And he completely skipped the middle part. Of COURSE he only played the first few bars that every person learning the piano knows by memory, because it's not entertaining enough than suddenly glitching out of existence.
K4z x since it’s not something I can change I decided to enjoy it! To bring joy to the crowd in my last few days! Judges: you are the American talent we need!!!!!
Can we just appreciate how when Brett and Eddy tried to play out of tune with each other, they still played in thirds and sounded 10 times better than the flautists? They couldn’t even bring themselves to play a tone apart.
When I took band my conductor was the same wayyyy ugh. I was a clarinet so it stood out when we took a breath and he would always yell at us to stop breathing😂
Not gonna lie, the social stigma around classical music is one of the reasons I stopped singing. I was a classically trained coloratura soprano and outside of my vocal coach everyone else thought I was the cartoon self-absorbed diva just because of my vocal range.
Never stop being YOU, honey! Looking at the horrendous stupidity and lack of taste in the world, do you really think those people's opinions carry any weight? They are pure reflection of what media brainwashed them to "think". And you singing is a reflection of your SOUL. Now, which one do you think matters more? 😉❤
Smh and *sigh Pls don’t give up on that beautiful voice because of others’ uneducated and WRONG opinions. As you grow up, you might regret ending your potential prematurely If you keep pursuing what you genuinely like, you’ll find yourself surrounded by right kind of people eventually, who knows.
I'm a soprano, and I say don't quit just because everyone else is being a jerk. There are plenty of people who would *love* to hear you sing with such a range. I sing on my church's worship team, and people have told me they love my voice. And my church is one that typically plays Christian Contemporary Music for worship!
People on AGT either: 1) Have a sad backstory (mediocre talent/skill) 2) Look crazy but is acutally good 3) A kid 4) Subvert the expectation (Ex: The piano player) 5) "Ooh im so shy uwu~" *_Sings/Plays with extreme confidence_*
as a BEGINNER flautist i dont even manhandle my flute like that. its my baby and i have protected it. my flute is from the early 00s, its a school one that was specifically lent to me and in no circumstances would i want to break my flute like that.
Same here I started like 3-4 months ago and the way he took the flute and he said he played the flute even as a beginner we know that’s not how you hold a flute and they’re were children in that crowd I would be traumatized by that for life if I saw that as a younger kid
I am an advanced flautist I’ve been playing for 9 years in 2023 and I was disgusted at how the guy held his flute played to notes how out of tune it was actually hurt me 😭
I'm a Pianist and the dude who kicked the stool made me slam my hand on my desk you NEVER EVER disrespect the stool okay, that dude took it to far and made me stop watching America's Got Talent edit: wow I got this many likes for the first time thank you guys for agreeing as well
@@triffus Kicking a stool like that can cause damage and it can weaken the wood and the stool can become damaged and unusable over time. I would never disrespect an instrument like that no matter if it’s a seat.
Omg! Well I guess congrats to her, for managing that. All the "performances" in this video were sacrilegious on a level that was unimaginable before...this....
Thelaretus that’s also true for any style of music. If you buy a deep purple best of record then you don’t need another one. Same for the Beatles, Michael Jackson etc. (Of course il not talking about the ones that have only one hit and we’re then sent into oblivion)
as a pianist whos been playing from a young age, this hurt to watch. it felt like torture watching an instrument being disrespected. my heart was sore watching this. he could've easily just danced on his own.
I agree man. It's not nice to disrespect something like that, especially when you're not just disrespecting *a* person, but disrespecting an entire genre of music, along with pretty much everyone who plays it or participates in it. Maybe that's a little too much, but it definitely felt like they're trying to make the entire classical genre seem boring at the very least, and that's already enough to anger more than just a few people.
I'm not a flutist, bit I feel like even those who play for 2 months could carry a tune, if not professionally enough. But I want to know what you think.
They give em a sheet that is a tone oft and then they play the wrong track over it so it sounds shit. Its just a show. He probably isnt even a proper musician
My review as a flautist: 1. His tuning is horrendous 2. He needs to start on a B natural for this piece, not an A flat. 3. Most of the notes are wrong. 4. He’s breathing in the wrong spots. 5. In this song, the upper register is played first. 6. He’s holding his flute at a terrible angle 7. HE DOESNT EVEN HAVE HIS FINGERS IN THE RIGHT POSITION I need Ling Ling Insurance 🙏
Ella: Alex, look! This is our teacher! Alex: *watches video* 😲😲🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 what is wrong with him!!! *Video spreads around the whole school* *Teacher is called to the office* Principal: I’m sorry, Mr. (idk), but you are a terrible influence on our students. You must be fired In the end, the teacher didn’t win AGT or keep his job. Sighhhhhhh
Reasons not to watch AGT: -scripting fake scenes -contracts that hurt contestants -committing sacrilege towards the arts -portraying things in immensely biased ways
@@Fikamar27 They make you do whatever they want you to do to make the show interesting (even humiliating you), and you cannot do anything about it. Basically, they have almost complete control over their contestants.
Maybe the audience was actually woke and was yawning because he was playing Für Elise and just the first page as well like every beginner pianist plays that
I think it was just creative editing; these "reality" shows will do that, put in a shot of something that actually happened at some other time in the production, to influence how you think about that particular scene.
@@guccideltaco it most definitely is. There have also been times in the show where they place someone in the audience with a microphone just to say certain things to make viewers laugh or feel a certain way about performers.
As a pianist, für Elise is one of the simplest piece that I have played, it just sound hard but easy. When that pianist was about to start his music, it was La campanella, a very hard piece so I was surprised. It just shame me when people don’t respect classical music, if you don’t respect it, then don’t play it, it’s shameless, not famous.
Hey guys, I've been to a live episode of AGT before and I wanna let you know that the audience reaction is totally fake. In fact, before the show even started, they pre recorded all of us making various fake reactions to things. They would say "ok now look surprised" "Okay, now clap". So everything you're mad at in this video could just be all the editor's fault and none of it actually happened how it looks like it happened.
@@roryreviewer6598 How can you get the people's reactions and the judges reactions when they show both at the same time. There is no way they could record them separately. I don't think any amount of editing will be able to do that.
8:01 I cake back to watch this after our school had a talent show. Two students played classical piano, and I remember the crowed was cheering at the top of their lungs. They got elected to the finals (so did I) but the crowd (mostly made up of friends and family of the contestants) had to vote. So it wasn't the fairest wins for some of us. But I loved the classical music appreciation.
I’m a flautist And this is absolutely horrendous. It’s not even multiple pitches, the flute isn’t even tuned and his breaths are so noticeable which Is not suppose to happen.
Betty-Alexandria Pride i remember my teacher telling getting mad because of my flute angle lmao my posture was good but my flute would tend to droop by the end of playing lmao
I’m so relieved I stopped caring about AGT. When talented musicians and comedians were being sent home instead of acts whose whole shtick is kicking guys’ balls, I was done.
Same. Here in my country I used to be bonkers about my local Got Talent but as time progressed,kids with sad backstories started to win,people not from our country started to come and I eventually quit watching and I'm glad for that.
Or maybe America's Got Talent is so off in judging talent, they won't even recognize Ling Ling and think he's just another classical music dude because he's actually playing the instrument. _sad violin, piano, cello, viola, piccolo, you get the point, noises_
Why do I feel like there's something grammatically wrong with this sentence but can't find what it is! Or it really is a legitimate but complex sentence.
You guys are so right about everything being scripted, zooming in on audience members, who happen to have a microphone near enough to them to pick up what they're saying at just the right moment. Also, what about the very bad acts? You know they know about them ahead of time. There are auditions beforehand.
The reactions to that pianist dancer guy made me so mad. People have such short attention spans that they think any classical music is boring. The judges fall asleep to someone playing classical music well, then give a golden buzzer to the people who go up and play michael jackson with horrible technique.
I heard some where else that they typically film the reactions prior to the actual performances (that's why the audience behind the judges are quiet when the audio is playing cheering/standing ovations), so it's possible that the audience weren't actually yawning during the boRing cLasSicAL parts, but the reactions were all just prerecorded ones.
I'm pretty sure this one guy didn't yawn because of classical music. He just did it sometimes (most probably not even related to the performance) and they just thought it would be perfect material to put in there to show how booooring classical music is 🙄
My school stopped calling the talent shows talents shows, and started calling them variety shows probably because they realized none of the school has talent. America’s got variety.
Contestant 1 : plays beautiful music no one has ever heard Judges: "meh" Contestant 2 : plays for three seconds by hitting a battery with a bowie knife Judges: "that's terrib..." Contestant 2 : "I have cancer" Judges: "YOU WIN!"
I was born into a loving family but then the hospital burned down 5 seconds after I was born and my family died, so I ended up in a corrupt orphanage where I got cancer and When I was 3 I was stolen by kidnappers and taken to Mexico where I worked in a sweatshop, and I was there until I was 7 when I found a guitar one day so I practiced the guitar every day after my 20 hour shift in the sweatshops and I've been doing that for the past 6 years. I finally got enough money to buy my freedom out of the sweatshop where I came here to America's got talent to put my guitar skills out into the world. If just one person is inspired by this my life dream will be complete.
I got so freaking triggered when he kicked the stool. How can you not think of how the paint will chip or how something could break of completely?! Would an artist rip up the masterpiece?! No!!! Because to them it’s art! The whole piano is art to a pianist! The keys, the bench, all of it! Dear freaking Jesus
im a beginner flutist, so here’s my opinion on the first guy: • why is he holding it like that, just hold it up, it’s not that hard • he’s breathing in all the wrong places (and he’s making it very obvious) • there was no need to strip, he just needed to find some way to “save” his performance • *TUNE. YOUR. FLUTE.* • my dude didn’t even play his Bb scale correctly • when the two of them started playing together... *my ears bled out* • if this guy is your teacher (as he stated in the beginning) get a new teacher.
Neo LPSTM Not a flutist here, here’s my opinion: Idk abt technical skill but anyone who had basic knowledge abt instruments and has been around then can tell THAT DUDE IS WAYYYY OUT OD TUNE. MY EARS ARE BLEEDING. I agree, if this guy is your teacher, find a new one
@Gabriel Garcia there are some highly paid good musicians out there that like to nicely flaunt a bit and get away with it , but this show should be taken off the air , the smutty English comedy shows of the 60s,70s have been - I always looked forward to the Liberace show in those days , the Black and White minstrel show was a favorite too.
I can feel you guys. I hate when they fake talent and the important one "strip ". I don't have that type of talent so I appreciate them like how I understand music. Yes, classical music is not everyone's type but it doesn’t mean they can capture an exact person that suddenly yawns each time it is about classical music.
OMG I AM A FLAUTIST AND I AM OFFENDED BY THAT FIRST DUDE EEEEEEHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH Also he was playing an alto flute which is in G, a normal flute is in C, which is why they were a tone out
I just hate it when someone starts to discriminate classical music, or any genre of music. Like dude, aren't you educated enough to respect people who trained for years to master their instrument or that kind of genre?
@@Guitarhurtsmyfingers it made me feel sad idk like all i do is useless cause i play piano 1h per day to get better and ive been playing piano for 5years and just seeing this video made me FEEL LIKE A SHIT YES
I agree with everything you guys said man. The other day I had my final music performance at school and I decided to play something from Schickhardt (on the recorder) with my ensemble and afterwards I heard (at least) the whole front row was laughing and looking away… Terrible… That caused the presenter to say “thanks for the sportive reaction”. Most of them were old classmates… (But in my language, I don’t know if this was correct english lol.)
@@totallymeta3654 that seems too much on a coincidence that you would bring a flute just for that small chance that u might play with the other flutist. it wouldnt make sense for him to do so
I’ve auditioned for AGT twice once around the second or third season and the last time was in 2019 and they didn’t send anyone from the grouping I was in and there was very talented people there. It 100% is exclusively about what will get them the most views and not if the people competing have talent or not.
"you breathe when the phrase has ended" my middle school band teacher: "DON'T BREATHE AT THE END OF A PHRASE OR ON A BAR LINe, breathe during the whole notes." my current band director:" DON'T BREATHE. YOURE A FLUTE ITS TOO NOTICEABLE"
It’s because when your’e a soloist you are more likely to be noticed when you breathe, when you are in a band there are other people playing during the whole note so it’s not as noticeable.
As a pianist, those stools cost a LOT, especially if you get a really good one. Anyone sane individual would not kick a piano stool. I really don't think that dude was sane
@@anastasiawasylinko5482 For reference for folks who don't know piano levels/use a different system, Fur Elise is one of the earliest pieces you learn on piano after your scales and simplified folk tunes like Scarborough Fair. So. Not terribly impressive.
My review as a pianist: 1. His piano is dramatized and obviously has no love for the instrument 2. He wants to put on a good show which is completely understandable, however, the PIANO DIDNT DO ANYTHING FLIPPIN WRONG 3. He most likely doesnt play the paino because if you look up fur elise on youtube, and play the two side by side, they sound the same. I love you two set. Plz make sure pianos lives matters: PLM
First he portrayed classical music as having nothing but one boring phrase from Fur Elise, then he does this strange robot dancing.... I experienced left lung failure after that.
He started young as a pianist and still plays Fur Elise on a talent show.... I mean if he was actually a musician he should actually show off his talent and play Liszt or something but eh. Maybe the director told him to play Fur Elise to emphasize how “boring” classical music is and it really pissed me off. Man if I ever hear Fur Elise or Canon in D on a talent show I am going to cringe to deathhh
I understand english is a little difficult if you are not from U.S.A or other country that speak English even for me is difficult so to write flautist instead of flutist is just normal 👌🙂
Really loved you guys for stressing at that classical music point as I have felt the pain myself I really love classical music but whenever you perform it people consider it boring but once you start doing the boom boom even though a musician would find it out of tune still others will love it
The sad part is that italian guy seemed like he was genuinely a good pianist and probably has a lot of talent in piano but he would never win the show playing classical music on its own
I had been scrolling to look for a comment like this. She is far from irrelevant and is one of many who have helped to bridge classical music to pop and and alternative music.
As a person who went to a filming of "Americas got talent" I can say it was the worst thing I've ever experienced. The audience is literally actors. You'll get maybe two acts and then the rest of the day is just filming audience reactions. Literally about 8 hours of nothing happening. Then they try to get the audience to compete for prizes by seeing who can cheer the loudest (for the take obviously). The thing is they'll never give the prize to anyone who actually wanted one (because once they get the prize what would be the incentive for the said audience member). The worst thing is they don't even hire an audience, but trick families into coming believing it was more of a show and less of a TV set filming. They basically force the "actors" to pay to be there. Worst thing ever. Edit: for anyone wondering, I actually found the clip of the showing that I went too. ua-cam.com/video/M4si8EbMMys/v-deo.html Now it was nowhere near as exciting as it was shown here. It was literally them telling us to make scared faces, then cheer when he hit the ground and that was it. Then the judges went inside and it was literally them having us " compete to see who could cheer the loudest" Some kids were cheering so loud we were losing our voice, including me. Once I even locked eyes with the "DJ" and he shook his head and pointed to the camera (gesturing for me to look) this happened about 3 times before my Dad noticed and he was pissed. He eventually had us get up and leave. He told the DJ off as we left but I don't remember what he said. Ended up going to a buffet to make it up. TL;DR: went to a filming of AGT. Got to see one act, then was bribed too scream on camera. AGT are scum who trick families into being up paid actors for an audience. Edit #2: Forgot to mention it was like 90° F out there, so yeah...around 8 hours in that kind of hear screaming. Edit: #3 damn guys thanks for the support!
@@AA-ok9uw I fucking hated it...fuck them and fuck everything about them. And definitely fuck the guy I charge of getting the crowd to cheer. Literally looked at kids who were cheering so loud that they were turning beat red in the eyes and told them they weren't screaming loud enough to get a prize, just because he knew these kids would keep screaming for the camera if he just dangled a cool toy in front of them.
I got bored with reality TV shows like this one during American Idol. It was the same schtick every episode...I told my friends the reactions were fake and the show is bullshit. You just proved what my 16 year old butt could not so many years ago...AUGHOSIOWIENROIHEPIAURHISEUNIUTHASTUGSD!
I have always hated those """"""reality"""""" TV shows. They have nothing realistic in them, it is incredibly fake. It's like the XVIII th century "naturalism" (I know that now the term is connoted with the XIX th century movement, although it suffers from the same problem, I just think that the one from the XVIII th was more egregious), it is just a vain attempt to captivate audience by giving them the illusion of reality, something that you've created from A to Z. There is nothing real about it, it is just an illusion, an allure
I went to an America's Got Talent taping once. Before ANY of the acts audition in front of the audience, the production comes out and tells the audience: standing ovation on 1, 2, 3. now, everybody look up and look surprised/scared. Now, act bored. Then they pick some audience members for the close-up shots of people yawning, laughing, etc. (without anybody on stage.) They do the same with judge dramatic reactions. THEN, the auditions begin and you find out why you were looking up scared/surprised... there's an act with a guy doing aerial stuff. I left after the second audition.
“I’m a teacher”
*Proceeds to strip on stage*
That explains alot
what an idiot.☺
He might not be one after that.
Never send my kids there
Not anymore
Two Set in Last Video: *We are not a roasting channel*
This Video: *ROAST TIME!!!*
Can't blame them, really. lol
Roasts are born, not created
no they just *REVIEW*
I was literally going to post this! 😂💕
They even made an intro for these roast videos😂
"I'm a professional classical pianist"
*starts playing grade 4 piece*
Eli Gibbons inniiiiiittt I was like “what is this. I played this when I was, like, 10. Whyyyyyyyyyy”
For a second there I thought you meant grade 4 for AMEB, but then I remembers that literally everyone is American these days
@@pumpkinhead3356 I'm actually from the UK, so I meant ABRSM. Don't assume my nationality, fool.
MangoCat we mean ABRSM from the uk hun
And he completely skipped the middle part. Of COURSE he only played the first few bars that every person learning the piano knows by memory, because it's not entertaining enough than suddenly glitching out of existence.
as a flutist i can 100% say that this man probably never played flute in his entire life
as a flutist i shed genuine tears looking at that guy
As a metal enjoyer an guitar player(beginer) i agree
same though how did he even get his flute to sound so out of tune like theyre not very high maintenance 💀
even if I don't know how to play flute, I can tell he played like sh!t
I agree, and I've only played the flute for a school project for one year in sixth grade-
Ling Ling: practices 40 hours a day
Judges: Ok?
Random person: My great grandpa died in 1937
Judges: *GOLDEN BUZZER*
John Tyler’s grandsons: our great-grandfather died in 1813
Nicolas Schellberg not interesting enough. You could have said he died in 1939
12:05 ok this is going to be interesting
12:26 umm
13:12 by sis I'm out
K4z x since it’s not something I can change I decided to enjoy it! To bring joy to the crowd in my last few days!
Judges: you are the American talent we need!!!!!
🤣1937 hahahahahaha
They should get an orchestra on America's got talent and have them play Tchaikovsky 1812 and aim the cannon at the judges
Madbanana //M.B. Specifically at Simon
Lmao
Madbanana //M.B. Yesssss
Yes great sugestion my friend
I’d volunteer
My review as a flautist: No.
My review as an erotic dancer: Also, no.
Which makes more money???
Andrei Ruizo 😂
@@andreiruizo3050 obvious hah
Exotic*
Lol
Can we just appreciate how when Brett and Eddy tried to play out of tune with each other, they still played in thirds and sounded 10 times better than the flautists? They couldn’t even bring themselves to play a tone apart.
That’s why they said playing out of tune is also a tAlEnT.
@@855188artists are not made, theyre born😔
Ikrrrrrrr
Not to mention Eddy has perfect pitch.
@ShaunakDesaiPiano they also have ReAl TaLeNt.
"I played the flute from a young age" hands are in the wrong position and it's out of tune
AHH NO NOW THERES TWO OF THEM!!!
Me and my friend are now watching this during our academic day in band and we both just sat here and roasted the flute player =3=
That’s probably why. He didn’t learn well 😆
He breathed a lot and he didn’t tune correctly he was just playing random notes.
Also he played like half a song so what was his talent?
Imagine watching America’s got talent and you see your teacher stripping *RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOUR EYES*
I bet he lost his job
Wouldn't be so bad if she was a bad one.
female teachers get fired for less.
What if you have a hotass teacher in her mid 20. Whould your eyes still burn, guys?
@@Only_gainz_official yea coz I'm gay
I'm sorry but :
Them: The whole point is to hide the breathing.
My conductor: Your whole point is to STOP BREATHING
*flashbacks of having to hold a high c for 45 seconds straight or else*
Circular Breathing
singing in choir be like:
Me: when are we suposed to breathe
director: *YESTERDAY*
@@lovelyunknown lol
When I took band my conductor was the same wayyyy ugh. I was a clarinet so it stood out when we took a breath and he would always yell at us to stop breathing😂
Not gonna lie, the social stigma around classical music is one of the reasons I stopped singing. I was a classically trained coloratura soprano and outside of my vocal coach everyone else thought I was the cartoon self-absorbed diva just because of my vocal range.
Never stop being YOU, honey! Looking at the horrendous stupidity and lack of taste in the world, do you really think those people's opinions carry any weight? They are pure reflection of what media brainwashed them to "think". And you singing is a reflection of your SOUL. Now, which one do you think matters more? 😉❤
My voice lacks the elasticity to sing so even though I’m not interested in singing I am still somewhat jealous. Don’t waste that skill and practise
People loooooove coloratura but they just don't realize it. Big movies always got one, game trailers as well. People live for that.
Smh and *sigh
Pls don’t give up on that beautiful voice because of others’ uneducated and WRONG opinions.
As you grow up, you might regret ending your potential prematurely
If you keep pursuing what you genuinely like, you’ll find yourself surrounded by right kind of people eventually, who knows.
I'm a soprano, and I say don't quit just because everyone else is being a jerk. There are plenty of people who would *love* to hear you sing with such a range. I sing on my church's worship team, and people have told me they love my voice. And my church is one that typically plays Christian Contemporary Music for worship!
Imagine how his students felt watching him....
Don't think he has any
He only teaches stripin
hot for teacher ;) also more realistically petrified from second hand embarrassment
Let's hope the students are as fictional as his flute-playing
He’s probably not really a flutist
People on AGT either:
1) Have a sad backstory (mediocre talent/skill)
2) Look crazy but is acutally good
3) A kid
4) Subvert the expectation (Ex: The piano player)
5) "Ooh im so shy uwu~" *_Sings/Plays with extreme confidence_*
HB FS well there sre some with real talent already
Do I see my precious Pearlie in your Profile Pic? :3
@@zakariamebrahtu1474
Yep 👌🏽
Accurate 😂😂💯
so true(nice profile pic btw. uwu)
i just hugged my flute because i was so horrified
edit: she's okay tho
hurricane tortilla, thank god.
Emboushure(me flute) is still recovering
@@pranavyarlagadda2143My flutes name is Freya ☺️
Annabeth Chase And my piccolos name is the sharp bastrd
@@pranavyarlagadda2143 Lol love that name
as a BEGINNER flautist i dont even manhandle my flute like that. its my baby and i have protected it. my flute is from the early 00s, its a school one that was specifically lent to me and in no circumstances would i want to break my flute like that.
Same here I started like 3-4 months ago and the way he took the flute and he said he played the flute even as a beginner we know that’s not how you hold a flute and they’re were children in that crowd I would be traumatized by that for life if I saw that as a younger kid
I am an advanced flautist I’ve been playing for 9 years in 2023 and I was disgusted at how the guy held his flute played to notes how out of tune it was actually hurt me 😭
We must treat our instruments like **babies! 😤
flute for 3 years and even i cringed at this bro it hurt me on the inside and i’m relatively new 💀💀💀
@@norazees I’m not even a flutist and that hurt ME
“I’m a classical pianist”
*Proceeds to play pop music and strip dance on stage*
He actually didn't play pop music on the piano it's just the track for his dance
Chris朱某人 *yawn*
Für elise is classical lol
Entertainment is shit tier rn lol
Well he didn't strip
*looks at this dude pole dancing with a flute* ....*gets flute and hugs it* it's ok.....ill never do such a thing
me tho
Gazelle di animal
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT TOO A FLUTE.
My piccolo shrunk form watching that
My flute is safe with my piano upstairs, they protect each other.
I have now tuned my flute and hugging it
When you're a flautist yourself.
1) His angle is horrid.
2) His tuning is non-existent.
3)His technique and playing is jsjskdkkdkdkd.
Simply Alana22 I couldn’t relate to you more 🤮
When you’re a flautist yourself and still say flutist *gasp*
@@hannahking9004 That's sort of rude, sorry for being grammatically incorrect.
Feel like the only boy in the world that plays flute aha
eXACTLYNZSNJS
I'm a Pianist and the dude who kicked the stool made me slam my hand on my desk you NEVER EVER disrespect the stool okay, that dude took it to far and made me stop watching America's Got Talent
edit: wow I got this many likes for the first time thank you guys for agreeing as well
NOT THE STOOL!!!!!😱😱😱😱😱😱
lol, who cares?
YOU NEVER,NEVER EVER EVER DISRESPECT THE PIANO
that made my soul cry- 😭😭😭
@@triffus Kicking a stool like that can cause damage and it can weaken the wood and the stool can become damaged and unusable over time. I would never disrespect an instrument like that no matter if it’s a seat.
@@triffus WE care.
Can we just agree, that everyone, even non-musicians, absolutely CrInGeD at the first guy
100%
I cringed out loud to all of them. Like WTF?!
Aye
I ve to skip the stripping part, cuz, like... he was stripping, on stage while performing an instrument.
I have 0 musical prowess, and every one of these made me want to die.
Me watching America's got talent: Hey mom look! Its my flute teacher!
mom:..
mom: how about learning the guitar?
Golbarg Ranjbar hahahahahaha
Guitar is better any way
Jk
@Isaac Flores I play classical lol
lmao
I really hope he isn't your teacher anymore
My 15 year old sister plays flute. She was given less than 24 hours to prepare a pice for church today and she still played better than this guy
Your poor sister...
Omg! Well I guess congrats to her, for managing that. All the "performances" in this video were sacrilegious on a level that was unimaginable before...this....
Flutes in church pogchamp
I'm so glad you didn't say she danced better than him!
Does that mean she played... not so good?
7:05 Simon probably didn't groan because it was classical music, but because he knew the guy was going to surprise-strip to pop music
Imagine how traumatised the first dudes students are
Hiruni goonasekera kids watching omg
Hiruni goonasekera IKR!!! Also I love your profile picture 💜💜💜
Probably isn't even a teacher
What students? I’d like to see a school that keeps him lol
the parents will be like :
I told you piano was better but you wanted flute!
Note that, despite the heat, Brett and Eddy keep their clothes on. Thanks for keeping it classy, guys.
Exactly! Keep it classy.
But we see only one part of their bodies...
probably because it's under 10 celcius in australia everday right now, middle of winter.
But it’s winter in Australian rn.....
Because it’s fuckin freezing rn in Australia lmao
You know it's sacrilegious when you can hear it's out of tune and you're not even a classical music student 🤒🤕
i dont know shit about music but i can very much agree that definitely does not sound right
I dont study music but i found out i have perfect pitch so....yeaaaa
Thelaretus that’s also true for any style of music. If you buy a deep purple best of record then you don’t need another one. Same for the Beatles, Michael Jackson etc. (Of course il not talking about the ones that have only one hit and we’re then sent into oblivion)
I’m a vocalist and even I noticed that it was out of tune.
Susannah S I don’t play flute(I’m a violinist) and I can still tell it’s out of tune.
as a pianist whos been playing from a young age, this hurt to watch. it felt like torture watching an instrument being disrespected. my heart was sore watching this. he could've easily just danced on his own.
I agree man. It's not nice to disrespect something like that, especially when you're not just disrespecting *a* person, but disrespecting an entire genre of music, along with pretty much everyone who plays it or participates in it. Maybe that's a little too much, but it definitely felt like they're trying to make the entire classical genre seem boring at the very least, and that's already enough to anger more than just a few people.
I'm a flautist, hi!
And he needs to stop lying about playing the flute since childhood. He plays like someone has played for 2 months.
I'm not a flutist, bit I feel like even those who play for 2 months could carry a tune, if not professionally enough. But I want to know what you think.
Not even, lmfao
Plot twist: He is a stripper, who also plays a flute. Badly.
2 months? More like 2 weeks…
@@aishutoon4553 more like 2 seconds as someone whos been playing flute i did better on my first lesson than these idiots did in their whole life
As a flute player, the first guy made me want to cry
putting the flute on the ground was esp horrible to me
They give em a sheet that is a tone oft and then they play the wrong track over it so it sounds shit. Its just a show. He probably isnt even a proper musician
I DID CRY
Even a beginner double reed player is more in tune lol
I play flute and piano so both made me cry
Seeing all those instruments being so mistreatead while i'm a guy who can't even afford a good keyboard is really painful
@@iba0232 omg so true. I end up having to go to Costco to use their displaying piano :(
Lê Bảo Ngọc Oh,I can relate. I have to use my school’s violins.
You can't say that. He probably treats his flute with more romantic diners than you treat your sweethearts.
Omg! Ikr?
I can feel that
As both a flautist and a pianist, I’m sufficiently traumatized for this life and the next. Please help me
As a flutist and a pianist, me too girl me too...
My review as a flautist:
1. His tuning is horrendous
2. He needs to start on a B natural for this piece, not an A flat.
3. Most of the notes are wrong.
4. He’s breathing in the wrong spots.
5. In this song, the upper register is played first.
6. He’s holding his flute at a terrible angle
7. HE DOESNT EVEN HAVE HIS FINGERS IN THE RIGHT POSITION
I need Ling Ling Insurance 🙏
yea the breathing is horrible like take one music leason and you will learn when to breath but yea i am just a euphonium player what do i know
Someone get the chinese kid to help
Yet he said that he was a teacher..
Not even mentioning he's using a G flute instead of a C flute...
I agree with your review but you discredit yourself when you refer to an instrumental piece as a "song" 👌 I'm just being pedantic 😅
Moral of the story:
If you can’t play in tune, become a stripper
Wh-
yepz ... maybe that's a good idea ....
thanks ;)
omg yes
Wait I think ur onto smth-
Does that count for singers too?
Contestant: plays instrument
Judges: Sit quietly and don't comment
Contestant: Takes off shirt
Judges: HOoOoO WoAoAoH
Ella: Alex, look! This is our teacher!
Alex: *watches video* 😲😲🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 what is wrong with him!!!
*Video spreads around the whole school*
*Teacher is called to the office*
Principal: I’m sorry, Mr. (idk), but you are a terrible influence on our students. You must be fired
In the end, the teacher didn’t win AGT or keep his job. Sighhhhhhh
Just imagine a mum telling their kid, “oh look let’s go watch this flute act, I’m sure you’ll love it!”
Then they go watch it.
Poor child is probably traumatized by now 😅
@Meli-Meliai the mum might also be traumatised
Reasons not to watch AGT:
-scripting fake scenes
-contracts that hurt contestants
-committing sacrilege towards the arts
-portraying things in immensely biased ways
Emerson Yu -story and shock value over actual talent
just wondering, what contracts?
@@Fikamar27 They make you do whatever they want you to do to make the show interesting (even humiliating you), and you cannot do anything about it. Basically, they have almost complete control over their contestants.
You forgot to add cutting out contestants, their scenes, or sometimes cutting the scenes so they look more dramatic/funny/sad etc.
They want you to fail cry and make a fool out of yourself just so they could get more views
The roasting of violin in the beginning somehow makes me really REALLY hungry.
*I N T E R E S T I N G*
Yummy 🤤
Nah we only burn ViOlas
Mmmm nicely tosted wood with that tasy lacquer sauce😋
/r/ForbiddenSnacks
new name: America's Got Strippers
LMAO
OMG 😂😂
Bruh-
Lol
It should be America's Talented Strippers
as a pianist,
god help me with that 2nd guy, i f*cking can't-
Maybe the audience was actually woke and was yawning because he was playing Für Elise
and just the first page as well
like every beginner pianist plays that
I think it was just creative editing; these "reality" shows will do that, put in a shot of something that actually happened at some other time in the production, to influence how you think about that particular scene.
That's what I think as well. Could even be a pre recorded reaction before the show even started. They did that to us when I was at a live AGT show.
@@guccideltaco it most definitely is. There have also been times in the show where they place someone in the audience with a microphone just to say certain things to make viewers laugh or feel a certain way about performers.
Honestly that piece is the EASIESt piece ever
thats what i thought at first
Strips down to my undies in my recital because I played my piccolo slightly out of tune
Haha
Big yikes. If every musician had to strip hen they messed up there would not be a strip free concert or recital.
So his talent is stripping
It's called the piccolo panic
Havoc THE PICCOLO PANIC 😂
That moment when people only play the first page of Für Elise because it gets much harder as it goes...
A whole page? You're giving them too much credit
More like the first few measures. Repeatedly.
What about Moonlight Sonata 🤣
I mean... I can play exactly the first the page and not a single measure after that, but I’m also not a pianist.
I can only play the first page too because I only know how to play the middle-ish hard notes.
As a pianist, für Elise is one of the simplest piece that I have played, it just sound hard but easy. When that pianist was about to start his music, it was La campanella, a very hard piece so I was surprised. It just shame me when people don’t respect classical music, if you don’t respect it, then don’t play it, it’s shameless, not famous.
I used to respect Simon years ago but then I realized he was jsut as much actor as everyone else in the room
Damn I was just thinking the same thing
Honestly.
Who is Simon?
The judge with the gray hair
He always wears a white shirt and jeans
Hey guys, I've been to a live episode of AGT before and I wanna let you know that the audience reaction is totally fake. In fact, before the show even started, they pre recorded all of us making various fake reactions to things. They would say "ok now look surprised" "Okay, now clap". So everything you're mad at in this video could just be all the editor's fault and none of it actually happened how it looks like it happened.
Too bad to hear that despite I knew paid audiences are exist :(
Well, I wish I got paid lol
That's impossible on so many levels
What's impossible?
@@roryreviewer6598 How can you get the people's reactions and the judges reactions when they show both at the same time. There is no way they could record them separately. I don't think any amount of editing will be able to do that.
8:01 I cake back to watch this after our school had a talent show. Two students played classical piano, and I remember the crowed was cheering at the top of their lungs. They got elected to the finals (so did I) but the crowd (mostly made up of friends and family of the contestants) had to vote. So it wasn't the fairest wins for some of us. But I loved the classical music appreciation.
My dad casually walked by while the dude was stripping and he just walked away, shaking his head, in dissapointment.
Wow
Cute budgie ❤️
That's rough buddy
F
LOL kkkkkk
I’m a flautist
And this is absolutely horrendous. It’s not even multiple pitches, the flute isn’t even tuned and his breaths are so noticeable which Is not suppose to happen.
Which piece is he playing
@@ijustlovefoodtbh25 In german its "Morgenstimmung" by Edvard Grieg
im sure u can find it with that
I know a 16 year old flautist who's way better than him
Sandra Helena Broas yourself?
I think it was flourist, just has a weird accent.
I can't even afford such a good piano stool. That kick hurt...
Konrad Jędruszek same
Same I have a broken one that can't adjust so I have to sit on books to make it high enough
@@noelle9853 I have a dining room chair that I put pillows on.
My dad just recently fixed my piano stool so the lid doesn't come off again, so yeah, that kick hurt
Konrad Jędruszek are you prodigy??? Stool? You must be a 9 year old prodigy playing the well tempered clavier already!!! Good for you
The stool kick was absolute pain for me and prolly for other pianist too 😭😭😭
I’m not a pianists but I know that’s not how you treat a piano
You always gotta respect your equipment, regardless of what instrument you play
as a beginner guitarist the stool kick wants me to break my classical guitar to buy a les paul and a grand piano all together
Even though I haven't played the piano in 6-7 years it made me cringe so hard.
A teacher kicked the piano stool at a pep rally at my school, and the worst part was that almost everyone cheered when he did that 😬
Any flute teacher would HATE this guy, whenever I saw him play I got flashbacks of my teacher screaming FLUTE ANGLE!!
same
I don't remember my flute teacher saying "flute angle"...
but "P O S T U R E" was a thing. 😅
Betty-Alexandria Pride i remember my teacher telling getting mad because of my flute angle lmao my posture was good but my flute would tend to droop by the end of playing lmao
Mr. Sunshine My music teacher literally gets destroyed, he basically gets bullied. Depressing, really.
Tyrancc Mine bullies her students😪 okay maybe not bully but you get me
“I played the flute from a young age.” Yeah he probably quit and started it again for this show.
It’s an alto flute
i believe they gave him a flute and told him how to play, made him go onto the stage then strip
I’m so relieved I stopped caring about AGT. When talented musicians and comedians were being sent home instead of acts whose whole shtick is kicking guys’ balls, I was done.
What, you mean you don't appreciate the creative genius of "OW! MY BALLS!"?
@@fritzthelibrarygoblin *yesn't*
Yep.
Same. Here in my country I used to be bonkers about my local Got Talent but as time progressed,kids with sad backstories started to win,people not from our country started to come and I eventually quit watching and I'm glad for that.
absolutley.
Thank you for sticking up for the flute!!! It's so much work trying to keep the breaths quiet. Love you guys and your roasts.
The music agt discriminates against:
1. Classical
2. Heavy metal
you know what sucks? When those two are your favorite.
@@garbiiiiij big oof 😂😂😂😭
why heavymetal?
When those are my only favorites😂
‘Cos peasants only understand pop music
“I played the flute from a young age.”
Well, folks, there you have it, the least improved flute player in history...
Either he sucked so bad his teacher quit or he rlly didn’t practice
sO TRUE
Somehow you missed it was a part of his act. He was lying, as a joke.
The guys just complimenting himself, “Oh yeah I’m young, I was young two weeks ago too!”
Flute gang spitting straight facts
First the Guinness Book of World Records. Now AGT.
Twoset ridding the world of evil one institution at a time.
Meleeneh Hairapetian who’s next I wonder
i actually didnt realize just how awful these talent shows are until now- its over sexualized
As a pianinst I feel violated by the way the second guy kicked the piano stool.
If Ling Ling goes on America's Got talent , he doesn't get judged.
He judge the Judges.
premium garbage and everyone gets a X!
damn smh i like username 😅
Or maybe America's Got Talent is so off in judging talent, they won't even recognize Ling Ling and think he's just another classical music dude because he's actually playing the instrument.
_sad violin, piano, cello, viola, piccolo, you get the point, noises_
Ling Ling would get an standing ovation playing Brahms' Lullaby and dressed as Bad Luck Brian.
The issue is that their portraying classical musical as no longer being a relevant valid form of art, I think is what your trying to say.
that linux guy sums it up nicely
Thanks to populism
Why do I feel like there's something grammatically wrong with this sentence but can't find what it is! Or it really is a legitimate but complex sentence.
@@kuro758 Yea there should be a comma between the words relevant and valid.
@@thatlinuxguyAlso they're and you're, but you encapsulated the problem with the show very nicely.
As a pianist, I feel a sudden urge to go pick up the poor bench and put it back and give it a hug
Yingying Luo same, but as a former pianist. Bench rights friend.
Im not a pianist and i want to do the same, and punch the guy.
same...like piano stools that are good quality cost quite a bit, and someone made that. please no. stop. get help.
Absolutely.poor chair.
I've never even touched a piano but I wanna do it as well
You guys are so right about everything being scripted, zooming in on audience members, who happen to have a microphone near enough to them to pick up what they're saying at just the right moment. Also, what about the very bad acts? You know they know about them ahead of time. There are auditions beforehand.
The reactions to that pianist dancer guy made me so mad. People have such short attention spans that they think any classical music is boring. The judges fall asleep to someone playing classical music well, then give a golden buzzer to the people who go up and play michael jackson with horrible technique.
I heard some where else that they typically film the reactions prior to the actual performances (that's why the audience behind the judges are quiet when the audio is playing cheering/standing ovations), so it's possible that the audience weren't actually yawning during the boRing cLasSicAL parts, but the reactions were all just prerecorded ones.
like someone else said, the reactions are probably planned, but even knowing that, it annoys me that they put classical music as boring.
I feel you
They actually screened something extremely imapropriate and disrespectful as a part of planned commercial. So cringy
Ikr!
I'm pretty sure this one guy didn't yawn because of classical music. He just did it sometimes (most probably not even related to the performance) and they just thought it would be perfect material to put in there to show how booooring classical music is 🙄
My school stopped calling the talent shows talents shows, and started calling them variety shows probably because they realized none of the school has talent. America’s got variety.
The Fox In Your Backyard: my school makes you try out for it because quite a few people at my school are musical.
Ephemerize the likes are at 222 PLEASE KEEP IT THAT WAY
Lol same
s a m e
@@nic_5226 it didnt stay that way ._.
America’s Got Talent: E X I S T S
Twoset: *I’m going to end this man’s whole career*
Hello I am one of your subscribers :3
Interesting
I play a guzheng, which isn’t even close to the flute, but the first two people made me want to cry from how bad it sounded :’)
Contestant 1 : plays beautiful music no one has ever heard
Judges: "meh"
Contestant 2 : plays for three seconds by hitting a battery with a bowie knife
Judges: "that's terrib..."
Contestant 2 : "I have cancer"
Judges: "YOU WIN!"
Dakota Sherlin truth right here
I’m going to wash my eyeballs now, that first guy was horrifying
wash it good
ikr lmfao
Wash them with bleach
Use tide pods to wash your eyes.
I’m just gonna wash em with holy water
You guys need to remember that America's Got Talent is designed to appeal to an audience that is very, very stupid.
Bahaha best comment 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yeah, I think the rest of the world doesn't understand that these kinds of shows are aimed at trailer trash.
Maybe I don’t remember correctly, but when I was younger I don’t remember agt being this fake.
Well the past ones doesn’t realy appeal audience. At least the winners deserve it
I was born into a loving family but then the hospital burned down 5 seconds after I was born and my family died, so I ended up in a corrupt orphanage where I got cancer and When I was 3 I was stolen by kidnappers and taken to Mexico where I worked in a sweatshop, and I was there until I was 7 when I found a guitar one day so I practiced the guitar every day after my 20 hour shift in the sweatshops and I've been doing that for the past 6 years. I finally got enough money to buy my freedom out of the sweatshop where I came here to America's got talent to put my guitar skills out into the world. If just one person is inspired by this my life dream will be complete.
I got so freaking triggered when he kicked the stool. How can you not think of how the paint will chip or how something could break of completely?! Would an artist rip up the masterpiece?! No!!! Because to them it’s art! The whole piano is art to a pianist! The keys, the bench, all of it! Dear freaking Jesus
I know right! That guy clearly isn't a musician, he's a fako
I feel you.
My heart broke when he kicked the chair
Honestly, it's just a stool. It's not part of the instrument.
@@TimTYT for them it is tho
When that one guy kicked the piano bench my soul screamed in pain.
Same
Ha shame
That bench, i bet was expensive tho, but not anymore after he kicked it >
@@Noblesse_Sapphire pfft you musicians are wayy to soft
@@mythicalyt6509 sorry i don't get it x"3
My English isn't that good, can you explain it? X3
im a beginner flutist, so here’s my opinion on the first guy:
• why is he holding it like that, just hold it up, it’s not that hard
• he’s breathing in all the wrong places (and he’s making it very obvious)
• there was no need to strip, he just needed to find some way to “save” his performance
• *TUNE. YOUR. FLUTE.*
• my dude didn’t even play his Bb scale correctly
• when the two of them started playing together... *my ears bled out*
• if this guy is your teacher (as he stated in the beginning) get a new teacher.
If he were in our marching band... his flute angle would be parallel to the ground and nothing less and nothing more. Perfectly parallel.
Neo LPSTM Not a flutist here, here’s my opinion:
Idk abt technical skill but anyone who had basic knowledge abt instruments and has been around then can tell THAT DUDE IS WAYYYY OUT OD TUNE. MY EARS ARE BLEEDING.
I agree, if this guy is your teacher, find a new one
Copied
When I Heard him, I couldn't believe that he's a teacher (but, idk, I just play the piano)
@Gabriel Garcia there are some highly paid good musicians out there that like to nicely flaunt a bit and get away with it , but this show should be taken off the air , the smutty English comedy shows of the 60s,70s have been - I always looked forward to the Liberace show in those days , the Black and White minstrel show was a favorite too.
I can feel you guys. I hate when they fake talent and the important one "strip ". I don't have that type of talent so I appreciate them like how I understand music. Yes, classical music is not everyone's type but it doesn’t mean they can capture an exact person that suddenly yawns each time it is about classical music.
As a pianist, watching that guy kick the piano stool made me cry and gave me shivers and goosebumps, the SACRILEGE
I can relate
I play games like all day, and imagining myself throwing my chair across the room like a Fortnite gamer makes me scared, too.
The piano abuse gave a concussion
Same! I couldn't watch!
Lucy {Celestial Queen} Heartfilia as a pianist, I agree... the sacrilege!!! I wasn’t impressed...
OMG I AM A FLAUTIST AND I AM OFFENDED BY THAT FIRST DUDE EEEEEEHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Also he was playing an alto flute which is in G, a normal flute is in C, which is why they were a tone out
Serena Sage I feel validated as I guessed it was an alto 🧠🧠
Thank you somebody finally said it!!!😂
How is C and G a tone out? The alto is lower by a 4th
I am personally not a fan of alto flutes without curved headjoints. It's so uncomfortable to have to stretch your arms out so far to reach the keys.
He should at least be competent enough to make up for the tonal differences if it was staged
I just hate it when someone starts to discriminate classical music, or any genre of music. Like dude, aren't you educated enough to respect people who trained for years to master their instrument or that kind of genre?
I'm pretty sure it's intentional.
They want the people to be stupid and ignorant. Easier to control and abuse.
@@sophiaperennis2360 I can never agree more.
yeah like they started playing fur Elise (a classical piece) and the camera pics up an actor freaking yawning. SAcReLiGeOuS.
@@Guitarhurtsmyfingers it made me feel sad idk like all i do is useless cause i play piano 1h per day to get better and ive been playing piano for 5years and just seeing this video made me FEEL LIKE A SHIT YES
@@Guitarhurtsmyfingers pretty sure it was a reused clip from another episode but with a dubbed yawn sound over it. The show is so stupid
I agree with everything you guys said man.
The other day I had my final music performance at school and I decided to play something from Schickhardt (on the recorder) with my ensemble and afterwards I heard (at least) the whole front row was laughing and looking away… Terrible… That caused the presenter to say “thanks for the sportive reaction”. Most of them were old classmates…
(But in my language, I don’t know if this was correct english lol.)
What? You don't think Terry Crews just HAPPENED to have his flute backstage, handy and ready to go? EDIT: Extreme sarcasm
I did not even realise until you pointed it out... :facepalm:
Same.
He might have seen the list of people for that day and one of them was a flutist, sk he brought his flute
@@totallymeta3654 that seems too much on a coincidence that you would bring a flute just for that small chance that u might play with the other flutist. it wouldnt make sense for him to do so
Kevin Chen Perhaps.
Pianist: Plays Fur Elise
Also pianist: turns into a robot
Also also pianist: kicks piano stool
*Beethoven wants to know your location*
also also also pianist: kicks the bucket.. .. .. ..
The teacher took the "not wanting to see your teacher in public" to an entirely different level 😂
Eika May imagine his kids(if he has any)
@@ElectroGaming5 he probably will if the doesn't recognize him cuz he's low-key fine 💀
First Class Experience LOL
I’ve auditioned for AGT twice once around the second or third season and the last time was in 2019 and they didn’t send anyone from the grouping I was in and there was very talented people there. It 100% is exclusively about what will get them the most views and not if the people competing have talent or not.
im a flutist, and clarinetist,,this made want to DIE he was SO out of tune
I too am a flutist and the first one made me want to die like seriously
Omg same i think i had an aneurism 😂😂
I’m a pianist but I could feel all your pain 😂
Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
This man would have been roasted by my section
I wanted to smash my harp onto him.
"you breathe when the phrase has ended"
my middle school band teacher: "DON'T BREATHE AT THE END OF A PHRASE OR ON A BAR LINe, breathe during the whole notes."
my current band director:" DON'T BREATHE. YOURE A FLUTE ITS TOO NOTICEABLE"
@@omeleteazulproducoes8196 sounds right to me
i’ve got two teachers that tell me to breathe at different spots
Oh god as a tuba player I could never imagine what that’s like I have the privilege of breathing like every two bars and my band teacher wouldn’t care
A kid in my choir once asked “what if you’re going to die if you don’t breath?” Our conductor just casually said “then we lose another one.”
It’s because when your’e a soloist you are more likely to be noticed when you breathe, when you are in a band there are other people playing during the whole note so it’s not as noticeable.
As a pianist, those stools cost a LOT, especially if you get a really good one. Anyone sane individual would not kick a piano stool.
I really don't think that dude was sane
I don't think cost is an issue as long as you get the ratings.
Trust me he earned enough from that performance to buy 100 stools
And that piece isn't that hard. Only a Level 7 in Piano.
And yes, that sounds pretty high, but it's not that hard to play, really.
@@anastasiawasylinko5482 Like I don't even learn piano and I can pretty much play the beginning of Fur Elise
@@anastasiawasylinko5482 For reference for folks who don't know piano levels/use a different system, Fur Elise is one of the earliest pieces you learn on piano after your scales and simplified folk tunes like Scarborough Fair. So. Not terribly impressive.
My review as a pianist:
1. His piano is dramatized and obviously has no love for the instrument
2. He wants to put on a good show which is completely understandable, however, the PIANO DIDNT DO ANYTHING FLIPPIN WRONG
3. He most likely doesnt play the paino because if you look up fur elise on youtube, and play the two side by side, they sound the same.
I love you two set. Plz make sure pianos lives matters: PLM
I hated every single second of the part of that pianist...
That... Was... Sacrilegious on a level it has yet not been measured
I seemed to be the only person upset when I saw this, finally someone agrees. :>
First he portrayed classical music as having nothing but one boring phrase from Fur Elise, then he does this strange robot dancing.... I experienced left lung failure after that.
He started young as a pianist and still plays Fur Elise on a talent show.... I mean if he was actually a musician he should actually show off his talent and play Liszt or something but eh. Maybe the director told him to play Fur Elise to emphasize how “boring” classical music is and it really pissed me off. Man if I ever hear Fur Elise or Canon in D on a talent show I am going to cringe to deathhh
I am triggered too.
i learned fur elise when i was 10. i was like seriously? every pianist knows how to play this??!!
First guy: I play flute! *brings out ALTO flute*
Amelie Smith I wanted to point that out! XD
Why is alto a problem? (i don't musical instruments)
@@Lyf4rMusic alto is just lower so its harder to play higher notes that are like the normal flute
@@cocowang2005 ahh! Should've got the bulb in my mind, when it said Alto.. my bad :)
Lyf for music it’s a different instrument
As a flautist, that was absolutely horrendous. I don't even consider myself to be very good, but that was awful.
@@WilliamHelstad yeah english is so complicated. How do I keep learning it
I understand english is a little difficult if you are not from U.S.A or other country that speak English even for me is difficult so to write flautist instead of flutist is just normal 👌🙂
@@WilliamHelstad us Americans like making everything harder for ourselves in almost every way that is humanly possible
I agree with you bean I am also an amatuar Flautist, and this guy sounds terrible.
Same
Really loved you guys for stressing at that classical music point as I have felt the pain myself I really love classical music but whenever you perform it people consider it boring but once you start doing the boom boom even though a musician would find it out of tune still others will love it
AGT contestants: My parents died in a fire and I lost everything.
*uses tremolo as if it's impressive*
The sad part is that italian guy seemed like he was genuinely a good pianist and probably has a lot of talent in piano but he would never win the show playing classical music on its own
Yeah...
@@wuzz still sounded pretty good and expressive
He is talented, tough around 8:29 he missed a few notes but he was probably busy knocking down that poor chair
Or the piano playing was fake because there was a track when he was dancing
@@wuzz you've either never played the part starting from the second page or your technique might just be awesome.
Guys, let’s be honest, this should have been called “America’s got *no* talent”
Or America's Got Strip Talent
Vanessa Lin yes
Omg yee
No.... America's got talent for messing up good stuff and promoting junk.
America's got strip
Having only 9 years of piano experience and yet this is devastating
Do what you want but don't ever HURT INSTRUMENTS
what about the viola ?
@@eddyshair7880 well there's the exception
Walerija Sultan hey now don’t be mean to viola
@@eddyshair7880 no instrument deserves that kind of treatment, would you go onstage and punch a dog in the face. No! ffs lol
Agreed. Instruments are precious, don't hurt them 😂
Taking your clothes off and acting sassy isn't talent.
Preachhhhh
And it aint funny eitherrrrr
@@teageamusic2033 shut the hell up
Ur just jealous
Zavier umm?
Exactly
Remember they rejected Lindsey Sterling... Who is now one of the most famous modern violinist.... AGT has no respect for REAL TALENT....
I had been scrolling to look for a comment like this. She is far from irrelevant and is one of many who have helped to bridge classical music to pop and and alternative music.
@@carolineballeza5090 true 👍
And also that young female contortionist who was amazing
Najmah T. A.
Sofia Dossi?
Stirling* No hate man.
As a person who went to a filming of "Americas got talent" I can say it was the worst thing I've ever experienced.
The audience is literally actors. You'll get maybe two acts and then the rest of the day is just filming audience reactions. Literally about 8 hours of nothing happening. Then they try to get the audience to compete for prizes by seeing who can cheer the loudest (for the take obviously). The thing is they'll never give the prize to anyone who actually wanted one (because once they get the prize what would be the incentive for the said audience member). The worst thing is they don't even hire an audience, but trick families into coming believing it was more of a show and less of a TV set filming. They basically force the "actors" to pay to be there. Worst thing ever.
Edit: for anyone wondering, I actually found the clip of the showing that I went too.
ua-cam.com/video/M4si8EbMMys/v-deo.html
Now it was nowhere near as exciting as it was shown here. It was literally them telling us to make scared faces, then cheer when he hit the ground and that was it. Then the judges went inside and it was literally them having us " compete to see who could cheer the loudest"
Some kids were cheering so loud we were losing our voice, including me. Once I even locked eyes with the "DJ" and he shook his head and pointed to the camera (gesturing for me to look) this happened about 3 times before my Dad noticed and he was pissed. He eventually had us get up and leave. He told the DJ off as we left but I don't remember what he said. Ended up going to a buffet to make it up.
TL;DR: went to a filming of AGT. Got to see one act, then was bribed too scream on camera.
AGT are scum who trick families into being up paid actors for an audience.
Edit #2: Forgot to mention it was like 90° F out there, so yeah...around 8 hours in that kind of hear screaming.
Edit: #3 damn guys thanks for the support!
Kale Chips damn exposeddd
@@AA-ok9uw I fucking hated it...fuck them and fuck everything about them. And definitely fuck the guy I charge of getting the crowd to cheer. Literally looked at kids who were cheering so loud that they were turning beat red in the eyes and told them they weren't screaming loud enough to get a prize, just because he knew these kids would keep screaming for the camera if he just dangled a cool toy in front of them.
I got bored with reality TV shows like this one during American Idol. It was the same schtick every episode...I told my friends the reactions were fake and the show is bullshit. You just proved what my 16 year old butt could not so many years ago...AUGHOSIOWIENROIHEPIAURHISEUNIUTHASTUGSD!
I have always hated those """"""reality"""""" TV shows. They have nothing realistic in them, it is incredibly fake. It's like the XVIII th century "naturalism" (I know that now the term is connoted with the XIX th century movement, although it suffers from the same problem, I just think that the one from the XVIII th was more egregious), it is just a vain attempt to captivate audience by giving them the illusion of reality, something that you've created from A to Z. There is nothing real about it, it is just an illusion, an allure
Capitalism at its finest, this is how humans turn themselves into slaughter animals by watching clowns in TV and try to mimic them.
I went to an America's Got Talent taping once. Before ANY of the acts audition in front of the audience, the production comes out and tells the audience: standing ovation on 1, 2, 3. now, everybody look up and look surprised/scared. Now, act bored. Then they pick some audience members for the close-up shots of people yawning, laughing, etc. (without anybody on stage.) They do the same with judge dramatic reactions. THEN, the auditions begin and you find out why you were looking up scared/surprised... there's an act with a guy doing aerial stuff. I left after the second audition.