10 Frequently Asked Questions: First Voyage Around the World
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лип 2024
- #readingsinphilippinehistory #philippinehistory #firstvoyage
In this discussion video, we will answer the 10 FAQs from our viewers on the Readings on Philippine History topic, First Voyage Around the World.
References:
Pigafetta, Antonio. Magellan's First Voyage Around the World (Robertson Edition). Cleveland OH: The Arthur H. Clark Company, 1906.
Torres, Jose Victor. Batis: Sources in Philippine History. C&E Publishing. Quezon city, 2018.
nhcp.gov.ph
Thank you sir
No questions for now Sir., I'm only thankful for this channel. I hope you continue to upload more videos that will serve as a foundation of not only knowledge but also patriotism.
Thank you for your appreciation! We will give our best!
I like your topic in history with a relayionship to magellans mabigation
thank you po! sana patuloy lang po kayong mag upload ng vids.
Thank you! I will try my best!
Merong mga survivors sa crew ni Magellan na nagsulat ng libro maliban kay Pegaffeta.... Meron din isa na bumalik sa Pilipinas at tumira na sa Pilipinas... at si El cano ay bumalik din sa mga sumunod na expedition kaso namatay siya sa biyahe at di na nakarating sa Pilipinas....
Resolved that antonio pigafetta was accurate in recording the first voyage of magellan around the world.
Pasagot po para sa debate namin
Bigyan niyo po ako ng dalawang tanong at yung sagot niya napo🙏🏿
Identifying historical issues that are addressed towards fully understanding Philippine history (2 items questions #3&4)
3.?
4.?
Developing critical and analytical skills through the use of the source (2 items questions #5&6).
5.?
6.?
Tulungan niyo napo ako!❤
Sana po meron kayong videos ng mga tanong nayan.
Pros and cons of 1st voyage in the Philippines.
Who were the 5 commanders of the 5 ship of Ferdinand Magellan?
Trinidad- FERDINAND MAGELLAN
San Antonio- JUAN DE CARTAGENA
Conception- GASPAR DE QUESADA
Victoria- LUIS DE MENDOZA
Santiago- JUAN SERRANO
correct me if I'm wrong 😊
What were the basic assumptions made by Pigafetta, Antonio on that journal Magellan's First Voyage Around the World? Thank you for answering
Hi! Going into the journey, their assumption is that they can go to the east by using the western route
Portuguese po si Magellan kaya Portuguese Ang alam din ni Enrique
Tama po kayo na si Magellan ay Portuguese pero ang wikang Espanyol at Portuguese ay galing sa wikang Latin kaya magkahalintulad ito sa maraming paraan.
We have a case study abt this and i watch your video po that u applauded po 2 yrs ago, i just want to ask lang po what is the main issue/arguments that i will write po abt sa topic? Although i have an idea na but i don't know if those arguments is the specific po for our case study hehe
Hi. I would suggest how Pigafetta's account would corroborate with anthropological and historical research about pre-colonial culture of Flipinos in the areas visited by Magellan.
@@profnextdoor21 Thank you so much, sir!
Hello po tanong ko lang po kung magkaaway po ba talaga si Rajah Humabon at Lapu Lapu? Kasi diba po si Rajah Humabon po yung nag utos kay Magellan na tapatan si Lapu-Lapu pero nung napatay na po ng mga tauhan ni Lapu-Lapu si Magellan, bumalik yung remaining tauhan ni Magellan kay Rajah humabon pero pinapatay niya ang mga ito. Ano po ba meron sa kanila ni Lapu-Lapu at Rajah Humabon?
Thank you for your great effort in understanding this part. The answer to your question could be politically related as Lapulapu and Humabon's territory are both located in Cebu. Researchers are also pointing out merchant ship raiding also caused the rift between the two.
Question ko po
Where was the historical event take place ?
Saan ho ha talaga ?
If you are talking about the first mass, I hope my latest vlog can help!
ua-cam.com/video/5bzjYV0vcJw/v-deo.html
how can you say po sir na naging bias po si pigafetta when it comes to this fellow travellers, catholic faith and to magellan?
Question #3 poyan.
At yung mga mayayaman duon sa Europa sila yung nagbibigay ng pondo para makabili ng mga barko at porwesyon...
Ano po yung porwesyon? Porwesyon poba?
Sana po masagot🙏🏿
I think you are referring to Provision. Yung Provision po ay ang supply nila ng mga pagkain at gamit sa paglalakbay
@@profnextdoor21 maraming salamat po sa pagreply!❤
Im a commercial pilot instructor. Any pilot, sailor or traveler on cars too knows all vehicles need to have the maps or charts of the route to follow not only one and the others "follow me". What about if the ship or vehicle in front loose the others in a storm or simply at night? The others, with no maps or idea where they were going will get lost. That is one of the rules of fleet or multi vehicle navigation. Magellan didnt give any maps of the route to the others ships, only the portughese crew one in which he was too. That is a huge violation of navigation rules. Im a pilot instructor. He lied to the others about giving them the maps after a while, but didnt.
Huge Magellan Devilish Plan to make the others get lost and he and the Italians and portugeese navigate only and put down Spain sailors. He wanted the Spain crews to get lost, of course. That is why the others mutiny againts him. The liar also become a murderer. Good his arrogance made him try to defeat about 1,000 islanders with only about 50. Arrogant got killed and Delcano decided to circumnavigate instead of backtrack which was the initial plan.
sir for you po, who is hurt by the ideas in the first voyage around the world?
What do you mean with your question? Can you please elaborate a little so I can answer effectively 🙏😊
like kung sino po yung negative na naapektuhan sa document na ginawa ni Pigafetta po
Hmmm wala naman sa kanila mismo pero siguro pinakita lang ng sinulat ni Pigafetta na mali ang pananaw ng mga espanyol na naabutan nila tayo dito na parang mga savage at walang alam dahil malinaw sa sinulat ni Pigafetta na mayaman tayo sa kultura at sopistikado na ang ating lipunan ng dumating sila dito
navigation
Can you create an analysis of the brief summary of the first voyage around the world by Magellan on the accounts written by Antonio pigafetta
@Prof next dor
@Prof next door
Sir, How are the narratives contained in the account First Voyage Around the World redefine Philippine history?
This opened up a lot of information about our precolonial culture and gave us a glimpse of how the Filipinos are living their lives thru a first hand source like Pigafetta's journal
Hi sir, is there a possible biases in Pigaffeta's account?
Yes, naturally he is biased towards his fellow travellers, to the catholic faith and of course to magellan
What's the author perspectives at the first voyage around the world ??
In summary, Pigafetta thought that Magellan's voyage is still successful even with the demise of Magellan while in the Philippine Islands.
Hi siirrr, according po kay Antonio Pigafetta, saan po ba sila nag held ng first mass sa Philippines? is it Limasawa or Masao?
Hi! I hope my vlog can help you with this query. Enjoy watching!
ua-cam.com/video/5bzjYV0vcJw/v-deo.htmlsi=nQXp9PXrFIo2OnWc
Hii po, good morning! Can I ask po kung ano 'yung author's main argument and examination of authors main argument sa first voyage around the world? Sana po masagot. Thank youu.・▽・
I think the best way to answer that question is that Pigafetta's writings tried to prove that Magellan's voyage were able to reach our country using the western/pacific route and was able to go back to Spain successfully.
Sir about po sa poem ni Rizal kay Sebastian Elcano ask lang po ano yong reason bat niya sinulat yon?
Hi, Rizal has a lot of interest with history specially the precolonial period. I think this is just him giving recognition to the efforts of Elcano to circumnavigate the globe
So possible poba na si Sebastian Elcano yong nakapag circumnavigate?
@@user-fu1hu9nk6s not just possible but technically pwede natin masabi na siya tlga unless proven na iba ang nauna
Thank you po✨
Si Lapulapu ay matanda na at nanood lang sa laban, Kilala nila si Lapulapu dahil nag negotiate nga sila diba para sakupin at para I ransom Ang bangkay ni Magellan
In the primary source, who are those who disnaturalized themselves?
Sir. Can I ask the date and publication?
A book was later published around 1894. It was said that Pigafetta gave copies of his journal as early as 1523.
@@profnextdoor21 thankyou sir❣️
Welcome and enjoy learning! Please share to others!
@@profnextdoor21 hello po, saang lugar po siya na published?
What was the importance of butuan city in magellans voyage?
It was the original site of the first mass until it was changed to Limasawa as the location of the first mass.
Thank you sir 🫰
Thank you! Please subscribe and follow my facebook page! facebook.com/profile.php?id=100092197217843&mibextid=D4KYlr
Sir tanong lang po bakit nag tatravel sya sa buong mundo si Antonio pigafetta ano yung purpose nya??
Actually na enganyo lang sumama si pigafetta out of curiosity dahil sa ruta na gagamitin ni magellan na papuntang kanluran upang makarating sa Asya
si pigafetta po ba yang nasa 5:04 po?
Hi! Si Magellan po
Hello sir, pwede po magtanong about pre-colonial and spanish period po ng Philippines?
If may bagay na mag re represent sa period po na ito, ano po yon? Kailangan po kasi namin magdala ng something that represents those period po and wala pa rin po talaga akong maisip na madadala 😭
Hi the best item that you can bring if pre-colonial ay kung may damit pangkatutubo po kayo. Sa Spanish period naman ay pwede ang any catholic religous item since ayun naman ang pinakanaipamana nila sa atin
@@profnextdoor21 thank you sir ❤️
@@ivanlawrenzovlog4165 thank you! Please like and subscribe to my fb page and youtube channel
@@profnextdoor21 sir ask lang po yung traditional crucifixion, kasama po ba 'to sa na influence sa Phillipines during Spanish period?
@@ivanlawrenzovlog4165 what do you mean? Yung pagpapako sa krus s mahal n araw or yung cross na cross n religious item? Yung second kasama po
Hi sir! I have a question. Why was Pigafetta's journal not published?
Hi. Pigafetta's journal was published but not immediately. The first copies of his journal went to European royalties which further the desire to travel to asia.
@@profnextdoor21 We were asked po kasi on why was his journal not published, and different cites says that the original was lost and others says that it was not published because of lack of fund for printing which I doubt since here’s from a wealthy family.
@@profnextdoor21 and bakit po napunta sa European Royalties?
The original manuscript of Pigafetta was indeed lost but he managed to publish copies of his journal although it was unclear where and when. French and Italian Archivist tried to study and translate the remaining sources in the 1800s and published their own work. Ito na yung mga ginagamit ntn na basis for studying the circumnavigation.
European royalties usually are interested with these books since Monarchy sponsored explorations are popular at that time.
Hi sir, ask lng po if the point of view of Antonio during his voyage was negatively biased towards natives especially the way he describes what he just sees?
Maybe biased in terms of his allegiance with Magellan. But towards the natives not really but he might have been biased in favor of his catholic faith with towards how the natives are performing religious practices
@@profnextdoor21 thank you po sir!
I've read some comments, and some of my classmates claimed he has a biased perspective towards native. But it was their view, and I know po I have nothing to do on it.
What are the negative impacts of the first voyage in the Philippines?
It led to the Colonization that started the oppression of Filipinos
moluccas po ba yan sir or moluquas?
Moluccas po. Pede rin po Moluques