Dr. Peter Hayes: "Why? Explaining the Holocaust"

[@carlitobrigante330]

Hayes is an absolutely incredible lecturer.

[@sandrastone7019]

The best.

[@ionelapopescu1259]

I agree. He is amazing.

[@piehound]

I'm certainly not an expert on the history of WW2 and much less the genocide of Jews during that era. But allow me to say this lecture has provided one of the most clear and succinct summaries of causal factors for the horrors of mass murder of Jews in WW2 i have heard (or read) so far. Thank you.

[@Funintherain13]

I would recommend the book.

[@tthomas]

Agreed...

[@willosee]

As someone who has more than a passing interest this is a very good lecture.

[@firstal3799]

It wasn't genocide just of Jews
It was also of Russians, Poles ans Eastern Europeans plus Roma. So just Jews is rather racist

[@randallsmith5631]

Clear & Concise lecture

[@sueannebrown2709]

Great lecture! Wish I would have been there.

[@devilal-suthar9924]

Start at 11:30

[@MegaAslan10]

My gawd, how many old men does it take to introduce this guy?!!!

[@SATXbassplayer]

Yes 🙌!!’

[@conorjosepharthur]

Seriously. They gave the person's entire professional history. WE GET IT. WE TRUST THAT HE'S A PROFESSIONAL. WHY TELL US SO MANY POINTLESS DETAILS.
Rant over.
Great lecture!!!

[@charleswinokoor6023]

Mr. Hayes is an excellent lecturer and historian. There’s another, longer lecture on UA-cam where he goes into much greater detail.
But I take umbrage with his casual analogy of the WWII sentiment of many Americans who opposed accepting greater numbers of desperate Jews with contemporary immigration policy.
Dismissing the argument that there’s a concern nowadays about terrorists entering the U.S. illegally doesn’t hold water.
The 9/11 attacks counted for something, and the continued threat of Islamic jihadi extremism throughout the globe is extremely relevant.

[@randallsmith5631]

This Dallas lecture was a week after the Pittsburgh Tree Of Life massacre that killed 11 Jewish people

[@ChiRedWhiteBlue]

I had to clap along with the audience after listening to this excellent lecture (and the Q&A was incredibly informative too).

[@Johnconno]

A Mexican wave is rather inappropriate for this subject.

[@SATXbassplayer]

Skip to 20:00 mark. The first 20 minutes are fluff…

[@devorahklein2129]

As the child of Holocaust survivors I thank you so much!
In present day classrooms PC and other nonsense is getting in the way of learning history.
Please it up.

[@danolone6708]

Thank you for posting this lecture.

[@foucault8964]

Now many people are needed for an intro??

[@coypu2005]

Thank you Dr Hayes! I just watched your lecture on IG Farben and I fell in love. You’re amazing.

[@sandrastone7019]

Yes. Exactly how I feel, too.

[@bartbarry2662]

Given there are less than 500k minutes in 11 months that is astonishing.

[@scratch57]

Skip to 11min to see what you came for.

[@Johnconno]

'Here there is no Why?'
Primo Levi.

[@luzalgarin9518]

Thank you so much for sharing with me an infamous fragment of the Hitler's Nazi horrendous regimen, via this lecture.
It must have been a painful odyssey it is to recollect such memories and to recount them.
The crimes and cruelties committed against my sons and daughters, my fathers and mothers, my brothers and sisters hurt me deeply, regardless their ethnicity and nationality.
In Isaiah 2: 4, Jehovah God, the Creator and Source of life, Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, promises:
"He will be judge among the nations and will settle matters in relation to many peoples. They will turn their swords into plowshares and their spears into pruning shears. The nations will no longer raise their swords against each other and learn no more to wage war."
My immediate neighbors are Jews and I am a Jehovah's Witness.
Their hearts are superior than pure gold by far. They are extremely kind.
The gentleman takes care of my trash can every Wednesday without my asking him to do so. They are lovely human beings, and they are not in need of the smallest improvement.

[@crimony3054]

The bombers in the Doolittle Raids could not make the round trip. They ditched in China after bombing Japan. And the bombing of Japan in early 1942 was considered symbolic. The death camps were reachable and America does bomb for symbolic reasons.

[@richardgietzen4591]

Interesting lecture :
I have recently finished reading a book (Against our better judgement) by (AlisonWeir).
If what she says is accurate well.....
Found in on Amazon : please read it and tell me what you think.
I want a civil conversation: and let's keep the dialog focused on the facts .
Looking forward to hearing from you

[@dianem6951]

Try just reading God’s word. It’s in the KJV.

[@Petal4822]

Gypsies, Serbs, Polish and Slavic were classed as non-aryan citizens in WW2.

[@fionaottley4976]

Worry if the level of violence escalates he said.

[@corrynthiaiam9205]

53:06 Wow..Still hear that today. Especially about Immigrants.

[@markedwards9247]

An interesting lecture by Dr Hayes.
However, a dialogue of appeasement and platitudes is not going to solve the ongoing antisemitic friction.
It is painful, and often insulting for the recipient to hear and discuss the real issues. But that is what must happen for consensual understanding to occur. It would be loud, angry, and spiteful, but the alternative is to bury our heads in the sand.
The real background of the lead up to the holocaust is both very old, and diabolically contentious.
I recognise Dr Hayes knowledge of the subject of the holocaust, and yet he failed to expand on the real background at all. It is far more deep rooted in European history than mere mistrust. I would not expect Americans to be cognitive of this history, but I am absolutely sure Dr Hayes is, and yet fails to bring these issues to the table.
And the reasons for the holocaust will re-occur again and again, until the subject is openly and unrestrainedly discussed. That cannot happen when any accusation is dismissed under an umbrella of antisemitism.
Why do I say that? Because the holocaust is not in any way a precedent. It is in fact a carbon copy of events that occured in Britain (and Ireland and France) almost a millenium earlier, in 1290. Surprised? The reasons run all the way back to the life of Christ, and implicitly includes the enlightenment of Islam.
But you know what? I cannot even write those things here, because it is illegal. And that is precisely why we have learnt nothing from the WW2 holocaust.

[@andersestes]

First 20 minutes of this, is a waste of time

[@mediapeikko5900]

Why did the Jews leave Israel in the first place and thus not being a wanted nation in many countries, did they not try to move back to their country of origin? If you compare the Jews to the Muslims who invaded the Iberian Peninsula and were expelled from Europe, the Jews have not been a more desirable group in Europe than the Muslims. The reason why Muslims are treated with tolerance is because many Muslim countries have oil, which Western countries are still dependent on for the time being, but nothing else. But what do Jews have that makes them tolerated in Western countries? The answer is: Jews don't really have anything that Westerners really need. The Jewish diaspora is actually some kind of colonization, because otherwise they would have merged with Western countries and abandoned their religion and old-fashioned ways, because that also happens in Western countries where people separate from the church and the scientific world view is strengthened. Jews can therefore be considered a self-interested group just like Muslims. It is claimed that the Jews had no part in Germany's defeat in the First World War. It is largely a lie, because the world economy has been well integrated since the industrial revolution at the turn of the 18th and 19th centuries, and the role of the Jews in it has been self-interested, just as can be seen in the actions of the Israeli state today.

[@mediapeikko5900]

But anyway great lecture and great lecturer. Lots of unheard information.

[@coypu2005]

I think the ‘why’ to the Holocaust is- insecurity, revenge and psychosis.

[@leojablonski2309]

Read up.

[@carolynetter8046]

On the day of Pentecost 3000 Jews believed the message about Jesus and were Baptized in the water and scripture says they were added to the fold. Most of them were farmers. And no one knows how many Jews or Gentiles they told about Jesus. But it would appear there are still also many Jews that still go by the Old Testament.

[@mitchb4084]

I think your thoughts here are not fitting . But with that said,, 🤢you do know that Romans wrote the book with their angle on things. Not Moses , or other great heroes but murdering Romans who killed the great and caring Christ.

[@carolynetter8046]

@@mitchb4084 Makes me want to look at some other Bibles I have heard of and compare. But I do not trust some of the newer Bibles.

[@koko2bware]

@@mitchb4084 Yes, the Romans did the crucifixion, but there is no denying the Pharisees (you know who) incited it! P. Pilate wanted to free Jesus but the crowd (you know who) wanted Jesus crucified. They (you know who) chose to free Barnabas instead of Jesus. Let us be honest, beside the Romans there were others involved (you know who)!

[@Petal4822]

@@koko2bware The crucifixion was done by the Romans…why were Italians not hated???

[@robreich6881]

@@mitchb4084The reality is the Jewish leaders plotted to kill Christ, that some Jews chose to believe in him and then later the Romans destroyed the Jewish temple and thus the heart of the Jewish religion. All that Judaism is now is an ethnic tribal religion of people who no longer have a temple or a covenant with God (the whole point of which is about having this Temple.) Whining is not gonna change this.

[@markreierstad2418]

When the first guest referred to "our leader," I checked the date. I thought at first he was referring to Dump. But then, I realized he said the word "leader," and I understood it couldn't have been him in anyway. My apologies for going into the cesspool and dredging up that turd. However, it is sadly relevant. If you gave Dump half the chance offered to a Hitler, a Stalin, even a Putin or Duterte, he would jump at it. That has been in my mind since early in his term. It's there now as I, along with everyone else, know that he will stop at nothing to get back into the White House. Once there, he will stop at nothing to ensure that he stays there. I found it especially chilling when he reminded us that during the 30s, there was a large-scale arrest and incarceration of political opponents. Fast forward 80 years. You have an arrogant, rude lout getting his sheep to chant "LOCK HER UP!" in reference to his opponent. No one can honestly tell me that's just words, just "galvanizing his base." If Dump had the chance to jail anyone who spoke out against him, he would take it in a heartbeat, then brag about it. The worst thing of all is that his sheep would love him even more for it. Anybody who observes this and ISN'T at least concerned needs to wake up. History doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes...

[@junanougues]

No need to apologize. Thinking along the same lines. Criminal Defendant One is an institutional arsonist of the worst kind, an outlaw. That revels in his villainy. Which a lot of people like and cheer on, on one hand. And, on the other, that not enough people are sufficiently situationally aware of the ongoing level of the threat should he win in November. Thank you, Sir.

[@menaszeytounian3256]

The lackadaisical mechanic unintentionally wave because step-mother beverly examine pace a real company. fancy, prickly parentheses