Truths About Hinduism - Black Magic, Rebirth & Ghosts ft. Devdutt Pattanaik | The Ranveer Show 143

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @beerbiceps
    @beerbiceps  3 роки тому +67

    Watch Devdutt Pattanaik's Hindi episode here: ua-cam.com/video/v6fWU3uy-eU/v-deo.html
    🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
    open.spotify.com/episode/7xAO6yfsWtiWhkxuEC1L3q
    Join Us On Telegram: t.me/beerbicepsguy
    Subscribe to our 'Shorts' channel:
    ua-cam.com/channels/zBvAIHPZ_Y7chhoN5ebv_A.html

    • @amaypandey1893
      @amaypandey1893 3 роки тому +1

      Sir Plz Make A Video On How to stay Motivated all the time 🙏🙏

    • @amaypandey1893
      @amaypandey1893 3 роки тому +1

      Plz Sir It's A Request 💗

    • @sandeepsinghnegi7106
      @sandeepsinghnegi7106 3 роки тому +17

      Dev dutt must stop saying its hindu mythology. its indian history and truth he must understand and mean it. Mythology term itself coined by british colonisers and he is quoting the same mind set...

    • @sandeepsinghnegi7106
      @sandeepsinghnegi7106 3 роки тому +16

      Try to bring rajeev malhotra sir and devdutt on a debate then will she who knows real hinduism and how deep understanding one have...

    • @dibyajyotimahapatra8856
      @dibyajyotimahapatra8856 3 роки тому

      Love u Ranveer bhai ❤️🙏

  • @revatipande7744
    @revatipande7744 3 роки тому +465

    Glad so many people know the reality of him in the comment section. :) Seriously I hope I won't see him again on TRS

    • @adityasrivastav8709
      @adityasrivastav8709 3 роки тому +4

      lol 😂... 🕶

    • @vishallohar6309
      @vishallohar6309 3 роки тому +3

      Yes ...

    • @voidwalker999
      @voidwalker999 2 роки тому +2

      Absolutely right

    • @ashwinvk4124
      @ashwinvk4124 2 роки тому

      What reality ?

    • @theasheeshpatel
      @theasheeshpatel 2 роки тому +5

      He is different perspective and that somewhere logical. He is not right but also he is may not wrong. We don't know. But you are disappointed because your religion beliefs get hurt, you should have different approach too instead of believe blindly and without proper proofs in religion. If you study psychology than they will get his points.

  • @VAIBHAVBHAIRAV
    @VAIBHAVBHAIRAV 3 роки тому +680

    I watched it half way and was easily able to figure that he is nothing but a historian.. wrong facts, conclusive answers which have changed from time to time i have been following Devdutt from quite a few years.. i cannot agree to what he says.. like i connect with abhijit chavda.. he is a genius and has logical answers to almost everything

    • @donalduncleusa6552
      @donalduncleusa6552 3 роки тому +31

      He is not even a historian properly he distorted everything and spreads propaganda. It's the worst podcast from Ranveer

    • @Sam...49
      @Sam...49 3 роки тому +11

      Sir I agree with u, u can listen abhijit chavda podcast he is a scientist and a historian.... and much more well read then this idiot

    • @frankfernandes718
      @frankfernandes718 3 роки тому +4

      nice joke abhijit chavda is not even close to devdutt patnaik most of the hindi serials even devo ke dev mahadev was also written by devduttpatnaik

    • @pp5k1
      @pp5k1 3 роки тому +16

      Not even a Historian though. He is just manipulative & biased, who just smartly provides the psychological analogies out of real history. This guy, if born in the year 2200 around so, he wud say "No it's not real Maharana Pratap was just an idea how can one carry 360kg extra weight which includes 70kgs of armor, 80Kgs of bhaala. It's just a myth. It's just like a man should be strong enough to carry life's burden and responsibilities."

    • @Sam...49
      @Sam...49 3 роки тому +2

      @@pp5k1 great example bro 🤣🙋‍♂️

  • @madhurakulkarni6058
    @madhurakulkarni6058 3 роки тому +235

    Please bring Praveen Mohan sir to the TRS!
    I hope to see him soon on your podcast.

    • @TheB657
      @TheB657 3 роки тому +3

      Best antidote to this poison.

    • @aryanyadav3690
      @aryanyadav3690 3 роки тому +3

      Yeah I told him many times, he even gave me a heart, but still he didn't called him

    • @madhurakulkarni6058
      @madhurakulkarni6058 3 роки тому +2

      @@TheB657 😅😂

    • @madhurakulkarni6058
      @madhurakulkarni6058 3 роки тому

      @@aryanyadav3690 okay, so now I assume that he has noted it down and is working on it 😃

  • @MsRosehip
    @MsRosehip Рік тому +12

    People don't seem to like this person. He comes from a unique angle. He has his own perspective and that has value in that it enables people to look at at themselves from a different viewpoint.

    • @MrinalM.
      @MrinalM. 11 місяців тому +1

      There is no different point of view in history! History is truth and you can't change truth in the name of different perspective 😂

    • @MsRosehip
      @MsRosehip 11 місяців тому +1

      ​@@MrinalM.history is always written by the conquerors.

    • @MrinalM.
      @MrinalM. 11 місяців тому

      @@MsRosehip not always and history is not always about conquerors or defeated, it's about what happened otherwise normally in peaceful Times too!

  • @the_sambar_vada
    @the_sambar_vada 3 роки тому +90

    Ranveer: What is kala Jadu
    Devdutt: It's Black Magic, Kala Black Jadu Magic
    What a genius

    • @DADDY_PUTIN
      @DADDY_PUTIN 2 роки тому +1

      I was not even aware of it man I'm enlightenment for sure after learning it from this guy I'm now more educated than rawana himself

    • @kiran2169
      @kiran2169 2 роки тому +1

      We need to be a historian to understand that.. 🙄
      We need to know who is an idiot!

  • @gauravxdhingra
    @gauravxdhingra 3 роки тому +758

    Never learn Spanish from an English Teacher,
    And Culture and History from Devdutt Patnaik

  • @pratiknaik2075
    @pratiknaik2075 3 роки тому +243

    The moment he uttered the words "Human imagination", I couldn't continue watching it anymore. I do not wish to see him ever again on the TRS.

    • @poojashahemir215
      @poojashahemir215 3 роки тому +3

      Same

    • @lalitshah1637
      @lalitshah1637 3 роки тому +3

      True bro

    • @eshwarkumar2834
      @eshwarkumar2834 3 роки тому +3

      exactly

    • @ImGirishUnde
      @ImGirishUnde 3 роки тому +4

      Absolutely right.. i reached there got irritated like anything

    • @shubhamkatyan8069
      @shubhamkatyan8069 3 роки тому +2

      ..why are you not open to new ideas...i am not criticizing you..i am just telling u to listen to everything
      ..for and against and then make a decision.....do not make a decision in ur mind by just listening to one idea...☺️ ......anyway have a good day

  • @vinayaksharma9892
    @vinayaksharma9892 3 роки тому +175

    Hoping to see J Sai Deepak in your podcast 🤩🙏 ❤

    • @supersaiyan3704
      @supersaiyan3704 3 роки тому +3

      He got in GD Bakshi and Major Gaurav Arya... Just a matter of time ;)

    • @shashankvaishnav5204
      @shashankvaishnav5204 3 роки тому +1

      🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥sahi bola

    • @aadarsh1243
      @aadarsh1243 3 роки тому +1

      He can't afford 😂

    • @vinayaksharma9892
      @vinayaksharma9892 3 роки тому +1

      @@aadarsh1243 😂😅 true! Try to kar sakte hai.

  • @shreeyaprasoon1368
    @shreeyaprasoon1368 2 роки тому +12

    this comment section didn't pass the vibe, Devdutt Patnaik is a man who interprets history in a very different way and sees things differently, all of us see things differently. In this particular video, this man provides so much more insight into how things might or might not have worked back in those days. If you don't agree with him it's fine, but the essential idea is to accept that people might perceive things differently and probably learn a thing or two from them. Because if you want a world that thinks exactly like you, then that would be a stagnant world, even I may not agree a lot of times with Devdutt sir but doesn't mean I'll deny what he says and disrespect him. He always talks of our culture in a very positive light, just the tone of thought is different. Probably the video's title should not be ''Truths of Hinduism" and rather interpretations as truth is a highly bolder word. And this comes from a person like me who has immense faith in Shree Krishna and Lord Shiva and is all about understanding the Indian culture.
    *Ranveer (bhaiya), I'd request you to please keep bringing these different people with different ideologies on your podcasts so that we can keep learning and unlearning.*
    PS: Thank you for joining my Ted Talk :p

    • @harshverma3548
      @harshverma3548 7 місяців тому

      Simple, people don't care about knowledge History etc. Majority of the subscribers are right wingers and Devdutt Sir ideology is left shifted, Nothing else.

  • @the_sambar_vada
    @the_sambar_vada 3 роки тому +38

    We discovered the moon only 100 years back, genius words by Devdutt.

  • @Aghorpath
    @Aghorpath 3 роки тому +749

    He is anything but historian bro. Check his writings how he engineer puranas to fit with western philosophy and we from Gorakhnath panth and Dashanami panth sadhus caught him many time red handed. But he just has no shame 😀

    • @Shazm_e_safar
      @Shazm_e_safar 3 роки тому +46

      I learned recently about him, I wont watch this episode because this would be just promoting him and distorting my mood.

    • @revatipande7744
      @revatipande7744 3 роки тому +37

      Completely agreed. He is a believer of mythology and literary mythology means false beliefs or imaginary stories. Kind of a communist historian, like Irfan Habib, or Romila Thapar etc. I love TRS but won't watch ones with Devdutt patnaik. We can learn more about true history and myths through Abijit Chavda than him.

    • @Aghorpath
      @Aghorpath 3 роки тому +19

      @@revatipande7744 Tantra comes from Guru parampara and 90 percent are secret practice and undocumented yet. Understanding this is only possible under a Guru not from books. But this dumb head Pattnaik won't get it 😀

    • @revatipande7744
      @revatipande7744 3 роки тому +12

      @@Aghorpath of course! I still don't understand how can a person interpret Sanatan scriptures, purans, ved, upnishads, epics without the blessing of a guru. This culture into Hindu scriptures with absence of Guru parampara is baseless and would never yield any good results. Guru parampara should be widely reintroduced, revived in our country. These things are so much better understood by Puri Shankracharya, who explains extremely common questions in a subtle manner with authentic explainations.

    • @s.g3452
      @s.g3452 3 роки тому +9

      Yes trying to popularize his books based on hindu books by twisting and turning into modernized and westernised way.

  • @Mohit-il9gx
    @Mohit-il9gx 3 роки тому +152

    The Caption of the video should be ""Devdutt pattanaik about Hinduism "" ,Not "truth about Hinduism "" If this man has a bit sense he would change the title of the video

  • @Amittraajpoot
    @Amittraajpoot 3 роки тому +352

    I have watched his Hindi podcast and now in middle of this English one. I am sorry to say - I don’t like mr. Devdutt’s way of thinking. He is good in manipulating words and don’t give proper answers to any question... leaving this in middle 🙏🙏

    • @supernov646
      @supernov646 3 роки тому +3

      Me too 🙂

    • @ankur.mahajan
      @ankur.mahajan 3 роки тому +10

      That's his speciality to twist facts to suit his narrative.

    • @matchboxwall3531
      @matchboxwall3531 3 роки тому +2

      Me too

    • @frankfernandes718
      @frankfernandes718 3 роки тому +1

      at least he respect Hinduism, yuva noah harari clearly tells your gods not even exist

    • @Amittraajpoot
      @Amittraajpoot 3 роки тому

      @@frankfernandes718 🙂 I have watch him on multiple debates, he give clear answer.. I have not read Sapiens yet but eager to know more about his work... if you like Mr. Devdutt you can follow him but I cannot waste my time...

  • @piyushkatariya1040
    @piyushkatariya1040 2 роки тому +2

    I am surprised to see negative comments. He is the most unbiased person, all answers are straightforward !

  • @danishtrivedi5800
    @danishtrivedi5800 Рік тому +8

    Haters hating in the comments, why watch the podcast and then ruin it for those who are genuinely interested? Don't watch it if you hate him so much! Spread your hate somewhere else, by cursing Devdutt you are only abusing the Hindu ideals of patience, tolerance and openness to other perspectives......................

  • @sandeepsinghnegi7106
    @sandeepsinghnegi7106 3 роки тому +565

    Try to bring rajeev malhotra sir and devdutt on a debate then will see who knows real hinduism and how deep understanding one have...

  • @truelight3224
    @truelight3224 3 роки тому +579

    Hey, Ranveer don't ignore the people who telling truth of Asurdatt Pattnayak !!!

  • @anujchaturvedi6296
    @anujchaturvedi6296 3 роки тому +85

    13:22 , Mr Devdutt can you care to explain the Radioactivity in the Soil of Kurushetra. 13:37 Could you care to explain the Ancient City of Dwarka which has carbon dating of 9000 years old? Could you care to explain how the description of Dwarka in Mahabharat matches the Sunken City of Dwarka?

    • @poojashahemir215
      @poojashahemir215 3 роки тому +5

      Exactly. I stopped watching it when he said it's all imagination

    • @porismitaborah2703
      @porismitaborah2703 3 роки тому +9

      Yes exactly I also have the same question.. and also the ram Setu is also proven to be manmade .

    • @debasishpadhi6342
      @debasishpadhi6342 3 роки тому +5

      Even the astronomical configuration of the day when dwarka got immersed is depicted in the mahabharata.

    • @subhamsoy1280
      @subhamsoy1280 3 роки тому +1

      Not saying you're wrong but any explanation of flying vehicle, talking apes and supernatural powers which were written in books?

    • @debasishpadhi6342
      @debasishpadhi6342 3 роки тому +2

      @@subhamsoy1280 in ramayana there is a brief description of a flying object called vimana with its diagram. We also get a reference from Ravana's pusphak vimana.

  • @kapilagureja8494
    @kapilagureja8494 10 місяців тому +2

    @devduttparranaik keep sharing your experiences and insights. You are doing amazing work.

  • @shashikanthpai2034
    @shashikanthpai2034 2 роки тому +37

    Devdutt is as good a historian as Rahul is a politician.

  • @kajalsaha4846
    @kajalsaha4846 3 роки тому +470

    Please bring Praveen mohan sir to this show he has so much knowledge about aliens extraterrestrial thing

    • @sandeepsinghnegi7106
      @sandeepsinghnegi7106 3 роки тому +7

      Yes well said praveen mohan will shock him thousand time...

    • @Seeker08
      @Seeker08 3 роки тому +5

      he's expert in something that might not exist...wow!

    • @letsevolve9441
      @letsevolve9441 3 роки тому

      Ha aur uska aum infinity wala video bhi deko ranveer bro👍👍

    • @evolvebatchexclusive6784
      @evolvebatchexclusive6784 3 роки тому +10

      PRAVEEN MOHAN IS VERY VERY UNDERATED !!! HE IS OP!!!

    • @evolvebatchexclusive6784
      @evolvebatchexclusive6784 3 роки тому +5

      I THINK WORLD IS NOT READY FOR PRAVEEN'S DISCOVERIES !!

  • @rithikjain4947
    @rithikjain4947 3 роки тому +72

    I was thinking, ki only i am having a bad belief about this episode
    But many people agree that he is not right person to be on Ranveer show

  • @SomShikhar
    @SomShikhar 3 роки тому +349

    Devdutt pattnaik crying in a corner of his room after reading all these comments 😂😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂

    • @ishabanerjee158
      @ishabanerjee158 3 роки тому +14

      Hes not out of job like you are 🤣

    • @ajayshera7082
      @ajayshera7082 3 роки тому +17

      @@ishabanerjee158 is accepting that she is out of job 😆

    • @CaptSat-ku2sq
      @CaptSat-ku2sq 3 роки тому +7

      Mostly people like him don't care about some shitty comments made by immature like you.

    • @anukoolvk
      @anukoolvk 3 роки тому +10

      @@CaptSat-ku2sq If mostly people like him, then its a matter of concern, because his interpretation of Hinduism is very much different from reality. He spreads non-sense that people like you (no offence) believe.

    • @CaptSat-ku2sq
      @CaptSat-ku2sq 3 роки тому +4

      @@anukoolvk That's what you think of him, it's your own belief regarding him, let me ask you that how many scriptures, Vedas and other religious texts have you read that you can judge what is right and what is wrong.
      I just simply like his perspective, his vision of Hinduism, and I don't find anything wrong in it. I'm not saying that he is right or wrong.

  • @Sky-ji3zf
    @Sky-ji3zf 2 роки тому +3

    What i learn from this is that devdutt sir don't personally believe in existence of BHAGWAN as i do but he believes in it as a concept, but he still RESPECTS people believes in existence of BHAGWAN.... and that's exactly what we need to learn to RESPECT

  • @kuldeeptalukdar9494
    @kuldeeptalukdar9494 2 роки тому +33

    If we look at it carefully he's actually right in many point,I feel it was a genuine and somewhat smart conversation between two people about their respective perception.

    • @rakeshkukreja9960
      @rakeshkukreja9960 6 місяців тому

      Perceptions need not be facts! Truth may be different

  • @sachintewarri4626
    @sachintewarri4626 3 роки тому +166

    He defames hinduism everywhere.

    • @abhishek____21
      @abhishek____21 3 роки тому +15

      Good to see people coming to know about porpaganda

    • @rohitkewat8730
      @rohitkewat8730 3 роки тому +5

      Hindutva

    • @darkassassin9686
      @darkassassin9686 3 роки тому +4

      @@rohitkewat8730 it's the same stuff

    • @sarthakmonga9107
      @sarthakmonga9107 3 роки тому +7

      @@rohitkewat8730 Hindutva= Hindu + tattva = Hinduness. Learn sankrit fuddu

    • @frankfernandes718
      @frankfernandes718 3 роки тому

      watch 50:52 you will have respect For devdutt not for Yuva Noah harri and Beerbiceps

  • @sudeshnakar5332
    @sudeshnakar5332 3 роки тому +128

    Please call Praveen Mohan ..... He has researched a lot on ancient structures and mysteries related to all of it ...he is an amazing person everyone should know the discovieries he has done through his research...

    • @jeetmakadiya23
      @jeetmakadiya23 2 роки тому +8

      Yes , praveen Mohan's knowledge is 1000% more than this old shit

    • @barnalidasmusic
      @barnalidasmusic 2 роки тому +2

      That would be an amazing mind boggling episode! Great suggestion👍

    • @somnathmajumdar9261
      @somnathmajumdar9261 2 роки тому

      @@barnalidasmusic Lol😂👌

    • @mychannel1029
      @mychannel1029 2 роки тому

      Ya please call praveen ji

  • @surajsaini6578
    @surajsaini6578 3 роки тому +48

    51:06 And at the same time he's calling my god mythological
    *THE IRONY*

    • @94pranjalshukla
      @94pranjalshukla 3 роки тому +2

      What about Viking mythology?
      Just like Indra and Agni was there a Viking god Thor, Odin, hela ?
      What about the Greek gods - Zeus, Poseidon, Aphrodite?
      Do you worship them too?
      Or your gods just confined to local geography?

    • @vmk9299
      @vmk9299 Рік тому

      You can call your god, god. He need not call your god, god.

  • @frustratedmel
    @frustratedmel 3 роки тому +5

    It is really important that we see both truth and lies before we conclude something as truth. I really liked that Ranveer choose a host who is basically against Ranveer's own ideas and beliefs on Hinduism or history of our culture. That's how we grow to be more tolerant.

  • @nehatickoo1195
    @nehatickoo1195 2 роки тому +14

    His interpretations are so poetic, rational and beautiful. One has to be able to appreciate art to get him. Unfortunately we are not a generation that was raised to appreciate poetry in life, myth, culture. Hence, even the soft hard liners do not understand what he says.

  • @aditiparey4405
    @aditiparey4405 3 роки тому +527

    Mr Devdutt’s views on aryan invasion theory is contradictory to Abhijeet Chavda sir’s views about it. Mr Pattanaik also feels god is a fiction as per this conversation. One needs a spiritual inclination to write their own version of Geeta and Ramayan. I am greatly disappointed by Mr Pattnaik’s views here.

    • @daruiraikage
      @daruiraikage 3 роки тому +15

      He is not called WendyPutra for no reason

    • @yaminisingh9958
      @yaminisingh9958 3 роки тому +21

      Devdutt is an idiot. Disliked the video already. You should watch Rajiv malhotra's video debunking this fool point by point.

    • @abhishekjain5758
      @abhishekjain5758 3 роки тому +10

      Don't know, is he on the path to demean Hinduism by knowingly or unknowingly, but he is spreading misinformation

    • @himanshudubey6998
      @himanshudubey6998 3 роки тому +18

      Yeah because it contradicts your belief 😂

    • @lelouchvibritannia9896
      @lelouchvibritannia9896 3 роки тому +28

      Okay let's go, let's say Ramayana and Mahabharata happened, then you follow it's teachings and move forward in life. Let's say it does not happened and it's exist only in our imagination, you still learn from it stories as teachings and move forward in life, the question it happened or not is just insignificant here, how the hell does it matter? Just because someone thinks about something different than you, you get disappointed, feel sad, criticize that fellow, that's not what you should do according to Geeta should you, huh?

  • @saurabhmishra4442
    @saurabhmishra4442 3 роки тому +539

    I stopped watching when he tried to convince that Mahabharata is just an imagination. And I'm sure later he will say ramayan is just a fiction. For me, it's disgusting.

    • @letschill830
      @letschill830 3 роки тому +24

      respectfully its true ramayan and Mahabharata is myth

    • @yashpatil3779
      @yashpatil3779 3 роки тому +12

      Same bro after that I pushed video and came to comment section

    • @letschill830
      @letschill830 3 роки тому +8

      @sugar high whale 😂 sorry but i am not Muslim i am agnostic
      i consider its myth because it against fundamentals of nature
      if anyone believe in physics and ramayan both.
      then he or she is hypocrite

    • @arnavkhare2638
      @arnavkhare2638 3 роки тому +39

      @@letschill830 no I m sorry to destroy your thought but we have many evidences for Ramayan And Mahabharat to be true. There are many indirect proofs and I know you won't like it so the direct proofs that I know are
      1.) Mahabharat: dwarika under water and bhagvad gita and the presence of chiranjeev
      2.) Ramayana: palk strait a bridge of stone that floats and footprints of lord hanuman and shlokas

    • @ayushjha5580
      @ayushjha5580 3 роки тому +36

      @@letschill830 typical immature kid. Everyone goes through that stage. Even me and my friends and cousins. Well if someone believe in science and not in mahabharat and Ramayan that's hypocrite. Because we have countless Scientific, Climatic and Geographical proofs. Look up you'll find it easily. A collaborative team of Nasa scientist and Discovery has also come up with scientific evidences (mainly climatic). Being myself a Btech student at tier-1 colleges of India. And having habbit of reading various physicist. I can say Hinduism and Science are replacable words. I know being a Muslim you are trained to be very critical about Hinduism. I see nothing wrong in asking questions and being sceptical but coming to a conclusion with almost no knowledge of science and research is mere stupidity. See what Max plank, Erwin Schordinger, Werner Heisenberg and Carl Sagan has to say about science and Hinduism. This are literally Nobel prize winner Physicist.

  • @anujchaturvedi6296
    @anujchaturvedi6296 3 роки тому +35

    53:07 Last time I checked Oxford English Dictionary Myth = Story = Fiction. Devdutt is describing himself when talking about Harari.

    • @akkkkk813
      @akkkkk813 3 роки тому

      😂😂

    • @frankfernandes718
      @frankfernandes718 3 роки тому

      that is 18th century meaning todays meaning Stories which inspired culture

    • @anujchaturvedi6296
      @anujchaturvedi6296 3 роки тому +2

      @@frankfernandes718 Stories which inspired culture is still Fiction.
      200 years later:
      Frank Fernandes: "Bharat is a word given by the British to the Indian Subcontinent".
      You are a joke. How much did you get paid by the Missionaires?

    • @NishantKumar-zi8ls
      @NishantKumar-zi8ls 3 роки тому

      Myth and Mythology are 2 different things

  • @ritikgupta8741
    @ritikgupta8741 3 роки тому +9

    I don't why so many hate comments I find this right in regards of science.
    People say I believe in science and he it self say that we respect every Idea.

  • @gigglypuff3589
    @gigglypuff3589 3 роки тому +8

    Devdut is more of an entertainer, I don’t take his insights on Hindusim that seriously

  • @sauravdevnath8874
    @sauravdevnath8874 3 роки тому +71

    If you call dev dutt patnaik a fiction writer a historian in a suger coated language and soft voice then I weep for your brains

    • @VSM101
      @VSM101 3 роки тому +1

      Guys a wish washy colonised brain embarrassment that takes lies of Western supremacist as fact with no evidence to back there assertions.

    • @sauravdevnath8874
      @sauravdevnath8874 3 роки тому

      @@VSM101 exactly... Man

  • @riyas5273
    @riyas5273 3 роки тому +503

    I wonder how ranveer doesn't knw that this guy is such a fraud, he changes the contexts from real meaning with his own interpretation.

    • @saranshbansal1948
      @saranshbansal1948 3 роки тому +32

      ranveer is one of those liberal educated fools who believes in this manipulative historians

    • @arrehaman6389
      @arrehaman6389 3 роки тому +19

      @@saranshbansal1948 ranveer Allabadia also want to earn money like devdut patnaik

    • @1234CDAB
      @1234CDAB 3 роки тому +15

      Because Ranveer himself is a fraud

    • @saranshbansal1948
      @saranshbansal1948 3 роки тому +15

      @@arrehaman6389 he can also earn money by calling genuine people only, like major gaurav arya, abhijit chavda, etc. Is cancer k sath podcast krne ki kya zarurat h

    • @breatherevolution6605
      @breatherevolution6605 3 роки тому +6

      @@saranshbansal1948 paisa ka chakkar babu bhaiya...paise ka chakkar

  • @hhrid
    @hhrid 3 роки тому +29

    If Devdutt Patnayak is a historian then I'm also the President of India.

  • @akshaypatwal6013
    @akshaypatwal6013 2 роки тому +20

    personally - This is a good podcast, guess most in comments had no time to watch it or may be they had. There is a lot to learn from this, if u think I am a fan of Dev dutt's work, yes I am. I also know he is wrong many times, I also do watch people's content who say he spouts nonsense.

    • @varun9213
      @varun9213 Рік тому

      Ingesting shit with food doesn't make your diet a 'balanced diet'

  • @AkashThakur-tm6dn
    @AkashThakur-tm6dn 3 роки тому +1

    Lord krishna once said that your beliefs built your intellect . Now I understand it practically through this man because all the time he is saying everything is a human imagination but I think he is living in his own imagination!

  • @KejriwalBhakt
    @KejriwalBhakt 3 роки тому +257

    Abhijit Chavda would chew him in debates without burping even when Abhijit is a scientist by profession. This dude is a proponent of AIT and Abhijit discusses AIT like every day. LMAO!!

    • @dr.harshitjain6410
      @dr.harshitjain6410 3 роки тому +8

      Abhijit Iyer Mitra's sidelong glance would be enough to burn his half baked knowledge.

    • @karankhaitan7923
      @karankhaitan7923 3 роки тому +1

      Devdutt doesn't believe in AIT. Give proof if you believe he does.

    • @KejriwalBhakt
      @KejriwalBhakt 3 роки тому +4

      @@karankhaitan7923 Watch his discussions and stuffs. You will know for sure. Thinking of him as some kinda "expert" on Indian scriptures is hilarious to say the least.

    • @karankhaitan7923
      @karankhaitan7923 3 роки тому

      @@KejriwalBhakt I have seen his discussions. Nowhere have I seen him say that AIT is true

    • @KejriwalBhakt
      @KejriwalBhakt 3 роки тому

      @@karankhaitan7923 DOnt believe me? Read up the comment sections. You will know what I am saying

  • @sigma1611
    @sigma1611 3 роки тому +86

    He said love doesn't exist, calls ramanaya and Mahabharata (our history) as mythology... He is a typical example of colonial education and mindset..My ears were bleeding after listening to him for 5 mins😂😂😂

    • @WanderlustingCouple
      @WanderlustingCouple 3 роки тому +4

      Totally agree 🙄

    • @WanderlustingCouple
      @WanderlustingCouple 3 роки тому +2

      @BeerBiceps please watch the channel dharma speaks to get the correct perspective about Hinduism. If possible bring him for such discussions.

    • @ksbhargav7638
      @ksbhargav7638 3 роки тому

      Exactly

  • @yashvardhansinghdeora467
    @yashvardhansinghdeora467 3 роки тому +131

    He literally distorts history... Has been debunked many many times. Don't give him a platform pls.

  • @TheParangi
    @TheParangi Рік тому +1

    Awesome a very different perspective of things!!👏👏

  • @manojtyagi9341
    @manojtyagi9341 3 роки тому +3

    People saying they don't like Devdutt Patnaik and his foolish and manipulative concepts. And then this video comes, with the most number of views among the last few ones, clearly depicts how negative feelings are more dominant and attractive 🤗

  • @amanbanduni
    @amanbanduni 3 роки тому +199

    Really? Devdutt Patnaik is the right person to discuss about all these things?

    • @mrgoodboi9420
      @mrgoodboi9420 3 роки тому +9

      If u don't like it, then don't watch it,
      And I think there are several of us,,who like devdutt pattanaik,

    • @poojashahemir215
      @poojashahemir215 3 роки тому +11

      This is the mostly disgusting podcast ever

    • @abhilashdas9115
      @abhilashdas9115 3 роки тому +7

      @@hrithik5274 that's what I am saying if you don't like him don't watch the podcast .......but I like to listen to both experts and take my own decisions........

    • @mrgoodboi9420
      @mrgoodboi9420 3 роки тому +2

      @@hrithik5274 are u insane, the examples u have given,they are criminals, asaram bapu and ram Rahim are convicted criminals,

    • @mrgoodboi9420
      @mrgoodboi9420 3 роки тому +3

      @@hrithik5274 he is simply giving his interpretation of hindu scriptures,he has explicitly mentioned it,now if u don't like his interpretation, u can choose to not watch it,u can watch something else,

  • @aDi7997
    @aDi7997 3 роки тому +223

    Ranveer you have brought knowledgeable people to your show, however Mr. Patnaik is a phony who disregards our epics as imagination/ undermines our Scriptures & I'm sure you're well Aware of this.
    Sadly 👎👎👎👎👎 for this video.

  • @रुद्रप्रतापरुद्र

    Please do not call this bloody liar again for the podcast, you have been amazing through all your podcasts . I respect u a lot but please do not being him again on the podcast, please.🙏💐

    • @TheTwara
      @TheTwara Рік тому

      You are the enemy of real Hindu Dharma.

  • @karthikmanju5368
    @karthikmanju5368 2 роки тому +10

    Such simple, realistic, unbiased, open, empathetic, complete 180 degree perspective

  • @sanjaygowda932
    @sanjaygowda932 2 роки тому +2

    I am so glad so many people are aware of this person. Requesting BeerBiceps to interview people like Rajeev Malhotra to teach true Hindu Dharma.

  • @anujchaturvedi6296
    @anujchaturvedi6296 3 роки тому +23

    50:53 Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hot hai. Devdutt blantantly says Indian Epics are mythology.

    • @suvodipmondal7625
      @suvodipmondal7625 3 роки тому

      Don't be fool. Read about definition of mythology. 💡

  • @hardikvegad3508
    @hardikvegad3508 3 роки тому +89

    After seeing Kailasa Temple of Ellora and other amazing ancient Indian marvels... I strongly believe that weapons like bhramastra,... Etc would have existed

    • @aadityamahajan9548
      @aadityamahajan9548 3 роки тому +8

      Watch Praveen Mohan's latest video on Sri Ram It's about these weapons. It's mind-boggling!

    • @hardikvegad3508
      @hardikvegad3508 3 роки тому +7

      @@aadityamahajan9548 yes I will... I'm big fan of his work🔥

    • @subhanhasan990tsikfm
      @subhanhasan990tsikfm 2 роки тому +3

      What's important is the lessons from Mahabarata not the weapons,

    • @theasheeshpatel
      @theasheeshpatel 2 роки тому

      One day you will strongly believe the world was destroyed on 12/12/12 when there will be proof only related to it. Because you only saw movie on it.

    • @vmk9299
      @vmk9299 Рік тому

      @@aadityamahajan9548 I find that people are more interested in implements of ruin ( the weapons). Why cant you show interest in the educational aspects of the temple architecture which Praveen Mohan has shown elaborately, many a time.

  • @Shazm_e_safar
    @Shazm_e_safar 3 роки тому +163

    I'm straight away going to dislike this, because I would hate to promote Mr. Patnaik. Please Watch Rajiv malhotra's video on his channel, you'll know what I mean, he has also recently been on TRS.
    🌴Peace!

  • @catchtheeye0407
    @catchtheeye0407 2 роки тому +6

    More facts and explanations from Devdutt Pattnaik sir and i am into more empathy with inside and outside world so big thanks to you Ranveer for making these kind of podcasts what actually improves our perception building process.loved it.

  • @succhi9
    @succhi9 3 роки тому +2

    This a great time to live in. People are beginning to understand what has been going wrong for ages and CANNOT be fooled anymore. I personally deleted the word ‘woke’ from this post after hearing out Sir Abhijeet Chavda. This is a GREAT channel. Thanks, Rajveer, you’re doing a brilliant job and thanks to all those who are talking about Praveen Mohan and Sir Rajeev Malhotra. There is so much to learn from their knowledge and wisdom!

  • @sanatanshikshak2302
    @sanatanshikshak2302 3 роки тому +8

    Deveddnut Patnaik - negative energy, gives us more energy to go deep into ancient scriptures to find out truth
    Rajiv Malhotra - positive enegy , who inspires me to dive deep into ancient scriptures
    Both negative and positive energy is helping me

  • @jayendradanidhariya9230
    @jayendradanidhariya9230 3 роки тому +18

    Review of this podcast : Logical mind tryin' perceive something.
    Learnings from TRS: Thanks to Ranveer, I've learnt to sit along with conflicting ideas without chaos.🙏🏻❤️

  • @Aghorpath
    @Aghorpath 3 роки тому +171

    Absolute crap. This guy has just studied from some book and has know experience of tantra. I, being a Nath Aghori from Tarapith, West Bengal myself with full responsibility saying whatever he is saying is absolutely crap and has no relevance with tantra or the philosophy of Aghor which is term by you as "black side". If you really want to know bring some aghori or someone from Nath panth. 🙏

    • @Aghorpath
      @Aghorpath 3 роки тому +1

      @@susabhanmishra1758 Yes and no. It's a big concept. and can't be told in one line. If you really seek to know you may discuss further in my fb with same name. 🙏

    • @thedebateroom3410
      @thedebateroom3410 3 роки тому +1

      @@susabhanmishra1758 yes god are real, like Jesus Christ and Allah.

    • @vaibhavsingh5845
      @vaibhavsingh5845 3 роки тому

      How to know about nath panth or join it

    • @vaibhavsingh5845
      @vaibhavsingh5845 3 роки тому

      @Pranshu there would be a procedure to join nath panth or any book where one can study about it

    • @thedebateroom3410
      @thedebateroom3410 3 роки тому

      @Pranshu you fail to understand what I said

  • @thebatman0777
    @thebatman0777 2 роки тому +2

    I don't agree with him on many things but it's good to hear different perspectives

  • @keithsunanon6671
    @keithsunanon6671 Рік тому +1

    I really appreciate you and your host very powerful words of wisdom. One love

  • @amanbangera640
    @amanbangera640 3 роки тому +41

    12:05 was hilarious 😂 😂. history TV always says that indian mythology was made by aliens. They also say that kailash temple is nothing but alien base 😶

  • @kuldeeplakhawat365
    @kuldeeplakhawat365 3 роки тому +28

    There is not a single history cell in this guy's body...

  • @Rakshi9
    @Rakshi9 3 роки тому +45

    You could’ve done this podcast either with abhijit chavda sir or radhakrishna pillai sir.

  • @vishalvasava7250
    @vishalvasava7250 3 роки тому +4

    you need to have BALLS to accept his perceptions, loved it🎡

  • @stalenfereira4160
    @stalenfereira4160 3 роки тому +5

    Ignore the bad comments, people are too conserved to understand his outlook.Amazing interpretation ✨🌟

  • @rishikeshvashishtha7347
    @rishikeshvashishtha7347 3 роки тому +32

    Bring praveen Mohan on podcast

  • @spy4303
    @spy4303 3 роки тому +257

    Didn't expected this from you Ranveer.. I got a heart attack in my ears 😭

    • @dontwatchmylatestvideo3965
      @dontwatchmylatestvideo3965 3 роки тому +11

      Maiko kidney mai aaya tha

    • @worldisone8282
      @worldisone8282 3 роки тому

      🤣

    • @94pranjalshukla
      @94pranjalshukla 3 роки тому +5

      No you didn’t got heart attack in your ears.
      What you actually got was emotional haemophilia- a condition where new information that doesn’t conform your existing beliefs leads to bleeding from every place of your body.
      This happens mainly to people following cults.
      Precaution- cover yourself with bubble wrap or hard titanium alloy coating so that no new information penetrates your already dense skull.

    • @vafy7527
      @vafy7527 2 роки тому

      @@94pranjalshukla 😂😂😂😂

    • @nitishpanwar1758
      @nitishpanwar1758 2 роки тому

      Bhai 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @praveen_7029
    @praveen_7029 3 роки тому +66

    He studied more about Greeks, Christianity than hindu🙏

    • @vionadixit872
      @vionadixit872 Рік тому

      Nooooo

    • @33ketamine33
      @33ketamine33 Рік тому

      All mythologies are about the same gods in different names with slight change in the concepts . True Biblical Christianity is not the Christianity we see for the 1700 years , post Constantine era. Roman Catholicism is trinity gods worship which is refored to as Father ,Son, and holy spirit. That is not the Trinity of Bible. There are no pictures or statues of them. Holy Spirit of Bible is SPIRIT whereas the holy spirit of Catholicism is the goddess which they named Virgin mary who is not Mother of Jesus Christ who is pure human .Who will give her worship for two thousand years ?

  • @variant7228
    @variant7228 2 роки тому +11

    I can see many people getting salty over here just cuz your opinion is different from his.... And he's got a very different approach about seeing all these things as metaphors and tbh these things sometimes strike inside my mind aswell so it's nice to see someone as Professional. as him share similar thoughts...!

  • @WormholeJim
    @WormholeJim Рік тому +1

    I just can't help thinking, as I watch, what sort of discussion would come out of it if you brought Praveen Mohan and this guy, Devdutt Pattanaik, on the show both at the same time😄 Mohan argumenting for, and Pattanaik against whether the ancient stories of hindu mythology should be understood literally or symbolically. Or maybe a bit of both. Those two approaches the same topic from completely opposite directions. I think it would be a very rewarding experience for everyone involved.
    Anyway, it's a great strength to your show, that you bring such a wide scope of both topics and angles. Always a pleasure and eyeopener to watch - especially for someone like me from a western culture that doesn't know many of these things by heart as do indians. Also I feel in so many ways India is opening up her vast wealth of spiritual knowledge for the whole world to benefit from. Thank you a lot for providing this opportunity to learn from the best and wisest your country has to offer, Ranveer. I already promoted your show to many I know. Not to promote it, but because it comes natural as a source of information to point others to.

  • @omkarrudradev2255
    @omkarrudradev2255 3 роки тому +32

    You lost me when this guys said Indian “mythology”.

  • @anshumaansrivastava6224
    @anshumaansrivastava6224 3 роки тому +522

    I just love to see comments that i am not the only one who thinks this was the most disgusting podcast of his channel 🙂🥀

  • @angadtewari7122
    @angadtewari7122 3 роки тому +15

    Do another episode with AMISH TRIPATHI

  • @kanikagyamlani
    @kanikagyamlani 2 місяці тому

    He talks about the hindu culture from a different perspective, he doesn't fixate on a certain pov and explores all angles of the belief, keeps an open mind and offers acceptance to other ideas as well, I feel that is indeed something to learn from him. Not only he talks about religions, he talks about spirituality, history, human nature, modern world and his ideas are so refreshing to hear. He articulates everything in a very poetic and understandable way, I absolutely loved this episode!
    I also believe people should be open to hear different perspectives and not shove their strict ideas down someone's throat.

  • @shayakbhadraray9017
    @shayakbhadraray9017 2 роки тому +1

    35:30 Iliterally googled how old is Vishnu Purana and it came out 500 BCE

  • @vaibhavplayzzz1963
    @vaibhavplayzzz1963 3 роки тому +25

    Amazing. Can you try to Get Dr. Jordan Peterson on your Podcast. Specially try to touch on the concept of 'Shadow' to him or any other Psychologist.It'd be mind blowing

  • @FromPlanetZX
    @FromPlanetZX 3 роки тому +7

    I urge everyone to watch this video. Though it will help Devdutt, but it will help Ranveer as well. And as Wiseman have said to know your enemy and with this you will know the weapons as well.

  • @kapildhavale9121
    @kapildhavale9121 3 роки тому +11

    This video helped me understand the West More.

  • @shivamkhattar2900
    @shivamkhattar2900 2 роки тому

    I would really like to know what you Ranjeev think about the existence of the Gods as we know you meditate and believe in Lord Krishna from your heart . So you think they are just stories or you think they really exist ?

  • @prashantraisharma
    @prashantraisharma 3 роки тому +2

    Simply awesome awesome awesome awesome
    Emotional rush throughout the episode

  • @RashmiPriyaWinner
    @RashmiPriyaWinner 3 роки тому +8

    Re birth is a very big reality. It is not just for karma clearing but also for fulfilling a very specific purpose together then it is all a matter of alignment and things fall in the right place at the right time. When the energies will be activated and how much past memory will be accessible to you is decision of the Universe. We are living in a divine mysterious realm ❤❤❤

  • @shivanshshivam8375
    @shivanshshivam8375 3 роки тому +44

    Do a podcast with Praveen Mohan! He got the best knowledge about ancient Hindu mythology

    • @sarthakmonga9107
      @sarthakmonga9107 3 роки тому +3

      It is not mythology but history. Shame on you if you are a hindu.

    • @abheekmazumder1262
      @abheekmazumder1262 2 роки тому

      @@sarthakmonga9107 yes! Absolutely. I mean after so many information, discoveries and ancient proof, some people still call it a mythology rather than a history.

    • @kratos7501
      @kratos7501 2 роки тому

      @@abheekmazumder1262 what type of proof can you tell me plz

  • @alladamodarreddy
    @alladamodarreddy 3 роки тому +50

    And after bringing legends like Abhijit Chavda, Amish Tripathi, Rajeev Malhotra, Gaur Gopal Das, Radhakrishnan Pillai, Gauranga Das. If you get people like Mr Patnaik, it is like questioning all that we learnt from legends. Because Mr Patnaik is based on imagination and all the others are very well researched.

    • @killmonger6512
      @killmonger6512 2 роки тому

      He is a gutter mouth

    • @TheGuruNetOn
      @TheGuruNetOn 2 роки тому +2

      Agenda + imagination

    • @bukharifaraz
      @bukharifaraz 2 роки тому

      😄🤣😅😂

    • @shiroyasha_007
      @shiroyasha_007 2 роки тому

      Anything that you disagree with = Poorly researched Imagination and Propoganda

    • @vmk9299
      @vmk9299 Рік тому

      Please know that every knowledge in the world is percieved by humankind and there is no limit to his imagination.

  • @mrinalinichakraborthy9022
    @mrinalinichakraborthy9022 2 роки тому +2

    Hii I m from Singapore...Me nd my 8 Yr old are your fan..we love nd follow ur podcast.. sply my son is fond of your himalaya adventures related podcast nd even physics related podcast mentioning abt black hole... he is fascinated with it and your podcasts with gr8 physisits are v fascinatingly informative.... gr88 going ....Best wishes for more awesome work that you are doing....

  • @saurabhaggarwal4077
    @saurabhaggarwal4077 3 роки тому +1

    Interesting to read some of comments below. I feel people are incredibly sensitive , you are free not to agree with Devdutt Pattnaiak , but not allowing different school of thoughts to co-exist is disappointing. Thanks Ranveer for this conversation, I absolutely loved watching a different perspective to Indian concepts such as Black Magic, rebirth and ghosts. Would love to see more of these!!!

  • @adityakaushik1329
    @adityakaushik1329 3 роки тому +133

    His logic seems to be more illogical than any mythology he claims to be illogical. He is the living incarnation of colonial mindset and how it has ruined the Indian education system and values.

    • @janicefernandess344
      @janicefernandess344 3 роки тому +8

      He feels whatever he knows is the only truth and rest is just an imagination of people.

    • @adityakaushik1329
      @adityakaushik1329 3 роки тому +2

      @@janicefernandess344 sahi mein

    • @abhilashdas9115
      @abhilashdas9115 3 роки тому

      @@adityakaushik1329 how is your life going as a Nazi

    • @adityakaushik1329
      @adityakaushik1329 3 роки тому +3

      @@abhilashdas9115 pretty good infact ! Much better than most of the librandu breeds or leftist slaves can ever imagine...!😊😊

    • @adityakaushik1329
      @adityakaushik1329 3 роки тому +4

      @@Vedantindian2012 Exactly he has some weird wild explanation to everything in our culture which he thinks is the only supreme truth, while it is nothing more than concocted white lies around Hindu mythology.

  • @himanshu8619
    @himanshu8619 3 роки тому +11

    BHAIYA ,,Please bring ACHARYA PRASHANT 🙏♥️

  • @deepakd6161
    @deepakd6161 3 роки тому +7

    Please bring Praveen mohan sir.... I am sure he will surprise us with his research of ancient technology... That have been definitely existed..

  • @vivekmaheshwarimusiclover
    @vivekmaheshwarimusiclover 3 роки тому +8

    Defining a religion/philosophy with just a plate of food. Lol to his intellect 😂 As per him, everything is idea or imagination.

  • @johnpersad5557
    @johnpersad5557 2 роки тому +3

    I really love this podcast this man is so knowledgeable I am so happy listening to him and follow along perfectly?🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🇨🇦

  • @kittycatty335
    @kittycatty335 3 роки тому +9

    Ranveer - I loved your heart behind introducing Devdutt Patnaik as a 'historian'. I felt you said that to give respect to and stand up for the validity of our itihasas. I also love that you so beautifully engage with people across the board and show everyone great respect and honor. It reflects your own great character. You are doing a great job. I pray that you continue to be blessed with greater wisdom and strength and wish you lots and lots more success in your noble endeavour ❤🙏

    • @CRU5ADER373
      @CRU5ADER373 3 роки тому +1

      This is illiteracy of the highest order !! Devdutt has been dismantled bit by bit his frauds are exposed all over internet, yet an agenda driven propogandist is given a stage to brainwash kids is worth appreciating? Would you want your family to be taught that earth is flat? This is the same, we expect @ranveer todeliver quality content not cringe propoganda.

    •  3 роки тому +1

      Unfortunately, seeing the good in Hitler is considered a virtue and there are apparently fans who bow down to such quality 🙏

  • @deepverma3
    @deepverma3 3 роки тому +12

    Now we need to learn hinduism from hindu haters. Atleast check his basic views about hinduism.

  • @ankur.mahajan
    @ankur.mahajan 3 роки тому +29

    If you want to bring someone to discuss Sanatan Dharma, then please bring someone who is not driven by anger, hate, pride, revenge and who weaves his own stories just to justify his view point.
    Sanatan Dharma is too great to be belittled by these self-appointed authority on this great civilization.
    You could have brought someone more research oriented and academic person like Dr. Pavan Verma or Dr. Bibek Debroy.

    • @saiyan0921
      @saiyan0921 2 роки тому

      My Vote to Bibek Debroy

  • @harishpatel2852
    @harishpatel2852 3 роки тому +2

    Always Nice and Genuine Podcast...
    Ranveerji...
    And Superb Devduttaji...

  • @chandreshrathod1501
    @chandreshrathod1501 3 роки тому +6

    Extreme podcast. Some points needed to be listen twice and thrice.

  • @TheSupermanMc
    @TheSupermanMc 3 роки тому +15

    If he has guts , then make him debate with Abhijit chavda

  • @shank5tiw
    @shank5tiw 3 роки тому +41

    This guy's work on Hinduism is just distortions. Not the right person to learn from.

  • @pratikkhobragade2871
    @pratikkhobragade2871 3 роки тому +14

    First video with good facts and straight thinking! Lots of love 💕

  • @selinapersaud7839
    @selinapersaud7839 2 роки тому +7

    I recently stumbled across ur show and I enjoy them very much as it's very informative. This episode was great, it is very interesting. Keep it coming! 🙏👍