She looks like a pre-Raphaelite painting by Bastien Lepage. I never really know who is best, but this is definitely up there on the dais with the other queens. The tone is ravishing, unsurpassed dynamics, and extremely musical. It doesn't sound like a coloratura wind-up doll, but a really sensitive young girl. Very, very beautiful.
Gorgeous vocal perfection from one of the greatest belcanto sopranos of all time, such beauty of tone and such a perfect technique. You were one of the greatest sopranos of all time. R.I.P.. the Queen of bel canto 👏👏👏
Нереально красивый ,по своему уникальный голос! Светлая память выдающейся певице! Спасибо вам,Эдита,что были с нами,и пусть ваш голос неизменно звучит по прежнему!!
I've had the passage from 3:47 to 4:09 as my ringtone for years. I thought I knew it. I knew the melody alright, and I knew the vocal acrobatics she performed, but I was still surprised just now at how absolutely gorgeous it sounds. Like a nightingale.
Well you can't compare all sopranos because there are many different fachs and not every fach sings everything efficiently so I believe you can compare her to other coloratura or leggera sopranos but to compare her to dramatic sopranos is a bit off since they sing different things. But if by preference you like her above every other singer you have heard regardless of fach or roles etc of course your opinion is respected
I am familiar with many versions of this aria and have just listened to 10 recordings and what surprised me was that singers schooled in the German tradition (Gruberova, Popp, Streich, Hallstein) generally sing this aria better than their Italian/Mediterranean equivalents. Of course, there are now many singers who defy classification who might best be called cosmopolitan but they too sing mainly the Italian repertoire. To my ears Ingeborg Hallstein is the best expotent of pure belcanto singing. The final note as sung by Lucia Popp is peerless - to my ears
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia Eh sai, in quel periodo (3 mesi fa) avevo detto delle castronerie allucinanti, se ne vedi qualcuna in giro non farci caso... 😂
Куда там, кому-то! Все Джильды по списку - после Эдиты, а потом еще Сазерленд, несмотря на фактуру, и Дессей еще. Мио падре.., вообще плачу всегда, когда поет Груберова.
English is my first language, when I listen to or attend Operas’ written in English, I always have to read the subtitles to understand them. My hearing is fine. It’s just too difficult to understand all those elongated vowels and light breathy consonants.
A mais linda interpretassao de caro nome que ja ouvi entre todws as interpretassoes e em segundo lugar a interpretassao de carla mafiolett brasileirinha de altissimo talento só que ouve pode avaliar as duas interpetes
Grande Voce, grande presenza scenica, pulita agile leggera ma allo stesso tempo ben timbrata, una grande la Gruberova!
What a beautiful rendition and what a beautiful stage design. Ms. Gruberova was one of the best! May she rest in peace!
The BEST EVER soprano colorature.🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️ Amazing....incredible. Love her since i discovered her ( 32 years ago)
How is this even possible?! Just like they say: "She's like an angel". She definitely sings like one!
As a coloratura soprano, I love the way she "hangs the high notes out to dry!" They hang there like golden threads in the sunlight..... wonderful!
exactly! Gruberova is a textbook for all sopranos to learn from. The technique requires tremendous control on the breadth.
Yes!!!!
Maravilloso ¡¡¡¡¡
Не только совершенная техника,но и очень чистый тон,редкий дар🙏❤🕊💐Непревзойдённая🙏❤🕊💐
She is the absolute best Gilda i've seen and heard. An innocent daughter of an overprotecting father. I love her.
She looks like a pre-Raphaelite painting by Bastien Lepage. I never really know who is best, but this is definitely up there on the dais with the other queens. The tone is ravishing, unsurpassed dynamics, and extremely musical. It doesn't sound like a coloratura wind-up doll, but a really sensitive young girl. Very, very beautiful.
So well said!
I'd say Dante Gabriel Rossetti rather than Bastien Lepage.
Felt the same👏👏👏👏
A young innocent Gilda. She is the one, don't know her name though. Magnificant.
Чудесный,неповторимый в исполнении голос замечательной Груберовой!!!!!
Rigoletto is the most sad of Verdis operas, the most sad opera of all, though the most beautiful.
È l'opera perfetta drammaturgicamente. Allora la Traviata cos'è in quanto a tristezza?
CARO NOME Is one of the most beautiful aria in Opera.
Amazing, I think her voice suits best this role. So delicate with great technique.
angel is whispering,
потрясающее исполнение! многих слышала, но это просто прекрасно🙏🏻❤️💐
браво великому таланту!💙💙💛💛
Best Caro nome ever!Viva Gruberova
Edita es perfecta, incomparable!!!!!
Rest in peace Edita.. Your music will. Keep spreading the love.
Gorgeous vocal perfection from one of the greatest belcanto sopranos of all time, such beauty of tone and such a perfect technique. You were one of the greatest sopranos of all time. R.I.P.. the Queen of bel canto 👏👏👏
Нереально красивый ,по своему уникальный голос! Светлая память выдающейся певице! Спасибо вам,Эдита,что были с нами,и пусть ваш голос неизменно звучит по прежнему!!
God bless you, Edita! RIP! After hearing you sing this, I could not recall any recorded soprano who could touch it!
I've had the passage from 3:47 to 4:09 as my ringtone for years. I thought I knew it. I knew the melody alright, and I knew the vocal acrobatics she performed, but I was still surprised just now at how absolutely gorgeous it sounds. Like a nightingale.
До чего же нежный, ласкающий душу голос! Спасибо, Эдита, за Ваше творчество и труд! Низкий поклон...
The best ! From Argentina, we will always be remember you, dear Edita.Rest in Peace! THANK YOU FOR BRINGING US YOUR EXCELENT TALENT.God bless you!🙏🙏🙏🙏
Requiescat in Pace, Gruberova…
Belissima voce.
Prácticamente escuché una bella angelita cantar. Qué impresionante video. Gracias por compartir.
I've never heard anything more beautiful than this performance.
She's freakin phenomenal.
Gruberova She is Slovak Soprano , Best Soprano 20 century !!!!!
From Argentina.....I agree with you....THE BEST of the century
Is Joan Sutherland
Well... 'Slovak Soprano', yes. 'Best Soprano 20 Century', no. Definitely no. 😊
Well you can't compare all sopranos because there are many different fachs and not every fach sings everything efficiently so I believe you can compare her to other coloratura or leggera sopranos but to compare her to dramatic sopranos is a bit off since they sing different things.
But if by preference you like her above every other singer you have heard regardless of fach or roles etc of course your opinion is respected
А Лючия Попп?
Quelle voix merveilleusement belle, subtile, pleine de nuances et de grâce !
C'est la meilleure version. Je ne vois pas comment faire plus beau !
Lo mejor de lo mejor!!!! Bravaaaaa por siempre!!!!!!
What Gilda SHOULD sound like! Brava, brava, brava!!!
Grande performance,wish you will singing happily in the heaven
🙏 😇
She is the best Gilda ever. I listen to her again and again. She can exactly perform that innocense that Gilda has. Love Gruberova.
Best Gilda forever
BRAVISSIMO. . . !!!!!
Do you mean, Bravissima ,becouse shes a woman, Bravissimo for Male singers.
@@chiclanolecter bravísimo is correct in spanish
@@OroAD ma è scritto in Italiano non spagnolo
@@selini52exactamente
Absolutamente divino!
This, Lucia Popp, and Joan Sutherland all leave me in awe.
Two of them were born in Slovakia :-)
She and Joan just breathtaking!!
Beautiful voice one of my favorite scenes!
......Superbe......
She had a take of this, divine.
La mejor Gilda que he escuchado. Nadie como ella.
La migliore Gilda di tutti i tempi!
Переслушала кучу Джильд, распрекрасных, рас... рас..., но это - настоящая.
Sensational! Huge! She is my favorite! Goosebumps!
BRAVO . . !!! INSUPERABLE . . .
Simplemente maravillosa ""Aria y voz""
Essa é a mocinha entregosa mais perfeita dos últimos tempos!
My favorite Gilda!
Ninja 6475, hear Renata Scotto. Also June Anderson is good
Прекрасная. Голос именно 15-летней девочки -= настоящей Джильды..
Best Gilda ever
I am familiar with many versions of this aria and have just listened to 10 recordings and what surprised me was that singers schooled in the German tradition (Gruberova, Popp, Streich, Hallstein) generally sing this aria better than their Italian/Mediterranean equivalents. Of course, there are now many singers who defy classification who might best be called cosmopolitan but they too sing mainly the Italian repertoire. To my ears Ingeborg Hallstein is the best expotent of pure belcanto singing. The final note as sung by Lucia Popp is peerless - to my ears
ERIC GARBUTT That's true if you think this aria is only about the high notes, and even then it's not true.
agreed
Yes, I think the Germanic sopranos generally have purer sounds for this aria than do their Italian counterparts.
Speachless
Ma com'è brava! Sembra un angelo ❤️
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia Lo so, lo so 😅 All'epoca ero ancora inconsapevole...
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia Non sapevo ancora che la Gruberova suonasse in realtà così male
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia Esatto! Viva Callas! 🥰
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia Canta tipo così:
Cæro næme che il miœ cœœœr fæstii primœ pælpitæær...
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia Eh sai, in quel periodo (3 mesi fa) avevo detto delle castronerie allucinanti, se ne vedi qualcuna in giro non farci caso... 😂
ГЕНИАЛЬНАЯ ПЕВИЦА.
Прелестное - Bellcanto...🌞🌞🌞
Gorgeous!
완전 미쳤나봐... 너무 잘 부르셔 심각해...
sublime.....no me canso de escucharla. THE BEST!!!!
RIP!!
Just OUTSTANDING
This is the best Gilda of all. I do like this opera cause her father Rigoletto is one of us Swedes.
R. I. P. Edita Gruberova
Da brividi.... meravigliosa!!!
Great performance by beautiful woman. She did not need that wig.
あのリゴレットのオペラフィルム、昔々なんとなく見たなあ、と思っていたけど、ここで始めてグルベローヴァだったと知りました。うーん、さすがの歌唱。ヴィーヴァ、グルベローヴァ！
Ihre pianissimo ist einmalig. Für mich war Sie immer bewundernswert. Großartig!
This is incredible
einzigartig!!!
3:11 love her staccato scale, and the final trill on B during "Gualtier Malde" coda.
Such incredible soprano
Rigoletto is a sad, sad story.
Exquisite, Edita!
WHO DOES NOT LIKE THIS???
Me
@@celibidache1000 🖕
Espetacular! Magnífico!
Sweet as Sweet can be,Brava !!!
Thanks
Куда там, кому-то! Все Джильды по списку - после Эдиты, а потом еще Сазерленд, несмотря на фактуру, и Дессей еще. Мио падре.., вообще плачу всегда, когда поет Груберова.
А Лучия Поппова
Wonderful interpretation!
UNICA.....FANTASTICA......MARAVILLOSA
brava brava brava!! flawless exit indeed!
Faultless and peerless!!!
BRAVISIMA ...INSUPERABLE
♡♡♡
Slovak Voice Diamond
Del mio cuore tu sei regina...
the fact that i'm literally italian and i live in Rome but i have to watch it with english subtitles to understand is killing me
English is my first language, when I listen to or attend Operas’ written in English, I always have to read the subtitles to understand them. My hearing is fine. It’s just too difficult to understand all those elongated vowels and light breathy consonants.
@@Parker-930 ikr
@@Rurururururururumi ❤️
Maravillosa interpretación.!!!
Sublime
Fantastic voice...………..!
Люблю во веки веков.
CELESTIAL . . . INSUPERABLE . . . ♡♡♡
Bellísima aria--Rigoletto
A mais linda interpretassao de caro nome que ja ouvi entre todws as interpretassoes e em segundo lugar a interpretassao de carla mafiolett brasileirinha de altissimo talento só que ouve pode avaliar as duas interpetes
Краща Джільда, не дивлячись ні на що..
I’m singing this in the conservatory. God damn! I think I will never sing it as beautiful,
Best Gilda
Люблю всегда.
EXQUISITA VOCE DI SOPRAN0 GRUBERONA
at least she knows belcanto in spite of her delicate voice.
Люблю.
Muy buena versión del aria
perfect.
If I'm correct, she was in the same opera with Giovanni Pavarotti. Beautiful indeed!
It's Luciano, not Giovanni.
Лучше нет. Настоящая Джильда.