Did Gurugram fail? Urban planning | Geo-Politics | Nutshell
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2024
- Gurugram has a lot of things- start ups, hotels, skyscrappers, huge offices. But were it lacks is in- urban planning. And it lacks pretty bad! Cause local Gurugram residents face a lot of issues that are not talked about as much. In this video, we will cover all the problems that the city faces- transport, water, sewage, pollution. And answer why the city faces these problems in the first place!
#gurugram #fail #geopolitics #nutshellindia
Interested in geopolitics?
Here are some videos you might like:
Why is China interested in Arunachal Pradesh?
• Why is China intereste...
Why is Japan investing so much in India?
• Why is Japan investing...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video Map:
00:00 - Introduction: What was the plan for Gurugram?
01:15 - No one cares about the roads! 1 death a day.
03:04 - 1/3rd population has no water
3:56 - Just 23% electricity is for residents
4:45 - 2/3rd of Gurugram is not connected to a sewage system
5:48 - World's MOST POLLUTED city?
6:45 - Problem of flooding
7:14 - What caused these problems?
8:19 - Fault of the goverment
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Producer
Andre Borges
Writer
Kavya Karnatac
Researcher
Madhura Sen
Featuring
Kavya Karnatac
Video Editor
Hikuptah Studios OPC Pvt. Ltd.
Thumbnail
Rachel Rodrigues
Sound
Hikuptah Studios OPC Pvt. Ltd.
Operation Manager
Vaibhav Bhavsar
Executive Producer
Shivam Ganiga
Video Operations
Harshita Dubey
Shreya Sharma
Subtitle
Digital Nirvana
Copyright © 2022
Pocket Aces Pictures Pvt. Ltd.
🔔 SUBSCRIBE HERE - / nutshellindia
👾 Join our Discord Server - / discord
FIND US ON
Instagram / nutshellindia
Facebook / nutshellindia - Розваги
What problems does your city face? Tell us in the comments.
drainage and property rates are a major concern in Mumbai
Jalandhar Punjab used to have good roads. After AAP government has come situation is worst
Corruption, politics, old saturated city - Kolkata
I am from Bengaluru. Well yall know
I am from moradabad Uttarpradesh. Deadly air pollution is major concern for me. My heart beat get uncontrolled after taking breath here. Despite so many problems of gurugram. I can bet anyone it's far far better than any city of UP ( may be exception is greater noida)
I live in gurgaon for last 10 years and have travelled to Other cities in india frequently like Mumbai, BLR. Not sure how many of you really lived in New Gurgaon, but its by far the best city to live in amongst other metros. I never faced major eletricity issues since last 3-4 yrs. Cant remember a day without water suppy as well. Not sure what this rant is about.
Haha bhai if you live in condos then DG and water tankers aate hain. New GGN is a village at the moment. Where do you go for shopping btw in GGN? Or do you use car for buying milk?
Your tone is as if gurugram is the best city in the world. Forget about New York, tokyo, Paris etc.
@@rohitsinghsharma5012 been there too, but cant argue with people who have seen nothing, not worthy of my time
@@lohumihem assume all you can, i didnt even say if i lived in a condo, or private house or a flat. Just FYI, i own both!
@@rocakfellacrazytown then why did you waste your time in typing.
I have stayed in Gurgaon now known as Gurugram for 10 years. I can vouch for the authenticity of the facts presented in the video. The city is a perfect example of how not to build a city.
Fully agree with the points raised in the video.
I have seen Gurugram in 2019. Although it may not be as good as many videos say, but it is not as bad as this video portrays. It is some where in between. I have visited Gurugram many times. In India, if it rains for 1 whole day -- any city will drown like anything.
Oh my god you covered everything so beautifully in detail. Hats off to pick this topic and we know gurugram ka bhagwan hi maalik hai. As we have grt CM n DM
Hello, liked your video. I have stayed in Ggn for 10 yrs, it has gone worst in terms of pollution and I had to move to Bangalore. I think it's the same story in Bangalore as well & high corruption has led to major infrastructure issues in the city. would appreciate your time if you make video on Bangalore as well.
😂😂😂poor guy left gurgaon wait 5-6 more years you will automatically come back to gurgaon
@@superhero2481 why
Bangalore is much much worse.
@@tejuswiprakash673 such a shame India's top cities are so bad and corrupt
Aasmaan se gira khajoor me atka....
I lived in Gurgaon for 8 Months but there are major problems which you consider i shifted my self to noida and here im okay and friendly environment feel rather then Gurgoan
i live in greater noida, when it rained for 4 days inc september(continuously). not a single road was flooded. few underpasses did fill up but that also sorted out quickly.
Open area wahan bahot hai. Water flows there. Wait for the time jab wo Gurgaon jaisa dense hoga. Half of the flats are empty there.
Noida to khali pada hai bhai. Aur gurgaon mai middle class ki bhi aukat nhi land ya flat lene ki fir bhi aate hi bik jate hai. 1.5 lakh rs per sq yard rate hai plot ka
Gurgaon will be the newyork of India. Get ready to witness the progress of the millennium city. It’s going to be most sought after city of India. 🔥🔥🔥
Tune ghar le liya kya sohna me luade 😂
Le noida: ha yeh karlo pehle
Pork khane se dimag band toh hoga hi.
😂🤣😅
Been living here 12yrs and I can say for a fact that this video is highly exaggerated. Facts are cherrypicked out of nowhere to correlate two factors when they are unrelated. Whatever factors you have stated are much worse in other cities of India and calling Gurgaon a 'failure' is just taking it too far tbh
Thank you for bringing such a detailed video. The facts have been presented in a meaningful fashion. Why don't you cover tier 2 cities such as Mohali, Chandigarh, Panchkula. Looking foward to your video. Thanks
I worked in Gurgaon for 6+ years and stayed there. Gurgaon ki asliyat barish Ane pe pta lag jata hai and water is also main concern.
Ludhiana being the richest city of Punjab does not have an airport. There is no proper Transport facilities, mismanaged traffic and poor Urban Infrastructure. Many of the Funds from Ludhiana have been used in other Cities like Amritsar. Amritsar is mainly famous for its pilgrimage and wagah border (no doubt they have massive Rice Sheller plants) and has an Airport but very less contribution to the overall development of Punjab. Surely Politics is involved in it.
Please see if you guys can post a video to highlight this issue of Ludhiana.
Hey abhinav, coincidentally am a ludhianvi currently living in gurugram, ludhiana is developing slowly (tata's new plant in ladhowal). It has what it takes to be the leading developing city, but just a little attention which can take the bars way high, now that i have experienced metropolitan, i believe ludhiana is better than gurugram as it has alot of downsides along with opportunities
that is why majority of Punjabis move to Mumbai Delhi and Canada,partly due to unemployment
I have been to your city Ludhiana 3 to 4 times... It is quite similar to my city Lucknow...
You nailed it. I have been pointing out these points for many years.
Actually, I have been living in this city for last 20 years. I have seen a small town to grow and become a metropolitan city that too in a very small time period for a city this big. And yes, there are problems in our city but as you already told in your video that MCG and GMDA have been setup. And the beautification is already being done in the city. And the drainage system has also been improved compared to the previous years. To conclude, YES, IT IS TAKING TIME TO MAKE THINGS RIGHT, BUT MAKING A CITY LIKE GURUGRAM IS NOT EASY THAT TOO IN A SMALL PERIOD. AND YOU YORSELF SAID THAT CITY WAS CONSIDERD A WASTELAND TILL 20 YEARS AGO, AND NOW IT IS THE 2nd LARGEST IT HUB AND PROVIDES 40% OF REVENUE FOR THE STATE OF HARYANA ALONE.
CORRUPTION AND LACK OF WILL IS THE MAIN ISSUE
Suggestion Pune is also on the path of gurugram soon you will have to make a documentary on this rapid development by breaking mountains rivers like Mula and mutha getting destroyed day by day, power issues, water tankers are common nowadays every society is dependent on ground water, no sanitation measures PMC and PMCMC keeps on fighting for.area and road development
Thanks to uncontrolled migration from North India. Don't ask this channel for a video. Ask a Marathi channel for a video and let the locals take back the city.
And then there is GIFT city, which will be taught in architectural classes as - How to build a city.
It is an white elephant.
What is GIFT city...??🙄🙄🙄
@@saptarshiadhikary3736 It's an acronym for Gujarat international finance tec City, the only smart City of India.
It's already a failed project
@@khemrajprasad5635 Well, it has been delayed for sure, but not failed. There has been rapid progress made in last 3/4 years. I say this coz I work there.
The roads are worse in Gurugram. Except Golf Course Road. Even the GCR is not planned. Well, you have U turn in the middle of the road closer to sector 56. See road conditions of Golf Course Extension Road post rain you would be is road made out potholes or potholes are made on road.
The property are over priced than the actual quality of life offered. I feel it will crash someday. There are better smart city coming up in India.
Won't crash as people are already living there. Property crashes when it is yet to be occupied. And then DEW is something to look forward to. It will see a better version of Gurgaon
wow very informative.
Please make more such urban planning videos.
I hope this video will be eye opener for the judicials to take some corrective measures.
Apprecite your efforts for meticulously collating and sharing in a not too bug video.
judiciary?Ab wo engineering pe bhi gyan denge?
Judiciary better focus on their own job.
They are anyways digging path for the government. Whenever any new bill or something which is for country's betterment is brought, they need an explanation over it which delays the work for at least 2-3 years and in some cases even more.
Very informative content & to the point. All points presented are true. I've been visiting Ggn since 2002.
Such conditions, situations will be everywhere in all cities, till politicians, bureaucracy call the shots and Professionals are made backbenchers But hv to face all the flak for poor design. A Constable decides the road design, alignment, traffic signs. NOIDA is fast following Gurugram.
Wow I saw this after finalising my shift to Gurugram 😂
mem india ke sabhi big city ki yehi (same) poblem hai, barish ke mausam me gurgaon hi nahi mumbai, delhi , bangluru, sabhi city me pani bhar jata hai, me gurugram me hi 2006 se rahta hun, par 2012 ke baad mujhe kabhi bhi electricity ki problem nahi hui, aur ab jo new gurugram ban raha hai usme aapke lagbhag saare isuue ko solve kar diya hai
good video hai aapka
That happens when a city is haphazardly planned. The builders should learn from Japan ,korea, Singapore how to plan n build infra
The examples you gave are planned cities by efficient govt. Gurugram is planned by private sector only. Because that's what the private sector wanted from the govt ie no interference.
Hard hitting. You mentioned in the beginning to offer solutions at the end. Pls do express your thoughts on solutions
Wow living in Noida, I came to cyber city once and only got amazed by the massive amount of companies in gurugram. Finally I now it's reason and disadvantage 😇🤞
Solve kese kareain all these infrastructure problems ko , uske upar video banao...
We want such videos for other cities also .
I admit in case of electricity,pollution and water crisis.
Looking at such metros, I feel nice about being brought up in ahmedabad and gandhinagar! City's public infrastructure growth is always ahead of the population growth, they dont wait for the situations to become uncomfortable to start the work, and it is downright one of the most sorted out to live in, you can reach anywhere via multiple very well maintained roads. Also the twin cities are extremely safe for everyone.
Stay in gaon 👍
Most of the problems discussed here are overexaggerated other than the transport. Local migration
As Gurgaon emerged as a industrialization hub, the rich people from all the North india started investment in land that increased the land prices to a very high levels, leaving the upper middle class and below to live in their current residences or migrate to the outskirts of the city, which are not really outskirts, they are different cities all together.
Truth is difficult to swallow
I am a resident of gurgaon. Every fact of yours is true. We even face traffic on Nh8 it self
Too much money doesn't solve problem, intelligence does.
Make a video on Delhi becoming the most densely populated place in India and the challenges the city is facing now because of this.
Bruh.....come to Mumbai
You will see the real population density 😂
- Local trains flooded with people
- Buses heavily packed stuck in traffic jam
- Metro also full
- Still road is fully packed with private vehicles
I wonder how high population density of pur city is🧐
@@just_a_curious_thinker because you guys don't have wide roads than Delhi... Above all I use to live in Delhi from 2009 to 2012. I once read an article in TOI in the year 2010 about the vehicles in the city.... It was somewhat 56Lacs that time including both private & commercial vehicles...
sab paisa govt kha jaati hai. itna tax aane ke baad bhi gurgaon ka roads pathetic hai except highways.
Lol she's so innocent. There has been a research in Washington University on Gurgaon and Faridabad.Gurgaon is developed so much because there was no Municipal corporation and and local planning body to take bribes and induce red tapism. On the other hand Faridabad did not develop so much because it had a Municipal corporation from the starting and the officers there demanded heavy bribes from developers so no developer from Delhi came to Faridabad.
Toh drainage b bna dete phir
@@halocraze9839 private developers ne bola tha CM saab ko ki MC ka kaamkaaj hame de do hum solve kar denge drainage problem. But politicians gurgaon ka khoon kaise piyenge agar mumicipal corp private ho gyi to.
When will the solution video be uploaded?
Do the same research on LUCKNOW as well... Since the last decade the city has grown enormously & the condition of the roads are pathetic since this regime...
Some people call it Posh.. Some people call it a living hell !!
The video looks incomplete. Should have added more facts and current status of the city...also some solutions
Visit old gurgaon, you will get many more points of this unplanned city, massive encroachment at sadar bazar, super driving skills of auto rickshaw and last but not the least is the underpass at mahaveer chowk which is constructed in long 5 years and not used by any one hehehehe
Nice one.what about sohna?
जितना ज़्यादा industrialisation उतना ही pullution
पानी की कमी
जंगल नष्ट
रोज़गार तो मिल जाता है लेकिन बहुत कुछ गवाने के बाद
Wait,how is it only related to gurgaon?
Even in other cities,there is dependence of groundwater,dumping ground,bad roads..but yes gurugram has escalated issues
Sounds so similar to Bangalore lol
This is really a lesson!
It's more or less the same story in every city..
AS YOU YOURSELF SAID IN THE VIDEO THAT THE CITY WAS A WASTELAND TILL 20 YEARS AGO. SO, BUILDING A CITY LIKE GGN IN JUST 20 YEARS IS HUGEEEE AND OFC THERE WILL BE SOME PROBLEMS AND THEY ARE ALSO BEING WORKED UPON. AND THE ISSUE OF POLLUTION ITS IS A PROBLEM FOR ALL THE MEGA CITIES IN INDIA WHICH ARE AWAY FROM SEA. SO, ACTUALLY POLLUTION IS NATIONWIDE PROBLEM NOT SOLELY LIMITED TO GGN
good ,case study on Hub city👏
After a ground analysis, I found that Bengaluru & Hyderabad are the worstly build cities.
Good presentation of the problems without enough solutions . Planning of the town has been wrongly mixed up with execution. All the area of town out side the old town are
covered by Development Plans providing for sound urban infrastructure and services.. Therefore, planning failure if any is negligible.However,the plan implementing agencies have not lived up to the mark for various reasons.This is what we see on ground today. Potholes, flooding ,traffic problem,water supply and electricity failure etc are not planning failure which the video tends to suggest.
Thanks madam...please make another video comparing noida and gurgaon ?
Surat city mein bahut sari problem hai transportation related labour related and Surat city bus wah per bhi bahut sari problem hai. To Madam next video of Surat Shahar ke bare mein banaaiye.
Aisa h mam issue har jagah pr h, banglore m bhi issue hai,koi bhi jagah 100 per safe nhi h
The land was fertile indeed back then in gurgaon...fine land rich with groundwater...
The employees living in near area are suffering from worst waste management and people are also contributing to that , rents are touching the sky but society is worst to live and those who are good rent is extremely high for freshers.
Please cover Bangalore also.
Make video about kolkata and its new town rajarhat
Itna sunn kar achha laga 😌😌😌😌😌😌 or niche jaye yeh to
But I don’t find it as really bad
because of the easy licenses they did developed which India could not at that time and it’s no any mafia or something
I think need some regulations but this was a nice example how government cooperation with companies can evolve people’s life
What are your thoughts on Pune's Hinjewadi & Kharadi I.T Parks which have been developed from scratch too. This could be an ideal comparison for Gurugram authorities to improve.
pune and Hinjewadi are just villages with some roads. sadly no city in India can compare to international standards
@@deepakpune1 don't need to compete with international standards. The work should always be to make the basics as best as possible and still keep working on it. What happens after that is only extra.
Make video on Noida and Greater Noida
PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO ON DELHI
Would like you to make video on Noida
Please make a video on chandigarh.
When you do your research from KuKu FM... Btw kitne paise mile hai?
Pls make a video on Kolkata city
Jaipur city ke baare me video banao
The thing about such core cities aka High Tech parks or villages, have a dark side to it..
Anywhere u go in the world, all core metro cities will start to feel choking and chaotic.
One video on delhi please
That's 100% true. Jokes apart it was the best city to live in india during COVID times, Google it.. history..It was chautala then CM (most corrupt man of India) and land mafia that created Gurugram what it is.. but then, it's improving slowly with a separate municipal corp that came into picture a few years ago. Been here for more than 25 yrs have seen all in and out
Dwarka expressway is what one should look forward to. It is this government who has to prove itself there.
@@autolover3316 they are leased focused there as they are getting bigger rush on New Gurugram, Sohna road and gold extension road side
@@ShobhitBaweja I think they are very much focused on the entire Dwarka expressway, SPR, and Gurgaon Sohna expressway. Can't say if they have left any of them. DEW- Global city, Met City, IIT, Medical college and hospital in 102 sector is not just on papers but things are happening for real
Please do analysis on Bangalore as well @nutshell
I live in girugram for 11 years near Dwarka expressway in Rajendra park
Every word is factual about gurgaon, from it's history to it's present state . It truly sucks thanks to the conglomerate of the govt and builder mafia. Fools who ended up buying property there at a cheap real estate period are suffering today big time.
There is no city planning in gurugram .
Thousands of acres were sold off to builders who never bothered with provisions for public spaces , plots for schools hospitals etc.
There's even no municipal corporation which is a issue with the state of haryana itself
Amazing content. It is becoming really hard for me to decide if I should go to Gurugram or Banglore. Can you create a video on BLR also?
Banglore
Racism nahi sehna chahte to Gurgaon. And of course better food and less traffic jams.
Kajin bhi jaa dono ka wahi jaal hai.....
Now i am kolkata atleast no water issues. Road abd bridges bekar hai nut metro msst chalta hai .
Bijli ki problem hai but itne bure hal nahi hai .
We have dams for power and Rivers for water.
Garbage problems are a issue for high profile areas don't have.
Pls make video about Ghaziabad.
transport is not an issue in gurugram since everyone has his own car/bikes….the people in Gurugram dont prefer metro and buses as a mode transport. Hence number of buses are less and metros are less occupied than normal.
Lol kya logic hai 😂 You think people in NYC, Moscow or London do not have or cannot afford their own transport? There is a reason why a good and efficient public transport is necessary for every city.
@@sidddddddddddddd Gurgaon neither moscow nor nyc…its still growing, the capitals u mentioned are developed ones and have way too much of population compare to gurgaon.
More about hill station/city
Make a video on kolkata
Wants to know about Gift city and dholera city, Gujarat.
Thanks welcome
Madam ye toh aap gurgoan k naam pe humare pure desh ki problems bataa rahe ho......
This is the issue in almost all cities in India and root cause is corruption!! Paisa hai to sab mumkin hain 🫡
What about Noida, greater Noida
hey #nutshellTeam please make video on Meghalaya and its basic problem
Next Video Delhi Please 🙏
So, Firstly I would like to clarify here that nothing repeat nothing os correct in this video which is shown as problem. Highly exaggerated for personal motive by the creator.
She is either from noida or from Bangalore who is astonished to see Gurgaon growth and future but can't do anything.
Air quality gets bad in gurgaon only when nearby farmers burn crops.
There is no water shortage in gurgaon as there is enough planning. I can vouch for it as i am living here for last 30 years. Ab koi unlicensed colony me ghr bnakr rhega to wha paani kaise aega.
Electricity...i don't remember ki last time light 1 hr se jyada kb gyi ti and no regular cut in a day.
Public Transportation is a problem but people earn very handsome in this place ki log autos and cabs book kr skte h. Aur metro has been planned which will execute in 3-5 yrs.
Now what makes gurgaon good for future growth and investment.
Proximity to delhi and igi airport. Desh ki rajdhani se sbse paas hone ka pura fayda gurgaon ke pas h aur ye fayda bdta hi ja rha h. even ab to delhi k log gurgaon me a rhe h.
Good business policies by government.
Planned industrial and commercial development, jisse bht sara international fund gurgaon me a rha h.
Good planning of city for futrure by GMDA.
Big and wide highways running through out the ciry, NH8, DWARKA EXPRESSWAY, GOLF COURSE ROAD, EXTENSION ROAD, CENTRAL PERIPHERAL ROAD AND SOUTHERN PERIPHERAL ROAD.
So ma'am pls check the complete facts first on ground and then video bnaya karo...kuch bi bak bak mt kr dia karo social media pe famous hone k lye...
Waise ye jo saari problems apne boli h usme se konsi problem Bangalore me nai h...I have traveled the country and found Gurgaon to be one of the best for modern living.
Please do make a video on Simpson cartoon as whatever it is shown in cartoon happens in reality like Britain queen death, America's election, corona virus n much more. Is it so everything is predecided by worldly dominators ?
Make one on gift City plz
They said NOIDA is far better than Gurugram...now I understand why they say that
The city is the problem
Fir bhi yaha 1.5 lakh per square yard land rate hai?😂😂
Please make a video on Siliguri city ( chicken neck of India)
That drop tho at 1:00
2 lakh per sq yard plot mil nahi raha aur tum kharab bata raahe city ko😂 tumhare hisab se ban jate to ghar dekhne ke paise lagne lagte gurugram mai
pl cover pune and pimpri too. just gone to dogs, just buildings and no roads or good traffic mgmt