The swing from utter disappointment to elation with that “no joke” fake out at the end was the emotional experience I was not expecting to have this day
As someone working in the creative industry, I LOVE hearing the behind the scenes of how things were achieved by the experts in the field. This is a great series!
My favorite one is in Fire Birds. There was a firefight between two helicopters. Helicopter A shot 2.75" diameter rockets at helicopter B. Helicopter B suffered being hit by .50 cal (half inch diameter) machine gun rounds as shown by the holes in the helicopter. The helicopter B pilot (The most interesting person in the world by the way) cries in pain before helicopter B blows up like the Death Star. By the way, helicopter A had a 30mm auto-cannon that is aimed by where the gunner looks yet unguided rockets were used. None of that scene made sense.
Please tell me you guys will be doing this again!! I absolutely love films, and it wasn't until I came across your channel years ago, that I ever really paid any attention to the prop side of films. Now I notice little things, and analyze scenes. This could easily be a weekly show, where you break down all the prop gags in film history! Thanks for this!
@@levesteM It’s a play on words. American’s use the word “Props” to mean “Proper respect”, or “To give proper respect.” So my comment was just another pun.
Thanks for the longer video and love the collaboration talk. Great to have these series. Just a random thought, what about having a series on taking an idea from someone or a script and designing the props for it? Show the design, construction, and final result.
Great episode. This type of thing is what I always want to see on the bonus features so it's nice to have a series dedicated to it. Looking forward to the next one.
I would have just assumed she was eating one food and then when you turned away she had just put it down and taken a bite of another food. She didn’t get to eat like that a lot so it would make sense her character would be trying everything.
I guess you could explain it this way. If it were something the director intended to convey though, they'd include her putting away the croissant in the cut. Without it, it reads more as a mistake than a conscious decision.
I agree with both of you in this thread...they edited it a little wonky and the scene lacked that little bit of exposition. I also thought she was just eating a little of everything.
OP and subsequent comments are all missing the point. It’s not JUST that it went from croissant to pancake. It’s that it went from croissant to pancake with one bite out. Then she takes a bite and the pancake has two bites out. Then back to pancake with one bite out and her taking the second pancake bite. AGAIN. Sure, write the croissant to pancake switch as her sampling everything. But she didn’t eat a whole ass pancake PLUS one bite out of a new pancake in the time it took RG to say his line 🤦🏻♀️. There are multiple issues here. The food change being one, failing to catch the pancake bite being the second, and third issue being the ability of commenters to notice attention to detail and acknowledge mistakes. In a breakfast spread like this that would have been delivered to the room, there wouldn’t have been pancakes. Fruit, pastry and assorted beverages. But not fruit, pastry AND pancakes. The pancakes were always a mistake in this.
That right there is suspension of disbelief in its best form. Building a story in your head to fix the mistake of the scene and be able to continue enjoying watching the movie.
10/10 would love to see some more videos. Props are a very obscure yet very important part of movies that is rarely talked about and I would love to learn more!
I LOVE THIS! Keep this series going. I love finding the pieces like Julia Roberts eating croissants then pancakes. We rewatch movies to find these goofs.
Omg! I'm SO here for this concept! (Already regular viewer of #CorridorCrew. And #Tested. Which I instantly feel would both be awesome to see cross paths with you too). Here's for you to go far with these as series 🥂🙌
It could be kool for each ep to have a theme, like food, cars, whatever, to make it more cohesive. Even if that theme is "our favourite props" it would help to make it feel like more of a *thing* rather than just random bits thrown together.
Regarding the hood and how his punching must've simply crushed the bolts to dust: i love how you guys think of this stuff on set. Logical continuity and reasoning behind thinga! It's just how i think when I'm watching a movie. Maybe I should have gotten into the props business!
Thank you for making a series! I had dreams of becoming a special makeup effects person and seeing others in the film/show industry always makes me happy. I thought there was an article in SFX or Fangoria that talked about the eggs and the way they did it... I need to look up the article.
This is such a great idea for a series. Not just professionals talking about what they know, but appreciating and trying to guess how their peers would do it/did it. Also, at 1:37, you see Striker (Robert Hayes) accept the ticket from the same position the airport staff is holding it. I think this could indicate that whatever was causing the ticket to "smoke" was reliant on direction.
Words cannot express how excited that your jumping into this meta. If you have the budget, this could be a series that lasts YEARS on the knowledge aspect alone.
More of this! You and the guys are fun. It's nice to see you guys shine some light on the props in movies, similar to corridor crew with their VFX artists react! I love it. Please make them even longer.
Bad jokes, dad jokes, bad dad jokes and genuine reactions to prop mistakes. What's not to love about this?! Looking forward to more! (I've always enjoyed your short videos!)
this is going to be an awesome throwback in 5 years how raw and pure this episode was. Like the corridor digital guys (with heir fancy slick smooth editing now) you bring an awesome insight into the magic of this world.
That is fantastic I'm so happy you borrowed the corridor digital format for props ! If I may make a small critic, the pacing is a bit off (which is to be expected for a first episode), and a little more breathing room would be nice: A little more time to introduce the movie/scene, and just a little more time to let the you react (including off topic banter) and you'll have a modern youtube classic. But in any case, thanks scott and crew for your amazing work I'll be here for the next one !
This is a great idea for a series! I love behind the scenes looks at film making. It would be cool for you guys to react to particularly clever props. One's that leave the audience guessing how they did it or props that turned out fantastic despite a shoestring budget. Either way, I look forward to episode 2.
This is awesome! I honestly didn’t really think of props in movies until watching your shorts. I love y’all giving us a chance to learn more about this aspect of filmmaking! So cool! 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Love it! So glad y’all are doing this series! I could watch filmmaker react videos all day. Y’all should collab with Corridor Crew sometime for their visual effects artists react series and they should come on this show!
I don’t know if this is specifically a prop thing but I was watching band of brothers recently and I noticed in the scene when they planes are taking off for the jump into Normandy, one of the pilots is wearing modern ear protection, and honestly, I don’t blame that pilot one bit Also this was awesome, please make more if you can!
This hits my love of practical effects so hard. Thanks guys! Would love to see a whole episode on the 80s version of The Thing and the more recent version. They tried to replicate the props and scenes from the 80s version.
Yesssss. Your shorts have made me use that cursed portion of youtube, glad to see you in boomer-form content ;) I'm making a prop ray gun, and planning on a saw Billy. You've inspired me!
Do this many more times! Even as a blind guy, the descriptions you guys have on the props and scenes really helps for movies I haven't seen when I could see. Shaun of the Dead? Please?
5:45 and there we learn the real point of this youtube channel: we always laugh at your puns :D And I loved that part with the eggs. You all had different ideas, and it turns out you were all right! Just shows how even with amazing professionals, everyone has thier own thought processes and takes on a problem, and combining them together can be what makes the scene :)
This was great. Love that it's focused on props, but also points out other things (like the audio on the thrown mirror). Countless episodes are possible! PS I just bought materials for a shoot I'm doing that needs an indoor BBQ grill. Couldn't have done it without seeing your youtube short!
Excellent series idea. Please continue. Even if it takes a while to take lift. Got a great spin on things.
Thirded
Yeah I would love this :)
This is going to be an epic series and I'm so happy about y'all collaborating; such a talented team
Thank you!! It should be a fun series!!
Omg me too!!
Me 3@@Ibuddy66
Hell yeah. Production Designer here. So proud of seeing how this channel has evolved over the years. You're an absolute gem. Keep it up Scott! 🎉🤘
The swing from utter disappointment to elation with that “no joke” fake out at the end was the emotional experience I was not expecting to have this day
As someone working in the creative industry, I LOVE hearing the behind the scenes of how things were achieved by the experts in the field. This is a great series!
Inconsistency in tv and movies drives me crazy sometimes. I love seeing you three scrutinize these cuts. I hope you continue. 😀🖖💕
My favorite one is in Fire Birds. There was a firefight between two helicopters. Helicopter A shot 2.75" diameter rockets at helicopter B. Helicopter B suffered being hit by .50 cal (half inch diameter) machine gun rounds as shown by the holes in the helicopter. The helicopter B pilot (The most interesting person in the world by the way) cries in pain before helicopter B blows up like the Death Star. By the way, helicopter A had a 30mm auto-cannon that is aimed by where the gunner looks yet unguided rockets were used. None of that scene made sense.
I don't know why...but the 'Prop Room' gag in Top Secret floored me when I saw it the first time.
Great format, dude! Corridor Crew has done it with VFX for awhile now, so I've often thought it would fit well with props and practical fx.
I can't tell you how happy I was this morning to wake up to this. This is gonna be so awesome
Thanks for your support!!
Please tell me you guys will be doing this again!! I absolutely love films, and it wasn't until I came across your channel years ago, that I ever really paid any attention to the prop side of films. Now I notice little things, and analyze scenes. This could easily be a weekly show, where you break down all the prop gags in film history! Thanks for this!
They have infinite source material!
Very fun vidéo guys.
I have to give you guys props. This is a great idea and I love the idea of a bunch of guys sharing ideas and having fun. Thanks guys for the fun!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Why give them props? I'm sure they have plenty in storage.
@@levesteM It’s a play on words. American’s use the word “Props” to mean “Proper respect”, or “To give proper respect.” So my comment was just another pun.
@@thornmallow1 I know! I was trying to continue the pun.
@@levesteM Awww nuts! Sorry!
Thanks for the longer video and love the collaboration talk. Great to have these series. Just a random thought, what about having a series on taking an idea from someone or a script and designing the props for it? Show the design, construction, and final result.
Nice!!
Great episode. This type of thing is what I always want to see on the bonus features so it's nice to have a series dedicated to it. Looking forward to the next one.
I would have just assumed she was eating one food and then when you turned away she had just put it down and taken a bite of another food. She didn’t get to eat like that a lot so it would make sense her character would be trying everything.
I guess you could explain it this way. If it were something the director intended to convey though, they'd include her putting away the croissant in the cut. Without it, it reads more as a mistake than a conscious decision.
I agree with both of you in this thread...they edited it a little wonky and the scene lacked that little bit of exposition. I also thought she was just eating a little of everything.
OP and subsequent comments are all missing the point. It’s not JUST that it went from croissant to pancake. It’s that it went from croissant to pancake with one bite out. Then she takes a bite and the pancake has two bites out. Then back to pancake with one bite out and her taking the second pancake bite. AGAIN. Sure, write the croissant to pancake switch as her sampling everything. But she didn’t eat a whole ass pancake PLUS one bite out of a new pancake in the time it took RG to say his line 🤦🏻♀️.
There are multiple issues here. The food change being one, failing to catch the pancake bite being the second, and third issue being the ability of commenters to notice attention to detail and acknowledge mistakes.
In a breakfast spread like this that would have been delivered to the room, there wouldn’t have been pancakes. Fruit, pastry and assorted beverages. But not fruit, pastry AND pancakes. The pancakes were always a mistake in this.
Ya know, that definitely was NOT planned but I think you definitely figured out how the editor probably sold the mistake.
That right there is suspension of disbelief in its best form. Building a story in your head to fix the mistake of the scene and be able to continue enjoying watching the movie.
This has so much potential to become an amazing series!
Please please please! Make more episodes. So incredibly entertaining, and you guys are sharp funny and watchable. You struck gold!!
I never would have thought about animating a series like this but now I need it.
The best words a Prop Man can hear, "We can fix it in post!" Always brought a smile to my face on set!
PLEASE DO MORE OF THESE!!!!! This is so ENTERTAINING SCOTT. I’m being serious this was AWESOME
FINALLY SOME LONG FORM SCOTT CONTENT
I hope you like it.
@@ScottPropandRoll loved it! Learning all the little things that go into making movies truly amazing is awe inspiring.
this is great. I love seeing prop people talking about the practical nature of making a scene work.
Way to go guys! Great first episode. I'm hooked!
10/10 would love to see some more videos. Props are a very obscure yet very important part of movies that is rarely talked about and I would love to learn more!
I have been soooo waiting for this.
More, More, MORE!
You are one of my favorite channels.
I LOVE THIS! Keep this series going. I love finding the pieces like Julia Roberts eating croissants then pancakes. We rewatch movies to find these goofs.
I will 100% watch this and every episode of this series!
I gotta give you PROPS, Scott. This was a great idea for a show.
omg I am already addicted to this series. MORE I NEED MORE
Loved your YT shorts since forever. As someone making short films of my own this isn't just fun to watch, but also super educational!
I think this series is what i’ve been waiting for all my life. Thank you scott and gang!
Glad to see people who appreciate their fields talking about it and sharing :)
Omg! I'm SO here for this concept!
(Already regular viewer of #CorridorCrew. And #Tested. Which I instantly feel would both be awesome to see cross paths with you too). Here's for you to go far with these as series 🥂🙌
MUCH more of this, please😃
This is great! Please for a future episode , break down all the effects in a single classic movie we all love. The 80s movies are goldmines.
It could be kool for each ep to have a theme, like food, cars, whatever, to make it more cohesive. Even if that theme is "our favourite props" it would help to make it feel like more of a *thing* rather than just random bits thrown together.
Regarding the hood and how his punching must've simply crushed the bolts to dust: i love how you guys think of this stuff on set. Logical continuity and reasoning behind thinga! It's just how i think when I'm watching a movie. Maybe I should have gotten into the props business!
Thank you for making a series! I had dreams of becoming a special makeup effects person and seeing others in the film/show industry always makes me happy. I thought there was an article in SFX or Fangoria that talked about the eggs and the way they did it... I need to look up the article.
glad to be here. for the start of a great series
Glad you're doing your own version of the VFX Artists Reacts! Big fan of prop talk!
I liked the idea of this series enough to make a comment for the interaction algorithm.
Always loved your content. This is a VERY welcome addition! Also, I have a fan EXACTLY like the one in the doodoo scene lol
Brawl in Cell Block 99 is one of my all-time favorite movies but even I think that scene is ridiculous.
This is such a great idea for a series. Not just professionals talking about what they know, but appreciating and trying to guess how their peers would do it/did it.
Also, at 1:37, you see Striker (Robert Hayes) accept the ticket from the same position the airport staff is holding it. I think this could indicate that whatever was causing the ticket to "smoke" was reliant on direction.
Love the new perspective you guys are bringing! Bunch of good films and iconic props and gags!
THIS. WAS. AWESOME. Please do more of these man!!!!
YESSSSS!I love this. Also great to see some longer content.
Words cannot express how excited that your jumping into this meta.
If you have the budget, this could be a series that lasts YEARS on the knowledge aspect alone.
I LOVE this series!
More of it, more of your crew too!
Love the channel looking forward to some slightly longer form content, props to you my man
More of this! You and the guys are fun. It's nice to see you guys shine some light on the props in movies, similar to corridor crew with their VFX artists react! I love it. Please make them even longer.
Bad jokes, dad jokes, bad dad jokes and genuine reactions to prop mistakes. What's not to love about this?! Looking forward to more! (I've always enjoyed your short videos!)
Thanks!!
this is going to be an awesome throwback in 5 years how raw and pure this episode was. Like the corridor digital guys (with heir fancy slick smooth editing now) you bring an awesome insight into the magic of this world.
As an AD I love Scott’s videos, but this is so needed! Can’t wait for more. Watch out Corridor Crew!
That is fantastic I'm so happy you borrowed the corridor digital format for props ! If I may make a small critic, the pacing is a bit off (which is to be expected for a first episode), and a little more breathing room would be nice: A little more time to introduce the movie/scene, and just a little more time to let the you react (including off topic banter) and you'll have a modern youtube classic.
But in any case, thanks scott and crew for your amazing work I'll be here for the next one !
I love this channel. And, I love that you've uploaded a long form video, at last!! 😊♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Scott you’re onto something here. Great work, highly entertaining. Keep it up guys
This is a great idea for a series! I love behind the scenes looks at film making. It would be cool for you guys to react to particularly clever props. One's that leave the audience guessing how they did it or props that turned out fantastic despite a shoestring budget. Either way, I look forward to episode 2.
This is awesome! I honestly didn’t really think of props in movies until watching your shorts. I love y’all giving us a chance to learn more about this aspect of filmmaking! So cool! 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Brilliant - Please do more as you’re shining a light on a way overlooked part of film making!
This is a great start to this series! Can't wait to see more episodes!
Love this whole series and the experts you are speaking too. Props are fascinating but your stories more so.
I was hoping you'd make longer format videos! Fantastic video! Looking forward to more
I already can't wait for more, and I already can't wait for a colab with corridor crew
Love the longer form content! Can't wait to see more
Love seeing you guys take the lid off props!
Love it! So glad y’all are doing this series! I could watch filmmaker react videos all day. Y’all should collab with Corridor Crew sometime for their visual effects artists react series and they should come on this show!
Agreeed
Came to the comments to say the same thing
This is fantastic Scott, we want MORE. No, seriously. MORE.
This is awesome! I always love learning about behind the scenes stuff about movies
I could watch this all day. Keep up the good work!
Yessss this show needs to continue
I don’t know if this is specifically a prop thing but I was watching band of brothers recently and I noticed in the scene when they planes are taking off for the jump into Normandy, one of the pilots is wearing modern ear protection, and honestly, I don’t blame that pilot one bit
Also this was awesome, please make more if you can!
I love that "Eh" after 9:02. It's just purified frustration :)
Yes, and thank you-I appreciated when someone appreciates my frustration!
i've been waiting for this for YEARS!!!! i love this content, keep reacting please!! i suggest the harry potter first films props
This hits my love of practical effects so hard. Thanks guys! Would love to see a whole episode on the 80s version of The Thing and the more recent version. They tried to replicate the props and scenes from the 80s version.
Fantastic first episode! Looking forward to more like this.
Yesssss. Your shorts have made me use that cursed portion of youtube, glad to see you in boomer-form content ;)
I'm making a prop ray gun, and planning on a saw Billy. You've inspired me!
This series is what I need in my life right now! Love it!
Props to the corridor crew for pioneering this format.
Love it. Looking forward to future episodes.
My kids and I grabbed some pizza and sat around to watch this. We loved it! Keep it up. ❤
I really like this new format. Keep it coming. :)
That was great! Glad you finally put this together!
Brilliant! Love these and will watch each new one you upload 👍🏻👍🏻
Looking forward to more of this!
"that joke was eggcellent", so understated, and completely run over at 5:50
Love the longer content. Movie props are fascinating to me.
Do this many more times! Even as a blind guy, the descriptions you guys have on the props and scenes really helps for movies I haven't seen when I could see. Shaun of the Dead? Please?
This series should be amazing, was always curious how stuff works behind the scenes.
We need more of this for sure. Twice as long too.
This is exactly this kind of stuff I love to discover about film/tv behind the scenes. Can’t wait for the next!!🧡🖤🧡
Well done guys! Look forward to seeing this format grow and evolve. Keep it up!
Loving this! Can’t wait for the next episode - sad someone missed saying the ghostbuster counter scene was eggcellent 🥚
Papi said it!!
I hope the deadpan 1000 foot stares continue to be the default response to puns going forward.
5:45 and there we learn the real point of this youtube channel: we always laugh at your puns :D And I loved that part with the eggs. You all had different ideas, and it turns out you were all right! Just shows how even with amazing professionals, everyone has thier own thought processes and takes on a problem, and combining them together can be what makes the scene :)
You keep making em’, I’ll keep watching!!
Loving this longer format, and looking forward to the next episode!
This was great. Love that it's focused on props, but also points out other things (like the audio on the thrown mirror). Countless episodes are possible!
PS I just bought materials for a shoot I'm doing that needs an indoor BBQ grill. Couldn't have done it without seeing your youtube short!
Love this idea! Great first episode and looking forward to subsequent ones. Nice work guys! 👍
Ohh I love this, this is 100% my new favourite series.
We need more content like this! Keep up the good work! 👍🏼
Great way to kick off a series! Definitely looking forward to more.