What is Khudi? | Part 2/2 | A Conversation between Dr. Muhammad Abid Ali & Salman Asif Siddiqui

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @anumsyed3327
    @anumsyed3327 5 років тому +8

    Answer for 7:05: Sahil Adeem.
    You guys , ERDC
    QaSim Ali shah
    And source code , raising the standards of thinking are doing a wonderful job

  • @Romaisaawesomeworld
    @Romaisaawesomeworld 4 роки тому +14

    Mashallah, a session with a learned man is much better than reading hundreds of books. Truly grasped the meaning of khudi today.

    • @SZEditor
      @SZEditor Рік тому

      I disagree
      A conversation with a knowledgeable man and reading books are two different things they can't be compared

  • @dreamers_space
    @dreamers_space 4 роки тому +7

    Have never seen much informative video then this one...this video actually changed my way of thinking and solved my inner conflict so well .... Jazakallah

  • @farwakhan9216
    @farwakhan9216 3 роки тому +3

    MashaAllah.
    Thank you, Sir, for sharing this.
    I need this very much. You are MURSHUD.
    We need more teachers like you in Pakistan .

  • @danishkhan1607
    @danishkhan1607 5 років тому +9

    Wow. Such clarity MashaAllah. Learnt so much from Dr. Abid, he knows so much about children.

  • @thinkersclub79
    @thinkersclub79 4 місяці тому

    Ma Sha Allah Great ❤

  • @muhammadferoz-cl1tv
    @muhammadferoz-cl1tv Рік тому

    Allah Rabul Ezat app ki khyr karay

  • @Khadma-m9r
    @Khadma-m9r Місяць тому

    Bri achi batain sunain KO Mili Hain
    Main aik point rkhna chaon Ga insan insan hi raha Ga is phase Sa bahir Ni nikl sakta jitna eman ziada hoga sabr krna itna asan ho Jye ga tqleef hogi lkin insan USA ACHa Sa handle kra Ga yih Ni K voh Boult proof ho Jye agr Apko saboot chaiya to main saboot Doon ga inshallah

  • @abutalib1962
    @abutalib1962 3 роки тому +1

    Senior one deserves to be listened time and again . Allama's poetry is completely based on The Quranic injunctions .

  • @abdulwahidhameed
    @abdulwahidhameed Рік тому

    Thanks for sharing

  • @sadatned
    @sadatned 5 років тому +1

    JAK. Thank you very much for clarifying between information dumping and seeking for information which leads to creative thinking.

  • @hareemshaikh5530
    @hareemshaikh5530 2 роки тому

    Thank you soo much for this video. Allah bless you for this. Much needed video for me. My khudi is totally damaged and I believe that khudi and arrogance is the two sides of same coin. I treat myself very inferior because I believe khudi is bad thing. Thanks alot.

  • @Awan-xl9nf
    @Awan-xl9nf 5 років тому +1

    Jazak Allah. Alhumdullilah.

  • @hadiaannain4718
    @hadiaannain4718 3 роки тому

    @salman Asif I found a little contradict in your statement on one point you quoted if you conditionally appreciate the kid then that Affects his khudi and later on 35:00 min you're saying it's hard to weaken a child's khudi ....
    Anyways a good discussion I appreciate Dr Muhammad Abid Ali (y)

  • @AliHassan-zq2pf
    @AliHassan-zq2pf 2 роки тому

    I have come to love Iqbal for his mind

  • @umar.maniar
    @umar.maniar 5 років тому +6

    Mashallah very rich content. Just one query.
    At time 33:30 you talked about the reward system. That "if a kid does this i'll reward him" which you said is wrong because than the kid works for the reward. But if see the whole world works on the same concept, rewards and incentives.
    Moreover if we see in the Quran even Allah talks about the same thing, repeatedly "Do good deeds, offer your prayers and obey my commands, i'll reward you with jannah and if you disobey and do shirk, you'll be burnt in hell". This type of verses are all over the place in Quran with small variation.
    Don't you think when Allah trains us this way, this is the right thing to train kids on other things too.
    Moreover when they ask us "why this is wrong/haram when others are doing, we have to say them because Allah has said and if we do it we are going to get punished and we abstain from it we are going to be rewarded".
    Eager to have your views on this.
    Jazakallah.

    • @ERDCPK
      @ERDCPK  5 років тому +1

      We would encourage you to watch the following video and you will get your answers, Insha-Allah: ua-cam.com/video/OiUKOJVKUpY/v-deo.html

    • @maverickkhan8341
      @maverickkhan8341 4 роки тому +2

      I have an answer for it only in one statement.I hope it clears your point
      "Self negation should be only for God".

    • @whoned
      @whoned 4 роки тому

      ...Its true most of time.....

  • @afghanipathan3209
    @afghanipathan3209 5 років тому +1

    This was profound discussion!

  • @munibaarooj3623
    @munibaarooj3623 3 роки тому +1

    Salman Asif siddiqui has great vision

  • @fatimadabir4876
    @fatimadabir4876 3 роки тому +1

    Very well explained

  • @W4wahajMaya-w6j
    @W4wahajMaya-w6j 5 років тому +1

    Amazing talk!

  • @muhammadferoz-cl1tv
    @muhammadferoz-cl1tv Рік тому

    May you live long

  • @natura599
    @natura599 3 роки тому

    Great

  • @bushrashahzadkhan2503
    @bushrashahzadkhan2503 5 років тому +1

    GOOD CONTENT

  • @junaiddooast7435
    @junaiddooast7435 Рік тому

    i wish I could have such friends😢

  • @maahinshoaib6761
    @maahinshoaib6761 4 роки тому

    Sir what is ilm. What are the tools to acquire it. And how do achieve ilm... what are the steps...

  • @narjissyed3802
    @narjissyed3802 10 місяців тому

    👍👍

  • @a.raillense5510
    @a.raillense5510 2 роки тому

    Nice

  • @shaikhshaukat7163
    @shaikhshaukat7163 5 років тому +1

    Why you are giving examples of John Hold just pip into our beloved prophet s life
    Ikbal also prefers to conceive prophet s life in our character from childhood

  • @hafeezazam5192
    @hafeezazam5192 4 роки тому

    sirr pleasee make.a.video on فلسفہ plzzzzz

  • @tanzishop2622
    @tanzishop2622 3 роки тому

    Ho q rha h

  • @Musaferjanewale
    @Musaferjanewale 3 роки тому

    Is khudi not a self ego

  • @hamasmalik9798
    @hamasmalik9798 5 років тому +4

    The Prophet Muhammad said, "No babe is born but upon Fitra (as a Muslim). It is his parents who make him a Jew or a Christian or a Polytheist." (Sahih Muslim, Book 033, Number 6426)
    Islam is the religion of all Prophets, Adam to Muhammad. Children are not born out of any sin, original, inherited or derived. They are born on the religion of their nature, i.e., Islam.

  • @abutalib1962
    @abutalib1962 3 роки тому +1

    The younger one lacks clarity and badly confused .

  • @niha1398
    @niha1398 2 роки тому

    آپ نے بتایا نہیں کہ ہم اپنے اندر خودی کیسے پیدا کریں

  • @muhammadmustafa8105
    @muhammadmustafa8105 5 років тому +1

    Topic Khudi ka ha Dr shb khan ja ra ha

  • @hassanaliofficial5372
    @hassanaliofficial5372 5 років тому

    is conversation main salman asif sab ki khudi gum hai ye mairy sath bhi huta hai ,

  • @niha1398
    @niha1398 2 роки тому

    Khuda paida krna Ka koi 2+2 Ka rule
    Ka ap ye ye Karen AUR khudi paida ho jaye

  • @minaamjam1863
    @minaamjam1863 2 роки тому

    @26 min "ya Toronto ki flight hoti" hahaha

  • @ferozkhan696
    @ferozkhan696 3 роки тому

    To bacho school nh byjy to unki khudi kud develop hoge

  • @israrulhaque7519
    @israrulhaque7519 2 роки тому

    خودی کو بلند کرنے کا کیا طریقہ ہے؟

    • @rizk131
      @rizk131 3 місяці тому

      Khudi ko Allah ke ehkam ke taabe krna
      Apni self worth aur potential ko develop krna iss tarh ke siwae Allah swt ke kissi ke saamne na jhukna

  • @israrulhaque7519
    @israrulhaque7519 2 роки тому

    اقبال کی خودی کا کیا ثبوت ہے؟

  • @hassanaliofficial5372
    @hassanaliofficial5372 5 років тому

    baaz owqaat insaan thak jata hai Allah nahi thakta ,insaani body main kamzori paida hu jati hai jis ki wajh sy zehni kamzori hu jati or kuch dair baad uska dmagh kaam karna chor jata hai or uska seen us k bahir sy indor huna shuru jata hai or 2osry log bhi usy tar k barthy huaty hain to shaitaan us k yaqeen ko shak main badlny ka waswsa karta rehta hai or insaan dpresion main chala jata hai ,pakistaan k 90%logon main khudi naam ki cheez hi nahi to woh akaila 1000 logn k takra kar thak jata hai or youn woh lose kar jata hai

  • @thales5999
    @thales5999 2 місяці тому

    Chayterbox

  • @noormelsundas675
    @noormelsundas675 3 роки тому

    sorry to say, but Mr. Salman ki khuddi es waqt khud hi chakerai ( spinned) hui lag rahi hai. putting us into some confusions.anyways have a good day.

  • @muhammadmustafa8105
    @muhammadmustafa8105 5 років тому

    Dr Salman shb mari trha thk gay han fazool baton sa
    Ma srf itna tim waste Salman shb ko suna k lia kr ri hn

  • @hassanaliofficial5372
    @hassanaliofficial5372 5 років тому

    100% pure guftago

  • @muhammadmustafa8105
    @muhammadmustafa8105 5 років тому

    Shkr ha Salman shb bola

  • @Truelight-p4e
    @Truelight-p4e Рік тому

    بالکل غلط اور ادھُوری تشریح کی ہے آپ نے " خودی " کی۔۔۔۔
    خودی کی تعریف خود اپنے ایک شعر میں کی ہے علامہ نے
    اک مردِ قلندر نے کیا راز خودی فاش
    یہ مردِ حق حضرت منصور حلاج تھے جنہوں نے انا الحق کہا تھا۔۔۔۔خود کی نفی اور رب کا اثبات ہی اصل خودی ہے۔۔۔ صاحبِ عقل اور خرد مندوں کے عقل و فہم سے بالا تر ہے۔۔۔خودی
    انڈیا سے

  • @muhammadmustafa8105
    @muhammadmustafa8105 5 років тому

    Dr shb Allah mian ni hota
    Allah tala hota ha

  • @thales5999
    @thales5999 2 місяці тому

    افسوس لوگوں نے اقبال کو پیغمبر بنا کر اس کی شاعری کو لے بیٹھے رہتے ہیں۔

  • @laughify..4036
    @laughify..4036 5 років тому +1

    Salaaam every one, I think in this video Salman Asif Siddqui sahib should not use his cell phone, because it is against the ethics of a debat or lecture , Thanks

    • @SK-ns6sl
      @SK-ns6sl 5 років тому +4

      I don't think it's a debate or competition. It's a friendly discussion to understand how to better ourselves

    • @nfaysal4060
      @nfaysal4060 3 роки тому +1

      Now a days cell phone is also working as a note book too so always think good, might be he is looking on points to discuss