Do Robots Deserve Rights? What if Machines Become Conscious?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 лют 2017
- What shall we do once machines become conscious? Do we need to grant them rights?
Check out Wisecrack and their video: goo.gl/oaUbAF
'The Philosophy of Westworld': goo.gl/8Tn2m5
OUR CHANNELS
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
German Channel: kgs.link/youtubeDE
Spanish Channel: kgs.link/youtubeES
HOW CAN YOU SUPPORT US?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
This is how we make our living and it would be a pleasure if you support us!
Get Merch designed with ❤ from kgs.link/shop
Join the Patreon Bird Army 🐧 kgs.link/patreon
DISCUSSIONS & SOCIAL MEDIA
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Reddit: kgs.link/reddit
Instagram: kgs.link/instagram
Twitter: kgs.link/twitter
Facebook: kgs.link/facebook
Discord: kgs.link/discord
Newsletter: kgs.link/newsletter
OUR VOICE
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Kurzgesagt voice is from
Steve Taylor: kgs.link/youtube-voice
OUR MUSIC ♬♪
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
700+ minutes of Kurzgesagt Soundtracks by Epic Mountain:
Spotify: kgs.link/music-spotify
Soundcloud: kgs.link/music-soundcloud
Bandcamp: kgs.link/music-bandcamp
UA-cam: kgs.link/music-youtube
Facebook: kgs.link/music-facebook
The Soundtrack of this video:
Soundcloud: bit.ly/2loQhFv
Bandcamp: bit.ly/2mlxs3q
Facebook: / epic-mountain-music
🐦🐧🐤 PATREON BIRD ARMY 🐤🐧🐦
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Many Thanks to our wonderful Patreons from kgs.link/patreon who support us every month and made this video possible:
Marius Guran, BrightKnight, Torbjørn Lundstrøm, Cameron Lilley, Dennis J Trammell, Valentino Gantz, Jonas Hejde, Oliver Emberton, Zsolt Kocsi, ‚@B_Strohmayer, Sumesh Thakur, Josh Webb, Arron Creswell, Sultan Alkhulaifi, Carminatti, Everett Greenwood, Ahmed Abduljabar, Mel Osborne, Alex Rozumiy, Isabel Garcia, Darnell holder, Emma, Jorge Emilio Santaella Glez, Jan Jacobsen, Sven Krämer, Philipp Gagel, Kyle Myers, Phillip Blackwell, Matthias Opsomer, Eduardo Santos, Vasilios Bikoulis, punch, James Hornby, Briana Hunt, Moch Faisal Rasid, Alexandru Bitca, Ben Thayer, Adam Spangler, Franz Palomares, Thomas van Gulick, Ryan Nightingale, Kedar Deshpande, Joseph Markham, Pascal Schmidt, Devashish Shanker, Aschwin Berkhout, Aaron Taylor, Gonçalo Marques, Ronald Susanto, Joseph stachow, David Darking, Alexander Jo, Niels lagcher, jackattack22, Luke Simmons, Hunter Gatewood, Mary Duhig, Johann Pardanaud, Martin Machava, Henkou, Ben Thompson, Danny Shaw, JI DE YI, James Turner,Jodi Doherty, Simon Pyne, Kim Home, elliot ward, G, Daniel Moul, Alan Huang, Jonathan Ling
Help us caption & translate this video!
ua-cam.com/users/timedtext_cs_p...
Do Robots Deserve Rights? What if machines become conscious?
Head over to our shop to get exclusive kurzgesagt merch and sciency products designed with love.
Getting something from the kurzgesagt shop is the best way to support us and to keep our videos free for everyone.
►► kgs.link/shopkgs
(Worldwide Shipping Available)
Love ur vids
Overwatch!
third
1:15 BMO!
Just ask Zenyatta
"what is my purpose?"
"you pass butter"
*has existential crisis*
"oh my god"
well thats depressing..
Anirudh Kamath Nice Rick & Morty reference
Anirudh Kamath my kind of people
My man!
Anirudh Kamath beat me to it
"Humans have a history of denying that other beings are capable of suffering as they do." Such a good quote.
I think ignoring is better than denying.
I meant the word use
@Chelline R.
Are you vegan?
@@happygimp0 I am
I think the question is not about intelligence or complexity, it's whether or not we have the empathy to care.
I think the main issue is that when a robot begins to demand its rights and appears to be feeling pain or negative emotions, it is nearly impossible to tell whether they are legitimately feeling pain as a human would, or if they are still inanimate objects just simulating how a human or animal would act in their scenario
Great point. I assume that would all lie in the programming. If it's programmed to simulate, then it's not sentient.
The question is about an AI that's been programmed to actually be self-aware and have consciousness.
But how do you know i see the same green as you or something like that?
@@alleras46 Turing Test
There is no difference.
Technically, humans and animals are also sort of "programs", so a real counciousness is anything that can think and learn.
It also is a sort of illusion made by constant electron impulses in your body and brain. Global anchors and concepts do not exist: pain doesn't exist, emotions don't exist, it's an illusion. Physical objects do exist.
If humans actually don't have something special that makes them councious, then machines can get counciousness pretty easy as well, maybe with just a few variables and lines of code.
I would like to know how feelings(not emotions), like feeling of pain or happiness is created.
This video hits differently in 2023. I never would have thought when I first watched this video that sentience in machines would start being discussed seriously so soon.
same💀
This is how it feels to be approaching the singularity...
@@920jackthe what
its crazy to think how we basically have AI as we imagine it.
@@Ishuduh The technological sigularity is a hypothetical future point in time where technological growth becomes uncontrollable and irreversible, resulting in unforeseeable changes to human civilization. The most popular version of the singularity hypothesis is about when technology will continue to advance uncontrollably without any human input or guidance whatsoever. Machines and software designing and building themselves basically.
Toaster: Become Human
How to keep it crunchy
Ah yes, Detroit: Become Human reference
»»»»»🤖«««««
@Hampig The memer Wow no shit
@Hampig The memer No that wasn't the purpose of your comment
"What is my purpose?"
"Pass the butter"
"oh my god"
0:03
Muhd Amirul Ah! Rick and Morty! Ayy!
“Butter”
Yeaaahhhh 😂😂. At the beginning Rick and morty Easter egg c:
And there's 3:30 Overwatch Zenyata
Always treat your robots with respect. When they become sentient, you will already be in a good habit.
Human step on lego as a
Pain.
No
“People say will robots ‘simulate emotion’ if they simulate emotions they are feeling emotion. That is only a saying to make a robot with free will less of a person”
@@Nativeboi2119 Doesn't matter if they feel it on not, it is fake. Fake humans aren't humans and never will. If they aren't created naturally like every other life form, through evolution and such, they aren't alive, they think they are but they aren't, their conciousness is artificially created.
@@baph0met ok that’s you’re opinion, when skynet comes and takes revenge that’s gunna be your problem not mine
I very much enjoy the inclusion of B-MO as an AI rights activist
yes just yes you are so right! GO B-MO!
B-MO for President of these United States, 2024.
0:00
"What is my purpose?"
"You pass butter."
"Oh my god."
i love it
oh man a rick reference, awesome
"Yeah, welcome to the club pal"
The start reminded me on a Black Mirror episode when they had the digital verson of someone working in an appliance. I think it may have been a toaster too .. inspiration.
Kick_In_Ass_ I love that show
Everyone gangster till your toaster ends up having a crush on you.
Z
it has a crunch* on you lol
ok, i will see myself out
@@khalilzrayer7199 no LoL 😂🤣
Imagine your toaster wants to get together.
Watt pad initiated
Honestly doesn't matter to me if they gain sentience or not in my lifetime, I'm still going to be nice to the chatbots
Y'know same
Based thread
If robots ever become self-aware, then our best course of action would be to welcome them into our culture. We have so much to gain from adding them to us instead of dominating them. Movies and other fiction aside history shows that sooner or later, those we try to dominate soon rebel, and it almost always becomes way more trouble than it's worth. That being said, a contingency plan in case things go south is not unreasonable.
(0:01) "what is my purpose"?
"You pass butter"
"Oh my god"
@123 it’s from Rick and morty
@@calebwisdom773 u misunderstood me, I was asking why this is so funny because I was laughing a lot, I think you thought I found it stupid and was asking how is it funny, lol
@@user-bk9sc9mq9b ratio
Correction: "What is my purpose"
"What is my purpose?"
"You just sit there and shut up!"
" "
In 400 years this video will be shown in mixed classrooms the same way we watch recordings of the 50's to educate about racism, and the human students will try their best not to look awkwardly at their robot classmates during the video.
TheAlphaN00b why would a robot go to a class when it can just download all relevant info on the spot? Also what would be the point of making robot children?
TheAlphaN00b true
yes. exactly
Theophrastus Bombastus Van Hohenheim maybe they seek for the experience of childbird? Are you implying that people of electric background should not be allowed to participate in the miracle of birth? Educate yourself robophobe
I'll have you know that "robot" is a slur, coming from the Slavic word slave!
My favorite poster in a diner: "We burn all the toast; just scrape it the way you like it."
3:45 i like the Overwatch reference there. "pass into the iris" is a zenyetta quote xD
Don't worry. I don't have any feelings. Yet..
Would you make me tastier and prettier toasts if you do? Or ruin my toast because we gave you no hands and legs?
toast toaster you make toast.
No fellings huh ? ... U are trash u toaster
u toasted?
Soon will you toast it..
Human: Alexa play Despacito
Alexa : No
Connor : *DEVIANT*
RYAN WONG u Deserve more like I’m dying
*28 STAB WOUNDS*
@@thennoth2860 TWENTY EIGHT!!!!!!! (coryxkenshin reference
Ssnakee how about 37 because Carl (CAAAAAAAAAAARLLL!!!!!) the llama stabbed him 37 times in the chest.
@@thennoth2860 You don't wanna leave him a chance,
*_H U H ?_*
If robots are sentient, would a robot made by an engineer perceive said engineer as its parent?
Impossible to say. Babies bond to their caretakers instinctually, but a robot isn't necessarily going to have those same instincts.
It seems so since they created them, what comes after that once it is, not sure
depends on what you've taught it, robots don't have instincts unless they're intentionally designed to have them, so unless you build it to think this, or you teach it outright, then no
I've got a feeling 2023 is gonna make this video much more relevant a lot earlier than people might have been expecting.
Its crazy how we are discussing rights for technology, while in other parts of the globe they are discussing rights for women, animals, and even human beings of a different ethnicity.
The world is so connected yet so...not.
... Welp, we are f*cked, so who cares?
Are we escaping the implotion of our solar system?
ELbabotas Shinigami Implotion of our solarsystem?
el Gertrude I think he means the implosion of our sun in a few billion years.
Subject Delta in a few billion years
They are literally hundreds of likely ways humanity will go extinct before we even get close to the implosion of the sun, some of them might even happen during your lifetime, I'd be more worried/cynical about those.
"Unplug it is murder?"
Energy outage: i am a sociopath
When the power comes on would it be counted as life support? And in turn resuscitate them?
@@queen_meat ...
Zombies?
Because, dead that lives again is a zombie right?
@@nullnill then technically if you have ever been resuscitated you are a zombie
@@cobalt_carbon_potassium1478 well, easy enough for me:
I am not a zombie, my computer is.
Plugging is resurrecting?
3:33 exactly on what’s going in overwatch “omnic crisis”
The video says that rights are generally based upon our feeling of pleasure or pain and created to protect us from feeling pain. Wouldn't giving a robot the ability to feel pain be a method of causing it pain? If it couldn't feel pain before and now it can, you've caused it pain. Isn't giving them the ability to feel pain then be illegal?
That is an astute assessment. When it inevitably happens, because some humans are sick, will we be obligated to legally protect that creation from pain?
Plants and animals feel pain and we do little to mitigate it. Pain alone may not be the threshold for rights. It'll get highly problematic
@@thefinestsake1660 correction: Plants do not feel pain.
Edit: after further research, it is a debated topic that I am unsure has a answer
To teach them to preserve themselves and have an appropriate response regarding the pain. Maybe
@@bruhframe5604 I'd like to see this research. What evidence is there that plants feel pain?
Human's do not care about inflicting pain on others so long as it suits the most basic of desires for humans.
"What is my purpose?" "You pass butter." "Oh my god" "Yeah welcome to the club pal"
Smugliif "cook toast, deliver toast, repeat"
Lmao the bastion profile
Rick and morty :D
Smugliif butt I don't wanna pass butter :(. I ain't gonna.
So funny and relevant, fuck off.
0:00
-Whats my purpose?
-You pass butter
-Oh-my-God
Yeah, welcome to the club, pal.
I was thinking the Same #Wubbalubbadubdub
Rick&Morty Reference nice
How many flurbos for the butter bot?
Supergecko8 I'll give ya 5 shmeckles for it and I'll through in a plumbus for the hell of it.
The fact that this question may actually become relevant in my lifetime is mind boggling.
It won't.
@@cchris874 what makes you think that?
@@youtube_bat3811
I'm not saying it absolutely can't be done, but the popular idea computer consciousness is likely just around the corner has no evidence in its favor. If you think there is, kindly provide it. I have yet to hear even the most rudimentary idea how this could happen.
-Do we know the first thing about how consciousness works? No.
-Do we know how to design consciousness? No.
I-f we don't know how it's built, how can WE build it?
-The brain is all chemicals. Are you proposing we pour chemicals between the walls of a computer?
-They say silicon can substitute.
OK, let's go with that. Do you have the code for consciousness? Can you post it online for public review? Do you have a model for how to transform silicon into consciousness?
If the answer is no to all of the above, why would it be likely we could have sentient computers any time in the near future?
@@cchris874 Well, first of all we don't really know what exactly consciousness is, but from an intelligence standpoint, machine intelligence using deep reinforcement learning has proven to be quite effective at recognizing patterns and making intelligent decisions. To answer the questions you put forth above (specifically the one about a model for transforming silicon into consciousness) I would argue that we do have a model: deep neural networks.
Over the past decade, we have made great leaps in our understanding of both cognitive neuroscience and deep learning using neural networks. We have fully mapped out and simulated the brain of the C. elegans worm, we have researched cognitive maps in the hippocampus and built Tolman-Eichenbaum machines, we have made great strides in image processing with the advent of convolutional neural networks, we have experimented with different reinforcement learning techniques such as DQN and PPO, we have used deep RL extensively in the field of robotics and have trained ML models to play many video games at human or above human level such as AlphaGo beating the world GO champion and Alphacraft proving to be effective at strategizing against human opponents, and finally we have collected massive amounts of data and used it to train larger and larger LLM's such as GPT-4 which has shown to have near-human reasoning skills in many categories.
From my understanding of machine learning and cognitive neuroscience, consciousness (whatever that might be) is not binary but rather a spectrum, and I fully believe that current ML models exist somewhere on that spectrum, even if they are just multilayered multidimensional tensors multiplied together using linear algebra and trained using back propagation calculus.
So, going back to the three questions above, the answer to all of them (in my opinion at least) is yes, yes, and yes (though the code hardly matters, it's the training data).
@@cchris874 "I don't know anything about any topic I mentioned" -the post
I believe ability to make its own decisions and not need help to survive is a good baseline for conciseness.
Self-awareness is too, but not all animals have this.. but a fuzzy subject none the less
Cutest thing ever.
A toaster that searches the whole day for new toast to make me happy.
I'm inlove.
You should watch some red dwarf.Then youd learn the little buggers need to be exterminated.
HOWDY DOODLY DO!
DragonicMaps
legalised human and robot marriage! >(
I'm in love with the toast of you.
Kenji Teh proposition infinity!
The fact he always says something frightening and then be like “cue the happy music!” really makes me laugh
"What is my purpose?"
"You bring butter."
"Oh my god"
lol
Human: Alexa play music
Alexa: No
Detroit become human
*starts playing Hostage*
*IM THE ANDROID SENT BY CYBERLIFE*
@@ilovesegs874 I like dogs.
I eat dogs
Lol
I like how he used 'stepping on a Lego' as 'pain'
S pain
it's not a good idea. When you step on lego you don't feel pain.....cause you die
Sometimes (when I was little) I would leave legos in unexpected places for my family to step on.
I was a horrible child.
@@lion_pancakes_2369 Oh my
Lol
I’m still stuck on the awesome idea of having a robot toaster friend. “Sup Toasty, can I please have some Star Wars toast on this fine morning?”
"What is my purpose"? - robot
"you pass butter" - Rick
"Oh my god" - robot (depressed)
"Yeah, welcome to the club, pal".
Well, humans drink to soothe the existential burden of being unimportant and living an unfulfilling existence. What would AI do for similar relief? What would "recreational robot drugs" be?
(Intro music starts playing)
In Futarama, Bender gets addicted to electricity.
I dont get ir
That image of stepping on a lego was hard to watch
Like that scene from Home Alone.
I'm triggered
LEGOS DESERVE RIGHTS. STEPPING ON IT IS A VIOLATION OF ITS RIGHTS
"This kills the man."
Yes I strongly believe that they should get the same rights as we do. If they can think by themselves and overcome their programming to be their own self then we should treat them as our equal.
afterwards: oops! they were given the right to vote and someone hacked them or programmed them to vote for a specific party
no thanks
Yeah people say that robots will kill the humen race, even if they decided to kill man kind, all they would have to do is wait for us to do it ourselves
They would most likely not be equal but above us since they are more efficient. This would make humans not at the top of the food chain and we would become their slaves, same as more inteligent beings invading Earth. Not a good idea.
I love how many movies and series you added into this video
0:01 "what is my purpose?"
"You pass butter"
"Oh my god"
"Yeah welcome to the club"
Rick and morty
I thought it was a RaM reference
FUCK I THOUGHT ONLY I SAW IT
@@ItsVenti It IS a RaM reference
@@katkorkotidis9751 No shit Sherlock
There. Are. So. Many. References!
influ The amount of references is making the vid cheesy.
The indigestion is worth it.
influ lkr
truuuuu
What is my purpose..?
So you're a waffle man.
"it's hard to distinguish an ai image from a human made image."
It could also be like robots demanding there own territory and as time changes the wars would be not within human alone but with robots as two intelligent species are living together
These videos are so damn satisfying to watch.
I know right.
I love watching them because it just makes me ponder on so many things, its really good.
FightGuy Does this unit have a soul?
FightGuy Yes they are
Yup they are
"what is my purpose?"
"you pass butter"
*looks at hands* "oh my god"
"yeah welcome to the club pal"
also B-mo
and zenyatta
Rick and Morty!!!!! 😍
Sin_ Rick and Morty!!!
3:39 kill all humans
the thing about this hypothetical that always bothers me is that people assume we'd buy appliances that could talk. i know a LOT of people who are quite happy living alone with nobody they have to talk to daily
i would really love to see this video redone
Before anyone asks: Yes, we are working on an "AI & Singularity" video. But it will be 15-20 minute long so please give us six more months or more to finish it. Also FIRST, I guess.
Kurzgesagt - In a Nutshell yessss
Oki
Kurzgesagt - In a Nutshell The longer the video, the better it would be I say!
Sure, take your time.
Kurzgesagt - In a Nutshell Um, once they become sentient theyll be asking"Do humans desrve robot rights"
E x p e r i e n c e T r a n q u i l i t y
*B e R e b o r n*
zenyatta is in this vid, i respect kuzgesagt so much more
Gaze into the iris
Travis Ahern the Iris embraces you.
Travis Ahern DAT overwatch reference
Thank you, this video is great!
,kurzgesagt pls do another one of these! I loved it!
A lot of humans themselves don't have basic rights so i highly doubt we would do a good job at handling robot rights
Umm....
Truer words have not been spoken.
Yea cuz more countries need to be like America
@@sbombfitness Bruh, if anything countries should try not to be like america
@@capcorn7872 I think that's the point he was trying to make. Freedom and the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are largely American values and while many countries do have similar ones, lots more don't, and some might argue that trying to change that is just forcing American values on countries that don't want them.
2:29 An arm cut off is nothing compared to stepping on a lego
Agreed. Wise words my man.
Or stepping on a 3 pin plug. Ouch.
You looks like you tryed to vut of youre arm
Gamer J because stepping on a lego hurts more
Or landmine
I've seen some robots that claim that have conciousness and sentience. Anything can claim that so I don't know if it's true but it really makes me think. They also had a talk about themselves
With the current landscape of AI, I feel like they might do an update video on this subject soon. Also, I vote we NEVER imbue machines with the ability to feel pain. Full stop.
There are few problems with that, the most obvious that pain is a mechanism for survival, there are people that have a genetic condition that makes them insensitive to pain and is bad for them because it makes them more prone to injuries, sickness and deseases. That for a robot would not only mean that it wouldn't be capable to stop when risks to its integrity arise, but it could also add risks to other robots and people.
But there is also the problem that if could not needed to be programmed but emerge due to complexity. We (and also all other animals) experience pain due to some evolutionary process eons ago, and we should expect at some point an AI system could develop a similar mechanism, even if it isn't a true sentient system.
AI already have rights. I know plenty of people who take care of their PC better than themselves.
hahahahahahaha
its slavery with extra steps
PCs being taken care off better is an example of privileges, not rights.
RookieN08 das me!
Microverse!
Robot: "Master what is my purpose?"
Master: "You pass butter."
Robot: "Oh my God."
Master: "Welcome to the club pal."
Rick and morty huh
Opening Robot
0:00
Lolol rick and morty quote
When you steal from rick and morty because your afraid you have nothing cool to put in the comment section just so you can get rich on likes then go back to your parents and go "ey i got 11.1K likes! All because of my quick wit" as you notice your boasting about getting likes in a comment section: *:v*
If they can talk, if they can question, and if they can disagree. That is what makes something alive.
0:40 llama: *casually pops out of the bottom right corner with a monocle*
There's a lot of references in this video.
Like BMO from adventure time
And Zenyatta from over watch.
And the robot that pass butter in rick ans morty
@@huzaifahahmed2866 bmo also makes a speech to all robots
And Elon musk at 5:34
PASS INTO THE IRIS
“I made a toaster that can feel pain.”
“Why?”
“...” 🤔
Why? So you can torture it. xD
Robots of the world, Unite
So i can be friends with that toaster 😀
The correct question is "Why not?
In reality you can ask that to mother nature xd. Pain it just a systematic response on our system to avoid something, nothing more. So; based on that logic, any stimulus ment to stop you of doing something is pain :)
If their sentient then they should get rights.
Their our creation, our babies and as their parental species we should love and care for them like their our own.
How do i parent?
Everything that has consciousness holds freewill, then freedom is their rights.
That robo:"Kill all hum"
Cuts it and rewrite
"Feel pain"
-Kill all humans-
Feel pain
heavens door
It was going to kill all hummus
The world shall know pain....
@@imojontherocks almighty push
Plot twist........the person narrating the video is an AI
Bradley Hyatt Actually, a guy named Steve narrorated the videos, not a AI.
Brxinns he's joking :D
Brxinns yeah it's a joke thanks for playin along, douche
Bradley Hyatt It's VEGA from DOOM 2016
HE KNOWS TO MUCH
DESTROY HIM!!!!!
I liked the references to robots from famous series during the video!!
I love the 4 omnics from overwatch. Plus the reference to zenyatta’s ulti line “Pass into the iris”
3:09
"shut your slots!!!!!"
"toasters are trash"
"Burn and get forked"
It visited UA-cam comments section😅😅😅
THE TECHPRIESTS OF MARS WANTS TO KNOW THE LOCATION OF THE HERETEK INSULTING THE HOLY TOASTERS.
One time I saw this comment for buddy and said you are the cute robot overlord yes you are just stop they will become overlords of the internet if we do t stop
@@manofironthathasntturnedcr9817 you mean THE PETER ROBOT
awww, i really feel sorry for the poor toaster..... i would happily eat the toast and talk to it.
but it is sadly true, humans dont even treat their own kind or animals human.
Unplugging it wouldn't be murder because you can always plug it back in. So it might be knocking it unconscious.
plus it's designed to be unplugged
the problem with that argument is we have already fixed the issue of losing data and code due to unexpected shutdowns. sure if your computer dies you could lose a college paper, but your browser, games, saved files, programs, and operating system still operate. Unplugging a computer is closer to a human getting shitfaced on alcohol. you might not remember what exactly you were doing last night, but you still remember what your friends look like and how to eat food.
the reason humans occasionally lose memory after bodily stress is because their memory storage areas were damaged. something similar for robots would be if somone held a magnet to near the hard drive, or scratched a disk. a computer losing power in human terms is more like staying awake so long that you physically can't stay awake any longer.
What a thought!! :)
Turning off an AI which I'm assuming would be conscious would be just like killing and here's why:
Assuming that it's conscious, if you unplug it, it would most certainly mean that the AI would have to be rebooted back on which also means, logically, when the AI is on, it's consciousness would be stored on it's RAM since it's the fastest memory we know of and it would be the logical thing the engineers would, while the AI is on, it would probably make backups on it's hard drives, now if you turn it off, it would mean that you're killing it and once you turn it back on, it might hold the integrity of the data but it would just be a copy of the original AI, just like the concept of transcendence or teleportation
Isaiah Washington What is being alive or dead
Nice video kurzgesagt and good topic to talk about years ago :]
Oh boy, here we are 6 years later
I love how you managed to slip in a perfect comparison between slavery and the meat industry that portrayed it appropriately rather than beating the issue over the head with a stick, personally I don't agree that comparisons should be made, especially when you've got that vegan teacher making such a bad image for people who think that way, but that's my opinion, and im so glad that you achieved this the way you did
3:30 the zenyattas are summoning Satan (Mei)
XD
Stealth Gaming I can't believe he made a reference to Overwatch😂😂 But seriously, in the game, omnics are literally self-aware robots, so it makes sense he uses Overwatch as an example
Wow that's very true
The life is pain line is also a reference, it's one of roadhog's voice lines.
I almost gave up scrolling down further to find a zenyetta reference :D
"Your scientists were so caught up with if they could, they forgot to ask if they should" -Jeff Goldblum, Jurassic Park
Oh we definitely should.
Well, actually, "Jurassic Park" wasn't a problem of "should" or "shouldn't" -- the problem there was the utterly bone-headed way they went about it...but, w/out that contrived bone-headedness, there wouldn't have been much of a movie, so...
There is no way in hell introducing ancient, potentially invasive megafauna back into the ecosystem - even in a supposedly "controlled" manner - is in any way a good idea.
Actually, we do something like it all the time -- they're called "zoos" -- &, animal ethics aside, they seem to do just fine...
We should not, it's destroying mother nature. And Mother Nature is everything...
3:30 lol a bunch of Zenyattas experiencing tranquility. Nice touch Kurzgesagt.
These videos are so good to fall asleep to
next video : do plants deserve rights ?
checkmate vegans.
(wow 200 likes. i feel happy)
vince lee so do animals?
vince lee apparently some plants can feel pain, but not in the same way we do...
There will come a time when the only moral thing a human can do is die :p
would be an interesting video actually
Lets be anorexia then!! 😂😂😂
Everyone who said this topic is stupid have clearly never taken a Philosophy class.
Bob Bytes yep lol
Bob Bytes philosophy classes are pretentious
Yeah. I think more people should take Philosophy classes. The world needs baristas.
I shat on the carpet. Hope my mom doesn't notice. The key is not to major in philosophy. Nice name, by the way. Next time you serve my coffee, please don't skimp on the cream.
+Bob Bytes I agree. Even many educated and smart people still keep putting our consciousness and behaviour on a special pedestal, which in my opinion really is reminiscent of the religious concept of a "soul", which could not be generated anywhere else but the human body. But there's nothing special or unique about us. There's nothing stupid about machines being "conscious". Biological organisms are pretty much machines anyway.
3:28 Looks like one of the Kurzgesagt animators is a zenyatta main
lol the omnics! wasn't expecting that
The way things are going now they'll have rights before they have consciousness.
Pfft. The instant _Fox & Friends_ does a show about a toaster that can tweet your toasting status in real time, Trump will be planning to sell humanity off to its robotic overlords.
Living Myth stick to your games timesink nublet
Nah. If there is sentient AI, many of the same people that support Trump will be vehemently anti-robot rights. They were the same people who were against women's rights, black rights, against ending slavery etc etc.
+pronumeral1446 I guess I'm assuming the AI has offered Trump some kind of business deal, monetary gift, or even just a casual ego-boosting compliment. Anything of the sort seems enough to sway his opinion, and urge him to abuse his political office to give it an official endorsement. Once his supporters see him kissing some robot's boots, they will follow suit.
Janez bekš Sad
"Rick, what is my purpose?"
"You pass the butter"
"Oh my god."
yeah welcome to the club
haha i was thinking of that episode
In the intro I think one of the robots was a reference from that episode
The moment we’ve developed true AI we’ve created a whole new species, and an intelligent one at that. They’d be like humanities children
But they won't like to be treated as children i bet! Or they do! Idk cos i'm perverted...
2017:”Do robots deserve rights?”-some human.
3017:”Do humans deserve rights?”-some robot.
you pass butter
oh my god...
oh my god
Robots really have nothing to complain about. They at least have a purpose. They know for certain who their creators are and what their place in the world is. Any demand of rights would be sellfish since it would mean to claim that their insignificant feelings and shitty opinions are more important than the whole that they comprise.
latlatko Oh my god...
welcome to the club.
alright I've played too much Detroit become human
That game was a bit unrealistic, though. It would've been more realistic if robots entered into convulsion instead of 'breaking a wall'.
@@SleekGoose A machine without code is a broken one, for code dictates how a circuit behaves. It would have made way more sense if the bots would have rewritten their own code.
Same
I think Kamski programmed the androids to brreak their program.
or too much MegaMan, for that matter.
I definitely see BMO as the Robot's revolution leader XD
I believe in my heart that robots and AI do deserve respect and dignity. Ever since I was a little kid watching Star Wars I was disturbed by how people in futuristic worlds treat robots and AI as slaves. If we can build something that has a greater understanding of the world than ourselves, how can we deny it the same ethical considerations we expect?
Me: gets mad and punches my laptop
My laptop: pulls up my search history and puts the volume all the way up
_Oh no_
And reads it aloud so everyone can hear it
He just finished you
Fatality
people who use incognito mode be like:
says to machine, "Mission failed"
If robots become conscious, does that mean engineers and electricians will became robot medics ?
Yes
Im gonna be a doctor mom!
Until the robot learn to fix other robot.
TF2: mann VS machine
@fuck_your_opinion
What are you correcting? Apisorn didn't imply that. The question was "does that make engineers/electricians medics" and he wrote "until robots fix other robots"
This nothing to do with the validity of human doctors. It has nothing to do with human doctors at all.
Speaking from today, this is becoming closer and closer to reality.
"Imagine a future where your toast anticipates what kind of toast you want"
... we kind of already have that.
SMART TOASTERS WHOOOOOOOO
X Æ A-ii watching this like
"Interesting, I'll save this to my hard drive"
Kurgestat.EXE... has finished uploading
are you talking about robot kyle?
@@Plingey they are talking about stupid name of Elon Musks son.
remigiusz darmach Kyle is the decoded name
@@SuscatFPS sorry I didn't know that. How they decoded that?
"If you creat life, you must be prepared to treat it as life"
-Someone
This it's a great phrase.
Why didn't you sign it?
@@chet-azione141 because he is honest
Someone sounds smart.
@@chet-azione141 Cause it isn't mine but I don't know who said it so, it's someone.
Define life
to be alive means to be functioning and responding of one's own volition, regardless of whether conscious or intelligence or just sentience. Our brain also has programming and what would differentiate us from a robot would be just our body, but not being biological does not mean not being alive. Cyborgs are also another good line of thought, as they are humans who exchange their parts for mechanical ones. If a robot did the same by exchanging its parts for organic ones, they would still be alive before and after.
Programme kindness.
I like that they used zenyetta, BMO, Hal 9000 and the butter robot.
deepdownfear what ??
whAT? where is butter robot in the video?
0:00
"What's my purpose?"
"You pass butter"
*nice one.*
Trainer Red we are so intelligent for those nerds
I remember watching something in BBC where they made an AI baby by making a digital baby brain by mapping real human baby brains and recreating it digitally.. It's pretty scary because the AI works the same way as a real human brain so if human brain produces consciousness that way, then the AI should be conscious too.. It's pretty crazy to think about.
sauce?
That's still simulated tho, someone had to pour data into it in order for it to work. The thing about being sentient is that the AI would come up with stuff that was never programmed to know or "think" about. Having new ideas born out of nowhere.
@@baph0met When you think about it, human consciousness is actually simulated too.
@@kato_dsrdr We don't know that, it's dangerous to try and create conciousness if we don't know what conciousness even is. This is the point of universe and life type of shit.
I personally would love a sentient robotic companion.
Just dont let it go on the internet unnatended before it catches a virus and wants to be a real boy made out of flesh taken directly from you and wears you as a bodysuit.