ISL vs I-League Decoded: The problem with football in India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- First came National Football League, then I-League and then ISL. The Indian Express's Mihir Vasavda explains how club football in India has become a fight for survival between the I-League and ISL clubs, and how it affects football in India.
Why Prithvi Shaw Banned and What is Indian cricket’s Anti-Doping Plan?: • Why Prithvi Shaw Banne...
MS Dhoni to do patrolling, guard and post duty with his Territorial Army battalion: • MS Dhoni to do patroll...
T20 Blast still promises to pull in the crowds?: • T20 Blast still promis...
Subscribe to Indian Express: goo.gl/RjJrX0
The Indian Express Online covers all latest and trending news across India, which includes political news, mobile launches, gadgets reviews, technology updates, Entertainment News, Bollywood news, public opinions and views on daily trends.
Connect with us:
Facebook: / indianexpress
Twitter: / indianexpress
Indian Express App: indianexpress.c...
Official Website: indianexpress.... Indian Express, The Indian Express Newspaper, The Indian Express, Indian express news, indian express editorial Today's Indian Express newspaper offers a comprehensive package of news, including Indian Express editorial analysis and Indian Express analysis today. This well-respected publication covers a wide range of topics in its India Express editorial and Indian Express news sections. Stay informed with the Indian Express newspaper today.
ISL was actually a product of Ambanis who thought the IPL model can be used in football. I’m a blasters fan but I have to admit as a person who lives in the UK and seen football structure outside India it actually makes sense why ISL lost its spark.
i hope in the coming years, ISL get more attention and become more popular than IPL. Im talking 10 years later cuz i know it takes time. i hope that the teams in ISL also increses in the coming years (like 20). And hope we get more of those amazing derby matches and tough competitions
@@heartfulbreeze6801 hopefully yes, but the problem I found is in the grassroots level in India. The way which young people are introduced to the game. In Europe a child kicks the ball almost when he is like 3 or 4, parents encourage it. Football becomes that child’s main way of spending spare time. In India a child doesn’t have a spare time. Children stay to play amateur level 9 aside and 11 aside at very age. They are coached and trained according to there age level. All clubs who are semi pro and above have a youth system where they develop players through there system. In India it’s like we are only doing it to catch up rather than the betterment of the sport.
@@jobin118 after 20 yrs from now u will see India beating European countries in football
@@saurabhrana9646 Bro ... don’t get me wrong... I want that... but that process is actually a slow process... it takes more than 20 years... a lot of money been put into grassroots and youth facilities... and above all... Game importance must go up... India is still a cricket loving nation... that needs to be changed.
@@jobin118 82 millions people watch world cup in 2018 so u can't say Indian don't love football . Isl is also growing every year and now we have to work on grassroots which is the major issue which will be resolve in next 5 to 6 yrs.
Quite a conundrum. The straight jacket approach of IPL can't be applied to ISL because Ranji trophy and various other domestic leagues were already in good places and providing top notch players to the Indian national team. In this case IPL became just another tournament, for one new format of Cricket.
Comparing same with ISL is like chalk and cheese.
I hope what happened with West Indies cricket doesn't happen with newly found Indian football.
Exactly, isl and i league should merge together to form a proper league.
Say what you want their were great teams before ISL but they never popularised the sport the federation dint know how to do business they dint do anything of what they should have done years ago
ISL removed indian football from its shell. And Indian football since have grown alot in India since the start of the isl
Watching this after news that East Bengal is joining ISL now. After ATK Mohun Bagan did do as well a while back. You guys should probably make another video again 😎 would be super interesting to watch 🙏🏼
ikr...
doesnt mean shit. ISL viewerdhip has dropped like an anchor. ISL needs a merger asap.
@@aono335 yes. You'll never be able to fill the stadium in mumbai Hyderabad or Odisha even if they sign Neymar or Messi coz there's no Football culture in those cities and AIFF is neglecting the traditional clubs which has genuine fan following and fans who worship the club. We need that kind of fan culture not this franchise based shit🤦♂️. Only mohun bagan, FC Goa, Kerala, chennaiyin, Bangalore n atk deserves to be in the top tier league along with likes of real kashmir, neroca, minerva etc
Isl brought some spark in indian football.
Who will play in ISL when all the clubs will shut down??
Pune City FC , and Delhi dynamos is just a start.
@@infinity8288 they shut because they did not play well and had no money
@@NOTHING-yx2xd Who wants to play when the losses in Isl range between 20 crore to 50 crore per season.
@@NOTHING-yx2xd if you play in cities which doesn't have any kind of Football culture or doesn't have any history that's what happens. If they'd given chance to clubs like aizwal, Neroca, minerva, Shillong lajong then something would've happened. Still time is there and AIFF should make a move to save Footballing culture in India
@@infinity8288 Thats when promotion and relegation comes to play, best clubs with best gameplay attract viewers, brought investment/sponsor's. Best one stays like a king. I just saw this video now😀
Indian football was nothing before the ISL... i-league clubs like East Bengal in a 100 years have done nothing for the growth of Indian football... Evolution always beats tradition
Isl isn't helping Indian football at all.
@@xddd5556 what has the i-league done then
@@das8713 because of Ileauge there was a chance for any club to come on top. But isl does not let that happen. So clubs like Peerless fc and bhawanipur fc Will never get the chance to play in the top tier. Even mohammedan will probably never get to play in it
@@xddd5556 these poor clubs don't deserve to play in the ISL... when BJP wins in West Bengal, east Bengals won't be in the ISL anymore
@@das8713 well I'm a right wing activist so yes I'll be happy if BJP wins. Anyways so the clubs you think which are rich that's why they are playing in isl. Those aren't even clubs. Every single team in isl is a franchise except bengaluru fc, mohon bag and achi and sc east bengal. That's why we don't see those clubs playing in other durand cup or Something like that. Franchises don't last long. We saw how the champions League of cricket ceased to exist.
Every team of isl and I league should be joined to make a 20 team league.
you didnt get it.................they dont have money to participate in i-league.....you want them to start playing isl...............what a joke
@@deveshsonam no I am telling that there should be no isl or I league . The one league should be India league 1
@@ManchesterUnited2611 brother isl clubs have huge fan bases and more money therefore more better players since now ATKMB and east Bengal are in isl . I league cannot be compared to isl
@@NOTHING-yx2xd I think what he wants to say is that there should be 20 teams playing in the league
@@anjuthapa1955 yes
Indianexpress you need better jaurnalist who knows football.. he didn't understand Indian football.
Wow no people to talk about in the comments about Indian football 👍 ...just wow
Though isl has basic fault yet I think it has helped Indian players impove...we were having an unbeaten run in Asian cup qualifiers under Constantine and even qualified for it 2019 without any backdoor tournament like in 2011 .. .yes there are negative but I think it's not all dark and minus ...some positive can been seen and atleast something is happening in Indian football whether good or bad
My opinion is both the league should be compiled or linked in some way and there should be only one tournament. Then we will have 20 teams and it will be a long season which will also benefit the indian players
You have cleared all very properly , thanks, plz describe the present situation .
The FIFA World Cup 2034 should be held in India. India has population of 140 crore.
When you want your footballing nation to flourish you don't make money a priority..... Football is a beautiful game... Money should not interfere in this affair unless you are broke
This is just WOW
Why so few comments
Please get input done properly n publish a new story now in current scenario
Well thing changed isl going start relegation
India will never reach world Cup if we go on like this system league that can't even get relegate.
Working on your voice and your sound is not much attractive... Work on it