Is this THE BEST TRAIN GAME on Roblox?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 сер 2024
- Is this THE BEST TRAIN GAME on Roblox? - Like 👍, Subscribe, and press the bell 🔔 if you enjoy my content!
In this video I answer the question: Is BR better than SCR? Watch to the end to find out!
This video is kid/family friendly! ✔
MUSIC USED
Music: Tobu - Higher
/ tobuofficial
SCORE CHANGES
+1 point for SCR on the scenery category, there is a lot more variety in SCR, such as there are rural areas and urban, city-like areas.
GAME
web.roblox.com...
CHAPTERS
00:00 Intro
00:31 Trains
01:13 Scenery
01:45 Sounds
04:34 Other Stuff / Features
05:06 Results
05:09 Outro - Ігри
For whoever's wondering, this was filmed and edited during v1.1.1, so the v1.2 additions ARE NOT INCLUDED in this video. Also, please DON'T TAKE OFFENCE if you have different opinions to me.
Even tho you have a different opinion than me, you own a sub for good videos and also not all point to only one team :)
You also have to think about how long the games have been out for, BR has only been out for about 6 months while SCR is almost 6 years old, so that is why SCR has more trains
Another good point, was going to mention this in the video as well.
Yeah but SCR still has more train than br if they both were 6 month old
I don't think it is fair to compare both games using the same categories, because the goal for SCR and BR are not the same. While BR focuses heavily on realistic graphics, trains and stuff, SCR has unique announcements recorded from irl train announcers, training system, a lot of technical features and is designed for a younger/less experienced playerbase with more "cartoony" look and easy to control trains.
Yep, I understand this, cheers for the info 👍
SCR is a ugly post Privatisation era game with post Privatisation era trains etc. and a toxic averagely 12 year old community.
@@mr.atomic2970 the main problem is the toxicity, but if you simply ignore it, you will be okay.
@@franciscosalcedo8754 yea thats true
@@franciscosalcedo8754 yeah that true but you barely join a server with toxic player tbh (As a player than played SCR fore more than 2 years)
1:45 The class 220/221 are also in both games just to let you know
Yes I know many people have told me about this already!
@@mrtrainguyofficial oh sorry
BR has 8 trains now and is even better since the update. Now it has these trains (Sorted after number):
- Class 90+Mk3
- Class 142
- Class 153
- Class 156
- Class 170
- Class 220
- Class 221
- Class 350
There are as well the routes to Newhurst for free, routes to Victoria Harbour for 50 coins, routes to Norrington for 400 coins, routes to Fleetwood for 400 coins and routes to Mill Bridge for 500 coins.
Yes, I know. (See pinned comment).
SCR is a game from 2017, so it has been around for years, British railway has only been an open game for 1 year, so it is expected for BR to have a more limited train selection as they are doing quality over quantity.
Seems to be that's what most new games are focusing on now.
220 is also in both games, and 142/143 should count
Yes I know about this, sorry!
SCR is a clear example of Quantity rather than mostly sadly, BUT it is like that because it is focused on being more of a arcade simulator
Yep, I know that SCR is quantity < quality.
Agree on everything said in this video.
Thank you!
Finally an unbiased comparison
Thank you!
BR train in high speed are more intense than scr because the train are bigger and have realistic sound. Also very high risk because the track are not easy as scr track and physic system.
You aren't wrong!
I think i prefer SCR because BR is overdetailed for a roblox game (This is my opinion)
So you don't like detailed games😂
1:47 that is incorrect. The Voyagers are also in both games. All other trains BR has that SCR doesn't. Technically you could say the 142 from BR and the 143 feom SCR (Waterline) but although they are from the same family of trains they don't count
Yep I am aware of this, please can you check the other comments next time in case this has been mentioned already?
@@mrtrainguyofficial Yeah I saw that. Sometimes things are taken blindly.
In all seriousness though you could technically say the Pacer family is in both games but not really with SCR going with the 143 and BR having the 142.
But yeah really decent video from someone that does content myself with British Railway being my most watched.
Keep the work up! 🙌
@@RBMapleLeaf Thanks! Yeah I understand that the 142/143 are in the same family of trains.
Here's what's in SCR and BR (1.2 version)
-class 220 and 221
-class 350
-class 170
I know about 1.2!
Alright Is time to say my thoughts about this video, so For my eyes right now realism Is the thing I care, BR Is much more realistic than
SCR In many ways, let's not forget that BR Is a game which Is slowly getting into recognition from People, for me when I started BR I found things a lot easier than SCR, Braking to stop at a station Is realistic as Irl you don't enter stations at 80 and Braking In BR you should brake before entering so for the features I said BR Is the only winner, you should do a review on WCR which Is more likely to be a better SCR, and I suggest people that starting SCR to come to BR and see the realism, cause some trains doesn't have combined throttle there, and there's a different notch for Brakes, last thing to this Idk nonsense this video Is good keep up the good work.
May do this in the future. Thanks for the information!
I know its tour opinion, but in stations SCR wins because in BR there are lots of copy paste stations
Sure, I understand that and if I would've covered stations I would have given SCR a point as there is more variety!
@@mrtrainguyofficial exactly!
I prefer BR because it is more realistic
@@polreigriol7512it literally dosent they make it that’s why it takes 1 year scr copy and pastes old tracks
You forgot Stepford Express
I did mention it?
@@mrtrainguyofficialyou did mention it.
Why is ur channel icon a bus when ur name is a mr train guy
I like buses as well!
Why would you ask that question....
@@fokuz2025scr syndrome
8 you genius.
Recorded in V1.1.1.
@@mrtrainguyofficial but uploaded some hours ago
1:51 class 220 AND 221 left the chat
SCR is 100 time better then BR!!!
both are good, but the scenery is so good
In fairness, both the games are not really comparable
Yeah I have realised that now!
Just subbed
Thank you! Much appreciated 👍
WHY DOES SCR HAVE MORE PLAYERS?
It's an older game.
@@mrtrainguyofficial Scr had 2 operates at this point and way more trains when it realesd also saying it's newer dissent change gameplay
@@astroboy4653 Even though it did have more trains, none of them were 'NextGen', quality has increased over time.
@@mrtrainguyofficial Yeah but back then roblox did not have as many features to work with.
Also I'm not trying to get any beef I love it channel.
WHY DID BR GET A POINT IN THE FIRST CATEGORY?
Trains are better-looking to me, more detailed etc. Now I know that there are mesh trains in SCR, they would've won if the devs had finished them/done a few more considering there are still old models in game.
4:27 actually SCR has better sounds lol
How the 350 fades away while in real life theirs a second motor at 20mph British railway follows it that means br is more better and it’s a fact
You forgot that voyagers exist
I know, others have informed me of this.
1:54 Voyagers...
Yep I know.
To the SCR fanboys/fangirls in the reply section
Does SCR have weather NO
Does SCR have the Class 90 the devs promised us NO
Does SCR have the 142 we were promised NO
Does SCR have realistic driving physics NO
Does SCR have the Class 153 and Class 156 people have been asking the devs to add for ages now NO
Does SCR have Break easily YES
Does SCR have a creator that had paedophilia allegations put against then YES
Does SCR have an endless amount of bugs YES
Does SCR have a dying fan base YES
is SCR screwed if BR continues to catch up YES
Over all SCR is fucked so just get over it
W
totally agree with u, br is fr catching up
Innit SCR is for people who don’t know about trains
I prefer the 170 sound on SCR more not because quality but the sound on BR almost made me deaf it was so loud and the only way to make it muffled is put the camera in the cab which i hate and the signal changer sound is i think is more muffled on BR which is ok but since this sound is not loud it shouldn’t be muffled
Just lower the volume then they made a realistic sound stop hating fr
@@fsoy7479Exactly!
Just lower the volume in game and it should work better!
Still on 50 percent volume doesn’t work
@@KMdonatestuntguy If you're wearing headphones, it doesn't help.
SCR>BR
ok?
Als be has free private Server
Yep, good point
Scr trains is still expensive 😭
I know
So what should I do how can I get rich quickly
@@ylchoibus11082 Just try and find the longest routes + routes that give the most points and keep repeating them
Can I just play SCR in peace?
Why watch this video then?
@@TheAaronsGamers I got recommended this.
Why did you click on it then when you knew you would be disappointed by br winning
@@TheAaronsGamers I didn't know, and I don't know.
Don’t you dare! SCR is just as good as BR!
Your opinion may be different to mine.
no.
far from it
@@Rowan66109yes
BR is too laggy so 0 points for BR!
eh, it's ok for me
its just ur pc
@@KBStrecke172 not everyone has a pc
Br is s**t it is hard to understand the gameplay
BR is only bad when you don’t know anything about trains
The scenery in scr absolutely smacks BR out of the park imo, yes BR has more detail but, for most of the map it’s the same bland foresty green scenery while SCR has actual cities with massive buildings while also having rural areas
Yep, completely understand this, should've picked up on that. Cheers for letting me know!
Edit: Scores have been updated, check description!
It's your opinion but uhh, most parts there's like nothing it's just flat land, no trees just flat grass with no detail
@@grapejuice116 in very small parts of the map like the willow field branch yes I agree but for the large part it pretty good, the ww- LBTS scenery is gorgeous, and the metropolitan areas like Benton and stepford area are very well done
Well BR got now with 1.2 rural and old Cities too (Belmond Green) and BR had before already greenish areas and big Cities.
@@grapejuice116exactly scr fanboys just cant handle that BR is better fu## the Privatisation.