Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on UA-cam & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
Can you please give me references from sunni books about the Event of Ghadeer. As many of our sunni brothers and sisters are of denial or are ignorant of this event.
Here ITALIAN reverted to SHIA and I can understand every single word u use, so good. I would really like to have THE REFERENCE for evey hadith or quran ayat. JazakAllah. It will help me searching quickly for them and save them in my computer.
We haven't uploaded these episodes for arguments sake. By the way, shouldn't this encourage you to look into the fact that such narrations are present in Bukhari.
No words to express my gratitude Syed Indeed the worst of enemies of prophet of Allah was not the idol worshippers but these hypocrites Ya Allah my prophet sawaws suffered so much A couple of years back My non muslim friend shared a very disturbing bukhari hadith with me regarding Ayesha married to prophet while playing with dolls and all .. nauzobillah She wanted its authenticity and by the grace of almighty alhamdulillah i got some really good explanations from our Shia scholars and shared with her.. These indecent hadiths and fabrications have done a great damage to the religion of islam. They have hurt our prophet sawaws in his life and after he passed away.. Masha Allah we have role models like syeda Fatima Zahra s.a. and syeda zainab s.a. to look upto.. Ya Allah swt help us to cling to the rope of Allah, household of your beloved prophet sawaws,his progeny a.s. The true infallibles.. In shaa Allah aameen Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a.. Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor. Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’" Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed." Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
What we have is our ability to reason. We were not present in those times. But with time we know much about human nature. If Aisha was 10 years old when she married the Prophet saw, and was with him for 8 years, according to main sources, she was not much more than a child, and adolescent in those years. How much of what comes from the thinking of children is tempered with reason or clarity, or even honesty?
And why you see her as child when it comes to Prophet as and anyway you take her childish and maybe naive to be your source of knowledge? It doesn’t make sense
@@Thaqlain 24:50 you are revealing what you really did. You, yourself, are claiming you are not claiming all is Sahih. How interesting. So cite all the hadiths in text that you spoke of in the lecture word for word and let's see what you are really quoting. Why would you even Quote hadith that you aren't even sure is Sahih in the first place?
To show that even your own books present her character as controversial hence we cannot take Sunnah of the Prophet from someone with such controversial character.
Allahume Sale Ale Mohamad wale ale Mohamad Selamün Aleykum, I have a question, does Ayesha have lied about tahrif of quran? Will there be a video about this? JazakAllah khayr.
Alaykum Salaam. The goal here is to explore how Ayesha is a controversial figure and unreliable source for religious guidelines and Sunnah. So we will limit to that only :)
@@jamaludenumpat2449 what benefit can you gain when in your bookd of ahadeeth says rasoollah cursed overweight Muawiah, sahaba cursed imam Ali. Lots of cursing in your sunni books of ahadeeth. Double standards.
I am shia and when I was a Sunni and hearing about Aisha I have to admit I didn’t liked her bcs of she was showed as someone who was jealous. I will be honest , although I’m not impressed by her person I’m not showing her disrespect bcs she was a wife of Muhammad sawa. I’m living her to Allah swt.
You are not a Sunni. For all Sunnis, Aisha is the best woman in the entire ummah of Muhammad, second to none. She is the most beloved person to Muhammad bar none.
@gq55sqgq55sqdoa don't know what's funny when the most important man in the islamic world the one that god spoke to said himself that out of all his wives aisha was his favourite
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a.. Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor. Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’" Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed." Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
@@Thaqlain Did Fatima r.a or Ali r.a ever claimed it was for them?? Read Qur'an and judge people.. (Quran 33:32). O wives of the Prophet! You are not like any ordinary women. If you keep your duty (to Allah), then be not soft in speech, lest he in whose heart is a disease should be moved with desire, but speak in an honourable manner. 33. And stay in your houses, and do not display yourselves like that of the times of ignorance, and perform As-Salat (Iqamat-as-Salat), and give Zakat and obey Allah and His Messenger. Allah wishes only to remove Ar-Rijs (evil deeds and sins, etc.) from you, O members of the family (of the Prophet ), and to purify you with a thorough purification. 34. And remember (O you the members of the Prophet’s family, the Graces of your Lord), that which is recited in your houses of the Verses of Allah and Al-Hikmah (i.e. Prophet’s Sunnah legal ways, etc. so give your thanks to Allah and glorify His Praises for this Qur’an and the Sunnah). Verily, Allah is Ever Most Courteous, Well-Acquainted with all things.
@@Thaqlain Neither Prophet s.a.w can marry other women nor wives of prophet can marry other men.. Allah has made special laws for them.. These Ahlul Bayt are different from ordinary people.. (Quran 33:52). It is not lawful for you (O Prophet to marry other) women after this, nor to change them for other wives ...And Allah is Ever a Watcher over all things. 53. O you who believe! Enter not the Prophet’s houses, except when leave is given to you for a meal, (and then) not (so early as) to wait for its preparation. But when you are invited, enter, and when you have taken your meal, disperse, without sitting for a talk. Verily, such (behaviour) annoys the Prophet, and he is shy of (asking) you (to go), but Allah is not shy of (telling you) the truth. And when you ask (his wives) for anything you want, ask them from behind a screen, that is purer for your hearts and for their hearts. And it is not (right) for you that you should annoy Allah’s Messenger, nor that you should ever marry his wives after him (his death). Verily! With Allah that shall be an enormity. 54. Whether you reveal anything or conceal it, verily, Allah is Ever All-Knower of everything. 55. It is no sin on them (the Prophet’s wives, if they appear unveiled) before their fathers, or their sons, or their brothers, or their brother’s sons, or the sons of their sisters, or their own (believing) women, or their (female) slaves, and keep your duty to Allah. Verily, Allah is Ever All-Witness over everything. 56. Allah sends His Salat (Graces, Honours, Blessings, Mercy, etc.) on the Prophet (Muhammad ) and also His angels too (ask Allah to bless and forgive him). O you who believe! Send your Salat on (ask Allah to bless) him (Muhammad ), and (you should) greet (salute) him with the Islamic way of greeting (salutation i.e. As-Salamu ‘Alaikum). 57. Verily, those who annoy Allah and His Messenger () Allah has cursed them in this world, and in the Hereafter, and has prepared for them a humiliating torment. 58. And those who annoy believing men and women undeservedly, bear on themselves the crime of slander and plain sin.
Can my sunni brothers clarify a question. If someone goes to war against the Ahlebait, are they true Muslims and be respected??? Aisha fought against Imam Ali (AS) in the battle of Jamel.
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
That is what the scholars are telling you. The biggest cover up. Read the quran. Addresses the wives 5 times. Read carefully what Allah says. Some desire this world and some desire the hereafter. Look at the verse where she and Hafsa go against rasoollah and she even disobeyed and went to fight Ali. The shia are correct. I did so much research if you analyse the verses. Don't follow interpretations from hater ibn tayyimah and ibk katheer. He did a lot of copy plaigarism and changed the words.
@user-eh2pv4sc7h Probably the biggest cover up was the event at Ghadeer, where the Holy Prophet was ordered by Allah to name his successor. Ali was appointed and all Muslims present were ordered to pay their allegiance. Even Umar khattab congratulated Ali on his position. But look what happened after the death of the Holy Prophet. So called Muslims gathered outside Ali's House to demand his loyalty to the new regime. And tragically Lady Fatima was martyred as a result of them setting fire to the house. All this is documented in sunni reference books. If only the Muslims had stuck with the orders of the Holy Prophet. If only........
@bolero4554 Your beloved muawiyah and his son not extremists ?? Read the tragedy of karbala and the so called Muslims who took part in the slaughter of the family of the Holy Prophet to realise who the extremists are. That is why we follow the Ahlebait, who are free from sin, pure in thought and are infallible. If only the ummah had followed the orders of the Holy Prophet at Ghadeer, after his death. If only.
Sahih al-Bukhari 4350 Narrated Buraida: The Prophet (ﷺ) sent `Ali to Khalid to bring the Khumus (of the booty) and I hated `Ali, and `Ali had taken a bath (after a sexual act with a slave-girl from the Khumus). I said to Khalid, "Don't you see this (i.e. `Ali)?" When we reached the Prophet (ﷺ) I mentioned that to him. He said, "O Buraida! Do you hate `Ali?" I said, "Yes."
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
Jazakallah. Whats the refrence for suicidal hadith? I'm currently debating with someone in regards to this matter and they say they believe in this Hadith because Prophets can make mistakes according to Quran and they don't do it only because Allah stops them from doing so. They mentioned how Prophet Adam (as) did what allah asked him not to do and how Prophet Yousuf (as) would've fallen for the trap of the Ruler's wife behind 7 doors if Allah didn’t stop him. So how do i argue about that? Theyre basically implying without Allah's help and support Prophets can commit sins
Your last line is correct -- Prophets can commit sins. But they don't. We have covered this in detail in various episodes of this series. Before debating, it is important to understand the underlying belief system and the intended goals. The reason Ahl al-Sunnah believes in Prophet commiting sins and mistakes is to justify the sinful behaviour of later caliphs. For the School of Ahlulbayt, Prophets not commiting sins is a core belief as we believe the leaders after the Prophet need to be infallible too.
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a.. Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor. Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’" Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed." Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
@@zainabb978 no they don’t but Aisha needs defending whereas lady fatima doesn’t as No one slanders her. However you guys treated aisha like a dog and have abu jahal in higher status than her.
I respect your work and effort in educating the public . But how does this correlate with the fatwa/decree of our Maraji “Insulting the personalities of Sunni brethren, including the wives of all the Prophets, in particular those of the Leader of the Prophets and accusing the wife of the Prophet of Islam, is forbidden (haram)”.
It is not that you are not speaking the truth. But I hope you realize that while you sit in the safety of your home and country, some innocent Shia will lose his life as retaliation in Pakistan, Afghanistan and other places. And to clarify, I am a Shia myself.
@@bukhariali71 You think Sunnis need an excuse in order to assassinate Shi’a? They have been doing this for more than a thousand years, regardless of whether Shi’a were loud, quiet, peaceful, angry, whatever Under the “leadership” of people like Khamenei, Shi’a within Pakistan alone have been bombarded and harassed for decades (LONG before such criticism as this video was even available on the internet). So I don’t think such leaders have any right to speak on the subject anymore, when their approach has not been productive in stifling Wahhabi psychosis whatsoever
We have most of our learned Ulemas in Pakistan working really hard to create an atmosphere of harmony and respect between sects. Lectures like these totally whitewashes their efforts. Again, it is not about hiding the truth, but the goal has to have a deeper purpose. If anything, follow the example of our 1st Imam after all the hardships he had to endure after the events @ his door and his rights being taken away. Even after the battle of Jamal, he was respectful to Aisha just because of her relationship with our Prophet (pbuh and his family).
@@bukhariali71 What?? I can show you video clips of Pakistani scholars literally mocking Aisha & the Three Khulafa, what are you talking about? If by “harmony” you just mean “Save your criticism for only private events & speeches”, then that is an entirely different discussion from “Don’t criticize them at all” As for Imam Ali, you’re saying that drawing a sword against a woman and her followers is somehow more “respectful” than simply citing her flaws from Sunnis’ OWN books? In what universe is this true? Has any Shi’a critic of Aisha started executing her followers in open combat yet??
Salaam Alaykum. We appreciate your thoughts on this matter. However, this episode is a part of 300+ episodes where we are compiling the Seerah of the Prophet of Islam. The question we are answering in the current episode is simple: why do Shias not take the Seerah/Sunnah of the Prophet from a figure like Ayesha, who has quoted hundreds of hadith from the Prophet? So it is purely an academic/objective discussion with no insult involved.
Maybe Aeisha was honest and true to what she had seen and heard. Muhammad and his friends were not a very good person we can see how his followers are today.
Don't insult family of Prophet.. It's personal matter of wife and Husband... (Quran 33:6). The Prophet is closer to the believers than their ownselves, and his wives are their (believers’) mothers. (Quran 33:32). O wives of the Prophet! You are not like any other women. If you keep your duty (to Allah), then be not soft in speech, lest he in whose heart is a disease (of hypocrisy, or evil desire ) should be moved with desire, but speak in an honourable manner. 33. And stay in your houses, and do not display yourselves like that of the times of ignorance, and perform As-Salat (Iqamat-as-Salat), and give Zakat and obey Allah and His Messenger. Allah wishes only to remove Ar-Rijs (evil deeds and sins, etc.) from you, O members of the family (of the Prophet ), and to purify you with a thorough purification. 34. And remember (O you the members of the Prophet’s family, the Graces of your Lord), that which is recited in your houses of the Verses of Allah and Al-Hikmah (i.e. Prophet’s Sunnah legal ways, etc. so give your thanks to Allah and glorify His Praises for this Qur’an and the Sunnah). Verily, Allah is Ever Most Courteous, Well-Acquainted with all things.
@hussamuddin2361 Personal matter? Aaisha said a lot of "personal" things in sahih bukhari that some would consider inappropriate. Did you even watch this video before commenting?
The only thing I get from all the hadees that the physical abuse towards women come from the followers of these books. Jazakallah khair for Educating Muslims. Islam Religion of Peace. Also follow the last Sermon of the Rasool Allah for guidance.
The main purpose of this lecture is not to blame anybody but to tell people that we can't take sunnah from such a person who is controversial and had narrated hadiths like this . When we have the best ladies and best role models like lady Fatima,Lady Khadija,Lady Asiya and lady Maryam (A.S)
Sahih Muslim 2540 - Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: Do not revile my Companions, do not revile my Companions. By Him in Whose Hand is my life, if one amongst you would have spent as much gold as Uhud it would not amount to as much as one much on behalf of one of them or half of it.
@@Thaqlain When it comes to the Sahaba, there aren't any wicked companions of the prophet pbuh. Yet, Shias claim as such, which directly goes against the hadith quoted above.
I think there’s a lot of slander against Aisha and most of it is hard to claim. Unless Allah has stated she is of a bad character, these statements shouldn’t be taken so seriously.
So then it technically becomes Sunnah, right? All men should read the Quran while putting their heads in the laps of their wives, especially when they are menstruating? Why are we never told of this Sunnah?
I hope this idea focusing sayeda aisha theme on battle of jamal Instead of sayidina imam ali themes Is a minor perspective of our brother in shia madzhab Not majority (olny hoping) Is the same when u focusing on abu jahl act to Rosulullah saww and his follower Instead of focusing on Rosulullah saww ahlak Imho If we want to focus on improving our ahlak Focus on teaching and ahlak our patrons Not focusing the opposite Right or wrong Good or bad Etc Sayeda aisha always be our mother (according to quran it self) If we still call our self muslim, Rosulullah saww was our patronese and quran as the source Is un negotiable
How is he sure that Ayesha made those fabrications? It's even possible that the people who supported her made those fabrications & disseminated in her name. I am sunni, but those hadiths that he mentioned always seem to be doubtful.
no proof it seems.because they giving their own interpretations.of hadith which has no further evidence but twisting the meanings of hadiths. yes they are definitely biased against a good woman. Allah guide them.
We really don't need to follow her or love her just respect her for sake of Rasool s.a.w. she was his wife . Leave her matter to her Husband and Allah . What y'all gonna do if PROPHET S.A.W says i forgive her for whatever she has done wrong and Allah forgives her too then what y'all who disrespected her will do ? Why didn't RASOOL S.A.W divorce her if she was such a bad women?
Salaam Alaykum. This should answer your concern ua-cam.com/video/yAHVmPEWrQI/v-deo.html Please note that these videos are part of a larger series. We have nothing against Ayesha or any of her family members. The question that we have been examining in these videos is whether Ayesha is a reliable source for the Sunnah of the Prophet.
@@LaceAndLore You can laugh all you want. My family is mixed with Shia, and my best friend is Shia, and they also think you are strange. You can interpret all you want and criticize a hadith but still use it to trash Prophet Mohammed pbuh. May Allah Guide you
I wonder if those hadiths were written by enemies of The Prophet to discredit Islam. I don’t think they can be fully trusted. If they are true, that means Aisha was suspect for saying these things.
Salaam Alaykum. The aim is not to create hate. The purpose is shared in episode 198. We are examining why we don't take Sunnah from her, though she quotes thousands of narrations.
OMG how dare ayesha ask her own husband to lift her to see kids playing???😾😾 how disrespectful is that omggg . How dare ayesha have her own husband recite quran while having his head on her lap???😾😾😾 HOW DISRESPECTFUL IS THAT !!!!! Ohhh noooooo😾😾😾
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor. Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’" Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed." Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
Brother, How do we know the truth? Unless we read Hadith, Why did they record such Hadiths. In India Sach Wala team, show,read such Hadiths, which tarnish the image of prophet s a w. Who dares to stop them. Can you ask sach wala team how long you read such Hadiths, it reflects how much grudge, enmity they had towards prophet Muhammad s a w.
Qur'an chapters Mominoon, Munafiqoon, during the period of prophet, then Muslimeen were Companions. Munafiqoon verse 3, They Became Believers, then turned to be Disbelievers kafir, have their Hearts sealed? or We Sealed their Hearts.(such companions Hearts had been Sealed, do we fault Qur'an, as Munafiqoon chapter revealed). Muhammad verse 24, Why don't you observe, notice in the Qur'an, have their Hearts locked? or We Locked their Hearts. At Tauba verse 66 69 80, Don't Make Excuses, After Becoming Believers, They Became Disbelievers kafir, if one sect is forgiven, punish another. Hypocrites Deeds (Muslimeen) would not yield any Benefit in this World, Here After. Oh Messenger, Even if you pray 70 times for them, supplication would not be approved by me Allah ( who were those? Hypo, Became Disbelievers, After Becoming Believers, How did prophet cover his shirt, on the Hypocrite companion, when he died, it contradicts Quraan, Quraan doesn't allow to supplicate hypocrites). Al imran verse 87 90, After Becoming Believers, They Became Disbelievers, curses by Allah, Angels, Humans On them.(Quraan cursing such companions, ). Having Become Believers, They Became Disbelievers, apology would not be approved.
We are no one to discriminate or slander especially one of the beloved wives of our prophet peace be upon him. No human is perfect of sin. We are told to guide rather than to speak Ill. We are no one to judge only allah azzawajal so leave it to him.
@@Thaqlainit is understandable on you’re end. We cannot understand the sunnah better from anyone else other than the prophet peace be upon him. I’m mainly speaking of her status of respect and honor with the prophet. The prophet peace be upon him regarded her as one who is most dear to him. Even so she had her faults we all do. Does that mean we shouldn’t respect each other? If the prophet were to hear what others say in terms to dishonor her do you truly believe he would allow it?
Not to belittle her, but how is it possible that she was the most dear when she along with Hafsa were condemned in Surah Tahrim. How can we accept narrations that go against the Quran?
You can tell to Sayed Mommamad Baqer Qazwini that maybe someone put false hadith about Ayesha..Maybe she did not tell all of these thing. Especially those Bukhary hadith..
Sayed has discussed this idea in this series. But the conclusion remains the same. With so much controversy around her, we need to be cautious when taking Sunnah of the Prophet from her.
Could it be that Hadeeth is fabricated and falsely attributed to Aisha? Just a thought. Whatever her short comings, she was not indecent. Btw I am not Sunni.
The goal is not to portray her as indecent, but rather to make the case that due to numerous controversies, she may not be the most reliable source for Sunnah.
I had the same thought (I don't follow a particular school... I just accept what is more evident and can be explained without illogical arguments)... but isn't in some of the hadith Muhammad (PBUH) spoke of Aisha very highly?
@@nightsky5037 Most hadith in praise of Ayesha is quoted by none other except Ayesha. And with the Quran rebuking her and Hafsa in Surah Tahrim, the case is pretty much clear that she is a controversial figure to extract Sunnah from.
The Quran itself rebuked some of them in Surah Tahrim. So it is better to understand the context of mothers of believers before passing judgement on others.
To understand this verse one has to understand the reason it was revealed--which is agreed upon by scholars of all schools. We have examined it in detail in the following episode: ua-cam.com/video/G0WBrSBScL4/v-deo.html&pp=gAQBiAQB
JxkAllah for clarifying.. AlhumdolillAllah I’m a fan n follower of true n only Faith on the lines of Allah Qur’an n Prophet Muhammad PBUH… and his Family The most beautiful beloved n purest AhlalBait ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤That’s All there’s needed n required for me being a true believer … AlhumdolilAhe Rabul Alameen
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
You are getting guidance from Allah. Respected scholar, explains the recorded Hadiths, without any bias, In the affection of their beloved elders 3, majority muslimeen became blind. Summum Bukmun, Umyun Fahum Laayarzioon. To tarnish the image of prophet s a w. With Enmity, Grudge, such Hadiths made recorded by 3, caliphs supporters. By listening such scholars, you are strengthening faith, Imaan. Allah guides you right path shown by Rasoolallah s a w. Real Islam associated with Ahlul Bayt 5, 12 Imaam. They are siraate mustaqeem, Ark of Nuh a, s.
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
I saw the speaker's other videos and thought, what a decent man he is! I did not expected false representation of hadith from his mouth. Here's what I found from Sahih al-Bukhari 3170 ( Rebuttal of the first hadith the speaker mentioned) Narrated `Asim: I asked Anas about the Qunut (i.e. invocation in the prayer). Anas said, "It should be recited before bowing." I said, "So-and-so claims that you say that it should be recited after bowing." He replied, "He is mistaken." Then Anas narrated to us that the Prophet (ﷺ) invoked evil on the tribe of Bani-Sulaim for one month after bowing. ' Anas Further said, "The Prophet (ﷺ) had sent 40 or 70 Qaris (i.e. men well versed in the knowledge of the Qur'an) to some pagans, but the latter struggled with them and martyred them, although there was a peace pact between them and the Prophet (ﷺ) I had never seen the Prophet so sorry and worried about anybody as he was about them (i.e. the Qaris).
You know how many narrations of the same incident by the same person have different isnad like one might be direct from him others from a nephew others from a companion who heard the narrator Wallahy plz Habibi use your intellect
If you don't like the father, it's obvious you will go to any extreme to misquote, misinterpret and disrespect his family. All you have achieved in this video with your closed mindset is to deepen the hatred among Muslim brotherhood. I love my Shia friends, but they are nothing in comparison with my love for my Prophets his Family and his Companions. Assuming you are a scholar, I kindly request you to focus more on Allah, his messenger, his message more and unite everyone. We are all Muslims first.
There is a principle flaw in the theory you presented: the unity of Ummah is in not discussing the unfavourable sides of companions. This has two problems: 1) Unless we discuss this, we won't realize through which companions we should take the Sunnah. Because ideally, we should take Sunnah only from the one with the most untainted character. 2) The Quran or the Prophet never endorsed your theory. Time and time again, the Quran discussed the limitation and, in fact, the hypocrisy of some companions. Even the wives of the Prophet were rebuked in Surah Tahrim.
You not even giving reference of the bukhari hadeethm...Half of the hadeeths are forged.....they made up lies in her name,how can you slander someone when hadeeths are just narrations and theres no 100% proof sahabah said any of these
I am surprised at your pronouncement that the Prophet pbup forbade singing: "In support of singing being halal, the jurist Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi says, "No sound hadith is available concerning the prohibition of singing", while Ibn Hazm says, "All that is reported on this subject is false and fabricated."
There are different schools in Islam, and each school has its opinion on Music. The scholars you quoted are Maliki and Zahiri, respectively. In the School of Ahlulbayt, music that confirms the standards of Lahw and La'ab is haraam and is considered a major sin.
@@Thaqlain Quote all the hadiths word for word in text from what you said in the lecture. Where on earth does it state he wanted to commit suicide and Jibril stopped him from doing so???
Allah has rebuked 2 of the prophets wives in the holy Quran,isn’t that sufficient for the believers? Can there ever be any comparison to the lady of light bibi Fatema with these 2? Never!
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
Indeed. So either the scope of 9:100 does not cover her or all these narrations found in Bukhari and Muslim are lie. The first option has higher possibility as she even fought against the Imam of her time resulting in the death of 2000+ Muslims.
Salaam Alaykum. Sorry, but this criterion is against the Quran. As Quran itself condemned some of the wives and the caliphs that came after the Prophet were not the ones chosen by the Prophet.
@@Thaqlain You are not chosen by Quran to be a Believer... Condition is they are Mother's only to Believers not for Dis-believers like you.. (Quran 33:6). The Prophet is closer to the believers than their ownselves, and his wives are their (believers’) mothers.
@@hussamuddin2361 ) The Prophet (P.B.U.H) said, “The one who wants to live my life and die my death will attach himself to Ali (A.S).” Musnad of Ahmad, 5/94; Mustadrak Al-Sahihain of Al-Hakim Al-Nisabori, 3/128; Kenz Al-Omal, 6/217; Al-Tabarani.
Yes and we don't desire to marry them after the Prophet's demise. Because that's exactly the context of the verse 33:6 :) This episode should help you: ua-cam.com/video/G0WBrSBScL4/v-deo.html&pp=gAQBiAQB
All these narations are from your books brother, and you still blindly follow her and call the followers of the Prophet and his Family (PBUT) non believers, wake up brother and put away what salafis have taught you and think logically, who is more worthy of being your master and guide towards Allah (SWT) Sayeda Fatima Al-Zahraa (AS) and her daughter Sayeda Zaynab (AS) or aisha and hafsa????? Please think logically, May Allah (SWT) guide you to the path.
oooh, such an ignorant group of people weirdly explaining the hadith, spreading lies and accusing the mother of mu'mineen. May Allah protect all of us from falling into his & his follower's Darajah. Feel soo sad for the punishment they are about to face if they die in the same state. May Allah protect us All
It seems you have missed the purpose of this episode. This episode is the part of a 400+ episode series exploring the life of the Prophet. From episode 198 to 205, we have explored why Ayesha bint Abi Bakr is a controversial figure to be considered as an authority for Sunnah of the Prophet.
We don't have given rights by allah to talk anything about prophets wives we dont come close to say anything about them only allah knows everything and we are not here to decide anything. Shias say they love prophet Muhammed saw and ahlel bait an still dont walk on the teachings of the prophet. So its Hipocracy to talk about these hight status person they are chosen by prophet and allah. May allah guide ummah to right path.
Allah Himself has rebuked some of the wives of the Prophet in the Quran. The aim of this episode is clear: why in the School of Ahlulbayt we don't take Sunnah from Ayesha.
Not worthy of any worship except ALLAH Muhammad messenger of ALLAH ali is beloved of ALLAH ali is successor of Muhammad Ali is first khlifa after Muhammad
Hadees of suicide is not from Aisa ....its a suspension from az zuhri ....go and learn from ahlus sunnah .... about this.....and not all chains contain this suicide....only chain from az zuhri ....so its not statment of Aisa r.a but Stetment of zuhri ...which he him self said ..."its reached to us" but from where not mentioned so its a suspension but Bukhari wrote this because of chain is ok ..but suspension is from zuhri not Aisha ...
Also you must understand your doing the same thing your accusing her of. If she did speak of such inappropriate thing, you don’t have to tell us the inappropriate things she said. Your opening up a portal for more people to slander her name.so let’s leave it to Allah!
It is all there in the hadits,if ever you believe koran it is an obligation for you to believe the hadits. If it is shahih than it is the truth. That is why people move out of Islam and apostasy is there like a tsunami. Internet open it wide.
Allah revealed 11 verses of Ouran to prove the innocence of Hazrat Aisha - Quran 24:11-21 Subhan Allah! Where Allah came Himself to declare the innocence of Aisha R.A who are we to disrespect !!!
@@rafsansamir5142 Quran says that "O wives of prophet stay inside your house and don't go outside of your house but Ayesha went against the order of Allah and came with a Army of thousands of Na Mahram people from Basra to Madina to fight Imam Ali what kind of mother she was 🙃 that's why once prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said to Ayesha you are like women of Egypt
These intimate details are shared to aware people [ummah], as these events are part of marital life. And plotting such things about the wife of Prophet [SAW] may take one out of Islam. When clearly Prophet [SAW] titled her {Aisha r.a } the most beloved person to him. According to surah Al Noor [24 : 17] Allah forbids you from ever doing something like this again, if you are ˹true˺ believers. Now ask yourself, "are you even a believer".
Why no other wife shared these details? Shouldn't this make it a Sunnah for other wives of the Prophet and wives of the believers to share intimate details of their relationship with the world? As for Surah Nur, we have covered it in detail in a separate episode.
I follow the women whose innocence was proved in the Quran itself. Allah doesn't make any mistake and the hadiths you mentioned, are you making a joke out of them? Reference: Surah e Nur Verse 11-26, deny Quran if you want, that is what shias generally do
If you don’t understand hadith by yourself you have no right to preach. Quran discusses intimate topics for our hidayah so did Ayesha R.A. Prophet discussed such topics with women at that time and you do in this time. Why is it a taboo for Ayesha A.S only to
Please share which Prophet's intimiate details are shared in the Quran? And which other wife of the Prophet shared similar initimate details of the Prophet's life? And shouldn't then this make sharing initimate details of ones private life a Sunnah that every Muslim should follow? It seems you are mixing taboo topics with intimate details :)
Don't disrespectfull towards Prophet 's wives... how can you believe on hadith that are not even written by prophet wife but by relatives of her after 100 years of her death. Secondly, if you don't consider her true , then don't talk about her. It's the time to get united otherwise all kafirs of world tear you apart..both sects sunni and shia.
The reason Kafirs are able to tear us apart because we left the ones who used to tear Kafirs apart and followed the ones who used to run from the battlefield. Anyways, the purpose of these episodes are mentioned in episode 198.
You say "why would I follow such a woman." Exactly, why would you FOLLOW Aisha? Not even Sunnis follow Aisha because we don't follow Aisha, we follow Muhammad pbuh. Aisha is 'the mother of all believers' as she was not to be remarried after the prophets pbuh death and was responsible for the most narrations of hadith and guiding others on proper aqeeda AT THE TIME. But nowhere does it state you follow Aisha, we follow Muhammad pbuh. This honestly seems like a smear campaign on Aisha, all these videos you're making. Why not debate with a Sunni scholar so people can see all cards laid out on the table?
How do u think u received the Deen brother?it's through transmission...after the prophet the Muslim followed the sahabah ,then tabeyin then so on and forth till today...it's through chain of transmission that we are connected to prophet saw
@@tazboy1934 They did not "follow" as we do not follow scholars today. Shias are the only ones who follow, as they have spiritual leaders, not sunnis. The Quran tells us to follow the Quran. We only seek guidance of the Quran from scholars but we don't follow them. We only follow the prophets and revelation from the prophets.
You behave as if Aisha was not human and that she was not a young immature woman with human qualities of being jealous etc. Answer one question why did the Rasul take her as his wife. If not to relate details that would only serve to enlighten the Ummah. Who is it that follow Aisha? Follow Quran and the Prophet
A large number of narrations come from Ayesha. So should we follow the Sunnah quoted by an "immature person"? Also, the topic on wisdom behind marrying her is already covered in this series. It seems you only watched this episode :)
Without attacking aisha and the sahaba, what else do you have to provide. Your religion is based on resentment and insult. Other than that what depth do you have.
Aren’t we stupid to make sects based on what Ayesha RAA says or Fatima RAA says . They aren’t the prophets nor did they get the revelation. We do not follow either because Islam should not have sects than it is not Islam . Islam is Quran first these are irrelevant hadiths
Astaghfirullah May Allah guide you in the straight path this all lies don't believe read the Quran Aisha (R.A) IS. THE MOST RESPECTED WOMAN AND SHE HAS NEVER DONE BAD THINGS
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100. Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
@@Thaqlain don’t think so even the prophet pbuh when people around him said we think he said the shahada he said I didn’t hear him. Abu talib was kind to the prophet but his arrogance towards his ancestors idol worship has led him to the hell fire.
We have explored the faith of Abu Talib in detail already. Not sure how is his faith justifying the acts of Ayesha. To learn more about the faith of Abu Talib, please check episode 58 onwards ua-cam.com/video/rM0Fce0erfs/v-deo.html
Because some Muslims are adamant about ignoring the vastly available evidence, Abu Talib and other ancestors of the Prophet were Hanifs. They already were following Allah (subhanahu wa tala)
See how they speak on the prophet’s wife? And they get mad when we say they’re not Muslim😂 God guide the sincere ones amongst you, and punish the willful transgressors.
@@Thaqlain accusing her of committing zina (astagfirullah)? The prophet’s own wife? What does that say about the prophet himself? You people best repent and move away from this doctrine which is based on filthy (and mostly sexual btw) accusations. All about hate and cursing prophet’s wife and companion
Also the claims You making is a clear sign You have no clue how the Great Jurist and His like Understood Agaadeeth so My sincere advice to You study اثرالحديث
(A) Allah tell us in al quran that His holy book will seperate 2 kind of human.. 1.person who read,practice and teach other with the sincere heart will always be guide,he never be astray.. 2.person who read,not practicing,and teach other with his only critical mind,he will be the best friend of iblis laknatullah.. (B)Allah also tell us that His previous book already being corrupt by devilish human.. Only quran Allah will preserve till the end of time but why al quran?? 1.means,Allah want to show us who is sincere toward His deen. He want human who have a desire and free choice to think very carefully for every choice human made eitheir with only his mind or using his mind combine with the sincere heart.. 2.Allah tell us clearly that human and iblis will againts His teaching,and if human and iblis can change the verse the previous holy book,what bout hadith?? They will find a way to do that because their cannot fight Al quran (Allah already promise to guard His final book) So we as a muslim,we need to learn and take hadith that never argue with the Al quran... This is the secret to learn hadith in islam... Our beloved prophet already clearly tell us at the end of His khutbah.. Hold tightly to Al quran and my sunnah Everyone who against its(whatever sect he is) means eithier he is jahil(low on knoledge)or he is pure munafiqun(double faces) To understand Al quran,we need ulama or schoolar that hold tighly with Al quran and sunnah of the prophet.. To recognise them,Allah already put some secret in Al quran for us.. To get that secret,u need heart that very very clearly sincere submit to Allah s.w.t Allah realy love this rare kind of heart... To know that if our heart is sincere toward Allah is when u read some verse,your body and soul will vibrte because of scared toward HIM,and your eyes will crying itself.. Means... U understand what ur reading and ur accept it with open heart.. Sincere heart is rarely hard to grab,to get it u have to be a best person in every action u did only for the sake of Allah.. When Allah is proud at u,u wont be misguide by any force or certain foolish group... Wallahu a'lam..
@@Thaqlain thats is your faith,mine only 2.. Alquran and sunnah.. If i want to study more bout quran deeply,then i can go refer to ulama and hadith.. If i want to know bout some faith or religion,i will study many references so that i always do just and honest for my own mind also for the cause of Allah.. We are not created to be perfect 101% to grab all knowledge in this world But what we can do is learn and compare it very carefuly with knowledge,both or lots of references,so that we can understand it very quickly without being force by other to accept it.. Enemy of islam forget bout this things.. They think they can do whatever they want in this world,but they cant make heart that is so pure and sincere became black and full of confusion.. Once heart feel the love of Allah,he just want to die and meet Allah very3 quickly.. He sure afraid bout his sin etc etc but pure sincere heart feeling to meet Allah is what enemy of islam cannot get or understand till the end if time.. What are wasteful time he have.. Thats why Allah told us,HE love us(pure sincere heart)more than our parent or spouse love us.. This love is so rare and special,if u dont cry or get tremble when reading quran,means ur heart are not fully sincere toward Allah s.w.t It is just waste of time.. They got money,beautiful women,nice car,big house,smart children,land and property.. But they will never ever,get that feeling.. Feeling love from Allah,and will do anything to make Allah proud at us.. He love Allah so much,and he knew that Allah also love him.. This person will never act ignorant and will do honest and justice eitheir for his self or to other.. Allahu akbar...
@@Thaqlain not mine..Schoolar.. Their are only our tool to knew Allah and his commandment.. Nothing more nothing less Their also a human being like us,our different only for knowledgeable.. Their book is not our GOD,not our core faith,we can take it to learn,believe or disbelieve at their opinion.. Only Alquran our core believe,we obey it and we listen.. Insya Allah... Other than that,is only for deep understanding and for free time.. We as a muslim,dont take prophet s.a.w or sahabah or ahlul bait as our GOD They are only our mentor on how to live in this world and after we all die,we can meet again.. But ofcourse,the goal is not them.. The creator itself!! Lots of question i got,like how mathmatic,wind,sky,gravity,soil in paradise or hell,between air and space,what kind of light can reach the lowwest sea,lot of it.. Ulama or schoolar do they have that?? Thats why as a muslim,we are not taking a schoolar,prophet,hadith,artis,material in world as our GOD Thats is why we always target only one goal.. To meet Allah only and to do that we realy have to focus one thing.. Sincere heart... Because Allah realy love that heart.. All the 'keys' actualy reveal in Al quran Only pure heart can 'see' it
Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S:
I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt).
II) Subscribe: Connect with us on UA-cam & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1
III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
Can you please give me references from sunni books about the Event of Ghadeer. As many of our sunni brothers and sisters are of denial or are ignorant of this event.
@@iMan-610 The proof is all in the video, sorry to say but she is not one to be followed if you read what Bukhari narrates from her
People who claim something about ISLAMIC things they give reference, where are the references?
Here ITALIAN reverted to SHIA and I can understand every single word u use, so good. I would really like to have THE REFERENCE for evey hadith or quran ayat. JazakAllah. It will help me searching quickly for them and save them in my computer.
We do have in plans to convert these videos into blog posts. InshaAllah there we will ensure all references are mentioned.
@@Thaqlainplease update us with that information InshaAllah
italian? Is it true you people don't like pineapple on Pizza?
@@AliJawad-q5d of course !! Pineapple / Ananas is not for pizza :)
I'll be happy to help if you have any questions regarding our fiqh. May Allah swt bless you.
May Allah guide you to the straight path
Ameen InshaAllah :)
Imteresting perspective may Allah give us a heart that can distinguish truth from falsehood and accept truth for what it is ameen
Astagfirullah at this point it’s no point arguing with shias at this point they are too far gone !!!!!
We haven't uploaded these episodes for arguments sake. By the way, shouldn't this encourage you to look into the fact that such narrations are present in Bukhari.
There is no Bukhari that defames any of the Prophet PBUHs family nor his companions! This poison is only from your reference sources !
No hadith in this episode is from the sources of School of Ahlulbayt.
ya allah.may allah curse who disrespect wives of prophet
@@Thaqlain
Every Hadees present deliberately wrongly...Al are easy to understand...but they are blind to blaim Aisha r.a
No words to express my gratitude Syed
Indeed the worst of enemies of prophet of Allah was not the idol worshippers but these hypocrites
Ya Allah my prophet sawaws suffered so much
A couple of years back
My non muslim friend shared a very disturbing bukhari hadith with me regarding Ayesha married to prophet while playing with dolls and all .. nauzobillah
She wanted its authenticity and by the grace of almighty alhamdulillah i got some really good explanations from our Shia scholars and shared with her..
These indecent hadiths and fabrications have done a great damage to the religion of islam.
They have hurt our prophet sawaws in his life and after he passed away..
Masha Allah we have role models like syeda Fatima Zahra s.a. and syeda zainab s.a. to look upto..
Ya Allah swt help us to cling to the rope of Allah, household of your beloved prophet sawaws,his progeny a.s.
The true infallibles..
In shaa Allah aameen
Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad
@Bahrom Olimov yeah
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a..
Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor.
Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’"
Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed."
Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
What we have is our ability to reason. We were not present in those times. But with time we know much about human nature. If Aisha was 10 years old when she married the Prophet saw, and was with him for 8 years, according to main sources, she was not much more than a child, and adolescent in those years. How much of what comes from the thinking of children is tempered with reason or clarity, or even honesty?
Interesting all this nonsense to defend nonsense
Our dear Prophet Muhammad sawa will never marry girl of 10 years. Read and you will find that she was at least 19 years old.
And why you see her as child when it comes to Prophet as and anyway you take her childish and maybe naive to be your source of knowledge? It doesn’t make sense
@@ibrahimharith9878please try to go into the Diwan of the Prophets and ask the Prophet upon him be peace yourself rather than here say
@@nebitnoprezime9871that's actually a solid point
So its true, Shias talk down on Aisha and other Sahabi like Umar and Uthman.
The narrations are from Sunni books including Bukhari.
@@Thaqlain 24:50 you are revealing what you really did. You, yourself, are claiming you are not claiming all is Sahih. How interesting. So cite all the hadiths in text that you spoke of in the lecture word for word and let's see what you are really quoting. Why would you even Quote hadith that you aren't even sure is Sahih in the first place?
To show that even your own books present her character as controversial hence we cannot take Sunnah of the Prophet from someone with such controversial character.
Syiah talk according to alquran...assunnah and kitabul seerah!!
I'm surprised how they interpret everything. Maybe her knowledge and narrations are a test for you.
Allahume Sale Ale Mohamad wale ale Mohamad
Selamün Aleykum, I have a question, does Ayesha have lied about tahrif of quran? Will there be a video about this? JazakAllah khayr.
Alaykum Salaam. The goal here is to explore how Ayesha is a controversial figure and unreliable source for religious guidelines and Sunnah. So we will limit to that only :)
@@Thaqlain alright then, thank you for the clarification, may Allah recompensate your efforts!
Amazing series
May Allah bless you
You are a source of blessing by whom we can reap the benefits
Subhan Allah
Please share it with your family and friends.
What benefit you can gain on shaia belief...only backbiting slandering envy...misguided...
@@jamaludenumpat2449 what benefit can you gain when in your bookd of ahadeeth says rasoollah cursed overweight Muawiah, sahaba cursed imam Ali. Lots of cursing in your sunni books of ahadeeth. Double standards.
Sir, great lecture , eye opening for me. SUBHANALLAH❤❤❤❤❤. Peacefully explained. Jazakallah khair. May Allah swt bless you.
Mashallah. ❤
Don't forget to share and support this initiative 🙂
I am sunni but agree with every single thing you say. I have no respect for Aisha. She was the reason behind the split..fitna
I am shia and when I was a Sunni and hearing about Aisha I have to admit I didn’t liked her bcs of she was showed as someone who was jealous. I will be honest , although I’m not impressed by her person I’m not showing her disrespect bcs she was a wife of Muhammad sawa. I’m living her to Allah swt.
You are not a Sunni. For all Sunnis, Aisha is the best woman in the entire ummah of Muhammad, second to none. She is the most beloved person to Muhammad bar none.
@@paramahansayogananda6719
Lol 😂😂😂😂
@gq55sqgq55sqdoa don't know what's funny when the most important man in the islamic world the one that god spoke to said himself that out of all his wives aisha was his favourite
@@akramsalman8199ya Ali madad
Who is giving you this information
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a..
Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor.
Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’"
Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed."
Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
Is Malik authority for the Quran? Because the Quran has rebuked Ayesha and Hafsa in Surah Tahrim.
@@Thaqlain later Allah revealed ayat e Tathir and made them pure.. Read ayat e Tathir
Even the wives never claimed the Ayat Tathir is about them. They too knew it was for Lady Fatima and her family :)
@@Thaqlain Did Fatima r.a or Ali r.a ever claimed it was for them?? Read Qur'an and judge people..
(Quran 33:32). O wives of the Prophet! You are not like any ordinary women. If you keep your duty (to Allah), then be not soft in speech, lest he in whose heart is a disease should be moved with desire, but speak in an honourable manner.
33. And stay in your houses, and do not display yourselves like that of the times of ignorance, and perform As-Salat (Iqamat-as-Salat), and give Zakat and obey Allah and His Messenger. Allah wishes only to remove Ar-Rijs (evil deeds and sins, etc.) from you, O members of the family (of the Prophet ), and to purify you with a thorough purification.
34. And remember (O you the members of the Prophet’s family, the Graces of your Lord), that which is recited in your houses of the Verses of Allah and Al-Hikmah (i.e. Prophet’s Sunnah legal ways, etc. so give your thanks to Allah and glorify His Praises for this Qur’an and the Sunnah). Verily, Allah is Ever Most Courteous, Well-Acquainted with all things.
@@Thaqlain
Neither Prophet s.a.w can marry other women nor wives of prophet can marry other men.. Allah has made special laws for them.. These Ahlul Bayt are different from ordinary people..
(Quran 33:52). It is not lawful for you (O Prophet to marry other) women after this, nor to change them for other wives ...And Allah is Ever a Watcher over all things.
53. O you who believe! Enter not the Prophet’s houses, except when leave is given to you for a meal, (and then) not (so early as) to wait for its preparation. But when you are invited, enter, and when you have taken your meal, disperse, without sitting for a talk. Verily, such (behaviour) annoys the Prophet, and he is shy of (asking) you (to go), but Allah is not shy of (telling you) the truth. And when you ask (his wives) for anything you want, ask them from behind a screen, that is purer for your hearts and for their hearts. And it is not (right) for you that you should annoy Allah’s Messenger, nor that you should ever marry his wives after him (his death). Verily! With Allah that shall be an enormity.
54. Whether you reveal anything or conceal it, verily, Allah is Ever All-Knower of everything.
55. It is no sin on them (the Prophet’s wives, if they appear unveiled) before their fathers, or their sons, or their brothers, or their brother’s sons, or the sons of their sisters, or their own (believing) women, or their (female) slaves, and keep your duty to Allah. Verily, Allah is Ever All-Witness over everything.
56. Allah sends His Salat (Graces, Honours, Blessings, Mercy, etc.) on the Prophet (Muhammad ) and also His angels too (ask Allah to bless and forgive him). O you who believe! Send your Salat on (ask Allah to bless) him (Muhammad ), and (you should) greet (salute) him with the Islamic way of greeting (salutation i.e. As-Salamu ‘Alaikum).
57. Verily, those who annoy Allah and His Messenger () Allah has cursed them in this world, and in the Hereafter, and has prepared for them a humiliating torment.
58. And those who annoy believing men and women undeservedly, bear on themselves the crime of slander and plain sin.
Can my sunni brothers clarify a question. If someone goes to war against the Ahlebait, are they true Muslims and be respected??? Aisha fought against Imam Ali (AS) in the battle of Jamel.
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
Well she did disobey and hurt his family.
That is what the scholars are telling you. The biggest cover up.
Read the quran. Addresses the wives 5 times. Read carefully what Allah says.
Some desire this world and some desire the hereafter.
Look at the verse where she and Hafsa go against rasoollah and she even disobeyed and went to fight Ali.
The shia are correct. I did so much research if you analyse the verses.
Don't follow interpretations from hater ibn tayyimah and ibk katheer. He did a lot of copy plaigarism and changed the words.
@user-eh2pv4sc7h Probably the biggest cover up was the event at Ghadeer, where the Holy Prophet was ordered by Allah to name his successor. Ali was appointed and all Muslims present were ordered to pay their allegiance. Even Umar khattab congratulated Ali on his position. But look what happened after the death of the Holy Prophet. So called Muslims gathered outside Ali's House to demand his loyalty to the new regime. And tragically Lady Fatima was martyred as a result of them setting fire to the house. All this is documented in sunni reference books. If only the Muslims had stuck with the orders of the Holy Prophet. If only........
@bolero4554 Your beloved muawiyah and his son not extremists ?? Read the tragedy of karbala and the so called Muslims who took part in the slaughter of the family of the Holy Prophet to realise who the extremists are. That is why we follow the Ahlebait, who are free from sin, pure in thought and are infallible. If only the ummah had followed the orders of the Holy Prophet at Ghadeer, after his death. If only.
Thanks for revealing and enlightening us with truth. May Allah bless you. Allah humma salli ala muhammad wa ale muhammad.
Sahih al-Bukhari 4350
Narrated Buraida:
The Prophet (ﷺ) sent `Ali to Khalid to bring the Khumus (of the booty) and I hated `Ali, and `Ali had taken a bath (after a sexual act with a slave-girl from the Khumus). I said to Khalid, "Don't you see this (i.e. `Ali)?" When we reached the Prophet (ﷺ) I mentioned that to him. He said, "O Buraida! Do you hate `Ali?" I said, "Yes."
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
She did disobey rasoollah have you not read what Allah says about her in the quran.
@@iMan-610She is rotting in Hell according to Sahih BuKhari
I love prophet muhammed (sawas) and his ahlalbayt (as)!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing channel! I absolutely enjoy watching each and every video that goes up, ajarkom allah 🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻
Duas 🤲🏻
youre getting manipulated lol, he doesnt even give resources
Jazakallah. Whats the refrence for suicidal hadith? I'm currently debating with someone in regards to this matter and they say they believe in this Hadith because Prophets can make mistakes according to Quran and they don't do it only because Allah stops them from doing so. They mentioned how Prophet Adam (as) did what allah asked him not to do and how Prophet Yousuf (as) would've fallen for the trap of the Ruler's wife behind 7 doors if Allah didn’t stop him. So how do i argue about that? Theyre basically implying without Allah's help and support Prophets can commit sins
Your last line is correct -- Prophets can commit sins. But they don't. We have covered this in detail in various episodes of this series. Before debating, it is important to understand the underlying belief system and the intended goals. The reason Ahl al-Sunnah believes in Prophet commiting sins and mistakes is to justify the sinful behaviour of later caliphs. For the School of Ahlulbayt, Prophets not commiting sins is a core belief as we believe the leaders after the Prophet need to be infallible too.
@Thaqlain that's perfect. Thanks for highlighting that point out. I'll look for the related videos on ur channel.
Actually Ayesha has shown her level by narrating these weird things.
She indeed exposed her in the end
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a..
Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor.
Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’"
Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed."
Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
@@hussamuddin2361 it’s amazes me why Sunni follow and respect Aisha more than the daughter of the prophet.
@@hussamuddin2361 its not slander when its facts. Learn your history.
@@zainabb978 no they don’t but Aisha needs defending whereas lady fatima doesn’t as No one slanders her. However you guys treated aisha like a dog and have abu jahal in higher status than her.
I respect your work and effort in educating the public . But how does this correlate with the fatwa/decree of our Maraji “Insulting the personalities of Sunni brethren, including the wives of all the Prophets, in particular those of the Leader of the Prophets and accusing the wife of the Prophet of Islam, is forbidden (haram)”.
It is not that you are not speaking the truth. But I hope you realize that while you sit in the safety of your home and country, some innocent Shia will lose his life as retaliation in Pakistan, Afghanistan and other places. And to clarify, I am a Shia myself.
@@bukhariali71
You think Sunnis need an excuse in order to assassinate Shi’a? They have been doing this for more than a thousand years, regardless of whether Shi’a were loud, quiet, peaceful, angry, whatever
Under the “leadership” of people like Khamenei, Shi’a within Pakistan alone have been bombarded and harassed for decades (LONG before such criticism as this video was even available on the internet). So I don’t think such leaders have any right to speak on the subject anymore, when their approach has not been productive in stifling Wahhabi psychosis whatsoever
We have most of our learned Ulemas in Pakistan working really hard to create an atmosphere of harmony and respect between sects. Lectures like these totally whitewashes their efforts. Again, it is not about hiding the truth, but the goal has to have a deeper purpose. If anything, follow the example of our 1st Imam after all the hardships he had to endure after the events @ his door and his rights being taken away. Even after the battle of Jamal, he was respectful to Aisha just because of her relationship with our Prophet (pbuh and his family).
@@bukhariali71
What?? I can show you video clips of Pakistani scholars literally mocking Aisha & the Three Khulafa, what are you talking about? If by “harmony” you just mean “Save your criticism for only private events & speeches”, then that is an entirely different discussion from “Don’t criticize them at all”
As for Imam Ali, you’re saying that drawing a sword against a woman and her followers is somehow more “respectful” than simply citing her flaws from Sunnis’ OWN books?
In what universe is this true? Has any Shi’a critic of Aisha started executing her followers in open combat yet??
Salaam Alaykum. We appreciate your thoughts on this matter. However, this episode is a part of 300+ episodes where we are compiling the Seerah of the Prophet of Islam. The question we are answering in the current episode is simple: why do Shias not take the Seerah/Sunnah of the Prophet from a figure like Ayesha, who has quoted hundreds of hadith from the Prophet? So it is purely an academic/objective discussion with no insult involved.
Salam.
Hadith from bukhari is 3268, not 3028.
Please share the other hadith you mentioned, so we can read more on the context, if any.
Alaykum Salaam. The hadith numbers differ in the print editions. Do share the other hadith you require reference and we will align that InshaAllah
could you provide number for the hadith in 8:26 please?
sunnah.com/bukhari:297
sunnah.com/bukhari:299
@@Thaqlainthank you, could you also help me with 3:56 please?
sunnah.com/muslim:350
Maybe Aeisha was honest and true to what she had seen and heard. Muhammad and his friends were not a very good person we can see how his followers are today.
The case is reverse. It began when corrupt usurped the position of the Prophet. Then they fabricated such narrations in order to justify their acts.
Literally aisha made herself a laughing stock...
Don't insult family of Prophet.. It's personal matter of wife and Husband...
(Quran 33:6). The Prophet is closer to the believers than their ownselves, and his wives are their (believers’) mothers.
(Quran 33:32). O wives of the Prophet! You are not like any other women. If you keep your duty (to Allah), then be not soft in speech, lest he in whose heart is a disease (of hypocrisy, or evil desire ) should be moved with desire, but speak in an honourable manner.
33. And stay in your houses, and do not display yourselves like that of the times of ignorance, and perform As-Salat (Iqamat-as-Salat), and give Zakat and obey Allah and His Messenger. Allah wishes only to remove Ar-Rijs (evil deeds and sins, etc.) from you, O members of the family (of the Prophet ), and to purify you with a thorough purification.
34. And remember (O you the members of the Prophet’s family, the Graces of your Lord), that which is recited in your houses of the Verses of Allah and Al-Hikmah (i.e. Prophet’s Sunnah legal ways, etc. so give your thanks to Allah and glorify His Praises for this Qur’an and the Sunnah). Verily, Allah is Ever Most Courteous, Well-Acquainted with all things.
@hussamuddin2361 Personal matter? Aaisha said a lot of "personal" things in sahih bukhari that some would consider inappropriate. Did you even watch this video before commenting?
Aisha spoke the dirty truth because she was bitter about Muhammad
@@Ya_Ali_313_then why was she one of the favourite wives of the prophet saw answer please
@@User-n7d7z we don't agree with that
Assalalmualaikum warahmatullah wabarakatuh Shaykh 🌹
The only thing I get from all the hadees that the physical abuse towards women come from the followers of these books.
Jazakallah khair for Educating Muslims.
Islam Religion of Peace.
Also follow the last Sermon of the Rasool Allah for guidance.
The main purpose of this lecture is not to blame anybody but to tell people that we can't take sunnah from such a person who is controversial and had narrated hadiths like this .
When we have the best ladies and best role models like lady Fatima,Lady Khadija,Lady Asiya and lady Maryam (A.S)
The most wholesome comment.
Sahih Muslim 2540 - Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: Do not revile my Companions, do not revile my Companions. By Him in Whose Hand is my life, if one amongst you would have spent as much gold as Uhud it would not amount to as much as one much on behalf of one of them or half of it.
May Allah protect us all from reviling the righteous companions of the Prophet.
@@Thaqlain When it comes to the Sahaba, there aren't any wicked companions of the prophet pbuh. Yet, Shias claim as such, which directly goes against the hadith quoted above.
Well then, this hadith goes against the Quran. So, as a Muslim, the choice is yours 🙂
Can you explain Quran 33:6?
What does; “”the prophet’s wives are the mothers of the believers”” mean?
We have covered this in this Chapter :)
I think there’s a lot of slander against Aisha and most of it is hard to claim. Unless Allah has stated she is of a bad character, these statements shouldn’t be taken so seriously.
Surah Tahrim is pretty clear on answering your concern :)
She also not included in 10 sahabah which Rasul (s) confirm enter jannah...???
The 10 sahaba hadith itself is very controversial.
He wasn't intimate with her when he was on her mensus. Putting his (pbuh) on her lap and reading the Quran is not intimacy.
So then it technically becomes Sunnah, right? All men should read the Quran while putting their heads in the laps of their wives, especially when they are menstruating? Why are we never told of this Sunnah?
Actually it was different times where she said those things
I hope this idea focusing sayeda aisha theme on battle of jamal
Instead of sayidina imam ali themes
Is a minor perspective of our brother in shia madzhab
Not majority (olny hoping)
Is the same when u focusing on abu jahl act to Rosulullah saww and his follower
Instead of focusing on Rosulullah saww ahlak
Imho
If we want to focus on improving our ahlak
Focus on teaching and ahlak our patrons
Not focusing the opposite
Right or wrong
Good or bad
Etc
Sayeda aisha always be our mother (according to quran it self)
If we still call our self muslim, Rosulullah saww was our patronese and quran as the source
Is un negotiable
How is he sure that Ayesha made those fabrications?
It's even possible that the people who supported her made those fabrications & disseminated in her name.
I am sunni, but those hadiths that he mentioned always seem to be doubtful.
Hence the reason we don't take Sunnah from Ayesha. Because in either case, narrations from her are doubtful 🙂
It's all hadiths in sunni books
Salam
Can you please share hadih numbers related to aishah (r.a)
Salaam Alaykum. Can you share the specific hadith you are looking for?
Could you provide the hadith which says, they had intercourse during her period?
sunnah.com/bulugh:145
Though Sunni scholars have now began to translate 'Yubashirni' as fondling.
no proof it seems.because they giving their own interpretations.of hadith which has no further evidence but twisting the meanings of hadiths. yes they are definitely biased against a good woman. Allah guide them.
We shared proof right away :)
We really don't need to follow her or love her just respect her for sake of Rasool s.a.w. she was his wife . Leave her matter to her Husband and Allah . What y'all gonna do if PROPHET S.A.W says i forgive her for whatever she has done wrong and Allah forgives her too then what y'all who disrespected her will do ? Why didn't RASOOL S.A.W divorce her if she was such a bad women?
Salaam Alaykum. This should answer your concern ua-cam.com/video/yAHVmPEWrQI/v-deo.html
Please note that these videos are part of a larger series. We have nothing against Ayesha or any of her family members. The question that we have been examining in these videos is whether Ayesha is a reliable source for the Sunnah of the Prophet.
But u say it's allow to curse her@@Thaqlain
Imagine you love some so much yet talk trash about his wife and friends. Not only that but you are obsessed with it.
Indeed. Bukhari and other sunni 'sahih' books shouldn't have narrated such disturbing narrations from the wife of the Prophet.
Yes that's what we ask sunnis and their scholars for narrating these hadith 😂
@@LaceAndLore You can laugh all you want. My family is mixed with Shia, and my best friend is Shia, and they also think you are strange. You can interpret all you want and criticize a hadith but still use it to trash Prophet Mohammed pbuh. May Allah Guide you
It is these narrations that trash our beloved Prophet.
I wonder if those hadiths were written by enemies of The Prophet to discredit Islam. I don’t think they can be fully trusted. If they are true, that means Aisha was suspect for saying these things.
What confuses me is that why we hate?? Leave it to Allah swt .. we shouldn’t create division
Salaam Alaykum. The aim is not to create hate. The purpose is shared in episode 198. We are examining why we don't take Sunnah from her, though she quotes thousands of narrations.
OMG how dare ayesha ask her own husband to lift her to see kids playing???😾😾 how disrespectful is that omggg . How dare ayesha have her own husband recite quran while having his head on her lap???😾😾😾 HOW DISRESPECTFUL IS THAT !!!!! Ohhh noooooo😾😾😾
It seems you haven't watched the previous episodes 🙂
@@Thaqlain womp womp you people can never make sense . 🤡
Please enlighten us on what do you feel is the motive behind this episode.
These hadith are there to basically disregard the prophet
Salam, will this series continue all the till Imam mahdi ? (From rasul life to imam Ali life all the way to imam mahdi )?
@thaqalain
Fatwa of ahle sunnah on cursing Aisha r.a
Sunni Islam are all agreed that whoever condemns ‘Aa’ishah for that of which Allaah has stated she is innocent is a kaafir, because he has rejected Allaah’s statement of her innocence in Soorat al-Noor.
Imaam Ibn Hazm quoted a report with an isnad going back to Hishaam ibn ‘Ammaar, who said: "I heard Maalik ibn Anas say: ‘Whoever curses Abu Bakr should be whipped, and whoever curses ‘Aa’ishah should be killed.’ He was asked, ‘Why do you say that concerning (the one who curses) ‘Aa’ishah?’ He said, ‘Because Allaah says concerning ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her (interpretation of the meaning): "Allaah forbids you from it [slander] and warns you not to repeat the like of it forever, if you are believers." [al-Noor 24:17]’"
Maalik said: "Whoever accuses her goes against the Qur’aan, and whoever goes against the Qur’aan should be killed."
Ibn Hazm said: "This comment of Maalik’s is correct, and it is complete apostasy to reject Allaah’s words that clearly state her innocence."
Brother, How do we know the truth? Unless we read Hadith, Why did they record such Hadiths. In India Sach Wala team, show,read such Hadiths, which tarnish the image of prophet s a w. Who dares to stop them. Can you ask sach wala team how long you read such Hadiths, it reflects how much grudge, enmity they had towards prophet Muhammad s a w.
Qur'an chapters Mominoon, Munafiqoon, during the period of prophet, then Muslimeen were Companions. Munafiqoon verse 3, They Became Believers, then turned to be Disbelievers kafir, have their Hearts sealed? or We Sealed their Hearts.(such companions Hearts had been Sealed, do we fault Qur'an, as Munafiqoon chapter revealed). Muhammad verse 24, Why don't you observe, notice in the Qur'an, have their Hearts locked? or We Locked their Hearts. At Tauba verse 66 69 80, Don't Make Excuses, After Becoming Believers, They Became Disbelievers kafir, if one sect is forgiven, punish another. Hypocrites Deeds (Muslimeen) would not yield any Benefit in this World, Here After. Oh Messenger, Even if you pray 70 times for them, supplication would not be approved by me Allah ( who were those? Hypo, Became Disbelievers, After Becoming Believers, How did prophet cover his shirt, on the Hypocrite companion, when he died, it contradicts Quraan, Quraan doesn't allow to supplicate hypocrites). Al imran verse 87 90, After Becoming Believers, They Became Disbelievers, curses by Allah, Angels, Humans On them.(Quraan cursing such companions, ). Having Become Believers, They Became Disbelievers, apology would not be approved.
We are no one to discriminate or slander especially one of the beloved wives of our prophet peace be upon him. No human is perfect of sin. We are told to guide rather than to speak Ill. We are no one to judge only allah azzawajal so leave it to him.
The video is not to slander but to present a case on whether we can take Sunnah from Ayesha or not.
@@Thaqlainit is understandable on you’re end. We cannot understand the sunnah better from anyone else other than the prophet peace be upon him. I’m mainly speaking of her status of respect and honor with the prophet. The prophet peace be upon him regarded her as one who is most dear to him. Even so she had her faults we all do. Does that mean we shouldn’t respect each other? If the prophet were to hear what others say in terms to dishonor her do you truly believe he would allow it?
Not to belittle her, but how is it possible that she was the most dear when she along with Hafsa were condemned in Surah Tahrim. How can we accept narrations that go against the Quran?
You can tell to Sayed Mommamad Baqer Qazwini that maybe someone put false hadith about Ayesha..Maybe she did not tell all of these thing. Especially those Bukhary hadith..
Sayed has discussed this idea in this series. But the conclusion remains the same. With so much controversy around her, we need to be cautious when taking Sunnah of the Prophet from her.
Could it be that Hadeeth is fabricated and falsely attributed to Aisha? Just a thought. Whatever her short comings, she was not indecent. Btw I am not Sunni.
The goal is not to portray her as indecent, but rather to make the case that due to numerous controversies, she may not be the most reliable source for Sunnah.
I had the same thought (I don't follow a particular school... I just accept what is more evident and can be explained without illogical arguments)... but isn't in some of the hadith Muhammad (PBUH) spoke of Aisha very highly?
@@nightsky5037 Most hadith in praise of Ayesha is quoted by none other except Ayesha. And with the Quran rebuking her and Hafsa in Surah Tahrim, the case is pretty much clear that she is a controversial figure to extract Sunnah from.
"The wives of prophet are ummahs mothers" (Al Quran)
So either you are disrespecting your mother, or you are not a believer..
The Quran itself rebuked some of them in Surah Tahrim. So it is better to understand the context of mothers of believers before passing judgement on others.
@@Thaqlain please enlighten me on the context... What did I miss...
It's very clearly mentioned that prophete wives are to be honoured and respected..
To understand this verse one has to understand the reason it was revealed--which is agreed upon by scholars of all schools. We have examined it in detail in the following episode:
ua-cam.com/video/G0WBrSBScL4/v-deo.html&pp=gAQBiAQB
Who is greater? Hz Ali (ra) or Hz Muhammad (sw)?
How is the question related to this video?
JxkAllah for clarifying.. AlhumdolillAllah I’m a fan n follower of true n only Faith on the lines of Allah Qur’an n Prophet Muhammad PBUH… and his Family The most beautiful beloved n purest AhlalBait ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤That’s All there’s needed n required for me being a true believer … AlhumdolilAhe Rabul Alameen
JazakAllah. We are honoured that our content has helped you be close to Ahlulbayt.
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
He brings false hadiths attributed to Aisha r.a..
You are getting guidance from Allah. Respected scholar, explains the recorded Hadiths, without any bias, In the affection of their beloved elders 3, majority muslimeen became blind. Summum Bukmun, Umyun Fahum Laayarzioon. To tarnish the image of prophet s a w. With Enmity, Grudge, such Hadiths made recorded by 3, caliphs supporters. By listening such scholars, you are strengthening faith, Imaan. Allah guides you right path shown by Rasoolallah s a w. Real Islam associated with Ahlul Bayt 5, 12 Imaam. They are siraate mustaqeem, Ark of Nuh a, s.
The best sermons I came across till the date...❤
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
I saw the speaker's other videos and thought, what a decent man he is! I did not expected false representation of hadith from his mouth. Here's what I found from Sahih al-Bukhari 3170 ( Rebuttal of the first hadith the speaker mentioned)
Narrated `Asim:
I asked Anas about the Qunut (i.e. invocation in the prayer). Anas said, "It should be recited before bowing." I said, "So-and-so claims that you say that it should be recited after bowing." He replied, "He is mistaken." Then Anas narrated to us that the Prophet (ﷺ) invoked evil on the tribe of Bani-Sulaim for one month after bowing. ' Anas Further said, "The Prophet (ﷺ) had sent 40 or 70 Qaris (i.e. men well versed in the knowledge of the Qur'an) to some pagans, but the latter struggled with them and martyred them, although there was a peace pact between them and the Prophet (ﷺ) I had never seen the Prophet so sorry and worried about anybody as he was about them (i.e. the Qaris).
You know how many narrations of the same incident by the same person have different isnad like one might be direct from him others from a nephew others from a companion who heard the narrator Wallahy plz Habibi use your intellect
If you don't like the father, it's obvious you will go to any extreme to misquote, misinterpret and disrespect his family. All you have achieved in this video with your closed mindset is to deepen the hatred among Muslim brotherhood. I love my Shia friends, but they are nothing in comparison with my love for my Prophets his Family and his Companions. Assuming you are a scholar, I kindly request you to focus more on Allah, his messenger, his message more and unite everyone. We are all Muslims first.
There is a principle flaw in the theory you presented: the unity of Ummah is in not discussing the unfavourable sides of companions. This has two problems:
1) Unless we discuss this, we won't realize through which companions we should take the Sunnah. Because ideally, we should take Sunnah only from the one with the most untainted character.
2) The Quran or the Prophet never endorsed your theory. Time and time again, the Quran discussed the limitation and, in fact, the hypocrisy of some companions. Even the wives of the Prophet were rebuked in Surah Tahrim.
People who claim something about ISLAMIC things they give reference, where are the references?
Most narrations are from Bukhari. We have shared specifics in the comments. Please share which reference you need and we will share it right away.
Aisha was only 9 tho, she was younger even when the prophet died. What do you expect of a young teenager girl?
And hence this 'young teenager girl' should not be considered as the source of the Sunnah :)
You not even giving reference of the bukhari hadeethm...Half of the hadeeths are forged.....they made up lies in her name,how can you slander someone when hadeeths are just narrations and theres no 100% proof sahabah said any of these
Please share reference that half of the hadiths are forged.
I am surprised at your pronouncement that the Prophet pbup forbade singing: "In support of singing being halal, the jurist Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi says, "No sound hadith is available concerning the prohibition of singing", while Ibn Hazm says, "All that is reported on this subject is false and fabricated."
There are different schools in Islam, and each school has its opinion on Music. The scholars you quoted are Maliki and Zahiri, respectively. In the School of Ahlulbayt, music that confirms the standards of Lahw and La'ab is haraam and is considered a major sin.
I’ve also read the same about Ayesha & correctly said she is a controversial figure
You are sharing da'if (weak) hadiths and then claiming sunnis believe in it? No wonder Sunnis don't take Shias seriously.
Are you suggesting Bukhari has da'if narrations?
@@Thaqlain They weren't all from Bukhari and not all of Bukhari is considered Sahih by many scholars.
@@Thaqlain Quote all the hadiths word for word in text from what you said in the lecture. Where on earth does it state he wanted to commit suicide and Jibril stopped him from doing so???
First let's conclude one discussion. So are you suggesting that the Sahah Sitta are technically not Sahih?
@@ronm7503when faced with truth this guy ran away like umar the mountain goat (Al-Tabari Tafseer, V.4, P. 193) 😂
Exactly, God bless you!
Allah has rebuked 2 of the prophets wives in the holy Quran,isn’t that sufficient for the believers? Can there ever be any comparison to the lady of light bibi Fatema with these 2? Never!
What was source of the last HADITH
We have asked Sayed for the exact reference 🙂
Musnal al-Shamiyyin by the scholar Tabarani. Hadith number 1171, volume 2, page 193, Resala edition (Beirut, Lebanon)
May Allah guide you all. 😢Ameen
Ameen :)
Asalamunalıakum
Alahuma sualıy ala Mohammed waalı Mohammed wa'ajılfarahum
Turkçe?
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
Indeed. So either the scope of 9:100 does not cover her or all these narrations found in Bukhari and Muslim are lie. The first option has higher possibility as she even fought against the Imam of her time resulting in the death of 2000+ Muslims.
Anyone who disrespects Prophet's wives , and the four Caliphs, cannot be called a true muslim.
Salaam Alaykum. Sorry, but this criterion is against the Quran. As Quran itself condemned some of the wives and the caliphs that came after the Prophet were not the ones chosen by the Prophet.
@@Thaqlain You are not chosen by Quran to be a Believer... Condition is they are Mother's only to Believers not for Dis-believers like you..
(Quran 33:6). The Prophet is closer to the believers than their ownselves, and his wives are their (believers’) mothers.
@@hussamuddin2361 ) The Prophet (P.B.U.H) said, “The one who wants to live my life and die my death will attach himself to Ali (A.S).” Musnad of Ahmad, 5/94; Mustadrak Al-Sahihain of Al-Hakim Al-Nisabori, 3/128; Kenz Al-Omal, 6/217; Al-Tabarani.
Yes and we don't desire to marry them after the Prophet's demise. Because that's exactly the context of the verse 33:6 :)
This episode should help you: ua-cam.com/video/G0WBrSBScL4/v-deo.html&pp=gAQBiAQB
All these narations are from your books brother, and you still blindly follow her and call the followers of the Prophet and his Family (PBUT) non believers, wake up brother and put away what salafis have taught you and think logically, who is more worthy of being your master and guide towards Allah (SWT) Sayeda Fatima Al-Zahraa (AS) and her daughter Sayeda Zaynab (AS) or aisha and hafsa????? Please think logically, May Allah (SWT) guide you to the path.
oooh, such an ignorant group of people weirdly explaining the hadith, spreading lies and accusing the mother of mu'mineen.
May Allah protect all of us from falling into his & his follower's Darajah.
Feel soo sad for the punishment they are about to face if they die in the same state. May Allah protect us All
It seems you have missed the purpose of this episode. This episode is the part of a 400+ episode series exploring the life of the Prophet. From episode 198 to 205, we have explored why Ayesha bint Abi Bakr is a controversial figure to be considered as an authority for Sunnah of the Prophet.
Aisha was arrogant and usurped masculine prerogatives! I DEMAND MY HAQQ!
We don't have given rights by allah to talk anything about prophets wives we dont come close to say anything about them only allah knows everything and we are not here to decide anything. Shias say they love prophet Muhammed saw and ahlel bait an still dont walk on the teachings of the prophet. So its Hipocracy to talk about these hight status person they are chosen by prophet and allah. May allah guide ummah to right path.
Allah Himself has rebuked some of the wives of the Prophet in the Quran. The aim of this episode is clear: why in the School of Ahlulbayt we don't take Sunnah from Ayesha.
Not worthy of any worship except ALLAH Muhammad messenger of ALLAH ali is beloved of ALLAH ali is successor of Muhammad
Ali is first khlifa after Muhammad
Is this the guy who said there will be a Ringbell in Jannah who says...... 😂😂😂
Did he say it from his own? Or are you making fun of hadith similar to those that are found in your own books of Manaqib?
Hadees of suicide is not from Aisa ....its a suspension from az zuhri ....go and learn from ahlus sunnah .... about this.....and not all chains contain this suicide....only chain from az zuhri ....so its not statment of Aisa r.a but Stetment of zuhri ...which he him self said ..."its reached to us" but from where not mentioned so its a suspension but Bukhari wrote this because of chain is ok ..but suspension is from zuhri not Aisha ...
Also you must understand your doing the same thing your accusing her of. If she did speak of such inappropriate thing, you don’t have to tell us the inappropriate things she said. Your opening up a portal for more people to slander her name.so let’s leave it to Allah!
The aim was in no circumstances to slander nor we will allow anyone to slander.
This is super helpful. Could you please also mention the Hadith numbers when you reference them? Thanks
We can share the Hadith numbers whichever you require. Thanks for the appreciation.
It is all there in the hadits,if ever you believe koran it is an obligation for you to believe the hadits. If it is shahih than it is the truth. That is why people move out of Islam and apostasy is there like a tsunami. Internet open it wide.
Allah revealed 11 verses of Ouran to prove the innocence of Hazrat Aisha - Quran 24:11-21
Subhan Allah! Where Allah came Himself to declare the innocence of Aisha R.A who are we to disrespect !!!
😂😂 yeah made up Quran at home to protect her come on you guys don't even know the difference between Lady of Jannah and Lady of Jamal😂😂
@@stevesmith8449then which quran you are recommending? Where in the quran it says anything against Ayesha R.A?
@@rafsansamir5142 Quran says that "O wives of prophet stay inside your house and don't go outside of your house but Ayesha went against the order of Allah and came with a Army of thousands of Na Mahram people from Basra to Madina to fight Imam Ali what kind of mother she was 🙃 that's why once prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said to Ayesha you are like women of Egypt
@@stevesmith8449 what’s the reference for all of these? Can you please provide? Did you read the 11 th verse of Surah Al Nur?
@@rafsansamir5142 I have I think you should read surah Ahzab's aya 53
intimate during haidh doesnt mean the actual act of.intercourse but includes also romantic gestures. please grow up
Please check the Arabic for yourself 🙂
Didnt our prophet muhammed say that out of all the wives he loved aisha pbuh the most
Nope. Even according to Ayesha, Khadija was the most beloved amongst all the wives 🙂
These intimate details are shared to aware people [ummah], as these events are part of marital life. And plotting such things about the wife of Prophet [SAW] may take one out of Islam. When clearly Prophet [SAW] titled her {Aisha r.a } the most beloved person to him. According to surah Al Noor [24 : 17] Allah forbids you from ever doing something like this again, if you are ˹true˺ believers. Now ask yourself, "are you even a believer".
Why no other wife shared these details? Shouldn't this make it a Sunnah for other wives of the Prophet and wives of the believers to share intimate details of their relationship with the world? As for Surah Nur, we have covered it in detail in a separate episode.
After finishing the full video what i understand is shia is all about negativity if aisha was a bad person why will the prophet tell us about it
We wish you had watched previous episodes to understand the context of this episode :)
I follow the women whose innocence was proved in the Quran itself. Allah doesn't make any mistake and the hadiths you mentioned, are you making a joke out of them?
Reference: Surah e Nur Verse 11-26, deny Quran if you want, that is what shias generally do
We have discussed this in Ep 206
If you don’t understand hadith by yourself you have no right to preach. Quran discusses intimate topics for our hidayah so did Ayesha R.A.
Prophet discussed such topics with women at that time and you do in this time. Why is it a taboo for Ayesha A.S only to
Please share which Prophet's intimiate details are shared in the Quran? And which other wife of the Prophet shared similar initimate details of the Prophet's life? And shouldn't then this make sharing initimate details of ones private life a Sunnah that every Muslim should follow?
It seems you are mixing taboo topics with intimate details :)
Why fellow Ali when he is died instead of rasulullah
Because the Prophet asked us to follow his progeny. Please refer to Hadith Thaqalayn in Sahih Muslim.
Don't disrespectfull towards Prophet 's wives... how can you believe on hadith that are not even written by prophet wife but by relatives of her after 100 years of her death.
Secondly, if you don't consider her true , then don't talk about her. It's the time to get united otherwise all kafirs of world tear you apart..both sects sunni and shia.
The reason Kafirs are able to tear us apart because we left the ones who used to tear Kafirs apart and followed the ones who used to run from the battlefield. Anyways, the purpose of these episodes are mentioned in episode 198.
So she was a normal human being and that’s wrong? Are you even listening to yourself?
The problem is not her being a normal human. The problem is taking the Sunnah from her 🙂
It’s better to leave her alone because she was the prophets wife and you saying it’s not true my be aren’t you committed a big Sin
Please check 198. Leaving her alone will mean leaving the narrations too. Because mainstream Muslims take a huge chunk of Sunnah from her.
You say "why would I follow such a woman." Exactly, why would you FOLLOW Aisha? Not even Sunnis follow Aisha because we don't follow Aisha, we follow Muhammad pbuh. Aisha is 'the mother of all believers' as she was not to be remarried after the prophets pbuh death and was responsible for the most narrations of hadith and guiding others on proper aqeeda AT THE TIME. But nowhere does it state you follow Aisha, we follow Muhammad pbuh. This honestly seems like a smear campaign on Aisha, all these videos you're making. Why not debate with a Sunni scholar so people can see all cards laid out on the table?
Following Ayesha here refers to taking Sunnah of the Prophet from her. The purpose was not debate at all :)
How do u think u received the Deen brother?it's through transmission...after the prophet the Muslim followed the sahabah ,then tabeyin then so on and forth till today...it's through chain of transmission that we are connected to prophet saw
@@Thaqlain The purpose incites debate.
@@tazboy1934 They did not "follow" as we do not follow scholars today. Shias are the only ones who follow, as they have spiritual leaders, not sunnis. The Quran tells us to follow the Quran. We only seek guidance of the Quran from scholars but we don't follow them. We only follow the prophets and revelation from the prophets.
I know agree that some shias are actually deviant people or misguided or hypocrites
Only Allah is infallible, not man.
Your statement is against Quran.
@@Thaqlain Not it's not
Please check Surah Najm verse 3. Don't belittle the Prophet to justify the status you give to certain companions and wives.
You behave as if Aisha was not human and that she was not a young immature woman with human qualities of being jealous etc. Answer one question why did the Rasul take her as his wife. If not to relate details that would only serve to enlighten the Ummah. Who is it that follow Aisha? Follow Quran and the Prophet
A large number of narrations come from Ayesha. So should we follow the Sunnah quoted by an "immature person"? Also, the topic on wisdom behind marrying her is already covered in this series. It seems you only watched this episode :)
Without attacking aisha and the sahaba, what else do you have to provide. Your religion is based on resentment and insult. Other than that what depth do you have.
So from a series based on 300+ episodes you watch one episode and present a conclusion? :)
He has a delusion 😂
Yahood 😂
C O N J E C T U R E 😂
A kufr 😢
Aren’t we stupid to make sects based on what Ayesha RAA says or Fatima RAA says . They aren’t the prophets nor did they get the revelation. We do not follow either because Islam should not have sects than it is not Islam . Islam is Quran first these are irrelevant hadiths
It seems you missed the purpose of this episode. 🙂
Well explanation.
Astaghfirullah May Allah guide you in the straight path this all lies don't believe read the Quran Aisha (R.A) IS. THE MOST RESPECTED WOMAN AND SHE HAS NEVER DONE BAD THINGS
Aisha r.a was among FIRST OF MUHAJIRUNS to whom Allah was pleased and promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.
Allah would never be pleased and promise Paradise if she would disobey Prophet a.s and hurt his family.
But they follow abu talib who didn’t even say the shahada on his death bed.
Because he did not need to. He was a Muslim already :)
@@Thaqlain don’t think so even the prophet pbuh when people around him said we think he said the shahada he said I didn’t hear him. Abu talib was kind to the prophet but his arrogance towards his ancestors idol worship has led him to the hell fire.
We have explored the faith of Abu Talib in detail already. Not sure how is his faith justifying the acts of Ayesha.
To learn more about the faith of Abu Talib, please check episode 58 onwards ua-cam.com/video/rM0Fce0erfs/v-deo.html
@@Thaqlain the evidence suggests otherwise.
Because some Muslims are adamant about ignoring the vastly available evidence, Abu Talib and other ancestors of the Prophet were Hanifs. They already were following Allah (subhanahu wa tala)
Never heard before seyad mohammad im 73 yrs old you only fooled yourselves 😅😂
These are all from your own books which are claimed as Sahih books :)
He is ignorant of the holy Quran and he misinterprets the Quran
That's a great accusation without any proof.
See how they speak on the prophet’s wife? And they get mad when we say they’re not Muslim😂
God guide the sincere ones amongst you, and punish the willful transgressors.
Does presenting the wrongful acts of a Prophet's wife make you non-Muslim?
@@Thaqlain accusing her of committing zina (astagfirullah)? The prophet’s own wife? What does that say about the prophet himself? You people best repent and move away from this doctrine which is based on filthy (and mostly sexual btw) accusations. All about hate and cursing prophet’s wife and companion
Where have we in this video accussed her of committing zina?
@@Thaqlain its a well known shia belief. Do you bot believe she did commit it?
Nope. No mainstream follower of Ahlulbayt believes in such garbage.
Y"all are fools ,for misinterpreting hadees . ZALIM !
Also the claims You making is a clear sign You have no clue how the Great Jurist and His like Understood Agaadeeth so My sincere advice to You study اثرالحديث
1:09 1:49
(A) Allah tell us in al quran that His holy book will seperate 2 kind of human..
1.person who read,practice and teach other with the sincere heart will always be guide,he never be astray..
2.person who read,not practicing,and teach other with his only critical mind,he will be the best friend of iblis laknatullah..
(B)Allah also tell us that His previous book already being corrupt by devilish human..
Only quran Allah will preserve till the end of time but why al quran??
1.means,Allah want to show us who is sincere toward His deen.
He want human who have a desire and free choice to think very carefully for every choice human made eitheir with only his mind or using his mind combine with the sincere heart..
2.Allah tell us clearly that human and iblis will againts His teaching,and if human and iblis can change the verse the previous holy book,what bout hadith??
They will find a way to do that because their cannot fight Al quran
(Allah already promise to guard His final book)
So we as a muslim,we need to learn and take hadith that never argue with the Al quran...
This is the secret to learn hadith in islam...
Our beloved prophet already clearly tell us at the end of His khutbah..
Hold tightly to Al quran and my sunnah
Everyone who against its(whatever sect he is) means eithier he is jahil(low on knoledge)or he is pure munafiqun(double faces)
To understand Al quran,we need ulama or schoolar that hold tighly with Al quran and sunnah of the prophet..
To recognise them,Allah already put some secret in Al quran for us..
To get that secret,u need heart that very very clearly sincere submit to Allah s.w.t
Allah realy love this rare kind of heart...
To know that if our heart is sincere toward Allah is when u read some verse,your body and soul will vibrte because of scared toward HIM,and your eyes will crying itself..
Means...
U understand what ur reading and ur accept it with open heart..
Sincere heart is rarely hard to grab,to get it u have to be a best person in every action u did only for the sake of Allah..
When Allah is proud at u,u wont be misguide by any force or certain foolish group...
Wallahu a'lam..
Just a minor correction: the Prophet, the Quran, and his progeny. This is the consensus of all Muslim books.
@@Thaqlain thats is your faith,mine only 2..
Alquran and sunnah..
If i want to study more bout quran deeply,then i can go refer to ulama and hadith..
If i want to know bout some faith or religion,i will study many references so that i always do just and honest for my own mind also for the cause of Allah..
We are not created to be perfect 101% to grab all knowledge in this world
But what we can do is learn and compare it very carefuly with knowledge,both or lots of references,so that we can understand it very quickly without being force by other to accept it..
Enemy of islam forget bout this things..
They think they can do whatever they want in this world,but they cant make heart that is so pure and sincere became black and full of confusion..
Once heart feel the love of Allah,he just want to die and meet Allah very3 quickly..
He sure afraid bout his sin etc etc but pure sincere heart feeling to meet Allah is what enemy of islam cannot get or understand till the end if time..
What are wasteful time he have..
Thats why Allah told us,HE love us(pure sincere heart)more than our parent or spouse love us..
This love is so rare and special,if u dont cry or get tremble when reading quran,means ur heart are not fully sincere toward Allah s.w.t
It is just waste of time..
They got money,beautiful women,nice car,big house,smart children,land and property..
But they will never ever,get that feeling..
Feeling love from Allah,and will do anything to make Allah proud at us..
He love Allah so much,and he knew that Allah also love him..
This person will never act ignorant and will do honest and justice eitheir for his self or to other..
Allahu akbar...
Your own books including Sahih Muslim mention Kitab wa Itrat 🙂
@@Thaqlain not mine..Schoolar..
Their are only our tool to knew Allah and his commandment..
Nothing more nothing less
Their also a human being like us,our different only for knowledgeable..
Their book is not our GOD,not our core faith,we can take it to learn,believe or disbelieve at their opinion..
Only Alquran our core believe,we obey it and we listen..
Insya Allah...
Other than that,is only for deep understanding and for free time..
We as a muslim,dont take prophet s.a.w or sahabah or ahlul bait as our GOD
They are only our mentor on how to live in this world and after we all die,we can meet again..
But ofcourse,the goal is not them..
The creator itself!!
Lots of question i got,like how mathmatic,wind,sky,gravity,soil in paradise or hell,between air and space,what kind of light can reach the lowwest sea,lot of it..
Ulama or schoolar do they have that??
Thats why as a muslim,we are not taking a schoolar,prophet,hadith,artis,material in world as our GOD
Thats is why we always target only one goal..
To meet Allah only
and to do that we realy have to focus one thing..
Sincere heart...
Because Allah realy love that heart..
All the 'keys' actualy reveal in Al quran
Only pure heart can 'see' it
thaqlain.org/guide/do-we-need-the-prophet-when-we-have-the-quran/
This should answer your concern.