Bengal Budget Triggers Debate: Madrasa Education Blooming Under Mamata Banerjee-Led Govt? | Newshour
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 чер 2024
- In this episode of Newshour, Pranesh Roy will discuss the controversy over the Bengal Budget. The Bengal Budget allocation has triggered a massive showdown. BJP criticizes West Bengal for allocating Rs 5,530 cr to Madrassa Education and labeled it as 'Appeasement Politics'. 'This is the impact of competitive appeasement politics (CAP)...' Shehzad Poonawalla, BJP National Spokesperson, reacted. No end to appeasement politics in Bengal? We are joined by a panel to discuss this in detail. 'Madrasa education needs to have a 360-degree analysis before allocating such a huge amount towards it...' says Binay Kumar Singh. 'Where is the radicalization happening? In which Madrasa, in which state, in which district? Point it out...' Atiq ur Rehman rebuts. Watch the full episode on Times Now!
#bengal #bengalbudget #bengalbudgetcontroversy #newshour #newshourdebate #mamatabanerjee #madrasa #politics #bjpvstmc #timesnowshows
Times Network takes the lead with its ground-breaking innovation and disruption of a new content category. The Times Network channels, which have a global footprint in 100 countries, inform, entertain, and engage viewers of all ages with fascinating and intriguing content, news, and information.
Subscribe to our channel - / @timesnow
Check out our website: www.timesnownews.com
Facebook: / timesnow
Twitter: / timesnow
Instagram: / timesnow
Until she is in power, Bengali Hindus face problems.
As long as hindus voting to tmc they have to face all the troubles from mamta begum.
Congress, Communists and now TMC all of them have done appeasement of minorities since independence in Bengal whereas the hindus have been in a denial mode all throughout these years. Firstly the right to religious freedom is under scrutiny, political rights have been eroding, education which was once a USP of Bengal is under threat and the business hub that it once was, no FDI or new businesses have been established in the past 15 years which is worth a mention. There is brain drain in Bengal due to unavailability of jobs and yet the Hindus in Bengal have not waken up to reality. It's about time the mentality of the people has to change and the change needed is now.
Bengal has gone. Out of Indian culture.
What's wrong in it? The Bengal Hindus voted for TMC in 2024 MP elections, they dug their own grave. They got what they hace voted for. Well done Bengali Hindus, you deserve this.
Ohh the Bengalis considered themselves to be the most modern and open not only in India but in the entire world ..few of my friends claim it and they don't understand that they are the laughing stock for the entire world. Just by gathering a PhD and certificates doesn't guarantee you logic. Bengalis are a good example of it. 😂
Rule by brahmin banor ji...hohoho...oh bhai bjp...now cut grass and study veda to know reasons...
@@drrmdebnath8356keep laughing, soon u will be a maulana in Bangladesh.
Chacha,,35% voted enmasse for tmc,thle leader of which is """kalapahaar ":: of this day...only 2 to 5 % hindus voted for this bauni..
90% h did not vote for her..
Ok ,do another partition..harharmahadev
Darr hai kanyuki vote ke baad u ko marte pitted hai....murder kerdete hai...log palawan kerrahe hai...pahle congress ne Kiya phir communist ne Kiya phir mamta ne Kiya.. ab bhagwan bharose hai....Hindu hirday Samrat bhi sogaya....governor rule lagena chahiye.....Hindu andhere me hai es baar modi ko hi hilladiya kanyuki center Government bhi ab congress ke pich per khelrahi hai...usko bhi mahatma banna hai....kya kersakte hai...nrc or ucc 10 saal me nahi lapayi...jisse sab dharm ke log ek kanoon ke Ander hote or desh ka vikash hota...sabka sath sabka vikash nahi sabke upper ek saman kanoon hona chahiye ek ka mandir control me or dusre ko free me sab kuch...Hindu tex do dusre dharmwale or rajneta mazze kare
Madrassas education should be banned.
1000000000000000000000%%%%
Not just in Bengal but all across the nation. Education should not be connected in any way with religion. You want to modernise education, as is being said by some political analysts here, why don't you bring it under the umbrella of the modern and legal education boards of the nation and the states? Why not invest in STEM, commerce, and arts instead of sketchy madrasas? Moreover, the Khagragarh incident in Bengal revealed how these madrasas are used by Islamic jihadis to train agents in Bengal in making explosives, ammunitions and other terror modules. The nation got to know about it only when the NIA set foot on the field, while Mamata and her administration knew everything all along and have been sheltering them silently. I really wonder, how come the union govt didn't impose President's rule on Bengal right away! That way the state wouldn't be destroyed this way.
One my friend was in Kolkata during the election. Her maid told her that TMC has stopped entire villages voting for BJP by picketing her goonda's in the villages from leaving the village to vote. Many people were afraid to go out to vote. Thats why many BJP voters stayed at home out of fear. I can't believe in 21st century, this kind of gooda gardi? Why didn't the EC take note and provide security for voters.
Investigation should be done. And WB should be under President rule.
Sanjay Jha:" Modi should resign"
@@nitichatterji5223Abe jana
😳
jai bjp
@@NATTYAL899 your language speaks volumes about your standards.
But Bengalis deserves this they like becoming a WEST BANGLDESH….What can we do about it….In BANGLDESH Hindu population fell from 24% (1951) to 7% (2024) and In West Bengal Muslim population rose from 15%(1951) to 28% (2011) at this rate they will become majority by 2051….We have another Kashmir to deal with 😢
😂😂 it shows that you are an illiterate if you know that Bengali Hindus are no longer present in Bengal the demography has changed completely and I'm pretty sure you must be a Bihari wait till Bihar's demography also changes then you will understand what has happened to Bengali Hindus beta Tera bhi time aayega The Other Hindus are not as safe as you think the Bengali Hindus and the Punjabis has already suffered all the blows that they could since the time of independence now it is for all the other Yadav's the Kumar's all the other caste people it is now your turn this Hindus will be now f***** up and change to Muslim congratulations up
Why indian tax payers have pay for medresa education? Let Mamata Begham pay from her own bank account.
Even her bank account has tax payers money 😂😂..she should get money from allah 😂
5530 cr to boost t@rror hub.. 😢😢😢😢
Aagh!!!! Sanjay Jha.. infectious ... worse than dengue.
Appeasement is the only way for all opponents of BJP. However BJP is not coming out clearly as a Hindu party. BJP is shying tp take a clear stand and hence their core voter is also devided and opponents know it
Soon Bengalis will have Madarsa University and apply for jobs with their madarsa degree 🤣
Sanjay Jha, you mentioned " it depends on the economic situation " in response to Shehzad's" Muslims being the 2nd largest majority". I have a question for you Sanjay Jha, why are the Muslims in this economic situation ? You can go back 70 years from 2014 for your answer, and know that the government in power then is entirely to blame.
How does madrasa education become government business?
The more indians votes for this opposition parties the likes of Vivek and others they will surely start selling educational seats like what they did in Bengal for jobs etc
this is a national security threat. center needs to intervene.
This is no surprise.Mamta bano is just moving ahead the legacy of communist which was minority appeasement.TMC is nothing but same SOAP in different wrapper.
Bengali Hindus Rewarded For Voting For TMC,Well Done TMC Government In Bengal.
SUN J IS A SADIST OF HIGHEST ORDER , HE STANDS FIRST IN THE LIST OF SARCASTIC SADISTS .
Sanjay Jha is obsessed by BJP, even if his so called ally abuses congress🤔He is rather personal and vitriolic 🤨
Vivek just a pepet of mamata ji, the party which was abolished by TMC shameless party is CPIM....
accha hua...aur sabak milna chaiye west bengal ke hindu religious logo ko...sab behaya log...500-1000 rupees mein bik jaate hai
Bengal people should think about it .
There can't because there watching Bengali serials!!! And getting freebies and there family main head is going other state for job , jobbbbbb and reason simple no jobs if this much is given to Madrasa and seeing when Bengal will be the next Kashmir or the bangladesh where the native are thrown out , first done by Mughals convert or die or run and now by TMC (the muslim congress) and many big corporate offices are shifting to Bangalore and Mumbai and i was like why there are leaving there root and here is the reason, no development only muslim and freebies and small development to show case people we are investing and secretly funding gundas and polices for our next election and this development also not for u it's for my bangladeshi voters, but I promise once I come to the centre u would see TMC is now fully active In eastern side of India which includes northeast too and soo now protect Bengal or else run for the whole eastern side of India in the next 50+years or 100 would be enough!!!! Kidding if not taken serious (why whole because indian government would be letting Bengal to become a country soo obvious I will spread my bangladeshi immigrants to whole eastern side of India and I don't know but sooner or later we may find out pfi was the main provider of voter for TMC !!!(Next 100 years the secret plan) Which is just a imaginary think of my brain and I hope it's just a imaginary)
Even pakistan and Bangladesh will not spend so much... thanks Hindus of west Bengal for electing her repeatedly....
My concern is what is taught in Madrasa?? The education should be enrolled into ministry of education under the secular program...
We need UCC.
Mr. Jha, speak on the topic! Your ",love" for Mr. Modi and BJP is well known.
Wow hypocrites like jha and Vivek, the irrationality we can see that they want to sack the accused immediately but were behaving like a wet cat for the accused khujliwal 😅😅😅
The muslim students should go to the normal educational institutions and not in the Quranschools. Otherwise there would not be any upliftment of muslims.
You are soo worried about their upliftment 😅
Hindu brothers and sisters note that.Remove the Begam..
Why unnecessarily worried? WB. Hindus don't care & BJP don't help their cadres.
I am from north Bengal what do you know about how are demography has changed and how it has impacted us and this cur of a leader Sanjay Jha and other spokesperson from TMC says it’s peanuts, then why only 800 cr for the development of entire north Bengal. What a shame.
Tell me honestly, what's wrong with bengali Hindus?
It's more looking like a pakistan budget rather than India. You might as well get a direct request of budget money from pakistan. 🙏👺
Maja aagya, hindu hoon main but hindu aisa religion hai ,apni lakdia and aag ka arrangement khud karta hai 😂😂
Bengali hindus r at fault, they r not united.Soon India will lose W.Bengal to Bangladesh.
When Mamatha needs support and she should please them with goodies. West Bengal looks like gone out of control.
These debators cannot hold more than one point in mind.. It's already established that Muslims need upliftment in WB. But it needs to be in proper education. Remember the people who wanted to build a school or hospital in place of ram mandir? Now what happened to them? Rahul caught their tongue? Let's build more schools not madrasas.. Isn't that the logical option then? I mean build your madrasas.. Don't use govt funds for it.. It's utterly shameless of Sanjay Jha to openly regurgitate whatever he wants.. I had felt he was more patriotic than that. The nation is being maid khokla from inside and this tunneling is spearheaded by Rahul Rajiv. Also Sanjay Jha please check liver function and kidney function.. Face looking puffy.. Genuine concern here. Nothing political
Modernization of madarasas will not work. It does nothing to change the radical mindset and hatred of khafirs
The hatred is in the book..😂 they should ban this cult just like china did.
How cynical n sick is the opposition.. its stuck only on one point.. Modi should resign. Does it make any sense?
In current scenario if Muslims are sending their child to madarasa and quetioning rojagari to Modi😂
Why do these media channels invite Sanjay jha? Like do they want to raise our BP?
He is one of the most blatant liars and a hypocrite at his core.
Sanjay can't bear to see his baba black sheepsitting on the P. M. chair for the 3rd consective time. What jealously.
Vivek Srivastav talks non sense always, hope he will change himself as a better person.
How can there be Madarsas in a secular country even after the bloody partition in the name of the same majhab??
Center should have intervened and declared president rule when sandeshkhali incident took place. Why didnt they?
Does Constitution permit? What we are doing?
Sanjay jha forgot what was the toopic😂
Mr.Tasif, should Mr. Bratya Basu and Mamata Banerjee resign?
She reigns ,they govern .
Thing is, with Mamata's blessings, Bengal is today being sandwiched between the nefarious Muslims of Bihar and UP, and their brethren from Bangladesh and Myanmar pouring in uncontrollably across the border regularly. She has unabashedly handed over the reins of the state to these felonious Muslims, and they, as is their wont, are wreaking havoc all across the state in every way possible. Unsurprisingly, the TMC, police, and criminals are all the same and one entity here today. Mark my words Indians, it won't be a surprise if Mamata declares West Bengal as a sovereign State separated from Modi's India after winning the state assembly elections in 2026. Bengal has already crossed halfway through that mark and hence, this high investment on the foot soldiers of the Sharia law.
won't be surprised if the same gets merged with her neighbouring nation under the prevailing situations
Pls stop inviting Sanjay Jha. He has no arguments to make. He details every show with his Modi hate. He really has nothing to say. If the Congress party has banned you, why do you want their perspective?
In every movie, there will be heroes and Villains...
And comedians like Sanjay Jha, who doesn't have any link with the narrative.
Earn money and leave the India.
Will in any Madarasa (despite allocating this much)... students will ever chant Vande Mataram ..Bharath Mata ki Jai ....Jai Hind..!! ....will they sing National Anthem ..Jana gana mana..?? ....will they stand up while national anthem played / sung.? .will they salute our tricolor flag.?.will they hoist tri color in madarasas?? ..
Let the Muslim Appeasement Parties (Indi Alliance parties) answer these question first.?..other questions can be answered later..!!
Where is pseudo seculars????? Is this is democracy
BJP out of frustration blaming TMC instead of Praising of their good work😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
We desperately need unknown man to take care of this situation.
Firstly, West Bengal Budget for 2024-25 was declared on 1st week of Feb. Why now, at the end June, suddenly there is "debate" on this issue ? Didn't BJP notice this fact back in Feb ? Or it's a diversion tactics to counter NTA scams ?
Secondly, what's BJP's objection ? One BJP spokesperson in the video credited Modi for improving Madrassa education. So why now oppose this move from Bengal Govt ?
When you can't enjoy a whole pie, let's divide and share and enjoy.
Indian Anchors should learn to discipline panelists whose only contribution is to only deviate from the topic. Most unproductive.
Disgusting. No one can stop this state to become a part of Bangladesh. Shamee to the Bengali Hindus to vote this govt
At this moment why is West Bengal, that and not Bangladesh?
what happened to jiski jitni abadi utni uski bhagedari?
In Bengal Hindus becoming 2nd class citizen , Bagladeshi n Rohingyas become 1st priority for vote bank .
.
Ohhhhh GOD.. will some pleaseeee BAN that joker Sanjay Jha from coming on debate ever??? Is only hatred for Modi the only qualification to come on TV???
...
Tmc should replace their present education system of Bengal with madarsa education system. At least people of Bengal can enjoy their democratic rights
What exactly is this Vivek, he doesn't seem to be a 'political analyst' but a 'political activist' advocating against one party😢😂😮
5500+ cr is allocated for maddrasa
I just dont understand as to why Modi doesn't impose President's rule
This is due to us hindus always divided
Mr. Rahul Gandhi should be the chief of NTA and then everything will run well .
Do not place the burrden of self imposed islamic poverty on other communities
Mr. Jha is practising tirade against Mr. Modi and BJP.
Madrasa should be constitutionally banned.
Lord I can't change
Oppotion parties didnot succeed bringing bharat into civil war now they are trying with student agitation ...
What Bengal govt doing is totally good and because of this TMC always win every election but BJP always get jealous 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why we people should pay for Madrasa education? Where they openly teach Muslim kids about hating non-Muslims, kaffirs... so why madrasa education should be encouraged in India after giving two separate Islamic countries.... go to their Madrasas if you need Madrasa education.
They are all political "opinionists" and not analysts...................unfortunately they are very vocal and sectary.
Single largest party win is BJP, still there is near to majority mandate from people of india
Sanjay JHA is the biggest Jalebi Master!
NOW THE SAME PKAISTAN IS WEST BENGAL. IN THE MEANTIME WEST BENGAL HAS BECOME MINI PAKISTAN AND MODIJI IS SLEEPING. BHARATVARSH WILL BECOME AN ISLAMIC NATION BY 2090
What is this about modernizing Madrassas...it should be closed. Let the muslim children study in normal schools
Why is every company/factory shutting down and leaving WB, furthermore no new company is either planning to invest in WB be it at the national or international level! हर हर महादेव जय श्री राम भारत माता की जय हिंद वंदे मातरम नमो नमो 🔱🕉️🥚🙏💪🇮🇳💪🇮🇳💪
Many Bengali are getting freebies and there family main head is going other state for job , jobbbbbb and reason simple no jobs if this much is given to Madrasa and seeing when Bengal will be the next Kashmir or the bangladesh where the native are thrown out , first done by Mughals convert or die or run and now by TMC (the muslim congress) and many big corporate offices are shifting to Bangalore and Mumbai and i was like why there are leaving there root and here is the reason, no development only muslim and freebies and small development to show case people we are investing and secretly funding gundas and polices for our next election and this development also not for u it's for my bangladeshi voters, but I promise once I come to the centre u would see TMC is now fully active In eastern side of India which includes northeast too and soo now protect Bengal or else run for the whole eastern side of India in the next 50+years or 100 would be enough!!!! Kidding if not taken serious (why whole because indian government would be letting Bengal to become a country soo obvious I will spread my bangladeshi immigrants to whole eastern side of India and I don't know but sooner or later we may find out pfi was the main provider of voter for TMC !!!(Next 100 years the secret plan) Which is just a imaginary think of my brain and I hope it's just a imaginary)
Apply 356 otherwise it will out of hand like Kashmir. BJP central gov is equal responsible, inspite of numerous corruption by Begum and her bhaipo, ED/CBI don't arrest them. Why?
Central voice not strong enough
Will anyone tell this idiotic Sanjay Jha the debate is for WB’s appeasement budget but he will speak everything except points on debate.
Sanjay Jha is a jocker
Ye Sanjay kaun si prajati ke prani hain? The so called minority of the country has all the benefits.. fer bhi pratardit hain?
All they do is study only one book in mad...ra...sa. for whole life and then they want upliftment
Jha jaise joker hai tabhi maja aata hai debate mai😂
sanjay jha is loosing his mind . why to even call him on debate if he doesn't answer any question on the topic
TMC spokesperson actually showed himself a mirror by telling stats that minorities are in such poor condition even after TMC ruling there for so long.
Secularism means Islamic rule. Hindus of Bengal voted for Islam 😀😀😀😀
For me their thinking is like Bangladeshi Muslim
What has mamata reduced the state to. Poverty poverty and poverty. No education no development no job no progress. Then cry.
Kerala and Now Bengal failed states.
What is contribution of bjpfor hindu community
Modi would have tripled it. Thank god his party didn't win.
Needs Kashmir like solution
sanjay jhhaaa educated baanarr
There is a joker in hindi bhadu and jha in english