Tata Harrier Automatic vs Jeep Compass | Comparison Test Review | Autocar India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 гру 2024
- NOTE: We filmed this test before the Coronavirus pandemic hit and before lockdown was enforced. We do not recommend venturing out of your home at this time except for essentials. Stay home, stay safe.
A year after its launch, the Tata Harrier is back with a more powerful diesel engine, more equipment and an automatic gearbox. Co-incidentally, the Jeep Compass got a few updates of its own recently too, including a diesel auto powertrain and more equipment. Which one is best? Renuka Kirpalani picks a winner.
#TataHarrier #JeepCompass #Automatic #ComparisonTest #TeamAutocar
SUBSCRIBE to Autocar India for hottest automotive news and the most comprehensive reviews ► bit.ly/AutocarInd
Autocar India is your one stop source for test drive reviews & comparison test of every new car released in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content including podcasts, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Click this link for latest car reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-NewC...
Click this link for comparison tests of latest cars & bikes ►bit.ly/ACI-Comp...
Click this link for latest bike reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-Bike...
Click this link for Autocar India exclusive features ►bit.ly/ACI-Feat...
Visit www.autocarindi... for the latest news & happenings from the auto world.
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Instagram: / autocar_india
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
G+: plus.google.co...
PLEASE NOTE: We filmed this test before the Coronavirus pandemic hit and before lockdown was enforced. We do not recommend venturing out of your home at this time except for essentials. Stay home, stay safe.
Ex showroom means onroad price??
Please compare creta and xuv 300
@@preetampujari8273 yes
Felt more comfortable with harrier... My ride of compass was less comfortable than harrier.. My wallet too was happy.. Thank you Tata for your excellency
Are you sure about the ride comfort on compass??
I have heard from many that harrier is much better on road as compared to compass.
Less bumpy than compass.
Two of my favourite SUVs. Heart says Compass while mind says Harrier. Wallet says None!
Harrier Indian hai vo american...
My heart says Hector, mind says harrier, wallet same as you.
🤣🤣🤣
Why heart says compass, when u drive it ull understand it's not good to drive
@@madsam9403 why??
25 lacs for the compass?
No sir!
Not at all VFM.
Tata Harrier is a way better deal, the Harrier looks great too.
35 Onroad for the trailhawk version.
Harrier 25L and compass 30+L for top variant
Still I will go with compass
@@GirishKumarBhat thats a joke......😎
@Los Blancos 13 True. I would buy a second hand A6 or 530D or XF for 25L and put the remaining 10L for the maintenance for five years (doable).
A 5lakh rupees lesser SUV giving such a gud competition is already a gud pick ❤️🤘🔥
Quality matter bro
Harrier is no where a match to the compass .... Compass is the better built , quality interiors , proper SUV with 4×4 options , better handling and drivability ...... So better don't go with the size ..... Only enthusiasts prefer to buy the cars in this segment and harrier won't appeal to enthusiasts as much as the jeep compass do .... And not to say about that jeep badge 💞 which deserves the money
Jeep compass obviously better product for long term and i would still pay 5 l more to get compass.
@@prudhviraj6416 why go for a car like jeep where we can get harrier with discovery quality better in look better in space and also Its TATA every body knows how long Tata car can run after 15 years i changed the tyres finally of my tata 15 yrs..
@@prudhviraj6416 Proper suv means ladder on frame. Get 2020 bs6 hexa 4*4.
I once drove harrier 12hrs straight with only 1 hr break and when i reached my destination i wasn't tired.. the thing i liked in the harrier is it kept reminding me to take a break
I was gonna write the same thing 16 hours straight and was not tired at all
Yup...the video seems to be a bit biased as Harrier has the best backseat and comfort in its segment...
True .. off-road for 8 hours still not tired
How does the car exactly remind one to take a break ? I bought the car and would like to know about this feature (haven't driven for long distance yet)
Compass is a great car, no doubt. But it has its issues
The 9 speed auto is nowhere near as enthusiastic as the hyundai 6 speed in the Harrier
The compass isn't as spacious
It isn't VFM anymore, limited plus is almost 30 lacs in some cities, and I'm sorry but a compact SUV like that is not worth 3 million rs, I'd rather shell out some more and get a proper SUV like the fortuner
Ofcourse it has its merits as well, compass is the better handler of the two
The 2.0 Multijet is the best in the compass compared to any other versions
The only one with 4x4 out of the two
Best fit and finish of the two
If I had to pick, I'd pick the Harrier automatic, just my personal preference
But its awd is garbage...more or less both suv are equal in offroading.
Lmao you just typed everything they said in the video. Pretty useless time wasting
Giving so much of opinion without even driving one . Lol
3 Million? 😂😂😂
Wanna be cool guy huh?
@@amit6844 really?
Even come off-roading
Harrier ✌️value for money.. jeep for brand value
Renoy Antony Jeep doesn’t have any brand value, it’s owned by Fiat. I don’t have to tell you Fiat reliability.
Jeep is obviously better brand and spending 17 + lakhs for Tata cars dont worth it..
True
Who would have thought that we would be comparing TATA to jeep.
Simple answer jeep is overrated tata is underrated and same goes for kia and Hyundai they are overrated
@@c.bulakh6231 , creta is overrated not Hyundai 😂
Lmao people are still tilted that seltos whooped harriers ass last year
@@c.bulakh6231 no way Hyundai is overrated
Jeep is over hyped here.. It is considered one of the most unreliable brand in US.
No doubt compass is a good car but when it comes to comparing with harrier,it is the harrier which is a clear winner because of its looks,road presence, space,solid built quality n value for money.
Of course it gives the same power as that of compass with a lower price when compare to compass
With a crappy build and inferior infotainment? Yea right!!
Just by adding memory seat , wireless charging, a bit larger and responsive touch screen, internet connectivity and air purifier . It will become far more superior than compass. Same needed in nexon variant. Now consumer can pay a good price for tata cars. Thats a belief reflects in sales figure.
I was waiting for this review with burning curiosity thank god i made right decision and bought Harrier.
Let's see the value after 3/4years…
@@minzyhaokip4515 Tata will have better service within 2-3years then talk about the resale and afterssle services
@Abraham Ering yes it has little body roll while cornering and taking sharp turn but thank god not like scorpio.
Abraham Ering no it isn’t and the two can’t be compared, Harrier is based on Land Rover Discovery which is miles ahead of Scorpio, the Suspension in harrier is well balanced.
@Abraham Ering don't compare apples with oranges.... How can the body roll of a Monocoque (Harrier) be compared to a Ladder on Frame Chassis (Scorpio)?.... Ofcourse Harrier is way superior to Scorpio in terms of body roll.....
tata's intention is not to make money, but to offer great build quality in a less price than the other brands as Tata always concern about safety 😍
yes but rember the indica, one of the worst cars for safety
Nexon top model cost 15 lakh while mahindra xuv 300 top cost 13 lakh. Harrier is priced same as compass. Not even single car of tata is priced below its competitors
@@Abhiram-nb8yk yes but indica is made in 2020 no right I think u understood what I am trying to say
Just bought top varent of harrier the dark edition 😍
@@Abhiram-nb8yk you can't blame a company for its first product. Everyone learns from their mistakes and so did Tata Motors. Its highly inappropriate to compare the recent car's safety to the one that was launched almost 11 years back
Harrier xza+ for sure
Hands down harrier is the clear winner
They said it's only due to price. Otherwise, compass is the clear winner. It's got the best ride quality and that is the major deciding aspect of any car for those who love to drive.
Compass looks better, handles better, has 4x4, better infotainment, better attention to detail with those red stitching on seats, better steering. Not right to say "clear winner". Compass is better for classier and self driving owners who don't mind spending the extra bucks. Harrier is better for chauffeur driven and gives much more value for money
I cant buy even a santro and here i am watching harrier. Man tata uped their game alot. Recently ive been to tata showroom and saw harrier. It is a beast! Even better than fortuner which is a big deal for a SUV.
For those who don't know, the ground clearance shown in this video is laden. The ground clearance (unladen) of the Harrier is 205mm
Hope Jeep does a price correction. Anyways harrier in this new avatar is an absolute bang for the buck 👍
Nope! It's a whole segment above..This is not an apples to apples comparison.
Soumen Das jeep should reduce the price !!
Had taken a test drive of the BS6 Harrier AT recently, absolutely loved it, I have a problem with 2 things first the touch screen and the reverse camera is a disgrace at this price point, secondly tata motors should focus on improving there electronics inside led reading lamp switch wasn't working, lastly the steering is not bad but yes it follows the road and it will tire you more than the compass.
It's called better feedback and stability, its hydraulic steering after all
@@nishchaynandre5540 Being a front wheel drive it felt a little weird when you put the power down, everytime had to hold the steering tightly. This is not the case in rear wheel drive vehicle's.
Harriet clear winner on price , size , looks , better gearbox performance , that woooden cabin looks more plush , Harrier’s 2wd works as well as compass’s 4wd , very spacious and comfortable and well ofcourse omega arc Land Rover platform is a boast
Honestly i'd go for the jeep cause i have test driven both cars and the jeep just feels so much better to drive. Bear in mind that there are people who buy cars for the basic fun of driving and the compass does fulfill that desire. Some models of the compass are slightly cheaper. The harrier is good but just too all over the place kinda car for me. In the end, i believe the extra 3-4 lakhs is worth it.
Harrier using jeep engine only and we must be proud that our indian company has much better car equal to an american product, support our Indian car's...
It isn't the jeep engine it's fiat multijet 2.0
Both harrier and compas using Fiat engine
@@sachinkb3028 it's 50% Tata engine because fiat has partnership with TATA in India.
@@rohitk.2209 exactly
@@mukarramjuzeralikesariya6177 i know that, am mentioning that this 2 car's using same engine...
Harrier steals the show! Undoubtedly best in sub 20lakhs segment!! 🇮🇳❤️
JEEP just did a price correction :)
If I am allowed to choose then it's definitely Harrier.. not only because of price tag but also did the fact that it's our home grown Tata which is now giving serious competitions to foreign manufacturers..
Infront of compass, Harrier is clearly winner..
The 2020 harrier automatic actually makes sense to buy in the price range it is offered.
I have the 2019 harrier xz n m completely in love with it
I can compromise tonnes of features for the looks and road presence of harrier❤❤ and when u get know the automatic is one segment above as well as the platform then i don't think any guy would need something else
Harrier's top end model is cheaper than Jeep's base model
Premium Ness matter
You get what you pay for - remember that!
It's like telling superb's top end model is less than 3 series base model
And Alto's top model is cheaper than Audi's base model😝
According to the comparison, we can easily tell that harrier is the new beast
But no one is going to buy it any way
@@needimanh still going to sell more than jeep.
@@needimanh everyone is buying lol
@@needimanh in ur world maybe not in real
jeep is more reliable than your harrier
Love you guys🙌😙.... was waiting for this from a while
Harrier any day 😍😍
Over anything in this segment
If I had money I would have gone for harrier ...just for its looks 🔥
Handsome - Harrier VS smart - Compass
1:11 are you sure those ground clearance figures are correct? They seem even less than a sedan like Honda City.
New government regulation requires manufacturers to declare ground clearance when the car is laden, not unladen. Hence the lower numbers. :)
@@autocarindia1 The laden ground clearance will depend on the no of people or the total weight of people + cargo in the car, so what is the standard?
@@ashutoshgupta546 400kg
@@ashutoshgupta546 Maximum possible occupancy and maximum possible cargo load capacity.
Harrier's road presence is no joke 💀
I was waiting for this comparo after the launch of the BS6 Harrier & was also expecting for other rivals to jump into the fray & spice up things, but, as always, Renuka Ma'am covered it up in a way no one can & came up with such an intriguing review...!👏👏👏 Tata has really come a long way & the Harrier is a testament that our perception towards the company needs to change. Its such a balanced product which has something to offer to every consumer. Comments might pour in to highlight the missing connected car tech & other useless features, but this car is all about enjoying the feel behind the wheel, the driving experience & that is something which will keep one more entertained than the long list of tech wizardry found in some other competitors. Great job Tata motors for bringing in such a great product & Autocar India for always exceeding our expectations.....!😊🎊🎉
Harrier's steering is tighter and there is slight false play and has some turbo lag. Still, it checkmates compass with compassion.
same bro dark edition!
Compassion?
4wd?
You guys read my mind to compare these two.
Thanks for comparing Harrier with Jeep. This is the first time Harrier get a respect by comparing same segment SUV technically not price point of view. All other UA-cam channel comparing with Hyundai Creta and kia Seltos unnecessary. I wish you will compare it with more SUV like Hyundai Tucson and many more.
Yes exactly! Harrier is a bigger SUV, it should be compared with compass, hector, tucson, xuv500
Kia Seltos not at all matches these two. Jeep&Harrier perfect comparison
Compass has 4 wheel drive and the jeep brand shows how quality is the Compass and solid build.
I hope the video was shot before the corona spread?? Wish you guys health and safety, stay home and stay safe
Obviously it was shot during the harrier media drive
Proud owner of jeep compass limited plus 4*2❤️
old skool look better than new
❤️
benji y right brother
2 years ago Compass was a value proposition. It made a segment of its own but now... it is the most expensive with trailhawk models touching nearly Rs.30lakh in some states. Not worth buying right now. Jeep needs to reconsider its pricing and maybe bring in a facelift soon after Coronavirus pandemic ends.
Trailhawk us comes around 35 lacs ...compass is nearly 29 lacs...
The smile on her face @2.11 is what the jeep compass is all about.
One of the Most awaited comparisons
uff finally a video today,i m interested in
Most awaited video ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Uconnect system is the best in industry.. 9 speed gearbox, better build quality than Indian cars, ride quality, interior fit and finish..flat fold seats..iconic design..I can go on
All time harrier ❣️❣️
Most awaited comparison.
harrier is great suv DNA of Land rover
old Ford ECUD platform(LR-MS d8 platform) not hardcore like discovery and bigger range rover .
Harrier to go for of course!
Still love u Jeep... Heart core fan of jeep compass.....Dad of all Suvs the brilliant suv...... in planet... love you jeep... Go anywhere Do anything... OlllllllO...cant wait to own one...
Harrier all the way! ✌🏼
Handsome looking car harrier
Clear winner 🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
Harrier for shure❣️
Nobody’s talking about the sick white bike at 3:48?
Thats a honda goldwing if i aint mistaken
Thank you 💓. I was waiting for this
No doubt Jeep Compass 🔥❤️🎈
Harrier❤❤💪💪
Jeep compass is the best ........ superb driving dynamics ......... even though compass is heavier and they share same engine technology , compass just blows out the harrier with performance , segment first suspension - fsd , jeep active 4*4 , and premium built quality justify the price ........ jeep compass can simply blows out fortuner and endeavour in performance .... jeep stability even above 200 + is remarkable ........
Ofcourse TATA HARRIER😍
Harrier is value for money and stylish suv
Being an Indian, it is a matter of proud that Tata SUV is being compared with the best of American SUV . This itself speaks volumes of positive success about our great car producer Shri Ratan Tata ji.
So let's prefer an Indian Tata harrier (the SUV).
Jai hind
Buying TATA car is helping the nation grow. Huge respect to TATA group for standing with India and remember TATA built India. Surprisingly they donate much of the wealth to welfare of People. Buyers can compromise some of flimsy features to by a quality Indian product.
Only thing missing in Harrier is the electronic park brake, hope they will add it soon.
3:48 who noticed a HARLEY OR INDIAN passing by..
...
Whoever is preferring Harrier over Compass here is forgetting that the Compass is a 4x4 drive and that's why the hefty price. Take them both on a snow mountain and you ll see how Good a compass is as a car.
Harrier for sure 😍😌🤞
Compass is better in every manner except for price . But still l would choose the lower variant of Compass because of driving dynamics , build quality and brand value .
Good to see Indian cars catching up. 👍
TATA HARRIER is best SUV in India love TATA.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
If u love driving..compass is the one👍
I drove the Harrier AT after seeing this video. Unfortunately, the transmission isn’t as good as I’d hoped it would be, and the Diesel engine makes way too much noise in the cabin. There is no place to rest your other hand if you’re cruising with one hand. The power of the harrier is good on paper but it let down by the transmission.
I love the positive steps Tata is taking, if they improve some of the finer details, the car would be much more attractive.
This shows Indian manufacturers have come a long way and are capable to make cars for even developed market.
Please upload more and more videos so we can sit at home and enjoy watching autocar ❤
😂😂
Apart from all a Big applause to the AUTOCAR INDIA team to keep us as viewers engaging at home with uploading videos as ongoing situation in India.. Thankz a lot AUTOCAR INDIA..
Stay Safe Team ..
Proud that the Tata can now match with the Jeep!!!
AWD on Jeep should justify the price tag. But then again how many people are really going to make use of it is a question. So maybe the AWD less variant should be a good comparison to Harrier.
I got compass 4×4 limited plus manual . I like it.
Much needed review. Thanks!
@AutocarIndia, I remember from your BS4 siblings comparison that Harrier arrests the exterior noises significantly better compared with Compass. The BS6 comparison has an absolutely contrast dialogue on noise cancellation. Any Reason to defend that point? Thank you in advance, Great review though!
Jeep Compass for me any given time if the price was not considered.But the extra price we pay is for the sheer engineering,and technology in it..It is not like Harrier with Land Rover platform,FIAT engine,Hyundai Gearbox.
3:45 anyone noticed that cruiser it was awesome
When is the new discovery sport review coming out ?
I didnt understand why tata omitted an awd variant for this wonderful vehicle with a landrover platform! Tata's r&d surely needs some young auto enthusiast.if they had given an awd variant then people would have stopped comparing it with creta and all! Personally i also wished a revision for that headlight in bs6 version, it feels like an afterthought! Anyways both are good.
Waiting for tata gravitaz🔥🔥🔥🔥
Can't wait for my XZ+ dark... stay safe guys...
What are the guys at TATA are doing?
Fiat Engine, Hyundai Transmission, Land Rover chassis.
Is there anything at all that TATA can call their own??
land rover d8 platform designed by ford. when ford owned JLR.
HARRIER ANYDAY.. great quality car
Thanks autocar this is the best birthday gift.
Tata is best now affordable and great build quality stronger than compass
Harrier ❤️
Jeep compass approach angle very bad
Even the breakover angle is poor!..
Will post judgement after test driving both. Meanwhile, 1>Technically : It's Jeep, On 2>Commercial aspects : Harrier, 3>living with : Jeep. Brand Appeal and Resale value ; Jeep . But buy a slightly toned down option of Jeep and live happily. Jeep could have bridges the gap by offering 6 speed auto I think that would have sealed the deal. Any takers huh?
Jeep campass - silent feel
Tata Harrier - ruff & tuff feel
I liked the last few words about harrier
Please, I humbly requesting for making 2020 tata harrier automatic vs 2020 Hyundai creta automatic
So if price is not a concern and ride quality is what we want, the jeep compass is the pick of the segment compared to it's rivals in both petrol automatic and diesel automatic isn't ?
Plz make a comparison between tuscon awd vs trailhawk