Nerd reacts to Sound of Silence by Disturbed

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 жов 2021
  • This is Part 2 of 3 for my Sound of Silence comparison. Part 1 is the original by Simon and Garfunkel, Part 2 is the cover by Disturbed, Part 3 is my comparison between them.
    Please leave me a comment below with opinions and/or suggestions
    Please support the original artist as they are the ones that did the hard work.
    Here is a link to the original video: • Disturbed - The Sound...
    Here is a link to the band’s UA-cam Channel: / @disturbedmusic
    Here is a link to the artist’s website: www.disturbed1.com/
    You can support me via any the links below if your interested:
    streamlabs.com/redneckalcatra...
    / redneckalcatraz
    Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 63

  • @johnpierce1251
    @johnpierce1251 Рік тому +6

    It was said Simon told David it’s not his song any more it’s David’s now he was massively impressed we disturbs cover

  • @michaelfredgren1342
    @michaelfredgren1342 2 роки тому +29

    The thing that doesn't necessarily standout that I love is the video itself. Disturbed was able to create a story of the chasm between song writers and musicians which goes to the meaning of the song that S&P's live versions do not. Makes understanding what Paul Simon was trying to say much easier for the masses.

    • @TheTibbott
      @TheTibbott 2 роки тому +3

      And it's not just the story of the video. It's the chasm of *all* the disconnection we sense at the moment. The songs that we don't share are *because* of the talking without speaking and the hearing without listening. The Neon God is what is keeping us on opposite shores.

    • @junco1312
      @junco1312 Місяць тому +1

      The tissues I've 🤧 gone through since I discovered David Draiman and Disturbed on April 29, 2024. That day I have to believe my spirit 🙏 guides (out of the blue) first led me to a cover video by Dan Vasc singing "Amazing Grace" 👏 and then to the cover video of Disturbed and David Draiman singing this most POWERFUL, EMOTIONAL 😂rendition of Simon and Garfunkels "The Sound of Silence". I'm 75 and was 15 when they released this classic song of our time during the 60's. It is amazing how relevant it is today, actually I feel it is even more relevant than ever in so many different ways. I've spent days since listening and seeing the many channels and each of their reactions and 😢 almost every time. It's funny that more males have gotten teary-eyed than females, just an observation. Diane Davis

  • @karentony3397
    @karentony3397 2 місяці тому

    Love your reaction and response. Found this band after hearing this song. Love all their other heavy songs now. I’m 57. Yippee. Luv from Australia ❤️🎼❤️🎼❤️

  • @CandyGirl44
    @CandyGirl44 Рік тому +4

    The visuals are as powerful as the music - perfect lighting, symbolism, absolutely stunning. Beats the Conan version hands down.

  • @lisayoung4987
    @lisayoung4987 2 роки тому +27

    Simon & Garfield was truly Impressed and contacted David and gave their Praise on How he did His Rendition of their Song. They Placed it on their Personal Playlists. How Honorable is that. I like the way you React and do it in parts. Very Classy. David fid this son also on the Conan's show and it was loved. David was ill and Still Grabbed the Audience in Silence. All. That represented this Song are Wonderful but this Video Really Provokes one's Mind. Technology is the Problem. Look around it is Silent yet everyone is all on their Phones. We Lost the Communication with each other Face to Face. Just a Hello and How are you Doing to may I Help You are so Drastically Hard to Utter such words to a stranger in a Dr's office Waiting For a Bus or in a Store. We used to Open Doors, Say Hello, even Comment on someone's clothing. That's the Sad Part we are Loosing HUMANITY

    • @johncunningham4820
      @johncunningham4820 2 роки тому

      Garfield ? GARFUNKEL ! !

    • @LlamaLlamaMamaJama
      @LlamaLlamaMamaJama Рік тому

      @@johncunningham4820 I’m guessing that might have been an autocorrect

    • @redrosewarrior2806
      @redrosewarrior2806 Рік тому

      Did you know that Paul Simon was reported saying that DISTURBED now owns the song.

  • @sugi2042
    @sugi2042 2 роки тому +20

    Part 4 I recommend the live version of Disturbed doing Sound of Silence on Conan. This is the most amazing version in my opinion. Love to see what you think of it.

    • @someoneawesome8717
      @someoneawesome8717 2 роки тому

      Or the Pentatonix version

    • @coreyboldt9604
      @coreyboldt9604 Рік тому +2

      @@someoneawesome8717 the disturbed live version is far better than the pentatonix version, which is absolutely fantastic as well

  • @janisphillips2433
    @janisphillips2433 Рік тому +5

    I fucking loved it best video and singer was not to be believed so so good it brought me back to music I am in the hospital and accidentally heard it it changed my life and made.my heart open up thought I was finished with that and brought me so much joy I feel alive now anything is possible and my joy is screaming this song thank you

  • @LeahDaVi51
    @LeahDaVi51 2 роки тому +9

    Question. Why does everyone skip over the symbolism there are the broken instruments in the beginning silence and the discarded ones as the song continues? I think it is great symbolism also to the song.

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  2 роки тому

      I'll be honest, I completely missed that. They did such a phenomenal job with the song and the video and there is a lot of symbolism in it that would probably have to watch it several times to catch it all. I am glad that people like yourself point those things out that I missed cause I get to learn/realize more interesting details

    • @outogetyougotyou5250
      @outogetyougotyou5250 Рік тому

      Probably because it's blatantly obvious, so people don't think it needs to be mentioned

  • @maureenjones7222
    @maureenjones7222 Рік тому +2

    You need to watch the live version, it's even better if that's possible but he does it beautifully. Thank you dear. Glad you enjoyed it. x

  • @jameskidd6122
    @jameskidd6122 5 місяців тому

    Thank you for showing the video nearly full size and for showing it from start to finish. The only other cover song that comes close to this is KD Lang's Hallelujah.

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  5 місяців тому

      Not a problem! It's always bothered me when people do reaction vids, they pause randomly in the vid and talk. So I do a full play through first and then go back through it again (sometimes I catch things I missed the first play through).

  • @StaceyHunt-tl9bu
    @StaceyHunt-tl9bu 3 місяці тому

    David owns this song now. Hes such a great singer.❤❤❤❤😊😊😊

  • @kirstenwyatt9675
    @kirstenwyatt9675 Рік тому +2

    They do several covers of songs that, the original is a warning, but their cover is a call to arms, or anger the warning wasn't heeded.

  • @AndaraBledin
    @AndaraBledin Рік тому +2

    Fountain pens are fun to write with. The ink showing on the top of the nib (the point) would indicate that the nib had been dipped into an inkwell. You don't get the same result when working with cartridge fountain pens. The only real trick to using either is that you need a more precise pressure and angle than you would with a modern ball point. The paper likely isn't especially special, but the texture is referred to as a linen texture because it emulates the texture of linen cloth.

  • @vacbrewernut
    @vacbrewernut Рік тому +1

    So moving. I would like to see more from them like this. Thay probably got flack like KISS for Beth.

  • @georgeannec3444
    @georgeannec3444 2 роки тому +7

    Did you notice that the first man to stand with the music in his hand , holds the same position as he is kneeling as the piano at the beginning silent section?

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  2 роки тому +1

      I didn't! Went back and rewatched it and that blew my mind! Nice catch!

  • @l.e.alvord6171
    @l.e.alvord6171 Рік тому +8

    I'll bet David Draymond's fan base probably doubled overnight with this song. once you've heard him sing like this you want to hear him sing like this on everything he sings even if it is heavy metal I think he drew a lot of people in to His band Disturbed.

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  Рік тому

      I personally did a double take when I first heard Disturbed did a cover of this song cause, like many, I knew their music and wasn't sure how this would turn out. It was AMAZING THOUGH! I do want to see them do more songs like this, it was just so powerful and amazing.

  • @josephdonais4778
    @josephdonais4778 Рік тому

    The Universe has gotten to know itself through us and how hubris indeed it has become. We are merely the Universe opening an eye before it rolls back over to slumber. Indifference, it's true nature. The Sound of Silence.

  • @tiffymcconkey
    @tiffymcconkey Рік тому +4

    The original was the warning and this cover is the war. I tell every reactor I've seen do this that have never heard of Disturbed that this is not their usual style of music lol. This was absolutely beautiful and David's vocals in this especially live are phenomenal

  • @ghostmonk8254
    @ghostmonk8254 Рік тому

    Im on a mission around to up the subscribers of as many lads as i can find. You got another.
    I love that cover

  • @redrosewarrior2806
    @redrosewarrior2806 Рік тому

    Yes Mr. Nerd.. Not what was always mainstream for DISTURBED, however if you really follow and love the band, you know that they absolutely are capable of putting out music that touches the heart as well as provides fuel to get things done. One of these songs that is very moving AND NOT a cover - is "Univited Guest"... ' a lil sonethin for your earhole '. ..please give it a listen.

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  Рік тому

      Disturbed has some good music. I'll add Uninvited Guest to my to-do list. Had to take some time off due to new job and health issues but I'm working to record some more stuff.

    • @redrosewarrior2806
      @redrosewarrior2806 Рік тому

      @@Redneck-Alcatraz oh, sorry to hear health issues! Hope you are well.
      Oh thank you sooo much! I look very forward to that and more.
      P.S. Uninvited Guest used to make me think of relationship parting... I haven't listened to it since my husband passed just this January. Think it's gonna be a little different.

  • @jilltaiwan
    @jilltaiwan Рік тому

    You are professional on this react, in a cute way 😄

  • @lindapow9351
    @lindapow9351 2 роки тому

    Great to listen inn RedNeck

  • @xheralt
    @xheralt 2 роки тому +2

    Now you need to do a part 4, compare and contrast the cover by Pentatonix

  • @vickiemace1238
    @vickiemace1238 2 роки тому +1

    A description and 'use of' an ink pen? With the music he just played? Good Lord.

  • @clarkd1955
    @clarkd1955 6 місяців тому

    This is a man singing! Wow!

  • @rickhill789
    @rickhill789 2 роки тому

    also done live on the CONAN show

  • @candicehughes8259
    @candicehughes8259 3 місяці тому

    This is a prophetic song...1963......A vision was planted in my brain....He was walking everyone through what he saw.....Look around ...everyone has their heads buried in their IPHONES ....He got angry because his words like silent raindrops fell.....the Neon god is AI...and that part is very true today also....people do bow down to AI....then he goes back to the prophetic theme when he says.....the words of the prophets are written on the subway walls and tenement halls.........But there is hope ....music is the answer..the boat with all the instruments is going to the people on shore ......which is changing people today. There are so many artists that are speaking the truth and bringing people together...Tom MacDonald is one of them...I am going to his concert tonight in Nashville ....just to hear that one song. I really don't get into metal but I can't wait to feel the vibes from the audience when he sings it.

  • @dizzynikki5912
    @dizzynikki5912 2 роки тому

    My favorite cover...
    Disturbed - Land of Confusion

    • @derekshoup9579
      @derekshoup9579 Рік тому

      Yeah that was an awesome cover. They also did a good cover of Faith No More's Midlife Crisis.

  • @dizzynikki5912
    @dizzynikki5912 2 роки тому +1

    Make sure to put..
    Small Town Titans - Mr. Grinch
    On your December playlist..
    You won't regret it..

    • @doppler1775
      @doppler1775 2 роки тому +1

      I play that multiple times every Christmas since I first heard it!!

  • @squidlicious8449
    @squidlicious8449 Рік тому

    Need to add Pentatonix version of this song.

  • @JoaoVitorGDrumond
    @JoaoVitorGDrumond 2 роки тому +1

    I love this song and disturbed, do avenged sevenfold and du hast live from paris

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  2 роки тому

      wait wait, Avenged Sevenfold did a cover of Du Hast?! I didn't know this. Will have to look it up (also the lyrics/translation because I don't remember that part). Rammstein vs A7F might be a fun one to do.

  • @loriloy7097
    @loriloy7097 2 роки тому +1

    Please watch the live on Conan O'Brien's show

  • @johncunningham4820
    @johncunningham4820 2 роки тому

    You should check out PENTATONIX A'Cappella version . Just Voice . A revelation .

  • @rorycoats8014
    @rorycoats8014 Рік тому

    Appreciate your Honest Reactions could you Please React to Billy Lord "SECTION 318" TY

  • @EVAkuraArmor
    @EVAkuraArmor Рік тому

    If you watch the visionary of the end of the video like you did the beginning, you might understand the words even better. You got caught up in the music (As I did too), and missed the messages he was relaying at the end. Love your vid though!

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  Рік тому +1

      It's hard not to get caught up in the music. Thanks for pointing out the visionary and thanks for enjoying it!

  • @gloriaminix9027
    @gloriaminix9027 Рік тому

    Is this the first time experiencing this for him?

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  Рік тому

      No, wasn't my first time listening to this. I have listened to this song a LOT because of how good it is. Some of my reactions are to share my views/opinions on them and to share the song as well to people who might not know about it. I also do first time reactions and I try to mark those as such so people know that I'm going in blind on the song.

  • @henrypeck8090
    @henrypeck8090 2 роки тому

    It's a great song dont break it.

    • @gcarap
      @gcarap 2 роки тому +1

      No breakage here, I think they actually improved it.

  • @betharp9085
    @betharp9085 2 роки тому +2

    There are two videos, find the 9/11 one.

  • @ingridbortner1025
    @ingridbortner1025 Рік тому

    This wasn’t your first time hearing this. Your lack of reaction made it obvious you should have had tears, copious tears.

    • @Redneck-Alcatraz
      @Redneck-Alcatraz  Рік тому

      No it wasn't my first time hearing it. I have listened to this song a lot. I think I had it on repeat when it came out

  • @frankdenny4593
    @frankdenny4593 2 роки тому

    you got off into the weeds and missed the point.

  • @lubotodo
    @lubotodo 4 місяці тому

    I didn't like your reaction!! Your soul is like a lump of ice - no emotions! I'm disappointed! If someone wants to watch such reactions, stay. I'm running away from you!👎

  • @annrothery2910
    @annrothery2910 Рік тому

    You talk all the way through 👎