Can Windows XP Run Minecraft 1 21?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- Ever wondered what happens when you mix cutting-edge gaming with some serious nostalgia? In this video, I take on the ultimate tech challenge: getting Minecraft 1.21 running on the ancient Windows XP!
Watch as I dive deep into compatibility issues, creative problem-solving, and maybe a bit of frustration. Will the blocky world of Minecraft thrive on this vintage OS, or will it be a complete meltdown? Tune in to find out and enjoy the ride through tech history!
If you ever need help or want a place to chill consider joining my Discord!
/ discord
For more gaming content, you can find me on Twitch!
/ justchrispro
Music used in this video:
0.00 - 1.38 - Addicted - VYEN
1.38 - 5.21 - Adventures - A Himitsu
5.21 - 9.06 - Albatros v2 - Computer Music All-Stars
9.06 - 15.26 - Abstract Corporate - Gribsound
15.26 - 18.33 - Alexandria - JAK
18.33 - 21.24 - Alter - Hunter Milo
21.24 - 23.48 - Amazilia Luciae - SKIRK
23.48 - 26.02 - Andromeda - Scandinavianz - freetouse.com/...
26.02 - 28.52 - A Promise - Niya
28.52 - 31.51 - Anywhere - Ikson
31.51 - 34.02 - Apollo - Patrick Patrikios
34.02 - 36.57 - Arise - SKIRK
36.57 - 39.46 - Around the Sea - Scandinavianz - freetouse.com/...
39.46 - 43.34 - Attraction - Hyaku
43.34 - End - Fearless (ChrisPro Mix)
Apologies all for the audio mess from 36:56 - 39:52.
Apparently the royalty free song I used in this portion of the video had since been made not royalty free.
Edit: I sorted it out with the copyright holder, audio is restored!
it felt pretty nice man! Reminded of the good old days of windows xp and shitty microphones Haha :)
The audio mess isn't that big of a deal for me - the audio quality I deliver is prone to be at least as bad as what you have in that portion you mentioned. Getting Minecraft 1.12 running on Windows XP... yeah, but I saw you haven't attempted anything between 1.12 and 1.19. If you don't want to test that out, I could try to make a video about Minecraft on Windows XP myself, but unfortunately, I'm currently suffering from a slight RAM downgrade compared to my old computer (yes, I've recently switched from something with 12 GB DDR3 RAM to something with 8 GB DDR4 RAM, but the CPU of the new one is better), which shouldn't affect how much RAM I would assign to XP anyway (My default was 3 GB for 32-bit and 4 GB for 64-bit on my old computer).
i just thought you were running xp off an authentic computer and you switched the mic
Guess they really did train their AIs with a whole bunch of muffled voices XDDDDDD
it sounds like you recorded the audio on the vm lmao
Former Java developer here!
The reason why it works 5% of the time is because it was written in Java.
Hope that helps!
I don't think this is funny but it is
Lmao
Yup! C++ for the win ✌🏻😭
Top tier comment right here
I scrolled down to make sure this was written here.
When I first played Minecraft in 2010 I was actually using Windows XP and running it on a GTX 260, crazy how it's changed so much that you couldn't even conceive using that setup anymore
I was playing it from late 2010 or the very start of 2011 and Beta, and until late in 2011, when I got my first computer, I was playing on school and library computers. Pentium 4s with Windows XP and likely not more than a gig of RAM.
Well, they saw PCs were getting better and decided to break compatibility to use the extra resources.
And hey, at least in terms of breaking old OSes, I get it! How many people play on WIndows XP because that's genuinely their best option?
For me the oldest I've seen is someone win Windows 7.
But when it comes to needing more RAM and a better CPU, I can no longer forgive it.
After all, mods have been able to optimize so many tiny things, and combining all these optimizations give us *huge* gains.
So if Mojang optimized better then it could at least work on older PCs.
I was playing it on XP with intel built in graphics at 15 FPS. Mostly played on superflat worlds.
@@AgentM124 Superflat didn't exist when I started playing.
Same here for me, except it was 2011 on a GT220.
The “Tiny” View Distance fog has always been nostalgic to me since lol
The fact it got SOOOOOOOO close is still honestly shocking and also I'm not surprised that 1.12 works semi fine with XP it's a known fact that after 1.12 Minecraft's performance took an absolute noise dive so that might also have something to do with it not wanting to be playable lol.
probably because of things introduced in 1.13 like the flattening
Minecraft java's performance is a whole lot better in 1.21. Without optifine or sodium, my fps never drops below 100 fps. Its very stable now
@@MrPlazma1.21 is not optimized
1.12 is very good
to be honest on my (pretty old, i5-3570k, novideo 660ti) pc, running linux, 1.21 runs way better than 1.12 or even 1.8
but then again my even older pc(core duo, intel gma 950), (also linux) it would run 1.16 at ~40-50fps, 1.12 at ~50-60fps, and 1.17 at ~5fps, because of having to render in cpu
ig for modernish systems it's better optimalized, whereas for old systems not
I understand that it wont run well on older PCs but if you have at least a 6 core cpu, and 16 gigs of ram, 1.21 runs smoothly. Im not here to argue, its just what my benchmarks show. If you prefer 1.12 thats okay, its a great version.
MultiMC is what Prism Launcher is originally based of off, but MultiMC still supports 32bit and is based on older version of QT and in theory should support everything up from Windows 2000, so with the Extended Kernel it should be working.
There's also a community build of Latest Java 22 and older for Windows XP both 32 and 64bit and I am able to run Minecraft 1.20.1 on Windows XP, I've already done it.
Hey, I would like to ask about how I can get my hands on the Java 22 community build for xp
why are you even on xp lmao
Yeah, we want to know where that java version is@@samarthdhiman7026
No, Prism is based on PolyMC which is based on MultiMC
@@My_Old_YT_Account Some context: -There was a split in the community due to back and worth arguing between developers, so some devs from PolyMC split off to form Prism!-
Edit: Corrected reply (after reading the reply below, and looking up what happened): The project lead kicked all the devs from PolyMC over politics. These devs then forked it and created Prism!
PolyMC is still an usable launcher. Some people worried the project lead would infect it with malware, but that obviously hasn't happened.
honestly enjoyed this a lot, long form of just showing off the brainstorming and hurdles of making stuff like this work is genuinely cool to see, ez sub
same, really enjoyed it
Honestly the way I would troubleshoot problems cause I'm stupid so I just Google everything and add Reddit to the end
Another channel I enjoy who does a lot of tech stuff like that is MichaelMJD. His videos tend to be a bit more chaotic tho... 😅
That startup sound gave me the chills , haven't heard it in a long while...
Fr
you can add it to windows 10, the sound options thingy is still available and working from the xp era
@@croozerdogcan you do it for Windows 11?
@@croozerdogreplying so I can see what's your answer if it can still be in windows 11.
u must be 30 years old 🫣
39:22 bro speaks the villager language
JAJAJAJAAJA
XD
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
Love how because there was so many memes made out of the Windows XP sound effects, I always thought he edited in those sounds.
Getting an x64 version of XP would have alleviated a lot of this...
P.S. I watched the whole video...
I think he was
Or getting a 32 bit version of either Prism or MultiMC.
Dude doesn't know how to read, he's downloading a 64 bit launcher and he's surprized it doesn't work.
It's pretty easy to verify if your executable is 64bit or 32bit, just open it with an hex editor and look at the PE signature, if you see 0x8664 it's 64bit, if you see 0x014c it's 32bit. You can even do this with notepad instead of hex editor but it's kinda cringe...
@@GumSkyloard Yeah. Dude was going through a ton of sus launchers instead of just trying a well known and liked one.
@@decom707 Not to mention he forgot to install the certificate update, which would've taken 5 mins at most.
Nice to watch someone who actually knows how to research things and problem solve haha. Nice work!
One tip to fix the certificate problems is to use Legacy Update. Legacy Update has an option to update the expired root certificates to newer ones.
yeah but One Core Api doesn't like that (the machine will be unbootable)
@@MickmickWashesThings_Official wait is that why I BSOD after installing OCAPI? LegacyUpdate?
@@MickmickWashesThings_Official It's unfortunate OneCoreAPI is so unstable given it's otherwise a fantastic idea. I personally don't use it on my XPx64 Workstation as a result.
@@alexisverity47 yep
Ryzen 9 7900X3D with 4gb is insane
most versions of XP are 32-bit only, so they can't access more than 4 GB
@@CocoTheMii the physical address extension in question (he got 16gb detected later in the video):
@@chlorobyte that's on me then, admittedly i didn't watch the whole thing
he updated to x64 before doing that.
a x32 OS cant detect more than 4gb of rams. @@chlorobyte
@@reineKenpachi look up physical address extension which allows addressing up to 64 GB of physical ram
If you did not understand, at 27:51 , you tried to use sodium, witch heavely modifies the way minecraft renders witch depends on opengl (minecraft default rendering api), with the vulkan mod, witch itself replaces and heavely modifies minecraft rendering engine to work with the vulkan rendering api
What's funny about that timestamp is that the Fabric Loader was actually unchecked, so none of these mods would have loaded successfully anyway.
And Vulkan support was only added in Windows 10 if I remember correctly.
@@Butterscotch_96 windows 7
@@ChrisProAUThe reason that MultiMC looks like Prisim is because Prisim is based on the now compromised PolyMC thats based on MultiMC. The devs of PolyMC got kicked out and started PrisimLauncher
Sodium don't use vulkan
ALL RISE FOR THE NATIONAL ANTHEM 0:01
🫡
Lol you're talking about the Windows XP startup you are the best 😂😂😂😂
@@Linux-Minecraft-life😂😂
yes sir
0:00 u mean
You might've just got me addicted to whatever kind of video type this is. Because this is really entertaining to see how far an older operating system can get
oh that update conversion you talked about at the end is pretty cool. Did not think it was possible to do that
I'd suggest checking out danooct1 then. His content is definitely different then this but he uses user-made and non-user-made malware against virtual machines running windows versions as far back as Win95-98.
Been a long time watcher of him so if you do stop by, I'd suggest watching his most popular videos first!
dude he was running sodium with fabric unchecked LMAO.. great vid btw
honestly I don't know what any of that means so I feel him
So nostalgic lol. I remember my old XP laptop my great-grandmother got me. I was trying to run early minecraft 1.7 on there and all I could manage to play was some mineplex drawing mini-game and SOME hunger games maps. Great video!
This video made me realize that when I started playing Minecraft in 2011 i was still on Windows XP
15:30 it works because you have "Physical Address Extension" which allows
OS to utilize more ram
lol, this is just the "lets go gambling, aw dangit, aw dangit, aw dangit" meme
6:48 funny thing is, the number is probably higher now, you just don't get to see where it's running.
Android runs java, and it's very popular outside the US (idk how you guys deal with apple, their products suck), lots of different programs use java, backend services, interfaces on devices like car panels, fridges, etc, may use Java, and Minecraft java edition still runs java, you just download the executable with Minecraft now, you don't need to install it manually.
Wait, even without a launcher like Pojav?
@@ThEspectrum20 Idk what's Pojav, but unless they developed Minecraft again from scratch, yes, it still uses java in some capacity.
Love these sorts of vids and experiments!! Definitely earned a place in my playlist
this is really underrated, nice video!
37:43 I hope with your report being sent Microsoft finally addresses this issue... We need a Windows XP patch ASAP.
The mouse issues can be fixed in VMware’s preferences, in the Mouse catergory
Java 8 can support up to 1.16
And 3D acceleration could fix the OpenGL issues.
I thought I was watching someone with 100k + subs, this was quality! Subscribed
This is a good video! One suggestion I have is at around ~9:13, when you open up the properties for ATLauncher, there was a little message that said something of the sorts that the file may have come from another computer and might be blocked, and you had an option to unblock the launcher. Maybe that could've dome something?
it would not. the extended kernel he used has a list of compatible apps, he DID NOT READ IT.
@@thecakelover4578 does that mean only the tested apps are supported? Surely there's more that aren't listed, yes?
@@koigoi yes, but don't quite expect most stuff to work, they probably won't
reddit consulting simulator 2024 (good video i enjoyed it)
aw man, the titan launcher gave me so much nostalgia. I used to use that launcher all the time and the og titanmc server was so fun. i miss the old days of minecraft.
nice video, I loved it! It's unfortunate that it doesn't run on 1.21, but I'm impressed that you got it running at all.
dude your dedication is incredible
Some info:
Minecraft until 1.16 requires Java 8, 1.17 requires Java 16, 1.18-1.20.6 requires Java 17, and 1.21+ requires Java 21.
Minecraft 1.13 made the switch from using LWJGL 2 to using LWJGL 3, which updated a lot of the system libraries the game uses. This is probably why 1.12 worked for you. I think the reason why modern versions crash might not actually be OpenGL, since you need OpenGL to start Minecraft at all, but rather because of the mouse capture. I don't think there's anything else that would require interfacing with the kernel, and it seems like you got exactly to the point where the game would capture the mouse. Since LWJGL2 probably uses a much older version of GLFW (the windowing library, it would handle mouse capture), that's why 1.12 worked fine (-ish, the weird mouse movement is just because of it being in a VM).
Also you should have tried 1.16.5 because afaik it only requires OpenGL 2.1 whereas 1.17 switched to OpenGL 3.2. Though since you got 1.21 to launch this probably isn't it.
There are mods for 1.17+ that change the OpenGL version back to 2.1 and it apparently works ok
1.16.5 is the last version that officially supports XP. Probably requires a compatible graphics card, which I had a GT 730 and worked just fine.
2:50 that restart was instant what the heck
Not the brightest bulb, are ya?
@@SwitchedUp08 What do you mean?
The restart was cut and made shorter by the editor
he meant that you are slow , and don't even know that something called editing exists@@aqwek
@@youcefdz5598 The time was exactly the same. It was 7:14, and then after it restarted it was still 7:14. I'm not slow. I do video editing as a hobby.
I didn't have an attempt to run 1.21 on XP, but I found an interesting behavior where 32-bit distributions of Java don't like being given too much memory (a bit more than 1GB) for some reason, which might explain the crash right before entering the game. With several memory optimization mods (FerriteCore, ModernFix...) I could get into the game on 32-bit Java, of course with moderate memory alloc (~400MB). Hope this helps.
Okay. I really love this video. I lovw how you didn't just cut the parts where you had to research and skip. I learned SOOOOO MUCH from this video. You are a legend. Permanent Subcriber!!!!!!!
Honestly it’s impressive how you got the 1.21 MENU on Windows XP.
First 1.16 on 98 now 1.21 on XP. I would imagine being on an NT Kernel not to mention much extended GPU support like the GTX 960, this would be A LOT EASIER. Windiws XP's OpenGL drivers are usually determined by the the graphics driver making OpenGL 3.2 absolutely available to have Minecraft run. Assuming Mojang doesn't yet again up minimum OpenGL requirements since 1.17.
you should include the dot between 1 and 21 in the video title
PrismLauncher is a fork of MultiMC
modern minecraft requieres at least 2GB of allocated ram to just the game
wam
Nope, i have done it with 1gb
If you use optimisation mods such as ModernFix and FerriteCore and others, you can go way lower
My personal best is 176mb on 1.20.1
to just the game? just is not a verb, you are under arrest by the grammar police
@@CrappyProductionsOfficial Probably a language barrier
Now I don't play Minecraft often, and I'm not a windows user, but from how I understand java, it runs in a JVM (Java Virtual Machine). Which means it creates a mini "OS" inside your computer so that it can run in its own environment.
That being said, so long as you can get the JDK working (Java 21, 22 64 bit), then there should be no worries with getting Minecraft to work.
Now I know there's the launcher which probably isn't written in Java, and I also didn't watch more than 5% of the video. But tell me where I'm wrong or what I'm missing.
0:01 That windows startup music is so nostalgic
I miss that old computer
Windows sounds are nostalgic 😢
Still remember playing Minecraft 1.5.2 on a Sony Vaio desktop that ran windows xp. That desktop is long gone, but I still have the hard drive
this was awesome to watch! you got so far. and congrats on the views!
5:36 you can literally just search up the dll and download it and place it in that x minecraft launcher folder instead of doing all that.
Awesome video man I enjoyed every second
can't imagine the time this must have taken. getting to the 1.21 menu was already amazing enough
That could have taken waaay less time if he acrually knew what to do before recording
@@nexonnera.k.a.8796 this is not a tutorial so no
Frankly it's impressive that you even got into the main menu on 1.21 on XP. That's crazy that it's even possible.
Minecraft 1.21 uses JRE/JDK 21, and can work with newer versions, but doesnt always. Mods also lower the chances of it working on other versions.
If you want to install every java version you would need for minecraft, install
JDK/JRE 21, JDK/JRE 17, and JDK/JRE 8
It's insane that this is still possible
Really cool video, great job
0:01 THATS INSANE!!! 🤯🤯🤯
Man I haven’t heard that sound in forever 😭
not as insane as your dad leaving you
"im 8 year old" ahh comment @@user-ci4nw4ok3f
@@user-ci4nw4ok3fless insane than your parents not loving you
@user-ci4nw4ok3f tbh u would probably be better off if your dad left you 😂
saw this on my feed happy to see that it is getting the attention that it should the editing is subtle but effective voice crack around 35:00 wouldve liked to see if multiplayer is possible with the essential mod this is relatable to me when i had a windows 7 laptop and upgraded to windows 10 to get minecraft working ended up losing a lot of files but got it to work the performance that i have gotten was not worth it id say just love to see windows xp as always was the first pc os i got to play with i have never seen it run this well before my pc was so trashy i am happy to see xp run this smoothly
0:01 Windows XP is goat
I’m getting sick of these comments why did UA-cam start floating these to the top
I’m getting sick of these comments why did UA-cam start floating these to the top 0:01
what
Launcherfenix is a windowsxp compatible launcher, is even compatible with ubuntu java sdk, its been made to be the most compatible launcher, if you can install java 5 or above you can use it, doesn't use windows dlls or anything only java
THERE'S NO WAY IS THIS A COINCIDENCE? I WAS RECENTLY TRYING TO MAKE MINECRAFT WORK ON MY WINDOWS XP VM AND NOW HERE'S THIS!
Damn the dedication great video :D
Thank you i couldn't ever play minecraft because of my windows xp operation system. Now i can play minecraft.
Just buy a new pc or upgrade to Windows 7 lol
are you still on windows XP?
Really loved this form of videos relaxing and really fun to watch diff need more
0:01 window startup so nostalgic
You mean at 0:00
@@midorikyiota4435it wouldn't work if 0:00
@@Antimer-tv8sd oh
"Oh cool video... let me just watch this really quic- OH MY GOODNESS 40 MINUTES"
Thank god I'm into that
There is another way you can run more than 4 GB of RAM under Windows XP. It's called PAE.
It's a way you can address up to 128GB under 32 bit OSes as it assigns programs its own 4GB memory space while the Windows kernel keeps everything working.
Originally only for windows server 2003 there's a patch to apply it to regular XP and it works mostly.
I know you're using a VM but there was still something hilarious about hearing you unironically say "let me go install more RAM"
W video rip xbox 360 dashboard
Hold f to show respect
@@blaketakesontheworld4491 fffffffffff
@@blaketakesontheworld4491ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff
0:00 yet the best startup sound ever.
I like how you tried to enable mods without fabric enabled…
Uh, also the vulkan mod isn’t compatible with pretty much every single other mod. ESPECIALLY sodium
Edit: also not having a gpu driver
Yep I noticed that when editing, figured I'd leave it in, I discover my mistake a bit later :P
Also XP doesn't even have Vulkan support
the fact that you managed to get onto the main menu is impressive!
Good!
On my windows, if I decrease the allocated ram, it fix the error "vm could not reserve ... object heap"
Can’t believe I was locked in watching a guy trying to get Minecraft working on windows XP for 40 mins. Great video 👍
The funny thing is you called it Windows XP 64 bit edition, but you're on x64 edition. 64-bit edition was for an entirely different architecture, the Itanium architecture. Its stupid, I know, but there is a difference. x64 is the x86 architecture with 64 bit additions, whereas the itanium was a true 64 bit processor that failed.
20:47 That's because prism launcher is a fork of polyMC by the entirety of the dev team minus the leader of that project, which was a fork of MultiMC
intel64 vs amd64
This is similar to what running any game was like when I was a kid, except we didn't have the internet
PRISM LAUNCHER YOU ARE GOATED
PolyMC is better ngl
Seeing this entire video makes me remember when I used to have a PC with Windows XP. Brings a lot of memories back, and makes me wish we could still have some type of "Windows XP look" on the new systems (if it's even possible with the big customization it has nowadays).
ryzen 9 7900x3d in a windows XP OS and 4GB ram makes me want to smash my Monitor into pieces
the virtual machine in question:
funny thing is, that configuration is literally not even possible - the smallest DDR5 sticks are 8GB
@@chlorobyte It's a Virtual Machine, he didn't give all the RAM he has to the VM, he only gave a small amount to it.
I would love for him to test this on a real Windows XP machine, virtual machine is a bit of cheating...
@@YannBOYERDev i agree
Hey, skip here
I tried doing the same thing, the newest version you can run with OneCore is 1.17. To make it join worlds and servers you need to pass an argument to force it to use IPv4, otherwise it never gets past 100% and multiplayer connections fail.
1.18 and newer have some internal change that prevents them from working, because older versions work fine on the newest java versions.
There are mods to make the new versions use OpenGL 2, but I couldn't get that to work in VMware so I had to use software rendering as well.
There is also a mod called Not So New which forces new versions to run on Java 8, and someone managed to get it to work. I was too tired to try it though.
Nice vid, it was fun to see someone else take a crack at it!
Why did you try to run Minecraft without acceleration for the entire video, then enable it and were surprised that 1.12 works? 1.21 might as well work with that enabled. Pointless video.
This video is very enjoyable both to listen and watch. Good quality mic! background music, very cool!
Watching someone troubleshoot in windows XP is surprisingly entertaining
Player87 is writing. Nice video man, minecraft is really nice to look at.
most underrated video ever, 100th like btw
Dude, I run Minecraft with mods relatively well (30 fps) on Windows 7 32 bits with Celeron and Geforce GT 1400 and I'm very happy.
As a fellow win 7 user I feel you. Why 32bit thought
@@plushrei5926 If I change it, won't it get slower?
@@bubobato no, probably the opposite. Only having 4gb of ram available is horrifying ngl
I don't know what it is but your voice is so soothing.
tittle: can windows xp run minecraft 1.21?
video ending: running minecraft 1.12
Looking at the title and the 45 min run time I knew this was going to be a glorious calamity of errors.
That startup sound. Omg the memories
First, we had Windows XP inside Minecraft. Now we have Minecraft inside Windows XP :P
you learn something new every day i didn't know that that plugin exist
There are tools for updating root certificates on legacy OSes, worth keeping in mind if you need them again in the future. I think TLS would still cause issues, because the integrated APIs in XP just don't support newer TLS versions. Supermium uses its own libraries, so it isn't dependant on TLS 1.2 support in the OS, but many things rely on the OS libraries. Apparently, you can use a local proxy to enable TLS 1.2 on legacy OSes. There are a few designed specifically for that purpose.
This video makes me feel the smartest one in the room
Startup sound made my life flashed before my eyes
it feels nostalgic with that border
EVERYTIME HE STARTED THE WINDOWS REMINDED ME OF THE MEME 😂
Love how you didn't give up
Oh shit the intro song remind me so much memories!
this video was so relaxing
Bro I love etweeking with computers like this
I remember when I played Minecraft on Windows XP back in 2015!
I had a similar thought of this experiment tho, instead of Windows XP, I had a thought of running it on Windows 98 (or if possible, Windows 95) but I was pushed back when I found out that it runs on x64 and I had a few experiments that were easier to do anyways... So I'm very surprised to see someone attempting on doing this Windows XP ESPECIALLY on x86
MultiMC looks like Prism Launcher because Prism Launcher is a fork of MultiMC. Don't quote me on this, but what I heard is that apparently the lead dev of MultiMC went nuts and just took full control of the project, effectively kicking out the rest of the team. Prism Launcher is a properly maintained and updated version of MultiMC from the original team, and has proper feature and security updates.
0:01 the most popular mems sound
I don't know why but it's so entertaining to watch :D
This little dog I always remember him saying F$@& lol. 4:15