They will say it's just a metaphor, but when you read the hadith, it is actually hard to say that it's not literally the heart: "I was brought a vessel of gold containing Zamzam water, so my chest was split, to here.’” - Qatadah said: “I said to Anas: ‘What does that mean?’ He said: ‘To the lowest part of his stomach.’” - He said: “So my heart was removed, and washed with Zamzam water, then returned to its placed. Then I was filled with Faith and wisdom." (Grade: Sahih Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3346)
If the heart had anything to do with cognition, memory, learned skills or knowledge then a person undergoing a heart transplant should develop a whole new personality post-operation. Also, post-operation the person wouldn't recognise his family or friends or anything that happened in his life because his memory would be lost. Also, he shouldn't have any problem recognising the donor's family. He would love the donor's wife and children as his own. Suppose a surgeon's heart was transplanted into a pilot then the pilot wouldn't be able to fly planes anymore but he could easily walk into an operation theatre and do the surgery because the medical knowledge and the surgical skills would all be in the heart the pilot received from the surgeon. Similarly, the person wouldn't be able to speak his mother tongue if the mother tongue of the donor was different. If the donor was a Christian and the recipient was a Muslim then post-transplant the recipient would become a Christian because faith, rituals and religious practices would all be in the heart. Now if you think all these sound like a funny story then tell this to those who think the heart is involved in cognition, emotion and learning. Also there are people living with artificial heart that lacks any intrinsic cardiac neurons and they don't have any change in their cognition, personality, emotions, memory, knowledge, beliefs etc. This is because ONLY the brain is the centre of these faculties.
While the heart has its own “operating system” there is also a communication channel between the brain & the heart. There is growing collaboration between cardiologists & neurologists and subsequent research could prove that a backup of the heart’s OS in a portion of the brain is transferred to the transplanted heart. New discoveries, Alhamdulillah, only continue to confirm what was revealed 1400 years ago.
@@sajidaziz7742 Stan Larkin, lived for two years without a hearth, just a machin pomping his blood there is also a communication channel between the brain and the gut ( this is why we call the gut the second brain ) People back then thought that the consciousness eregateted from the hearth, which false and sadly muhamed copied dumbly that in the Quran.
@@sajidaziz7742 a very weak answer. and the fact that each time a muslim is asked about it, they give different answers, proves how much of a mistake it is. coupled with where cows milk comes from between excretion and blood (Quran 16:66), the sun setting somewhere on Earth in a muddy spring surrounded by people (Quran 18:86), the planet being compared to a carpet rather than a sphere ( Quran 20:53) and that a man's seed comes from between the spine (backbone) and the ribs (Quran 86:5-7)... proves the Quran, or rather who made it, had no clue what they were talking about. tried to appear scientifically savvy and spouting the same crap ppl of that time believed about the world does not make the Quran any more divine than a child's bedtime-story book.
@@ragael1024 heart has its own memory... As said above after heart transplant person should act deffrently .... There r such cases ... That dosent mean all the memory and reasoning r done by heart .
When someone has a heart transplant, they remember everything, but if they have a brain trauma they may or may not forget everything depending on the severity of the trauma.
Also in the story of الاسراء و المعراج, I remember before Muhammed went to heaven the angel took his heart out and cleaned it from 'desires' or whatever.
After cleaning the heart Mo the prophet came down onto the earth conducted more caravan robberies raids rapes, slave trade, took concubines killed men and children took their women and girls ...all with a divinely clean soul. Alham dulila....
[Qur’an 17:36] "You shall not accept any information, unless you verify it for yourself. I have given you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brain, and you are responsible for using them." It seems like it was well known that the brain is used for reasoning. I think "hearts" were used figuratively in those verses.
Should you trust your heart or mind? Listening to your head may lead to more tangible success, but not following your heart increases your risk of regret, so if you want to lead a more satisfying life, follow your heart.30 Nov 2019
The heart is a blood pumping organ, not more not less. What you feel in your heart is brain generated emotion and signals of the vagus nerve. That is childish thinking to misappoint an organs function to another.
@@اسكندرفكار Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain. “The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
@@brazenbull36 The Thinking Human Heart Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain. “The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
You are verry ignorant, you don’t know science and you don’t know the Quran , first of all Allah knows best wat we do witch our heart and brain. Modern science has discovered we lie with our brain espaisly Science “Regions in the frontal and parietal cortex showed higher activation when participants lied compared with when they were telling the truth, regardless of whether they were asked about their past experiences or opinions.” www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5390719/#:~:text=Regions%20in%20the%20frontal%20and,their%20past%20experiences%20or%20opinions. Quran : What if that ˹man˺ persists in denial and turns away? Does he not know that Allah sees ˹all˺? ut no! If he does not desist, We will certainly drag him by the forelock- a lying, sinful forelock So let him call his associates. We will call the wardens of Hell. What considering the fact of that we als feel and think with our heart is not an ancient myth anyomore , you don’t catch up with sciene . Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system. Feelings have so much to do with the heart, as they do with the brain. It's actually a two-way relationship. Our emotions change the signals the brain sends to the heart and the heart responds to the brain in complex ways. norwestchiro.co.nz/heart-and-brain-connection#:~:text=Feelings%20have%20so%20much%20to,the%20brain%20in%20complex%20ways..
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why. Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief. "No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16) This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?" The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason. The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything." These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs. Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
@@14__16 Mind isn't in the brain does not mean its linking with heart 😆 Well mind is an abstract thing. Even gases have mass though they don't have shape. And mind has neither shape nor mass nor color Btw whats your definition of ''soul'' and ''mind''??
My favorite verse regarding this is, "...Indeed, it is not the eyes that are blind, but it is the hearts in the chests that grow blind." (Quran 22:46) It moved Joram Van Klaveren when he was writing an anti-Islam book. Yet, it can move some others to a very different path. I think it's so true "We send down the Quran as healing and mercy to those who believe; as for those who disbelieve, it only increases their loss." (Quran 17:82) I'm pretty sure these 'blind hearts' is not about the physical heart that pumps blood, and it's not also about the mind. It's more than that.
Those hearts did not "grow" blind, but usually it's Allah, who leads them astray. And astray usually means: they believe in another God, who is not that blood-thirsty.
@@OrpheusXL @OrpheusXL Say, ‘People of the Book, let us arrive at a statement that is common to us all: we worship God alone, we ascribe no partner to Him, and none of us takes others beside God as lords.’ If they turn away, say, ‘Witness our devotion to Him.’ (Quran 3:64) I encourage you to read the Quran through the lens of Al-Fatihah, not the lens of another human being. May God bless you.
@@nadhirahafizha9611 Well, it's the Quran which says, that Christians worship 3 gods. Why? Because Mohammed did not understand the trinity. He did not even understand anything spiritual. Even the islamic paradise is material and more like a sex club than anything else. Christians have three names for the main attributes of Jesus/Jehova. Muslims have 99 names for Allah. Are there 99 gods? And through then "lens" of Al-Fatiha it looks like cursing all people who are not Muslims. ---> Let us not be that bad and evil like those! And you curse us ever day like this. How can we come together? Jesus said: Who denies the Father, also denies the Son, that is the Antichrist.
@@OrpheusXL "People of the Book, do not go to excess in your religion, and do not say anything about God except the truth: the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, was nothing more than a messenger of God, His word, directed to Mary, a spirit from Him. So believe in God and His messengers and do not speak of a ‘Trinity’- stop [this], that is better for you- God is only one God, He is far above having a son, everything in the heavens and earth belongs to Him and He is the best one to trust." (Quran 4:171) That verse says, 'Do not go to excess' (تَغۡلُواْ فِى دِينِكُمۡ). So the verse doesn't say Christians had the intention to worship more than One God. By using that phrase, it acknowledges the sincere intention to worship One God. "The Most Excellent Names (ٱلۡأَسۡمَآءُ ٱلۡحُسۡنَىٰ) belong to God: use them to call on Him, and keep away from those who abuse them- they will be requited for what they do." (Quran 7:180) They are the names of God. It helps people to call and understand Him. Had God not facilitated it to be known on the tongues of the children of Adam, none from the creation would have been able to call His names. Muslim scholars viewed these names as aligned to human beings' language and comprehension, but it doesn't mean God has names limited only to ninety nine. Suppose I say that you are *sincere and kind.* *Sincere and kind* are your attributes. I did not refer to other entities. "Guide us to the straight path: the path of those You have blessed, those who incur no anger and who have not gone astray." (Quran 1 [Al-Fatihah]: 6-7) The verse talks about the path (ٱلصِّرَٰطَ). When it talks about the path, it is about beliefs, actions, behaviors. The Quran should be firm with its position regarding this path (ٱلصِّرَٰطَ), but never the verse says to curse people who hold other beliefs. My friend, I am a Muslim, and I want to devote myself to God. I genuinely trust that you want to devote yourself to God as well. But media has portrayed me as someone hateful and ready to curse anyone who doesn't have the same beliefs as me. I hope you don't fall into that trap. If you find some Muslims who did that, remember that what some Muslims do, doesn't always represent what Islam says in the Quran; then you may forgive them. As always, may God bless you.
Science still hasn't proven the mystery of conciousness, and if such a thing as a soul exists. I think 'heart' in this instance refers to the soul, which is the source of conciousness.
Science still hasn't proven where conciousness comes from. Conciousness is indeed one of the biggest mysteries in Neuroscience. What do you say to that?
@@JosephKing001 Never from the brain! YOU can observe your thoughts. You are aware of it (when your attention goes into the observation. But usually we are asleep) Question: WHO is the observer? This makes it very clear, that consciousness is NOT in/from the brain.
@a m That's a wrong explanation You can go back to the first explaners.. and you will see that they absolutely disagree with your explanation anyway their explanation or your Explanation the two are full of sh!t
@a m The classic exposition of judgement at death comes in the Book of Coming Forth by Day, in chapter/spell 30 and in chapter/spell 125, and the so-called weighing of the heart. To the Egyptians, the heart, or ib, rather than the brain, was the source of human wisdom and the centre of emotions and memory. Because of its apparent links with intellect, personality and memory, it was considered the most important of the internal organs. It could reveal the person's true character, even after death, so the belief went, and therefore the heart was left in the deceased's body during mummification. In the weighing of the heart rite, the heart of the deceased is weighed in the scale against the feather of the goddess Maat, who personifies order, truth, and what is right. Spell 30 was often inscribed on heart scarabs that were placed with the deceased. The spell appeals to the heart not to weigh down the balance or testify against the deceased to the keeper of the balance. Part of the spell gives instructions for making the heart scarab: ‘Make a scarab of nephrite adorned with gold and put within a man's breast, and perform for him the ceremony of opening the mouth, the scarab being anointed with myrrh.’.1 www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3960665/#:~:text=In%20Egyptian%20religion%2C%20the%20heart,weighing%20of%20the%20heart%20ceremony.%F0%9F%A4%A3%F0%9F%A4%A3%F0%9F%A4%A3
@a m "so their hearts may reason" = metaphorical "ears may listen" = literal how funny you guys need to twist and smash up your koran by pointing out it lacks continuity As someone else already said it: *_Cardiocentric hypothesis is where the idea came from,7th century myths ,, accept it and move on...your book is manmade full of errors of that time_*
The role of the human heart from an Islamic perspective. The heart's central role is to mantain phisical & spiritual activities of the body. In the Qur'an different characteristics like wisdom, intelligence, disease, thinking & many others are related to the heart. There's no need to explain that what is termed in literature as gnosis ( irfan) as " the heart " is not the organ which is in the left side of the body & pumps blood. It is clear what is meant by the heart is a sublime & distinguish reality which is totally different from the organ of the body.We are told in the Qur'an " There's an illness in their hearts, so God increases them in illness " 2:9. Certainly3
In the quran says zarah which today means an atom , the atom that has electrons and neutrons but hundreds of years it meant a grain of sand or something small The heart or al qalb means the organ which pumps blood that has oxygen in our body but probably hundreds of years it meant other stuff Also the soul is in the heart so your soul is the one which thinks using the heart and our soul is the one which makes its decisions
If there is anything that I understand from this, it is only the fact that the Egyptians had been really 'idiots' in terms of "philosophical and spiritual understanding" from day 1 of their existence in this world till today. Anyway, TQ for unwillingly/unintentionally/indirectly promoting Islam and making my faith in Islam much stronger.
It is amazing how some Muslims come here to comment (in three easy steps). 1. They don't address anything in the presented argument (because they have nothing logical to say against it) 2. They resolve into attaching the person and insulting him instead of responding with respect to "a bad argument" 3. They claim their victory, pat themselves on the back and assure themselves that their faith is much stronger I see this over and over, hundreds of times, in the comments...
@@AdamElmasriEnglish Sorry bro. To be honest I don't mean to 'attaching' and insulting you. I was just trying to showcase your ignorance and arrogance in not wanting to submit yourself to the 'truth' from Allah, just like the Egyptian 'Pharaoh', if not mistaken Ramses II who ended up drowning in the Red Sea due to his 'arrogance', but trying to claim victory and pat yourself on your back, as though you are too smart, while that's not the case . Anyway, coming to the point: Any grown ups would know/understand that the word derived from 'qalb' Allah mentions does not literally refer to the biological 'heart' we have, neither the brain, but in terms of human understanding/ day to day use of the word in common conversation to denote the 'deep feelings', one has about a subject matter . Because only Allah knows and we know not or grasp certain 'phenomena' for example the 'soul' which is beyond human definition or understanding that Allah says, of its 'knowledge' only a little that had been given to us. Btw, I do not claim to be too smart either, but surely better than you in understanding certain such 'phenomena' like the 'qalb' or the 'ruh' (soul) from the little knowledge that I have been given by Allah, to grasp its closest meaning or how it works in relation to human anatomy/organs, which I believe is beyond definition. But I made a search in Google on 'qalb' and the closest definition I could come up with that resonates with my kind is this Sufi view/terminology/definition that says: "The qalb is a bright essence separate from matter, between the human soul and the human self." So my request is, 'Stop spreading non sense abt things that you have no sure knowledge about and stop imposing your beliefs on others, thus 'contradicting yourself telling others not to impose their belief on others. Let the people choose themselves what is right and what is wrong. (Note: I am not native English. Pls bear with it) TQ
@@observerzzi didnt see him imposing any belief? in fact he argued with respect and intellect..with backed up references for people to think and searching for the truth and not blindly follow any religion .those resorted to killing the apostate is in fact the one who imposing and forcing a belief. how come a religion need to survives by threats and punishment? waging war? why such feeling of insecurity if the the message brought is the truth?
Wonderful video. Your arguments are flawless. I have such a ton of respect for people like you. There’s nothing more relieving than listening to people who speak with beautiful logic and reason, and not having to force arguments to explain nonsense. It’s like therapy and heals me from the years of anguish and anger I felt trying to make sense of Islam and to believe in something I genuinely and sincerely could not accept. I can’t lie to myself anymore. Also your Arabic is beautiful. I love hearing you speak actual truth in such a lovely language free from any Islamic discourse and rhetoric
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
@@shaun.august Allah is Shaitan. He prefers sinners, he promises sex and women to men only in Jannah, he discriminates against Jews and Christians and let the Jinn write verses. Allah is limited in power as well, as he cannot become flesh. What a halfass god he is.
@@shaun.august - can you explain to me why not one of these 124k prophets mentioned Islam until after the 7the century? We have found dinosaur fossils from millions of years ago. But not 1 shred of historical text of these alleged prophets shouting about Islam/Muslims. Funny that
@@shaun.august Have you eve watched the video the heart is not used as a figure of speech ,the writers of quran just took ancient greek belief ie plagiarized Aristotle ,just like they plagiarized Galen and many other ancient greek believes ,the verse al Ahraf 79 clearly demonstrates that heart is not an idiom in quran but an organ responsible for thinking and rationalizing ...
We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things? Q41:53
Verily, the truth has come to you from your Lord. So be not of those who doubt (it)[].95. And be not one of those who believe the Ayât (proofs, evidences, verses, lessons, signs, revelations, etc.) of Allâh, for then you shall be one of the losers.96. Truly! Those, against whom the Word (Wrath) of your Lord has been justified, will not believe.97. Even if every sign should come to them, - until they see the painful torment.
@Toxic Tricks Completely wrong. The heart neither thinks nor learns. These neurons exist for muscular coordination and blood pressure regulation and the stress axis.
@@haiderabbas8486 Aha. If nothing works anymore, you will conjure up eternal torment in hell. Great! If there is a God, he gave us the ability to think and reflect so that we could use it. But Islam has the same weakness as all religions: a maxim common to all - "Thou shalt not ask questions!"
Sir why he doesn't want quote the context , this people are playing with the of some people , in West Africa we know there is one God before the europeans came , our forethers never heard the name Jesus till the europeans came , moreover the letter ( J ) is not Jewish alphabet or Arabic, there are tribes in West Africa without the letter( J )
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why. Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief. "No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16) This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?" The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason. The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything." These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs. Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
@@ryan10001 their is no confusion in my mind about that ideology from the 7th century i.s.i.s. open my eyes on how evil islam is actually ,they follow your ''prophet'' to the letter i read their ''dabiq'' publications that explain the why they do what they do taking slaves cutting christians head ect... to the glory of that god from hell killing,killing it is a death cult the trees and the rocks will tell you to kill jews it is so absurd everywhere where there are islamists hell follows
@@AdamElmasriEnglish Please read about the "Nous" and "Heart" in the Old Testament. Evidently, the people who wrote the quran incorporated the concept of Nous without being able to understand or explain it.
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why. Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief. "No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16) This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?" The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason. The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything." These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs. Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
@@ryan10001 I half agree with you. I think it's the authors of the Quran that are stupid. When they invented the Quran, they made such a disjointed mess that people have to keep interpreting it. It's almost like Muslims are admitting Allah is autistic and isn't able to communicate properly, so he needs his own creations to explain and interpret this mess. You are right about one thing though, the authors of the Quran certainly used metaphors and examples that are very locally specific.... which goes to show that this was the works of men, not god. Good effort on trying though dude, but it's impossible to put lipstick on a pig and call it beautiful
Once again very well done, and a great topic that did not crossed my mind. Awesome to see your channel grow, more people need to be aware of these videos.
Have they not traveled in the earth so that they have hearts to think with or ears to hear with? Surely then it is not the beholdings (i.e. the eyes) that (grow) blind, but (it is) the hearts within the breasts that (grow) blind. Q22:46
Until recently, modern science perceived the heart as merely a pump to regulate the flow of blood throughout our bodies. But across numerous cultures, the heart has historically been thought to have a much greater function that corresponds with our thoughts, emotions, and spirit. When we speak or share feelings from a place of deep meaning or passion, we say we’re speaking from the heart or we’re trying to convey something that is heartfelt. This is no longer just an archaic maxim, but instead, one with factual backing. And science is now realizing that the heart and brain have more of a corollary, interactive relationship than previously thought … a relationship that has residual consequences on our bodies, and possibly even humanity as a whole.
Islam goal is not to make man pursue happiness unlike the Capitalist system. Man's goal is to strive to achieve God's validation, not to be validated by His creations. If one strive to develop a submissive mindset, he will eventually reach the level as God state in the Quran: "(O Man) Say : Indeed my worship, my striving, my life and my death all are for God the Lord of creations." When your goal is solely to serve God, as His Vicegerent on earth, then your legacy to humanity will be eternal like late boxer Muhammad Ali's statement engraved on his grave stone: "Service to others is the rent you pay for your room in Heaven." Islam aim is to make Man highly valuable and live a truly meaningful life as following: "If you could envisioned the the type of person God intended you to be, you would rise up and never be the same again." Unlike other creations, Man has a malleable mindset and he can transform himself to a better human version. The Quran motivates him thus: "Indeed, God will not change the condition of a people until they change what is within themselves" Capitalism has created a void within humans which can only be solved by a paradigm shift. These Quranic verses pinpoint the Western disease: "For indeed, "rivalry for worldly gain distracts you until you visit your graves". With a deep and grave rhythm the Qur'an then strikes their hearts with the terror awaiting them after coming to the graves: "Indeed, you shall know".
Understanding by haert means using intuition، it has nothing to do with organs and biology. I am a Bahai، I don't believe Islam is last religion، but happy to debate about Islam.
When the blood flow to the brain is compromised, a condition called stroke, the person can lose cognitive faculties. The person can lose consciousness, lose the ability to speak or comprehend language, become disoriented to time, place and person, lose either immediate memmory or long term memmory or both, become paralysed, endure sensory loss etc. If there is a cerebral injury sparing the brainstem the person can enter a vegetative state in which his vital functions like respiration and circulation are intact but the person is in a coma. This is because the brainstem regulates our vital functions where as the cerebral cortex is involved in cognitive, motor and sensory functions. In these conditions the heart is spared and can function normally yet the patient's cognition, behaviour, motor and sensory functions are affected. On the other hand when a person has a heart attack there is no loss of cognitive, behavioural, motor or sensory function. This itself shows how the heart is not involved in any of the cognitive, behavioural, motor or sensory functions.
If the heart had anything to do with cognition, memory, learned skills or knowledge then a person undergoing a heart transplant should develop a whole new personality post-operation. Also, post-operation the person wouldn't recognise his family or friends or anything that happened in his life because his memory would be lost. Also, he shouldn't have any problem recognising the donor's family. He would love the donor's wife and children as his own. Suppose a surgeon's heart was transplanted into a pilot then the pilot wouldn't be able to fly planes anymore but he could easily walk into an operation theatre and do the surgery because the medical knowledge and the surgical skills would all be in the heart the pilot received from the surgeon. Similarly, the person wouldn't be able to speak his mother tongue if the mother tongue of the donor was different. If the donor was a Christian and the recipient was a Muslim then post-transplant the recipient would become a Christian because faith, rituals and religious practices would all be in the heart. Now if you think all these sound like a funny story then tell this to those who think the heart is involved in cognition, emotion and learning. Also there are people living with artificial heart that lacks any intrinsic cardiac neurons and they don't have any change in their cognition, personality, emotions, memory, knowledge, beliefs etc. This is because ONLY the brain is the centre of these faculties.
@@AyeshaKhan-0-. The heart is not just a pump. It has its neural network or "little brain." The methods targeting the heart modulate pain regions in the brain. These methods seem to modulate the key changes that occur in the brain regions and are involved in the cognitive and emotional factors of pain. Thus, the heart is probably a key moderator of the brain
I am not a believer in any religion, but I think in this case perhaps the writers of the quran WERE using the term as a figure of speech even if they did indeed believe that the heart was the center of intelligence and feelings. The way the verses are written they could certainly be interpreted both ways. The problem is that if it really was a figure of speech, Islamic scholars would use that answer to the question all the time...and not some easily disproven claim that the word had two meanings.
Not only that, a perfect book, dictated by God, shouldn't use a figure of speech as to confuse believers, isn't that the reason why the quran was sent , to be superior to the Bible which does need exegesis. If the quran needs explanations too, what makes it different from the Christian and Jews scriptures.
It is a demonstration of the art of Taquiya promoted by Allah in the Quraan. Taquiya means to tell.ies to save your face or promote the interests of jihaad (Isma's claims) .
Please google Little Brain in the Heart. There is a group of neuron cells in the heart that is independent from our brain. I hope this will open up your heart to the truth.
these islamophobia know it was figure of speech but making an issue because they have nothing against islam , in every language people said listen to your heart and not mind why ?
@@Toppgg-ci9erIslam commands sexual slavery, pedophilia and wife beating.. no thanks 👍 And makes scientific errors beyond question such as the 7 earths and skies/heavens, the sun setting in a muddy pool, and the shooting stars are actual stars thrown at the jinn to stop them from reaching heaven.. A man made religion, with more than 100 grammatical errors in the holy book.
The word kalb has two meaning one is heart and other is intelligence and it means intelligence there and it also speaks in some verses that the heart behind breasts but it that's too not the correct translation because the word used in Arabic for breast("sadaq") has two meaning that is centre now the meaning changes to centre of intelligence. So, why I used centre here because in other place the word used for breast is used when the musa(a.s) asked to allah to in surah taha(26-28) increase my (breast-"sadaq") for me. See here the word doesn't mean breast but it means its centre, he asked to increase his centre not brests. Likewise it is the centre of intelligence (intelligence within the centre)is blocked. And it's refuted easily so go take some other things to refute.
You just copied the BS from zakir nayek which I presented in the video.. clearly you haven’t watched the full video if you’re just repeating the utter nonsense. I bet you are not a native Arabic speaker!! Please provide me with one example that the word Kalb means intelligence and not heart!
to whom you are wasting your time he is blind with his heart as ALLAH SWT explain Now he will make another Video see Quran say heart has eyes which blind their eyes are not blind but hearts are
Interesting. This same arguement applies to all the astonomy references as well. A geocentric (earth is center of universe) view of the universe is understood and expressed even though the reality is that the sun (heliocentric) is the center of our solar system.
Agreed. The verses are not precise however so Muslims re-interpret them and say that the orbits talked about are different, they say that the orbit of the Sun is with respect to the center of our galaxy (even though the Quran mentions day and night in the same verse!).
Also I must add a leading cleric the director of madina University ibn baz felt so strongly on this issue that he issued a fatwa calling those who didn't accept pre copernican understanding as kafirs
“Those who believe (in the Oneness of Allah - Islamic Monotheism), and whose hearts find rest in the remembrance of Allah, Verily, in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find rest”. [Quran 13:28]
Very well done!👏New subscriber here. This is an example of why the words Quran and science fit together only as well as a woolly mammoth through the eye of a needle.🦣
@@AdamElmasriEnglishhi I’m not sure if you’ll ever see this but I hope one day you can do a response to Mohammed hijabs video refuting the videos that say there are scientific errors in the Quran, he made an argument against people saying that actually there is something in science that proves “gushing water “ actually does come from the back bone & the rib. If what I have wrote is unorganised it is because of my autism I have recently left Islam & am looking for the truth as I don’t speak Arabic.
@@rb757 my dear friend, thank you for reaching out to me, your lovely comment and request. Please connect with me on Instagram freethinker_adamelmasri and send me Mohamed Hijab’s video in question. I look forward to connecting with you.
Quantum neurocardiology is an emerging field of study that seeks to understand the relationship between the heart, the brain, and quantum physics. The field suggests that the heart, in addition to its function as a pumping organ, may also serve as a complex information processing center that communicates with the brain and other organs through electromagnetic fields. The heart has its own nervous system, known as the “intrinsic cardiac nervous system," which contains neurons and neurotransmitters that allow it to function independently of the brain. Studies have shown that the heart’s electromagnetic field is much stronger than that of the brain, and that it can influence the brain’s electrical activity and even affect cognition and emotion.
So instead of admitting that the quran is blatantly false, you will go to such lenghts to humiliate yourself in order to defend it? It is easier for people to be fooled than for them to admit they have been fooled.
@@muhammadumernaseervisiting964 Mhm. Instead, just prove that god exists and you'll have turned the entire world to your cause. You have the burden of proof, after all.
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
@@muhammadumernaseervisiting964 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, another pseudoscience buzz word is 'quantum'. They just throw in the word 'quantum' with nonsensical ideas thinking it will add credibility. Neither the proponents of such ideas nor the people who cite such ideas as evidence for their pre-scientific religious or political agendas know what is meant by pseudoscience buzz words like 'quantum' or 'holistic'. Treatment should be target specific and that's what evidence based medicine is aiming for by introducing 'target specific immunotherapy' for cancers and many rheumatological diseases. There is no need to treat healthy organs or the whole body for a disease of a specific pathophysiology unless it affects or spreads to other areas of the body. 'Holistic' treatment only harms the person. Even when evidences show the harmful effects or the inefficacy of these so called 'holistic' treatments, quacks and people alike ignore it. Similarly, Heartmath institute says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
If you watched the video to the end, you’d know where that metaphor comes from.. and why it is not accepted as a metaphor from the Quran! But you probably didn’t watch the full video!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish i watched the whole video, and i m telling you that quran talks to people according to what they used to in their place / time , they used the heart as a metaphor for sense , feelings , you need some non materialistic thinking sometimes 🌹
So why no metaphor was used with eyes to see and ears to hear ??? And why no mentioning of brain anywhere in quran??? Just because you have no excuse to defend , you use "METAPHOR" ...it ain't gonna work now...
@@hareth3911 reality is what that is written,, imagination is what you are trying to do by saying it to be metaphor... Egyptians used to beleive that heart is the organ that controls human body... So it was copied like that... Simple and easy
Good question but ask yourself another question. Why did God use the Arabic language to communicate? So humans at those times would understand. So wouldn't God use figurative speech to convey his message especially by the fact the Quran sounds like more of a poem? Figurative language back then were used by the Arabs and God sent down the Quran in THEIR language. Discussion over.
@aminafarah9933 The crazy thing is that Muslims keep saying end of argument as if they are scared if a response. If it were the heart playing the part of the brain, I would also say it's a figure if speech buuuuuuttttt😂😂😂 Semen comes between the rib and the backbone- is that a figure of speech? The sun sets in a swamp - is that a figure if speech? A string ties up the anus - is that a figure of speech? Whoever orgasms first is who the child will look like - is that a figure of speech? Is having 4 wives also a figure of speech? - Muhammad had 11! Is there only being one Quran also a figure if speech? Because there are 31 variations 😮 Is Allah's words being unchangeable also a figure of speech because sheep ate, uthman burned😮 Were the debunked miracles also a figure if speech. Ooooh looks like the conversation has not yet ended😂😂😂😂 Look forward to your reply
Human conviction is the only thing that keeps religions alive. I can think of myself confidently as a hero, while bullying others. I can also be bullied by others, and think that I'm the one whose guilty. People are drawn to conviction, and at times can blindly believe lies because of that. That is why it is very important to be a person who understands others' vulnerabilities and have people who would do the same for you. If one's confidence comes from diminishing others, that's a faulty thing. A God which condemns people to eternal hellfire for disbelieving is obviously a tool created by humans for unification and division.
The classic exposition of judgement at death comes in the Book of Coming Forth by Day, in chapter/spell 30 and in chapter/spell 125, and the so-called weighing of the heart. To the Egyptians, the heart, or ib, rather than the brain, was the source of human wisdom and the centre of emotions and memory. Because of its apparent links with intellect, personality and memory, it was considered the most important of the internal organs. It could reveal the person's true character, even after death, so the belief went, and therefore the heart was left in the deceased's body during mummification. In the weighing of the heart rite, the heart of the deceased is weighed in the scale against the feather of the goddess Maat, who personifies order, truth, and what is right. Spell 30 was often inscribed on heart scarabs that were placed with the deceased. The spell appeals to the heart not to weigh down the balance or testify against the deceased to the keeper of the balance. Part of the spell gives instructions for making the heart scarab: ‘Make a scarab of nephrite adorned with gold and put within a man's breast, and perform for him the ceremony of opening the mouth, the scarab being anointed with myrrh.’.1 www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3960665/#:~:text=In%20Egyptian%20religion%2C%20the%20heart,weighing%20of%20the%20heart%20ceremony.🤣🤣🤣
Egyptians also believed the sun travelled across the sky every day and then sank into a dark abyss where it battled the monsters of darkness to re emerge again in the east to then repeat the journey - this idea is reproduced in the Koran and hadiths where it says "When he reached the setting place of the sun he FOUND it set in a muddy spring."
This video presentation is bogus. There is nothing wrong with the Qur'anic verses cited related to the heart. The ancient people understood this relationship between the heart and consciousness and reasoning. Obviously, there is a special relationship between the brain and heart that has yet to be fully discovered scientifically. However, stay tuned and brace yourself for future breakthroughs in deeper knowledge and understanding. It is interesting that Christians see no problem when the word "heart" is used in similar contexts in the Bible. To me, this is just another campaign of Christian desperation to establish some credibility by bashing Islam and Muslims.
1600 years ago, some beduin goat herders suddenly decided that they could write a book that explains everything ... Now imagine, in 2022 people being gullible enough to accept every word in it correct...
@a m The heart in the quran is not used as idiom ,its used as an organ which is responsible for comprehension, thinking ,rationalizing thats is easily seen in the verse Al Ahraf 79 as the verse clearly explains the function of multiple organs ie ears for hearing ,eyes for seing and heart for thinking and raationalizing,quran just plagiarizes Aristotle just like it plagiarizes Galen and many other ancient greek believes ....
Allah Says the Smartest Things: 1. “The sun sets in a muddy spring” (Surah 18:86) 2. “He followed a way until he reached the rising place of the sun” (Surah 18-89) 3. “Allah holds the sky so as it cannot fall on the Earth” (Surah 22:65) 4. “And after that, He spread the Earth” (Surah 79:30) 5. “He (Allah) made for you the Earth like a carpet spread out” (Surah 20:53) 6. “Semen is made between the backbone and the ribs” (Surah 86:5-7) 7. “Cow’s milk is made between the dung and the blood” (Surah 16:66) 8. “The sun runs on unto a resting place for him” (Surah 36:38) 9. “We made the sperm-drop into a clinging clot, and We made the clot into a lump, and We made the lump bones, and We covered the bones with flesh. (Surah 23:13-14) 10. “We have adorned the lowest heaven with lamps and made them [missiles] for stoning devils for whom We have also prepared the torment of a blazing fire.” (Surah 67:5) 11. Fun bonus: “O you who believe, do not enter the houses of the Prophet, unless you are permitted for a meal, not (so early as) to wait for its preparation. But when you are invited, go inside. Then, once you have had the meal, just disperse, and (do) not (sit for long) being keen for a chat. This (conduct of yours) hurts the Prophet, but he feels shy of (telling) you (about it), but Allah is not shy of the truth.” (Surah 33:53) Remember, Allah is claimed to be the “all-knowing” “all-powerful” “creator of the universe” and he is quoted verbatim, word-for-word, in Allah’s “clear book” the eternal, uncreated Quran which has existed in Heaven before the beginning of time and creation. But as you can see, all-knowing Allah says things no different from a 7th century Bedouin. As the all-knowing creator of the universe, you would expect Allah to state scientific truths (in perfect, indisputable detail, requiring no jihadi-bearded dawah boys to help interpret) like the Theory of Relativity, the Double Helix Structure of DNA, Quantum Mechanics, Particle Physics, etc. But no. (Fun fact: When you see the sun in the sky, take note that it is in a muddy spring for the time zones before you and under Allah's bum in other time zones. True story.) It's simple to prove Allah does not exist. We just need to prove Allah’s CLAIMS don’t exist. As the Quran is the “kalamullah” i.e. all-knowing Allah's verbatim word, the Quran must be 100% accurate. But it is not. The Quran makes many ignorant 7th-century statements. And since Allah’s claims don’t exist, Allah doesn’t exist. Stay away from Islam. Nothing good comes out of Islam.
The problem with many people they don't understand the Arabic word "أرض" "Earth" in English and "Erde" in German, and also unfortunately many Muslims scholars thinks word "أرض" or earth means the planet earth but it literally means the matter from which planets are made so in short I would say its not easy to understand this book if you are trying to translate using translator. Be patient do your research and you will find mind blowing things, so please dont fall into the trap of the so called religious scholars and youtubers always do your own research. All these books like Bibel, Torah and Quran etc are not easy to understand. good luck.
Nah your Allah just can't write clearly, just like his math ain't mathing. Anyway, the Quran is not Arabic. It's Aramaic written in Arabic letters. What an embarrassment.@@haroonafridi1802
FYI, scientific knowledge is not complete yet, then y does a heartbreak and emotional trauma, physically hurts in the chest n heart.... There is an amazing connection in heart n brain, plus new research that shows heart has feelings n memory, so i hope u learn n see things n not turn your heart blind
Deity: "Ok, here's my holy book and...have another book. Hang on to that one for later." Backwater Prophet: "What's this, O Divine One?" Deity: "Harvard University Calculus texbook." BP: "....those four words mean nothing to me." Deity: "Trust me on this one - make sure you just stick some of that in between the misogyny and slavery stuff. It'll blow their minds in a few centuries." That, boys and girls, is how an omnipotent deity COULD have shown they have knowledge of the future.
Does the heart have a mind? Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.14 Nov 2019
So have they not traveled through the earth and have hearts by which to reason and ears by which to hear? For indeed, it is not eyes that are blinded but blinded are the hearts which are within the breasts. [Quran, 22:46]
We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things? Q41:53
But what is the evidence that the intrinsic cardiac nervous system controls non-cardiac mental activity? Without such evidence, it cannot be said that the heart has a mind any more than other vital organs have a mind.
@@mosadeqmauthoor2587 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Sorry you’re wrong. The Heart Math Institute has found that everything begins in the heart. The heart's brain is an intricate network of several types of neurons, neurotransmitters, proteins and support cells similar to those found in the brain proper. Its elaborate circuitry enables it to act independently of the cranial brain - to learn, remember, and even feel and sense. Look up Joe Dispenza, watch how people heal themselves. Everything starts from the heart, even thought. The heart is the seed from which the body grows.
Most of us have been taught in school that the brain and nervous system controls every organ in the body including the heart. With that said, you’re probably thinking that we only use the brain in every situation, even with dealing with feelings. However, that’s not the case! Feelings have so much to do with the heart, as they do with the brain. It’s actually a two-way relationship. Our emotions change the signals the brain sends to the heart and the heart responds to the brain in complex ways. Both actually depend and influence each other’s function, very much like how you harmonize with someone when doing a duet. In fact, recent research from HeartMath has shown that the heart communicates to the brain in different ways
Research in the relatively new discipline of neurocardiology has confirmed that the heart acts as a sophisticated information encoding and processing center that enables it to learn, remember, and make functional decisions independently of the cerebral cortex. Additionally, numerous studies have demonstrated that cardiac signals to the brain affect autonomic regulatory centers and higher brain centers involved in cognition and mood regulation.
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why. Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief. "No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16) This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?" The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason. The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything." These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs. Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain. “The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
@nothing-we6bh When i meet one human with such an artificial heart and examine him , then i will give you the answer. If you find one, then we can prove or disprove the functions of the heart.
Adam, it is very easy to debunk your accusation about the Quran having a scientific error regarding the "heart". It is not the Quran that has an error but your logic. Let me explain. Your most fundamental error about this accusation is how you try to debunk the Quran using the translation, which makes me wonder why you keep doing this. You speak Arabic and yet you rely on the translation to debunk the Quran smh. When you want to talk about the heart in the Quran, you cannot only talk about "Qalb" (which you do in this video) but you also have to mention "Fuaad" and "Aql". When the Quran talks about the heart using the word "Fuaad", it talks about the heart as the place of emotions with no logic. Many verses indicate this, but the one indicates the most is QS.16:7. That verse talks about how we are from our mother's womb and Allah gives us sight, hearing, and Fuaad (the heart as the place of emotions). Babies do not yet have logic and reason. They are 100% emotional. So this is Fuaad. Emotions with no logic involved. On the other hand, "Aql" is logic. Reason. The ability to think, to comprehend, to understand something. This is our brain. I don't need to give you any reference, you can search it in the Quran. Almost every verse that uses the word "Aql" talks about how God asks us to understand things. So this is Aql. And in between "Fuaad" and "Aql" we have "Qalb". Qalb is the combination of "Fuaad" (emotion) and "Aql" (logical reasoning, intellect, etc). "Qalb" is not merely the heart. It has much deeper meaning than a mere heart. There are hundreds of verses using the word "Qalb", check them all. They mostly talk about how we need to use intellect (Aql) as well as emotions (Fuaad) to think and understand something. So, when you are questioning about how QS. 22:46 states the "Qalb" is responsible for reasoning, the verse actually makes 100% perfect sense. You have to use the combination of "Aql" and "Fuaad" to understand something. For example, if you are in the state of hunger your emotion might be angry or sad that you might no longer be able to think normally. You just want to eat, that's the first thing you want at the moment. And after your emotion is calm then you can think normally. I hope you understand my explanation. You will of course understand if you use your Qalb. Otherwise, you will not if you only use Fuaad (emotions) and let it block your Aql (intellect). So if you want to debunk Islam and the Quran, use your Qalb truthfully. You might find the truth instead.
The Arabic word 'Qalb' has two meanings: 1 intelligence and 2 heart as in English there are words with two or more meanings e.g. Fair If the Quran is not from God, how could the description of human embryo be mentioned in 7th century ??? Furthermore, mention of two seas that do not meet and mention of lowest point on Earth??? And remember Prophet Muhammad was illiterate; couldn't read and write
You need to understand your creator and quran with your heart not just your mind to understand and accept what Allah SWT is saying to you. May Allah SWT give you the light of correct knowledge. Ameen.
@Toxic Tricks All cognitive functions including processing thoughts and emotions happen only in the brain. It's true that there are a few nerons in the heart but they are incapable of processing thoughts and emotions like the brain does. The neurons communicate with the brain and vice-versa but it's all about regulating the electrical and mechanical activities of the heart such as the rate and rhythm of heart beat as well as the contractility of the heart muscles. Now if the Qura'an was speaking about this set of nerons in the heart popularly dubbed as "heart-brain" as many muslim apologists claim, then the god must have been very specific. The god should have specifically mentioned what this "heart-brain" does and how it takes precedence over the brain in cognitive function(the "heart-brain" has absolutely NOTHING to do with the cognitive functions of the brain). Instead the quran clearly follows the cardiocentric hypothesis as it claims that humans 'reason with heart'. All cognitive, behavioural and emotional functions take place only in the brain. Unfortunately, the popular media as well as the muslim apologists have been very successful in convincing the poor deluded believers that the so called "heart brain" is the organ of cognition and not the brain. If heart had anything to do with cognition then a person undergoing a heart transplant should develop a whole new personality post-operation. Also there are people with an artificial heart which doesn't have this intrinsic cardiac neurons, yet they don't have any problem with cognition, emotion, sensory function, motor function etc.
@toxictricks1666 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, another pseudoscience buzz word is 'quantum'. They just throw in the word 'quantum' with nonsensical ideas thinking it will add credibility. Neither the proponents of such ideas nor the people who cite such ideas as evidence for their pre-scientific religious or political agendas know what is meant by pseudoscience buzz words like 'quantum' or 'holistic'. Treatment should be target specific and that's what evidence based medicine is aiming for by introducing 'target specific immunotherapy' for cancers and many rheumatological diseases. There is no need to treat healthy organs or the whole body for a disease of a specific pathophysiology unless it affects or spreads to other areas of the body. 'Holistic' treatment only harms the person. Even when evidences show the harmful effects or the inefficacy of these so called 'holistic' treatments, quacks and people alike ignore it. Similarly, Heartmath institute says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Scientifically WRONG! This alone will shut everything down : allah’s scientific miracle MISTAKE : allah thinks milk is made in a cow's Belly (stomach) Q16:66 - And there is certainly a lesson for you in cattle: We give you to drink of what is in their bellies, from between digested food and blood: pure milk, pleasant to drink. jMILK IS 100% NOT MADE IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF THE COW, NOR IS MILK IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF A COW.. allah is 100% FALSE, quran is 100% FALSE, mahamed is 100% FALSE
Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system. In addition, the heart communicates with the brain in many methods: neurologically, biochemically, biophysically, and energetically. The vagus nerve, which is 80% afferent, carries information from the heart and other internal organs to the brain. Signals from the "heart brain" redirect to the medulla, hypothalamus, thalamus, and amygdala and the cerebral cortex. Thus, the heart sends more signals to the brain than vice versa. Such a misleading video this is.
Qalb" is the Arabic word for "heart". In Islamic philosophy, the "qalb" is the center of the human personality. The literal meaning of "qalb" is "to turn". The root meaning suggests that the heart is always in a state of motion and transformation. The "qalb" is the home for all of our emotions, rationale, and obedience or disobedience to Allah. The "qalb" is the basis of activities, intentions, meaning, and deep understanding of the world around us.
C " Certainly in this is a sure reminder for those whoever has a heart". 50: 37. THE CURE FOR THIS ILLNESS IS NOT TO BE HAD BY ANY HEART SPECIALIST. Now u know the truth.
The Thinking Human Heart Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain. “The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Ancient peoples described the heart as the location of the will. We see the same understanding in the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures. The only difference I see is that Christians and Jews (mostly) do not insist that the language is scientifically true.
You are verry ignorant, you don’t know science and you don’t know the Quran , first of all Allah knows best wat we do witch our heart and brain. Modern science has discovered we lie with our brain espaisly Science “Regions in the frontal and parietal cortex showed higher activation when participants lied compared with when they were telling the truth, regardless of whether they were asked about their past experiences or opinions.” www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5390719/#:~:text=Regions%20in%20the%20frontal%20and,their%20past%20experiences%20or%20opinions. Quran : What if that ˹man˺ persists in denial and turns away? Does he not know that Allah sees ˹all˺? ut no! If he does not desist, We will certainly drag him by the forelock- a lying, sinful forelock So let him call his associates. We will call the wardens of Hell. What considering the fact of that we als feel and think with our heart is not an ancient myth anyomore , you don’t catch up with sciene . Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system. Feelings have so much to do with the heart, as they do with the brain. It's actually a two-way relationship. Our emotions change the signals the brain sends to the heart and the heart responds to the brain in complex ways. norwestchiro.co.nz/heart-and-brain-connection#:~:text=Feelings%20have%20so%20much%20to,the%20brain%20in%20complex%20ways..
Studies indicate that heart transplant recipients may exhibit preferences, emotions, and memories resembling those of the donors, suggesting a form of memory storage within the transplanted organ. Explain this Mr Pretentious
It's important to note that these claims are largely anecdotal and lack robust scientific validation. The mainstream medical and scientific community generally views these reports with skepticism, attributing such changes to psychological factors, medication effects, or the profound experience of undergoing a heart transplant rather than actual memory transfer through transplanted cells.
The heart being a smart organ reraining nervous impacts still doesn't mean it has any role in cognitive functions as the Quran claims. The proof is that some people can live without a heart at all (on an artificial pump) and they can still think and function cognitively very well. The Quran still got it wrong!
Recent work in the relatively new field of neurocardiology has firmly established that the heart is a sensory organ and an information encoding and processing center, with an extensive intrinsic nervous system that’s sufficiently sophisticated to qualify as a heart brain. Its circuitry enables it to learn, remember, and make functional decisions independent of the cranial brain. To everyone’s surprise, the findings have demonstrated that the heart’s intrinsic nervous system is a complex, self-organized system; its neuroplasticity, or ability to reorganize itself by forming new neural connections over both the short and long term, has been well demonstrated. The Heart-Brain System Pathway There are several areas of the brain that are in direct communication with the heart. ` The cortex: the thinking brain `The thalamus: which synchronizes the cortical activity `The amygdala: which houses emotional memory `The medulla: which regulates the ANS and blood pressure
They communicate via the HPA axis as blood pressure and stress and pulse increase. That is all what the crosstalk is about. Nothing else. Think better about your sources next time.
Being all-knowing and expecting people to consider the Koran 1400 years later, one might expect Allah to be a bit more considered in his choice of expression and get his facts right. Really the discussion is only over if you are scared of its implications.
Actually people at that time knew that the brain was the source of thoughts. this is actually a miracle of the Quran, not a mistake.. Modern day scientists proved that the heart has a consistent influence on brain thoughts. Here is why: 1 Heart has thinking and calculating nerves, it is not me who says it, its Dr J. Andrew Armour of the Montreal University. After an extensive research with a staff of neurocardiologists, He founded that heart has a brain of its own. His work made in 1991 revealed that the heart has a complex intrinsic nervous system that is sufficiently sophisticated to qualify as a "little brain" in its own right. 2 It Participates in leading and guiding individuals based on certain calculations, emotions and feelings. 3 Relays information back to the brain and has a 2-way communication system with the brain that enables it to take part of the thinking, processing, and decision-making. 4 Can force the brain to obey its commands. 5 Has memory and data retrieval (remembering) capability. The heart contains 40 000 neurons... called sensory neurites, which detect circulating hormones and neurochemicals and sense heart rate and pressure information. Hormonal, chemical, rate and pressure information is translated into neurological impulses by the heart’s nervous system and sent from the heart to the brain through several afferent (flowing to the brain) pathways. It is also through these nerve pathways that pain signals and other feeling sensations are sent to the brain.
This a major problem, if there was a verse in the quran that sais " 1+1=3" then the scholars nowadays would say "No, the actual meaning of the verse is blablabla and thats why it means 2 insha alla".
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
We now have scientific evidence that the heart sends us emotional and intuitive signals to help us manage our lives. It is an intuitive and extremely rapid source of wisdom and clear perception, an intelligence that encompasses and stimulates mental and emotional intelligence. We call it “the intelligence of the heart”. Heart Intelligence is the intelligent flow of awareness and intuition we experience when the mind and emotions come into a state of balance and coherence through a self-initiating process. This form of intelligence, experienced as direct and intuitive wisdom, manifests in thoughts and emotions that are beneficial to ourselves and others.
Then please answer this, how come people living with an artificial heart pump don’t lack any intuition or intelligence?? We now also have evidence that when the heart of totally replaced, no loss of memory, cognitive skills or intelligence is lost! - but these are all lost or impacted by the brain damage!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish hhhhh....Ah ok I understood your opinion...we are talking about spirituality. The soul is a term that designates everything that makes up the psyche of the individual: these are his states of consciousness, his intelligence, his reason, his intuition, but also his feelings, his emotions, his passions and his instincts. ""the heart""
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Prof. Dr. Ibrahim B Syed Scientists have discovered that the heart thinks, learns wisdom, and contains neurological canters that save data. The heart contains 40,000 nerve cells that form a “real brain”!! Qur’an revealed this fact more than 1400 years ago. In Surah Hajj (Pilgrimage) 22: 46, Allah says: The English translation is: Do they not travel through the land, so that their hearts (can think/can reason/can learn wisdom/can understand or comprehend) and their ears may thus learn to hear? Truly it is not their eyes that are blind, but their Hearts which are in their breasts. In many places in the Quran, one comes across “A-Falaa T’a’aqiloon”. or “Don’t you understand?” In this Ayah we need to focus on the words “Qulbun Ya’aqiloon”. The vast majority of the Muslim scholars have translated it as “Hearts understand”. Although Ya’aqiloon has several meanings: that is the Heart can Think, Heart can Reason, Heart can learn wisdom, Heart can understand or comprehend, the Muslims scholars until today translated it as Hearts understand. The Heart: Not Just Brawn but Brains, Too About 100,000 times a day the heart repeats this monotonous task of survival. But what many think is a mindless pump turns out to have a mind of its own. According to the Institute of HeartMath-a nonprofit research and education organization dedicated to helping people live healthier, happier lives-there are networks of nerve cells (neurons) around the heart that function in much the same way as parts of the brain. Back in the 1960s, research conducted by John and Beatrice Lacey-pioneers in the field of psychophysiology-showed that the heart has its own reasoning that is not determined by directives from the brain. Subsequent investigations revealed an actual pathway and mechanism allowing the heart to send messages that inhibit or facilitate electrical activity in the brain. The new field of neurocardiology evolving from this research led to the development of the concept of the “heart brain” in 1991. The “heart brain” is equipped with some 40,000 neurons(Brain Cells). These neurons can deliver pain signals and other sensations to the autonomic parts of the brain (which are largely unconscious), as well as messages to brain centers involved in conscious thought and emotion. Contact with the “executive” part of the brain can influence perception, decision making, and emotional responses. (www.rewireme.com/explorations/your-heart-and-stomach-may-be-smarter-than-you-think/)
@toxictricks1666 the quran will never be wrong.... All the accuracies mean if science has not agreed with one particular thing, then that is the limitations of science and not the word of God......there are so many scientific verses which would not have been understood back then and now are understood with technology..... Just like this heart verse, it will be understood clearly soon. I posted a short finding. Prof. Dr. Ibrahim B Syed Scientists have discovered that the heart thinks, learns wisdom, and contains neurological canters that save data. The heart contains 40,000 nerve cells that form a “real brain”!! Qur’an revealed this fact more than 1400 years ago. In Surah Hajj (Pilgrimage) 22: 46, Allah says: The English translation is: Do they not travel through the land, so that their hearts (can think/can reason/can learn wisdom/can understand or comprehend) and their ears may thus learn to hear? Truly it is not their eyes that are blind, but their Hearts which are in their breasts. In many places in the Quran, one comes across “A-Falaa T’a’aqiloon”. or “Don’t you understand?” In this Ayah we need to focus on the words “Qulbun Ya’aqiloon”. The vast majority of the Muslim scholars have translated it as “Hearts understand”. Although Ya’aqiloon has several meanings: that is the Heart can Think, Heart can Reason, Heart can learn wisdom, Heart can understand or comprehend, the Muslims scholars until today translated it as Hearts understand. The Heart: Not Just Brawn but Brains, Too About 100,000 times a day the heart repeats this monotonous task of survival. But what many think is a mindless pump turns out to have a mind of its own. According to the Institute of HeartMath-a nonprofit research and education organization dedicated to helping people live healthier, happier lives-there are networks of nerve cells (neurons) around the heart that function in much the same way as parts of the brain. Back in the 1960s, research conducted by John and Beatrice Lacey-pioneers in the field of psychophysiology-showed that the heart has its own reasoning that is not determined by directives from the brain. Subsequent investigations revealed an actual pathway and mechanism allowing the heart to send messages that inhibit or facilitate electrical activity in the brain. The new field of neurocardiology evolving from this research led to the development of the concept of the “heart brain” in 1991. The “heart brain” is equipped with some 40,000 neurons(Brain Cells). These neurons can deliver pain signals and other sensations to the autonomic parts of the brain (which are largely unconscious), as well as messages to brain centers involved in conscious thought and emotion. Contact with the “executive” part of the brain can influence perception, decision making, and emotional responses. (www.rewireme.com/explorations/your-heart-and-stomach-may-be-smarter-than-you-think/)
I read the interpretation of Al Qurtubi about the first verse.. He stated: "It was said that the thought happens in the brain, as told by Abu Hanifa, and I (Al Qurtubi) do not agree with him!!
Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.14 Nov 2019
Until recently, modern science perceived the heart as merely a pump to regulate the flow of blood throughout our bodies. But across numerous cultures, the heart has historically been thought to have a much greater function that corresponds with our thoughts, emotions, and spirit. When we speak or share feelings from a place of deep meaning or passion, we say we’re speaking from the heart or we’re trying to convey something that is heartfelt. This is no longer just an archaic maxim, but instead, one with factual backing. And science is now realizing that the heart and brain have more of a corollary, interactive relationship than previously thought … a relationship that has residual consequences on our bodies, and possibly even humanity as a whole.
@@mosadeqmauthoor2587 Yeah but the brain is still the organ that does most mental work and the heart does way less. The heart is involved in psychology a bit because for example if you get into a really dangerous and scary situation, then your brain releases a lot of adrenaline and sends signals to your heart to make your heart beat faster so that blood flows faster, so the adrenaline gets sent around the body quicker in the blood, but the brain still does most of the mental work and the cardiocentric hypothesis is plain wrong. I would also argue that "souls" are a misunderstanding of what human consciousnesses are, because consciousnesses are in brains but back when books like the bible and quran were written the writers who believed the cardiocentric hypothesis misunderstanding wrote stuff like that souls are in the hearts of people, and souls are said to be strongly associated with emotions and thinking and so on, but there is no evidence of souls existing and instead consciousnesses really do exist in the brains of people and how they work through electricity and brain chemicals in the brain has been studied a lot even though its not entirely understood yet.
It takes a Muslim mind to discover the scientific miracles in the Quran. The worst thing you can do to any child is to tell the child to memorize a book written by God-Any book! It's impedes the child's critical thinking when reading that book. Thankfully, the internet and people like you, are allowing Muslims to critically reexamine contradictions of this book.
Armour in 1991 discovered that the heart has it's own ' little brain' or intrinsic cardiac nervous system. This ' heart brain' is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are like neurons in the brain. Meaning that the heart has it own nervous system.
@@AdamElmasriEnglish bro having arabic name does not make you scholar in arabic stop being an idiot Arabic is the most eloquent language and you know in Quran word Fouwad is also used it ALLAH SWT was describing different feelings of Human in QUran , you are my friend a liar and insecure Christian who did not read Quran properly , every language used this term listen to your heart and not mind , if we use your logic then every language will be in a problem .. you need serious education dude
Why can’t your logic define human consciousness 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂get the answer to above you will get answer of everything 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Allah hu Akbar ❤
i was thinking that when any language uses the word heart for a figure of speech it is doing so to artistically capture the emotion of the reader to speak to their feelings and is not trying to be stating a fact. I think the bible even uses the same language to but only to describe a deeper meaning other than intellect because the heart is what keeps us alive while the brain could be a vegetable while the heart is what's keeping the soul within the body. just my thought though
If we normalized 2+2=12 would it make sense for God to say 2+2=12 and not 2+2=4? In other words, why not correct mistakes instead of repeating the norm.
"heart" is more correct than "brain", because "heart" commonly/usually refers to brain + desire/intention, while "brain" refers to brain only/pure logic/clear mind, & clear mind can't be blind
Desire, intention, emotions, mind, consciousness, cognition etc are not abstract entities that exist independent of brain, these are all 'PRODUCTS OF THE BRAIN' themselves. Heart is only a pump. The "heart-brain" people talk about has nothing to do with cognition, emotion or behavior or any of the faculties of the the brain. The cardiac intrinsic neurons got dubbed "the little-brain of heart" because they regualte cardiac cycle, that's the only job they do. Even the person who coined "the little -brain of heart", Dr Armour NEVER ever claimed any of the things that muslims and pseudoscientists like Dr Rollin Mccraty claim he did. Even Dr Mccraty admitted that the heart CANNOT think or learn like the brain but says heart knows something "outside time and space". What a joke!!! A load of pseudoscience jargon. Does he have any evidence for this realm outside "time and space"? Maybe we need to borrow infinity stones from Marvel movies to know!!!!
Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.
That doesn't mean that YOU can think and comprehend with your heart (as the Quran claims). Those recent findings only mean that the Heart is an intelligent organ. But you cannot think and understand using your heart!
By your point, the gastrointestinal system also has its own nervous system, the Enteric Nervous System, it doesn't mean it can store memories and consciousness like a brain do. How to explain when a person is declared brain dead, but has a beating heart. Can that person still be conscious by relying on his heart after the brain cease its function?
There is zero thoughts occurring in the heart. The gut also has its own neuromotor loops, but a neuromotor loop is not a thought, just as hitting the reflexes in your knee doesn't test your thoughts.
@@toomanymarys7355 As I wrote before: You can verify where he thoughts coming from in deep meditation (self-observation). Scientists know nothing about this.
Adam Elmasri is not a scientist or in the medical field to tell you... The creator knows best. The heart does have a "little brain". The heart does not contain brain cells. It contains neurons that comprise its own intrinsic system for regulating cardiac function. Further, neurons alone do not equal mind or consciousness. It takes the specialized organization of neurons in the brain to produce cognitive processes that we experience as the mind. A complex network of neurons can function like a computer chip. This is all a complex and fascinating system... the creator tells you more than 1400 years ago and now scientists are studying about them.
Are you a scientist or a doctor? Why criticize Adam for being in the same position? Heart: The heart does not actually feel emotion, reason, or learn. It has a complex nervous system that responds to various stimuli. The Qur'an reflects the common belief of the sixth century, when people thought the heart was the organ responsible for the mind and emotions.
People awaiting heart surgery can live without a heart (completely taken out) and replaced by an artificial pump. Now tell me again about how the heart think and memorise!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish Again, your flaw in understanding. The heart is considered the source of emotions, desire, and wisdom. Quran 22:46 So have they not traveled through the earth and have hearts by which to reason and ears by which to hear? Read pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31728781/ Without a body and a beating heart, a stomach that can rumble and lungs that fill, the brain would be adrift. We navigate the world by seeing, hearing and touching too. We make choices to stay alive. Perhaps the real magic of consciousness comes from the combinations - of heart and brain, of the outside world and inside world, as mysterious as it may yet be.
Allah - there is no deity except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer of [all] existence. Neither drowsiness overtakes Him nor sleep. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. Who is it that can intercede with Him except by His permission? He knows what is [presently] before them and what will be after them, and they encompass not a thing of His knowledge except for what He wills. His Kursi extends over the heavens and the earth, and their preservation tires Him not. And He is the Most High, the Most Great. Holly quran 2:255
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
Mohamed god is satan 1. [Umdah al-Ahkam: Vol. 3, Hadith no. 460] “Narrated by Anas Ibn Malik “I heard from the Apostle of Allah (Peace and blessing be upon him) that he said “Allah was Satan in the form of an angel that revealed to me the verses and his book the Quran and I’ am his prophet رواه أنس ابن مالك “سمعت من رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم أنه” كان الله شيطان في شكل ملاك كشف لي الآيات وكتابه القرآن وأنا نبي
@Zain_Pakfreethinker Did you remember the time back in childhood when you first went to school and your teach said to you: open the book and read words after me. Did he/she not know that you know nothing and can't read? in the case of revelation upon Muhammad, God is telling him oh illiterate the moment had come you need to start reading and teaching your nation what I/God will teach you. Be ready to read and then teach what is going to reveal oh prophet Muhammad.
It’s not my own Tafsir… it is 5000 years of human history that you’re ignoring so you can save the Quran from a fatal error! And error that we believed in for 5000 years and the Quran simply repeated it! Now you’re trying to claim that the Quran has a different Tafsir 😉😅
@@AdamElmasriEnglish 30 Days Ramadan Dry Fasting: Indeed persistent and consistent good habits help us achieve a positive Muslim mindset. Most importantly, on waking up, don't develop the bad habit of picking up your mobile. Connect and praise your Creator as Muhammad p.b.u.hù. taught us: Alhamdulillah illazi ahyaana barda ma amaatana wa ilaihin nushuur/ The praise belongs to Allah who restored our lives after our death (sleep) and to Him we'll be gathered (for accountability). Habits build you or destroy you. So start inculcate good habits gradually which will make you eventually replace the bad habits with good enhancing habits. Developing good healthy habits and moral habits make you a more productive, positive and confident human being. We have a tremendous advantage over the non-Muslims in that we know the answers for these 3 recurring questions within our souls: * Where we come from? * What is the purpose of our existence here on earth? * Where are we going after We die? The Merciful has given us, Muslims, the month of Ramadan which is great healing to us, both spiritually and physically. With the non-Muslims so amazed how we can abstain from food and drink for so long hours is truly a blessing to be thankful for. This is the Miracle of Ramadan to us Muslims. If the non-Muslims could see how Ramadan benefit us tremendously, they would sure attempt to deprive us of it by any means. Good habits are our building Blocks!
@@mosadeqmauthoor2587 Every religion practises fasting and only muslims practise dry fasting. Well dry fasting isn't that good for health. Funny part is that guillible abduls think only them fast. By any chance, meditation is a better practice than fasting and dry fasting is just wasting working hours
So have they not traveled through the earth and have hearts by which to reason and ears by which to hear? For indeed, it is not eyes that are blinded, but blinded are the hearts which are within the breasts. [Quran, 22: 46]
So when u c ur crush why ur heart beats fast ? If brain response all emotions then why ur brain doesn't beats like heart..brain and heart works together..here Allah seal the heart so that they will not get the love of Allah when they go in extreme...
The book of death: weighing your heart Francesco Carellicorresponding author The classic exposition of judgement at death comes in the Book of Coming Forth by Day, in chapter/spell 30 and in chapter/spell 125, and the so-called weighing of the heart. To the Egyptians, the heart, or ib, rather than the brain, was the source of human wisdom and the centre of emotions and memory. Because of its apparent links with intellect, personality and memory, it was considered the most important of the internal organs. It could reveal the person's true character, even after death, so the belief went, and therefore the heart was left in the deceased's body during mummification. In the weighing of the heart rite, the heart of the deceased is weighed in the scale against the feather of the goddess Maat, who personifies order, truth, and what is right. Spell 30 was often inscribed on heart scarabs that were placed with the deceased. The spell appeals to the heart not to weigh down the balance or testify against the deceased to the keeper of the balance. Part of the spell gives instructions for making the heart scarab: ‘Make a scarab of nephrite adorned with gold and put within a man's breast, and perform for him the ceremony of opening the mouth, the scarab being anointed with myrrh.’.1 🤣🤣🤣🤣www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3960665/#:~:text=In%20Egyptian%20religion%2C%20the%20heart,weighing%20of%20the%20heart%20ceremony.
If a viscous dog runs towards you your heart will also beat fast. If a Dr examines you & tells you that you have a deadly disease, your heart will alao beat fast. Many things can make your heart beat fast but the reality is we dont do any thinking from our hearts, all our thinking & emotions gets processed by the brain. The quran is a book of fairytales.
I know the heart physically hurts when the love of your life leaves you. You physically feel a nice vibration sensations when you are excited. Physically feel it pounding when you are scared. Explain how these emotions ar connected to the heart?
In the same way, your gut crumbles when you’re stressed, or you could feel “butterflies” in your stomach when excited… that doesn’t mean you think with your gut or stomach!!! The heart is the same!.. the heart has nothing to do with cognitive functions!
As a muslim, i dont mind this sort of video. Although i strongly disagree, im glad you are overall respectful, this way we can get to the crux of the issue and not cause hatred. Your are welcome to make your points and we have our scholars/apologists who will counter them. If more people were respectful like you, us muslims will be more willing to tackle the points. Anyway peace, friend
So you admit that you muslims got a lots of points to tackle them. But you already stated that your scholars will counter this mans massage from your own sources. Good sign you are on this channel ,it means you are not really satisfy with your scholars,you searching for the Truth.May God open your eyes and your mind to this Truth
brother this world is based on struggle he Told us that also so struggle and doo good deeds and yeah as you mention human recently discover its brain not heart who things have feelings and much more so at that time nobody new and Allah Wasnt teaching us scince he is guiding us so he used that langage to make those people of that time understand nowing brain does the processing humans are still using heart instead of brains so please ambrace the meaning of quran other wise it will be too late time isn't stopping for nobody and yes Allah didnt wanted to teach us scince and biology we can learn it our selfs and we are doing it and he know this again m telling please understand the meaning behind dont let it to be too late for you. and if please update your research about heart too might help you rethink
Then you contradict a lot of Muslims claims over the Quranic scientific miracles then because of how the Quran got something before modern science did.
You can't be serious after the quran has been exposed so fully and blatantly to be a fraud from satan . It is you that needs to turn to CHRIST JESUS in sincere humility and ask HIM to save you and give you a new heart and mind full of joy . You've betrayed CHRIST but HE will forgive you if you'll just humble yourself and present yourself before HIS mercy . It's too late for mohamaax the child raper my friend but it's not too late for you . YET !
@@luigianchondo7241 Science is constantly being updated, it should be taken with a grain of salt especially when we, ourselves, are not doing the research. One of the qualities of Islam is that it is never changed. It wouldn't be surprising if we discover new things about the heart later down the line that we never knew about.
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
تفهم العربية جيدا و تفهم التعبيرات المجازية جيدا و تفهم معنى تلك الآيات لكنك تطبق ما تقوله تلك الآيات فالعين ترى لكن القلب أعمى و مثلك بالضبط ما قال عنهم الله و تركناهم في ظلمات لا يبصرون و لم يقل لا يرون و أنت تعرف الفرق و شكرا
Nawjubillah.. Allah never can do any mistake. And the quarn is way way more better than science...I love allah and Quarn and Muhammad peace be upon him.❤❤❤
@@webdev643 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
@@webdev643 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go... New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from. Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, another pseudoscience buzz word is 'quantum'. They just throw in the word 'quantum' with nonsensical ideas thinking it will add credibility. Neither the proponents of such ideas nor the people who cite such ideas as evidence for their pre-scientific religious or political agendas know what is meant by pseudoscience buzz words like 'quantum' or 'holistic'. Treatment should be target specific and that's what evidence based medicine is aiming for by introducing 'target specific immunotherapy' for cancers and many rheumatological diseases. There is no need to treat healthy organs or the whole body for a disease of a specific pathophysiology unless it affects or spreads to other areas of the body. 'Holistic' treatment only harms the person. Even when evidences show the harmful effects or the inefficacy of these so called 'holistic' treatments, quacks and people alike ignore it. Similarly, Heartmath institute says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim. Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific. Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition. I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
They will say it's just a metaphor, but when you read the hadith, it is actually hard to say that it's not literally the heart: "I was brought a vessel of gold containing Zamzam water, so my chest was split, to here.’” - Qatadah said: “I said to Anas: ‘What does that mean?’ He said: ‘To the lowest part of his stomach.’” - He said: “So my heart was removed, and washed with Zamzam water, then returned to its placed. Then I was filled with Faith and wisdom." (Grade: Sahih Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3346)
Sahih muslim or bukhari??
@@thisisron7994 none lmao, it is from tirmidhi
ARE YOU A MUSLIM?
@@okko7988 From the very first line of his comment you should know that he isn't. Don't you?
@toxictricks1666
Absolute nonsense and misinformation. Do you at least have reliable sources ?
Allah is just as smart as his creator, Muhammad.
Nah
Indeed 👍
@@raulwolthersryff yah
I like that
I agree with that.
If the heart had anything to do with cognition, memory, learned skills or knowledge then a person undergoing a heart transplant should develop a whole new personality post-operation. Also, post-operation the person wouldn't recognise his family or friends or anything that happened in his life because his memory would be lost. Also, he shouldn't have any problem recognising the donor's family. He would love the donor's wife and children as his own. Suppose a surgeon's heart was transplanted into a pilot then the pilot wouldn't be able to fly planes anymore but he could easily walk into an operation theatre and do the surgery because the medical knowledge and the surgical skills would all be in the heart the pilot received from the surgeon. Similarly, the person wouldn't be able to speak his mother tongue if the mother tongue of the donor was different. If the donor was a Christian and the recipient was a Muslim then post-transplant the recipient would become a Christian because faith, rituals and religious practices would all be in the heart.
Now if you think all these sound like a funny story then tell this to those who think the heart is involved in cognition, emotion and learning. Also there are people living with artificial heart that lacks any intrinsic cardiac neurons and they don't have any change in their cognition, personality, emotions, memory, knowledge, beliefs etc. This is because ONLY the brain is the centre of these faculties.
Very good but hilarious solution to "heart problems".
While the heart has its own “operating system” there is also a communication channel between the brain & the heart. There is growing collaboration between cardiologists & neurologists and subsequent research could prove that a backup of the heart’s OS in a portion of the brain is transferred to the transplanted heart. New discoveries, Alhamdulillah, only continue to
confirm what was revealed 1400 years ago.
@@sajidaziz7742
Stan Larkin, lived for two years without a hearth, just a machin pomping his blood
there is also a communication channel between the brain and the gut ( this is why we call the gut the second brain )
People back then thought that the consciousness eregateted from the hearth, which false and sadly muhamed copied dumbly that in the Quran.
@@sajidaziz7742 a very weak answer. and the fact that each time a muslim is asked about it, they give different answers, proves how much of a mistake it is. coupled with where cows milk comes from between excretion and blood (Quran 16:66), the sun setting somewhere on Earth in a muddy spring surrounded by people (Quran 18:86), the planet being compared to a carpet rather than a sphere ( Quran 20:53) and that a man's seed comes from between the spine (backbone) and the ribs (Quran 86:5-7)... proves the Quran, or rather who made it, had no clue what they were talking about. tried to appear scientifically savvy and spouting the same crap ppl of that time believed about the world does not make the Quran any more divine than a child's bedtime-story book.
@@ragael1024 heart has its own memory... As said above after heart transplant person should act deffrently .... There r such cases ... That dosent mean all the memory and reasoning r done by heart .
When someone has a heart transplant, they remember everything, but if they have a brain trauma they may or may not forget everything depending on the severity of the trauma.
Also in the story of الاسراء و المعراج, I remember before Muhammed went to heaven the angel took his heart out and cleaned it from 'desires' or whatever.
Truuuuuuue
After cleaning the heart Mo the prophet came down onto the earth conducted more caravan robberies raids rapes, slave trade, took concubines killed men and children took their women and girls ...all with a divinely clean soul. Alham dulila....
@Orthodoxprince4everhe we to heaven alive.
@Orthodoxprince4ever al isra wal miraj. You can read up on it.
@@shwenxthis scenario is wishful thinking. If he enters heaven at that time how come he's dead now and not in heaven?😅
[Qur’an 17:36] "You shall not accept any information, unless you verify it for yourself. I have given you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brain, and you are responsible for using them." It seems like it was well known that the brain is used for reasoning. I think "hearts" were used figuratively in those verses.
Cepruttt
I looked at 6 translations, none say brain.
Should you trust your heart or mind?
Listening to your head may lead to more tangible success, but not following your heart increases your risk of regret, so if you want to lead a more satisfying life, follow your heart.30 Nov 2019
The heart is a blood pumping organ, not more not less.
What you feel in your heart is brain generated emotion and signals of the vagus nerve.
That is childish thinking to misappoint an organs function to another.
Your heart doesn't think
@@اسكندرفكار Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain.
“The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
what? Heart doesn’t do any thinking whatsoever.
@@brazenbull36
The Thinking Human Heart Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain.
“The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
An Arab Ex-Christian giving a critique of Islam/Quran.
Count me in.
You are verry ignorant, you don’t know science and you don’t know the Quran , first of all Allah knows best wat we do witch our heart and brain. Modern science has discovered we lie with our brain espaisly
Science
“Regions in the frontal and parietal cortex showed higher activation when participants lied compared with when they were telling the truth, regardless of whether they were asked about their past experiences or opinions.”
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5390719/#:~:text=Regions%20in%20the%20frontal%20and,their%20past%20experiences%20or%20opinions.
Quran :
What if that ˹man˺ persists in denial and turns away?
Does he not know that Allah sees ˹all˺?
ut no! If he does not desist, We will certainly drag him by the forelock-
a lying, sinful forelock
So let him call his associates.
We will call the wardens of Hell.
What considering the fact of that we als feel and think with our heart is not an ancient myth anyomore , you don’t catch up with sciene .
Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.
Feelings have so much to do with the heart, as they do with the brain. It's actually a two-way relationship. Our emotions change the signals the brain sends to the heart and the heart responds to the brain in complex ways.
norwestchiro.co.nz/heart-and-brain-connection#:~:text=Feelings%20have%20so%20much%20to,the%20brain%20in%20complex%20ways..
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why.
Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief.
"No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16)
This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?"
The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason.
The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything."
These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs.
Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
@ryan10001 the word translated actually mean forelock nothing more. And for scientific miracles m.ua-cam.com/video/vyqaohY3gKY/v-deo.html
That word is actually forelock and Regarding scientific miracles m.ua-cam.com/video/vyqaohY3gKY/v-deo.html
The word is actually forelock but forehead. Next about scientific miracles in the quaran. m.ua-cam.com/video/vyqaohY3gKY/v-deo.html
The word HEART is a metaphor for deep/ profound feelings ---deep emotions. This is not Heart itself---- heart means emotions and feelings.
Dr Haitham Talaat answered your questions with clear and scientific evidence
No he did not. He changed the argument completely!!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish
He proved scientifically that the mind is not in the brain
@@AdamElmasriEnglish
Watch his response
@@14__16
Mind isn't in the brain does not mean its linking with heart 😆
Well mind is an abstract thing. Even gases have mass though they don't have shape. And mind has neither shape nor mass nor color
Btw whats your definition of ''soul'' and ''mind''??
@@TENGRI-101
Listen to the doctor
My favorite verse regarding this is, "...Indeed, it is not the eyes that are blind, but it is the hearts in the chests that grow blind." (Quran 22:46)
It moved Joram Van Klaveren when he was writing an anti-Islam book. Yet, it can move some others to a very different path.
I think it's so true "We send down the Quran as healing and mercy to those who believe; as for those who disbelieve, it only increases their loss." (Quran 17:82)
I'm pretty sure these 'blind hearts' is not about the physical heart that pumps blood, and it's not also about the mind. It's more than that.
Those hearts did not "grow" blind, but usually it's Allah, who leads them astray.
And astray usually means: they believe in another God, who is not that blood-thirsty.
@@OrpheusXL @OrpheusXL Say, ‘People of the Book, let us arrive at a statement that is common to us all: we worship God alone, we ascribe no partner to Him, and none of us takes others beside God as lords.’ If they turn away, say, ‘Witness our devotion to Him.’ (Quran 3:64)
I encourage you to read the Quran through the lens of Al-Fatihah, not the lens of another human being. May God bless you.
@@nadhirahafizha9611 Well, it's the Quran which says, that Christians worship 3 gods.
Why? Because Mohammed did not understand the trinity. He did not even understand anything spiritual. Even the islamic paradise is material and more like a sex club than anything else.
Christians have three names for the main attributes of Jesus/Jehova.
Muslims have 99 names for Allah.
Are there 99 gods?
And through then "lens" of Al-Fatiha it looks like cursing all people who are not Muslims.
---> Let us not be that bad and evil like those! And you curse us ever day like this.
How can we come together?
Jesus said: Who denies the Father, also denies the Son, that is the Antichrist.
@@OrpheusXL "People of the Book, do not go to excess in your religion, and do not say anything about God except the truth: the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, was nothing more than a messenger of God, His word, directed to Mary, a spirit from Him. So believe in God and His messengers and do not speak of a ‘Trinity’- stop [this], that is better for you- God is only one God, He is far above having a son, everything in the heavens and earth belongs to Him and He is the best one to trust." (Quran 4:171)
That verse says, 'Do not go to excess' (تَغۡلُواْ فِى دِينِكُمۡ). So the verse doesn't say Christians had the intention to worship more than One God. By using that phrase, it acknowledges the sincere intention to worship One God.
"The Most Excellent Names (ٱلۡأَسۡمَآءُ ٱلۡحُسۡنَىٰ) belong to God: use them to call on Him, and keep away from those who abuse them- they will be requited for what they do." (Quran 7:180)
They are the names of God. It helps people to call and understand Him. Had God not facilitated it to be known on the tongues of the children of Adam, none from the creation would have been able to call His names.
Muslim scholars viewed these names as aligned to human beings' language and comprehension, but it doesn't mean God has names limited only to ninety nine.
Suppose I say that you are *sincere and kind.* *Sincere and kind* are your attributes. I did not refer to other entities.
"Guide us to the straight path: the path of those You have blessed, those who incur no anger and who have not gone astray." (Quran 1 [Al-Fatihah]: 6-7)
The verse talks about the path (ٱلصِّرَٰطَ). When it talks about the path, it is about beliefs, actions, behaviors. The Quran should be firm with its position regarding this path (ٱلصِّرَٰطَ), but never the verse says to curse people who hold other beliefs.
My friend, I am a Muslim, and I want to devote myself to God. I genuinely trust that you want to devote yourself to God as well.
But media has portrayed me as someone hateful and ready to curse anyone who doesn't have the same beliefs as me. I hope you don't fall into that trap.
If you find some Muslims who did that, remember that what some Muslims do, doesn't always represent what Islam says in the Quran; then you may forgive them.
As always, may God bless you.
@@nadhirahafizha9611 Is Mary the part of Trinity?
Science still hasn't proven the mystery of conciousness, and if such a thing as a soul exists.
I think 'heart' in this instance refers to the soul, which is the source of conciousness.
Nope, you're trying to hold on to your religion by lying to yourself
ua-cam.com/video/KhzEMJHQt2I/v-deo.html
There's nothing like soul. Consciousness comes from the brain.
Science still hasn't proven where conciousness comes from. Conciousness is indeed one of the biggest mysteries in Neuroscience.
What do you say to that?
@@JosephKing001 Never from the brain!
YOU can observe your thoughts. You are aware of it (when your attention goes into the observation. But usually we are asleep)
Question: WHO is the observer?
This makes it very clear, that consciousness is NOT in/from the brain.
There is word for Soul. It called Rouh (روح) in arabic.
Heart and Soul different words. Heart does not mean soul
Islamic logic can turn lies into facts and believe them ‼️
Actually the opposite. What do u think ur purpose is in life
@a m exactly
@a m
That's a wrong explanation
You can go back to the first explaners.. and you will see that they absolutely disagree with your explanation
anyway their explanation or your Explanation the two are full of sh!t
@a m The classic exposition of judgement at death comes in the Book of Coming Forth by Day, in chapter/spell 30 and in chapter/spell 125, and the so-called weighing of the heart. To the Egyptians, the heart, or ib, rather than the brain, was the source of human wisdom and the centre of emotions and memory. Because of its apparent links with intellect, personality and memory, it was considered the most important of the internal organs. It could reveal the person's true character, even after death, so the belief went, and therefore the heart was left in the deceased's body during mummification. In the weighing of the heart rite, the heart of the deceased is weighed in the scale against the feather of the goddess Maat, who personifies order, truth, and what is right. Spell 30 was often inscribed on heart scarabs that were placed with the deceased. The spell appeals to the heart not to weigh down the balance or testify against the deceased to the keeper of the balance. Part of the spell gives instructions for making the heart scarab: ‘Make a scarab of nephrite adorned with gold and put within a man's breast, and perform for him the ceremony of opening the mouth, the scarab being anointed with myrrh.’.1 www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3960665/#:~:text=In%20Egyptian%20religion%2C%20the%20heart,weighing%20of%20the%20heart%20ceremony.%F0%9F%A4%A3%F0%9F%A4%A3%F0%9F%A4%A3
@a m
"so their hearts may reason" = metaphorical
"ears may listen" = literal
how funny you guys need to twist and smash up your koran by pointing out it lacks continuity
As someone else already said it: *_Cardiocentric hypothesis is where the idea came from,7th century myths ,, accept it and move on...your book is manmade full of errors of that time_*
The role of the human heart from an Islamic perspective.
The heart's central role is to mantain phisical & spiritual activities of the body.
In the Qur'an different characteristics like wisdom, intelligence, disease, thinking & many others are related to the heart.
There's no need to explain that what is termed in literature as gnosis ( irfan) as
" the heart " is not the organ which is in the left side of the body & pumps blood.
It is clear what is meant by the heart is a sublime & distinguish reality which is totally different from the organ of the body.We are told in the Qur'an " There's an illness in their hearts, so God increases them in illness " 2:9. Certainly3
It also means the koran is not clear because it uses figurative language. 🔥
In the quran says zarah which today means an atom , the atom that has electrons and neutrons but hundreds of years it meant a grain of sand or something small
The heart or al qalb means the organ which pumps blood that has oxygen in our body but probably hundreds of years it meant other stuff
Also the soul is in the heart so your soul is the one which thinks using the heart and our soul is the one which makes its decisions
If there is anything that I understand from this, it is only the fact that the Egyptians had been really 'idiots' in terms of "philosophical and spiritual understanding" from day 1 of their existence in this world till today.
Anyway, TQ for unwillingly/unintentionally/indirectly promoting Islam and making my faith in Islam much stronger.
It is amazing how some Muslims come here to comment (in three easy steps).
1. They don't address anything in the presented argument (because they have nothing logical to say against it)
2. They resolve into attaching the person and insulting him instead of responding with respect to "a bad argument"
3. They claim their victory, pat themselves on the back and assure themselves that their faith is much stronger
I see this over and over, hundreds of times, in the comments...
@@AdamElmasriEnglish Sorry bro. To be honest I don't mean to 'attaching' and insulting you. I was just trying to showcase your ignorance and arrogance in not wanting to submit yourself to the 'truth' from Allah, just like the Egyptian 'Pharaoh', if not mistaken Ramses II who ended up drowning in the Red Sea due to his 'arrogance', but trying to claim victory and pat yourself on your back, as though you are too smart, while that's not the case .
Anyway, coming to the point: Any grown ups would know/understand that the word derived from 'qalb' Allah mentions does not literally refer to the biological 'heart' we have, neither the brain, but in terms of human understanding/ day to day use of the word in common conversation to denote the 'deep feelings', one has about a subject matter . Because only Allah knows and we know not or grasp certain 'phenomena' for example the 'soul' which is beyond human definition or understanding that Allah says, of its 'knowledge' only a little that had been given to us.
Btw, I do not claim to be too smart either, but surely better than you in understanding certain such 'phenomena' like the 'qalb' or the 'ruh' (soul) from the little knowledge that I have been given by Allah, to grasp its closest meaning or how it works in relation to human anatomy/organs, which I believe is beyond definition.
But I made a search in Google on 'qalb' and the closest definition I could come up with that resonates with my kind is this Sufi view/terminology/definition that says: "The qalb is a bright essence separate from matter, between the human soul and the human self."
So my request is, 'Stop spreading non sense abt things that you have no sure knowledge about and stop imposing your beliefs on others, thus 'contradicting yourself telling others not to impose their belief on others.
Let the people choose themselves what is right and what is wrong.
(Note: I am not native English. Pls bear with it)
TQ
@@Toppgg-ci9er So people with artificial hearts are basically lobotomized and completely catatonic?
Check yourself before you wreck yourself.
@@observerzzi didnt see him imposing any belief? in fact he argued with respect and intellect..with backed up references for people to think and searching for the truth and not blindly follow any religion .those resorted to killing the apostate is in fact the one who imposing and forcing a belief. how come a religion need to survives by threats and punishment? waging war? why such feeling of insecurity if the the message brought is the truth?
@@iliyasrazali83So true
Absolutely brilliant video
Wonderful video. Your arguments are flawless. I have such a ton of respect for people like you. There’s nothing more relieving than listening to people who speak with beautiful logic and reason, and not having to force arguments to explain nonsense. It’s like therapy and heals me from the years of anguish and anger I felt trying to make sense of Islam and to believe in something I genuinely and sincerely could not accept. I can’t lie to myself anymore.
Also your Arabic is beautiful. I love hearing you speak actual truth in such a lovely language free from any Islamic discourse and rhetoric
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
@@shaun.august Allah is Shaitan. He prefers sinners, he promises sex and women to men only in Jannah, he discriminates against Jews and Christians and let the Jinn write verses. Allah is limited in power as well, as he cannot become flesh. What a halfass god he is.
@@shaun.august - can you explain to me why not one of these 124k prophets mentioned Islam until after the 7the century?
We have found dinosaur fossils from millions of years ago. But not 1 shred of historical text of these alleged prophets shouting about Islam/Muslims. Funny that
@@shaun.august Have you eve watched the video the heart is not used as a figure of speech ,the writers of quran just took ancient greek belief ie plagiarized Aristotle ,just like they plagiarized Galen and many other ancient greek believes ,the verse al Ahraf 79 clearly demonstrates that heart is not an idiom in quran but an organ responsible for thinking and rationalizing ...
We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?
Q41:53
Now I understand why the Prophet's heart was cleansed (not the brain).
First time on this channel and it’s owned my subscription 👍
Mohammed is Islamic god and he put in Quran what limited knowledge he had😂
ua-cam.com/video/wq7D7ILUVGY/v-deo.html
Verily, the truth has come to you from your Lord. So be not of those who doubt (it)[].95.
And be not one of those who believe the Ayât (proofs, evidences, verses, lessons, signs, revelations, etc.) of Allâh, for then you shall be one of the losers.96.
Truly! Those, against whom the Word (Wrath) of your Lord has been justified, will not believe.97.
Even if every sign should come to them, - until they see the painful torment.
@Toxic Tricks Completely wrong. The heart neither thinks nor learns.
These neurons exist for muscular coordination and blood pressure regulation and the stress axis.
@@haiderabbas8486 Aha. If nothing works anymore, you will conjure up eternal torment in hell. Great!
If there is a God, he gave us the ability to think and reflect so that we could use it. But Islam has the same weakness as all religions: a maxim common to all - "Thou shalt not ask questions!"
you dont have any knowledge regarding Islam lol
What about those people who get transplant hearts from pigs, are those pig’s hearts thinking too?
Obviously yes. Islam is all utter stupidity beyond imagination.
thank you, as always very informative
Sir why he doesn't want quote the context , this people are playing with the of some people , in West Africa we know there is one God before the europeans came , our forethers never heard the name Jesus till the europeans came , moreover the letter ( J ) is not Jewish alphabet or Arabic, there are tribes in West Africa without the letter( J )
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why.
Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief.
"No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16)
This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?"
The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason.
The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything."
These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs.
Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
@@ryan10001 their is no confusion in my mind about that ideology from the 7th century i.s.i.s. open my eyes on how evil islam is actually ,they follow your ''prophet'' to the letter i read their ''dabiq'' publications that explain the why they do what they do taking slaves cutting christians head ect... to the glory of that god from hell killing,killing it is a death cult the trees and the rocks will tell you to kill jews it is so absurd everywhere where there are islamists hell follows
Excellent video! Awesome to see your channel growing and looking forward to seeing you on Apostate Aladdins channel ya basha!
Much appreciated!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish
Please read about the "Nous" and "Heart" in the Old Testament.
Evidently, the people who wrote the quran incorporated the concept of Nous without being able to understand or explain it.
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why.
Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief.
"No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16)
This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?"
The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason.
The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything."
These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs.
Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
@@ryan10001 I half agree with you. I think it's the authors of the Quran that are stupid.
When they invented the Quran, they made such a disjointed mess that people have to keep interpreting it. It's almost like Muslims are admitting Allah is autistic and isn't able to communicate properly, so he needs his own creations to explain and interpret this mess.
You are right about one thing though, the authors of the Quran certainly used metaphors and examples that are very locally specific.... which goes to show that this was the works of men, not god.
Good effort on trying though dude, but it's impossible to put lipstick on a pig and call it beautiful
Thank you Adam THE IN LIGHTING IS JUST STARTED.🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺
You are so welcome. Thank you for your comment!
Once again very well done, and a great topic that did not crossed my mind. Awesome to see your channel grow, more people need to be aware of these videos.
Have they not traveled in the earth so that they have hearts to think with or ears to hear with? Surely then it is not the beholdings (i.e. the eyes) that (grow) blind, but (it is) the hearts within the breasts that (grow) blind.
Q22:46
Until recently, modern science perceived the heart as merely a pump to regulate the flow of blood throughout our bodies. But across numerous cultures, the heart has historically been thought to have a much greater function that corresponds with our thoughts, emotions, and spirit.
When we speak or share feelings from a place of deep meaning or passion, we say we’re speaking from the heart or we’re trying to convey something that is heartfelt. This is no longer just an archaic maxim, but instead, one with factual backing. And science is now realizing that the heart and brain have more of a corollary, interactive relationship than previously thought … a relationship that has residual consequences on our bodies, and possibly even humanity as a whole.
Islam goal is not to make man pursue happiness unlike the Capitalist system.
Man's goal is to strive to achieve God's validation, not to be validated by His creations.
If one strive to develop a submissive mindset, he will eventually reach the level as God state in the Quran:
"(O Man) Say : Indeed my worship, my striving, my life and my death all are for God the Lord of creations."
When your goal is solely to serve God, as His Vicegerent on earth, then your legacy to humanity will be eternal like late boxer Muhammad Ali's statement engraved on his grave stone:
"Service to others is the rent you pay for your room in Heaven."
Islam aim is to make Man highly valuable and live a truly meaningful life as following:
"If you could envisioned the the type of person God intended you to be, you would rise up and never be the same again."
Unlike other creations, Man has a malleable mindset and he can transform himself to a better human version. The Quran motivates him thus:
"Indeed, God will not change the condition of a people until they change what is within themselves"
Capitalism has created a void within humans which can only be solved by a paradigm shift. These Quranic verses pinpoint the Western disease:
"For indeed, "rivalry for worldly gain distracts you until you visit your graves".
With a deep and grave rhythm the Qur'an then strikes their hearts with the terror awaiting them after coming to the graves: "Indeed, you shall know".
Understanding by haert means using intuition، it has nothing to do with organs and biology. I am a Bahai، I don't believe Islam is last religion، but happy to debate about Islam.
When the blood flow to the brain is compromised, a condition called stroke, the person can lose cognitive faculties. The person can lose consciousness, lose the ability to speak or comprehend language, become disoriented to time, place and person, lose either immediate memmory or long term memmory or both, become paralysed, endure sensory loss etc. If there is a cerebral injury sparing the brainstem the person can enter a vegetative state in which his vital functions like respiration and circulation are intact but the person is in a coma. This is because the brainstem regulates our vital functions where as the cerebral cortex is involved in cognitive, motor and sensory functions. In these conditions the heart is spared and can function normally yet the patient's cognition, behaviour, motor and sensory functions are affected. On the other hand when a person has a heart attack there is no loss of cognitive, behavioural, motor or sensory function. This itself shows how the heart is not involved in any of the cognitive, behavioural, motor or sensory functions.
Ever seen a braindead person have emotions through their heart?
I rest my case.
If the heart had anything to do with cognition, memory, learned skills or knowledge then a person undergoing a heart transplant should develop a whole new personality post-operation. Also, post-operation the person wouldn't recognise his family or friends or anything that happened in his life because his memory would be lost. Also, he shouldn't have any problem recognising the donor's family. He would love the donor's wife and children as his own. Suppose a surgeon's heart was transplanted into a pilot then the pilot wouldn't be able to fly planes anymore but he could easily walk into an operation theatre and do the surgery because the medical knowledge and the surgical skills would all be in the heart the pilot received from the surgeon. Similarly, the person wouldn't be able to speak his mother tongue if the mother tongue of the donor was different. If the donor was a Christian and the recipient was a Muslim then post-transplant the recipient would become a Christian because faith, rituals and religious practices would all be in the heart.
Now if you think all these sound like a funny story then tell this to those who think the heart is involved in cognition, emotion and learning. Also there are people living with artificial heart that lacks any intrinsic cardiac neurons and they don't have any change in their cognition, personality, emotions, memory, knowledge, beliefs etc. This is because ONLY the brain is the centre of these faculties.
From where blood go and supply Brain ???
Think .
@@Laura-y3d5e Thank you for agreeing with my point that the heart is just a pump.....✌🏼
@@AyeshaKhan-0-. The heart is not just a pump. It has its neural network or "little brain." The methods targeting the heart modulate pain regions in the brain. These methods seem to modulate the key changes that occur in the brain regions and are involved in the cognitive and emotional factors of pain. Thus, the heart is probably a key moderator of the brain
I am not a believer in any religion, but I think in this case perhaps the writers of the quran WERE using the term as a figure of speech even if they did indeed believe that the heart was the center of intelligence and feelings. The way the verses are written they could certainly be interpreted both ways. The problem is that if it really was a figure of speech, Islamic scholars would use that answer to the question all the time...and not some easily disproven claim that the word had two meanings.
Not only that, a perfect book, dictated by God, shouldn't use a figure of speech as to confuse believers, isn't that the reason why the quran was sent , to be superior to the Bible which does need exegesis. If the quran needs explanations too, what makes it different from the Christian and Jews scriptures.
see with the eyes , hear with the ears, ... understand with the heart ?? Really ?
It is a demonstration of the art of Taquiya promoted by Allah in the Quraan. Taquiya means to tell.ies to save your face or promote the interests of jihaad (Isma's claims) .
Please google Little Brain in the Heart. There is a group of neuron cells in the heart that is independent from our brain. I hope this will open up your heart to the truth.
these islamophobia know it was figure of speech but making an issue because they have nothing against islam , in every language people said listen to your heart and not mind why ?
Good research! Keep on exposing the lies of islam bro👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻
@@Toppgg-ci9erIslam commands sexual slavery, pedophilia and wife beating.. no thanks 👍
And makes scientific errors beyond question such as the 7 earths and skies/heavens, the sun setting in a muddy pool, and the shooting stars are actual stars thrown at the jinn to stop them from reaching heaven..
A man made religion, with more than 100 grammatical errors in the holy book.
The word kalb has two meaning one is heart and other is intelligence and it means intelligence there and it also speaks in some verses that the heart behind breasts but it that's too not the correct translation because the word used in Arabic for breast("sadaq") has two meaning that is centre now the meaning changes to centre of intelligence. So, why I used centre here because in other place the word used for breast is used when the musa(a.s) asked to allah to in surah taha(26-28) increase my (breast-"sadaq") for me. See here the word doesn't mean breast but it means its centre, he asked to increase his centre not brests. Likewise it is the centre of intelligence (intelligence within the centre)is blocked. And it's refuted easily so go take some other things to refute.
You just copied the BS from zakir nayek which I presented in the video.. clearly you haven’t watched the full video if you’re just repeating the utter nonsense. I bet you are not a native Arabic speaker!!
Please provide me with one example that the word Kalb means intelligence and not heart!
to whom you are wasting your time he is blind with his heart as ALLAH SWT explain Now he will make another Video see Quran say heart has eyes which blind their eyes are not blind but hearts are
Interesting. This same arguement applies to all the astonomy references as well. A geocentric (earth is center of universe) view of the universe is understood and expressed even though the reality is that the sun (heliocentric) is the center of our solar system.
Agreed. The verses are not precise however so Muslims re-interpret them and say that the orbits talked about are different, they say that the orbit of the Sun is with respect to the center of our galaxy (even though the Quran mentions day and night in the same verse!).
Also I must add a leading cleric the director of madina University ibn baz felt so strongly on this issue that he issued a fatwa calling those who didn't accept pre copernican understanding as kafirs
“Those who believe (in the Oneness of Allah - Islamic Monotheism), and whose hearts find rest in the remembrance of Allah, Verily, in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find rest”.
[Quran 13:28]
Justify and celebrate your stupidity by all means
Very well done!👏New subscriber here. This is an example of why the words Quran and science fit together only as well as a woolly mammoth through the eye of a needle.🦣
Thanks for subbing
@@AdamElmasriEnglishhi I’m not sure if you’ll ever see this but I hope one day you can do a response to Mohammed hijabs video refuting the videos that say there are scientific errors in the Quran, he made an argument against people saying that actually there is something in science that proves “gushing water “ actually does come from the back bone & the rib. If what I have wrote is unorganised it is because of my autism I have recently left Islam & am looking for the truth as I don’t speak Arabic.
@@rb757 my dear friend, thank you for reaching out to me, your lovely comment and request.
Please connect with me on Instagram freethinker_adamelmasri and send me Mohamed Hijab’s video in question.
I look forward to connecting with you.
@@AdamElmasriEnglish thank you for your kind response I will reach out to you on Instagram with the video thank you very much.
@@AdamElmasriEnglish I hope you receive my message on Instagram I am probably in your Instagram message requests
Quantum neurocardiology is an emerging field of study that seeks to understand the relationship between the heart, the brain, and quantum physics. The field suggests that the heart, in addition to its function as a pumping organ, may also serve as a complex information processing center that communicates with the brain and other organs through electromagnetic fields.
The heart has its own nervous system, known as the “intrinsic cardiac nervous system," which contains neurons and neurotransmitters that allow it to function independently of the brain. Studies have shown that the heart’s electromagnetic field is much stronger than that of the brain, and that it can influence the brain’s electrical activity and even affect cognition and emotion.
So instead of admitting that the quran is blatantly false, you will go to such lenghts to humiliate yourself in order to defend it?
It is easier for people to be fooled than for them to admit they have been fooled.
@@Akillesursinne Hair splitting is right as long as atheists do it.
@@muhammadumernaseervisiting964 Mhm. Instead, just prove that god exists and you'll have turned the entire world to your cause. You have the burden of proof, after all.
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'.
Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
@@muhammadumernaseervisiting964 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, another pseudoscience buzz word is 'quantum'. They just throw in the word 'quantum' with nonsensical ideas thinking it will add credibility. Neither the proponents of such ideas nor the people who cite such ideas as evidence for their pre-scientific religious or political agendas know what is meant by pseudoscience buzz words like 'quantum' or 'holistic'. Treatment should be target specific and that's what evidence based medicine is aiming for by introducing 'target specific immunotherapy' for cancers and many rheumatological diseases. There is no need to treat healthy organs or the whole body for a disease of a specific pathophysiology unless it affects or spreads to other areas of the body. 'Holistic' treatment only harms the person. Even when evidences show the harmful effects or the inefficacy of these so called 'holistic' treatments, quacks and people alike ignore it.
Similarly, Heartmath institute says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
In quran and in human’s history across nations the heart is a metaphor on feeling, sense , knowing things as your gut tells you , just a metaphor
If you watched the video to the end, you’d know where that metaphor comes from.. and why it is not accepted as a metaphor from the Quran!
But you probably didn’t watch the full video!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish i watched the whole video, and i m telling you that quran talks to people according to what they used to in their place / time , they used the heart as a metaphor for sense , feelings , you need some non materialistic thinking sometimes 🌹
So why no metaphor was used with eyes to see and ears to hear ??? And why no mentioning of brain anywhere in quran??? Just because you have no excuse to defend , you use "METAPHOR" ...it ain't gonna work now...
@@thisisron7994 the context , reason , history, reality determines
@@hareth3911 reality is what that is written,, imagination is what you are trying to do by saying it to be metaphor... Egyptians used to beleive that heart is the organ that controls human body... So it was copied like that... Simple and easy
Good question but ask yourself another question. Why did God use the Arabic language to communicate? So humans at those times would understand. So wouldn't God use figurative speech to convey his message especially by the fact the Quran sounds like more of a poem? Figurative language back then were used by the Arabs and God sent down the Quran in THEIR language. Discussion over.
@aminafarah9933
The crazy thing is that Muslims keep saying end of argument as if they are scared if a response.
If it were the heart playing the part of the brain, I would also say it's a figure if speech buuuuuuttttt😂😂😂
Semen comes between the rib and the backbone- is that a figure of speech?
The sun sets in a swamp - is that a figure if speech?
A string ties up the anus - is that a figure of speech?
Whoever orgasms first is who the child will look like - is that a figure of speech?
Is having 4 wives also a figure of speech? - Muhammad had 11!
Is there only being one Quran also a figure if speech? Because there are 31 variations 😮
Is Allah's words being unchangeable also a figure of speech because sheep ate, uthman burned😮
Were the debunked miracles also a figure if speech. Ooooh looks like the conversation has not yet ended😂😂😂😂
Look forward to your reply
I want my 11 minutes back, learnt nothing
you actually learnt that some videos are nothing and you are to take the consequences.
Human conviction is the only thing that keeps religions alive. I can think of myself confidently as a hero, while bullying others. I can also be bullied by others, and think that I'm the one whose guilty. People are drawn to conviction, and at times can blindly believe lies because of that. That is why it is very important to be a person who understands others' vulnerabilities and have people who would do the same for you. If one's confidence comes from diminishing others, that's a faulty thing. A God which condemns people to eternal hellfire for disbelieving is obviously a tool created by humans for unification and division.
The classic exposition of judgement at death comes in the Book of Coming Forth by Day, in chapter/spell 30 and in chapter/spell 125, and the so-called weighing of the heart. To the Egyptians, the heart, or ib, rather than the brain, was the source of human wisdom and the centre of emotions and memory. Because of its apparent links with intellect, personality and memory, it was considered the most important of the internal organs. It could reveal the person's true character, even after death, so the belief went, and therefore the heart was left in the deceased's body during mummification. In the weighing of the heart rite, the heart of the deceased is weighed in the scale against the feather of the goddess Maat, who personifies order, truth, and what is right. Spell 30 was often inscribed on heart scarabs that were placed with the deceased. The spell appeals to the heart not to weigh down the balance or testify against the deceased to the keeper of the balance. Part of the spell gives instructions for making the heart scarab: ‘Make a scarab of nephrite adorned with gold and put within a man's breast, and perform for him the ceremony of opening the mouth, the scarab being anointed with myrrh.’.1 www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3960665/#:~:text=In%20Egyptian%20religion%2C%20the%20heart,weighing%20of%20the%20heart%20ceremony.🤣🤣🤣
Egyptians also believed the sun travelled across the sky every day and then sank into a dark abyss where it battled the monsters of darkness to re emerge again in the east to then repeat the journey - this idea is reproduced in the Koran and hadiths where it says "When he reached the setting place of the sun he FOUND it set in a muddy spring."
This video presentation is bogus. There is nothing wrong with the Qur'anic verses cited related to the heart. The ancient people understood this relationship between the heart and consciousness and reasoning. Obviously, there is a special relationship between the brain and heart that has yet to be fully discovered scientifically. However, stay tuned and brace yourself for future breakthroughs in deeper knowledge and understanding. It is interesting that Christians see no problem when the word "heart" is used in similar contexts in the Bible. To me, this is just another campaign of Christian desperation to establish some credibility by bashing Islam and Muslims.
That has yet to be discovered? What makes you say this?
1600 years ago, some beduin goat herders suddenly decided that they could write a book that explains everything ...
Now imagine, in 2022 people being gullible enough to accept every word in it correct...
Only muslims, because they must.
Hahahaa...no wonder islamic country doomed to fail
Bro went from an illiterate, married a rich lady, became war general from nothing and owned hundreds of slaves. Bro is a scammer 💀
Excellent video, keep it up👍 and also don't forget the Arabic channel.
@a m The heart in the quran is not used as idiom ,its used as an organ which is responsible for comprehension, thinking ,rationalizing thats is easily seen in the verse Al Ahraf 79 as the verse clearly explains the function of multiple organs ie ears for hearing ,eyes for seing and heart for thinking and raationalizing,quran just plagiarizes Aristotle just like it plagiarizes Galen and many other ancient greek believes ....
Allah Says the Smartest Things:
1. “The sun sets in a muddy spring” (Surah 18:86)
2. “He followed a way until he reached the rising place of the sun” (Surah 18-89)
3. “Allah holds the sky so as it cannot fall on the Earth” (Surah 22:65)
4. “And after that, He spread the Earth” (Surah 79:30)
5. “He (Allah) made for you the Earth like a carpet spread out” (Surah 20:53)
6. “Semen is made between the backbone and the ribs” (Surah 86:5-7)
7. “Cow’s milk is made between the dung and the blood” (Surah 16:66)
8. “The sun runs on unto a resting place for him” (Surah 36:38)
9. “We made the sperm-drop into a clinging clot, and We made the clot into a lump, and We made the lump bones, and We covered the bones with flesh. (Surah 23:13-14)
10. “We have adorned the lowest heaven with lamps and made them [missiles] for stoning devils for whom We have also prepared the torment of a blazing fire.” (Surah 67:5)
11. Fun bonus: “O you who believe, do not enter the houses of the Prophet, unless you are permitted for a meal, not (so early as) to wait for its preparation. But when you are invited, go inside. Then, once you have had the meal, just disperse, and (do) not (sit for long) being keen for a chat. This (conduct of yours) hurts the Prophet, but he feels shy of (telling) you (about it), but Allah is not shy of the truth.” (Surah 33:53)
Remember, Allah is claimed to be the “all-knowing” “all-powerful” “creator of the universe” and he is quoted verbatim, word-for-word, in Allah’s “clear book” the eternal, uncreated Quran which has existed in Heaven before the beginning of time and creation.
But as you can see, all-knowing Allah says things no different from a 7th century Bedouin. As the all-knowing creator of the universe, you would expect Allah to state scientific truths (in perfect, indisputable detail, requiring no jihadi-bearded dawah boys to help interpret) like the Theory of Relativity, the Double Helix Structure of DNA, Quantum Mechanics, Particle Physics, etc. But no.
(Fun fact: When you see the sun in the sky, take note that it is in a muddy spring for the time zones before you and under Allah's bum in other time zones. True story.)
It's simple to prove Allah does not exist. We just need to prove Allah’s CLAIMS don’t exist. As the Quran is the “kalamullah” i.e. all-knowing Allah's verbatim word, the Quran must be 100% accurate. But it is not. The Quran makes many ignorant 7th-century statements. And since Allah’s claims don’t exist, Allah doesn’t exist.
Stay away from Islam. Nothing good comes out of Islam.
Indeed ... allah knows bestest 😂😂
Allah cannot be wrong so truth must be wrong
I suppose Christian God does not know much, and you like that, you would like to teach God somethings?
The problem with many people they don't understand the Arabic word "أرض" "Earth" in English and "Erde" in German, and also unfortunately many Muslims scholars thinks word "أرض" or earth means the planet earth but it literally means the matter from which planets are made so in short I would say its not easy to understand this book if you are trying to translate using translator. Be patient do your research and you will find mind blowing things, so please dont fall into the trap of the so called religious scholars and youtubers always do your own research. All these books like Bibel, Torah and Quran etc are not easy to understand. good luck.
Nah your Allah just can't write clearly, just like his math ain't mathing. Anyway, the Quran is not Arabic. It's Aramaic written in Arabic letters. What an embarrassment.@@haroonafridi1802
FYI, scientific knowledge is not complete yet, then y does a heartbreak and emotional trauma, physically hurts in the chest n heart.... There is an amazing connection in heart n brain, plus new research that shows heart has feelings n memory, so i hope u learn n see things n not turn your heart blind
If the same message in BIBLE IN ENGLISH is not acceptable metaphorically but only Qur'an does.
Deity: "Ok, here's my holy book and...have another book. Hang on to that one for later."
Backwater Prophet: "What's this, O Divine One?"
Deity: "Harvard University Calculus texbook."
BP: "....those four words mean nothing to me."
Deity: "Trust me on this one - make sure you just stick some of that in between the misogyny and slavery stuff. It'll blow their minds in a few centuries."
That, boys and girls, is how an omnipotent deity COULD have shown they have knowledge of the future.
Does the heart have a mind?
Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.14 Nov 2019
I didn’t think this was real but the heart can actually feel , learn , remember and sense indépendantly from the brain . Wow
So have they not traveled through the earth and have hearts by which to reason and ears by which to hear? For indeed, it is not eyes that are blinded but blinded are the hearts which are within the breasts. [Quran, 22:46]
We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?
Q41:53
But what is the evidence that the intrinsic cardiac nervous system controls non-cardiac mental activity? Without such evidence, it cannot be said that the heart has a mind any more than other vital organs have a mind.
@@mosadeqmauthoor2587 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'.
Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Sorry you’re wrong. The Heart Math Institute has found that everything begins in the heart. The heart's brain is an intricate network of several types of neurons, neurotransmitters, proteins and support cells similar to those found in the brain proper. Its elaborate circuitry enables it to act independently of the cranial brain - to learn, remember, and even feel and sense. Look up Joe Dispenza, watch how people heal themselves. Everything starts from the heart, even thought. The heart is the seed from which the body grows.
You see Mr Satan, Allah is talking to hopeless and aimless people like you, your hearts is seel already so you will never understand the Quran
Clown 🤡
Thank you Adam !
You are very welcome Paul. I’m the message resonates with you! 🙏
And thank you for your continuous support as a paid member! Much appreciated my friend.
This has been disproved by scientists. The heart is proactive, and thinking organ.
Ah another unemployed and unqualified guy again.
yeah and islamophobia makes alot of money too 😂
@@rabielazazi787 wdym?
Adam: you are intelligent, reasonable and cute.
And your comment made me smile :) Thank you so much
Most of us have been taught in school that the brain and nervous system controls every organ in the body including the heart. With that said, you’re probably thinking that we only use the brain in every situation, even with dealing with feelings.
However, that’s not the case! Feelings have so much to do with the heart, as they do with the brain. It’s actually a two-way relationship. Our emotions change the signals the brain sends to the heart and the heart responds to the brain in complex ways. Both actually depend and influence each other’s function, very much like how you harmonize with someone when doing a duet.
In fact, recent research from HeartMath has shown that the heart communicates to the brain in different ways
Research in the relatively new discipline of neurocardiology has confirmed that the heart acts as a sophisticated information encoding and processing center that enables it to learn, remember, and make functional decisions independently of the cerebral cortex. Additionally, numerous studies have demonstrated that cardiac signals to the brain affect autonomic regulatory centers and higher brain centers involved in cognition and mood regulation.
0:00 Introduction
0:56 They have hearts
4:08 Arabic meaning of heart
5:55 What a twist
6:58 The cardiocentric hypothesis
8:45 Conclusion
This is a very stupid way to critic the Quran and I will tell you why.
Allah using the heart as the base reasoning is just a metaphor and nothing more. The idea that the Quran thinks that the heart is the base of all logical reasoning is not true because we find a verse that challenges that belief.
"No! If he does not stop, We will take him by the naseyah (front of the head), a lying, sinful naseyah (front of the head)! "(Quran, 96:15-16)
This verses shows us that God is describing the front part of the forehead was a laying forehead. Today, science tells us that the frontal lobe contributes to lying. If the Quran really subscribed to the cardiocentric hypothesis like you said, shouldn't we expect the verse above to say something like, "A laying sinful HEART?"
The real meaning of the verse where Allah uses the heart as the base of reasoning in similar verses is a metaphorical way to say that their eyes and ears will see and hear the truth, their brain will realize the truth, but their hearts (desires of this worldly life) will reject the truth and refuse to reason.
The proof of this in verse 41:53 to 41:54 - "We will show them Our signs in the universe and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that this ˹Quran˺ is the truth. Is it not enough that your Lord is a Witness over all things?" "They are truly in doubt of the meeting with their Lord! ˹But˺ He is indeed Fully Aware of everything."
These verses shows us that god will show his signs to the people until it become CLEAR to them (in the brain) that it is the truth. HOWEVER, the disbeliever's heart or the desires of this worldly life will reject those signs.
Also remember, the Quran is revealed to a people form the 7th century, so it is logical to use the pre-existing terminology to convey the MAIN message to the people, with creating discourse and confusion.
there was also history where hurt muhammed was cleaned 2 angels from bad desires ,Look this,it wasnt brain or somethink esle,it was exactly hurt
That was stolen from a story about Zoroaster.
Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain.
“The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
Then explain how humans can live with completely artificial hearts without having any consciousness problems
All organs communicate with the brain 😅
@nothing-we6bh
When i meet one human with such an artificial heart and examine him , then i will give you the answer. If you find one, then we can prove or disprove the functions of the heart.
@@alqawiyu
Just Google it brother
I understand that it's so hard to accept the truth...
@@nothing-we6bhartificial heart there is no such thing exists
Adam, it is very easy to debunk your accusation about the Quran having a scientific error regarding the "heart". It is not the Quran that has an error but your logic. Let me explain.
Your most fundamental error about this accusation is how you try to debunk the Quran using the translation, which makes me wonder why you keep doing this. You speak Arabic and yet you rely on the translation to debunk the Quran smh.
When you want to talk about the heart in the Quran, you cannot only talk about "Qalb" (which you do in this video) but you also have to mention "Fuaad" and "Aql". When the Quran talks about the heart using the word "Fuaad", it talks about the heart as the place of emotions with no logic. Many verses indicate this, but the one indicates the most is QS.16:7. That verse talks about how we are from our mother's womb and Allah gives us sight, hearing, and Fuaad (the heart as the place of emotions). Babies do not yet have logic and reason. They are 100% emotional. So this is Fuaad. Emotions with no logic involved.
On the other hand, "Aql" is logic. Reason. The ability to think, to comprehend, to understand something. This is our brain. I don't need to give you any reference, you can search it in the Quran. Almost every verse that uses the word "Aql" talks about how God asks us to understand things. So this is Aql.
And in between "Fuaad" and "Aql" we have "Qalb". Qalb is the combination of "Fuaad" (emotion) and "Aql" (logical reasoning, intellect, etc). "Qalb" is not merely the heart. It has much deeper meaning than a mere heart. There are hundreds of verses using the word "Qalb", check them all. They mostly talk about how we need to use intellect (Aql) as well as emotions (Fuaad) to think and understand something.
So, when you are questioning about how QS. 22:46 states the "Qalb" is responsible for reasoning, the verse actually makes 100% perfect sense. You have to use the combination of "Aql" and "Fuaad" to understand something. For example, if you are in the state of hunger your emotion might be angry or sad that you might no longer be able to think normally. You just want to eat, that's the first thing you want at the moment. And after your emotion is calm then you can think normally.
I hope you understand my explanation. You will of course understand if you use your Qalb. Otherwise, you will not if you only use Fuaad (emotions) and let it block your Aql (intellect).
So if you want to debunk Islam and the Quran, use your Qalb truthfully. You might find the truth instead.
Islam is finished. It will not survive next 50 years.
I love this. thanks Adam! 👍
The Arabic word 'Qalb' has two meanings: 1 intelligence and 2 heart as in English there are words with two or more meanings e.g. Fair
If the Quran is not from God, how could the description of human embryo be mentioned in 7th century ???
Furthermore, mention of two seas that do not meet and mention of lowest point on Earth???
And remember Prophet Muhammad was illiterate; couldn't read and write
@@Toppgg-ci9er you are a 🤡.
You need to understand your creator and quran with your heart not just your mind to understand and accept what Allah SWT is saying to you. May Allah SWT give you the light of correct knowledge. Ameen.
@Toxic Tricks All cognitive functions including processing thoughts and emotions happen only in the brain. It's true that there are a few nerons in the heart but they are incapable of processing thoughts and emotions like the brain does. The neurons communicate with the brain and vice-versa but it's all about regulating the electrical and mechanical activities of the heart such as the rate and rhythm of heart beat as well as the contractility of the heart muscles. Now if the Qura'an was speaking about this set of nerons in the heart popularly dubbed as "heart-brain" as many muslim apologists claim, then the god must have been very specific. The god should have specifically mentioned what this "heart-brain" does and how it takes precedence over the brain in cognitive function(the "heart-brain" has absolutely NOTHING to do with the cognitive functions of the brain). Instead the quran clearly follows the cardiocentric hypothesis as it claims that humans 'reason with heart'. All cognitive, behavioural and emotional functions take place only in the brain. Unfortunately, the popular media as well as the muslim apologists have been very successful in convincing the poor deluded believers that the so called "heart brain" is the organ of cognition and not the brain.
If heart had anything to do with cognition then a person undergoing a heart transplant should develop a whole new personality post-operation. Also there are people with an artificial heart which doesn't have this intrinsic cardiac neurons, yet they don't have any problem with cognition, emotion, sensory function, motor function etc.
Heart only pumps blood. L.
@toxictricks1666 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, another pseudoscience buzz word is 'quantum'. They just throw in the word 'quantum' with nonsensical ideas thinking it will add credibility. Neither the proponents of such ideas nor the people who cite such ideas as evidence for their pre-scientific religious or political agendas know what is meant by pseudoscience buzz words like 'quantum' or 'holistic'. Treatment should be target specific and that's what evidence based medicine is aiming for by introducing 'target specific immunotherapy' for cancers and many rheumatological diseases. There is no need to treat healthy organs or the whole body for a disease of a specific pathophysiology unless it affects or spreads to other areas of the body. 'Holistic' treatment only harms the person. Even when evidences show the harmful effects or the inefficacy of these so called 'holistic' treatments, quacks and people alike ignore it.
Similarly, Heartmath institute says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
😂 ok, then what is the knowledge that helps accept scientific errors? God does not make errors. The quran contains errors. Find the bug.
Scientifically WRONG!
This alone will shut everything down :
allah’s scientific miracle MISTAKE :
allah thinks milk is made in a cow's Belly (stomach) Q16:66 - And there is certainly a lesson for you in cattle: We give you to drink of what is in their bellies, from between digested food and blood: pure milk, pleasant to drink.
jMILK IS 100% NOT MADE IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF THE COW, NOR IS MILK IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF A COW.. allah is 100% FALSE, quran is 100% FALSE, mahamed is 100% FALSE
Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system. In addition, the heart communicates with the brain in many methods: neurologically, biochemically, biophysically, and energetically. The vagus nerve, which is 80% afferent, carries information from the heart and other internal organs to the brain. Signals from the "heart brain" redirect to the medulla, hypothalamus, thalamus, and amygdala and the cerebral cortex. Thus, the heart sends more signals to the brain than vice versa. Such a misleading video this is.
Does a man with an artificial heart lose any brain capacity? No!
The heart has nothing to do with cognitive function!! The Quran is wrong!
Qalb" is the Arabic word for "heart". In Islamic philosophy, the "qalb" is the center of the human personality. The literal meaning of "qalb" is "to turn". The root meaning suggests that the heart is always in a state of motion and transformation. The "qalb" is the home for all of our emotions, rationale, and obedience or disobedience to Allah. The "qalb" is the basis of activities, intentions, meaning, and deep understanding of the world around us.
Good!
Do not we say " youre breaking my heart "
" i love you with all my heart " and you have got a good heart etc
this guy is just looking for a quick buck
جزاك الله خيرا.
Now, use it in the context of the verse. You're crazy.
C
" Certainly in this is a sure reminder for those whoever has a heart". 50: 37.
THE CURE FOR THIS ILLNESS IS NOT TO BE HAD BY ANY HEART SPECIALIST.
Now u know the truth.
The Thinking Human Heart Dr. Armour called this small but complex nervous system, “the Little Brain in the Heart”. His discoveries reveal to us that heart’s nervous system contains about 40,000 neurons - called sensory neurites - which actually communicate with the brain.
“The idea that we can think with our hearts is no longer just a metaphor, but is, in fact, a very real phenomenon. We now know this because the combined research of two or three fields is proving that the heart is the major center of intelligence in human beings.” Joseph Pearce
The brain has over 80 billion neurons and Allah failed to give us the organ that control everything.
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'.
Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'.
Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
Mohammad thought more with his balls
Ancient peoples described the heart as the location of the will. We see the same understanding in the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures. The only difference I see is that Christians and Jews (mostly) do not insist that the language is scientifically true.
You are verry ignorant, you don’t know science and you don’t know the Quran , first of all Allah knows best wat we do witch our heart and brain. Modern science has discovered we lie with our brain espaisly
Science
“Regions in the frontal and parietal cortex showed higher activation when participants lied compared with when they were telling the truth, regardless of whether they were asked about their past experiences or opinions.”
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5390719/#:~:text=Regions%20in%20the%20frontal%20and,their%20past%20experiences%20or%20opinions.
Quran :
What if that ˹man˺ persists in denial and turns away?
Does he not know that Allah sees ˹all˺?
ut no! If he does not desist, We will certainly drag him by the forelock-
a lying, sinful forelock
So let him call his associates.
We will call the wardens of Hell.
What considering the fact of that we als feel and think with our heart is not an ancient myth anyomore , you don’t catch up with sciene .
Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.
Feelings have so much to do with the heart, as they do with the brain. It's actually a two-way relationship. Our emotions change the signals the brain sends to the heart and the heart responds to the brain in complex ways.
norwestchiro.co.nz/heart-and-brain-connection#:~:text=Feelings%20have%20so%20much%20to,the%20brain%20in%20complex%20ways..
I'm so glad there is more debunking channels comming up ❤ Good luck with your channel bro, I'll help spread it
What r u spreading? Ur legs..?
you're on illusion
@@wadibenabdallah2822stupid religion is an illusion
Studies indicate that heart transplant recipients may exhibit preferences, emotions, and memories resembling those of the donors, suggesting a form of memory storage within the transplanted organ. Explain this Mr Pretentious
It's important to note that these claims are largely anecdotal and lack robust scientific validation. The mainstream medical and scientific community generally views these reports with skepticism, attributing such changes to psychological factors, medication effects, or the profound experience of undergoing a heart transplant rather than actual memory transfer through transplanted cells.
@@kyoungd mainstream scientific and medical community😂 wth you're talking about mr pretentious
@@palabd877 OK. Name the study, Mr. know-it-all. Let's look it up.
The heart being a smart organ reraining nervous impacts still doesn't mean it has any role in cognitive functions as the Quran claims. The proof is that some people can live without a heart at all (on an artificial pump) and they can still think and function cognitively very well.
The Quran still got it wrong!
Recent work in the relatively new field of neurocardiology has firmly established that the heart is a sensory organ and an information encoding and processing center, with an extensive intrinsic nervous system that’s sufficiently sophisticated to qualify as a heart brain. Its circuitry enables it to learn, remember, and make functional decisions independent of the cranial brain. To everyone’s surprise, the findings have demonstrated that the heart’s intrinsic nervous system is a complex, self-organized system; its neuroplasticity, or ability to reorganize itself by forming new neural connections over both the short and long term, has been well demonstrated.
The Heart-Brain System Pathway
There are several areas of the brain that are in direct communication with the heart.
` The cortex: the thinking brain
`The thalamus: which synchronizes the cortical activity
`The amygdala: which houses emotional memory
`The medulla: which regulates the ANS and blood pressure
Thanks
They communicate via the HPA axis as blood pressure and stress and pulse increase. That is all what the crosstalk is about.
Nothing else.
Think better about your sources next time.
Being all-knowing and expecting people to consider the Koran 1400 years later, one might expect Allah to be a bit more considered in his choice of expression and get his facts right. Really the discussion is only over if you are scared of its implications.
Actually people at that time knew that the brain was the source of thoughts. this is actually a miracle of the Quran, not a mistake..
Modern day scientists proved that the heart has a consistent influence on brain thoughts.
Here is why:
1 Heart has thinking and calculating nerves, it is not me who says it, its Dr J. Andrew Armour of the Montreal University.
After an extensive research with a staff of neurocardiologists, He founded that heart has a brain of its own.
His work made in 1991 revealed that the heart has a complex intrinsic nervous system that is sufficiently sophisticated to qualify as a "little brain" in its own right.
2 It Participates in leading and guiding individuals based on certain calculations, emotions and feelings.
3 Relays information back to the brain and has a 2-way communication system with the brain that enables it to take part of the thinking, processing, and decision-making.
4 Can force the brain to obey its commands.
5 Has memory and data retrieval (remembering) capability.
The heart contains 40 000 neurons... called sensory neurites, which detect circulating hormones and neurochemicals and sense heart rate and pressure information. Hormonal, chemical, rate and pressure information is translated into neurological impulses by the heart’s nervous system and sent from the heart to the brain through several afferent (flowing to the brain) pathways. It is also through these nerve pathways that pain signals and other feeling sensations are sent to the brain.
hmm this time you nailed it.. I criticized your last video but this one is absolutely right and brilliant..
It has been proved in 2020 scientific research.
This a major problem, if there was a verse in the quran that sais " 1+1=3" then the scholars nowadays would say "No, the actual meaning of the verse is blablabla and thats why it means 2 insha alla".
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
@@shaun.august there you go blablabla... If i read that blue is blue why are you defending its not.
@Toxic Tricks and semen comes from the rib😂 now a fake scientist will back allahs claim write his name
@@shaun.august Still wrong.
well bible say it 1+1+1=1
We now have scientific evidence that the heart sends us emotional and intuitive signals to help us manage our lives.
It is an intuitive and extremely rapid source of wisdom and clear perception, an intelligence that encompasses and stimulates mental and emotional intelligence. We call it “the intelligence of the heart”.
Heart Intelligence is the intelligent flow of awareness and intuition we experience when the mind and emotions come into a state of balance and coherence through a self-initiating process. This form of intelligence, experienced as direct and intuitive wisdom, manifests in thoughts and emotions that are beneficial to ourselves and others.
Then please answer this, how come people living with an artificial heart pump don’t lack any intuition or intelligence??
We now also have evidence that when the heart of totally replaced, no loss of memory, cognitive skills or intelligence is lost! - but these are all lost or impacted by the brain damage!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish hhhhh....Ah ok I understood your opinion...we are talking about spirituality.
The soul is a term that designates everything that makes up the psyche of the individual: these are his states of consciousness, his intelligence, his reason, his intuition, but also his feelings, his emotions, his passions and his instincts. ""the heart""
Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'.
Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
What happens to a person which needs a new heart? Thanks gentleman for this presentation.
Good question! The Quran didn't know about heart transplants back then ;)
Prof. Dr. Ibrahim B Syed
Scientists have discovered that the heart thinks, learns wisdom, and contains neurological canters that save data. The heart contains 40,000 nerve cells that form a “real brain”!! Qur’an revealed this fact more than 1400 years ago.
In Surah Hajj (Pilgrimage) 22: 46, Allah says:
The English translation is:
Do they not travel through the land, so that their hearts (can think/can reason/can learn wisdom/can understand or comprehend) and their ears may thus learn to hear? Truly it is not their eyes that are blind, but their Hearts which are in their breasts.
In many places in the Quran, one comes across “A-Falaa T’a’aqiloon”. or “Don’t you understand?”
In this Ayah we need to focus on the words “Qulbun Ya’aqiloon”. The vast majority of the Muslim scholars have translated it as “Hearts understand”. Although Ya’aqiloon has several meanings: that is the Heart can Think, Heart can Reason, Heart can learn wisdom, Heart can understand or comprehend, the Muslims scholars until today translated it as Hearts understand.
The Heart: Not Just Brawn but Brains, Too
About 100,000 times a day the heart repeats this monotonous task of survival. But what many think is a mindless pump turns out to have a mind of its own. According to the Institute of HeartMath-a nonprofit research and education organization dedicated to helping people live healthier, happier lives-there are networks of nerve cells (neurons) around the heart that function in much the same way as parts of the brain.
Back in the 1960s, research conducted by John and Beatrice Lacey-pioneers in the field of psychophysiology-showed that the heart has its own reasoning that is not determined by directives from the brain. Subsequent investigations revealed an actual pathway and mechanism allowing the heart to send messages that inhibit or facilitate electrical activity in the brain. The new field of neurocardiology evolving from this research led to the development of the concept of the “heart brain” in 1991.
The “heart brain” is equipped with some 40,000 neurons(Brain Cells). These neurons can deliver pain signals and other sensations to the autonomic parts of the brain (which are largely unconscious), as well as messages to brain centers involved in conscious thought and emotion. Contact with the “executive” part of the brain can influence perception, decision making, and emotional responses. (www.rewireme.com/explorations/your-heart-and-stomach-may-be-smarter-than-you-think/)
@toxictricks1666 the quran will never be wrong.... All the accuracies mean if science has not agreed with one particular thing, then that is the limitations of science and not the word of God......there are so many scientific verses which would not have been understood back then and now are understood with technology..... Just like this heart verse, it will be understood clearly soon. I posted a short finding.
Prof. Dr. Ibrahim B Syed
Scientists have discovered that the heart thinks, learns wisdom, and contains neurological canters that save data. The heart contains 40,000 nerve cells that form a “real brain”!! Qur’an revealed this fact more than 1400 years ago.
In Surah Hajj (Pilgrimage) 22: 46, Allah says:
The English translation is:
Do they not travel through the land, so that their hearts (can think/can reason/can learn wisdom/can understand or comprehend) and their ears may thus learn to hear? Truly it is not their eyes that are blind, but their Hearts which are in their breasts.
In many places in the Quran, one comes across “A-Falaa T’a’aqiloon”. or “Don’t you understand?”
In this Ayah we need to focus on the words “Qulbun Ya’aqiloon”. The vast majority of the Muslim scholars have translated it as “Hearts understand”. Although Ya’aqiloon has several meanings: that is the Heart can Think, Heart can Reason, Heart can learn wisdom, Heart can understand or comprehend, the Muslims scholars until today translated it as Hearts understand.
The Heart: Not Just Brawn but Brains, Too
About 100,000 times a day the heart repeats this monotonous task of survival. But what many think is a mindless pump turns out to have a mind of its own. According to the Institute of HeartMath-a nonprofit research and education organization dedicated to helping people live healthier, happier lives-there are networks of nerve cells (neurons) around the heart that function in much the same way as parts of the brain.
Back in the 1960s, research conducted by John and Beatrice Lacey-pioneers in the field of psychophysiology-showed that the heart has its own reasoning that is not determined by directives from the brain. Subsequent investigations revealed an actual pathway and mechanism allowing the heart to send messages that inhibit or facilitate electrical activity in the brain. The new field of neurocardiology evolving from this research led to the development of the concept of the “heart brain” in 1991.
The “heart brain” is equipped with some 40,000 neurons(Brain Cells). These neurons can deliver pain signals and other sensations to the autonomic parts of the brain (which are largely unconscious), as well as messages to brain centers involved in conscious thought and emotion. Contact with the “executive” part of the brain can influence perception, decision making, and emotional responses. (www.rewireme.com/explorations/your-heart-and-stomach-may-be-smarter-than-you-think/)
@@nurulislam1284 neurones exist in all across the body.
I read the interpretation of Al Qurtubi about the first verse.. He stated: "It was said that the thought happens in the brain, as told by Abu Hanifa, and I (Al Qurtubi) do not agree with him!!
Thanks you Adam for this great and informative video. The true will prevail. 🤟
Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.14 Nov 2019
Until recently, modern science perceived the heart as merely a pump to regulate the flow of blood throughout our bodies. But across numerous cultures, the heart has historically been thought to have a much greater function that corresponds with our thoughts, emotions, and spirit.
When we speak or share feelings from a place of deep meaning or passion, we say we’re speaking from the heart or we’re trying to convey something that is heartfelt. This is no longer just an archaic maxim, but instead, one with factual backing. And science is now realizing that the heart and brain have more of a corollary, interactive relationship than previously thought … a relationship that has residual consequences on our bodies, and possibly even humanity as a whole.
@@mosadeqmauthoor2587 Yeah but the brain is still the organ that does most mental work and the heart does way less. The heart is involved in psychology a bit because for example if you get into a really dangerous and scary situation, then your brain releases a lot of adrenaline and sends signals to your heart to make your heart beat faster so that blood flows faster, so the adrenaline gets sent around the body quicker in the blood, but the brain still does most of the mental work and the cardiocentric hypothesis is plain wrong. I would also argue that "souls" are a misunderstanding of what human consciousnesses are, because consciousnesses are in brains but back when books like the bible and quran were written the writers who believed the cardiocentric hypothesis misunderstanding wrote stuff like that souls are in the hearts of people, and souls are said to be strongly associated with emotions and thinking and so on, but there is no evidence of souls existing and instead consciousnesses really do exist in the brains of people and how they work through electricity and brain chemicals in the brain has been studied a lot even though its not entirely understood yet.
It takes a Muslim mind to discover the scientific miracles in the Quran. The worst thing you can do to any child is to tell the child to memorize a book written by God-Any book! It's impedes the child's critical thinking when reading that book. Thankfully, the internet and people like you, are allowing Muslims to critically reexamine contradictions of this book.
I appreciate the comment. Thanks
@@AdamElmasriEnglish
What about the comments you delete?
Just found your channel. If you haven't already can you do videos on the history of Islam how the Quran was put together etc? Good stuff
Armour in 1991 discovered that the heart has it's own ' little brain' or intrinsic cardiac nervous system. This ' heart brain' is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are like neurons in the brain. Meaning that the heart has it own nervous system.
That has nothing to do with the heart being responsible for cognitive functioning like the Quran falsely claims!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish oh are you a doctor too? Who would know better, you or the one who created the heart?
@@AdamElmasriEnglish bro having arabic name does not make you scholar in arabic stop being an idiot Arabic is the most eloquent language and you know in Quran word Fouwad is also used it ALLAH SWT was describing different feelings of Human in QUran , you are my friend a liar and insecure Christian who did not read Quran properly , every language used this term listen to your heart and not mind , if we use your logic then every language will be in a problem ..
you need serious education dude
Some people follow religion blindly and think that they found the truth
Indeed!
you mean christianity?
Why can’t your logic define human consciousness 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂get the answer to above you will get answer of everything 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Allah hu Akbar ❤
I shared this video in my Facebook Account.
Sir, I think you should show us classical Islamic commentaries especially Tafsir al tabari about this mistakes. It will make your point more stronger.
i was thinking that when any language uses the word heart for a figure of speech it is doing so to artistically capture the emotion of the reader to speak to their feelings and is not trying to be stating a fact. I think the bible even uses the same language to but only to describe a deeper meaning other than intellect because the heart is what keeps us alive while the brain could be a vegetable while the heart is what's keeping the soul within the body. just my thought though
If we normalized 2+2=12 would it make sense for God to say 2+2=12 and not 2+2=4? In other words, why not correct mistakes instead of repeating the norm.
@@jamesbrown4364 your questions doesn’t make sense
@@ninjaked1265
You just didn't get it.
"heart" is more correct than "brain", because "heart" commonly/usually refers to brain + desire/intention, while "brain" refers to brain only/pure logic/clear mind, & clear mind can't be blind
Desire, intention, emotions, mind, consciousness, cognition etc are not abstract entities that exist independent of brain, these are all 'PRODUCTS OF THE BRAIN' themselves. Heart is only a pump. The "heart-brain" people talk about has nothing to do with cognition, emotion or behavior or any of the faculties of the the brain. The cardiac intrinsic neurons got dubbed "the little-brain of heart" because they regualte cardiac cycle, that's the only job they do. Even the person who coined "the little -brain of heart", Dr Armour NEVER ever claimed any of the things that muslims and pseudoscientists like Dr Rollin Mccraty claim he did. Even Dr Mccraty admitted that the heart CANNOT think or learn like the brain but says heart knows something "outside time and space". What a joke!!! A load of pseudoscience jargon. Does he have any evidence for this realm outside "time and space"? Maybe we need to borrow infinity stones from Marvel movies to know!!!!
Wrong. This is illogical and informal. Lack of rigorous definition.
@@Wabbelpaddel it's logic for informal/artistic/poetic language, look the word of "blind", do you think that sentence is using formal language? 🤦🤣
Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its "little brain" or "intrinsic cardiac nervous system." This "heart brain" is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system.
That doesn't mean that YOU can think and comprehend with your heart (as the Quran claims). Those recent findings only mean that the Heart is an intelligent organ. But you cannot think and understand using your heart!
By your point, the gastrointestinal system also has its own nervous system, the Enteric Nervous System, it doesn't mean it can store memories and consciousness like a brain do. How to explain when a person is declared brain dead, but has a beating heart. Can that person still be conscious by relying on his heart after the brain cease its function?
We are three-brained beings.
Instinctive brain.
Intellectual brain.
Emotional brain.
Each has it's own function and it's own memory.
There is zero thoughts occurring in the heart. The gut also has its own neuromotor loops, but a neuromotor loop is not a thought, just as hitting the reflexes in your knee doesn't test your thoughts.
@@toomanymarys7355 As I wrote before:
You can verify where he thoughts coming from in deep meditation (self-observation).
Scientists know nothing about this.
Adam Elmasri is not a scientist or in the medical field to tell you... The creator knows best.
The heart does have a "little brain". The heart does not contain brain cells. It contains neurons that comprise its own intrinsic system for regulating cardiac function. Further, neurons alone do not equal mind or consciousness. It takes the specialized organization of neurons in the brain to produce cognitive processes that we experience as the mind. A complex network of neurons can function like a computer chip. This is all a complex and fascinating system... the creator tells you more than 1400 years ago and now scientists are studying about them.
Are you a scientist or a doctor? Why criticize Adam for being in the same position?
Heart: The heart does not actually feel emotion, reason, or learn. It has a complex nervous system that responds to various stimuli. The Qur'an reflects the common belief of the sixth century, when people thought the heart was the organ responsible for the mind and emotions.
@@kyoungd How do you know?
People awaiting heart surgery can live without a heart (completely taken out) and replaced by an artificial pump.
Now tell me again about how the heart think and memorise!
@@sgmovies7864 Because of Science. Check out google or chatgpt. This is a well-known fact.
@@AdamElmasriEnglish Again, your flaw in understanding. The heart is considered the source of emotions, desire, and wisdom.
Quran 22:46
So have they not traveled through the earth and have hearts by which to reason and ears by which to hear?
Read pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31728781/
Without a body and a beating heart, a stomach that can rumble and lungs that fill, the brain would be adrift. We navigate the world by seeing, hearing and touching too. We make choices to stay alive. Perhaps the real magic of consciousness comes from the combinations - of heart and brain, of the outside world and inside world, as mysterious as it may yet be.
Allah - there is no deity except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer of [all] existence. Neither drowsiness overtakes Him nor sleep. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. Who is it that can intercede with Him except by His permission? He knows what is [presently] before them and what will be after them, and they encompass not a thing of His knowledge except for what He wills. His Kursi extends over the heavens and the earth, and their preservation tires Him not. And He is the Most High, the Most Great.
Holly quran 2:255
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
Mohamed god is satan
1. [Umdah al-Ahkam: Vol. 3, Hadith no. 460]
“Narrated by Anas Ibn Malik “I heard from the Apostle of Allah (Peace and blessing be upon him) that he said “Allah was Satan in the form of an angel that revealed to me the verses and his book the Quran and I’ am his prophet
رواه أنس ابن مالك “سمعت من رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم أنه” كان الله شيطان في شكل ملاك كشف لي الآيات وكتابه القرآن وأنا نبي
@Zain_Pakfreethinker Did you remember the time back in childhood when you first went to school and your teach said to you: open the book and read words after me. Did he/she not know that you know nothing and can't read?
in the case of revelation upon Muhammad, God is telling him oh illiterate the moment had come you need to start reading and teaching your nation what I/God will teach you. Be ready to read and then teach what is going to reveal oh prophet Muhammad.
@@shaun.august 🤣🤣🤣🤣
How well he made his own tafsir of the verses 😂😂😂😂
It’s not my own Tafsir… it is 5000 years of human history that you’re ignoring so you can save the Quran from a fatal error! And error that we believed in for 5000 years and the Quran simply repeated it!
Now you’re trying to claim that the Quran has a different Tafsir 😉😅
@@AdamElmasriEnglish
30 Days Ramadan Dry Fasting:
Indeed persistent and consistent good habits help us achieve a positive Muslim mindset.
Most importantly, on waking up, don't develop the bad habit of picking up your mobile. Connect and praise your Creator as Muhammad p.b.u.hù. taught us:
Alhamdulillah illazi ahyaana barda ma amaatana wa ilaihin nushuur/ The praise belongs to Allah who restored our lives after our death (sleep) and to Him we'll be gathered (for accountability).
Habits build you or destroy you. So start inculcate good habits gradually which will make you eventually replace the bad habits with good enhancing habits.
Developing good healthy habits and moral habits make you a more productive, positive and confident human being.
We have a tremendous advantage over the non-Muslims in that we know the answers for these 3 recurring questions within our souls:
* Where we come from?
* What is the purpose of our
existence here on earth?
* Where are we going after
We die?
The Merciful has given us, Muslims, the month of Ramadan which is great healing to us, both spiritually and physically.
With the non-Muslims so amazed how we can abstain from food and drink for so long hours is truly a blessing to be thankful for.
This is the Miracle of Ramadan to us Muslims. If the non-Muslims could see how Ramadan benefit us tremendously, they would sure attempt to deprive us of it by any means.
Good habits are our building Blocks!
@@mosadeqmauthoor2587
Every religion practises fasting and only muslims practise dry fasting.
Well dry fasting isn't that good for health.
Funny part is that guillible abduls think only them fast.
By any chance, meditation is a better practice than fasting and dry fasting is just wasting working hours
Why don't you look at your own books of Tafsir?
I have an uncle who had a heart transplant. Still inloved with her wife.
Very useful
So have they not traveled through the earth and have hearts by which to reason and ears by which to hear? For indeed, it is not eyes that are blinded, but blinded are the hearts which are within the breasts. [Quran, 22: 46]
So when u c ur crush why ur heart beats fast ? If brain response all emotions then why ur brain doesn't beats like heart..brain and heart works together..here Allah seal the heart so that they will not get the love of Allah when they go in extreme...
Cardiocentric hypothesis is where the idea came from,7th century myths ,, accept it and move on...your book is manmade full of errors of that time
The book of death: weighing your heart
Francesco Carellicorresponding author The classic exposition of judgement at death comes in the Book of Coming Forth by Day, in chapter/spell 30 and in chapter/spell 125, and the so-called weighing of the heart. To the Egyptians, the heart, or ib, rather than the brain, was the source of human wisdom and the centre of emotions and memory. Because of its apparent links with intellect, personality and memory, it was considered the most important of the internal organs. It could reveal the person's true character, even after death, so the belief went, and therefore the heart was left in the deceased's body during mummification. In the weighing of the heart rite, the heart of the deceased is weighed in the scale against the feather of the goddess Maat, who personifies order, truth, and what is right. Spell 30 was often inscribed on heart scarabs that were placed with the deceased. The spell appeals to the heart not to weigh down the balance or testify against the deceased to the keeper of the balance. Part of the spell gives instructions for making the heart scarab: ‘Make a scarab of nephrite adorned with gold and put within a man's breast, and perform for him the ceremony of opening the mouth, the scarab being anointed with myrrh.’.1 🤣🤣🤣🤣www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3960665/#:~:text=In%20Egyptian%20religion%2C%20the%20heart,weighing%20of%20the%20heart%20ceremony.
If a viscous dog runs towards you your heart will also beat fast. If a Dr examines you & tells you that you have a deadly disease, your heart will alao beat fast. Many things can make your heart beat fast but the reality is we dont do any thinking from our hearts, all our thinking & emotions gets processed by the brain. The quran is a book of fairytales.
I know the heart physically hurts when the love of your life leaves you. You physically feel a nice vibration sensations when you are excited. Physically feel it pounding when you are scared. Explain how these emotions ar connected to the heart?
In the same way, your gut crumbles when you’re stressed, or you could feel “butterflies” in your stomach when excited… that doesn’t mean you think with your gut or stomach!!! The heart is the same!.. the heart has nothing to do with cognitive functions!
@AdamElmasriEnglish what about how our brain receives signals from our body first to cause a reaction ? How does that work?
@@Orlandofinesse2tymes Study biology, YT is not the place to teach you science, it requires much time and effort.
As a muslim, i dont mind this sort of video. Although i strongly disagree, im glad you are overall respectful, this way we can get to the crux of the issue and not cause hatred. Your are welcome to make your points and we have our scholars/apologists who will counter them. If more people were respectful like you, us muslims will be more willing to tackle the points. Anyway peace, friend
So you admit that you muslims got a lots of points to tackle them.
But you already stated that your scholars will counter this mans massage from your own sources.
Good sign you are on this channel ,it means you are not really satisfy with your scholars,you searching for the Truth.May God open your eyes and your mind to this Truth
brother this world is based on struggle he Told us that also so struggle and doo good deeds and yeah as you mention human recently discover its brain not heart who things have feelings and much more so at that time nobody new and Allah Wasnt teaching us scince he is guiding us so he used that langage to make those people of that time understand nowing brain does the processing humans are still using heart instead of brains so please ambrace the meaning of quran other wise it will be too late time isn't stopping for nobody and yes Allah didnt wanted to teach us scince and biology we can learn it our selfs and we are doing it and he know this again m telling please understand the meaning behind dont let it to be too late for you. and if please update your research about heart too might help you rethink
Then you contradict a lot of Muslims claims over the Quranic scientific miracles then because of how the Quran got something before modern science did.
You can't be serious after the quran has been exposed so fully and blatantly to be a fraud from satan . It is you that needs to turn to CHRIST JESUS in sincere humility and ask HIM to save you and give you a new heart and mind full of joy . You've betrayed CHRIST but HE will forgive you if you'll just humble yourself and present yourself before HIS mercy . It's too late for mohamaax the child raper my friend but it's not too late for you . YET !
@@luigianchondo7241 the Quran is timeless meaning ppl of each generation can find it to b the clear truth
@@luigianchondo7241 Science is constantly being updated, it should be taken with a grain of salt especially when we, ourselves, are not doing the research. One of the qualities of Islam is that it is never changed. It wouldn't be surprising if we discover new things about the heart later down the line that we never knew about.
Alas, The speaker had gone out of mind. God never make a mistake. God uses the language of arabs to communicate to them and those arabs used/believe heart(qalb) to be a place of consciousness, thinking, wisdom. God figuratively using the word heart to mean mind as they arabs mean it. moreover in arabic lang, qalb is also used to be the center of consciousness. Divinity never makes misakes or invents words Himself but rather uses the existing language of people to talk to them including the figurative speech. God's intent is to put the message across to the people of that language using their own figurative speech effectively so that they can understand in the best way possible and that is how effective communication happens. God show you the path to light, dear bro. Fear your God as you are blaming Him for his mistake which actually is not a mistake but intentionally used figurative speech.
They followed what ancient Egyptians's beliefs. Everything is recorded in the heart, not in the brain.
تفهم العربية جيدا و تفهم التعبيرات المجازية جيدا و تفهم معنى تلك الآيات لكنك تطبق ما تقوله تلك الآيات فالعين ترى لكن القلب أعمى و مثلك بالضبط ما قال عنهم الله و تركناهم في ظلمات لا يبصرون و لم يقل لا يرون و أنت تعرف الفرق و شكرا
لا تحاولون ترقعون ايات الخريان الخسيس ، الاية سخيفة ولا يوجد فيها اي اعجاز ، هذا فقط في عقلك الجاف
تريد ان تقنعنا ان ألقرآن بكل اخطاءه وسخافته هو من خالق هذا الكون؟ 😂
Haven't ever read a hadith that says allah cleansed (physically) heart of prophet?
Nawjubillah.. Allah never can do any mistake. And the quarn is way way more better than science...I love allah and Quarn and Muhammad peace be upon him.❤❤❤
The heart has its own intelligence, and its neurological system and electromagnetic field are actually much larger and more powerful than the brain's.
You think with your heart or with your brain?
@@enisrebiai4206 But i research first before believing stupid stuffs like in this video .
@@webdev643 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'.
Similarly, he says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.
@@webdev643 Well, Muslims are blindly copy-pasting write-ups about the "heart-brain" from websites, articles, quora or fb posts and citing Dr J Andrew Armour's 1991 study on intrinsic cardiac neurons. They are doing this either because they haven't read Dr Armour's paper or don't have the qualification to understand the paper. This study proposes that the intrinsic cardiac neurons, dubbed the "little brain of the heart" plays a role in coordinating the cardiac cycle by working with the extrinsic nervous system of the heart. He also wrote a review of this article in 2007 and also in 2016. In NONE of his studies did he ever say that the 'heart can think, feel, sense or produce emotions, learn, store memory or knowledge'. NEVER EVEN ONCE did he say that the 'heart controls or regulates the cognitive, emotional, motor or sensory functions of the brain'. He didn't even say there are '40,000 neurons in the heart'. The only thing he said was the intrinsic cardiac neurons regulate the cardiac cycle i.e. the rate and rhythm of the heartbeat. This occurs through communication between intrinsic cardiac neurons and the CNS. In short Dr Armour DID NOT say any of the nonsense that people claim he said. So how did people come to believe in this heart-brain nonsense? Well, thanks to the charlatan 'new-age' writer Gregg Braden who misrepresented Dr Amour's legitimate work so that he could weave a 'loony tale' with his wild imagination. Braden unashamedly lied about Dr Amour's paper and profited from perpetuating his lie through his book. He is also the person who said there are 40,000 neurons in the heart. So where is the evidence for that? Well... Braden said so... There you go...
New Age is used to describe spiritual or non-scientific activities such as meditation, astrology, and alternative medicine, or people who are connected with such activities. A new-age writer is the last person to learn science from.
Similarly, we have Dr Rollin Mccraty, the director of Heart-Math Institute who is a proponent of the heart brain. He admits that the heart cannot think or store memory like the brain but he believes
the heart knows information 'outside the realm of time and space'. What a load of bogus!!! This is nothing but 'PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC JARGON'. What does he mean by 'outside time and space'? How did he come to this conclusion? Can he demonstrate the existence of this realm? Exactly what information is in this realm? Well, everything sounds like a 'Marvel movie plot'. Similarly, another pseudoscience buzz word is 'quantum'. They just throw in the word 'quantum' with nonsensical ideas thinking it will add credibility. Neither the proponents of such ideas nor the people who cite such ideas as evidence for their pre-scientific religious or political agendas know what is meant by pseudoscience buzz words like 'quantum' or 'holistic'. Treatment should be target specific and that's what evidence based medicine is aiming for by introducing 'target specific immunotherapy' for cancers and many rheumatological diseases. There is no need to treat healthy organs or the whole body for a disease of a specific pathophysiology unless it affects or spreads to other areas of the body. 'Holistic' treatment only harms the person. Even when evidences show the harmful effects or the inefficacy of these so called 'holistic' treatments, quacks and people alike ignore it.
Similarly, Heartmath institute says the heart produces em waves. First of all, the heart is not the only organ that produces em waves. All muscles have electric potential and can produce em waves. During rest, the heart has the highest intensity of em waves but during exercise skeletal muscles can produce em waves of intensity as high as the heart at rest. Here the pseudoscience is the heart-math's claim that the heart controls the brain and other parts of the body through em waves. Again this is just another figment of imagination and there is no evidence for this claim.
Now religions that oppose well-known facts like evolution are in dire need of scientific evidence to justify or cover up or even reinterpret the pre-scientific nonsense in their ancient texts. What an irony!!! This quest for scientific evidence is rampant among Muslims. Even Muslim doctors and Muslim researchers, especially from Islamic countries, are desperately trying to convince believers to believe in the pre-scientific notions of the Quran by publishing fabricated studies and poor-quality research. These studies are based on false premises, the study methodologies are problematic, the data is incoherent, data is wrongly interpreted leading to wrong conclusions. The same is true with the quacks trying to portray quackery( alternative systems) as scientific.
Well, the enteric nervous system(ENS) which contains 200-600 billion neurons compared to the 86 billion neurons of the brain, can work independently of the CNS. We have clear evidence that shows the ENS can trigger mood changes through serotonin and other neuropeptides that act on the brain. This is one of the pathophysiologies of 'Irritable Bowel Syndrome'. The ENS is even called the "Second Brain" or the "Gut-brain" even though it's not capable of cognition.
I wonder why muslims don't talk or care about the "gut-brain" which unlike the "heart-brain" is known to trigger mood changes and even cause IBS. Why don't they come up with claims that our gut can think, learn, feel, store memory etc like the brain? Oh, Wait!!! I got it... The Quran doesn't say we 'think with the gut'. It only says we 'think with the heart'. So one less problem for the Muslims.