That's not exclusive to the beauty world, you find that in every area of human interest. The biggest example I have is Mark wahlberg. The fact that he was able to become so successful after what he did is revolting. But people are fickle.
Patrick gets criticized, but James Groomer Charles gets to keep doing his sh!at in the beauty world? Why is everyone acting like nothing happened? Double standards at their finest.
@@urmomvia yes but I meant something more pretty privilege it can be as small as smiling at an attractive person and yet frowning or ignoring a lesser attractive person
Can we just stop it with the racial privilege thing, Labeling people by their groups? It leads to awful things label him as an individual for his individual traits and not his skin color or the group he belongs to@@urmomvia
as an artist, the ai thing bugs me cause he could've easily commissioned some artists to make original artwork, but the gifts did seem very sweet and heartfelt also the bonus argument is so dumb, obviously he wouldn't have given out bonus checks for a tiktok, it seems so disingenuous to just hand out money and then film it
The way he was acting like he put so much hard work into it, like all you did was give it a prompt, youre not the one who programmed it or made the art its taking "inspiration"(stealing) from
People would have lost their shit if he posted a video giving them bonus checks. They would find something to complain about like he's touting his wealth.
As a human being I’m tired of the entitlement from artists. If someone wants the quality of art your creating, they’ll buy it. If they don’t stop whining that they’re choosing to use a different source. Especially in these times I cannot imagine not getting a real fucking job, then whining people aren’t spending their hard earned money on my creations. We don’t all have money to spend on your art lmao! We’ll use a source we either have a one time fee for, or at an exceptionally less than the cost of your art. If you want a stable income, get a stable job.
@@ScreamingDucksShotMyMotherthe problem is that ai steals from artists and artists that get their art stolen and incorporated into ai dont get compensated for it at all
That whole situation also screamed "People didn't do their research and just filled their carts only to have buyers' remorse." I would never buy almost $200~ worth of product or bundles without cross referencing them and making sure I'm getting what I'm buying. 🤷♀️
@@AmberTurdsShittyBedsheetTHIS. This kind of thing happens all the time. This is very telling that people are plucking this out as an issue with Painted. Next time you go to the grocery store, pay attention to your ounce per dollar. Big brands everywhere are fooling buyers with bundles and larger containers only to be charging you higher prices for your laziness on that math. Companies everywhere are doing this and it blows all around. It’s not ethical, but it’s legal and it’s rampant. Same for shipping issues. PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT YOU BUY BEFORE YOU COMPLETE YOUR ORDERS, yo. It’s that simple.
the whole thing with patrick’s gifts made me roll my eyes, people find anything to be mad at, the gift was cute, some people don’t get anything at work for christmas
I agree with the AI art. But I wouldn’t want my boss filming my reaction to receiving a bonus or anyone else knowing about. Especially social media. That’s a boundary that a lot of people don’t want to cross
My boss doesn’t even want us to discuss it with our colleagues, let alone the internet. I don’t think we need to know that information, plus not everyone gets a Christmas bonus
When you become an employee for a company, you normally sign a document saying you consent to being on social media or have your image used for the company so I don’t see the problem with him posting his employees
I don't believe In using ai..it goes against my beliefs. I also think he's cheap not giving out bonuses. Even though I don't celebrate Xmas. It could've been at the top of the year like a new year's bonus..
As someone in the cosmetic skincare industry, Rhode’s packaging was neither innovative or original. It follows the trend of minimalistic and aesthetically pleasing packaging that many other brands had already been doing. A lot of people don’t recognize how design trends intersect across mediums. That blob shaped simple/smooth monochromatic look is just following the same (specifically genz) interior trends, graphic design trends, etc. in the same way rhode was. Brands are more closely following these trends more and more for their packaging as the aesthetics and the “keeping it on the sink” appeal is becoming way more of a major factor in how people decide to buy their skincare now compared to the last decade where people preferred products that looked clean and medicinal. It’s an unfortunate coincidence considering their history but neither of them have original or unique packaging in the first place. You can specifically tell they had this packaging planned in advance because the blob/ambiguous shape trend is already on the way out.
Yes wasn't Kim Kardashian's brand Skkin exactly the same concept just in brown? I think people are reaching to try and create more drama between the two.
@@daria5846 I do not care about either of these people, loved Selena on Wizards of Waverly Place and I don’t know much about Hailey but she’s very beautiful. That’s about it I don’t think about them. This comment doesn’t even make sense because Selena is quite literally getting the response you’re claiming only Hailey would get, we just watched the same video about it. I felt like my comment was relatively neutral in saying neither had original packaging to begin with so I don’t feel like there’s anything to say besides marketing teams trying their hardest to sell the most product by using packaging that is proven to sell.
@@nicolasf7243 Ehhh... ok? It's fine? I'm not sure how you not caring is relevant here Lol but anyway, I'm just pointing out how when Selena is "the bad guy" people tend to be more logical. If it was the other way around the comment section would be pretty different.
As someone that works in packaging design, the Rhode product design isn’t original. It’s minimalism with soft forms, which Is a huge trend in personal care packaging right now.
The Patrick thing kind of had my hackles raising... not because of him, but because of the backlash he received. He did a sweet thing for his staff, and they seemed appreciative of the fact. Could he have commissioned the art? Sure. However the response from everyone just reminds me that the internet is why we can't have nice things... people just want to attack people, no matter what they do, and it makes me truly sad.
It is not just because he "could have commissioned the art". AI art generators have to have been trained with art that actual artists made in order to function in any capacity, and its not just one or two, or a few hundred pieces either. It is not just taking away potential future jobs from artists, but actively stealing past works and IPs of artists who have not given them permission to make money off of said works. Honestly I don't think Patrick did it with any malicious or lazy intentions, but that he was just ignorant about how these AI generators work, just like most people. I personally wouldn't fault him for it because he clearly didn't know, even as an illustrator myself who is aware how AI could affect the entire industry as a whole. It'd just be better if he knew, so it's still the right thing to do to inform him. The whole art instead of bonus thing was incredibly silly though. I doesn't make much sense for him to not give a bonus along with a gift, since its customary to give both in a lot of work places.
do these people have jobs? if so, what did they get at their jobs? they complain but don't mention what their own job gives them for christmas. the people complaining are probably unemployed themselves. lol
Soon as Selena did something people didn’t like, they ran to be on Hailey’s nuts as if they didn’t try to ruin her and her brand before. Internet is a strange place.
Why do people feel entitled to know if Patric's employees got a bonus or not? lol Why on earth would Patrick show or say that publicly on social media? That's usually something that stays within the company and employees
not a fan of AI BUUUTTT.... he clearly put work into the rest of the gift so i don't really care plus like he doesn't need to flaunt giving money to his workers that would be just as weird😭😭
Its funny people are comparing Rhode’s and Rare Beauty’s packaging when they are not the same. When you mentioned it I was expecting the bottles to have the exact same shape but theyre not even close 💀. I also heard from Johnny Ross that Rare Beauty worked with Physical Therapists to design the packaging. Apparently the hand lotion bottle doubles as hand massager and everything is easy to open 👀
i can believe the thing about physical therapists, since Selena said the same thing when she released the original Rare Beauty line. Like people were questioning why there were domes on the lip products and blushes, and she made a whole video explaining how it helps people with arthritis like her. honestly always liked Selena but i have a new level of respect for her when she puts details like that into her products so anyone can use it easily.
Patrick is a creative person and the idea is super cute but to be able to make those AI pictures the system had to rip off real artist art styles which is the real problem for me. There's a lot of great artist in the internet age and this is like a punch in the face to see him doing this. The bonuses are not our business and frankly I would be uncomfortable if my boss showed to the world how much he's giving me. I'm disappointed but not surprised art is never taken seriously even by other artists (and yes Patrick is an artist make up is art)
@@deme4869if you chose to make high school photos of you and post it on TikTok, or use photos of you as a queen as your profile, you’ve consented to whatever that entails. This was a surprise, I’d appreciate the gift from my boss but I wouldn’t be too happy with AI having my likeness forever, I didn’t press yes to those terms and conditions.
@@deme4869 You may not have seen it, but there were/are artists who have talked about it. Oftentimes their opinions just aren't as wide spread, but that doesn't mean they don't exist- especially the artists whose work is being stolen by AI.
@@deme4869artists have been protesting against AI for pretty much the entire year, especially on twitter. it was central in the SAAG strike. if you dont see people applying this energy, you arent looking.
Also bonuses are typically given during an end of the year review. In office. Also, private between employer and employee. It would be really weird to give out money in front of everyone.
As an artist, I'm kind of bugged out with AI Art, but I accepted it because AI will become a big thing in the future. I truly do believe Patrick's action were genuine and cute. However more people really need to do their research about AI Art especially it is stealing from other people works. I just accept that AI will take over but it doesn't justify that we still need to but ground rules with AI Art.
I love Patrick, but I really agree with the AI thing. I’m an author and it is a big debate in the field too - obviously using AI is 500 times cheaper than commissioning an artist for a design and/or doing a shoot with people…but I am still firmly on the side of artists. Plus the results are just 10 times better and more original. I hate that even very wealthy influencers now go the AI route. So yeah…it’s not a non-issue to me.
I got absolutely nothing from my employer for Christmas. I'd be GLAD to get literally anything, even if it's just a small gift or nice chocolate. You know...something that doesn't make me feel completely unappreciated.
People are so hard to please. The employees of Patrick Star enjoyed the party, love the gifts just look at their reactions! Unless those who hate are his employees then I'll understand. But if the hate comes from those who just want to hate on anything and everything... Happy holidays!❤.
I agree about AI not being the way to go for a personalized picture of yourself, I wouldn't want to support something that it's feeding off of real art made by real artists. I also don't want anything about me to be a reference to those tools that suck creativity out of people and make someone believe they're an "artist" by asking a machine what to put on a canvas lol. I'm sure Patrick has the money and means to comission someone, he just didn't want to go that route and chose the lazy way out. AI is stealing the work of people that actually put thought on what they are drawing.
THANK YOU. As a full time illustrator, it’s so frustrating to see AI being used for art. It’s such a lazy shortcut to a craft that people dedicate their entire lives to learning and honing
@@emileek4107 Hi AI developer here! AI is meant ti make our life easier quick and efficient. An artist will take over 3 hours to do this wile an AI takes less then 5 minutes. The AI isn't perfect tho it still struggles to draw noses and hands but as a programmer we are working on that :) Your work is greatly appreciated and it can be made with more details but s project like what Patrick did and AI is not too bad since its something quickly and simple and isn't using a lot amount of details and if he did I don't think the AI would understand it.
@@HahaGoCry so you’re fine taking away jobs from hard-working artists bc a machine is faster? Nice; thanks for your service to the world 🙄 Did you really think I would be impressed by this comment?
Bruh idc if its an artist or ai who did it, if i work under him and he gave me this i’d be so happy that my boss thought of me and treat me well! It’s hard to find a boss who treat their employees with such a kind gesture! Even if the gift was cheap he made it by hands!! Warp and wrote by himself thats so kind 🥺🥺
selena has interesting packaging, usually not typical shapes, to be more friendly to arthritis bc of her illness and such. i see that in the packaging, easier to grip. idc if it looks like other packaging, its the meaning behind it. i bet hailey probably didnt have that in mind when choosing packaging.
That's pretty great. Wish there was more packaging like that. Maybe just refillable, arthritis-friendly bottles would be better. I didn't even know that was an option!
I’m sorry the Patrick Starr hate is so dumb. People just looking for something to be mad about, assuming and hating is so ridiculous. It was a cute idea and everyone looked so happy
That's what I was thinking. It was a thoughtful gift. I don't like him, but the fact that he did this by hand makes it pretty cool. I don't know why everyone is so salty about it. Guess their boss' never did anything so special for them
I think it's so vile how everyone was dragging Patrick Starr! especially during the holiday season! He's not problematic AT ALL! He seems like such a sweetheart and, yeah, do I wish he hadn't used AI? OF COURSE. But, look at how happy all his employees were! So weird to assume he didn't get them a christmas bonus. It's not our business whether or not he did give them one, it's between him and his employees!
I would’ve liked those gifts from Patrick. I love personalised gifts and I love Disney. It would’ve gone on my bedroom wall asap. People just want to hate by the looks of it
Some people are really acting as if holiday bonuses are normal anymore (I wish they were). While Patrick for sure could and should have commissioned an artist vs using AI, that doesn't mean holiday bonuses were ever an option unfortunately :( I work at a massive university with profit margins in the millions for this FY alone, and I got a $20 gift card to use downtown that expires and refunds to the sender in 30 days if I don't use it.
But really, those shipping costs are insane. Every country has it's own rules, but when I wanted to buy a custom hockey mask for my son it was about 100 dollar with USA shipping costs included, but as soon as the package would be here in the Netherlands, the real sh*tshow began: Tax, shipping fee, another tax, customs tax, all in all I would have to spend another 150 dollar just to get the mask in my hands 🤦♀️😱 Yeah, I didn't get it.......
I am not a fan of Patrick, but that was a very sweet idea. The fact that he did it himself, didn’t make his assistants do it, like most CEOs would is even more wholesome. The hate he’s getting for this is ridiculous. He probably gave them a bonus and if he didn’t, does anyone have any idea about the salaries and the work conditions he offers? I’m pretty sure the employees would rather he uses AI, prepares the gifts himself instead of spending thousands to hire a few artists to do all of this. That money could go to them instead.
I do hope Patrick gave his employees a money bonus, because just a picture would suck, but I'm petty so.. and James Charles just needs to go away. He's gross AF
Honestly some people are REACHINGGGGG like lets think about it, why would Patrick actually pay an artist to do it when ai can do it for FREE? Some people need to acknowledge that one size is a BUSINESS and will naturally try to cut cost where it’s able to.
The ai art thing isn’t just that it’s taking jobs, it’s that people are training ai on stolen art. The ai is just mashing different pieces stolen from artists together. Think about it this way: imaging you’re an artist and you made a beautiful piece, you post it online to advertise your struggling business and an ai takes this piece without permission edits it together with some more stolen art and sells it making someone else a profit. It’s theft and the only thing these people have to say is “well if you didn’t want it stolen don’t put it somewhere where I can steal it.” Or “it’s not stolen it’s a bunch of people’s art!” It’s disgusting. Not to mention the fact that those people’s likenesses are permanently online being used by whoever for whatever reason without their permission.
yeah, these people still do not get this, and want to justify the use for it. i don't get why he can't just commission when he is hella rich (he can easily afford 50-$100 for a commission that is WAY better than this stolen shit.
Came looking in the comments for ones like these and the amount of comments in support of his use of AI or saying people are looking for a reason to be mad at him is so concerning
I never buy a bundle without doing my own calculations on the "deal" I can agree James team should of done a discount but the customers should do their best to inform themselves too.
Great to see when the internet drags Hailey Bieber for laminating her eyebrows but Rare beauty skincare packaging is "just what in trend right now."😂😂😂😂
I don't know when everyone decided it was cool to live in everyone else's wallet, but this is really gross, telling people that they need to give their employees a bonus or not is not your decision. a lot of people don't want their financial standing out on the internet, and the fact that Patrick never really shows any of their workers is nice because no one has to feel like they'll be doing their job and all of a sudden Patrick will pop up and will be forced to do a video. I could never imagin e owning a company and having random people that don't work for me, don't buy from me, probably didn't know that I existed a year ago telling me how I should spend my company money. it's so embarrassing.
I think people are so ungrateful and delusional. This was a thoughtful personalized gift. I’m a nurse and I got a canvas tote bag and absolutely no bonuses ever.. like some people just work for a living and don’t get presents and extra money and designers gifts. That’s not the point of Christmas or working for a company. You should just love the work you do. If your main event for the year is what you get for Xmas from your boss revaluate your life please
i will never take the beauty community seriously anymore on who is problematic, the amount of people who STILL support james was the tipping point for me
And if he did give out bonuses on TikTok people would complain about that…you can’t win anymore. People find an issue in EVERYTHING, it’s beyond annoying. Cancel culture has given people way too much confidence in thinking they can control how celebrities/influencers are perceived. This is why when serious shit happens and people are “cancelled” it’s not taken seriously, they take a break and come right back.
Could you imagine the backlash if Patrick posted the cash bonus value they gave their employees? Everyone would think it’s a flex and tacky, yeah using AI isn’t great but we don’t know if they’ve been using it for fun as a collective at work and that may be a reason to have done it? Either way I think the priority is working out why people are happy giving their money to a literal proven and self confessed predator
The Selena/Hailey thing is ridiculous. You can decide to not support someone for immoral values without lying about how much you hate their product and love a product you hated a couple months ago when the internet was stanning Selena. Tell me how all of sudden her AMAZING makeup line became mid and overrated. Just be honest instead of following hive mind. She has some great products. They're great quality. Some things are just more important, and lying about the reason you don't like/want a product discredits the real reason.
that everybody has to judge everything is just annoying. He made something by hand with notes which is very cute. If he would have bragged about giving everyone x amount of money people would be complaining that he is not giving the money to charity. It’s a very unnecessary drama
I'm sure his employees got a bonus and this is a fluff gift. Their employees seem to be appreciative and are having fun. Last year my bonus was a $10 uber eats card. I'm not even joking.
A few months ago there was a trend of pet owners turning their dogs and cats into disney characters with AI. Meanwhile me - a freelance artist - does pet portraits for 25 bucks that I pour a lot of loveand time into and make sure they actually look like the pet. I have sold NONE this entire year.
That is really sad, I hope u get more commissions❣️❣️ ai art looks so cheap and I don’t know why people are still getting them, I don’t mind as a TikTok 30s trend but like the ting Patrick star did for example is so bad. I took a break from my digital practice cuz I am learning traditional art but now I don’t wanna go back to digital 😞 and ai didn’t affect my art journey one bit when it was starting to get buzz, but now I have grown and thinking of pursuing a career, it is starting to be scary Like I am not even kidding when I say those portrait partick star did so look cheap😭😭😭 idk how him as an artist think they r worth spending his time decorating, cuz he just didn’t give it out, he was farming.
@@kaitlynb5467 Aw, thank you a lot! Luckily my other types of art I offer sell well enough so I can pay my bills. And I know, it's a scary time. But if you enjoy doing digital art, pursue it either way! Corporations might go for AI images since they care about profits only, but I do really think there will always be people willing to pay for human made art!
I know this type of stuff is extremely discouraging but please don’t give up and keep trying! It’s easier said than done I know but you will get your ball rolling so fast eventually you will be overwhelmed! Hang in there :)
I think for Christmas bonuses, it's a payment thing that's meant to be discreet, no? But, for artwork, it's a double edge sword. On one hand, there's artist out there that really do need the commission to survive and, it really shuns their artistry. Meaning, people are discrediting the years of artwork they (artist) create. On the other hand, it's easy to get the artwork done easily without spending the dollars
I think it was a nice gesture and who's to say that he did not give them bonuses. Im sure he didnt do this with a "dystopian" goal in mind. Yeah he could have commissioned an artist I agree with that part. But dont take away the sweetness of the gesture.
The thing about the bonus... its rarely given as cash or separate check these days. It's usually given as an item added onto your paycheck/stub, which so many people just have paperless direct deposit for now. It's done with the regular paycheck for that pay period because it's taxable, considered "supplemental income." Anyway point is I agree its unlikely that anyone would hand out checks on camera for bonuses, it would just be weird.
I work for the warehouse that houses Sephora. We got NOTHING. Not a bonus, or a gift. We had to take Christmas as an unpaid day off. A bunch of us couldn’t afford it. Only some of the managers got paid for time off, I was one of the managers that didn’t.
I also would be extremely upset if my employer use my face for AI… I would never willingly give my information to AI, and if my employee did that… Lawsuit
As an artist, I'll explain why AI art is not it other than taking jobs. AI needs source material and AI art will use other artist's work as their database without crediting or even asking them. I have used AI before to generate references, but using was AI spits out and calling it a day is technology assisted art theft.
Everyone is fine with the AI pixar app till an influencer uses it. The disappointment I felt as an artist when I saw my friends and family use AI Pixar knowing they have artist friends. They’re willing to pay $5 for stolen art but insult and degrade artists who charges over $5 for quality art.
For me it seemed like Patrick thought of those gifts last minute, especially with the “I spent 14 hours working on these”, which is probably why he used AI instead of an actual artist. I’m not saying what he did was right or morale, I just kinda understand where he’s coming from.
1. Patrick did a sweet gesture to his employees and gave a gift and everyone loved it, why do people care about him giving bonus to his employees or not 2. James explained why it costs more, and idk if u want to pay less just buy the 2 of em seperately? 3. As the person in the video said the packaging look nothing alike. People should stop hating on everyone lol
i absolutely agree with the ai art thing, commissioning an artist would’ve also been more heartfelt, but you can tell by everyone’s reactions that they still love their gift, and i do love that he thought in depth enough to include the dog, idk maybe that’s just me, but it’s still sweet and the workers obviously did appreciate it
Hi My opinion, minimal fonts were in the use for years, not invented by Rhode only. Besides there is only so many font styles available at some point some similarities will be showing, doesnt necessarily mean it was copied. Let’s not be quick to judge each other spread love ❤
The fact James Charles is still around speaks volumes to what the beauty world considers acceptable.
absolutely. what patrick did is hardly egregious.
100 %
That's not exclusive to the beauty world, you find that in every area of human interest. The biggest example I have is Mark wahlberg. The fact that he was able to become so successful after what he did is revolting. But people are fickle.
@@melissaheil5178 Who said it was?
The fact that him and Jeffrey are still around is such a huge red flag for the industry
Patrick gets criticized, but James Groomer Charles gets to keep doing his sh!at in the beauty world? Why is everyone acting like nothing happened? Double standards at their finest.
A total double standard its due to James being more attractive so he's not thrown away total pretty privilege
@@dionneking8or he just has that white privilege cus if I remembered patrick is filipino or half filipino
@@urmomvia yes but I meant something more pretty privilege it can be as small as smiling at an attractive person and yet frowning or ignoring a lesser attractive person
Can we just stop it with the racial privilege thing, Labeling people by their groups? It leads to awful things label him as an individual for his individual traits and not his skin color or the group he belongs to@@urmomvia
People just want to hate Patrick, but want to keep James for some reason
honestly like what
right??? like, patrick really isn’t that bad. james, however, is probably the worst of the worst of the beauty influencers.
I think Patrick is ignorant, but James Charles is 10× worse. He should literally be in a jail cell, not selling his shitty makeup brand
@@laur83 It's all relative I guess
@@_.B00._this a lot of people are innocent to the true dangers of AI fair enough, James is dangerous to children
as an artist, the ai thing bugs me cause he could've easily commissioned some artists to make original artwork, but the gifts did seem very sweet and heartfelt
also the bonus argument is so dumb, obviously he wouldn't have given out bonus checks for a tiktok, it seems so disingenuous to just hand out money and then film it
agreed, its really not hard at all to find artists that can actually do that shit 10x better than ai and is what you said heartfelt and genuine
The way he was acting like he put so much hard work into it, like all you did was give it a prompt, youre not the one who programmed it or made the art its taking "inspiration"(stealing) from
People would have lost their shit if he posted a video giving them bonus checks. They would find something to complain about like he's touting his wealth.
As a human being I’m tired of the entitlement from artists. If someone wants the quality of art your creating, they’ll buy it. If they don’t stop whining that they’re choosing to use a different source. Especially in these times I cannot imagine not getting a real fucking job, then whining people aren’t spending their hard earned money on my creations. We don’t all have money to spend on your art lmao! We’ll use a source we either have a one time fee for, or at an exceptionally less than the cost of your art. If you want a stable income, get a stable job.
@@ScreamingDucksShotMyMotherthe problem is that ai steals from artists and artists that get their art stolen and incorporated into ai dont get compensated for it at all
Sorry but if you support a predator’s business then getting scammed is the karma 🤷♀️
Yup, if you don’t want to get scammed don’t trust a predator.
Exactly!
That whole situation also screamed "People didn't do their research and just filled their carts only to have buyers' remorse." I would never buy almost $200~ worth of product or bundles without cross referencing them and making sure I'm getting what I'm buying. 🤷♀️
Frfr idk how ppl still support him it’s sad
@@AmberTurdsShittyBedsheetTHIS. This kind of thing happens all the time. This is very telling that people are plucking this out as an issue with Painted. Next time you go to the grocery store, pay attention to your ounce per dollar. Big brands everywhere are fooling buyers with bundles and larger containers only to be charging you higher prices for your laziness on that math. Companies everywhere are doing this and it blows all around. It’s not ethical, but it’s legal and it’s rampant.
Same for shipping issues. PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT YOU BUY BEFORE YOU COMPLETE YOUR ORDERS, yo. It’s that simple.
the whole thing with patrick’s gifts made me roll my eyes, people find anything to be mad at, the gift was cute, some people don’t get anything at work for christmas
I agree with the AI art. But I wouldn’t want my boss filming my reaction to receiving a bonus or anyone else knowing about. Especially social media. That’s a boundary that a lot of people don’t want to cross
My boss doesn’t even want us to discuss it with our colleagues, let alone the internet. I don’t think we need to know that information, plus not everyone gets a Christmas bonus
Agreed. I’d be upset if my boss blasted my financials anywhere. That’s not social media business.
People had become so chronically online this is alarming.
I respect don’t know what will happen if we will have a global disaster
When you become an employee for a company, you normally sign a document saying you consent to being on social media or have your image used for the company so I don’t see the problem with him posting his employees
I don't believe In using ai..it goes against my beliefs. I also think he's cheap not giving out bonuses. Even though I don't celebrate Xmas. It could've been at the top of the year like a new year's bonus..
As someone in the cosmetic skincare industry, Rhode’s packaging was neither innovative or original. It follows the trend of minimalistic and aesthetically pleasing packaging that many other brands had already been doing. A lot of people don’t recognize how design trends intersect across mediums. That blob shaped simple/smooth monochromatic look is just following the same (specifically genz) interior trends, graphic design trends, etc. in the same way rhode was. Brands are more closely following these trends more and more for their packaging as the aesthetics and the “keeping it on the sink” appeal is becoming way more of a major factor in how people decide to buy their skincare now compared to the last decade where people preferred products that looked clean and medicinal. It’s an unfortunate coincidence considering their history but neither of them have original or unique packaging in the first place. You can specifically tell they had this packaging planned in advance because the blob/ambiguous shape trend is already on the way out.
Yes wasn't Kim Kardashian's brand Skkin exactly the same concept just in brown? I think people are reaching to try and create more drama between the two.
@@nikitatavernitilitvynova it was , including skn by Lori Harvey
If it was the other way around people would be crying "sHe wAnTs tO bE SeLeNa sO bAdLy".
@@daria5846 I do not care about either of these people, loved Selena on Wizards of Waverly Place and I don’t know much about Hailey but she’s very beautiful. That’s about it I don’t think about them. This comment doesn’t even make sense because Selena is quite literally getting the response you’re claiming only Hailey would get, we just watched the same video about it. I felt like my comment was relatively neutral in saying neither had original packaging to begin with so I don’t feel like there’s anything to say besides marketing teams trying their hardest to sell the most product by using packaging that is proven to sell.
@@nicolasf7243 Ehhh... ok? It's fine? I'm not sure how you not caring is relevant here Lol but anyway, I'm just pointing out how when Selena is "the bad guy" people tend to be more logical. If it was the other way around the comment section would be pretty different.
As someone that works in packaging design, the Rhode product design isn’t original. It’s minimalism with soft forms, which Is a huge trend in personal care packaging right now.
I remember when Rhode launched everybody was saying it was a Florence by Mills copy like...
The Patrick thing kind of had my hackles raising... not because of him, but because of the backlash he received. He did a sweet thing for his staff, and they seemed appreciative of the fact. Could he have commissioned the art? Sure. However the response from everyone just reminds me that the internet is why we can't have nice things... people just want to attack people, no matter what they do, and it makes me truly sad.
My thoughts exactly
Yeah it's not like he is selling it. Many people were doing it on tiktok for themselves
Agreed. People like to start problems for no reason.
It is not just because he "could have commissioned the art". AI art generators have to have been trained with art that actual artists made in order to function in any capacity, and its not just one or two, or a few hundred pieces either. It is not just taking away potential future jobs from artists, but actively stealing past works and IPs of artists who have not given them permission to make money off of said works.
Honestly I don't think Patrick did it with any malicious or lazy intentions, but that he was just ignorant about how these AI generators work, just like most people. I personally wouldn't fault him for it because he clearly didn't know, even as an illustrator myself who is aware how AI could affect the entire industry as a whole. It'd just be better if he knew, so it's still the right thing to do to inform him.
The whole art instead of bonus thing was incredibly silly though. I doesn't make much sense for him to not give a bonus along with a gift, since its customary to give both in a lot of work places.
do these people have jobs? if so, what did they get at their jobs? they complain but don't mention what their own job gives them for christmas. the people complaining are probably unemployed themselves. lol
Soon as Selena did something people didn’t like, they ran to be on Hailey’s nuts as if they didn’t try to ruin her and her brand before. Internet is a strange place.
😢😢😢
I think supporting a genocide is more than just "doing something people didn't like"
@@melon06h That’s what it is. Thank you for proving my point.
@@melon06hoh please even Hailey has posted pray for Israel along with her husband
@@melon06hthis bull rhetoric is consistently repeated which is false. She has not supported any genocide. Enough with these lies.
Why do people feel entitled to know if Patric's employees got a bonus or not? lol Why on earth would Patrick show or say that publicly on social media? That's usually something that stays within the company and employees
Ughh we have had enough of james cant he just bye sister himself away again💀
But forever this time
I hope if we stop talking about him he’ll go away
Saaaameee
@@Walksonthesky that pedo has far too many weirdos following him
Thats when we stop giving him attention too
Ah yes, influencers. The gift that keeps on giving…THAT NOBODY WANTS😂😭Happy holidays tho☃️
not a fan of AI BUUUTTT.... he clearly put work into the rest of the gift so i don't really care plus like he doesn't need to flaunt giving money to his workers that would be just as weird😭😭
Its funny people are comparing Rhode’s and Rare Beauty’s packaging when they are not the same. When you mentioned it I was expecting the bottles to have the exact same shape but theyre not even close 💀. I also heard from Johnny Ross that Rare Beauty worked with Physical Therapists to design the packaging. Apparently the hand lotion bottle doubles as hand massager and everything is easy to open 👀
i can believe the thing about physical therapists, since Selena said the same thing when she released the original Rare Beauty line. Like people were questioning why there were domes on the lip products and blushes, and she made a whole video explaining how it helps people with arthritis like her. honestly always liked Selena but i have a new level of respect for her when she puts details like that into her products so anyone can use it easily.
The minimalistic design is popular right now, there’s only so many ways you can design minimalist packaging or it defeats the purpose.
The beauty world letting James stay but are getting angry at Patrick speaks VOLUMES
Moral of the story with Patrick: you’re damned if you do and you’re damned if you don’t because someone will always have a problem.
Patrick is a creative person and the idea is super cute but to be able to make those AI pictures the system had to rip off real artist art styles which is the real problem for me. There's a lot of great artist in the internet age and this is like a punch in the face to see him doing this. The bonuses are not our business and frankly I would be uncomfortable if my boss showed to the world how much he's giving me. I'm disappointed but not surprised art is never taken seriously even by other artists (and yes Patrick is an artist make up is art)
I don’t see anyone apply this energy when the world was literally doing AI trends….
@@deme4869if you chose to make high school photos of you and post it on TikTok, or use photos of you as a queen as your profile, you’ve consented to whatever that entails. This was a surprise, I’d appreciate the gift from my boss but I wouldn’t be too happy with AI having my likeness forever, I didn’t press yes to those terms and conditions.
@@deme4869 You may not have seen it, but there were/are artists who have talked about it. Oftentimes their opinions just aren't as wide spread, but that doesn't mean they don't exist- especially the artists whose work is being stolen by AI.
@@deme4869artists have been protesting against AI for pretty much the entire year, especially on twitter. it was central in the SAAG strike. if you dont see people applying this energy, you arent looking.
@@deme4869 You should look into Kelly McKernan. They're really one of the loudest artists that are speaking out against AI.
why are we still supporting the groomer like genuinely why are you giving a platform to his content?
They support groomers, abusers, racist, they really couldn't care less
exactly why tf does she keep talking about him
You know what I got as a bonus for being a teacher…? Another tote bag that says how great of a teacher I am. No check lmao just a tote.
As a dr in spain (public healthcare) i got a pat on the back 😂
Also bonuses are typically given during an end of the year review. In office. Also, private between employer and employee. It would be really weird to give out money in front of everyone.
As an artist, I'm kind of bugged out with AI Art, but I accepted it because AI will become a big thing in the future. I truly do believe Patrick's action were genuine and cute. However more people really need to do their research about AI Art especially it is stealing from other people works. I just accept that AI will take over but it doesn't justify that we still need to but ground rules with AI Art.
Please please let the Selena vs Hailey thing go like society would advance leaps and bounds without it
I love Patrick, but I really agree with the AI thing. I’m an author and it is a big debate in the field too - obviously using AI is 500 times cheaper than commissioning an artist for a design and/or doing a shoot with people…but I am still firmly on the side of artists. Plus the results are just 10 times better and more original. I hate that even very wealthy influencers now go the AI route. So yeah…it’s not a non-issue to me.
I got absolutely nothing from my employer for Christmas. I'd be GLAD to get literally anything, even if it's just a small gift or nice chocolate. You know...something that doesn't make me feel completely unappreciated.
I’ve never had a holiday bonus. Holiday bonuses are not mandatory
People are so hard to please. The employees of Patrick Star enjoyed the party, love the gifts just look at their reactions!
Unless those who hate are his employees then I'll understand. But if the hate comes from those who just want to hate on anything and everything... Happy holidays!❤.
At this point everyone who still supports James should just have a badge saying"I support predators."
Same with Colleen....
Whether or not Patrick gave out bonuses is nobody's business. I seriously don't understand what people are having a fuss over.
Omg exactly, like some people just love to complain and insert their opinions in other peoples business. It’s nearly Christmas, where is the spirit 🤣
People who spend too much time online just want to be pissed about something
Exactly
I agree about AI not being the way to go for a personalized picture of yourself, I wouldn't want to support something that it's feeding off of real art made by real artists. I also don't want anything about me to be a reference to those tools that suck creativity out of people and make someone believe they're an "artist" by asking a machine what to put on a canvas lol. I'm sure Patrick has the money and means to comission someone, he just didn't want to go that route and chose the lazy way out. AI is stealing the work of people that actually put thought on what they are drawing.
Amen!!! Patrick can afford to hire a human artist to do these portraits.
Who the fuck cares? Why do y’all act like you have to support artists or you’re a shit person??
THANK YOU. As a full time illustrator, it’s so frustrating to see AI being used for art. It’s such a lazy shortcut to a craft that people dedicate their entire lives to learning and honing
@@emileek4107 Hi AI developer here! AI is meant ti make our life easier quick and efficient. An artist will take over 3 hours to do this wile an AI takes less then 5 minutes. The AI isn't perfect tho it still struggles to draw noses and hands but as a programmer we are working on that :) Your work is greatly appreciated and it can be made with more details but s project like what Patrick did and AI is not too bad since its something quickly and simple and isn't using a lot amount of details and if he did I don't think the AI would understand it.
@@HahaGoCry so you’re fine taking away jobs from hard-working artists bc a machine is faster? Nice; thanks for your service to the world 🙄
Did you really think I would be impressed by this comment?
My thought on ai are summarized by a random tweet I saw "why would I bother to read/look at something no one bothered to actually write/create"
Bruh idc if its an artist or ai who did it, if i work under him and he gave me this i’d be so happy that my boss thought of me and treat me well! It’s hard to find a boss who treat their employees with such a kind gesture! Even if the gift was cheap he made it by hands!! Warp and wrote by himself thats so kind 🥺🥺
Of course, everyone acted excited. They're LA people and Patrick is their boss.
I thought so too😆
Hating on a POC and a gay person again
@@lawsrealgf8its not about that but ight
Not the "I worked so hard for 14h to refine the ai images" 😭 it's so hard to write some Ai prompts, truly a hard working king /s
selena has interesting packaging, usually not typical shapes, to be more friendly to arthritis bc of her illness and such. i see that in the packaging, easier to grip. idc if it looks like other packaging, its the meaning behind it. i bet hailey probably didnt have that in mind when choosing packaging.
That's pretty great. Wish there was more packaging like that.
Maybe just refillable, arthritis-friendly bottles would be better. I didn't even know that was an option!
I’m sorry the Patrick Starr hate is so dumb. People just looking for something to be mad about, assuming and hating is so ridiculous. It was a cute idea and everyone looked so happy
That's what I was thinking. It was a thoughtful gift. I don't like him, but the fact that he did this by hand makes it pretty cool. I don't know why everyone is so salty about it. Guess their boss' never did anything so special for them
i totally agree. people are REACHING and find anything to complain about.
I agree like come on.
agreed. i would’ve been thrilled with that if i was an employee. it’s a super cute idea.
Fr people are just reaching atp
I find it funny when people say "the beauty community"....like that's NO community its a Circus 😂
No large corporate company will give you a Christmas bonus. People like to talk so much and I assure you 90% of them only had a company dinner
I think it's so vile how everyone was dragging Patrick Starr! especially during the holiday season! He's not problematic AT ALL! He seems like such a sweetheart and, yeah, do I wish he hadn't used AI? OF COURSE. But, look at how happy all his employees were! So weird to assume he didn't get them a christmas bonus. It's not our business whether or not he did give them one, it's between him and his employees!
I would’ve liked those gifts from Patrick. I love personalised gifts and I love Disney. It would’ve gone on my bedroom wall asap. People just want to hate by the looks of it
Some people are really acting as if holiday bonuses are normal anymore (I wish they were). While Patrick for sure could and should have commissioned an artist vs using AI, that doesn't mean holiday bonuses were ever an option unfortunately :( I work at a massive university with profit margins in the millions for this FY alone, and I got a $20 gift card to use downtown that expires and refunds to the sender in 30 days if I don't use it.
Right? I have never received a bonus and I have a big girl job lol we get end of the year raises that start the following year but that’s it.
How dare PS hold a holiday party with personalized gifts (and likely bonuses) and just generally give them all a good holiday party. smh. how could
he
But really, those shipping costs are insane. Every country has it's own rules, but when I wanted to buy a custom hockey mask for my son it was about 100 dollar with USA shipping costs included, but as soon as the package would be here in the Netherlands, the real sh*tshow began: Tax, shipping fee, another tax, customs tax, all in all I would have to spend another 150 dollar just to get the mask in my hands 🤦♀️😱
Yeah, I didn't get it.......
I am not a fan of Patrick, but that was a very sweet idea.
The fact that he did it himself, didn’t make his assistants do it, like most CEOs would is even more wholesome.
The hate he’s getting for this is ridiculous. He probably gave them a bonus and if he didn’t, does anyone have any idea about the salaries and the work conditions he offers? I’m pretty sure the employees would rather he uses AI, prepares the gifts himself instead of spending thousands to hire a few artists to do all of this. That money could go to them instead.
"Customized AI for hours" 😂😂😂😂😂
I do hope Patrick gave his employees a money bonus, because just a picture would suck, but I'm petty so.. and James Charles just needs to go away. He's gross AF
Honestly some people are REACHINGGGGG like lets think about it, why would Patrick actually pay an artist to do it when ai can do it for FREE? Some people need to acknowledge that one size is a BUSINESS and will naturally try to cut cost where it’s able to.
These people are spending over $100 to support a predator
The ai art thing isn’t just that it’s taking jobs, it’s that people are training ai on stolen art. The ai is just mashing different pieces stolen from artists together. Think about it this way: imaging you’re an artist and you made a beautiful piece, you post it online to advertise your struggling business and an ai takes this piece without permission edits it together with some more stolen art and sells it making someone else a profit. It’s theft and the only thing these people have to say is “well if you didn’t want it stolen don’t put it somewhere where I can steal it.” Or “it’s not stolen it’s a bunch of people’s art!” It’s disgusting. Not to mention the fact that those people’s likenesses are permanently online being used by whoever for whatever reason without their permission.
yeah, these people still do not get this, and want to justify the use for it. i don't get why he can't just commission when he is hella rich (he can easily afford 50-$100 for a commission that is WAY better than this stolen shit.
Came looking in the comments for ones like these and the amount of comments in support of his use of AI or saying people are looking for a reason to be mad at him is so concerning
cry
@@mfourxx not to mention his time itself is probably worth more, 14 hours of a famous person like him doesn’t come cheap.
Okay Patrick’s gift was actually so wholesome. Not usually the type to care but it pisses me off the reaction it got from the public.
I never buy a bundle without doing my own calculations on the "deal" I can agree James team should of done a discount but the customers should do their best to inform themselves too.
Speak with your dollars. Avoid problematic creators.
Great to see when the internet drags Hailey Bieber for laminating her eyebrows but Rare beauty skincare packaging is "just what in trend right now."😂😂😂😂
Rare beauty skincare line packaging is lie rohde !!!!! These people have some serious eye sight 😂
I thought the gift was cute. No one is grateful for anything anymore, he didn’t have to get them anything. Bonuses are great but not mandatory.
I don't know when everyone decided it was cool to live in everyone else's wallet, but this is really gross, telling people that they need to give their employees a bonus or not is not your decision. a lot of people don't want their financial standing out on the internet, and the fact that Patrick never really shows any of their workers is nice because no one has to feel like they'll be doing their job and all of a sudden Patrick will pop up and will be forced to do a video. I could never imagin e owning a company and having random people that don't work for me, don't buy from me, probably didn't know that I existed a year ago telling me how I should spend my company money. it's so embarrassing.
people would rather have the money those frame's cost
I think people are so ungrateful and delusional. This was a thoughtful personalized gift. I’m a nurse and I got a canvas tote bag and absolutely no bonuses ever.. like some people just work for a living and don’t get presents and extra money and designers gifts. That’s not the point of Christmas or working for a company. You should just love the work you do. If your main event for the year is what you get for Xmas from your boss revaluate your life please
i will never take the beauty community seriously anymore on who is problematic, the amount of people who STILL support james was the tipping point for me
And if he did give out bonuses on TikTok people would complain about that…you can’t win anymore. People find an issue in EVERYTHING, it’s beyond annoying. Cancel culture has given people way too much confidence in thinking they can control how celebrities/influencers are perceived. This is why when serious shit happens and people are “cancelled” it’s not taken seriously, they take a break and come right back.
THANK YOU👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Could you imagine the backlash if Patrick posted the cash bonus value they gave their employees? Everyone would think it’s a flex and tacky, yeah using AI isn’t great but we don’t know if they’ve been using it for fun as a collective at work and that may be a reason to have done it? Either way I think the priority is working out why people are happy giving their money to a literal proven and self confessed predator
it would've been so easy to just commission on artist instead of using AI, but the idea was really cute won't lie
he doesnt have to commission an artist u geek
@@GFBSTPPIso it’s fine to steal art to you? And resell stolen art?
@@Varikas steal art? LMAOOOOO
@@GFBSTPPI yes, ai art is fueled by stealing art LMAOOOO
@@GFBSTPPI AI is basically stealing art from different artists and using it just makes it worse
It is bad, you're just too dumb to understand
Everyone saying they wouldn't want an AI generated portrait as a gift. Well it's a gosh darn good thing the gifts weren't for you.
i’m DISGUSTED people are still not worrying about their own lives. who cares what celebs give their workers & friends??? so rude
The Selena/Hailey thing is ridiculous. You can decide to not support someone for immoral values without lying about how much you hate their product and love a product you hated a couple months ago when the internet was stanning Selena. Tell me how all of sudden her AMAZING makeup line became mid and overrated. Just be honest instead of following hive mind. She has some great products. They're great quality. Some things are just more important, and lying about the reason you don't like/want a product discredits the real reason.
I’m so over minimal packaging. I need some pizzazz
that everybody has to judge everything is just annoying. He made something by hand with notes which is very cute. If he would have bragged about giving everyone x amount of money people would be complaining that he is not giving the money to charity. It’s a very unnecessary drama
Completely agree w you!!!
I'm sure his employees got a bonus and this is a fluff gift. Their employees seem to be appreciative and are having fun.
Last year my bonus was a $10 uber eats card. I'm not even joking.
People being make at Patrick is so silly omg
From thirty years ago to today's world is disturbing.
The ai is the worst part of that story. Im so absolutely disappointed in other creatives using ai as long as its not their job being affected by ai.
I don't understand how James still has fans and an audience.
A few months ago there was a trend of pet owners turning their dogs and cats into disney characters with AI.
Meanwhile me - a freelance artist - does pet portraits for 25 bucks that I pour a lot of loveand time into and make sure they actually look like the pet. I have sold NONE this entire year.
That is really sad, I hope u get more commissions❣️❣️ ai art looks so cheap and I don’t know why people are still getting them, I don’t mind as a TikTok 30s trend but like the ting Patrick star did for example is so bad. I took a break from my digital practice cuz I am learning traditional art but now I don’t wanna go back to digital 😞 and ai didn’t affect my art journey one bit when it was starting to get buzz, but now I have grown and thinking of pursuing a career, it is starting to be scary
Like I am not even kidding when I say those portrait partick star did so look cheap😭😭😭 idk how him as an artist think they r worth spending his time decorating, cuz he just didn’t give it out, he was farming.
what’s your handle or how do we order
@@kaitlynb5467 Aw, thank you a lot! Luckily my other types of art I offer sell well enough so I can pay my bills. And I know, it's a scary time. But if you enjoy doing digital art, pursue it either way! Corporations might go for AI images since they care about profits only, but I do really think there will always be people willing to pay for human made art!
I know this type of stuff is extremely discouraging but please don’t give up and keep trying! It’s easier said than done I know but you will get your ball rolling so fast eventually you will be overwhelmed! Hang in there :)
As long as he gave them Christmas bonuses, I see nothing wrong with the Ai portraits. It was sweet.
I think for Christmas bonuses, it's a payment thing that's meant to be discreet, no?
But, for artwork, it's a double edge sword. On one hand, there's artist out there that really do need the commission to survive and, it really shuns their artistry. Meaning, people are discrediting the years of artwork they (artist) create. On the other hand, it's easy to get the artwork done easily without spending the dollars
I think it was a nice gesture and who's to say that he did not give them bonuses. Im sure he didnt do this with a "dystopian" goal in mind. Yeah he could have commissioned an artist I agree with that part. But dont take away the sweetness of the gesture.
The thing about the bonus... its rarely given as cash or separate check these days. It's usually given as an item added onto your paycheck/stub, which so many people just have paperless direct deposit for now. It's done with the regular paycheck for that pay period because it's taxable, considered "supplemental income." Anyway point is I agree its unlikely that anyone would hand out checks on camera for bonuses, it would just be weird.
The way they just assume he didn’t give them a Christmas bonus is gross to me.
Honestly rare's packaging reminds me way more of Kim Kardashians skincare packaging
People shouldn’t assume they didn’t get a bonus, my job gave bonus’ and also a large gift too.
“Lazy”, but hand assembles 100 gifts. I’m so glad I’m not gifting to these people.
The outrage over Patrick using Ai to make cute gifts for his employees is ridiculous. My goodness people stop being so chronically online
I work for the warehouse that houses Sephora. We got NOTHING. Not a bonus, or a gift. We had to take Christmas as an unpaid day off. A bunch of us couldn’t afford it. Only some of the managers got paid for time off, I was one of the managers that didn’t.
7:45 James Charles be looking like Kim kardashians mom, proper middle aged woman
I also would be extremely upset if my employer use my face for AI… I would never willingly give my information to AI, and if my employee did that… Lawsuit
As an artist, I'll explain why AI art is not it other than taking jobs.
AI needs source material and AI art will use other artist's work as their database without crediting or even asking them. I have used AI before to generate references, but using was AI spits out and calling it a day is technology assisted art theft.
thats the exact same things human artists do, get inspiration from other art and artists and use that to create their own
@@GFBSTPPI except AI isnt a person creating something with their own hard work. They are just using other people's work point blank.
@@ArringtonJohnson just like human artists lmao. yall just mad a computer can do something in 2 minutes what it takes yall hours to do
Shut up😊
OMG that Rare Beauty looks like a RHODE in pink.-.... cray cray
this whole video was just a backup of my theory that ppl will complain or find anything to complain about.
The fact anyone is paying hundreds for a James Charles product is beyond me. Predator palate
Everyone is fine with the AI pixar app till an influencer uses it. The disappointment I felt as an artist when I saw my friends and family use AI Pixar knowing they have artist friends. They’re willing to pay $5 for stolen art but insult and degrade artists who charges over $5 for quality art.
looks like the only people upset are the ones who didn't get the holiday gift and secret bonus.
For me it seemed like Patrick thought of those gifts last minute, especially with the “I spent 14 hours working on these”, which is probably why he used AI instead of an actual artist. I’m not saying what he did was right or morale, I just kinda understand where he’s coming from.
1. Patrick did a sweet gesture to his employees and gave a gift and everyone loved it, why do people care about him giving bonus to his employees or not
2. James explained why it costs more, and idk if u want to pay less just buy the 2 of em seperately?
3. As the person in the video said the packaging look nothing alike.
People should stop hating on everyone lol
so first guy basically got free art and then gave it as gifts....
i absolutely agree with the ai art thing, commissioning an artist would’ve also been more heartfelt, but you can tell by everyone’s reactions that they still love their gift, and i do love that he thought in depth enough to include the dog, idk maybe that’s just me, but it’s still sweet and the workers obviously did appreciate it
I think the Patrick Star gift was beautiful… I would have been honored to receive it ❤️
ppl have bones to pick with james ab the price of his makeup and NOT with him admitting to being a predator??
Patrick should have hired an artist, he’s being cheap. I hope he gave them nice bonuses
That minimalist style to packaging is not owned by Haley or selena, they didn't create it.
Hi My opinion, minimal fonts were in the use for years, not invented by Rhode only. Besides there is only so many font styles available at some point some similarities will be showing, doesnt necessarily mean it was copied. Let’s not be quick to judge each other spread love ❤