LIVE: MA v. Karen Read Day 12 - Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial | COURT TV

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 чер 2024
  • LIVE COURT CAM: MA v. #KarenRead - DAY 12 - Testimony continues in the murder trial of Karen Read. Read is accused of murdering her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, whose body was found in the snow outside of another Boston officer’s home in Canton, Massachusetts.
    Prosecutors allege Read hit O’Keefe with her car and left him to die in the snow. But Read’s defense team says she never hurt O’Keefe and that she is being framed by the true killers, who may have been inside the house where his body was found.
    00:00:00 MA v. Karen Read Day 12
    00:28:28 STATE WITNESS #31: JULIE NAGEL, Friend of Brian Albert, Jr.
    00:33:55 STATE WITNESS #32: TERI KUN, FORENSIC SCIENTIST
    01:25:49 STATE WITNESS #33: RYAN NAGEL, BROTHER OF JULIE NAGEL
    02:32:04 STATE WITNESS #34: HEATHER MAXON, RYAN NAGEL’s GIRLFRIEND
    03:00:16 STATE WITNESS #35: RICHARD D'ANTUONO RYAN NAGEL’s FRIEND
    03:41:21 STATE WITNESS #36: ALLISON MCCABE, COLIN ALBERT'S FRIEND
    06:22:38 STATE WITNESS #37: COLIN ALBERT, BRIAN ALBERT'S NEPHEW
    #CourtTV Catch up on all the facts of the case against #KarenRead, Killer Or Cover-Up #MurderTrial. ⚖️👇
    MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/
    Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
    Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
    Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
    FOLLOW THE CASE:
    Facebook / courttv
    Twitter/X / courttv
    Instagram / courttvnetwork
    TikTok / courttvlive
    UA-cam / courttv
    WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE www.courttv.com/trials/
    HOW TO FIND COURT TV www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/

КОМЕНТАРІ • 537

  • @COURTTV
    @COURTTV  19 днів тому +8

    00:00:00 MA v. Karen Read Day 12
    00:28:28 STATE WITNESS #31: JULIE NAGEL, Friend of Brian Albert, Jr.
    00:33:55 STATE WITNESS #32: TERI KUN, FORENSIC SCIENTIST
    01:25:49 STATE WITNESS #33: RYAN NAGEL, BROTHER OF JULIE NAGEL
    02:32:04 STATE WITNESS #34: HEATHER MAXON, RYAN NAGEL’s GIRLFRIEND
    03:00:16 STATE WITNESS #35: RICHARD D'ANTUONO RYAN NAGEL’s FRIEND
    03:41:21 STATE WITNESS #36: ALLISON MCCABE, COLIN ALBERT'S FRIEND
    06:22:38 STATE WITNESS #37: COLIN ALBERT, BRIAN ALBERT'S NEPHEW
    #CourtTV Catch up on all the facts of the case against #KarenRead, Killer Or Cover-Up #MurderTrial. ⚖👇
    MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/?

  • @Chris-Alia
    @Chris-Alia 19 днів тому +64

    06:20:28 Allison said, "He (Colin) was not at the house WHEN JOHN WAS THERE" - quote. So, John was there.

    • @theghostofrethsich2813
      @theghostofrethsich2813 19 днів тому

      @@Kaykay-nn8ydthe pig dna puts John inside the house …. Dr Scott stills case comes to mind.
      Woman found deleted at bottom of stairs, only dna they find comes from a pig. It took a while before the police found out their dog always had a pig ear to chew

    • @glo3139
      @glo3139 19 днів тому +8

      Her POINT is that someone or MANY saw OJO THERE, and it’s being covered up!!! Oh please!!!

    • @user-cd9yl2qd1u
      @user-cd9yl2qd1u 19 днів тому +16

      @@Kaykay-nn8yd Tf is my point? It's HER point, not mine. How does she KNOW when John was there? Hmm? How does she KNOW if his body and Colin weren't on the property at the SAME TIME? Oh, I know. BECAUSE SHE TESTIFIED that Colin wasn't there WHEN JOHN WAS THERE.

    • @jellyhead2100
      @jellyhead2100 19 днів тому +3

      Yes...he was outside with KR in car, not physically in the house.

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому +2

      Another one. Do people twist things the way the want the. Twisted ? Like a defence team.
      She said he wasn’t there when John was. Time stamps know this to be fact. There wasn’t 2 cats out front when she picked him up were there ?

  • @glo3139
    @glo3139 19 днів тому +51

    I think that the defense HAS ALREADY PROVEN REASONABLE DOUBT, and frankly, that’s their only job. It’s up to the Commonwealth to prove guilt, and they haven’t done that! Jurors aren’t idiots. If we see through the lies and inconsistencies, they do too!!! THAT is the point!!

    • @christinab3019
      @christinab3019 19 днів тому +8

      Thank you for having common sense

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому +2

      Yeah I have no doubt. Others might. We know what’s coming. The defence are trying to play twisty. It doesn’t work on me but may work on others.

    • @brandybiscoff9685
      @brandybiscoff9685 18 днів тому +6

      Trial isn’t even halfway through so of course the case isn’t proven yet… there’s still a lot of evidence to come. This is why a jury isn’t allowed to deliberate until the entire case is presented… you don’t get to just watch the first 1/3 of the trial and then say “not enough evidence.”

    • @InjuriousPersonalities
      @InjuriousPersonalities 15 днів тому

      You have it backwards lol. Reasonable doubt is what the defense has to inject into the commonwealth’s case. The prosecution is the one who has to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt.

  • @AshleyMarieMommy
    @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +11

    I love when these “kids” get pressured and mad they say angerly say nope

  • @julybliss4440
    @julybliss4440 19 днів тому +19

    How can allison McCabe say that Collin wasn't there when O'Keefe was at Albert home , when everyone is saying they didn't see O'Keefe at that home and definitely didn't see him in front of home being ran over by who they are accusing.

  • @user-se1ev7my6f
    @user-se1ev7my6f 18 днів тому +15

    ‘Collin was not at the house when John was there.’ 😳. Then tearless ‘tears’. WTF?

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому +2

      I love the we are harassed comment. As if your family hasn’t harassed the entire Town for the past 50 years

  • @06mrselfdestruct
    @06mrselfdestruct 19 днів тому +39

    He remembers brake lights from 2 years ago, but when asked if he talked to his sister about their mom picking her up he says “ it was 2 years ago” funny how that works huh?

    • @December2013
      @December2013 19 днів тому +12

      Kind of like all the Alberts remembering the exact order everyone came in and left and who was there and where they sat but they don't remember anything else from that night

    • @Seryma86
      @Seryma86 19 днів тому +7

      @@December2013 at this point unless there’s a smoking gun yet to be unleashed it seems like Read will be found not guilty by reasonable doubt. That entire canton police force along with all the people involved need to be investigated. There’s no way they’re that inept to the the point they make inspector clouseau look like Sherlock Holmes

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому +2

      Visual memory is superior to auditory memory.

  • @user-se1ev7my6f
    @user-se1ev7my6f 18 днів тому +18

    I’ve never heard this many prosecutors witnesses, in Any trial, saying ‘Can you rephrase that?’ Talk about being ‘coached’! And every prosecutor witness looks at Lalley when the defense asks questions on cross to see if he is going to Object! This is insane!

    • @brandybiscoff9685
      @brandybiscoff9685 18 днів тому +2

      That’s bc you have no experience in trials or examining witnesses. The times witnesses have said that, is bc the question wasn’t clear as worded. Witnesses are always told- by both sides- if you don’t understand a question, ask to repeat or rephrase the question. It’s a standard ground rule.

    • @user-se1ev7my6f
      @user-se1ev7my6f 18 днів тому +5

      @@brandybiscoff9685 you couldn’t be more Wrong! I used to work for a District Magistrate, you know, the First Court Defendants are required to attend! So, come again?

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +6

      Gives them time to think

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +5

      @@brandybiscoff9685it’s because they’ve been “prepped” and they were prepped if they need time to think they ask that

    • @SimplySuspiciousShawna
      @SimplySuspiciousShawna 18 днів тому +1

      I had to give a deposition once and my lawyer told me to look at him to verify whether he would object or not prior to answering questions.

  • @gs11817
    @gs11817 19 днів тому +55

    MR. LALLY NEEDS TO SPEAK UP! ugh, he is so hard to hear and one of the witnesses asked him to speak up twice. Judge has never asked him to speak louder but has asked more than one to speak into the mic. Judge has also reprimanded some on defense side for answering “yup” or “mhm”, but not once to anyone on prosecution side. Same thing for “Don’t say what you heard, but what actually happened”…she is one sided. She is always rushing the defense and shutting down important questions.

    • @glo3139
      @glo3139 19 днів тому +7

      Seems like Mr Lally doesn’t know what a microphone is!!! 🙄🙄🙄🙄

    • @melissabenson6749
      @melissabenson6749 19 днів тому +3

      Who "Aunt Bev" Albert's family friend?

    • @redsassyfox1912
      @redsassyfox1912 19 днів тому +9

      I just can’t with this Judge she is so rude and unfair

    • @brihaver1951
      @brihaver1951 19 днів тому +3

      @@redsassyfox1912Completely biased.

    • @DT-su8cq
      @DT-su8cq 18 днів тому

      I feel she’d biased but I haven’t decided who I’m believing yet!

  • @Bigslick99578
    @Bigslick99578 19 днів тому +21

    Ryan Nagel confirms the Feds are watching. This hearing is just the opening act not the main attraction.

    • @brandybiscoff9685
      @brandybiscoff9685 18 днів тому +1

      This hearing (??) Do you mean the trial?

    • @user-ji5gz5fu3g
      @user-ji5gz5fu3g 18 днів тому +1

      The Feds have been looking in to all this and obviously found nothing so far. Seems that investigation will go nowhere and everyone is getting hyped up over nothing as usual.

    • @crystalclearsun
      @crystalclearsun 17 днів тому

      🍿 😎

    • @user-ji5gz5fu3g
      @user-ji5gz5fu3g 17 днів тому +1

      @@crystalclearsun The Feds have been on this case so long….if something was going to happen it would have by now. Dream on people that are getting hyped up for nothingness 😴 💭

    • @crystalclearsun
      @crystalclearsun 17 днів тому

      @@user-ji5gz5fu3g
      You're not looking forward to the liars having their day in court? When they are exposed?

  • @jeannie2315
    @jeannie2315 18 днів тому +8

    Colin doesn’t remember much but he remembers 12:10 🤣🤣 interesting!!!

  • @mariap4828
    @mariap4828 19 днів тому +10

    Wow! Who knew you could change the date and time!!?? I just tried it. Thank you Mr Ianetti!

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому +2

      I tried but no dice there. I cannot change mine. Maybe because it’s an older phone.

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому +1

      Screen shots are easy to manipulate too with photoshop or a photocopier and an exacto knife

  • @theghostofrethsich2813
    @theghostofrethsich2813 19 днів тому +19

    Pig DNA? Reminds me of the Dr. Scott Sills trial They found pig dna on her but they found out her dog loved pigs ears

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому

      Lol yeah sure. So are you saying that pig would be shown but not dog ? Haha. More like he had bacon cooking at it spat as it does.

    • @casey5683
      @casey5683 19 днів тому +3

      @@stevenprice6957if a dog had eaten a pig ear, holding it with his paws and then scratched someone you would find the pig dna before the dogs

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому +2

      @@casey5683Ridiculous. Fairy stories. More like he cooked bacon at some stage or pork. That is not a dog scratch. It looks as though it’s the glass that’s also. Made out of plastic that has crashed on impact and gone into his arm. That’s what I think.

    • @julybliss4440
      @julybliss4440 19 днів тому +5

      ​@@stevenprice6957lol. Talk about ridiculous. Arm Injuries twice the size of the whole glass( shattered or in one piece.

    • @notsorryyouretriggered
      @notsorryyouretriggered 19 днів тому +3

      @@stevenprice6957 Not a “fairy story” real life DNA transfer. Having no comprehension of how something occurs doesn’t make it an improbability. Learn that.

  • @blufifi
    @blufifi 18 днів тому +6

    Why on earth can they not quieten that courtroom down! Ridiculous. Sniffing ,coughing , banging, sirens, trucks. Offering the coughers a lozenge might help.

  • @Deanna_422
    @Deanna_422 19 днів тому +21

    Why isn’t it a big deal that minors are being allowed to drink alcohol? I or anyone in my family would never allow someone to drink alcohol if they weren’t 21 or older!!!

    • @ellimpiador6559
      @ellimpiador6559 19 днів тому +8

      It's the Boston area, where abiding by rules is often aspirational.

    • @redsassyfox1912
      @redsassyfox1912 18 днів тому +3

      Boston PD is allowing it! So it’s on them now

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому

      Cop kids cops gave it to the kids

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому +2

      Lol.What about all the cops? It is not like you don't know that parents buy alcohol for their minor kids.

    • @adriennem7927
      @adriennem7927 18 днів тому +1

      ​@@maanmohammad8459doubt they bought alcohol. Not t he point

  • @deltatango6793
    @deltatango6793 19 днів тому +13

    The best time to notice a damaged brake light is at night when the brakes are being used.

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому +3

      Yeah Well I’m sure the 3 people behind knew that there was going to be a dead man a massive trial that night. They just knew the car was running. Karen among her 4 or 5 different stories said that she got there dropped him off and then sat out front for 10 mins. More like she sat with him for ten minutes before killing.

    • @deltatango6793
      @deltatango6793 19 днів тому +2

      @@stevenprice6957 or she waited for him to text her and say it was okay to come inside.. and she never got a text and got mad and left because he was jumped on his way in by a jealous and drunk Higgins in the basement… and the Nagel sister came out to her brother through the door by the basement but how did she go back in? Or was Karen’s dome light on because her passenger door was open because John was standing next to the car talking with her still?

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +1

      YUp and at night you’d know!!!

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +2

      @@stevenprice6957when the tale light cover is broke the lightbulbs are Clear. They only show red because the cover is covering them. If broken it would have shunned bright white especially in the dark!!!! Without covers they would look like headlights maybe deemed

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому +2

      No other cams on the block captured any of this??

  • @deltatango6793
    @deltatango6793 18 днів тому +5

    “He’s bound to mess it up.” …before Ricky takes the stand… who? What? How?

    • @mandyb3509
      @mandyb3509 4 дні тому

      He said "I was bound to mess it up" referring to Ricky's last name. Prosecution and defense struggled multiple times to say his last name. Hope this helps 🙂

    • @deltatango6793
      @deltatango6793 4 дні тому

      @@mandyb3509 but it was several seconds after he already said it. The whole name. And I get the impression that they never saw Karen driving from the direction that they claim she came… That was all fabricated to make it seem like Karen pulled up to the house from that side and a three-point turn was made after she dropped off John… But in reality she came from the other direction, those three kids in the car never saw her at that intersection, and Karen made the three-point turn before pulling up to the front of the house and letting John out of the car. Which is another reason why Jen McCabe wanted to get all of the messages from that girl that was getting picked up so she could create her perfect little scenario.

  • @Bigslick99578
    @Bigslick99578 19 днів тому +24

    They got the q-tips for the dna swab from the same neighbor cop that gave them the red solo cups

    • @christinab3019
      @christinab3019 19 днів тому +2

      I don't mean too laugh but you're right 😂

    • @julybliss4440
      @julybliss4440 19 днів тому

      😂

    • @bobking4031
      @bobking4031 19 днів тому

      Yes its funny how the dna came back as a pig and he was murdered at a policemans place Hmmmm the mind boggles

  • @337lonewolf
    @337lonewolf 19 днів тому +30

    All these witnesses have attitudes on cross

    • @brandybiscoff9685
      @brandybiscoff9685 18 днів тому +2

      They’ve kept pretty good control of their attitudes, but any attitude on cross is easily explained by the fact that they’ve been brutally harassed for 2 years bc of this case by people like you, and much worse.

    • @337lonewolf
      @337lonewolf 18 днів тому +1

      @@brandybiscoff9685
      Evidently, you’re not watching the same trial
      They all had attitudes their tone changed the way they came across with answers changed. They were very short.
      They had attitudes with the defense and the jury will see that. Only two people only two people have reported being harassed. is a difference when I say all the witnesses have attitudes meaning all of them
      When you talk about harassment your sidebar Ing something else that has nothing to do with anything because it was only two not all . Good try though.

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому +2

      @@337lonewolfyou could see Colin try to not do that bully thug body shake when he was upset. His body bent and visibly moved on the right side when he was pissed. They can put him in a button down and Henley pullover all day long, he’s a thug.

    • @337lonewolf
      @337lonewolf 18 днів тому +1

      @@Hhevvy
      I agree. You can see his body change between the state and the defense. And you can tell on the videos, him talking like a little thug.
      When I first seen him on the stand, I had bad vibes on the kid.
      How many times are gonna catch them up in a lie
      It’s just funny that some of these witnesses stories don’t line up

    • @kingduran007
      @kingduran007 17 днів тому

      Your attitude would change when the defense treats you like a criminal and act like your under interrogation

  • @stellawilkerson7579
    @stellawilkerson7579 18 днів тому +4

    Who thinks the State Police dropped the ball? Innocent or guilty???

  • @DCB-lk4nj
    @DCB-lk4nj 18 днів тому

    What time is court starting today ?

  • @AshleyMarieMommy
    @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +5

    What’s the most said words in this trial? *Objection sustained*

  • @06mrselfdestruct
    @06mrselfdestruct 19 днів тому +12

    “She was alone” that proves John went into that house, they didn’t see him go in the house because he was talking to his sister

  • @erikchristysalek9007
    @erikchristysalek9007 17 днів тому +1

    Whats with the commas in the dates on the photos of the screen shots?
    Jan 28, 2022,

  • @kathleenframe4480
    @kathleenframe4480 3 дні тому

    He keeps saying “ to my acknowledgment “…….🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @hannadowney
    @hannadowney 18 днів тому +6

    Is this trial sponsored by white claw?

  • @taraholloway8569
    @taraholloway8569 19 днів тому +32

    Did Alli say Colin wasn't at the house when John was?!!

    • @annapires1879
      @annapires1879 19 днів тому +6

      Yes

    • @hammer6803
      @hammer6803 19 днів тому +5

      Dude I heard that too!!!! 6min and 20 seconds *

    • @josephinedimercurio5012
      @josephinedimercurio5012 19 днів тому +3

      No

    • @JB-ge7vc
      @JB-ge7vc 19 днів тому +13

      She sure did! And in the screenshots of the text messages the date never changed from the 11:55pm msg to the 12:10am msg which I believe iPhone does automatically. Something is very off imo.

    • @gs11817
      @gs11817 19 днів тому

      Can you time stamp it because I can’t find it

  • @MrPotterb33
    @MrPotterb33 19 днів тому +12

    All I can hear is Ms Nagel breathing into the mic

    • @gigis6790
      @gigis6790 19 днів тому +1

      I know...classy right?

    • @user-yy3nq8bs3y
      @user-yy3nq8bs3y 18 днів тому +1

      Breathing was elevated for sure

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому

      @@user-yy3nq8bs3yher depends may be full ya know? :). Haha

    • @pbate08pvz31
      @pbate08pvz31 14 днів тому +1

      Darth Nagel

  • @davidrichards1302
    @davidrichards1302 19 днів тому +4

    Does anyone know when the prosecution will begin arguing their case?

  • @amy.gali13
    @amy.gali13 18 днів тому +3

    Normally when either side objects during a trial, they have to justify the objection ..... "Objection, leading. Objection, heresay" ect. This is the first trial I've ever seen where the lawyers dont have to justify their objection. Anyone know why?

    • @mandyb3509
      @mandyb3509 4 дні тому

      I started to read comments while prosecutor asks the same 20 questions to each witness 😅 Anyway, on another day of the trial, some of the commenter's were saying the judge instructed them not to say a justification. I don't know if that's true, or why (if it is true). Hope that helps 🙂

  • @aaronwhite1929
    @aaronwhite1929 19 днів тому +2

    This crime can be summed up in a word problem riddle.
    A train leaves Miami, FL at 12:10pm, another train leaves Canton, MA at 12:05pm travelling backward in a blizzard. Both trains are traveling at 42mph. How long does it take for both trains to meet in Baltimore, MD? … About 7 to 8 minutes.

  • @JockMacHH
    @JockMacHH 19 днів тому +7

    Drinking and driving in Canton seems the thing to do, no Uber's?

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому

      Allie McUber

  • @926paaja
    @926paaja 18 днів тому +4

    Why weren’t there bubbles in the text for Colin? Why is the time stamp weird? John was at the house? Hmmm… time line of everyone is off… oh the feeling of being caught in a lie and the look at me and I’ll object and the judge will sustain game… this is freaking sickening

  • @DeborahFerreira-xw5mc
    @DeborahFerreira-xw5mc 18 днів тому +3

    The year is not shown on text messages and there surely is not a comma between the year and time!!!!

  • @cynmndz2645
    @cynmndz2645 19 днів тому +6

    Heater saying “idk” to most questions seems suss to me

  • @hanginthere65
    @hanginthere65 12 днів тому

    is there any video footage of her or them driving thru town at the times they have testified to???

  • @MFC7625
    @MFC7625 19 днів тому +11

    Allie "McAlbert" said Colin wasn't in the house when John was

  • @lisawileman2342
    @lisawileman2342 18 днів тому +3

    It's funny they all upgraded their phones

  • @Lawh
    @Lawh 19 днів тому +1

    Does anyone know where one could get an audio only live version of this feed?

    • @consciousmachine4138
      @consciousmachine4138 17 днів тому +1

      Just don't look at the screen, bot. You're on youtube, there is sound.

    • @Lawh
      @Lawh 17 днів тому

      @@consciousmachine4138 Alright, then tell me how to play it in the background.

  • @mariap4828
    @mariap4828 19 днів тому +25

    I’m sure she’s a very smart witness by working in the crime lab, but it’s NUCLEAR-NOT NUCULAR!!!

    • @UNiKA_Eye_Color_Inspired
      @UNiKA_Eye_Color_Inspired 19 днів тому +4

      Common pronunciation. It's not like she said 'irregardless' or 'should of went" etc.

    • @WhiteRose360-ji8wc
      @WhiteRose360-ji8wc 19 днів тому +3

      It the accent lol .

    • @julybliss4440
      @julybliss4440 19 днів тому +9

      How can allison McCabe say that Collin wasn't at the there when O'Keefe was at Albert home , when everyone is saying they didn't see O'Keefe at that home and definitely didn't see him in front of home being ran over by who they are accusing.

    • @mariap4828
      @mariap4828 19 днів тому +2

      @@UNiKA_Eye_Color_InspiredMaybe it’s common, but it’s a MIS pronunciation. President Bush said it but it was wrong then too.

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      ​@@UNiKA_Eye_Color_Inspired
      Lol.Or Febeuary

  • @ZachJAudet
    @ZachJAudet 18 днів тому +3

    Life 360 data is gonna be a major determining factor.

  • @3mt696
    @3mt696 17 днів тому +2

    Sounds like she picked him up twice. But they left that out. He didn’t remember who brought him over to uncles.

  • @QUANTSCALE
    @QUANTSCALE 19 днів тому +2

    Not a tear from the witnesses, not one, for such a close community.....

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому +1

      For how much these people supposedly loved John and are there to support him now. Such baloney.

  • @maanmohammad8459
    @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому +3

    The door is opened 😂😂😂and who opened it? Been waiting for those idiots who think theatricals and badgering witnesses will help them win the case.

  • @helen6191
    @helen6191 18 днів тому +6

    I've never seen a judge initiate so many sidebars. also since when can a prosecutor object without a qualifier??? and then the judge allow it and sustain without one! what is going on?

    • @brandybiscoff9685
      @brandybiscoff9685 18 днів тому +1

      Maybe educate yourself on the case & then you would know. The judge ordered that BOTH sides are to object only, and not state the grounds for the objection, and that if more info was needed they would go sidebar. This is bc many attorneys (defense & prosecution) engage in improper speaking objections that can often cross the line into the attorneys “testifying.” It muddies the waters. Better to have a clean trial with clean objections.

    • @helen6191
      @helen6191 18 днів тому +1

      @@brandybiscoff9685 thanks for your gracious explanation.

    • @fatelvis1581
      @fatelvis1581 17 днів тому +1

      @@brandybiscoff9685 Maybe educate yourself on not being a nasty b.

    • @fatelvis1581
      @fatelvis1581 4 дні тому +1

      @@brandybiscoff9685 Maybe educate yourself on not being such a total B.

  • @user-se1ev7my6f
    @user-se1ev7my6f 18 днів тому +1

    Wow! I did not know about changing date/time on a photo/text! (I’m 65 not a tech savvy 20 something). Yianetti is absolutely correct! I just changed a photo I took today to 15 months ago!😳

  • @michaellewis7117
    @michaellewis7117 19 днів тому +7

    wow, caught!

  • @jeannie2315
    @jeannie2315 18 днів тому +1

    So Colin goes around back how does Ally see him get into the building 🤷‍♀️

  • @truckersteve1056
    @truckersteve1056 19 днів тому +2

    OPPPS don't say the FED'S LOL

  • @txmermaid5178
    @txmermaid5178 18 днів тому +3

    🎪🎪🎪There are so many unnecessary interruptions in this case!!! The attorneys object and approach the bench constantly! The judge rushes the attorneys and wants to take breaks more frequently than is warranted.
    The outcome of this trial will be very interesting, to say the least.🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @adriennem7927
    @adriennem7927 18 днів тому

    Question❤

  • @AshleyMarieMommy
    @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +1

    I thought John wasn’t *at* the house

  • @lindazaragoza9528
    @lindazaragoza9528 19 днів тому +4

    Gosh strike me the judge sounds like she’s being woken up w her voice lol

  • @jjcole5830
    @jjcole5830 3 дні тому

    The time stamp on her message!! It’s missing. What a bunch of liars

  • @lissayers8901
    @lissayers8901 19 днів тому +8

    6:59:28 - who is speaking when the voice says "He's bound to mess it up"?

    • @evelynmahoney3569
      @evelynmahoney3569 19 днів тому +3

      @lissayers8901 I caught that too. I went back and looked / listened a second time. It sounded like Mr. Lally said that, the prosecution.

    • @marieannedexter2843
      @marieannedexter2843 19 днів тому +2

      That was about the pronunciation of the last name.

    • @caseylea5151
      @caseylea5151 19 днів тому +1

      Definitely was Lally that said that in response to whatever it was the female that sits right next to him said right before it. I listened a couple times but couldn’t understand what she said.

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      Try harder😂😂it was about the name because everyone was mispronouncing it The case is fine.

    • @evelynmahoney3569
      @evelynmahoney3569 17 днів тому

      @@maanmohammad8459 What name were they referring to?

  • @y-c840
    @y-c840 19 днів тому +4

    The girl sitting beside JOk's brother, looks so like KR they could be related xx

  • @deltatango6793
    @deltatango6793 18 днів тому +2

    Colin never mentions bumping into his aunt Nicole on the way out of the Albert house. I feel like I would have mentioned that.. neither he nor Ally mentions that Nicole and Brian Sr. were home when Ally picked up Colin. Isn’t that what Nicole said? So if Colin was coming outside when Ally was there, shouldn’t they have all been in the driveway at the same time? How did Nicole not know who picked up Colin?

  • @thesewallshaveeyes1508
    @thesewallshaveeyes1508 19 днів тому +2

    Was John O'Keefe's arm itself swabbed as he could had his sleeves pulled up when he received those marks on this arm. I do that all the time myself with long sleeves if I get warm.

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      Lol Try harder

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому

      @@maanmohammad8459nah the examiner didn’t even send clothing to the dog dna person

    • @pbate08pvz31
      @pbate08pvz31 14 днів тому

      In uk we call the police pigs- funny the police presented a swab with only pig dna on it🤷‍♀️😂

  • @sandihulbert5902
    @sandihulbert5902 19 днів тому +5

    Why didn’t defense redirect after she says When John was there??!

    • @JB-ge7vc
      @JB-ge7vc 19 днів тому +9

      Because everyone heard her say it and the point was made. No need to give her an opportunity to “explain” what she meant. I’m sure it will be noted for closing arguments. They may even quote it.

    • @sandihulbert5902
      @sandihulbert5902 19 днів тому +3

      @@JB-ge7vc Good point

    • @Chris-Alia
      @Chris-Alia 19 днів тому +1

      06:20:28 I know! Why?

    • @sandihulbert5902
      @sandihulbert5902 19 днів тому +5

      @@Kaykay-nn8ydnot manipulation, reasonable doubt 🙄

    • @JB-ge7vc
      @JB-ge7vc 19 днів тому +10

      ⁠@@Kaykay-nn8yd She’s a witness for the prosecution so it’s not a defense tactic. She said he was there and the defense can now use her statement. The defense doesn’t have to prove a theory either. The only thing they need is reasonable doubt which the prosecution continues to help provide. So far, there has been zero evidence that Karen hit John.

  • @Witchypout
    @Witchypout 18 днів тому +4

    I've never seen witness testimony presented to the courtroom in multiple choice format by a prosecutor 😳 wtf? Is this proper procedurally ? Judge just sits there or say to witness YOU DIDNT SEE THAT RIGHT? wtf? This whole case is such malarkey. Isn't it obvious to others too?? 🤨

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      I'm sure you're with the crocodile boy camp attacking the judge.But in fact you gave her credit if you're paying attention to when she asks the question herself.

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому

      @@maanmohammad8459she’s phoning it in. Come on.

  • @dianaL579
    @dianaL579 18 днів тому +2

    "i dont remember" the Alberts

  • @storytimeisallthetime2120
    @storytimeisallthetime2120 18 днів тому +2

    Lally needs to SPEAK UP HE'S LITERALLY WHISPERING COMPARED TO THE WITNESSES

  • @user-se1ev7my6f
    @user-se1ev7my6f 18 днів тому +7

    Would a forensic deep dive into an iPhone be able to unveil the date/time a photo/text was originally taken/sent? I’m amazed at how everyone on the Albert side ‘upgraded’ their phones🙄

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому +2

      I bet they can if it tells you everytime the screen goes from horizontal to vertical and vs versa

  • @lindawhitener373
    @lindawhitener373 19 днів тому

    Speak up!!!!!

  • @adriennem7927
    @adriennem7927 18 днів тому +1

    4 hour break already?? Didnt she just step up and start court. What's up with that????

  • @hannadowney
    @hannadowney 18 днів тому +1

    2:59:24
    “He’s bound to mess it up.”

  • @06mrselfdestruct
    @06mrselfdestruct 18 днів тому +1

    Doesn’t matter if they didn’t see John go into the house, they already said he wasn’t in Karen’s car when they left

  • @LouiseLLee
    @LouiseLLee 9 днів тому

    I have an IPhone, didn’t know I can change time of a text message 😊

  • @jillgott6567
    @jillgott6567 17 днів тому

    Who is the man seated alone behind Karen Read and Alan Jackson ?

  • @goodgrief1026
    @goodgrief1026 19 днів тому

    We all know that the lab only receives The swab to be tested and the do not watch who does the swabbing. Next question Defense...

  • @goodgrief1026
    @goodgrief1026 19 днів тому +2

    Can't wait for Karen to take the stand ...

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      She already did and screwed herself up.

    • @dimitrastamos2222
      @dimitrastamos2222 18 днів тому

      She did?? Do you know which trial day she took the stand

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      @@dimitrastamos2222
      Of course she didn't.But doing an interview on national TV is as good as taking the stand.

    • @NancyHakkinen-uj1bx
      @NancyHakkinen-uj1bx 18 днів тому

      God you are annoying

  • @thomasmadden4150
    @thomasmadden4150 19 днів тому +2

    Why don’t Collin or some of the other young witnesses have the Boston accent?!

  • @michellebailey4769
    @michellebailey4769 18 днів тому +3

    Funny how Colin remembers the exact time as him leaving as 12:10, but can’t remember other details…this case has corruption stamped all over it!

  • @ginabeswick1446
    @ginabeswick1446 18 днів тому +1

    Brian was not at the house when John was there .Everyone saying John wasn't there noone seen him !

    • @AshleyMarieMommy
      @AshleyMarieMommy 18 днів тому

      Brian or Colin? Sorry I’ve not made it that far

  • @marjory642
    @marjory642 15 днів тому

    6:20:29 “He (Colin) was not at the house when John was there”. John was at that house. Being on the lawn is not being at the house. I’m sure she would’ve said “outside the house” to clearly differentiate he was not inside.

  • @user-ns3gy1ju7x
    @user-ns3gy1ju7x 2 дні тому

    Another one that got ride of her phone just like the other ones same answer they up graded there phones.Her phone is in the dumpers with the other ones.

  • @red___shoes
    @red___shoes 19 днів тому +2

    I don't believe either side have proven either of their theories so far.
    However, as Vinnie Politan has said, defence seems to be throwing spaghetti aka pointing the finger at many diffrent people (Colin, Brian H etc).
    I really think a better defence theory (seeing as they have chosen to have one), would have been that an altercation had occurred outside the residence with someone who had been inside previously. Leaving JO beaten in the snow.

    • @therandomguy1861
      @therandomguy1861 19 днів тому +1

      @@Kaykay-nn8ydxenophobe

    • @theghostofrethsich2813
      @theghostofrethsich2813 19 днів тому +3

      Not enough blood for that to be the scene

    • @red___shoes
      @red___shoes 19 днів тому

      ​@theghostofrethsich2813 this is true. Such a WTF case.

    • @theghostofrethsich2813
      @theghostofrethsich2813 19 днів тому

      excepts from dateline about Dr. Scott Stills.
      “There was a scarf sitting on the floor. We found stains on it that looked like blood.
      We did DNA testing on the scarf.
      Which produced what?
      Pig DNA. Your reaction was the same as mine.
      Well, first of all, that morning, Scott Sills told the firemen that when he came down, the dogs were pulling on it. And that's why we did DNA testing on the scarf.
      Which produced what?
      Dog DNA and pig DNA.
      Pig DNA?
      Yes. That's. You know, your reaction was the same as mine. Pig DNA. And then I asked the children, what did you feed the dog and pig ears. That was her favorite treat to get the dogs.”

    • @red___shoes
      @red___shoes 19 днів тому

      ​@@theghostofrethsich2813 I'm watching a few cases atm, can you remind me how much blood was on JO? I'm just thinking if it wasn't significant, more so a bloody mouth/nose plus the arm scratches, it could be possible a few punches to the head, might only throw splatters of blood. Perhaps someone grabbed said glass, fight starts, a few slashes are made before punches are thrown. JO gets knocked down and is too disorientated to get back up, drifts in and out and ultimately freezes to death.

  • @Physics072
    @Physics072 17 днів тому

    She is a decent actress. Notice how she rarely looks at the Jurors during all questioning.
    Except cue the "The Door has been opened, ill allow it" questions on harassment. She then looks directly at the jurors and wells up some amber tears (no tears). The staring at the jury along with the facial expressions and the "Cant I have a moment" was well played buy her and I think she scored points with the jury.
    Of course no door was really opened for it. But that does not matter if you have biased Ref/Judge

  • @jjcole5830
    @jjcole5830 3 дні тому

    “When John was there”

  • @kingduran007
    @kingduran007 17 днів тому

    What proof has been given that anyone was in the basement?

  • @kingduran007
    @kingduran007 16 днів тому

    That is not true you cannot change a time in a text once it’s sent the lawyer is wrong
    He is wrong
    Prosecutor should have caught that

  • @Physics072
    @Physics072 17 днів тому

    6:20:54 - They judge wants him to continue with more harrasment on the witness. "Focus on this witness not so much on colin albert" because that would be more effective if you get her to perform/cry. That is coaching by the judge. She is bold for sure.

  • @amycartee1358
    @amycartee1358 19 днів тому +9

    This judge is extremely biased

  • @evelynmahoney3569
    @evelynmahoney3569 19 днів тому +9

    What was Ally doing after she allegedly dropped Collin off? This is when she says she went home, arriving there around 12:30, & stayed home.
    BUT:(!) The Family Circle App on her phone says she went to the vicinity of her home. She didn't stop though. Then she was zooming back & forth to the vicinity of the high school and other places, and finally arriving home around 1:30-ish. WHAT?!?!?

    • @margartpotris3890
      @margartpotris3890 18 днів тому +3

      I think he ran from the house and she went out looking for him

  • @nikkijohnson4933
    @nikkijohnson4933 15 днів тому

    I think the actual impact of John's loss of life would be greatly more impacted by videos of him!!! Why arent there ANY VIDEO'S OF JOHN O'KEEF

  • @Mwabacn
    @Mwabacn 18 днів тому +3

    Colin Albert needs to read more...his vocabulary really needs some improvement

    • @Hhevvy
      @Hhevvy 18 днів тому

      He in college yo! Pull up! :). Haha

  • @chadbatts3292
    @chadbatts3292 18 днів тому +2

    Mr Lally needs to cut out the "sort of " and throat clearing.
    He ALSO needs to accept that he's bald and get rid of that baby bird nest on his head 🐦

  • @DT-su8cq
    @DT-su8cq 18 днів тому +3

    Question! Why’d the girl call her brother to pick her up and then decides to stay? Doesn’t make sense to me!

    • @michellestlicitra9105
      @michellestlicitra9105 18 днів тому

      Others offered to bring her home if she wanted to stay, so she did!

    • @926paaja
      @926paaja 18 днів тому +2

      The brother was bringing drugs

  • @shaunb93291
    @shaunb93291 19 днів тому +4

    Not an attorney, why so many sustained objections by Lally? Some or a lot of the questions seemed normal

  • @cmarachi
    @cmarachi 19 днів тому +5

    This judge...my GOD. Why?

  • @marlborogranite8208
    @marlborogranite8208 15 днів тому

    What the heck? Did he eat some ribs that night?

  • @06mrselfdestruct
    @06mrselfdestruct 18 днів тому

    Catherine Doody 😂

  • @Lexifer21
    @Lexifer21 3 дні тому

    So the prosecution can mention how the defenses motion to preserve Alberts phone was denied, but the defense can't mention a lab tech failed her qualifications when the DNA chick said she assumed the crime lab knew what they were doing? That seems balanced

  • @dianewilliams9729
    @dianewilliams9729 19 днів тому +5

    That is a lot of stress for these young people to handle. That pretty young McCabe girl was so well spoken but the harassment question brought her raw emotions out but she recovered quickly for a 20-year-old person.

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому +1

      And that is the defence exact goal.Intimidate witnesses in the hope that somebody does something that leads to a mistrial.

    • @dianewilliams9729
      @dianewilliams9729 18 днів тому +3

      @@maanmohammad8459 I have never watched a trial like this one where the Defense appears to be using the same tactics that detectives have used that have led suspects to confess to crimes they did not commit. The Defense Attorneys are making statements and then trying to get the witnesses to agree with those statements. A lot of these witnesses are very young adults but they appear to be handling the situation.

    • @brandybiscoff9685
      @brandybiscoff9685 18 днів тому +1

      Agreed. These young witnesses have been very impressive & held their own under intense questioning/badgering. I hope the conclusion of this trial brings closure to all parties, no matter how the jury rules.

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому +1

      @@dianewilliams9729
      Don't forget that most of these witnesses had been harassed for the last two years.

    • @maanmohammad8459
      @maanmohammad8459 18 днів тому

      @@dianewilliams9729
      Lol.And I wrote the previous comment before I saw Alison's testimony.Finally it came out thanx to the idiot Yanatti.

  • @Bigslick99578
    @Bigslick99578 19 днів тому +8

    “Not at the house when John was there” so John was there? Which is it!?

    • @margie999
      @margie999 19 днів тому +2

      when he was delivered there

    • @user-cd9yl2qd1u
      @user-cd9yl2qd1u 19 днів тому +7

      @@margie999 06:20:28 No, not delivered. She said "He was not at the house WHEN JOHN WAS THERE" John was there at the house. Her words "JOHN WAS THERE." Don't try and twist plain English.

    • @margie999
      @margie999 19 днів тому +1

      you know what she meant

    • @Bigslick99578
      @Bigslick99578 19 днів тому

      @@margie999yes she meant John was there. At the house. End of story. The Feds know all this anyway, this case is just a sideshow. Expect indictments

    • @stevenprice6957
      @stevenprice6957 19 днів тому +1

      @@margie999did she say in the house or at the house ? I mean you and I know he was at the house right ? He was found dead there? Lol

  • @jjbba
    @jjbba 18 днів тому +3

    mr lally be red

  • @goodgrief1026
    @goodgrief1026 19 днів тому

    I believe they use gloves when handling evidence give her a break.. damn poke poke poke more holes . Is what defense does best ....

  • @saraortiz7818
    @saraortiz7818 19 днів тому +7

    This has been the most boring court case ever.. Dragging on and on.. I won’t be surprised on how fast the jury come back with a verdict… 😬😵‍💫

  • @MikeWilliams-pk6oz
    @MikeWilliams-pk6oz 13 днів тому +1

    I really don’t like this defense attorney at all. I hope she’s guilty because of him and his harassment of Jennifer McCabe. Look man it’s simple, she told you she did it from the start. All this questioning is just a distraction!

    • @926paaja
      @926paaja 11 днів тому

      Oh stop … you hope someone goes to jail bc you think the attorney is mean?? Lolloo omg that’s not how it works

  • @sylerbo
    @sylerbo 18 днів тому

    Omg... kmn.... just learned i have misophobia... I just can't listen to HM another second. Its irritating me to my very soul..🙄