Is MyWhoosh Better Than Zwift? A Cyclist’s Honest Thoughts

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @MikeJenicCycling
    @MikeJenicCycling  Місяць тому +5

    Thanks for watching, if you enjoyed this video then do check out some of my other videos and subscribe to the channel 🙂 Let me know if you have any questions about MyWhoosh in the comments!

    • @insidecyclingworld
      @insidecyclingworld Місяць тому

      Hey!!! Appreciate you checking out my virtual cycling channel where I ride and also focus on commentary for virtual cycling racers! Thanks and much appreciated 🙏🏻👍🚴😊

  • @jms493
    @jms493 Місяць тому +7

    Always good to have competition. I really enjoy the group riding in Zwift and even the group workouts. For that I don’t see me leaving Zwift.

  • @JBuchmann
    @JBuchmann 12 днів тому +4

    I'm super cheap when it comes to montly subscriptions. Especially for things i may only use a few/couple times a month. This is right up my alley, thanks for sharing :)

    • @shinobusensui9395
      @shinobusensui9395 День тому

      you look into the GTBike V
      Its a mod that allows you to use your indoor trainer to control the bike in GTA5.
      For a free option, its amazing and stats can be uploaded to Strava.

  • @norbertleitgeb6105
    @norbertleitgeb6105 24 дні тому +5

    I switched to MW because it is a good alternative to Zwift for my way of using it. This is riding in a number of new worlds (I know everything in Zwift already) and for workouts. I use it with an average Ipad connected to a TV and had no problems so far. Also my Polar heart rate monitor is always recognized immediately. A new pairing is only necessary if I have connected the HR monitor to any other device, like a Garmin watch, since my last MW session.
    I agree, the main downside at the moment is the lack of other riders on MW. This compared to the main advantage: Free of charge.
    The argument of sports washing, yes: If all my decisions as a consumer would consider all kind of misconducts on this planet, I would not be able to buy anything and especially no bikes and their components.

  • @deanb61
    @deanb61 19 днів тому +2

    Same as you I have a Wattbike and recently swapped from Zwift to MyWhoosh. I train mostly for Barcelona Ironman each October so I'm quite happy training on my own; however I will say that I have noticed more people joining the group rides over the past few weeks, there are now usually a small number of humans, in addition to the bots.
    One correction, at around 15 mins, you point to a figure and say 'there's only 2 people' on this ride. The figure you point at is the number of laps, not the number of people on that ride :) (I made that mistake too).
    Another useful feature is the MyBunch, this is a ride with bots at a specific watt/kg power output, similar to Zwift's Robopacers, except in my experience it's implemented better. Again, good for my Ironman training where I want a steady power output.

  • @stasheAUS
    @stasheAUS Місяць тому +11

    I went back to zwift as it just works...I had multiple issues with MW and I ended up pulling the pin.

    • @MikeJenicCycling
      @MikeJenicCycling  Місяць тому

      That's interesting, what issues did you have?

    • @MegaBigmule
      @MegaBigmule Місяць тому +1

      Indeed! What what!

    • @stasheAUS
      @stasheAUS Місяць тому +4

      Connection issues with devices, duplicate strava uploads or no uploads, warping bots, crashes, low fps on a decent gaming rig, and unreal engine crash errors on exiting. I might return in the next big update to see if any optimizations have been made, but in all fairness, zwift just works on my end without all these issues. In my opinion, Zwift looks better, and having those extra frames makes for a smoother experience. The social side of Zwift is amazing. Oh MW really need to sort out their app also. No flames this is my own opinion

    • @geoffwalmsley3066
      @geoffwalmsley3066 23 дні тому

      I run MW through a decent desktop, everything connects and it runs like a dream, my setup is a 2018 system running a good graphics card for the year the desktop was built, rog vega 56 pro, 16gb memory.you could pick this type of system up for £300/£400, less than 2 years Zwift subscription.

  • @ketle369
    @ketle369 Місяць тому +3

    The color of the line on the segment you are doing is showing also the color of the next. So that’s how it’s supposed to show how hard the next interval is. I only ride inside 1-2 times per week so I have just dropped Zwift and only use MyWhoosh on my iPad 10 now. Zwift is too expensive for my needs. Been using MW for over a year. First it was totally empty. More people now. I think it’s more popular in South America and Asia so more people are on it outside typical European time.

  • @yspegel
    @yspegel Місяць тому +4

    I always found Swift underwhelming for the price they were asking, for them increasing the price even more shows the lack of competitive app's. It's great for us users that there are coming new apps to compete.
    Thanks for this review, I'm sure going to try it this winter.

    • @erod707
      @erod707 Місяць тому +2

      I agree that’s why I left zwift

    • @ismellrudolph
      @ismellrudolph 28 днів тому +2

      Gtbike 5 is another great alternative, it requires a better computer set up but is super immersive with zwift play controllers as you can open world cycle around the whole of the gta5 map. I like to keep myself mentally engaged by attempting to get to locations by memory without the help of the map. Before I know it I've cycled 50 miles with very little mental effort to do so due to how much fun I'm having.

  • @ianrob4760
    @ianrob4760 26 днів тому +2

    so for me my trainer bike basically after years of punishment broke. So either I brought a cheap steel one for 700 or so and need to maintain or do I use the Zwift bike, and as I type I am awaiting the Zwift bike !! I used Mywhoosh, Indie, Rouvy, Bkool etc and eventually get bored of them. However always come back to zwift I guess and now tied in for app bar any structured workouts I could use another. in context Mywhoosh is free of course but it is very limited as compared to others I found plus ethical concerns over who backs it.

    • @ianrob4760
      @ianrob4760 26 днів тому +1

      oh my whoosh is full of bots !! to try and pretend it is popular I guess

  • @roboto25
    @roboto25 Місяць тому

    I primarily use MW for training, but I occasionally switch to Zwift for some competition or when there’s an exciting event like the ToW

  • @ABarnett
    @ABarnett Місяць тому +2

    14:50 you mentioned 3 people signed up, i think that is 3 laps not people?

    • @MikeJenicCycling
      @MikeJenicCycling  21 день тому +2

      You are right, and I don't even know why this slipped through! In the racing video I did I check correctly, tbh I should have realised in this as no mywhoosh race would have 3 people signed up so far ahead 🤣

  • @DavidAlfonso
    @DavidAlfonso 4 дні тому

    I would like to know your feedback on how realistic the pedaling sensation is, especially when climbing. I've always had the feeling that it penalizes the rider's weight excessively. Thanks for the video.

  • @VadIzm
    @VadIzm 2 години тому

    Hi, How do I invite a friend to go on a ride together?

  • @midhc5072
    @midhc5072 Місяць тому

    MyWhoosh works perfectly for me on Apple TV 4K. I had a family membership for my daughter and myself on Zwift and had constant problems with her set up. Both of us have no issues using MyWhoosh. The graphics are better and more routes are being added all the time. Where it fails is with the lack of auto descent with my Tacx turbo and the lack of upload to Garmin connect as the fit file numbers are never correct.

    • @garyewen1135
      @garyewen1135 26 днів тому

      Family membership on zwift? Is that a thing?

    • @midhc5072
      @midhc5072 26 днів тому +1

      @ child under certain age can have a free membership connected to a parent but, it has to be renewed periodically. Think it was every twelve months and my daughter’s achievements dropped off with each renewal.

  • @MatthewBlue-yg1wk
    @MatthewBlue-yg1wk Місяць тому +1

    Thanks, when you talked about editing workouts, I thought cit would let you edit duration and whole workout would be modified proportionately.

  • @mrmadmogli7
    @mrmadmogli7 Місяць тому +1

    Thanks for your Infos 👍 i Thank i will give MW a try …the grafic Looks much better than in Zwift

  • @John-zs5nw
    @John-zs5nw 11 днів тому +1

    with an RTX4070 I wouldn't call this midtiered gaming PC, it may be the mid-tiered NVidia graphics card but in the market you are pretty near the top for gaming graphics.

  • @paulgordon7526
    @paulgordon7526 13 днів тому

    I run MyWhoosh on an Honor Pad X9 4Gb ram 128Gb storage and it run's myWhoosh fine ... cost around £130

  • @anthonymian1242
    @anthonymian1242 Місяць тому +1

    I was zwift then went to mw and now im back to zwift just cause i need racing and every race i found on mw had 2 people in it.

  • @MarkRiddellRacing
    @MarkRiddellRacing Місяць тому +2

    And yet, even with a fairly decent gaming rig, there’s noticeable stuttering. Also, appears you’re a bit out of touch as Zwift have changed the elevation graph so worth making sure you are comparing against the current version.

  • @demonsteps
    @demonsteps День тому

    MW looks weird on Apple Tv and had many connections problems with my phone to get trainer, HR to connect. Game seems very "tunnel" like and not open world like zwift. MW game menu is bad with the appel remote, MW is also very clustered with signs mm in-game, almost no one online and it's impossible to see who's a bot and a real person.

  • @alantait5968
    @alantait5968 Місяць тому +1

    Nice review Mike I did download it as I liked the look of the graphics however I quickly discovered it doesn’t support all Apple TV generations.

    • @MikeJenicCycling
      @MikeJenicCycling  Місяць тому +2

      That's a shame, I've been super impressed but as said I have the luxury of a powerful PC to run it! You could maybe use a phone to give it a try?

  • @DaveRider719
    @DaveRider719 6 днів тому

    I stopped using MW because my char stopped earning xp. I dont know why 😀I made a second account and same experience but at a higher level. I am not sure if when you have more than 50k coins you stop earning xp. It's not a big issue but I want that all features works

  • @lucaslenoir2338
    @lucaslenoir2338 Місяць тому

    Anyone knows if they worked out the compatibility with the Zwift cogs?

  • @jakobjas4212
    @jakobjas4212 24 дні тому

    The worlds look great, there's something about the rider avatar that's a bit uncanny valley though. maybe I'm just too used to the Zwift avatars.

  • @chrisoliver6690
    @chrisoliver6690 Місяць тому

    Does it have a trainer difficulty setting?

  • @johnthebiker300
    @johnthebiker300 Місяць тому

    Not sure you can hike the price up from free. Start charging maybe. I did try installing on my IPad but it wouldn’t have left much space for anything else

  • @deDANIEL11609
    @deDANIEL11609 29 днів тому +1

    Why is myWoosh lagging so much, Ryzen 7 7700x and Rtx 4070 cannot run it?

    • @TheYondaime008
      @TheYondaime008 18 днів тому

      It is probably using the CPU for graphics instead of your GPU. It is what happened to me on my AMD.

    • @deDANIEL11609
      @deDANIEL11609 18 днів тому

      @@TheYondaime008 ah well, so would have to manually change that?

    • @deDANIEL11609
      @deDANIEL11609 18 днів тому

      @@TheYondaime008 just checked at it is using GPU as well

  • @slavzizek403
    @slavzizek403 Місяць тому +1

    very informative, thanks

  • @miketalley1666
    @miketalley1666 Місяць тому

    love it, never has crashed, graphics are stunning... compared to zwift

  • @andylewis4726
    @andylewis4726 24 дні тому

    Good overview thanks

  • @BurningHorizons
    @BurningHorizons Місяць тому

    Two things kill it for me vs Zwift. 1: The stuttering. I also have a high-end PC too and experience the same. It's so distracting. 2: There is no sense of speed, no matter how fast you are going, and because of that it just feels so boring. Fix those, and I'm all in.

  • @MrWobling
    @MrWobling Місяць тому

    Zwift have fixed the elevation graph - but currently only for following routes.

  • @redcup19999
    @redcup19999 Місяць тому +1

    Nice Video. BUT 30 FPS. On a 1500gbp gaming PC. It's a slideshow. I don't care how pretty it looks - it's not a smooth experience at all. Both Zwift and Training Peaks Virtual are smoother visually - and for me that's a deal breaker. It's really not hard for the Devs to target 60fps.

  • @All4Grogg
    @All4Grogg Місяць тому +10

    It is funded by the UAE government.
    Sportswashing to put it bluntly.
    That said, it's not a covert plot so much as a diplomatic effort.

    • @MegaBigmule
      @MegaBigmule Місяць тому

      Haha ! Winner winner chicken dinner!

  • @tj7875
    @tj7875 14 днів тому

    I'm on an 2024 M4 iPad Pro and MyWhoosh looks just amazing. The graphics are miles and miles better. I've been using Zwift for a long time and in comparison it looks really outdated. If you are running Zwift on a desktop Mac then it's somewhat ok. iOS on the other hand is just a pure insult to the eyes. Although, Zwift promised to make the graphics better for the M-Series of iOS devices it sill looks terrible. MyWhoosh smokes Zwift out of the window while running on an M4 iPad Pro . Not even close. I also own a workstation PC with a 4090 and it's really, really immersive, especially, with its additional 20gb+ of texture files and all the displacement and detail but I'd rather use an iPad with its 30w power draw instead. Cheers!

  • @xyxyxy1991
    @xyxyxy1991 Місяць тому +5

    I guess the main reason there is no cost is because it's made possible by UAE nation state. Money is no object.
    On a few points, Zwift has improved both the climb profile and also the mini map recently.
    No harm in seeing the alternatives though. Nice vid

    • @MikeJenicCycling
      @MikeJenicCycling  Місяць тому +1

      Thanks :)
      Didn't realise they'd changed the climb profile, will go check that out now!

    • @xyxyxy1991
      @xyxyxy1991 Місяць тому

      Also worth giving indievelo a go as well when you trying this stuff out

  • @ramsden35
    @ramsden35 Місяць тому +1

    Hmmmm that looks really good

  • @adamcoppock5018
    @adamcoppock5018 3 дні тому

    It's free to attract and build community density.

  • @duttyvegan
    @duttyvegan 16 днів тому +1

    Tried it, went back to zwift 😂

  • @paulgoucher6177
    @paulgoucher6177 23 дні тому +1

    I think it looks better than Zwift, don’t have any issues using iPhone 15pro and it always remembers my heart rate monitor.

  • @PedroPrego
    @PedroPrego Місяць тому +3

    It's free because its sports washing. You buy yourself some nice exposure/pr. In this case oil money UAE state

  • @decoherence926
    @decoherence926 16 днів тому +2

    Terrible graphics. I have top of the line gaming PC and it lags, speeds seem unreal, and the racing is just meh. Back to Zwift. For $20, I mean, c'mon gym memberships are five times that and people spend more on Netflix to sit around and get fat. Horses for courses, of course.

  • @StellasVegetablegardens
    @StellasVegetablegardens Місяць тому +1

    i like the idea of a free app however i personally find their graphics underwhelming- if it’s a game i want my avatar not to attempt looking like a real human it kills the balance and makes it difficult for me to enjoy the ride

    • @BarrioBarranco1
      @BarrioBarranco1 Місяць тому +2

      I only ride with first person POV, don't ever worry about what my avatar looks like!

    • @StellasVegetablegardens
      @StellasVegetablegardens Місяць тому

      @ good idea I might try it now that I have an iPad to which I can download it as I like the look of the roads

  • @Faustoverdenova
    @Faustoverdenova Місяць тому +4

    Why Free?? Its totally sponsored by the UAE ..That why its free .

    • @MegaBigmule
      @MegaBigmule Місяць тому +1

      It’s called sports washing.
      Makes UAE look not so harmful to human life…

    • @geoffwalmsley3066
      @geoffwalmsley3066 23 дні тому

      Stick to zwift and keep getting ripped off,I'm very happy getting it for free.

  • @repmortskcab8483
    @repmortskcab8483 Місяць тому +4

    Don't forget that once you opt in for MW terms and conditions for using the platform, guess who ownes your data. GDPR? LOL. And it's not free, we pay everyday in the form of overpriced oil.

    • @robertmichel8102
      @robertmichel8102 Місяць тому +1

      But you pay for the oil even when you do not use MW, so where is the difference?

    • @repmortskcab8483
      @repmortskcab8483 Місяць тому

      At least in Europe it's laws against government backed companies competing in the open market, but MW flies under the radar. Even if you mainly copy others innovations, it still cost money. Free service won't give much revenue to pay the bills

  • @r3gflm916
    @r3gflm916 Місяць тому

    Thanks Mark Zuckerberg! I think I'll give it a try.

  • @SimonTheChimp
    @SimonTheChimp Місяць тому

    Sports washing, will not be using it

  • @EssKayTee1
    @EssKayTee1 20 днів тому +3

    Depends if you want to use an app bankrolled by a nation state with a very questionable human rights record. Sportswashing at its finest.

    • @hugodias5056
      @hugodias5056 9 днів тому +1

      you mean the USA right?

    • @ZwiftDude
      @ZwiftDude 9 днів тому

      What about all the child exploitation going in the world right now, lithium extraction labour camps and sweat shops the West so depends on. So apparently disguised human rights violations is OK.

    • @EssKayTee1
      @EssKayTee1 9 днів тому

      @hugodias5056 Not sure why USA would bankroll MyWhoosh but the UAE certainly do.

    • @hugodias5056
      @hugodias5056 9 днів тому

      @@EssKayTee1 when you mentioned questionable human rights record ( i mean guantanano and waterboarding did happen amongst many other things USA leaders refused to answer for ) let's not forget illegal war that has killed milions , I'd call that a human rights record to not be illegally invaded and have your country raped and destroyed by a foreign illegal power. And most important lets not forget the American company Nike who has supported drug programmes and cheaters as well as abusing athletes as slaves. Those living in glass houses should shut the fuck up about other nations.

    • @blaquaman1739
      @blaquaman1739 8 днів тому

      Myself and my ancestors faced unfair equal rights in the USA. I live on an island now filled with immigrants that are here because the USA nuked them soooo…