Maison Martin Margiela Replica Collection Jazz Club & By The Fireplace REVIEW with Redolessence

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 сер 2024
  • Redolessence: / redolessence
    Brooklyn Fragrance Lover Blog: brooklynfragran...
    Follow Brooklyn Fragrance Lover on Facebook: tinyurl.com/pbu...
    Follow Brooklyn Fragrance Lover on Instagram: tinyurl.com/pdn...
    Follow Brooklyn Fragrance Lover on Twitter: / carlos319

КОМЕНТАРІ • 261

  • @sirreginaldlee3576
    @sirreginaldlee3576 2 роки тому +23

    RIP to Carlos and Mr Samuels 🙏🏽 they were heavy hitters in the fragrance world..great guys

    • @ayazmalik5260
      @ayazmalik5260 Рік тому

      Did Steven also die ? 😢

    • @jaybrick8973
      @jaybrick8973 Рік тому

      ​@@ayazmalik5260no

    • @soulrebel2006
      @soulrebel2006 Рік тому

      No Steven didn’t

    • @steb0ne
      @steb0ne Рік тому +1

      @@ayazmalik5260Believe he's talking about Kevin Samuels....he reviewed Jazz Club around this time too I think

    • @ayazmalik5260
      @ayazmalik5260 Рік тому

      @@steb0ne Thanks mate. For clearing it. I appreciate….☺️🙏

  • @josephXedge
    @josephXedge 3 роки тому +12

    Rip Carlos 💙

  • @King_Ty98
    @King_Ty98 Рік тому +2

    RIP CARLOS, YOUR LEGACY WILL BE FOREVER!

  • @cheryllynnlopez
    @cheryllynnlopez 6 років тому +22

    Jazz Club was love at first sniff. Great comparison review.

  • @scubaleon3460
    @scubaleon3460 6 років тому +11

    I really like how you guys portray the image these fragrances evoke

  • @MrSillage
    @MrSillage 6 років тому +26

    Omg! My favorite thing was when you called it MMM because that's what I call the house most of the time as well!! 😂 These 2 Scents are AMAZING. I also love ACROSS SANDS from the REPLICA FANTASIES collection! Thank you for your review on these Carlos and Steven!👍👍

  • @banzaiburger9589
    @banzaiburger9589 6 років тому +43

    I’ve tried by the Fireplace and the office ladies loved it, said it smelled like I was a walking cheese Danish. lol

  • @Kalima1231
    @Kalima1231 6 років тому +5

    I love when the two of you do reviews together - you have such a great rapport! I've seen another review of By the Fireplace and it's on my list to sample next month. Can't wait to try them and you did a wonderful job of describing the notes, especially the amber and vanilla.

  • @chickboy359
    @chickboy359 6 років тому +5

    So glad you guys finally noticed this. Been wearing these two including At The Barbers for almost 2 yrs now and nobody seemed to be paying attention to the line.

  • @ddpanda
    @ddpanda 6 років тому +10

    I've had By The Fireplace on my wishlist for 2 years. I was thinking of buying it before the end of the year. I really love it.

    • @BrooklynFragranceLover
      @BrooklynFragranceLover  6 років тому

      Me too!

    • @Statestepper
      @Statestepper 5 років тому +1

      What’s the longevity on it ?

    • @SouthernArawak
      @SouthernArawak Рік тому

      I'm pretty sure you've bought it already but if not send me your po box I'll ship it to you

    • @DianaDevlin
      @DianaDevlin Рік тому

      @@SouthernArawak Are you offering to send a bottle of By The Fireplace to me?

  • @AGentlemansJourney77
    @AGentlemansJourney77 6 років тому +10

    By The Fireplace would be my favourite from the two and from the entire house. They do have some rather interesting scents.

  • @byKevinSamuels
    @byKevinSamuels 6 років тому +33

    Bath and Bodyworks Marshmallow Fireside is a dead ringer for By The Fireplace. I also have Across The Sands.

    • @isaz597
      @isaz597 5 років тому

      Is it available as a fragrance? I know its available as a candle & a room spray. I was something to wear on the skin

    • @coolslc
      @coolslc 5 років тому

      by Kevin Samuels haha you’re right about that, straight candle! Not a fan of By The Fireplace

    • @OHHnoYOUdidntMAN
      @OHHnoYOUdidntMAN 11 місяців тому

      RIP KEVIN SAMUELS 🙏🏽

  • @tyonj4329
    @tyonj4329 4 роки тому +3

    By the Fireplace is definitely a great cozy smelling fragrance! A few sprays are great if you’re just relaxing with significant other for cuddling. Out and about I’d say give your clothes about 4 sprays!

  • @AmberGilbertson
    @AmberGilbertson 4 роки тому +22

    When I bought this I didn't even notice it stated "mens fragrance" I don't care, its sexy as hell, I'm wearing the crap out of it!

    • @alaguiza8541
      @alaguiza8541 4 роки тому +2

      jazz club or by the fireplace ?

    • @jz9172
      @jz9172 4 роки тому +1

      In my opinion, both genders could rock them.

    • @guaguancos.montunodcubop8923
      @guaguancos.montunodcubop8923 3 роки тому

      Absolutely. Jazz Club is INCREDIBLE. It caught my eye cuz im a jazz musician LOL and then when i smelled it i went nuts cuz its a scent that i love... its very close to T.Ford "Santal Blush". Anything with that scent i love. And ever since i got this Jazz Club I've been smelling myself a 100 times a day when i wear it

  • @jacklarage2651
    @jacklarage2651 3 роки тому +2

    I just bought fireplace. Love it.

  • @shanerose501
    @shanerose501 6 років тому +15

    Love jazz club !!! Finely its getting some love and reviews 👍👍👍

  • @Barkingspider
    @Barkingspider 5 років тому +6

    Two of the best fragrances out. Period the end!

  • @RemixRampage
    @RemixRampage 4 роки тому +2

    Jazz club would be a perfect vacation scent for a night out. I love it. Need to try by the fireplace still!

  • @runningyogamom1114
    @runningyogamom1114 6 років тому +5

    I just picked up samples of both scents as well as lazy Sunday morning and promenade in the gardens...So happy to get them at Sephora...and Glad to see your review, as always..well done 😊💥🎄tfs

  • @professorx8258
    @professorx8258 6 років тому +5

    I loved the two of you reviewing 2 well-quality fragrances that deserve more love in the fragrance community. It's a bit hard for me to pick a favorite of the two, but my favorite from the MMM Replica line is By The Fireplace.

  • @brandonbalala1181
    @brandonbalala1181 6 років тому +2

    Always go back to smelling By the fireplace a sephora every visit, amazing scent.

  • @mohtown8751
    @mohtown8751 6 років тому +1

    I had a chance to smell these two along with At the Barber. I was 50/50 with Jazz Club, liked At the Barber but was blown away by By The Fireplace. It was the first scent I came across where the smell matched the title! That smokiness is something I never smelled in a fragrance before

  • @drumslapn
    @drumslapn 6 років тому +1

    I absolutely love By The Fireplace and plan on picking it up in a few days. Im so glad you finally put out this review. I’ve been looking forward to your thoughts on these fragrance.

  • @johnpaulpersad8997
    @johnpaulpersad8997 2 роки тому

    Still coming back to your vids, for your opinions even after you gone!

  • @Nosebleedsandunderdogs
    @Nosebleedsandunderdogs 5 років тому +2

    Everytime I see my local Nordstrom’s have stock of By the fireplace. I buy them all. By far my favorite in my collection. I think it just dethroned CREED Aventus.. I know they are completely different fragrances. Easily my new fall/winter scent over Tom Ford Tuscan Leather.

    • @HDcompany_
      @HDcompany_ 4 роки тому +1

      Shiddd send me one bro, i love that shit. 😂

  • @jon2941
    @jon2941 6 років тому +3

    I think you guys work well together on these reviews, it's good to hear both your perspectives! Thank you for your reviews!

  • @theolfactoryzone
    @theolfactoryzone 3 роки тому +3

    Kinda late to this scent, but Jazz Club is magical!

  • @sorryremix
    @sorryremix 6 років тому

    It's a nice house & by the fireplace is just lovely . Perfect season for this type of scent . Count me in please & thank you gentlemen . Good luck to all !

  • @gerardorodriguez5404
    @gerardorodriguez5404 6 років тому +3

    My fragrance choice between the two would be By The Fireplace. I enjoy cold weather scents as well as smoky and intimate scents.

  • @fingersmicke8856
    @fingersmicke8856 6 років тому +1

    I really like these joint reviews. You two play off each other so incredibly well. I have been looking at Jazz Club for a couple months but now I’m really intrigued by By The Fireplace. Add another to the list.

  • @aa6270
    @aa6270 6 років тому +4

    Hahaha, love the 90s club genre music at the beginning. Felt like Night at the Roxbury.

  • @nadinecunningham6194
    @nadinecunningham6194 6 років тому +1

    Hey Carlos & Steven, nice one guys. I've been wanted to try this house for some time now but I've been a bit tentative. With your review I've been enlightened & will be making a few purchases soon. Thanks for your take on these two.always a great collab when you two hook up, you guys compliment each other. Thanks for the opportunity to get my nose on these fragrances.

  • @Dr.Kyriazidis
    @Dr.Kyriazidis 4 роки тому +35

    Me: Finds a new perfume and ready to press the "add to bag" button.
    My alter ego: Stop. Searches UA-cam for review by redolessence.
    Me: Makes final decision.

  • @No85Limits
    @No85Limits 4 роки тому +4

    Jazz Club and By the Fireplace - absolutely amazing (for by the fireplace - best results in the cold weather - preferably 40 or under) - wrote comment before watching video, and seen that you touched on this specifically, it really had to be cold to get the full experience. I remember wanting to show my fiance in a sephora in the city and she didn't like it until we walked out of the store and she smelled my wrist again after we had walked around for 15min (she loved it - of course) lol. Jazz club is like The One EDP BY Dolce & Gabbana but way better imo and better performance.

  • @patrickmiller714
    @patrickmiller714 Рік тому +2

    RIP King!

  • @jeromelucas8283
    @jeromelucas8283 6 років тому +1

    I own and love both of them! Perfect cold weather frags. Keep it up guys

  • @evaristoroman4166
    @evaristoroman4166 6 років тому

    Was not a fan of by the fireplace at first. But decided to give it a chance and the sweetness in the dry down, with the smokiness! I️ fell in love. Most definitely a fall/winter fragrance.

  • @LJIan996
    @LJIan996 6 років тому +5

    That background music is nice!

  • @bethaminkhan8068
    @bethaminkhan8068 6 років тому +1

    Good video. I bought both of these fragrances for my college age son. I purchase based on your recommendations and now he has a rather extensive collection. I will stay tuned!

  • @ThePerfumeNerd
    @ThePerfumeNerd 6 років тому

    I have three favorites from this house. By The Fireplace, Jazz Club and At The Barber's. Depending on my mood, the time of day, event, season or application each one of these fragrances has it's place.

  • @Dannyup
    @Dannyup 5 років тому

    Just got a sample of this from Sephora and after 1 hour it’s already a guaranteed buy from me in the future I can’t wait!

  • @kennethdaniel1516
    @kennethdaniel1516 6 років тому +1

    Jazz club is one of my faves. You can turn this scent into an edp if u spray their blur or glow oil based filler on first .

  • @keiserious
    @keiserious 6 років тому +2

    "Where you gonna put it?...put it. Right there,put right there" need the jingle more Carlito! Great review, I had a decant of Untitled,sweet and green.

  • @bigbullet9224
    @bigbullet9224 4 роки тому +1

    Love both have both

  • @seanpdoyle100
    @seanpdoyle100 6 років тому

    I finally got to smell By the Fireplace a couple weeks ago. I really enjoyed it.

  • @neilandrei
    @neilandrei 6 років тому +12

    By the Fire Place smells amazing. Great video as always!

  • @Galzura
    @Galzura 6 років тому

    By The Fireplace is my favorite. It just brings an image to your mind instantly

  • @toonlad4091
    @toonlad4091 6 років тому +1

    Great video lads.
    I love By the Fireplace, I would bathe in this stuff if I could lol.
    Not tried Jazz club yet but next on my list.
    Peace from Newcastle England!!!

  • @mzgalanty
    @mzgalanty 6 років тому

    been having my eyes on replica fragrances..thanks for giving a detailed representation so that I can get an idea of what they smell like.

  • @t.j.bennett6454
    @t.j.bennett6454 6 років тому

    You’re always giving us what we want Carlos thank you! As always having Steven there is an added bonus for us. Hope you’re both doing great have a wonderful night!

  • @MotivationalmonkTv
    @MotivationalmonkTv 5 років тому +1

    Blind bought both bcos everyone was talking about them on UA-cam, Jazz club has a good scent but poor silage for me, stays close to my skin. Performs poorly for me . By the fire place is my favorite from this house can’t have enough of it! I rate it 9/10, would give it 10/10 if it was EDP!

  • @HDcompany_
    @HDcompany_ 4 роки тому +2

    My only complaint with by the fireplace is that they dont make it in a big windex size gallon bottle. 😭

  • @ladysuici
    @ladysuici 6 років тому

    I’ve sampled Jazz Club, I like it very much for cold weather. I love Lipstick On and it won’t take to long for me to buy it.
    Would love to have a decant from both, so I can sample them for this cold season.
    I think it’s very fun how you bring up memories about the smells.

  • @gabrielgallawa8205
    @gabrielgallawa8205 6 років тому +2

    I'm in. I enjoyed the two for one review. I've never smelled anything from the line but my son is going to try and send me a sample of BTFP.

  • @albertperez590
    @albertperez590 6 років тому

    Amazing video again Carlos and Steven. I’ve sniffed these before and remembered these were amazing!!! Always again thanks for the videos!!!👍🏻

  • @nrcdcar63
    @nrcdcar63 6 років тому

    Finally you got these. I purchased a blind buy decant of the fireplace scent and I love it. I need to smell jazz club. Hopefully I win one of your giveaways. Great context my guys.

  • @pvalex100
    @pvalex100 6 років тому

    Testing Jazz Club currently. Hoping to try By the Fireplace soon. I always enjoy the fraghead camaraderie with these collab videos.

  • @sergioteixeira
    @sergioteixeira 6 років тому

    Love how you guys help us "imagine" the scents, the info behind the perfumes and the house are invaluable.
    PS: Carlos, the camera on the table shakes a lot.

  • @brianwade9474
    @brianwade9474 6 років тому

    Another great video. I love by the fireplace and I definitely want to try jazz club.

  • @jimtyrrell6419
    @jimtyrrell6419 5 років тому +1

    BTF is so yummy! even down here in the tropics we have AUTUMN & man this scent says FALL I have a few gourmand frags but this is so RICH maybe its the SMOKY/VANILLA gonna check out JAZZ CLUB next thanks for the info JIM from MIAMI BEACH

  • @blackeuro718
    @blackeuro718 6 років тому +2

    By the fireplace.. Probably my Aventus lol I love it that much. Then Velvet by commodity

  • @AniMerci
    @AniMerci 6 років тому

    I just picked up a sample today of MM Music Festival at Sephora. Heaven. Buying a bottle very soon.

  • @shawng746
    @shawng746 6 років тому

    Great job as always. I love scents with that smokey scent to them, so I'll have to give By the Fireplace a smell. Thanks for the review guys.

  • @demondwebster1876
    @demondwebster1876 6 років тому

    Thanks for the review. I've never tried this house before and rarely see reviews for these. Would love to get my nose on both of them.

  • @triktrak_1451
    @triktrak_1451 6 років тому

    Great vid. I like it when brands use simple bottles and labels-- it gives you that old apothecary feeling.

  • @LivingMemorial3200
    @LivingMemorial3200 6 років тому

    I absolutely love by the fireplace. Never tried any of the others from that house. Would love a decant.

  • @reydean1803
    @reydean1803 6 років тому +1

    thank you carlos i havent smiled any from that line but i love to try by the fireplace

  • @Ivanaob
    @Ivanaob 6 років тому

    Love to watch you guys, Dream team of fragrance reviewers ❤️
    I think that I must wait couple of more years to smell MMM in my country (Serbia)
    😘

  • @teklocalceleb
    @teklocalceleb 6 років тому

    By the Fireplace is such an amazing scent, it's definitely my favorite from the line. It's so comforting and brings back my childhood memories, this just makes me happy every time I smell it in any store. Those decants would definitely be going to someone who will love and appreciate them if you pick me! :)

  • @ericdunthorne1981
    @ericdunthorne1981 6 років тому

    I alway enjoy the team up. I don't own any Replica fragrances yet but my favorite is Lipstick On. Which I will hopefully be purchasing soon. Thanks for the giveaway and everything both of you do for the fragrance community.

  • @EdwardvanBerkum
    @EdwardvanBerkum 6 років тому

    Great review! I tried them both last week and ended up with buying jazz club.
    Jazz club is more wearable of these two, I think by the fire place is great, but it's less versatile, this is a real December fragrance for my feeling, I found something in the top notes now which wasn't my thing.
    There is a sampler set of 10ml from mmm with at the barbers, jazz club and by the fireplace. This is 65 Euro's.

  • @BretCahill
    @BretCahill 6 років тому

    Every time I wear jazz club I get at least one complement. It's smells so good! Also the strongest reaction complement I got was on a hot summer night out.

    • @ashlm9100
      @ashlm9100 5 років тому

      How many sprays and where do you spray it

  • @jgrave2811
    @jgrave2811 6 років тому

    By the fireplace is the only one I’ve smelled and it’s definitely on my list to own

  • @willardgrant2001
    @willardgrant2001 6 років тому

    MMM fragrances sound very pleasant, I 'd love to smell these!

  • @JoeBur
    @JoeBur 6 років тому

    Thanks for the video. You MUST try Maison Martin Margiela: At The Barber's. A wonderful barbershop fragrance.If you're a fan of barbershop fragrances.....it's a must have.

  • @jussi2284
    @jussi2284 6 років тому

    Awesome, I have been waiting for these reviews! Really interested in these. Never smelled them but read alot about them. Keep up the good work!

  • @Dieggovelazquez
    @Dieggovelazquez 6 років тому +1

    Jazz club definitely has that warm cigar lounge aspect to the nose, first time I smelled it definitely had some Miles Davis Jazz in the background

  • @sdrawkcabvag
    @sdrawkcabvag 6 років тому

    Always love the double reviews

  • @iconz255
    @iconz255 6 років тому

    Hello Carlos. From your review I would definitely go for the Jazz Club.

  • @manny44
    @manny44 6 років тому

    Never tried this house before & would love to get my nose on these two. Sound groovy for Fall and Winter.

  • @louarenivarchavez2769
    @louarenivarchavez2769 6 років тому

    Jazz Club sounds great !!You can't go wrong with vanilla scents during fall and winter Hmmm!!

  • @Rynadian
    @Rynadian 6 років тому

    'At the Barbers' was another awesome scent from the Replica line when I first sniffed them. By the Fireplace has to be my favourite though.

  • @Recharg3
    @Recharg3 6 років тому

    I've never tried any MMM fragrance until now but i know for sure jazz club has a lot of hype around it. Great video.

  • @pandorap872
    @pandorap872 6 років тому

    Nice review and comparison between the two most popular MMM releases. I actually prefer By the Fireplace. Would like to hear your thoughts on Soul of the Forest from the same house. Thanks, Carlos and Steven.

  • @davidfoster7119
    @davidfoster7119 3 роки тому +1

    Just a hint, when you don't call them out by name it's hard to follow which ones you are referring to with specific elements of the fragrance

  • @davecarrizal7715
    @davecarrizal7715 6 років тому +1

    Great video. The sound like wonderful scents!

  • @c.miller2460
    @c.miller2460 6 років тому

    Got a sample of Jazz Club and like it. It's sweeter and more tame than i predicted which was a bit of a disappointment, but I still enjoy it. Now you have me wanting to test the By the Fireplace one. Thanks, Guys! :)

    • @c.miller2460
      @c.miller2460 6 років тому

      Santoryu Thank you so much for telling me that. I'm not really into sweet perfumes so I think I'll pass. Thank you again for sharing that info with me.

  • @Jimbo_81
    @Jimbo_81 6 років тому

    I actually just picked up a sample from Sephora last night of both of them I am absolutely in love with by the fireplace I just feel like snuggling up when I wear you I would love to win a 5 mil decant of both thanks great video

  • @Longshore79
    @Longshore79 6 років тому

    By the fireplace is the best out of the line. Drydown is a a warm spicy Gucci pour homme 2. Love it !

  • @desertdetroiter428
    @desertdetroiter428 2 роки тому

    Miss you Carlos!!

  • @lisafox1001
    @lisafox1001 5 років тому

    Great reviews guys!! I haven’t tried Jazz Club yet, bit plan on trying it. I concur that BTF is wonderful. I actually think BTF is a masterpiece. The sweet and smoky notes are addictive. Apparently, according to my husband, this fragrance has projection that can fill a room, a house! I will (try to) wear in moderation😀

  • @ammarmali
    @ammarmali 6 років тому

    I would love to try this line! Been hearing so much about it! My fav thing is the collab, always love em!

  • @bryanf7021
    @bryanf7021 6 років тому

    Great review as always. Have not tried any from this house, but would love to.

  • @larrygeisler
    @larrygeisler 6 років тому

    Can't go wrong with either, but would love to win jazz club. MMM is great at putting you right where they say...

  • @matildajr
    @matildajr 6 років тому

    Love both these scents!! It's tough to choose between the two. Sephora is having their VIB sale now so I think I need to get my nose on them to make my purchase. Thanks guys for your insightful thoughts!!

  • @m4df4m65
    @m4df4m65 6 років тому

    My favorite duo! Thanks and I'm in! Getcha SMELLYEAH!

  • @bernie7772
    @bernie7772 6 років тому

    Some think Jazz Club was a bit feminine. Personally haven't tried it. I do trust your noses, so I think I would love to try By The Fireplace! Great review.

  • @manhimanh
    @manhimanh 6 років тому

    This line is really great MMM did a great job replicating the "moments".

  • @nononscents826
    @nononscents826 6 років тому

    Really love both of these! Great review guys!

  • @gqsown2516
    @gqsown2516 6 років тому

    These two smell amazing together.