drums in the studio only, for the album 'Born Again'.
@@joenorris8220 then why was Bev Bevan on the back cover credited on drums.
@@SteveVillan He wasn't.
@NUT-km3wr you're right,I was drunk when posted that comment. Although Bev did play drums on the Born Again tour,because Bill had quit again.
@@SteveVillan Understandable
Carmine pronounces his name as Apiece, Vinny as Appisee - and this isn't Vinny. This is Bill Ward on the studio version. Vinny joined Sabbath during the tour for Heaven and Hell, and his debut was on Mob Rules.
Yup I dug into that at the end of the vid. Cheers Aaron!
Yes, as others have said, it IS Bill Ward on the album. I suggest listening to Neon Knights from this album. Side note- Bill was deep in his substance issues at the time, and has said that he does not remember anything of recording the album. Glad he got the help he needed.
Neon Knights is a metal masterpiece and the drumming by Bill Ward is excellent 👌🏽
I remember an interview years ago with Bill Ward saying he was so messed up on drugs and alcohol during the recording of heaven and hell that he barely remembers making it. It was Bill on the studio version. I think Vinnie took over for the tour.
It's Ward on drums. He left the band in mid tour bcs he cudn't be in "Black sabbath" without Ozzy, especially playing Original Sabbath songs with anyone else besides Ozzy singing them, particularly the song Black Sabbath. He cudn't do it he felt like he was betraying Ozzy during that song. He was drinking himself to death at that time. He woke up on the street in an alley one morning while on tour and just went home and then to a detox and began his sobriety that he is still on today, with just a few stumbles along the way early on. I love Ward. I think he's my favorite of the bunch! and Im a singer / bass player.
Edit:
Ward came back after The Mob Rules to record Born Again with Ian Gillan on vocals and fell of the wagon early on during the tour and then dropped off the tour, replaced by Bev Bevan. That was the first Concert I ever went to back in 1983.. 7th row on the flor on Tony's side. Nassau Coliseum NY. It was Soo loud AF! Loudest music I ever heard in my life.
After Appice and after Dio there was the explosive Cozy Powell on drums and the greatly underrated Tony Martin on vocals. The most underappreciated and underrated lineup and albums ever.
“Born to Lose” is in my Top 5 Sabbath songs
@@charlesfitzgerald9631 I wouldn't say top 5 but it's certainly an excellent song.
@@SteveVillan , that riff & especially that solo really “trips my trigger” lol
Mike G: Powell was not in Sabbath until 1989, Eric Singer was their next drummer & Tony Martin blows, he was Sabbaths 2nd biggest mistake, Martin is 'Underrated for a reason & that is that he extremely sucks.
The most unappreciated and unrated period of the band.
Love how you are experiencing in 2022 what we went through in 1980-1
Thats Bill, Vinnie appears on the Mob Rules LP
Bill Ward quit on August 21st 1980 and got on his bus without saying goodbye except for a phone call to Ronnie James Dio telling him he was off. I saw them on September 26th Charlotte Coliseum North Carolina and they were amazing. John Bonham had passed away the day before on September 25th 1980 the show was dedicated to the memory of John Bonham and Vinny did a amazing drum tribute to him and the band performed a blistering 2 hour performance that evening. Dio small in size, huge singing voice and bigger heart!🤘
It’s Bill Ward on the album. Vinny replaced Ward when he quit the band in the middle of the tour. Vinny stayed on with the band & recorded the next album, The Mob Rules.
Dio’s an amazing singer. His work with Rainbow in the 70s is terrific. That’s another act you should check out, especially since the drummer was the great Cozy Powell.
It was Bill Ward who did the recording and then quit. They hired Vinnie and BTW Carmine to me was the first heavy metal drummer. Watch Vanilla Fudge You Keep me Hanging On 1967.
In 75 my parents bought me a kit because I always tapped my hands and feet, it drove them crazy. Nothing clicked and I sold my kit a year later. Then I heard this album in 80 and I got to play again but didn't have an opportunity. In 82 a Friend of mine who is a drummer needed a place to practice and my parents moved to Florida and I had an empty house and I let him and I immediately went to Heaven and Hell and Molly Hatchet. Long story short a year later my parents moved, in 04 my oldest son bought me a drum kit for my Bday and shocked me and the first album i put on was Heaven and Hell. It's the best, go Bill Ward. FYI by 08 I started to get board with it and then I discovered Opeth and Martin Lopez and to this day I only play this album and all of Martin Lopez's years with Opeth. Check out the entire album of Heaven and Hell and not only do I think they're better than Ozzy years it's Bill Wards best.
This is Bill Ward!!! Although he has said he barely remembers recording this album. Alcohol had finally got to him. Vinny Appice did the tour and also the follow up album Mob Rules
Not Vinnie ! it’s the distinctive, busy & powerful bass drum kick of Bill Ward.
After the Dio years Sabbath did one album with the Deep Purple singer called Born Again... It sounds like a sort of return to the style they had with Ozzy... I like that album quite a bit... Try the song Trashed
It's the only kinda acceptable non ozzy Sabbath album. Terrible production but great music. Still not Sabbath though. Trashed is hands down the best non ozzy Sabbath song.
Vinny has a very specific way of hitting hi-hats/ride on the kick beat.
Hi Andrew,Bill Ward plays the drums on this album.
And....for so many people Ronnie James Dio is a Metal God.Before he went to Sabbath,he was singer by Elf and Rainbow.After Sabbath he founded his own Band,DIO.
Greetings from Germany
Sorry for my english.😂
Thanks for the input!
And your English is great!
Totally different band. Produced by Martin Birch. This is the beginning of what is referred to as the New Wave of Heavy Metal. Forget about the Ozzy era when you listen to this. I challenge you to review a couple of the other tracks on this album. Try Wishing Well or Walk Away, or Die Young. Incredible grooves. But again, this was an absolutely brand new band with Ronnie James Dio at the helm. He and Iommi took the band in an entirely different direction, hence the completely different Bill Ward treatment. Bill was playing within a new set of constraints. To me, he killed it. Listen to any of those tracks I mentioned and ask yourself how another drummer would have handled it. Would have been rubbish. Despite Ward's alcoholism at the time, he still absolutely kills it on this album. He adapted.
The recorded studio version IS Bill Ward he left the band afterwards sometime during the tour.
I love this album, but I will admit not every song sounds like Bill. Indeed, a strong argument can be made that this record is a more suitable follow-up to Rainbow's 1978 album than to Black Sabbath's 1978 album.
Bill found Black Sabbath without Ozzy to be a strange place, and he wasn't comfortable in it. This is why lasted only very short stints, and didn't tour.
The album 'Technical ecstasy' is generally not people's favourite record by Sabbath, but it IS mine. The style is a little different in so far as there aren't the crunchy riffs and punchy tracks but it is really emotional. I'm wandering if Geezer or Tony was going through stuff with their wife at the time?? Please listen to 'You won't change me' 'Dirty women' and my all time favourite Sabbath track 'Gypsy' - this track just kills me, listen to the subtle use of piano and Tony Iommi's guitar genius. Even after all these years, I still don't know how someone actually wrote the songs on this album, mind blowing ..... you will enjoy it, the album is very deep.
I have the same feeling for majority of songs of 70s Black Sabbath.I still can't believe 4 guys wrote this music.They are really a unique band
I’ve thoroughly enjoyed Andrew’s long series of videos in which he’s
“discovered” Sabbath, during which I’ve come to appreciate Ozzy’s singing and lyrical contribution. Having said that…. Ronnie is a truly amazing vocalist and is my personal favorite hard rock front man of all-time. Definitely an apples to oranges comparison though.
Yup 2 completely different approaches to vocals
Bill Ward was on the album, 'Heaven And Hell'. He didn't leave the band til partway through the tour for that album.
Yes, this is Bill Ward, not Appice. Ward talked about not liking the direction the band was taking under Dio lyrically, and how he really didn't remember recording Heaven and Hell becuase he was often drunk. His favorite songs from it were Lonely is the Word, and Children of the Sea. He actually did tour with Heaven and Hell to start before leaving soon after, calling Dio to say was at the airport and leaving. That's when Appice joined. He missed all of the Mob Rules period and came back to the band to record Born Again, but didn't tour on that, either.
Bill Ward is on the drums. Appice entered the band after the first leg of the tour when Bill decided to leave
Yes :)
It is bill Ward. I have a copy of this album in my CD collection. Bill Ward is the drummer on every track of this album.
Hi Andrew. Definitely Bill Ward on the studio version of this song (the one you reviewed), Bill left after this album and Vinnie did the follow up (Mob Rules) album. That said, Bill has recounted numerous times that his alcoholism was so rampant at this point he has little memory of tracking this album.
Whomever said that it's Vinnie on drums may be thinking of a live version subsequent to Bill's departure. Cheers
So a bunch of people have already told you that this is Bill, but you're probably also being impacted by the very different production. Martin Birch, who's best known for producing Iron Maiden's seminal albums, gave them a much more modern (for the time), polished sound.
Bill Ward was on drums on the Born Again album in 1983 but did not stay for the tour. Bill and Ozzy played together for the Live Aid show for a one off show.
It's Bill Ward on drums on the album - he left after the recording. Vinnie Appice took over after that and played on every other Dio/Sabbath inluding Heaven and Hell (the band)
My (original release) copy lists Bill as the drummer - Something went wrong in your info stream . . .
But Geezer's playing on this album is worth paying attention to. Dammit - now I need to fire up the phono stage and pull out the vinyl again.
As a die hard Sabbath/ Iommi fan, I did enjoy the Dio years and after. But, it was a different animal. You could tell Bill wasn't himself on this album. I questioned a lot of punching in and out too. Great reaction 🤘
Bill Ward was the drummer in the studio but they had Vinny while touring due to Bill Wards Drinking problem. Bill Ward stated he can't remember recording this entire album
The drummer here is Bill Ward but Vinnie Appice do the tour ...Bill Ward comeback to Sabbath in 1983 in the lp "Born Again" with Ian Gillan on vocals (yes, Ian Gillan of Deep Purple) Vinnie Appice follow to Dio on his solo albums....but in 1992 Dio and Appice return to Black Sabbath! Vinnie Appice was the Dio´s drummer ... and well, Bill Ward return to Black Sabbath (with Ozzy on 1999)
It's Bill on Drums. I have the original album. Ronnie is great and a great human being but the original Sabbath line up is the classic line up. Everything else is another band. Love your channel ...
I agree totally. There's no way to duplicate what those 4 created with different players.
I love Ozzy in and out of Sabbath but damn did Dio work well with them. This song is so so good.
Nothing will be better than the four of them together. Dio was more forward in the songs vs an instrument like Ozzy was
A little slick for me. I like the more “rough around the edges (in a good way)” Sabbath.
Me too Christopher!
Bill Ward played on this album. He left mid tour. Vinnie flown in for a show they had in Hawaii and stayed on through the follow up Mob Rules and tour. Then left with Ronnie to form the Dio band. Bill rejoined to record Born Again and couldn't again do the tour and Bev Bevan ex-ELO sat behind the kit on tour. after that it was a revolving door of musicians except for Iommi. The Dio/Appice lineup rejoined for the Dehumanizer album and tour They then left again and Iommi reformed the previous incarnation of the band with Tony Martin on vocals and Cozy Powell on drums.
omg i was just wondering when the heaven and hell reaction will be yesterday lmao WOOO
Back in the day, I had a great deal of trouble accepting this band being called Black Sabbath, because of that change in sound and style, which to me is more conventional rock songs. The music is good, and Dio is a terrific rock singer, no doubt. But til this day I call this band Black Sabbath with Dio singing.
this is the title track off one of the greatest metal albums of all time. heard this when i was maybe 13 (47 now) and it's literally been one of my top 5 albums ever since. think the tempo fluctuations are either punches or just an artifact of tape speeds on the mix down...
pretty certain it's Vinnie on the drums. Lonely is the Word is a beautiful song.
this era does feel like a different vibe, a different band even but there's no denying when you hear Iommi and Butler locking in together than it's Sabbath. just a perfect album for me.
Black Sabbath recorded in the studio October 1979 to January 1980 with Bill Ward on the drums. Heaven and Hell released April 18th 1980 and Bill Ward quit while on tour August 21st 1980. Vinny a p p i c e replaced him for the rest of the tour also the recording of the Mob Rules album and tour 1981-82.
Please check out my fav Sabbath song “Dirty Women”.
Loving the Sabbath reactions and dives into the drumming, one drummer who is amazing live and would love to see your reactions to is Dave Lombardo of Slayer, songs like War Ensemble or South of Heaven at the Big 4 show in 2011 have some incredible work
Yup I did War Ensemble!
Album produced by Martin Birch who also produced Deep Purple. Interesting to consider if Ian Paice was Sabbaths drummer back in the day....
If you check out the back of the album sleeve, it's definitely Bill Ward. Vinnie did the tour
Bro please just do Sabbath bloody sabbath or sabotage, they’re great, they’re the original guys, symptom of the universe is the only track you’ve done off of those 2 awesome albums. It’s the sabbath you love, just do them man!!!
jospeh - great advice! sabbath bloody sabbath is my favorite, and sabotage is my second favorite sabbath album. i love all their albums from 1970 - 1983 (ozzy/dio/gillan). do not care for the glenn hughes/tony martin albums. dehumanizer/the devil you know/13, were o.k. i guess, but rarely ever listen to them.
There's an undeniable change between Ozzy's Sabbath and Dio's. To me it's always been about Ozzy following guitar riffs way more while Dio's vocals are more of a different melodic instrument, they tend to build more elaborate songs imo, while Ozzy's were ... raw-er I guess.
Nice! Yup total different style
Right. They changed a lot of things with Heaven and Hell, also the riffing style, totally different song writing and Ronnie‘s fantasy lyrics. And they became more commercial, less artistically daring and more self aware. Because of all of these reasons they should have used a different band name imho.
@@wernermoritz882 I don't think they had a choice. Record deals are quite binding. Especially back in the 70's through the 90's.
@@lazarusnecrosis5869 You‘re probably right. I still don‘t like it, to me it is a different band with Tony and Geezer in it.
Long live Dio, Bill Ward on the Studio version. Vinny on the Tour for the album, as well as the next one, Mob Rules.
Andrew if you would like to hear some Sabbath thrash I say give the album " Born Again" a spin. A lot of people don't like it but I happen to think it is a good album. The lead singer is Ian Gillan of Deep Purple fame. A few songs are " Disturbing the Priest", " Zero the Hero" or "Trashed"
Bill Ward did the all the drumming on the LP. Appice appeared later.
they also spray painted bill with gold paint then sprayed a clear coat on him as well. They had to rush him to the hospital because all his poors were clogged and he could not breathe
Drew! Bill Ward did the drumming on the album. Vinnie joined afterward for the tour.
I love 70s Sabbath, but Dio's first two albums with them destroy the earlier material in terms of songwriting and technical ability. They evolved into a monster of a band for a tragically short time, and could even be seen as a beacon to the NWOBHM scene that was peaking around them in the UK. \m/ \m/
No matter which drummers, singers or bassists, I still regards each Black Sabbath lead by Tony Iommi for a full range Black Sabbath. The incarnations are very different but always exiting.
Even if it turned into a bit of Spinal Tap with the singers. I’ve lost count. 😂
Tony Iommi IS Black Sabbath! ignorant Ozzy fanboyz are missing out on some great music.
@@Gil334 As a 40 year musician, and a huge fan of Iommi, the early years with Ozzy were the best, those first few albums were ground breaking , it's what Black Sabbath are renowned for. The 4 of them made magic together and wouldn't be the same with any other format.. I love Mob rules, But It's a completely different Animal...
@@MickH60 I never said early Sabbath wasn't the best. That doesn't mean the later stuff wasn't Sabbath too. It's called diversity, growth, moving on. And I'm a 61 year old, junior.🙂
Bill Ward has said in interviews that he actually has no recollection of recording this album. At the time he was having serious issues with his alcohol intake especially, along with other issues including the death of family members.
3:29 Andrew, I'm not a drummer and I see the drumm patterns of Bill.. this is Bill Ward !! The one who pushed this on was/is hnot a fan, or he would have known
A review and post of “Godsmack - Batalla De Los Tambore” would be most excellent. Definitely a good one to groove to. Thanks!
Yes Vinnie Appice and Carmen Appice pronounced their last names differently. But for the record I believe that’s the great Bill Ward playing.
Although there was turmoil, they managed to produce a fine piece of work. I consider it the Dio Sabbath band. one of my favourite albums of all time. I don't really think of it as Sabbath. I just love it for what it is.
✌️❤️🤗
Great reaction/review! As everybody says, this is Bill Ward! Bill left, but also came back for Born Again. I love this album, and the next one, Mob Rules is great too. And Dehumanizer with Dio is worth checking out. Dio was such a force that he made his version of Sabbath unique. Appice went on to play on Dio’s first few solo albums, then came back for Dehumanizer and played in Heaven and Hell with Dio, Iommi, and Butler.
For me is this album Black Sabbath (and the "Mob Rules" too) and nothing else. Yes, different singer, but Black Sabbath it is.
You are 100% correct about the surnames. Vinnie uses a slightly Americanized version of the traditional Italian pronunciation, but Carmine uses the weirdly Anglicised version Rod Stewart insisted on using for him. Rod Stewart would always introduce Carmine as "a piece", and it stuck.
Hi Andrew..Yes this is Bill Ward on the studio album but Vinnie came aboard for the tours bc sadly Bill Ward was very far gone on booze and substances...They did change the production on this album making it sound up to date to what was happening in the early 80's...Peace ✌️
Check out song called Die young from this album,if you haven't already..
Watching this reminds me that you should do Stargazer by Rainbow with Cozy Powell (R.I.P.) on drums, Ronnie James Dio on vocals and Richie Blackmore on guitar.
just saw neil peart checking the 30th anniversary dw drum kit. just soloing.
I'm sure it's already mentioned in the comment section, but they played the tempo change live as well.. slowed even more, live... IMO.
If you want to check out Sabbath w/Appice on drums, I would suggest "Falling Off The Edge of the World" from Mob Rules. Great job as always!
Its Bill Ward on Heaven and Hell album.
Vinny took over during the tour
Listen to this and then listen to Mob Rules (the album), there's such a stark difference.
It's Bill Ward. Without question.
Appice is fine, but he's a bog slogger.
It's like the difference between Mitch and Buddy playing behind Jimi.
drums aside, how is that base line when the tempo picks up ....furious ...and iommi shredding one of Sabbaths greatest tracks.
🙌
Hey andrew , have you thought about { you may have already } doing some phil rudd assessments/reviews ? Riff Raff is a great one if you want to . Dude is a human metronome.@@AndrewRooneyDrums
I haven't read about this anywhere, just my opinion, my own narrative probably. Black Sabbath didn't just change members around this album, they were very aware of the New Wave of British Heavy Metal, and altered their own game, (which was the game that inspired all those NWOBHM bands) to keep up with the sounds of the times.
Bill Ward recorder the album but then left before the tour .
Look at the back of the album cover it will tell you who is in the band and they're on the back cover
Appice is " Appitchè" its italian.
They did prononced Appees and Appessey for americans that struggle a lot with Romances languages spelling .
One of the songs ever!!
Bill Ward’s comments about Dio’s lyrics were very apt and certainly something I agree with him on. Geezer was a much better lyricist and certainly more “real” with subject matter.
I always felt Dio was too melodramatic in everything he did. Overly theatrical and certainly loved the medieval fantasy genre in full cliché.
Some people love it, but it’s just not my bag, baby! This album though was the best Dio album of all the bands he was in.
Brodie Bradley gave you some wrong information. This album is with Bill Ward. Vinny's first album with Black Sabbath was the Mob Rules album which was released after Heaven and Hell.
actually Bill Ward was still drumming on this album...
YUP
I agree with your comments; Black Sabbath just changed after the original lineup split. Great music but a totally different band, and let's not even talk about the post-Dio era 😅🤣
And Dio is one of the best metal vocalists ever. You should totally check out a couple more songs from this album, it's a good one.
On the album sleeve it says Bill Ward was the drummer. The next album Mob Rules Vinnie Appice is the drummer
Bill Ward played drums on this album. Later on, he claimed not to remember anything about the sessions.
Bill Ward was the drummer on this album. Vinnie's 1st with Sabbath was Mob Rules.
Bill struggled in the studio for this album claiming he was drunk most of the time and that he doesn't even remember recording the album. Despite all that the album went on to respark Black Sabbath's career and remains one of their best selling albums. I listen to Ozzy era Sabbath as well as Dio era material. They're different but equally good.
Yeah I'm sure that both eras have their moments!!
Bill Ward played the drums on this recording.
Appice was drummer in Vanilla fudge he claims when opening for Zeppelin in 68 that's where Bonham got the triplets from watching Appice play take in for what it's worth Appice played on the tour when ward's left the studio version is ward
They were around decades before that. I'm guessing Bonham heard them on jazz records
@@AndrewRooneyDrums Vanilla Fudge released their first album in 1967. Toured with Led Zeppelin in 1968. Carmine a p p i c e was a big influence on John Bonham. A p p i c e born 1946 Bonham born 1948. Vinny was 23 years old when he joined Sabbath born 1957. Bonham mentioned to a p p i c e about how he liked his triplets to which he replied he wasn't even aware of them. The jazz/ Funk drummer is Bernard p u r d i e John Bonham also admired him.
Greetings, Andy Rooney,Bill Ward is the drummer on the Heaven and He'll album Vinnie Appice did not play on an album until The Mob Rules album. However Bill Ward dropped out of Heaven and he'll tour prior to the Hawaiian concert ,Bill Ward's drinking got the better of him.But Bill Wards rejoined in 1983 and Bill Ward is the drummer on the Born Again Album, but dropped out for the tour for the Born Again Tour and was replaced by Bev Bevan.
I think you might like Hollowed Be They Name by Iron Maiden. The official video, it's live.
Take a look at the back cover for line up
Decapitated-"25 year anniversary tour warm up rehearsal-mother war" :)
Can you give a listen to "jazz sabbath" rat salad any many other classic songs would be Awesome to see your reaction much respect 👍🇬🇧
Hey Andrew, here's another metal request for ya. The song I'm talking about is First Fragment - Soif brûlante (drum playthrough by Nicholas Le Fou Wells). Hope to see it on your channel mate!
I am a huge Sabbath fan and a Dio fan and the Dio years don't feel like Sabbath to me either even though I really like both Heaven and Hell and Mob Rules. My first exposure to them was the Ozzy years. I have a friend who prefers the Dio Sabbath but his first exposure was Heaven and Hell.
This is where I left Sabbath. Not a Dio fan. I think it would be cool if you could look at some Keith Moon. The video from The Rolling Stones Rock and Roll Circus is killer with them doing a Quick One While He's Away. Another cool guy to check out would be Mitch Mitchell. Maybe I Don't Live Today or Straight Ahead.
You should react to Ingo schwichtenberg Eagle Fly Free drum cam video, would be pretty cool he was the original drummer for the powermetal band Helloween
Great as always, Andrew! One of the things I enjoy about your reactions is that you put in the homework and try to provide a good thoughtful analysis beyond, "I didn't like that" or "That was good." Bill Ward drummed on this album, but my understanding was that he was struggling personally with a lot of substance issues, including acid. The slowdown of the beat on this has always been a distraction to me, which didn't sound like it happened on live performances on this with Vinnie Appice (APP-eh-see). From what I've read, Iommi wanted Dio, which was resisted strongly by the band's manager at the time, until he was ultimately overruled. Interestingly, later on, Dio was replaced by the very underrated singer Tony Martin, and the drumming was taken over by another former member of Rainbow, the great Cozy (Colin Flooks) Powell, who unfortunately passed away in a traffic accident in 1998 going 104 mph (167 kph) in bad weather on the M4 in England at the age of 50. There has always been a big debate among fans as to which singer they prefer. The guitar playing by Iommi on this song is outstanding and is a classic.
I need to go through in album order and hear the evolution. Fascinating stuff Mike. Thanks!
Black Sabbath manager in 1980 was Don Arden father of Sharon Arden AKA Sharon Osbourne. Tony wasn't able to fire him! Ronnie James Dio formed his own band Dio and Ian g i l l a n became the lead vocalist for Black Sabbath for one year well Don Arden was still the manager for them. It wasn't until 1987 when Tony Martin became the vocalist on the Eternal Idol album. Who was replaced by Ronnie James Dio in 1992 who got replaced by Tony Martin in 1994 LOL. Good luck keeping up with that history never mind it Glenn Hughes was the vocalist for the 1986 album Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi 7th star. Haha!
@@richardhincemon9423 I see after looking back that Arden was overruled, but his contract was not terminated at that time.
@@mikeg.4211 Don Arden remained the manager during the born again album and tour, seventh star album and tour, the Eternal Idol album which was the last one for Warner Brothers records when they were finally able to get rid of manager, businessman Don Arden. Tony Iommi and cozy Powell signed with IRS records in 1989 for the recording of the Headless cross album when their management became miles Copeland III owner of IRS records and the brother of Stewart Copeland drummer for The Police.
@@richardhincemon9423, yes.
Saw a comment on another video suggesting The Blister Exists by Slipknot! Please add it to your “joey video” playlist. Its a great song.
It’s fascinating watching you have the same reaction to the new Sabbath sound we all had when it first came out. I love the Dio Sabbath stuff but nothing is better than the original Sabbath.
When Ronnie joined they should have changed. There name to a least Sabbath.
Heaven and Hell and Mob Rules are fantastic albums and I am an old school Sabbath fan
I must stringently disagree. The three Dio era albums are hands down the best. Frankly, I think Ozzy is heavily overrated.
Didn't like it then still hate it 40+ years later. Anything called Sabbath without Ozzy is crap.
@@shspurs1342 They had a record deal. The record company probably wouldn't allow them to change their name without counting it as a breach of contract and dropping them.