Ranking Every Brenner Era Episode
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 лип 2024
- To celebrate its 10th anniversary, I ramble about the Brenner era for 2 hours.
UA-cam ▶ / @thebrendamengine
Twitter ▶ / brendam_engine
Discord ▶ The Brendam Engine # 5988
All video footage was taken from this spreadsheet (it was a godsend): docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
The Railway Series illustrations were taken from the Thomas the Tank Engine Wiki.
Music used:
• Season 19 Engine Roll ...
• Paper Mario: The Thous...
• Bowser's Inside Story:...
• Boss Theme - Ver. 1 (N...
• Super Mario RPG: The R...
• Mario Party 2: Horror ...
• Castle Theme/Fortress ...
• Paper Mario Medley [Ro...
• Paper Mario: The Thous...
• Super Mario Sunshine: ...
• Cheep Cheep Beach (Mar...
• GBA Boo Lake - Mario K...
• GBA Riverside Park - M...
• Chill [Brawl] - Super ...
• Dino Piranha - Mario &...
• Super Princess Peach: ...
• Super Mario World: For...
• Inside the Castle Wall...
• Ice Ice Outpost - Mari...
• Yoshi's Island - Under...
• "Mr. L, Green Thunder"...
• Mario Paint Medley - S...
• Flower Garden - Yoshi'...
• Minor Circuit [Remix] ...
• Game & Watch Gallery 2...
• Mario & Luigi: Bowser'...
• Title Theme - Super Ma...
• Super Smash Bros: Peac...
• Slide (Super Mario 64)...
• Super Mario RPG: Midas...
• Bowser's Fury - Scampe...
• Sky-High Sundae (Mario...
• Mario Golf: Toad Highl...
• Donkey Kong Country: M...
• Super Mario All-Stars:...
• Donkey Kong (GB): Show...
• Big Blue - Mario Kart ...
• DS Mario Circuit - Mar...
• Sherbet Land - Mario &...
• Cool, Cool Mountain - ...
• "SMB Snow" Super Mario...
• N64 Choco Mountain - M...
• Super Mario 3D World -...
• Main Theme - Super Mar...
• David Wise - Mining Me...
• Super Paper Mario: Lin...
• Toad Road (Mario Party...
• GCN Sherbet Land - Mar...
• Moo Moo Meadows (Mario...
• Menu Theme (Mario Kart...
• Greenhorn Forest (Wari...
• Circuit Theme (Mario K...
• DK Island Swing - Mari...
• Woody Woods - Mario Pa...
• Mario Kart DS: DK Pass...
• Mario Kart Fan Music -...
• Mario & Luigi: Bowser'...
• 3DS Neo Bowser City - ...
• Sonic 2 - Emerald Hill...
• Lip's Theme - Panel de...
• A Rare Minigame (Mario...
• Dream Ski Cross (Mario...
• Underwater (New Super ...
• David Wise - Fear Fact...
• Super Paper Mario: Glo...
• Meta Knight's Revenge ...
• Bowser's Lava Lake Kee...
• Tour Merry Mountain - ...
• Wrecking Crew Medley -...
• DS Peach Gardens - Mar...
• Mario Kart: Double Das...
• Super Mario RPG: Bewar...
• Mario Party 3: Chilly ...
• Main Theme - Luigi's M...
• Dan Salvato - Doki Dok...
• Super Mario 3D Land - ...
• Super Mario Sunshine: ...
• Arms Grand Prix Offici...
• Frosty Village / Walru...
• Game & Watch Gallery 3...
• Circuit - Mario Kart 7...
• sans. - Remix Cover (U...
• Super Paper Mario - Fr...
• Daisy Circuit - Fanmad...
• Mario and Sonic at the...
• DS Shroom Ridge - Mari...
• Dolphin Shoals - Mario...
• Athletic Theme from Yo...
• Mario Kart Fan Music -...
• 3DS Rock Rock Mountain...
• Mario Party 2: Going S...
• Sonic Mania: Studiopol...
• "Steam Gardens" Super ...
• Tour Berlin Byways - M...
• Mushroom Bridge Theme ...
• Underground Mozart | D...
• Creative Exercise from...
• Donkey Kong Country: I...
• Super Punch-Out!! - Mi...
• Waluigi Pinball - Mari...
• Mario Kart Fan Music -...
• Mario & Luigi: Superst...
• Super Mario 64: Dire, ...
• Super Mario 3D Land Th...
• Super Mario Odyssey: S...
• Honeylune Ridge Caves ...
• Wii DK Summit - Mario ...
• "Smooth Starry Night" ...
• "Popple Battle" Mario ...
• "K. Rool Returns" Donk...
• Mount Wario (Medley) -...
• Tee Lopes - Super Mari...
• Stickerbush Symphony -...
• Super Mario Galaxy - G...
• Super Mario Odyssey | ...
• Main Theme (Arranged) ...
• Wii Maple Treeway - Ma...
• King Dedede's Theme [B...
• GBA Sky Garden - Mario...
• Mario Freaks Orchestra...
• Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Ba...
• The Map Page/Bonus Lev...
• SNES Rainbow Road - Ma...
• Rainbow Road (Mario Ka...
• Mario Kart Fan Music -...
• Credits (Mario Kart DS)
DISCLAIMER:
Although this video can be enjoyed by kids, its target audience are older fans who are more familiar with the franchise.
Thomas is property of Mattel Creations.
#thomas #thomasandfriends #brennerera #10years #anniversary #tvseries - Розваги
The fact that you put the Beast of Sodor and Diesel and the Ducklings above Luke's New Friend is unforgivable.
Being slower paced is kinda the point of Luke's New Friend? Like I genuinely didn't get that criticism
@@brightredmogul1912 Really though, how is it possible to not like animal-centric episodes when almost all of the ones in the Brenner era are goated? Dude's just making up a reason.
@@rustymidlander05 Goated?
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 Basically, GOAT is an acronym for Greatest Of All Time, it's a term used mostly by sports fans. In this case, I used it as a pun because I was talking about animals.
@@rustymidlander05I don't agree with the placement of lukes new friend, but it's just called having an opinion not "making up a reason" 😭😭
Philips introduction episode kinda reminds me of Thomas' arrival in The Adventure Begins.
Yeah, I do like that parallel, especially when Edward mentions it in the episode.
It makes me think they did it on purpose
Though Thomas didn't keep Edward from sleeping like Phillip 😡
The fact you had the balls to do this 👏👏
One idea that could make Missing Breakdown Train and Rocky Rescue better is what if those two episodes are mashed up together (given that they were written by Davey Moore), but instead Judy & Jerome are the ones that rescue Rocky instead of the Search and Rescue Team! Title-wise, I'd call it "Breakdown Rescue".
That's a great idea! I would've loved to see an episode with Judy, Jerome and Rocky together.
@@thebrendamengine So would I. Would be interesting to see.
@@thebrendamengineHow about including Harvey in that
Why were you not on the writing team that year?
The reason why Diesel 10 didn't appear after Season 17 is because Mattel deemed him too scary for younger audiences which is a shame because we would love to see him appear more in the CGI Brenner era and back to his evil portrayal because that's his true character as a villain that we love and would be part of Day of the Diesels done right with no genuine care for others, even other diesels whom some are good and friendly to steam engines. Villains are meant to be scary. What do people expect? So, there you go. Such a disappointment of him not appearing after Series 17, is it?
To hell with Mattel
The reason why diesel 10 was never seen again after season 17 is because Mattel thought that he was quote"too scary for children",if want more info check out on the thomas and friends wiki,search diesel 10 behind the scenes.
37:51 Percy stole Mr Narrator's line
Mr Narrator : hey that's my line
I find that annoying that Percy finds the situation funny, in reds vs blues every time he talks I would say in my mind Shut up Percy!
Frozen turntable well if Gordon should've let Percy be in Tidmouth Sheds and get stuck none of this would've happen
Great list
I love Signal Crossed when it has Toby trying know which of is his signal I don't mind i was aware of Ferdinand from Misty Island who little appear in the Andrew Brenner era
The Beast of Sodor aka Abominable Controller was the best with Henry and Spencer good with their relationship finding an abominable snowman but it was just Sir Topham Hatt who was late and when his mother showed up Thomas now Sir Topham Hatt had caused Confusion and Delay
That episode is funny, sure that Brenner era may made sir toppen hat was to much. But it was funny for me, and it helps seeing him as any ordinary person. That he isn’t always taken serious. 😂
You love spamming don't you
@@kevin-2.1 I was talking to Vanessa
"Flatbeds Of Fear has the lamest ghost story ever"
In my opinion, Phantom Express has a worse ghost story.
Flatbeds Of Fear's ghost story is at least *somewhat* worrying, with it essentially being a runaway train that has and will never come to a stop. Sure, runaway trains are basically a regular Sunday on Sodor, but the tension is still there.
Phantom Express, however? I'll summarize that ghost story - "wow guys the train is puffing around and blowing his whistle, soooo scarry!!!!". That's like if I told a story about the Headless Horseman, except he's just some guy who rides with his horse in the woods and just so happens to not have a head and that's it.
How am I supposed to perceive this ghost train as a genuine threat? For all I know, it could just be Neville going on a midnight stroll through the castle because he was feeling a bit silly that day! And the craziest part is - that unironically would've made for a more enjoyable episode than what we got!
Yeah, but at least Phantom Express has Stephen, which is pretty cool
Stephen is not written that well in phantom express i'm sorry
this guy thinks an owl hooting could possibly be a ghost train and that's what makes him start doubting whether or not ghosts are real before james plays his trick
@@brightredmogul1912 Yeah that's fair, I haven't seen the episode in a long time
Well, I think both of those ghost stories are lame, but Stephen brings up The Phantom Express a little. I like some of his dialogue, like when he crashes and finds Percy and says "I see you've found the meeting place."
' Scary ' episodes were never the same after season 5. Cannot have anything even remotely scary for the toddlers' moms.
and in way she does when Thomas talked about going to Misty Island what if we could pretend the misty Island trio have appear
Really enjoyed watching this! It deserves a lot more likes!
This was one of my favorite videos ever
Old Reliable Edward aka Gordon Gets Tricked and Thomas being a Troll
I like that episode too, and Gordon gets tricked now that’s a good title sort of similar to Thomas gets tricked title.
I love No More Mr Nice Guy aka engine when Hiro and Diesel first time meet each other and Diesel gets right about now
I cannot believe this video exists and what an amazing watch this was. I understand you need a big rest after this but it would be sooo cool if we eventually get a video like this for every era of the show
Thanks! I don't think I'd be able to get through the Miller or BWBA eras though, lol
@@thebrendamengine I wouldn't be able to either to be honest
You know that things don't last long with Diesel and he resumes being his devious self afterwards regardless, not just in CGI but the other eras of the show. Disappearing Diesels is just a episode of Diesel playing tricks on Paxton and no more. Remember that. No offense. It's just my thoughts overall but we'II see what you think of it and if you understand where I'm coming from or not.
Why am I NOT surprised the top 3 are the Small Railway Adaptations. Cue the Toy Story 2 clip of all the Buzz's in the toy store pan out as I think EVERYONE thinks this. Unless you're me (*Glances at All in Vain, Pouty James, and Love Me Tender* Yes I have a huge bias for James. Shush. XD)
I love Henry in the Dark with Henry glow with a payback
Henry sure gotten even with them, and it would be cool if they made a toy Henry that glows in the dark.
4:37 Oh No the Train
But I wish Bill and Ben could meet Charlie in the Brenner Era
Duncan getting challenged to not complain for one day and failing at it is why he’s one of my favourite characters. He’s such an icon.
the airship in hugo and the airship SHOULD'VE had a face and its name would be hugh. last name jass
26:32 yeah if James hadn't crashed into Tidmouth Sheds none of this would've happen when Edward move to my least favorite character of Philip
That is a good point & maybe the they should of make more episodes of Edward and Philip so they get to know each other better. Instead of having Edward willingly move out of the sheds, to an engine he knows little.
I like to think of Big Micky as the crane from “Edward’s Brass Band” that knocked Edward off the track while unloading a huge ship’s boiler.
I missed the old days
The only good CGI era.
Indeed.
And even then it has its significant problems
@@pranavrao6370 Every era of Thomas has problems even the classic series.
@@pranavrao6370 Which should not talk about much. Less said the better. Wouldn't want to damper what makes the Brenner era good with that.
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967why not?
The episodes starring diesels are my personal favorite. They’d give us as Thomas fans something that could have been done had Awdry given the time to expand the characters, (I can’t wait to waste my breath on these) The Missing Christmas Decorations is a pretty sweet and cool episode that shows how mistreated the diesels were till the end, Diesel 10 had a point about everyone’s preference to steamers, Percy and Sidney’s dynamic was touching and the moral from Thomas was unbelievable. Disappearing Diesels, it gave us a reason to love Paxton even more, his friendship with Diesel might have been toxic, but at least Paxton did the right thing to help him then be mad at him. I’m also glad to see the diesels’ drivers here again. Salty All At Sea, this episode gets some flak and I cant understand why? Salty had a pretty understandable reason for why he doesn’t flies going out to sea, which makes sense given the bridge of Vicarstown. Besides he doesn’t run away and hide, but finds more work to do just to get away from his fear, besides it’s nice to see him take passengers for once. Toby’s New Friend, it develops Philip a bit more. Philip now understands the importance of being quiet and slow for once. Toby’s duo with the diesels hasn’t changed really and he has a blast showing the ropes to them. Even Philip admits that he doesn’t always have to win. And Springtime for Diesel, this episode has two characters that we thought would never happen if this show had ended, Diesel and Daisy. Diesel finally gave us an explaination for why he is so aggressive to other engines and redeems himself to become a better engine.
wait the brendam engine has 222 subs (number 2 anyone?)
Philip is likely my least favorite character in Thomas 44:52
Philip is alright, it’s just that he talks a lot and he barely learns a lesson (ex Philip’s race & Philip to the rescue).
Hey I'm a UA-camr just starting out and I want some advice on making videos also ironic that harold actually has 4 small wheels
What advice do you want specifically?
@@thebrendamengine What should I do if I want to get clips of what I am talking about and what site do you use to edit your videos thanks
@@Kionsmyguy3 I guess that depends what footage you need. For this video, I used a spreadsheet containing every episode of Thomas, which I linked in the description, and downloaded episodes from there. For editing, I just used iMovie on my laptop.
I often why Jack, Alfie, Oliver, Max and Monty were the only pack members brought into CGI, where were Kelly, Ned, Isabella, and Byron? Maybe a budget issue.
Extremely under rated
You think that other writers would have created episodes for Donald and Douglas and written them properly in their true proper personalities in CGI instead of Davey Moore.
Not necessarily, but I think they should've drawn from more episodes for Donald and Douglas' personality, because it's fairly one-dimensional in CGI. Davey Moore did this with Daisy, for instance, with each of her episodes being centered around a different facet of her character.
@@thebrendamengine How so if you don't mind me asking?
I really wish you had more subscribers. You really deserve it. Don't feel demotivated because you aren't picking up steam, you will someday, and hopefully soon.
Thank you, I really appreciate it. Tbh I feel if I uploaded more regularly I would gain traction faster, but I don't want to burn myself out. I still have plans for the channel in the future, though, so I hope that grows my audience, even if it's gradual.
@@thebrendamengine it's deserved
Honestly with Emily in the middle I can agree with you on half. Like the arguing was every second but for me I’m just happy to see them but I do definitely agree with you. using the Formular of they just argue gets so annoying after a bit. But on the other hand irl twins will fight. But still like 50% agree with you the arguing constantly gets annoying and drags it down a ton
I've heard the argument of "all twins fight", and I'd be OK with it if it was a once in a while thing like in Love Me Tender, but Emily in the Middle portrays Donald and Douglas as if they fight all the time, which just doesn't sit right with me
@@thebrendamengine agreed
What's the music you played while talking about "No Steam Without Coal"? I think it's from a Kirby game, but I can't quite place it...
It's a remix of Yoshi's Island - Underground by Qumu: ua-cam.com/video/_ulBZmL6JwE/v-deo.htmlsi=eOHwIkhROyrmQBQ4
1:05:43 my favorite 3 steam engines gruff with the Farquhar trio being the billy goat trio Toby is the little Goat Percy is the medium goat and Thomas is the big goat
40:36 “snow snow for Thomas”
Oops...
I love the way you explain yourself to these episodes, I mean I’m a bit disappointed that not so slow coaches wasn’t at number one. But still the way you explain how good each episode is was great, and how some of the characters are in they’re original state like in the classic series. Good I like that you explain that Thomas isn’t all bad in The emergency cable. It just shows that Thomas wanted payback for what the bird watcher has done. And in All in vain, we see James trying to do better and not let his complains get the better of him so that I like. And as for Porter we should see more of him in action, like seeing his strength and weakness. We saw what Salty’s weakness is (afraid of the sea), Cranky (getting replaced), Percy (being afraid of dark places) and others too. Just saying we need more Porter episodes, but good list 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🚂🚂🚂🚂🚂🚂
Thanks! Porter definitely deserved more episodes as a lead, so that he could have more of a personality than just another dockyard engine.
Finally got around to watching this. Since it started with the bottom of the list, at first I thought to myself "man, this era wasn't as good as I remembered" but as you reached the good ones I realised why I miss the Brenner era so much.
I think Saving Time deserved a higher spot, Samson's antics are hilarious and him never learning is what makes him and the ending so fun
I actually managed to forget No Steam Without Coal, why did you have to remind me
I personally like Carly's colour scheme because of the reasons you listed. My ideal Sodor is one that grows and isn't immune to change, and a new crane that looks very modern and clean is exactly the kind of addition that shows change
No Snow for Thomas is pretty much just a rewrite of a better S8 episode with the same plot and characters, it should be lower imo
Overall I really enjoyed this
R.I.P Brenner Era.
2013 - 2017
Btw, follow up on that, porter actually has a character. Rewatch away from the sea and gone fishing very closely and you’ll see what I mean.
29:35 Philip is my least favorite when he annoys James and Gordon and talk too much with Edward
I’m either blind or it’s not here but can someone show me where his review on ‘The Big Freeze’ is? I can’t find it
It's at 19:29
@@thebrendamengine thx
4:52 Yeah TBH In my AU I think that Donald and Douglas are basically Bill and Ben but the opposite And don't fight
Well sometimes they do argue with each other, Bill and Ben.
Finally someone agrees with me 4:30
7:28
In my eyes I think No Snow For Thomas was meant to be the episode where Thomas learns to wear his snowplough as shown in Last Train For Christmas he Doesent care about wearing it and they seem to remain consistent with it even in the BWBA seasons from what I can recall as I am 100% sure he doesn’t complain about it throughout the rest of the Brenner era
Also I’m going to say it I love The Phantom Express just for the nice writing, Stephen and it feels like an episode where Percy is getting the TOTB build up
I do like Stephen's role in The Phantom Express
@@thebrendamengine Yeah though I was mainly just doing my defense on the episode but this is an amazing video you have great dedication ranking 5 seasons
Toby wants stay away from Philip 33:47
Well he just wants some alone time, since he refer the quiet forest. At the end he doesn’t mind Philip being around him.
questions, would u rank the miller era episodes if you had time to?
I don't know if I'd have the commitment to sit through all of them, let alone rank them. Maybe one day though
@@thebrendamengine thats understandable.
For me episodes with a returning character or a secondary character as a lead like Duck, Oliver, Thw Twins, The SKR crew, Salty those episodes rank higher as the steam team characters bar edward are writte. Badly (Henry and Toby), Overused (Gordon, James, Percy) or extremely overused/shoehorned every episode (Thomas) and Emily I only like a handful of her episodes mlstly her pre steam team ones) which is somewhat due to me having Duck and Oliver as my favourites and Duck was going to be steam team but in the Brenner Era I enjoy some emily episodes again but mostly (I think it was bwba) where she got her number). I think the steam team basicially was a bad idea as the show was better as an essamble. Id have prefered a quota that Thomas has to appear in a role for say 10 episodes (not always as a lead) and the rest can be devoted to other characters/areas and Tidmouth back to being whoever is near at night
Thomas, Edward, Henry, Gordon, James, Percy and Toby are like main characters to me and other fans which is obvious from the first season so perhaps a main group is required for them regardless of ensemble.
@davidbrennan3967 Edward was the only one who didn't suffer too badly from overuse or bad writing.
From season 8 onwards episodes focusing on anyone else was rare or they'd be shoved into a co lead lead role. Thomas and Percy suffer with it the worst
And also Toby, Edward and Henry were written off the main cast in later seasons.
The show should have remained ensemble preventing overuse forcing the steam team in every episode as a lead, Co lead. Like 1 episode lead each and rest can be supporting roles as the other characters get their stories
@davidbrennan3967 duck also is a main character. They ram out of episodes before his first story in the first season, went to England with the others and was going to be in the steam team. If we had to have a steam team it should be all engines 1-12 and Emily given her number earlier
@@Joey15811 At least The Brenner era give focus to other characters besides The Steam Team. Only trying to have you understand. Do Thomas and his friends from the first season feel like main characters to you?
@@Joey15811 If you mean by adding Oliver, Donald and Douglas in it then yes, I agree.
Do you guys think that season 19 is underrated?
Because i think it is
What do you guys think??
I think it's a middle of the road Brenner season. Not the best, but not the worst either.
we havent really seen the tracks buckle before? uhh Thomas Gets Bumped... XD
I forgot about that one...
@@thebrendamengine its all good lol i was confused though
How dare you take the idea I mentioned on Twitter and never made a video on??? 😡😡😡 JK good vid man
Thanks lol, tbf I've been working on this one for months. I started writing the script back in April 2022
Donald and Douglas arguing to much in Twin Trouble Bad Day At Castle Loch Love ME Tender and Emily in the Middle
I never noticed Ferdinand in Signals Crossed! Wow
I didn't notice myself until I saw it on the Thomas wiki
the top 3 felt verrrry forced
I think in my opinion that the brenner era (Seasons 19 to 21) is the only 'New Thomas' I like 👍 👌 dont worry, I still LOVE the classic series and model era though
I dont mind a shed for edward. It makes sense. Phillip shouldn't be at Wellsworth sheds
If it wasn't for the ending, I would've placed the episode a lot higher
Well at least they didn’t cry like children when he left.
A Shed For Edward should be the worst, but I get why Henry Spots Trouble is the worst. 3 strike formula, Henry being a dumbass, ugh. Signals Crossed is a bad concept. Toby shouldn’t be scared of the junction, he has been there dozens of times. Emily In The Middle is a guilty pleasure for me. Flatbeds Of Fear is sh*t, but I like how Emily is written as the voice of reason in it. Away From The Sea was a good concept. I kinda like seeing this insecure side of Salty, something you wouldn’t expect from such a nice guy like him. Stuck In Gear, Harvey’s insecurities are somewhat consistent given how he was in Harvey To The Rescue. But it is a bit extreme. The Frozen Turntable was a perfect story for Gordon, I love the beautiful night shots, and Gordon’s karma. To me, No Snow For Thomas is a repeat of Thomas, Emily & The Snowplow, but in that episode, Emily actually played a good part, whereas in No Snow, Emily is kinda an NPC. Daisy’s Perfect Christmas 🎄 is visually beautiful. The Fastest Red Engine On Sodor felt like a bit of a wake-up call for James. He doesn’t seem really boastful or annoying after this. And yes, the crash is f*cking awesome. In my top 10 crashes. Bill or Ben is just simple, enjoyable fun. The ending is beyond funny, the way they twist the punishment around in their favor is beyond priceless😂. I love the dynamic between James and Edward in All In Vain. Of course the Small Railway Engines stories would be at the top of the list. I’ll collect Take N Play versions of them all someday!
This whole video made me smile, I respect your dedication to make this.
You really like Mario don’t you
The fact you said Samson has a better character than Porter is unforgivable. I don’t hate Samson but since porter is my favorite cgi only character of the entire series, in my opinion, saying Samson is better than him when it comes to character is a sin.
Imo, Three Steam Engines Gruff is the worst of The Brenner Era. It’s so hard to get past Toby & Percy acting really timid, and whilst I do think the music was great in that scene when Thomas crosses the bridge, because the episode directly references Three Billy Goats Gruff so much, everything feels so contrived and so forced within that scene. And then all that suspense just disappears when it’s revealed the noises were by a cow. We couldn’t even get Thomas crossing the bridge so that the suspense is fulfilled before it’s ruined by Annie & Clarabel. It suuuucks
Fair enough, I know I'm in the minority when I say I kinda like it
The revival era should be like this era.
I hate the benaissance era sometimes
11:01 for me
21:48 21:48
All narrow gauge engines had been absent though 19-24 that was lame and at least the Trainz era of Thomas is half model half cgi has comfortable characters with same narrow gauge engines that truly has talk about them
1:37:07 *one of the best crushes of cgi series. XDDDD you're comparing real physical model crush to a cgi made one?
I mean, I do think The Fastest Red Engine on Sodor's crash is up there.
when i was 6 or 7 and 1st watched diesel and the ducklings i cringed too lol
i did not come here to hear about that God awful reboot.
Leave twin trouble alone
How dare you hate Luke new friend
As much as OII love the Brenner Era, I do hate how Sir Topham Hatt was treated. To me Big Freeze could've of been episode that Boco returned in to pull the Express.
YOURE INSULTING SOME OF THE BEST BRENNER ERA EPISODES! HOW DARE DOU?!!!!