A MASTERPIECE! | Attack On Titan Season 4 Part 3 Animation Breakdown
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 бер 2023
- Can't spell "shingeki no kyojin" without "kino"...
Background music used covers by mattyyyM - / mattyyym
Follow my Instagram - / kannas_ricebowl
Follow my Twitter - / kannas_ricebowl
Check out my animation channel - / @tryingsakuga7339
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
#attackontitan #mappa #shingekinokyojin #cgi #attackontitanfinalseason #attackontitanthefinalseason - Фільми й анімація
Not once has an anime scene made me literally cry from the fear of it. The whole rumbling sequence was just too perfect, I felt like I was running among the helpless civilians. Like I was in hell... Hayashi proves that once again he is goated and no one should ever doubt him
I love those comment it make my heart explode from the love I have for the series both anime and manga
You have no emotional integrity lol , it's nothing to cry in aot season 6
@@initialdosth8221 Coming out swinging I see? Who tf r u
@@lebyandsmartiel318 Probably someone from r/titanfolk
We really just had to wait for Hayashi to cook. He's been getting better each Part
The team behind this really weren't lying when they said they wanted this to feel cinematic.
Of course, with the runtime alone it already feels larger scale but the fact that they even went out of their way to give each shot that cinematic touch to it really helped with immersion.
Also really glad you mentioned that moment with Zeke. I actually had to rewatch it a couple times to even see how they pulled off such a smooth transition. Just the fact that they got one of the worst looking CG titans to look amazing is a testament to how far they went with the visuals.
If this is the level of quality that we can expect for the finale, it'll probably be more than enough to make up for some of the compromises they had to make during Part 1.
First time crying while being marveled by the ODM gear scene at the same time. Choking on my tears while in awe. What an experience
Appreciate the fact that you credit the animators for each scene in every video, really gives them the spotlight for how much work and blood they put into animation!
So first this amazing episode, then your amazing breakdown of it? Feels like I got two episodes of aot lol, can't wait to watch this.
9/10 overall, when it's really good you need to appreciate it. Nice animation, nice creative choice of color, approach, the music, the voice when Eren told to Ramzi it just so fking good and so many things good in this one hour episode. big thx to Yuichiro Hayashi as the director, and my man you really need to sleep. The freedom panel one was a little bit off but I'm ok with it
They are a lot of Taiwanese Animators for Hange vs Collosal fight like Q Kawa( everyone should know this or 邱家和), 曾信雄 the one who animate Hange on fire， 姚杰善 the first Hange flying to colossal, the special effect of bombs explosions and Zeke turning into Titan(超级豆仁) and many more animators, I really appreciate they giving all out
Oh Q Kawa is Taiwanese? Didn't know that
Bro your knowledge of the episodes (who and how theyre animated) is astounding. Great work!
I never really liked the hange sequence in the manga but the added content in the anime definitely elevated the scene for me. Now it's one of my favorite sequences from s4
Yeah I agree with you this episode was my favorite with the animation and ost. I loved how the rumbling was depicted with the horror and desperation of people. Also, the cgi models for the colossals was really impressive considering they went close up to them during the Hange scene and looked 2d at times in the close up. How would you rank this part to other AOT parts and how would you rank it among other MAPPA works?
Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but I think this was the second best installment of aot, second only to season 1. As for overall mappa shows, I don't think this looks better than csm or rage of bahamut, so around the number 3 spot I think...
@@ProbablyPretentious IMO aot season 2 looks better than 1 final season part 3 is prob tied with s1
@@ProbablyPretentious Quick question why do you think season 1 is better than season 2? I do agree with you but the overall community thinks that season 2 is the best visually.
@owo jjk s2 should be even more impressive considering gosso as director and more experienced teppei ito and lol some big names r also working on it🗿
I have explained my reasons in a video, firstly s2 has less action compared to S1, and wit's aot team was not good at non action storyboards and rarely featured any character acting, so a lot of episodes felt dull, visually. The armoured titan was limited because of the design upgrade (although much better than s3 pt 2) and the colossal had some wonky moments, compared to that, S1 was just...perfect wasn't it?
they properly fed the animators in the basement this time
Bruh
For me the only thing that puts S1 above this part is the rough edges throughout the scenes. S1 is pretty much perfect animation-wise (though looking back WIT's art style look too 'cartoony' to me).
The sad part is that this part has some of the series's best character acting (as has been the case for a lot of MAPPA's animation). But at least people will realise that MAPPA can do good animation after the amazing ODM scenes.
Those people dont watch other mappa anime and just feed off an echo chamber
MAPPA staff are damn talented and personally Hayashi is the best director they have. Horror, suspense and the best storyboarding (both speed and quality). Not to mention being an expert in directing cg into anime. I would say if there is a universal MAPPA trait for their anime, its their character acting...esp in Chainsaw Man where the majority of their non-action sakuga is fluid and concise character acting. AoT S4 has more character acting than S2, a season with some of the most infamous still frames (S1 has more...but a bit better used...and I love S2 over S1 so pain)
I still see hate for this 💀
Of course. There is always hate
@@guyxjoy1486which is not bad at all. It's not like part 2 or specially part 1
The first part of attack on titan season 4 was a little off compared to that of wit studio(I am not talking about style change. Because the style that mappa used was perfect for the sutuation. I wouldn't have liked the glittery style of first 3 seasons in such situations. I just felt like they didn't give a good finishing touch to what they made most probably due to less time). But honestly the later parts looked really good. They were one of the best I have ever watched not just good. And not just good but they were really matching the story and situation. Because a good animation is not only about fluidity of the animation but there are other things to consider too. To be honest I like the animation of part 3 of season 4 AOT more than that of wit studio.
And to those people who are still criticizing mappa even after seeing the animation of part 3 then they are just obsessed over wit studios animation and they can't see the reality.
You deserve more subs
The first half or 40mins was truly top tier but that last part was a little rough in some places i feel and i’m looking forward to the more polished/improved blu ray version. Curios to see what they will do.
Do you also do breakdowns on western animation? Cuz' there's a French animated movie called "Dofus Book 1: Julith" and I think it's has really interesting animation, and I'd like to hear your thoughts on it.
Edit: There's also a French cartoon made by the same studio called Wakfu, but it's mostly animated in Flash so i doubt you would have much to say. But the animation is surprisingly good for a cartoon made mostly with Flash, especially the 17th episode of the first season.
Yes... This might be cringe to some but...I love your content man...I really hope to see your channel grow...👍
Thanks a lot fam🙌
Great breakdown. I really enjoyed this episode. The dynamic movements are standout for me. if I have to nitpick, I wasn't the biggest fan of background music, it could have been a bit more subtle imo. Ofc that's a small issue and I am just heavily biased towards manga, but overall yeah, it was great. I would definitely rewatch it
Hmm, well I think the rumbling ost was very subtle and tasteful, because it's genocide, hype music screams immaturity, overly dramatic music makes it feel fake, the ost choice for the rumbling was subtlety at it's finest so are you talking about the hange scene?
@@ProbablyPretentious yea Hange scene mostly. I am just not a fan of vocals. I think the instrumentation was fine. Not that I mind vocals in my OSTs but this one is meh for me. The vocals took me out of the scene. The song by itself might be good but it didn't work for me at that scene. Also I agree OST during rumbling was good but during the Freedom scene, it was lacking a bit. The visuals were good so music definitely could have elevated it to next level. But I am no musician so it might be just me
@@chasinghaze0962 living proof of the statement "cant please everyone". not knocking u its just interesting to see 99% of people praise the scene then theres just 1 guy who never liked it for whatever reason
@@tater8960 I mean as i said before, it's just a nitpick, not some big issue. I still enjoyed it overall.
It's off topic but did you watch summertime render if you have whats your opinion on ep15 animation
What about your exams bro?,how did it go 💀
Episode was pretty amazing.
Surprisingly well actually, I'm free now (which is ironic)
@@ProbablyPretentious LoL that's what everyone else feels after giving exams especially tough ones
Am I so excited for it to end, so that hayashi can finally rest then probably continue directing dorohedoro.
@@guyxjoy1486mappa is just animation studio brother they just animates and its kodansha you should be talking about do some research before saying stuff like that it's embarrassing
Curious to see how exactly Hayashi and Co. pull off the actual ending considering (spoilers below)
All the different variations of the Nine Titans.
That's why they got themselves some time man can't wait for it Hayashi is cooking rn 🗿
Real peak
1:47 I’m crying 😂
This episode was amazing (like your video❤️). Hayashi Really cooked. Also looks like madhouse is doing an anime called (frieren:beyond journey's end). What do you think about The PV? It looks Really good and the manga has a pretty good rating
Madhouse doing a new anime project,I will check the PV for the show.
Edit: NGL there wasn't much "movement" compositing and colour grading looked appealing. Idk man Madhouse isn't the same anymore 😔
@@harman4321 it's a very short. You can't Tell 100% obviously. But there was a little bit of Character acting. Also you can't expect the same Quality of old madhouse because they lost a lot of staff and maruyama. But they can do Solid and very good looking anime if they have a decent schedule and the PV looked pretty good (from The comments and the ratings, The story is gonna be pretty good too)
@@user-og6pb6dd5p True man
Also yout thoughts on Aot episode??
Imo it was one of the best episodes in anime,the terror of rumbling was portrayed so well, Hayashi Supremacy 🛐
It wasn't flawless but it was incredible.
Also Asakawa actually improved
Characters were also really consistent this time.
Those 3d wall titans were rigged so well.
Hange and other odm scenes were also incredible.
Amount of effects and background character animation blew my mind.
10/10 episode.
@@harman4321 all the things that you said, i agree with it too. Character acting, direction, storyboards, Action Animation, The compositing was actually pretty good, story, music and ost, hanji's death Scene with that OST. The rumbling was VERY amazing and well handled. Hayashi and his team did a fantastic job. (i hope he can go back on dorohedoro after AOT). The art style has a lot of detail consistently and it moves Really well, it's ridicilous. This Quality of the final product is better than season 3 and 2 as a whole. I think season 1 is still the best animated season (although this episode was better than like or Most of season 1)
@@user-og6pb6dd5p Yeah direction and storyboarding also matters tbh while S1 of Aot have amazing animation, it lacks creative storyboarding, it does have good storyboarding (Hayashi is just better though) non action/static shots in S1 are really hard to sit through.
Also have you watched Ghost in the shell movie??
If you haven't then you should definitely give it a try, it's peak production IG,top tier storyboarding, animation and direction.
Yes yes
This is the type of quality I should expect for aot to have, not whatever happen in the Marley.
Nice nice
An anime-only here. So compared to this part how difficult would the next part will be to animate?
I'd imagine that the rumbling shots wouldn't be much, but there might be a lot of ODM scenes and titan on titan battle
(No spoilers pls, just a general overview)
Yea I'll tell you, so basically this episode ended with chapter 134, the beginning of that chapter contains some ridiculous rumbling shots but the episode skipped them, those will most likely be a part of the next installment. They are not too dissimilar to the rumbling shots in the beginning of this ep, except instead of a few hundred/thousand people, those shots literally have millions, it's millions of moving people on screen alongside many, many colossals, so that's insane. Also the actual fight, bunch of shifters literally fighting on top of a bigger shifter, it's an insane setpiece so part 2 will be several times more complicated and large scale
@@ProbablyPretentious Holy fuck what was Isayama smoking while making all of that 💀
@@harman4321 bro forgot his work also has to be adapted to a Anime
waited for the EN dub and knew i had to watch this video afterward.
Wait this is the end of the part??? I thought the parts were gonna be like 2-3 episodes each.
You have never seen any masterpiece....
I believe in the supremacy of Hayashi's Cinema
Wait wut was with the centipedes again???
Just an ominous cut ig, nothing too deep there
There is one thing i found strange, i tought eren's face was flesh coloured but instead in this episode we see it and it's white.
Probably a stylistic choice, or kinda like eren's eye color that keeps changing depending on the surrounding light. I must say, the white looks amazing, mostly because it's so different and oddly terrifying
He is made of bones here, hence it makes sense that it looks white in closeup.
@@ProbablyPretentious i think you are right, is a matter of light, also he is white in volume 33’s cover
It’s sad the worst part of the whole series gets peak animation
L take
Do you refer to the rumbling or alliance vs eren?
@@ProbablyPretentious This episode is not exactly the worst part of aot but the next is god awfull and we all asume that cour his gonna look atleast as good
@@ProbablyPretentious I mean comparing every other part of the series before this, they’re all better
Irrelevant opinion get out
Freedom scene was butchered in anime
@@mikacommenter no. Art was trash. We couldn’t see the end of horizon. The titan steam was made look into clouds. A lot of problem
@@mikacommenter another ignorant manga reader. No wonder you dont think the scene was butchered. Reread the manga. That was titan steam. You could see it if you read it properly.
@@mikacommenter i never d ride wit. But you always d ride mappa. Even in videos of chainsaw man. I never said wit is better than mappa. I said wit is better at fight scenes than mappa. And wit is better at delivering expression. Look at eren's speed to Ymir. Eren's design there is so inconsistent. Wit nails at important scenes. Like eren's scene at the last of season 3. It looked so iconic and consistent. Memories of the future is top 3 most important episode/chapter of aot. But look at character expression at that episode . Compared to manga that episode's character design looks trash. Wit nails action scenes. Mappa had 1 year to do one episode yet they didn't do anything like levi vs kenny or levi vs beast. I know people working to be animator. Even they agree, wit's action scenes surpasses mappa's. And they messed the most important panel of the rumbling arc. It also important for eren's character
@@SamirSiraj8542yeah when everything is almost outsourced to another studio or almost every great animated Scene is almost by a freelancer arifumi imai
@@user-og6pb6dd5p why didn't mappa do the same? Freedom is such a easy thing to do. They butchered all the symbolism. They ruined it
Lmao no disrespect to mappa, but they are not the right studio for AOT, the animation was not even their best, the music for the rumbling was horrible and the voice acting for the screams was just too little, the censorship was too much and the rumbling was not terrifying at all, worst episode ever
Well, this is your opinion, and we only have facts here 🤗 😴👋
L+ ratio + instead of ranting about aot why don’t you rant about the reason u get no bitches
Well it's not like any other studio could even produce a finished product in that time frame (also for the record I strongly disagree with all of your arguments besides the first one, yea hayashi's team can still do better, mostly because they are some of the most creative and talented people in the industry)
L take. wit cencored a lot more than Mappa. Also didn't know that voice acting and music is a part of Mappa 💀
You bring shame to all the other people out there who you share the same account name with
First of all thanks to hayashi and his team for adapting one of the hardest arc to animate (though the real hard part will be in 4.3.2)
Hayashi cooked 🤌🤌
He perfectly showed the horror of rumbling and also that beast Titan transition from 3d to 2d was really smooth and lastly that hange scene u perfectly explained it
Do you think that the next part will witness the presence of bigger names such as Kojima or maybe a lot of webgen animators , because it is assumed that that battle will require many animators
@@saadbendaoud7475i hope so
@@saadbendaoud7475 kojima maybe and shishido is confirmed coz we saw him working in that 100cam video but I'm not sure about omine ig he is busy with spyxfamily and Satoshi iwataki since he is also busy with jigo as AAD
I'm sure we will get more webgen animators coz of wataru connection and....Hmmm yen bm can also join though since he worked on takt op so wataru can bring him again