Why ? Everything is sacred, water, air, the ground, it really does not matter if you are a hindu or an atheist or a muslim..........Did you read the vedas or a re you a cultural Hindu ? ( like me, i was raised with rituals and superstitions and festivities, called hinduism, very much filled superiority complex, so arrogant- these so called Hindus. wtf is Hindu ? It is different every 40 mk and every 10 years......and filled with hate sometimes, waht is hindu and what is culture ? ) Better read the Vedas, learn a bit of Sanskrit
Who said Haidava culture is scripture based..we have no the ultimate creater..our only value is moksha ie literature please seek the truth rather than mug up beliefs..
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna. Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
Please stay true to your art & humanity Mansiya! I feel sorry for the poor decision of these so called temple ”authorities" and their orthodoxy. Not all Hindus are narrow minded and myopic 🙏🏼
Secular dhimmi gadhe !!! If she loves HIndu dharm so much she can definitely do ghar wapsi to Hindu Dharm. Also, dancing singing are haram in Islam. So, what is she doing in Islam? Leave Islam and come back to Hindu Dharm. Class Hindu temple dance is kufr in Islam. She can't do both stay in Islam and also do Hindu classical dance.
Why should we be sorry for Temple rules? They are not wrong. The temple is for Hindu devotees. If she wants so much craving to perform at temple then become a Hindu and then perform. Is a non-muslim allowed to enter Mecca and Medina? No, right? Then respect the rules of religious intitution or get out of there. It's a religious place, not a playground. Stupid.
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
Fought orthodox muslims to learn bharatnatyam and now she is fighting with Orthodox hindus... Don't know when this society will progress, shame on mentality of indian society
Why are women always exploited... She is right Here is women who is futuristic in approach so positive in life ... all those rigid hard strong religious .....Listen to her .. What a beautiful thought perspective all the best ..May you be happy 🙏🙏👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Some ppl are saying that Hindus are not allow to go to masjid and all. See if Muslims don't allow hindus does that mean we should not allow it. We have to show how them we are welcoming ppl. Hindu is a religion which accept and respect others
If don't believe in religion then don't do bharatanatyam cause it is a religious dance of hindusim. And also those fools who is saying art has no religion so for your information hindusim is combination of (art,dance,music and religion) that's why we call hindusim a way of life
@@aashayj Bharatanatyam is a major Hindu form of Indian classical dance that originated in the modern-day region of Tamil Nadu. The Natya Shastra by Bharata Muni. It is one of eight widely recognized Indian classical dance forms and it expresses South Indian religious themes and spiritual ideas, particularly of Shaivism, Vaishnavism and Shaktism, collectively Hinduism. Link of wikipedia en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bharatanatyam
Even the great singer yesudas was never allowed to enter guruvayoor temple even though his devotional hindu songs are played everywhere in kerala, so it's nothing new.
tell that to Muslims who are using Yazidi's as sex slaves and tell that to Turks what are they doing to armenians... just because they do not follow their own religion...
@@motabhai7287 no woman is allowed to Masajit for namaz. In temple Hindu would look the dance with humble and respect in the name Hindu God but non Hindu may perform the art with mocking the witnesses
@@brajabashisurendra429 Okay So we are comparing ourselves with Islam now? Well she was a Muslim girl in a Muslim family who gave up her religion. You ppl keep saying hijab/burqa, well she is dancing bharatnatyam, wearing bindi. What more do you want? What more she has to do for you to say she is one of us?
Temple is not a public auditorium. And Classical dance is salutations to hindu gods. You cant be atheist and perform bharat natyam on Radha nad krishna at the same time. If you do you will be cheating yourselves and your audience. And besides there is a photoof this lady doing classical dance with Flag of communist party in hand. LOL> Classic communist dance.
Shameful..! This was the difference b/w hinduism and other faiths.. the ability to accept and still thrive.. an all encompassing religion and at the same time not a religion at all if measured against strict definitions of the word. We can't be losing this, we shall never lose this.
Secular Gaandu! ability to accept what, Virus of Islam and Christianity, shall we Hindu accept tham also. Do hv proper knowledge of abrahamic cults, then give secular sermons.
If it had been decimated, me and you wouldn't have been hindus today, but that's not to say that repeated attempts at decimation weren't made. still around 86% follow hinduism and hinduism derived off shoots in India. Which means we survived.. we survived the onslaught and lived to tell the tale unlike so many ancient religious which were wiped out by the organised abrahamic faiths. There is inherent greatness in Hinduism, no doubt about that. It's not for nothing that hinduism is also referred to as sanatan dharm.
Performing Artists Dilemma discussed with all shades n colors n abeaming smile that cast relevant questions for the spiritual believers and also simply Human beliefs*
God, or the energy - as I like to call it, belongs to all. As a rule, the places of worship, art and architecture should be open to all and most definitely to artists. Ustaad Bismillah Khan was a devout Muslim as well as a devotee of Saraswati. Let’s not get artists into our petty politics.
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
@4:55 she should loose her faith in islam not in all religions. Never Hindus said I lost in faith in all religions because of some theft or other illegal stuff done my Hindu community.
Lol few days back the same Hijabi girls were protesting to wear Hijab as their "fundamental right" .... They also chanted slogans of Allah hu akbar and Hijab over Kitab.... Now they're saying dance is my only religion? Why are the muslims in India so confused about their religion? And Burkha Dutt glad to see you alive and still covering anti India stories!! Great job...Now we'll have more roast material ;)
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna. Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
@@sumithraroy7303 First of all why are u using Hindu names to hide ur real identity? Are u ashamed of being a muslim? Secondly, you have nothing to counter my words, so u talk about Ram.... Why are muslim girls even dancing in temples? Is not haram?? Iska hijab kaha hai ab? kaha gaya iska fundamental right ab?
The only way this country can go forward and come out of being a part of the 3rd world country is being tolerant towards each other's religion, caste etc🙏🙏
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
@@mehnurevolution.899 . Here I think she is talking about a muslim woman not being allowed to dance in a temple.. atleast she should be allowed to worship ina Mosques
If the Temple is for Hindus worshippers and devotees, why should any non-Hindu be allowed into the Temple premises? It's a religious place, not a playground or public place. Would any non-muslim and non-muslim be allowed to enter Mecca and Medina or Vatican Church meant for religious devotees? No, right? Then DON'T MAKE A FUSS ABOUT HINDU TEMPLES! Each religious place and institution has its rules and that must be respected and abided. Otherwise you hurt the sentiments of that religious community. If this dancer has so craving to perform at Hindu temple, vecome a Hindu and then perform. What's a big deal? Unnecessarily making an issue and creating controversy to demean Hinduism and Hindu Temples. Disgusting.
GREAT MINDS BECAUSE OF THEIR BEST PRACTICES AND STANDARDS IRRESPECTIVE OF RELIGION , ENERGIES TEMPLES . EVEN THEIR ATTENDANTS HAS TO FOLLOW THEIR GUIDELINES TO MEET THEIR STANDARDS.
Muslim refused islamic burial to your mother is because of her own beliefs or becos you are a classical dancer ? What is Ortodox muslims...are they muslims who practice islam or muslims who are extreme ? How did denial of burial as per islamic practice became an issue here becos you can also do burial as per hindu or christian practice, since you are not practicing islam anyway ? Just having a muslim name or by birth does not make anyone a muslim, right ? And why is muslim denial called no-tolerance by the anchor and hindu temple denial called tradition ?
Though I don't support the temple for what they did but I think giving half truth as per agenda is dangerous.. she's nt stopped dancing everywhere bt only in temple.. & I think as institutions temples also hv rights
No. Temple rules must be respected and abided. If she wants to perform in the temple, then better become a Hindu and then perform. Or perform somewhere else where Temples allow non-Hindus to enter, like Vishwanath Temple or Mathura, Vrindavan Prem Mandir.
Temple dance is for Hindus belief devotion to the deity of temple, not a stage to show dance performance. If she is so devoted to the deity of the temple, then she can become Hindu & do ghar wapsi. cuz, doing Hindu classical devotional dance and doing Allah namaaz can't go togetgher. It is shirk according to Islam. So, leave Islam and become Hindu.
@@slmsinghania Absolutely. People who are non-Hindus jump quickly to comment on Hindu rituals and customs. Who the hell gave them any locus standi to speak or comment on Hinduism when we don't interfere into theirs? And those Hindus who have so much problem with the rules, take note of it: DO NOT VISIT THE TEMPLE, THEN! As simple as that. Temple rituals and customs won't change as per your whims and caprice. These are religious customs, Not your PMS/Mood Swings, damn it!!!
@@shubhashishdwivedi9873 Vedic sanatan dharm allows one to question existence of god. She is nastik and well within the framework of vedic sanatan dharm because of her closeness towards vedic sanatan sanskriti and being married to a hindu man.
I am a “common Hindu”. Don’t speak on my behalf. I do not want a Muslim to dance before my temple or my God. If you feel she deserves a platform to showcase her dance, my God’s temple is not a place for that. By all means invite her to your house to perform.
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna. Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
She can continue to dance anywhere else. Why create a new controversy ? Barakha please avoid raising such diecy issues. The special community is not likely to change as a result of such attempts. She seems to be a Muslim in heart 💖
Well Upanishads say dance in temple is ritual just like mantra , every step in these dance are telling story , and she is saying she does not belive in religion but by doing this dance she just performing ritual , is not it's contradictory herself
Secularism ka theka sirf hinduo ne nahi le rakha. Why only Hindus are expected to allow everything in their temples. For them it's their religion everytime and for us Hindus, we are required to follow secularism
What a unique level of hypocrisy.. a popular mohiniattam dancer's show was stopped by a high court judge. But you didn't say anything because he belongs to the secular religion but now you are covering this story. Hence proved whatever story this channel covers is against Hindus only.
If she loves HIndu dharm so much she can definitely do ghar wapsi to Hindu Dharm. Also, dancing singing are haram in Islam. So, what is she doing in Islam? Leave Islam and come back to Hindu DHarm.
We don't need hee. If she is that interested, she can go and dance in a mosque. Today they wanna dance, tomorrow they will ask for namaz in out temples. Better to show them there place at the start only. Secularism ka theka hinduo ne nahi le rakha.
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna. Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
It's her choice if she is renouncing religion and decides to live without any religion..... How should name impact.... Where is vasudhaiv.... If it is a state governed temple... Than it's a public place.... If it is a religious trust managed place they can certainly take a call on who should perform.... No one should question. It is their right to decide. Religion is a personal matter, and religious places are subjective from the devotees emotions... So that is also a personal matter...
First give permission to muslim women to enter masjid, then lecture Vasudheiva Kutumbakam. She can do ghar wapsi and do HIndu classical dance in Hindu temple. And Hindu mandir is not public place, Mind ur language bastard Jihadi.
Talk about your religion first. They ostracised her as apostate. Says a lot about Islam's inclusiveness. More fingers point at your religion way too more.
@@babarkhan1782 Yes you did talk of religion Look into your religion. You don't have locus standi to speak about our religion. You are no one to dictate to us about Hindu rituals. So, STFU.
Reading about ancient India especial from Bihar part where I belong to.... Our ancestor were creating new thought new so called religions there were so many out of them buddhism Jainism survived and they were all questioning each other.... But coming of Abrahamic religion created something in Indian religion which started imitating them.... Like Haram thing.... There is no definition of what is Hindu who is Hindu....i read some Hindu book and then see around and feel where are Hindus? Don't follow anything Hindu except few cultural thing which might also be followed by some non Hindu... Am I not Hindu? What am I? I do philosophical part of indic religions
Need to really appreciate her parents to stand against all odds and her commitment for the dance is really commendable.
Dance comes from the Nrtya Sastra, which is a part of the Upaveda called Gandharva-veda. If dance really is your religion, then convert to Hinduism.
r you ashamed we don't convert others
Why ? Everything is sacred, water, air, the ground, it really does not matter if you are a hindu or an atheist or a muslim..........Did you read the vedas or a re you a cultural Hindu ? ( like me, i was raised with rituals and superstitions and festivities, called hinduism, very much filled superiority complex, so arrogant- these so called Hindus. wtf is Hindu ? It is different every 40 mk and every 10 years......and filled with hate sometimes, waht is hindu and what is culture ? ) Better read the Vedas, learn a bit of Sanskrit
@@johnny_____5432 Who is saying, a converted christian
Who said Haidava culture is scripture based..we have no the ultimate creater..our only value is moksha ie literature please seek the truth rather than mug up beliefs..
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna.
Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
May god bless you and Her with fame and wealth
Please stay true to your art & humanity Mansiya! I feel sorry for the poor decision of these so called temple ”authorities" and their orthodoxy. Not all Hindus are narrow minded and myopic 🙏🏼
Secular dhimmi gadhe !!! If she loves HIndu dharm so much she can definitely do ghar wapsi to Hindu Dharm. Also, dancing singing are haram in Islam. So, what is she doing in Islam? Leave Islam and come back to Hindu Dharm. Class Hindu temple dance is kufr in Islam. She can't do both stay in Islam and also do Hindu classical dance.
Whether christan and Hindu women can perform dance or enter in Masajit
Why Hindus should not be orthodox ?
Why should we be sorry for Temple rules? They are not wrong. The temple is for Hindu devotees. If she wants so much craving to perform at temple then become a Hindu and then perform. Is a non-muslim allowed to enter Mecca and Medina? No, right? Then respect the rules of religious intitution or get out of there. It's a religious place, not a playground. Stupid.
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
Fought orthodox muslims to learn bharatnatyam and now she is fighting with Orthodox hindus... Don't know when this society will progress, shame on mentality of indian society
Why are women always exploited...
She is right Here is women who is futuristic in approach so positive in life ... all those rigid hard strong religious .....Listen to her ..
What a beautiful thought perspective all the best ..May you be happy 🙏🙏👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
This is painful. She needs to be allowed Bharatnatyam.
Nobody is stopping her from dancing...it's just dancing in temple is forbidden by a muslim girl..no matter how much she likes the art
Bharatnatyam is Hindu Art. If you dont believe in Hinduism, then keep yourself out of our Temple. Its a Place of Devotion.
Some ppl are saying that Hindus are not allow to go to masjid and all. See if Muslims don't allow hindus does that mean we should not allow it. We have to show how them we are welcoming ppl. Hindu is a religion which accept and respect others
Hypocrites are in every religion and no one understands that humanity is the true religion why can't people understand
Humanity is true religion then stop fighting against triple talaq and nikah halala. Hypocrites
Hijabi gang ki Jihadin. Ghazwat-Ul-Hind ki agent. Give lectures on humanity to Taliban.
@@dollwatibhat221 Proved what?
If don't believe in religion then don't do bharatanatyam cause it is a religious dance of hindusim. And also those fools who is saying art has no religion so for your information hindusim is combination of (art,dance,music and religion) that's why we call hindusim a way of life
@@aashayj When you don't have enough knowledge about hindusim then don't shit with your mouth first do research then speak. Emotional fools 😒
@@aashayj Bharatanatyam is a major Hindu form of Indian classical dance that originated in the modern-day region of Tamil Nadu. The Natya Shastra by Bharata Muni. It is one of eight widely recognized Indian classical dance forms and it expresses South Indian religious themes and spiritual ideas, particularly of Shaivism, Vaishnavism and Shaktism, collectively Hinduism.
Link of wikipedia
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bharatanatyam
Even the great singer yesudas was never allowed to enter guruvayoor temple even though his devotional hindu songs are played everywhere in kerala, so it's nothing new.
Toooo enter Mecca ONLY for Muslims. All world respect. Same HINDU temple only for Hindus . Reason .....if have faith please convert and enter
Seriously sad to see how religion has become a weapon to divide humanity😢!
tell that to Muslims who are using Yazidi's as sex slaves and tell that to Turks what are they doing to armenians... just because they do not follow their own religion...
Let her dance in public hall/theatre. Temple is restricted for Hindu
No. Whoever wants to can come to temple.
@@motabhai7287 no woman is allowed to Masajit for namaz. In temple Hindu would look the dance with humble and respect in the name Hindu God but non Hindu may perform the art with mocking the witnesses
@@brajabashisurendra429 Okay So we are comparing ourselves with Islam now?
Well she was a Muslim girl in a Muslim family who gave up her religion. You ppl keep saying hijab/burqa, well she is dancing bharatnatyam, wearing bindi. What more do you want? What more she has to do for you to say she is one of us?
@@brajabashisurendra429 Thats what differenciates us from others
Temple is not a public auditorium. And Classical dance is salutations to hindu gods. You cant be atheist and perform bharat natyam on Radha nad krishna at the same time.
If you do you will be cheating yourselves and your audience. And besides there is a photoof this lady doing classical dance with Flag of communist party in hand. LOL> Classic communist dance.
Shameful..! This was the difference b/w hinduism and other faiths.. the ability to accept and still thrive.. an all encompassing religion and at the same time not a religion at all if measured against strict definitions of the word. We can't be losing this, we shall never lose this.
That’s why Hinduism has been decimated because of this misunderstanding of vampire religions
Secular Gaandu! ability to accept what, Virus of Islam and Christianity, shall we Hindu accept tham also. Do hv proper knowledge of abrahamic cults, then give secular sermons.
@@slmsinghania your language shows you aren't even a good human being, leave alone a good Hindu.
If it had been decimated, me and you wouldn't have been hindus today, but that's not to say that repeated attempts at decimation weren't made. still around 86% follow hinduism and hinduism derived off shoots in India. Which means we survived.. we survived the onslaught and lived to tell the tale unlike so many ancient religious which were wiped out by the organised abrahamic faiths. There is inherent greatness in Hinduism, no doubt about that. It's not for nothing that hinduism is also referred to as sanatan dharm.
@@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386 lol aatnkwadi aur rapsit religion wale🤣🤣
Performing Artists Dilemma discussed with all shades n colors n abeaming smile that cast relevant questions for the spiritual believers and also simply Human beliefs*
Very nice interview ……Manisiya tons of good wishes and blessings to you. Please don’t change …be the way you are 👍👍
God, or the energy - as I like to call it, belongs to all. As a rule, the places of worship, art and architecture should be open to all and most definitely to artists. Ustaad Bismillah Khan was a devout Muslim as well as a devotee of Saraswati. Let’s not get artists into our petty politics.
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
She can perform any where, but in Hindu temple. If she wants to perform in temple then she needs to convert to Hinduism. it is as simple as that.
@4:55 she should loose her faith in islam not in all religions. Never Hindus said I lost in faith in all religions because of some theft or other illegal stuff done my Hindu community.
I am a born Hindu and I can clearly say I don't have faith in any religion, what are you upto?
IF DANCE IS HER ONLY RELIGION THEN SHE MUST OPEN A DANCE SCHOOL ,
Any Art = worshipping God .Denying someone to perform their art is next to denying God
She doesn’t even believe in a god, so her dance remains merely a dance. It is not an act of worship.
She doesn't belive in that god. She believes in a sky daddy.
Lol few days back the same Hijabi girls were protesting to wear Hijab as their "fundamental right" .... They also chanted slogans of Allah hu akbar and Hijab over Kitab.... Now they're saying dance is my only religion? Why are the muslims in India so confused about their religion? And Burkha Dutt glad to see you alive and still covering anti India stories!! Great job...Now we'll have more roast material ;)
They are not confused. They are doing doing AL-Taquiya to confuse us Hindus. SO, Hindus should not get trapped into it.
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna.
Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
So hindus can sought jai shri ram, that is okay, but muslims cannot chant Allah hu akbar, what crap hypocrite you guys are
@@sumithraroy7303 First of all why are u using Hindu names to hide ur real identity? Are u ashamed of being a muslim? Secondly, you have nothing to counter my words, so u talk about Ram.... Why are muslim girls even dancing in temples? Is not haram?? Iska hijab kaha hai ab? kaha gaya iska fundamental right ab?
@@slmsinghania who even cares about them
At least there is no blasphemy law 👍
A Hindu is a Hindu . You can dance with Shiva .
Om nama shivaya
Privileged kashmiri pandits and poor muslim..wasn't that ur remark.. same the Hindu people are doing same..
Devaswom minister must resign
Hindu refers to a geographical identity. It is not a belief system where everyone should inevitably go through the same machine to get processed😂
The only way this country can go forward and come out of being a part of the 3rd world country is being tolerant towards each other's religion, caste etc🙏🙏
Hindus can assimilate Christians and Muslims in their culture, but how many Muslims or Christians are willing to recognize Krishna or Shiva as a Universal God? That's Sarva Dharma Samabhav for you. A practicing Abrahamic can never recognize your Idols. They're just 'False Gods.'
@@solo.108 in your dreams
even first world countries have the same perception.
Do females go to Mosques and if not then why this Discrimination..kindly speak for women's rights to go to mosque..let them be from any religion
Why are everyone so concerned abt muslim women rights?? Why don't you take care of your own rights?
@@mehnurevolution.899 . Here I think she is talking about a muslim woman not being allowed to dance in a temple.. atleast she should be allowed to worship ina Mosques
@@nehaagrawal1903 😄😄👍👍
Because she is a hindu. Hindus barred entry of hindu woman
@@hai-pn8xr ..she is not a Hindu..muslim woman who does not believe in God.
Art has no religion.
If the Temple is for Hindus worshippers and devotees, why should any non-Hindu be allowed into the Temple premises? It's a religious place, not a playground or public place. Would any non-muslim and non-muslim be allowed to enter Mecca and Medina or Vatican Church meant for religious devotees? No, right? Then DON'T MAKE A FUSS ABOUT HINDU TEMPLES!
Each religious place and institution has its rules and that must be respected and abided. Otherwise you hurt the sentiments of that religious community. If this dancer has so craving to perform at Hindu temple, vecome a Hindu and then perform. What's a big deal?
Unnecessarily making an issue and creating controversy to demean Hinduism and Hindu Temples. Disgusting.
Hindus have to stop saying All religion equal. These abrahamic cults are exploiting and taking illegal advantage of it.
GREAT MINDS BECAUSE OF THEIR BEST PRACTICES AND STANDARDS IRRESPECTIVE OF RELIGION , ENERGIES TEMPLES . EVEN THEIR ATTENDANTS HAS TO FOLLOW THEIR GUIDELINES TO MEET THEIR STANDARDS.
Muslim refused islamic burial to your mother is because of her own beliefs or becos you are a classical dancer ? What is Ortodox muslims...are they muslims who practice islam or muslims who are extreme ? How did denial of burial as per islamic practice became an issue here becos you can also do burial as per hindu or christian practice, since you are not practicing islam anyway ? Just having a muslim name or by birth does not make anyone a muslim, right ? And why is muslim denial called no-tolerance by the anchor and hindu temple denial called tradition ?
Super👌👌👌👌
Though I don't support the temple for what they did but I think giving half truth as per agenda is dangerous.. she's nt stopped dancing everywhere bt only in temple.. & I think as institutions temples also hv rights
Please come back to your roots and accept Sanatan Dharma.... Become a Hindu and trust me the World will be at your feet
Please let her dance in temple. I am 100% sure most of the common hindus won't even bother.
No. Temple rules must be respected and abided. If she wants to perform in the temple, then better become a Hindu and then perform. Or perform somewhere else where Temples allow non-Hindus to enter, like Vishwanath Temple or Mathura, Vrindavan Prem Mandir.
Temple dance is for Hindus belief devotion to the deity of temple, not a stage to show dance performance. If she is so devoted to the deity of the temple, then she can become Hindu & do ghar wapsi. cuz, doing Hindu classical devotional dance and doing Allah namaaz can't go togetgher. It is shirk according to Islam. So, leave Islam and become Hindu.
@@slmsinghania Absolutely. People who are non-Hindus jump quickly to comment on Hindu rituals and customs. Who the hell gave them any locus standi to speak or comment on Hinduism when we don't interfere into theirs?
And those Hindus who have so much problem with the rules, take note of it: DO NOT VISIT THE TEMPLE, THEN! As simple as that.
Temple rituals and customs won't change as per your whims and caprice. These are religious customs, Not your PMS/Mood Swings, damn it!!!
@@shubhashishdwivedi9873 Vedic sanatan dharm allows one to question existence of god. She is nastik and well within the framework of vedic sanatan dharm because of her closeness towards vedic sanatan sanskriti and being married to a hindu man.
I am a “common Hindu”. Don’t speak on my behalf. I do not want a Muslim to dance before my temple or my God. If you feel she deserves a platform to showcase her dance, my God’s temple is not a place for that. By all means invite her to your house to perform.
It would be good if research is done on Air pollution or something of significance
Don't exploit this issue shamelessly.
Respect the temple tradition and do it outside. Shame on Burkha for bringing non-issues for publicity purpose.
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna.
Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
Exploit?! Shame on the temple.
@@WhatsInAName222 shame on masjid where no woman is allowed to enter
Inspirational. Truly all religions does is to divide people. Use them as vote banks .
I wish this women reaches her goals .
Ask her to go to Mosque and dance.
Lmao 😂😂😂😂 fatwa nikal jayega
Nice story. Thank you.
Pls allow her to dance in masjid
@@anukapoor258 randi khana mandir hai to whi nach gana hoga na.
She can continue to dance anywhere else.
Why create a new controversy ?
Barakha please avoid raising such diecy issues.
The special community is not likely to change as a result of such attempts.
She seems to be a Muslim in heart 💖
Did God say only hindus should perform?
@@sumithraroy7303 why females not allowed in Mosques
@@sumithraroy7303 YES , BECAUSE ISLAM SAYS MUSIC , DANCE , ARTS IS HARAM
@@sumithraroy7303 God did not, but are you a left liberal ?
Well Upanishads say dance in temple is ritual just like mantra , every step in these dance are telling story , and she is saying she does not belive in religion but by doing this dance she just performing ritual , is not it's contradictory herself
Secularism ka theka sirf hinduo ne nahi le rakha. Why only Hindus are expected to allow everything in their temples. For them it's their religion everytime and for us Hindus, we are required to follow secularism
Mansiya is an perfect example of love kurukshetra victim
What a unique level of hypocrisy.. a popular mohiniattam dancer's show was stopped by a high court judge. But you didn't say anything because he belongs to the secular religion but now you are covering this story. Hence proved whatever story this channel covers is against Hindus only.
If she loves HIndu dharm so much she can definitely do ghar wapsi to Hindu Dharm. Also, dancing singing are haram in Islam. So, what is she doing in Islam? Leave Islam and come back to Hindu DHarm.
She is not Muslim. She is an atheist
We don't need hee. If she is that interested, she can go and dance in a mosque. Today they wanna dance, tomorrow they will ask for namaz in out temples. Better to show them there place at the start only. Secularism ka theka hinduo ne nahi le rakha.
Shree Mangesh Devasthan, Mangeshi Goa, prevented Late Shree Dinanath Mangeshker, BharatRatna Lata's father, from singing in temple premises based on some quaint archaic pseudo-religious arguments. Master Dinanath, a famous Sangit naatak stage artist of his times, died in utter poverty and little Lata with her three siblings struggled her way to the top and went on to become BharatRatna.
Mansiya, you too will reach the top one day.
@@umanathkakodker4412 stop spamming troll
Art unites poeple, Religion divides.
Please judge people on the basis of their identity and not religion-identity.
PLEASE SAY THIS AND DANCE INSIDE A MOSQUE
It's her choice if she is renouncing religion and decides to live without any religion..... How should name impact.... Where is vasudhaiv.... If it is a state governed temple... Than it's a public place.... If it is a religious trust managed place they can certainly take a call on who should perform.... No one should question. It is their right to decide.
Religion is a personal matter, and religious places are subjective from the devotees emotions... So that is also a personal matter...
First give permission to muslim women to enter masjid, then lecture Vasudheiva Kutumbakam. She can do ghar wapsi and do HIndu classical dance in Hindu temple. And Hindu mandir is not public place, Mind ur language bastard Jihadi.
Talk about your religion first. They ostracised her as apostate. Says a lot about Islam's inclusiveness. More fingers point at your religion way too more.
ITS NOT A PUBLIC PROPERTY
ITS OCCUPIED BY THE STATE
@@shubhashishdwivedi9873 did I talk of religion, or you're just ready to jump the guns... Read it once again, what I have written...
@@babarkhan1782 Yes you did talk of religion
Look into your religion. You don't have locus standi to speak about our religion. You are no one to dictate to us about Hindu rituals. So, STFU.
I m sure it's not religion it's from people.... Fools who don't understand the commands for humanity...
In dance you pray to hindu gods and goddesses then how come you have no religion
Music, dance is Haram in izlam
Dance only leads to Hell
Reading about ancient India especial from Bihar part where I belong to.... Our ancestor were creating new thought new so called religions there were so many out of them buddhism Jainism survived and they were all questioning each other.... But coming of Abrahamic religion created something in Indian religion which started imitating them.... Like Haram thing.... There is no definition of what is Hindu who is Hindu....i read some Hindu book and then see around and feel where are Hindus? Don't follow anything Hindu except few cultural thing which might also be followed by some non Hindu... Am I not Hindu? What am I? I do philosophical part of indic religions
Nah nah dance means u are worshipping some kind of hindi god