extra metrics for GKs that I think would reveal the keeper quality would be: 1. avg xg per shot that resulted in a goal 2. avg xg per shot parried/held/etc
Good ideas. I think both of those would benefit more from being measured in terms of PSxG (Post Shot xG) which takes into consideration the actual placement of the shot. We can only hope that gets included in future FMs!
I think a lot of the choices you make to gather information is why I preferred Kevin Hitchcock compared to Dmitri Kharine. Another Moneyball Glossary poorly explained well! edit- I forgot how to language
Not related, but Dmitri Kharine is my avatar for Hotmail/Outlook. A decision I made 25 years ago. I have no idea why. I refuse to change it because it confuses me to the point of laughter every time.
Hi, I really like your videos I and I congratulate you for all of them. I just wanted to know if there was a mustermann skin but were we can also see the numerical stats.I know last year there was one but can i put it on fm 24 ? And if not how could i do please ?
No, the Mustermann Iconic skin is attributeless and there are no plans to release an attributed version. The FM23 skin will not support any of the changes brought in for FM24 (for example, the set piece creator)
Sorry if the answer doesn't match the content of he video. But I wonder how do you assess the players intelligence or movement based on the statistics? For exaple if a centre-back is good at marking, positioning and he doesn't switch off (concentration). Do you take a glance at attributes?
Of course I use the attributes, just in a far more broad sense (e.g. the ranges used in the skin and discussed in every one of these videos). That said, intelligence and movement can be assessed through Possession Won/Lost metrics for most outfield positions. A player with good positional discipline is likely to regain possession at a higher rate. A player with good decisions/vision is likely to lose possession less frequently (although, always consider that in respect to other actions - e.g. a creative player might lose the ball more often than a safe player, but a more intelligent creative player will lose it less often than other creative players with lower decision making abilities)
Love your videos. Suggestion. These hidden gems could be compared with more recognizable players in similar roles, but in higher leves of course. I mean, I would love to know what's Ter Stegen Save quality in Barcelona, and if it compares with players on this list..
A great suggestion! Something I considered when I started this series but ultimately found lacked in nuance when there is such wide variety to player profiles. Perhaps easier with keepers where there's very few roles/archetypes. I'll revisit it and possibly change things around for FM25!!
A great option. A player who made it down to my final 37* but fell short. 78% Save Ratio (53% parried), 0.36 xGP (28% xGP Ratio), 12.11 Passes Completed (52.14% accuracy), 3.34 Possessions Won. *I don't specifically refine down to 37. I identify as many options as I can, remove those whose contract started in 2023. Scout/filter the remainder for adaptability, big matches, consistency. That just happened to be 37 players this time. The final 9 (or 7 in this case) is based on transfer fee/wage demands/teams they're willing to sign for)
Question! 🙋🏻♂️ The difference in minutes played between your selections are quite significant. There’s a couple of choices around 3,500 minutes compared to one choice that could boast over 33,000. That makes me think at least a couple of your selections were not first choice at their respective clubs. If that was the case and their performance data has been mostly earned from cup games - where there’s a much wider level of skill faced - might having a larger selection of those games help trend their stats upwards somewhat? Oh and one more thing - an automatic disqualification for any GK or DC choice should be having a height under 6ft! I find this game is actively heightist - something I’m sure anyone else that has managed in any Asian leagues can attest to!
You know when I said the words "backup keeper", that's because they are backup keeers 😂 There is a discrepancy, and certainly the larger the data set, the more confidence you can have in an assessment. As mentioned in the description, player data was only exported for those who registered more than 900 minutes in a simulation (the equivalent of 10 full games), and then only included in the final data set if they met that threshold in at least 2 of the 10 simulations. Subsequently, that means that players have featured in at least 20 games. Yes, I checked to see that the majority of their performances came in league games, but you are right that otherwise that could distort their figures. In all instances (Zivkovic, Femenias & Gudino) they got their game time due to injuries to the starters. Keepers and defenders under 6 foot are perfectly fine if you plan accordingly. I certainly wouldn't advise a whole defensive unit constructed of such. When watching through highlights of de Arruabarrena only 1 goal could be chalked down to sub-optimal aerial reach. It is neither a concern in his attributes or his performance. It is also worth adding that the Portuguese league attempts an above average number of crosses (34.21 vs 29.74 per game) and completes just below average (15.10% vs 15.16%).
good video watched on my ps5 , i also want to thank you on your right back video u highlighted a player from celta vigo called oscar , as i play as liverpool as a liverpool fan i was after a right back so gomez could play centre back more often and give connor bradley more time to develop , you said he was good but not how good , liverpool push for champions league and oscar scores mid 7s and even scores and gets lots assists a great back up for trent thank you
When I say players can perform for elite sides, I mean it!! I'm not interested in that clickbait/hyperbole, just thoroughly researched, sensible suggestions driven by data.
@@DavidVenters I've not played the console version, so unfortunately not sure of the limitations. I would consider prioritising views on squad pages that will give you your key metrics for each area. Also, if you don't already, check out FMConsole on UA-cam. He's done some stuff on Moneyball specifically for console players!!
extra metrics for GKs that I think would reveal the keeper quality would be:
1. avg xg per shot that resulted in a goal
2. avg xg per shot parried/held/etc
Good ideas. I think both of those would benefit more from being measured in terms of PSxG (Post Shot xG) which takes into consideration the actual placement of the shot. We can only hope that gets included in future FMs!
I think a lot of the choices you make to gather information is why I preferred Kevin Hitchcock compared to Dmitri Kharine. Another Moneyball Glossary poorly explained well!
edit- I forgot how to language
Not related, but Dmitri Kharine is my avatar for Hotmail/Outlook. A decision I made 25 years ago. I have no idea why. I refuse to change it because it confuses me to the point of laughter every time.
@@mustermannfm Approved!
Hi, I really like your videos I and I congratulate you for all of them. I just wanted to know if there was a mustermann skin but were we can also see the numerical stats.I know last year there was one but can i put it on fm 24 ? And if not how could i do please ?
No, the Mustermann Iconic skin is attributeless and there are no plans to release an attributed version. The FM23 skin will not support any of the changes brought in for FM24 (for example, the set piece creator)
Sorry if the answer doesn't match the content of he video. But I wonder how do you assess the players intelligence or movement based on the statistics? For exaple if a centre-back is good at marking, positioning and he doesn't switch off (concentration). Do you take a glance at attributes?
Of course I use the attributes, just in a far more broad sense (e.g. the ranges used in the skin and discussed in every one of these videos).
That said, intelligence and movement can be assessed through Possession Won/Lost metrics for most outfield positions. A player with good positional discipline is likely to regain possession at a higher rate. A player with good decisions/vision is likely to lose possession less frequently (although, always consider that in respect to other actions - e.g. a creative player might lose the ball more often than a safe player, but a more intelligent creative player will lose it less often than other creative players with lower decision making abilities)
@@mustermannfm Great answer, thanks! I'm starting to dive deep in this game style and this kind of questions are keeping me up late at night 😅
Slough town top? From around the area or have you done FM save in the past would love to know as live directly opposite where they play
I will reply with a link to another channel: ua-cam.com/video/t79lflK-n8Q/v-deo.htmlsi=FlNSVyfpaK1ddj3X
Love your videos. Suggestion. These hidden gems could be compared with more recognizable players in similar roles, but in higher leves of course. I mean, I would love to know what's Ter Stegen Save quality in Barcelona, and if it compares with players on this list..
A great suggestion! Something I considered when I started this series but ultimately found lacked in nuance when there is such wide variety to player profiles. Perhaps easier with keepers where there's very few roles/archetypes. I'll revisit it and possibly change things around for FM25!!
My GK of choice is pontus dahlberg. Solid 3 mil GK who received 2 times GK of the year with Udinese. Curious to see his performance in your database
A great option. A player who made it down to my final 37* but fell short.
78% Save Ratio (53% parried), 0.36 xGP (28% xGP Ratio), 12.11 Passes Completed (52.14% accuracy), 3.34 Possessions Won.
*I don't specifically refine down to 37. I identify as many options as I can, remove those whose contract started in 2023. Scout/filter the remainder for adaptability, big matches, consistency. That just happened to be 37 players this time. The final 9 (or 7 in this case) is based on transfer fee/wage demands/teams they're willing to sign for)
Question! 🙋🏻♂️
The difference in minutes played between your selections are quite significant.
There’s a couple of choices around 3,500 minutes compared to one choice that could boast over 33,000.
That makes me think at least a couple of your selections were not first choice at their respective clubs.
If that was the case and their performance data has been mostly earned from cup games - where there’s a much wider level of skill faced - might having a larger selection of those games help trend their stats upwards somewhat?
Oh and one more thing - an automatic disqualification for any GK or DC choice should be having a height under 6ft!
I find this game is actively heightist - something I’m sure anyone else that has managed in any Asian leagues can attest to!
You know when I said the words "backup keeper", that's because they are backup keeers 😂
There is a discrepancy, and certainly the larger the data set, the more confidence you can have in an assessment. As mentioned in the description, player data was only exported for those who registered more than 900 minutes in a simulation (the equivalent of 10 full games), and then only included in the final data set if they met that threshold in at least 2 of the 10 simulations. Subsequently, that means that players have featured in at least 20 games.
Yes, I checked to see that the majority of their performances came in league games, but you are right that otherwise that could distort their figures. In all instances (Zivkovic, Femenias & Gudino) they got their game time due to injuries to the starters.
Keepers and defenders under 6 foot are perfectly fine if you plan accordingly. I certainly wouldn't advise a whole defensive unit constructed of such. When watching through highlights of de Arruabarrena only 1 goal could be chalked down to sub-optimal aerial reach. It is neither a concern in his attributes or his performance.
It is also worth adding that the Portuguese league attempts an above average number of crosses (34.21 vs 29.74 per game) and completes just below average (15.10% vs 15.16%).
i let it crust
Have you take down your CB video I carnt see it. Great content as always
There isn't a CB video yet!
@mustermannfm oh sorry my mistake. I thought I seen a CB but I might have been just players from your midfield video who can also play CB sorry
It is finally here! ua-cam.com/video/AEY89TLqkV4/v-deo.html
I could watch this all day,love it 👏👏👏👏
Much appreciated, dude!!
Finding GKs is now easier (for a little bit...)
Anotther good video! do you run the simulation every time for each new video (database) or you did it once and reuse it
No, I reuse the same database.
good video watched on my ps5 , i also want to thank you on your right back video u highlighted a player from celta vigo called oscar , as i play as liverpool as a liverpool fan i was after a right back so gomez could play centre back more often and give connor bradley more time to develop , you said he was good but not how good , liverpool push for champions league and oscar scores mid 7s and even scores and gets lots assists a great back up for trent thank you
When I say players can perform for elite sides, I mean it!! I'm not interested in that clickbait/hyperbole, just thoroughly researched, sensible suggestions driven by data.
@@mustermannfm as im autistic i like stats how can i come close on ps5
@@DavidVenters I've not played the console version, so unfortunately not sure of the limitations. I would consider prioritising views on squad pages that will give you your key metrics for each area.
Also, if you don't already, check out FMConsole on UA-cam. He's done some stuff on Moneyball specifically for console players!!
What's a keeper?
They're the player whose sole purpose is to be the scapegoat for every goal conceded
@@mustermannfm thought so
Love the intro
Thank you, dude! It is probably the dumbest thing I've done yet (and I've done plenty of dumb things so far)