Can't hear this song without crying, makes me think of playing the xbox again with my brother. I miss you sooo bad lil B, I'll see you again one day. R.I.P Brandon. I love you.
sjvm1123 sorry for your loss :( I’m sitting here crying cause my guitar got water damage when there’s people who lost loved ones. Thanks for putting my shit in perspective and once again, I’m so sorry for your loss.
FATA reminds of my brother too, stole his too bad youre beautiful cd when i was in middle school. Short Stories with Tragic Endings is still my favorite
28 almost 29 and I’m listening to this song like my emo 12 year old self again 😭 for everyone reading this I hope you find your soul partner and they love you back ♥️
5 years ago i used to come here and listen this song, sing along the video and play it with my acustic guitar. 5 years later, now, i'm still doing it. Thanks for the upload!
This is a song I have to prepare myself for, it's that powerful to me. Easily the best friend I ever had was named Autumn. She died in a car crash in 05'. But about a year before I introduced her to this song and it immediatly became HER song, which technically speaking it kinda was, her name WAS Autumn haha. But to this day I cannot listen to this song without crying. Autumn Doran I miss you every single fucking day. And I just hope I can be half a good person as you were so I can see you again
My mom and I used to listen to this when I was like 5 and she played it recently and it made me feel nostalgic I'm like "gimme the name of that song" I'm 15 and love this so much
I forgot this song existed until I just picked up a guitar and my fingers wanted to play it. It's been a long time. This song is so sad I can't handle it. Something about it really makes you feel autumns feelings :(
This song holds so much meaning for so many people its a shame its not the most listened to song. This song is about that love that got away, I would kill to get it back...
The girl is Melanie Wills. She also sang in FATA's '03 album, The Fiction We Live, on the songs Short Stories With Tragic Endings and Autumn's Monologue. She's from the band One True Thing.
Never give up singing. I'm a soon to be opera singer and I've been singing sense I was five or younger. Wonderful song. Beautiful lyrics. It's one of those songs that really has meaning and most of those who listen to it will be able to relate to it. Everyone goes to heartbreak. I did as a mater of fact.
like so many others here i heard this song many years ago when the album first released. and after all this time it stabs me right in the feels more than ever...truly amazing how music can do that.
I had all buy forgotten about some of this older stuff until some conversation on Saturday made me look them up again. Wow, this really takes me back. Thanks for posting this up here.
Glad to finally see a beautiful song from a metal band this isn't getting pounded by close-minded headbangers calling the band sell-outs because they made a ballad. I love versatile bands that can excel in both high energy and soft songs. Metallica has their share of slow songs, as does Black Sabbath, that is how it should be.
Beautiful song, I have been listening to it for years as I have evolved through the unthinkable. This song reminds me of a place I can always go when things are not panning out the way I want them to
broke up with my ex back in 2008 and this was all I'd listen to. We got back together years later and broke up again because life happened. This song is just as powerful to me as it was back then.
I remember the first time I heard this song, I had just broken up with a long time girlfriend, and a friend had just been dumped by his long term g/f and he showed me this song, and I was crying like 3 seconds into it. Such a great song and she has such a beautiful voice. Definitely 5 stars.
This song could be so much bigger. It's so so good, this many years later. It's beautiful. Very well sung. Even covered I could imagine would be good. I loved it 13 years ago, and I love it still!
Yesterday, my brother suddenly got this song played on his car, and I was immediately transfered back to my teenage years, where I was having difficult time. Such a bitter sweet feeling all flooding in. Both of us ended up singing this song together and I was kinda choked up because I haven't seen him yor 2 years already .He just got home yesterday, and that us singing together was the first thing that makes me really feel connected and bonded as a family again
I thank Aarron for introducing me to this song...it is one of my favorites and most of the time i cannot even get it out of my head..i find myself singing it all the time to myself...i love this song so much!
I used to like this song when i was like 4/5, listening to it again now, it kinda reminds me of the last person i liked,however cal i know you will probably never see this so im comfortable saying this here, was it really hard to like me back after everything, you literally have never even considered it huh?
This song seems like a voice from my dreams. That first love I lost, taken to pieces as the clock spun. A memory broken in two each time I tried remembering. She's not what she was, but I still hold her close. Some pieces are gone, but I still love the ghost.
I think its been more than 10 years since i listened to this song by the first time, and now I'm a woman and now I really know what is to break in two for a loved person :( I wish that I was that teenager who didn't know about love and broken hearts...
The first time i herd this song i was with my ex.. i can now listen to it and not think of her anymore. Its a beautiful song that i love listening to eveyday!!
+Samantha Gossman my freshman year of hs, than a girl stood me up for their concert. I went by myself, even though these chicks outside were making fun of me for being alone. I thought to myself "posers". I even gave a smoke to a member of fata, wont mention who :P This person was trying to quit, this was around xmas 2005 Orono, Maine
this song- I swear will reel anyone in. I miss who brought this to my attention. Thought for sure he was forever for me. My father died, he cheated on me during. And when all was said and done, I broke his heart by not forgetting and getting back together. But this song...geez ♡
This song will always hit me like a ton of needles on my skin. Its so beautiful, and trajic and the way she writes her heartbrake is very unique but all the same so deep. I remember crying to this song so long ago, even when all that is gone, this song will always remind me of that girl I used to be.
I had the pleasure of seeing these guys play local long island shows over 10 years ago and knew how much this song would haunt me for the lest of my life.
I remember seeing them back in 05' (maybe 06') at warped and one of my favs then and now. This song was my breakup song for the boy that took me there (high school love), and many more after. Now on the other side of a lot of my trauma it hits a little different. Still a top fav.
Imagine how this band would have turned if Melanie would not brainwash the shit out of the main vocalist and turn him against his bandmates and never left the band tho
@@Gr3nthDude, I've never heard of that, sheesh. I'm a new school fan of the band but now it's time to do some research on this. It's like 4am, we'll see what that ought to do.
Doesn't it though? This song always hit me like that. I heard it when it came out and had the same meaning then that it does now and still breaks my broken heart. 💔💔
this song is a fossil... a precious ornament in time. It will be dug up and dusted off for some of us though... we are there within the earth dusting along side it...
![From Autumn To Ashes - Short Stories With Tragic Endings [Lyrics]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/va9HxF86KHY/mqdefault.jpg)
![From Autumn To Ashes - Short Stories With Tragic Endings [Lyrics]](/img/tr.png)
This song will ALWAYS be a masterpiece regardless of the recognition it didn't get
AGREED! A true work of genius
I wrote a cover version of it because of this same exact thought... Wish I could sing though...
Absolutely
Let’s leave it that way lol
13 years later...still playing this. Song gives me goosebumps.
Anthony Conwell you're right
AC_is_BAD same!
You got it my friend
All these songs stopped giving me goosebumps a while ago... Did something die in me?
@@VerticalWit just means your depressed
I get a shiver when the chorus comes along. Beautiful song.
Yep, 37 years old and still think this song is epic.
I know the life you lived with this song. I got you. You got this
It's absolutely beautiful
Can't hear this song without crying, makes me think of playing the xbox again with my brother. I miss you sooo bad lil B, I'll see you again one day. R.I.P Brandon. I love you.
sjvm1123 really sorry about your brother, what happened to him? If you don't mind me asking
sjvm1123 sorry for your loss :( I’m sitting here crying cause my guitar got water damage when there’s people who lost loved ones. Thanks for putting my shit in perspective and once again, I’m so sorry for your loss.
FATA reminds of my brother too, stole his too bad youre beautiful cd when i was in middle school. Short Stories with Tragic Endings is still my favorite
This song will live forever.
✓
28 almost 29 and I’m listening to this song like my emo 12 year old self again 😭 for everyone reading this I hope you find your soul partner and they love you back ♥️
Shut up lilith, I'm talking to my homie, wait until we have fortified our kinship.
i just got chills i’m 29 i just found this song and now i’m crying LMAO i feel like my 12 year old emo self again too
@@alleymahreeYour channel is a time machine for yourself.
I’m 41 and still listening to this song ! I didn’t find my soulmate , well maybe but I’m to dumb to recognize her 🤷🏻♂️ Hope you have find it
46 still love it found my soulmate but messed it up. Powerful song makes me tear up every time
I first heard this song at some point in high school about 20 years ago. Randomly this tune just hauntingly pops up and brings back so many memories
How time flies. I'm 42 now and it's 3 in the morning and this is on repeat.
41 here. Midnight. 🖤
This song has been stuck in my head for over 10 years. (Edit - 16 years)
Is it still stuck.😢
For me 18 years
5 years ago i used to come here and listen this song, sing along the video and play it with my acustic guitar. 5 years later, now, i'm still doing it. Thanks for the upload!
This is a song I have to prepare myself for, it's that powerful to me. Easily the best friend I ever had was named Autumn. She died in a car crash in 05'. But about a year before I introduced her to this song and it immediatly became HER song, which technically speaking it kinda was, her name WAS Autumn haha. But to this day I cannot listen to this song without crying. Autumn Doran I miss you every single fucking day. And I just hope I can be half a good person as you were so I can see you again
2024 and listening cause my sad feelings T.T thanks for this song FATA you helped me to download from my heart all the pain
My mom and I used to listen to this when I was like 5 and she played it recently and it made me feel nostalgic I'm like "gimme the name of that song" I'm 15 and love this so much
LITERALLY ME RN
Welp I'm old AF now 🤣
@@Cartergamegang 😂😂 I feel the same way.
Check out the fiction we live.
It's from the guys perspective.
Glad these songs are still finding the youth of today.
This is actually my aunt singing. Lost her to leukemia almost 20 years ago. May she rest in piece,
I forgot this song existed until I just picked up a guitar and my fingers wanted to play it. It's been a long time. This song is so sad I can't handle it. Something about it really makes you feel autumns feelings :(
Tearing up the circle , old man now ... still tear it up this was different ,
you know,, it is good to see a metal band came out this type of beautiful song!! OUTSTANDING!!
This song holds so much meaning for so many people its a shame its not the most listened to song. This song is about that love that got away, I would kill to get it back...
The girl is Melanie Wills. She also sang in FATA's '03 album, The Fiction We Live, on the songs Short Stories With Tragic Endings and Autumn's Monologue. She's from the band One True Thing.
Never give up singing. I'm a soon to be opera singer and I've been singing sense I was five or younger.
Wonderful song. Beautiful lyrics. It's one of those songs that really has meaning and most of those who listen to it will be able to relate to it. Everyone goes to heartbreak. I did as a mater of fact.
Are you singing opera now?
like so many others here i heard this song many years ago when the album first released. and after all this time it stabs me right in the feels more than ever...truly amazing how music can do that.
18 years later i’m still sobbing over this song 😭🤣
Same.
Yep, old bstard i became but still this song gets me
Same here
I had all buy forgotten about some of this older stuff until some conversation on Saturday made me look them up again. Wow, this really takes me back. Thanks for posting this up here.
Glad to finally see a beautiful song from a metal band this isn't getting pounded by close-minded headbangers calling the band sell-outs because they made a ballad. I love versatile bands that can excel in both high energy and soft songs. Metallica has their share of slow songs, as does Black Sabbath, that is how it should be.
2019 is almost over, but we're still here crying to this song
Sheena Pangco And now 2020
The Puzzler88 righttt we're still here and sad
Lol 2020
Listen to the fiction we live.
It's from the guys perspective.
2023 and still listening
A great song for a year finale, makes me cry everytime
always ...
This song absolutely melts my heart...
2016 and Im still listening to this.. deep song.
Gosh the way she ends the song "and now you don'ttt" so much emotion went into this song
Beautiful song, I have been listening to it for years as I have evolved through the unthinkable. This song reminds me of a place I can always go when things are not panning out the way I want them to
broke up with my ex back in 2008 and this was all I'd listen to. We got back together years later and broke up again because life happened. This song is just as powerful to me as it was back then.
Right in the feelz
Melanie should've been a huge star.
true
Right?! Her voice shakes my bones
Fame would of poisoned her beauty, she did well dropping this everlasting gem, God bless her :)
100%
How come she wasn’t?
18 years later still listening
the only song that makes me cry. I'm 30
haha me too man.
awww
what about... So long goodbye by 10 YEARS?
me too
When did crying became a question of age?
still loving this song Even after all these years
This is definitely my favorite acoustic song of all time.
wow the first time i heard that song i was blown away by that voice .i still feel the same way couple of years later its incredible big thumbs up
I remember the first time I heard this song, I had just broken up with a long time girlfriend, and a friend had just been dumped by his long term g/f and he showed me this song, and I was crying like 3 seconds into it.
Such a great song and she has such a beautiful voice. Definitely 5 stars.
awesome!
My daughter introduced me to this song..
fell in love with it.melanie's voice is so clean and the lyrics are awesome.
How are you feeling about this song 15yrs later?
This song could be so much bigger. It's so so good, this many years later. It's beautiful. Very well sung. Even covered I could imagine would be good. I loved it 13 years ago, and I love it still!
Was going through a hard breakup when this song came out. Brings tears to my eyes everytime I listen to it
first time listening to this I was maybe 11-12... now I'm 20.. I love this song so much!
and now you're 24
Listening in October 2024
They really dont make this music anymore.
Breaks me down every time, perfect in its beauty
Yesterday, my brother suddenly got this song played on his car, and I was immediately transfered back to my teenage years, where I was having difficult time. Such a bitter sweet feeling all flooding in. Both of us ended up singing this song together and I was kinda choked up because I haven't seen him yor 2 years already .He just got home yesterday, and that us singing together was the first thing that makes me really feel connected and bonded as a family again
Congrats, I’m glad you’re happy. Hope you’re doing well from stranger to stranger
I thank Aarron for introducing me to this song...it is one of my favorites and most of the time i cannot even get it out of my head..i find myself singing it all the time to myself...i love this song so much!
this is the only song i ever cried listening to, great song. it really touched me.
15 years later and im still stuck here in time, many things changes and ive changed a lot but i still break in two when i hear this song
This song is so.. beautiful. Although it brings back horrible memories, I can't help but listen to it.
My all time favorite, first heard it almost 13-14 years ago and it’s still my go to on my playlist ❤️
god this is a nice,nice song reminds me of a girl that past away may god be with her. i love this song heart full : )
I used to like this song when i was like 4/5, listening to it again now, it kinda reminds me of the last person i liked,however cal i know you will probably never see this so im comfortable saying this here, was it really hard to like me back after everything, you literally have never even considered it huh?
I always listen to this song especially when I'm in a depression and feel crappy. This for some reason makes me feel better.
This song seems like a voice from my dreams. That first love I lost, taken to pieces as the clock spun. A memory broken in two each time I tried remembering. She's not what she was, but I still hold her close. Some pieces are gone, but I still love the ghost.
July 2018. Don't know if you still write and sing but dam honey.. You are amazing. So deep and beautiful. Completly under rated, this song is magic
I think its been more than 10 years since i listened to this song by the first time, and now I'm a woman and now I really know what is to break in two for a loved person :(
I wish that I was that teenager who didn't know about love and broken hearts...
NEVER GET BORED WITH THIS SONG. LOVE YOU
This still hits me in the same feels in 2020.
Omg takes me back
Ty sm for posting 🥰
It's a beautiful song...usually I'm not into music like this but the words are just so emotional...it couldn't have been worded better
The first time i herd this song i was with my ex.. i can now listen to it and not think of her anymore. Its a beautiful song that i love listening to eveyday!!
This is such a beautiful song!!!!
LOVE her VOICE and the lyrics too!
I didnt know there could be songs made like this anymore, this one touches my heart. Makes me cry sometimes
Holy fuck. I was 13 when I first heard this.
+Samantha Gossman my freshman year of hs, than a girl stood me up for their concert. I went by myself, even though these chicks outside were making fun of me for being alone. I thought to myself "posers". I even gave a smoke to a member of fata, wont mention who :P This person was trying to quit, this was around xmas 2005 Orono, Maine
+brandon Johnson This fucking guy lmao Catfishing bitches on a FATA UA-cam video. damn nigga you fly
My mom has this on her radio station in the car and I love the song. It is so good. There so good on the song and I love it!
There so good and I love the songs and I think it's great! My mom listens to it on the CD in the morning and the night in the car
this song- I swear will reel anyone in. I miss who brought this to my attention. Thought for sure he was forever for me. My father died, he cheated on me during. And when all was said and done, I broke his heart by not forgetting and getting back together. But this song...geez ♡
So under rated. Love playing this on guitar
I wish they give concerts again...
The song is pure beauty
This is good shit
High-school year god damn
Imagine being a teens back then doing online class instead of going to school jamming during breaks
Saw this live early 2000s in high school
This song will always hit me like a ton of needles on my skin. Its so beautiful, and trajic and the way she writes her heartbrake is very unique but all the same so deep. I remember crying to this song so long ago, even when all that is gone, this song will always remind me of that girl I used to be.
I had the pleasure of seeing these guys play local long island shows over 10 years ago and knew how much this song would haunt me for the lest of my life.
i sang this song on stage with a friend for a performance piece in our performing arts course
Beautiful. A gem just for us
haha, i was tutored by one of the guitarist for FATA's aunt, and I heard a couple FATA songs back in '06 an I was an instant fan. beautiful song.
2:34-3:00 is just as chilling and emotional as the parts with singing. This song is one I don’t listen to frequently becuase It’s so sad and haunting
I remember seeing them back in 05' (maybe 06') at warped and one of my favs then and now. This song was my breakup song for the boy that took me there (high school love), and many more after. Now on the other side of a lot of my trauma it hits a little different. Still a top fav.
Brings me back to the time when...
so beautiful yet so sad..I was literally crying. I listened to this about 4 times.
ive always loved this song.. such powerful emotion.. kudos
Awesome song. OMFG! Such a beautiful voice! Eargasmic... omg....
I could listen to this all night long man...
WOW. WHAT A SONG. LYRICS ARE WONDERFUL, DEEP AND TOUCHING. BRYAN COLLINS RASON
Imagine how this band would have turned if Melanie was a vocalist on all of their albums ? 3 amazing vocalists :O
Imagine how this band would have turned if Melanie would not brainwash the shit out of the main vocalist and turn him against his bandmates and never left the band tho
@@Gr3nth Oh, what's the story ? I had no idea, my bad.
@@Gr3nthDude, I've never heard of that, sheesh. I'm a new school fan of the band but now it's time to do some research on this. It's like 4am, we'll see what that ought to do.
@@Gr3nthI've got nothing after 21hrs. Think you could please tell me (us)?
@@Gr3nthCan you please inform us on this? If ya want, delete the comment after you say it.
Such a beautiful, powerful song...
This song will always have a place in my heart.. Love it..
Her voice is so beautiful. It really portrays her sadness in this song. I got goosebumps from her voice.
Just...
Beautiful !!!
So beautiful
This song is perfect. It breaks my heart even when it's already broken.
Doesn't it though? This song always hit me like that. I heard it when it came out and had the same meaning then that it does now and still breaks my broken heart. 💔💔
this song is a fossil...
a precious ornament in time.
It will be dug up and dusted off
for some of us though... we are there within the earth
dusting along side it...
I listened to this when i was young :(
+Alliaaa yeah me too and 10 years later i heard again
Now you are old?
this has been one ofmy favourite songs for a while now :)
Ohh thats some good nostalgia
This is my aunt singing..I miss you, autmn..
"Hold me down...fold me in. Deep. Deep. Deep in the heart of your sins. "
Beautiful voice.
Still listening to this in 2020 ... from autumn to ashes is awesome
takes me back to high school
one of my fav songs eva!! its so beautiful!!