Cubs’ Fan Exposes MAJOR Holes in Team's Roster

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 127

  • @chiefgangmusic
    @chiefgangmusic 4 дні тому +4

    My most worries start at the ownership level. We have Dodgers type money with a Pittsburgh Pirates type budget. And it’s been that way since the team was last purchased. We only won in 16’ bc the draft and trades mostly and none of those players were resigned.

  • @d.j.8059
    @d.j.8059 4 дні тому +2

    The Matthew Boyd signing is a perfect encapsulation of Jed "Smartest Man In The Room" Hoyer. Boyd is 34 years old and in the past four seasons he's made a total of 38 starts and pitched a total of about 190 innings.
    Why spend $14M on a pitcher like that when you could get Max Fried for about $11M more?

  • @Jknows22
    @Jknows22 5 днів тому +6

    This man spitting. Still alot of issues here & im not holding my breath for change

  • @RojoCube
    @RojoCube 5 днів тому +20

    My question is why the hell is Miles Mastrobuoni still part of the organization ?

  • @franciscosantiago9032
    @franciscosantiago9032 5 днів тому +3

    Man.. Turner still has very good serviceable numbers and he could very well be a cheap and effective backup.

  • @fbales
    @fbales 5 днів тому +3

    Sounds like the Cubs as always, except for the middle teens. Same old, same old. I’ve been a Cubs fan since the early 60’s, and have been disappointed over and over again. At least I lived to see a Cubs WS champion-my parents never did. I’ll always be rooting for the Cubs, but I’ll say this: Cubs fans deserve MUCH better from this organization. I don’t expect any great signings. You don’t get those without spending money. The Cubs have been poorly managed, period.

    • @Georgeglinos-bh8wy
      @Georgeglinos-bh8wy 3 дні тому +1

      Totally agree! Just turned 62 and 69 was my first REAL year as a Diehard. Man have we experienced some crap teams. Way too many. And now when we thought we had a real owner, we find out that there are other "silent", owners/investors. It's always something with our Cubs. As neither one of us know when our last day will be, this BS they keep doing just becomes more maddening! Put a damn winner on the field and stop bleeding us, and stringing us along. Otherwise, what's the point, other than lining owners pockets?

  • @RGabeDavis
    @RGabeDavis 4 дні тому +3

    Need a closer!!!

    • @gregthegroove
      @gregthegroove 4 дні тому

      I agree. But I wouldn’t hold my breath. There’s 100% chance Jed gives that job to start the season to Porter Hodge unless they pick up a stud closer. With how poor they’re crying, I highly doubt that.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      💯

  • @resmarted
    @resmarted 5 днів тому +1

    I traded for Gage Workman in OOTP and it worked out great, guy played excellent defense all over the infield, so it's going to work out in real life too. Also Pablo Aliendo was a great defensive catcher that I kept for a while so that's also an indisputable fact.

  • @BigLar56321
    @BigLar56321 4 дні тому +1

    What’s the deal with Justin Turner? Is he a possibility to obtain? Can he still play a serviceable third? Could he play at first if necessary? Does he have any hits left in his bat? Anyone else like him out there? Maybe ask Lance about this.

    • @Georgeglinos-bh8wy
      @Georgeglinos-bh8wy 3 дні тому

      I love Turner! Plays mostly first now, and DH. Still plays some 3rd but not a lot. Had 28 HR's in 23, but fell off with Toronto and Seattle last season. I think Wrigley could bring the beast out again. My concern is whether or not he could accept a bench role. I wish we could grab him, if for nothing else, his veteran presence

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому +1

      I think 1B for Turner. I think he’s a perfect fit

    • @Georgeglinos-bh8wy
      @Georgeglinos-bh8wy 2 дні тому

      @@SetupManCubs Kyle, what are your thoughts on wether or not he's open to accepting a bench role/platoon situation (if CC continues on that path with Busch)? He'd be such a great pick up for his ability to lead and be a positive voice in the clubhouse. Idk who besides the Mets, are looking for a veteran 1b/DH. Maybe Seattle, but he didn't have great numbers there in the 2nd half last season. He may just retire if he can't get a full time gig for somebody

  • @ThatOneStryker
    @ThatOneStryker 4 дні тому +1

    Holy crap, didn't realize how dire this is. GET SOME SIGNINGS DONE!!!

  • @bassslayer2566
    @bassslayer2566 4 дні тому

    Brandon Drury is an option, had a terrible year last year but was injured. He has pop and a track record with the bat and is versatile (2nd 3rd corner outfield) assuming he's healthy. Short term buy low deal

  • @Hunter-R-Hickey
    @Hunter-R-Hickey 4 дні тому +5

    If the front office does not acquire major league talent to strengthen the depth on the roster, then I have no problem going with the kids. Plus, at some point, the kids need to get some experience at the big-league level.

    • @d.j.8059
      @d.j.8059 4 дні тому

      I have no issue going with the kids either, but I also accept that doing that leads to a larger percentage chance they will miss the playoffs.

  • @davelutter396
    @davelutter396 5 днів тому +2

    Kyle, love the analysis... and here's the OTHER problem: Cubs 40-man is full at 40!!! Trades or DFA's have to happen before Jed can sign anyone

    • @benoitwaffle5439
      @benoitwaffle5439 5 днів тому +1

      I don't see that as a big deal. The Cubs have 23 pitchers on the 40 man. They are carrying a bunch of relief pitchers on the 40 who are far from integral. If they weren't on the 40, they'd be non-roster invitees with the Cubs or elsewhere. It just doesn't serve a purpose to drop them prematurely.

    • @its_Jaketendo
      @its_Jaketendo 5 днів тому

      I don't think we need to worry about the 40 man roster. We have guys like Mastrobuoni and Brujan who I think are likely DFA candidates. Also a lot of pitchers so we'll probably drop a few.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому +2

      Plenty of DFA-able guys on this roster

  • @miltonalbright1606
    @miltonalbright1606 4 дні тому +1

    Hay man this milt the old cubbie fan sine 1955 we need a stopper I mean a good one Milton

  • @d3mo1isher64
    @d3mo1isher64 4 дні тому

    I think injuries just means a rookie has to come and prove why the cubs system is considered one of the most loaded ones in the MLB.

  • @kevinholloman4055
    @kevinholloman4055 3 дні тому

    It wouldn't be the 1st time an organization penciled in a top prospect in a position. The more concerning subject is the bullpen.

  • @WithFearGaming
    @WithFearGaming 4 дні тому

    This further proves what I've been saying all off-season. We're overdoing how badly we need Starters. I'd rather spend the money on depth for our infield than for MORE depth to the Rotation.
    We're not gonna have 3 Starting Pitchers get injured at the same time.
    Steele
    Taillon
    Imanaga
    Boyd
    Assad
    Wicks
    Brown
    Killian
    Horton
    We can manage using a bad starter for a couple weeks if needed. If we lose someone on the infield for more than 2 weeks we are SUNK.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      I just don’t know if the org sees Brown, Kilian, and Horton as starters in ‘25. I think they are bullpen pieces (or spot starters/swingmen)

  • @Xxxomar880
    @Xxxomar880 5 днів тому +4

    Tom ricketts is Cheap 🥴

  • @NOBlinders
    @NOBlinders 4 дні тому

    I guess you mean Bote which I agree he has more power. What I mean is that Mastrobuoni
    was willing to get down and dirty to try to win. If you noticed he always has a dirty uniform.

  • @WB2028WCS
    @WB2028WCS 5 днів тому +1

    Depth depth depth! This is the least talked about part of this team. They are missing arms, BUT also INFIELD DEPTH!

  • @foundthingsifound
    @foundthingsifound 4 дні тому

    Please don't let Ricketts get away with dumping Belli and not using that money on the team

  • @mango8918
    @mango8918 4 дні тому +1

    Just as questionable as the Cubs depth chart is why doesn't The Setup Man, Kyle Stanley, have more Subscribers? Come-on Cubs fans, let's get behind this channel - it is quality analysis and interviews for FREE.

  • @davidpaine4880
    @davidpaine4880 4 дні тому

    If there’s a plan in place, it’s clearly a secret. Most of us have been focused on the Cubs adding a starter and then a good back end reliever. Then we talk about potential trades but when we look at the bench as you just did, it’s concerning. Hoyer is most likely waiting for the market to drop then he will pick up some cheap marginal talent to fill the bench.

  • @A_Gus20
    @A_Gus20 4 дні тому +1

    Was Thielbar not a major league relief move?

    • @Georgeglinos-bh8wy
      @Georgeglinos-bh8wy 3 дні тому

      No, he's a look and see acquisition. We'll see what he's got and make a decision. I doubt he sticks.

  • @arthurcaron9271
    @arthurcaron9271 5 днів тому +1

    I think Canerio will be traded for SP depth as a throw in. Workman will start against righties he’s gone to be just a lefty but that raw power could profile well since he had 31 homers last season

    • @Georgeglinos-bh8wy
      @Georgeglinos-bh8wy 3 дні тому

      I like the looks of Gage. But what he did was at AA. I hope if he makes the 26 man, his power, which BTW, just surfaced last season, transfers to MLB. Big jump to make

  • @Aetnaboy73
    @Aetnaboy73 5 днів тому +1

    Same story, different season.

  • @patricklee4316
    @patricklee4316 5 днів тому +2

    It doesn’t matter, they will be starting a rebuild on July 31st.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      Patrick would have started the rebuild in 2017 😂

    • @patricklee4316
      @patricklee4316 День тому

      @@SetupManCubs I mean you could have got some good prospects for Arrietia. Just saying lol

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  21 годину тому

      @ I have no idea if you are joking or serious. That’s how much I know you love trades 😂

  • @Heinrich4956
    @Heinrich4956 4 дні тому

    gabriel arias guardians for IF depth. 1b,2b,ss,3b.

  • @davidnunez385
    @davidnunez385 3 дні тому

    Even if Nico is out to start the year I think the Cubs should still start Shaw at 3B. He needs to get real comfortable there.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      Who would you have at 2B?

    • @davidnunez385
      @davidnunez385 2 дні тому

      @ me? Triantos. Cubs? Brujan probably. Hopefully that changes when they make a depth utility signing or something though.
      P.S. I’m a fan of the idea of signing Kim

  • @justinnoceda2115
    @justinnoceda2115 4 дні тому

    I'll be worried about it more if we don't sign roki and not sign anybody in January they need to strike very soon

  • @johnlenon8872
    @johnlenon8872 4 дні тому +1

    The Cubs have no real depth. True. Bellinger was your 4th outfielder and the starting 1B. Suzuki was a 5th OF. Busch could have been moved to 3rd base. We are talking logic here. Jed saying "we see Busch as a first baseman" is nice and all. Last year he "saw" Morel at 3b. How did that work out? Clearly if there was no concern for defense at 3b last year, why is there concern this year? If the team was owned by the Mets owner and the team had a GM who knew how to construct a lineup with depth and versatility, Belli would be on the team. I'd rather have Shaw and or Busch fighting for ABs and playing time vs being where the team is. As you correctly put it. The Cubs have no depth. If Busch is hurt who plays 1b? If Nico is hurt who moves to 2nd base if Shaw is at 3b? If Danby is hurt, and who cares what the chart shows, your next best SS is Nico, so you slide your best player to SS and find a 2b. If Shaw is at 3rd, you slide him to 2nd and if so, who goes to 3B? Bottom line, the depth is AAA dudes because Cody was not valued. Now before the season starts, the Cubs fans see what you see. There can be ZERO people getting hurt. And Shaw has to hit. But you are totally spot on. If Nico and Shaw are hurt in April, then Miles is your guy? Ugh.

    • @patricklee4316
      @patricklee4316 4 дні тому

      It could be an ugly year. It will get ugly by the trade deadline. It’s getting torn down!

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      💯

  • @mizer9510
    @mizer9510 2 дні тому

    Too many outfielders, not enough infielders. We still need another starter. 2 decent relievers, and a player that can play multiple positions on the infield.

  • @robhansen6370
    @robhansen6370 5 днів тому

    If Busch gets hurt, it may not be ideal, Kyle Tucker has a very small amount of experience at 1B. Move KT to first and play Caissie/Suzuki in RF. Just have Tucker play 1B in spring training 4 or 5 times, it's good to have at least a do-able fall back option.

    • @randylewis8628
      @randylewis8628 5 днів тому

      No need to move Tucker to first. They already have Amaya who can play there, Ian Happ can play there. Ballesteros is likely to be moved there. most think he is like schwarber and won't stick behind the plate. Workman can play first.

    • @resmarted
      @resmarted 5 днів тому

      I think Happ playing there with Suzuki PCA and Tucker in the OF is much more likely.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      I don’t think Tucker will be the guy. I think they still need to get a 1B backup

  • @Jknows22
    @Jknows22 5 днів тому +1

    I take heat on X for being pessimistic. But I see it as Just being realistic. What has this organization done to deserve optimistic takes? It's clear to me that they are not interested in a WS. So at least put a team on the feild worth routing for. They have failed to do that year after year. 2016 was a long time ago guys.. Another dreadful off-season of big rumors & very little actually being done. Even with Roki, there are still so many issues. No one is afraid to play the Chicago Cubs in 2025. Same bs playbook from the last few years. What happened to this being a retool? Or having long term success like LA? Where's Cade Horton? Shots a dawg but he's not having a year as good as last. Holes at 3rd & 1st are screaming. Miss me with this Monncada crap. Tuker can't save a mediocre offense either. Im tired boss

    • @patricklee4316
      @patricklee4316 4 дні тому +1

      Tommy only wants 83 wins like Jerry. We are getting another rebuild though, and it sadly needs to happen.

  • @lttraveler2458
    @lttraveler2458 5 днів тому

    I finally learned your name!!!!!!

  • @drewcorry5056
    @drewcorry5056 4 дні тому +1

    Absolutely this guy has said from day 1 the Cubs are not done adding

  • @ScottMeinschock
    @ScottMeinschock 4 дні тому +2

    I would rather play the kids then old washed up veterans. The team that we are trying to pass in the division plays mostly young guys. The current Cubs manager knows how to win and develop young players. The last few years we have signed veteran backups that suck both position players and bullpen arms. Relax!!!

    • @d.j.8059
      @d.j.8059 4 дні тому

      I'd rather have signed some good veterans instead. But since we're here: does that mean that you are OK with "playing the kids" and missing the playoffs again in 2025?

    • @ScottMeinschock
      @ScottMeinschock 3 дні тому +1

      @@d.j.8059 The Brewers play kids and win why can't we?

    • @d.j.8059
      @d.j.8059 2 дні тому

      @@ScottMeinschock The Brewers' 2024 pitching staff was league average in terms of age. Their position players were 3rd youngest in MLB, but a lot of that is 20-year-old Jackson Churios. The rest of their starters ranged from 24-31.
      Players playing in their first year in MLB have a wider range out outcomes for their performance level than established Major Leaguers. All I'm saying is that, sure, we can make Matt Shaw the full-time 3B next season, but don't be shocked if he's hitting .300, .200, or anything in between come July. Whereas someone like, say, Alex Bregman, is very likely to be a .260-.270 hitter next year, based on track record.

  • @babagaming7867
    @babagaming7867 5 днів тому

    Call it out at the convention

  • @Xxxomar880
    @Xxxomar880 5 днів тому

    I thought cubs going to building a 90 team

  • @calanblack2679
    @calanblack2679 5 днів тому +2

    Workman was great at 3b at college and brujan reminds me of Emilio Bonifácio

  • @sbcburgos2300
    @sbcburgos2300 4 дні тому

    Dude, stop being so damn negative. James Triantos is a different cat, because he is mostly a contact guy. He is not a high K hitter, so his learning curve at the MLB level should not be as difficult as it was for Mervis or others.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      I’m being negative? Because I don’t think a minor leaguer won’t be a hero right out of the gate?

  • @michaelbingham6907
    @michaelbingham6907 17 годин тому

    Sign Bauer nowadays!

  • @babagaming7867
    @babagaming7867 5 днів тому +1

    Connor Joe was a dawg for the Albuquerque Isotopes. Id take him as Tachman 2.0, but only because Tauchman was also an Isotope

  • @Jknows22
    @Jknows22 5 днів тому

    Like Beli, Tuker can't save a mediocre offense. They keep running back the same exact thing & alot fans eat it up. It's a shame that small market teams are making bigger & better moves than the Cubs. The division is up for grabs. WHAT ARE THEY WAITING FOR

    • @randylewis8628
      @randylewis8628 5 днів тому

      Belli couldn't because he wasn't very good.

    • @kyles2232
      @kyles2232 5 днів тому

      ​@@randylewis8628You can add any player you want to our line up instead of Tucker or belli and it still does not make our team better than la not even close.

    • @Jknows22
      @Jknows22 5 днів тому +2

      @randylewis8628 Beli was the most clutch bat on this team. Surround him with killers like NY just did, & he will flourish. 1 bat ain't fixing all these problems is the point

    • @randylewis8628
      @randylewis8628 2 дні тому

      @@Jknows22 he has the same guys around him the last 2 years. Actually better guys this past year and he regressed. He's had 1 good season in the last 4 years. He's washed

    • @randylewis8628
      @randylewis8628 2 дні тому

      @@Jknows22 Yankees lineup is mid outside of Judge.

  • @NOBlinders
    @NOBlinders 5 днів тому +1

    Wrong on Mastrobuoni he is a working man player.

  • @mizer9510
    @mizer9510 2 дні тому

    Who's the Cubs fan?

  • @born2run995
    @born2run995 5 днів тому

    Justin Turner to backup 3B and 1B

  • @jgphantombeats
    @jgphantombeats 5 днів тому

    Look at how much Jackson Holliday struggled and our prospects aren't even rated as high as he was

  • @glennsheffield3603
    @glennsheffield3603 4 дні тому

    Put the kids in this team is not built to win anyways

    • @patricklee4316
      @patricklee4316 4 дні тому

      @@glennsheffield3603 you are correct and they are about to rebuild again. So why not play the kids?

  • @jamespullos8027
    @jamespullos8027 5 днів тому +2

    Jed traded for Kyle Tucker, What else do you want 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @patricklee4316
      @patricklee4316 5 днів тому +1

      And Kyle Tucker will be used for the rebuild

    • @rongbips024
      @rongbips024 5 днів тому

      Did you watch the video 🤡

    • @Aetnaboy73
      @Aetnaboy73 5 днів тому +1

      Yep, he's single handedly gonna get us to the postseason. 🤣🤣🤣

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому +1

      Takes more than one player, brotha

  • @kyles2232
    @kyles2232 5 днів тому

    Mediocre team with zero shot of a championship. That's realistic...

  • @jeremysmith8033
    @jeremysmith8033 4 дні тому

    I will wait until spring training before I start complaining about the roster. The offseason is not over yet. No reason to worry about the roster until spring training begins

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      Yes, and I did say that. But that’s a lot of holes for 30ish days out

    • @jeremysmith8033
      @jeremysmith8033 2 дні тому

      @SetupManCubs not a ton of holes. Need 1 bullpen arm. Maybe another starter in a trade and maybe somebody who can play 1st base to help Busch. Shaw and Workman can handle 3rd. Or Brujan is a possibility.
      Team isn't that far off and there's alot of offseason left

  • @michaelplowman8674
    @michaelplowman8674 5 днів тому

    Just about every team team is in a situation like this. Teams only have 13 position spots typically on the 26 man. Of the 5 bench spots, one is a DH/OF, one C, OF, and then 2 IF. It's great if you have 4 guys who can play 5 different positions competently but those guys don't come along very much.
    I'm still thinking they make a big trade to bring in a TOR starter and hopefully a closer with it and then sign Bregman or Kim for 3B and run with Shaw at 2B.

    • @gregthegroove
      @gregthegroove 4 дні тому

      Ask the Dodgers about their depth. Ask them about how they lost all their pitching arms essentially and still won a trophy. Their bench/depth costs more than other teams starters. We are fans of a cheap ridiculous out of touch unrealistic front office baseball org. I’m just glad I have a secondary team I follow closely as a kid like the NYY because I live vicariously through them.

    • @michaelplowman8674
      @michaelplowman8674 4 дні тому

      @@gregthegroove Which is why I said "just about." And for all that spending, the Dodgers have 1 more title in the past 25 years than the Cubs have. Their manager would have been fired if they didn't win all last year even with all the injuries because they have such high expectations. I will admit I want the Cubs to spend like the CBT is just an annoyance same as the Dodgers, but most people forget the Dodgers spent the better part of 15 years building a base that turned them into the place where FA will take less for the chance to win. The Cubs would have to continue on their path for another decade for that.
      And I'll keep saying, fans only complain about a lack of spending when it's really a lack of winning they are upset about.

    • @d.j.8059
      @d.j.8059 4 дні тому

      If *just about" every team is in a similar position, why are there 5 teams in the NL clearly better than the Cubs?
      Also, the Cubs bring in more revenue than "just about" every team. Saying "yeah, but other teams have their problems too" is weak sauce.

    • @michaelplowman8674
      @michaelplowman8674 4 дні тому

      @@d.j.8059 No, it's accepting reality and that throwing money at the problem isn't the solution. Want proof? How well did it work for the Mets? Yes, they made the NLCS last year, and it wasn't because of any big contract they signed. And 5 teams better? I'll grant the Dodgers, Braves, and Phillies. Now make the argument for whichever you say are the other 2. The Cubs have players who were top 10 in WRC+ at 1B, 2B, LF, RF, and DH. They are expected to get right at league average production at the other 4 spots.
      They have holes that need addressing. I'd be calling the Twins and Red Sox and offering a package of Nico, Horton, Alcantara, Wick and Birdsell for Lopez and Duran. Nico would go to Boston, who would send 2 prospects (Arias and Sandlin) to Minny. Everybody wins.
      Cubs then sign Bregman for 3B (adding a top 10 WRC+ for the one lost in Nico) and roll with Shaw at 2B, who should have a better chance at being above average at 2B versus 3B. Cubs might still only be the 4th best team in the NL, but it's about getting to the dance and then seeing where the music takes you.

    • @d.j.8059
      @d.j.8059 4 дні тому

      @michaelplowman8674 Dodgers, Padres, Mets, Braves and Phillies are all better than the Cubs right now.
      I love how "yes, the Mets made the NLCS, but..." is part of your argument. Weak. Sauce.

  • @jasonvalencia8565
    @jasonvalencia8565 4 дні тому +1

    I don't think it's an 80 win team. Regression coming for Imanaga. Questions up the middle. RP still a joke

    • @patricklee4316
      @patricklee4316 4 дні тому

      @@jasonvalencia8565 you aren’t wrong. You are going to see Tucker, Steele and Suzuki traded at the deadline. This team will be starting another rebuild

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  2 дні тому

      Respectfully disagree. It would take a LOT of injuries for this not to be an 80 win team. But that’s not the goal. Gotta get to 90+

  • @carloschristanio4709
    @carloschristanio4709 День тому

    Dont worry guys, wrigley will still be filled and the beer will flow like a river.

    • @SetupManCubs
      @SetupManCubs  21 годину тому

      Aspen… where the beer flows like wine