How can you tell how well proofed your dough is?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 жов 2022

КОМЕНТАРІ • 900

  • @MaryGraceBread
    @MaryGraceBread  Рік тому +821

    If you wanna learn more about how to make the most delish sourdough bread without it being stressful or complicated, my book, Live Laugh Loaf is for you!
    It’s available as an ebook
    www.marygracebread.com.au/shop/p/ebook-live-laugh-loaf
    and a printed book too:
    www.marygracebread.com.au/shop/p/print-live-laugh-loaf
    You’ll find beginners recipes for making a starter and your first loaf on my site too! And some troubleshooting tips for common questions 💗💗💗
    www.marygracebread.com.au/troubleshooting
    www.marygracebread.com.au/recipes
    I just wanna help you make good bread ✨✨🍞🍞

    • @Terratetradon
      @Terratetradon Рік тому +3

      Why is it gray

    • @erikadelisle8792
      @erikadelisle8792 Рік тому +8

      @@Terratetradon Part of the dough is colored with butterfly pea, which has a natural blue tint

    • @martaleszkiewicz5115
      @martaleszkiewicz5115 Рік тому +4

      @@erikadelisle8792 I just came to ask why it's blue marbled, thanks for answering in advance!

    • @dreyhawk
      @dreyhawk Рік тому +1

      Have you ever tried making a gluten free sourdough bread? I love watching bread being made but I have Celiac disease and can't eat the majority of them. I'm hoping to give it a try soon as sourdough is my favorite bread.

    • @spanqueluv9er
      @spanqueluv9er Рік тому +2

      @MaryGraceBread It’s ^*over-proofed and ^*under-proofed, not overproved and underproved.👌

  • @lifegoeson7745
    @lifegoeson7745 Рік тому +5275

    Why am I so satisfied by this-😭

  • @omnipotentfaces1514
    @omnipotentfaces1514 Рік тому +4809

    It’s also no biggie if it is over or under proofed because it will still likely taste delish and non bakers don’t know! Just saying as alot of online recipes put tons of pressure on ‘perfection’

    • @midnightgir6
      @midnightgir6 Рік тому +29

      Does anyone know what kind of bread this is?

    • @LeonetteGo
      @LeonetteGo Рік тому +140

      @@midnightgir6 based on how it was cooked it might be a sourdough-based loaf.

    • @midnightgir6
      @midnightgir6 Рік тому +20

      @@LeonetteGo Are they normally gray?

    • @JacquelineUnderwood
      @JacquelineUnderwood Рік тому +116

      @@midnightgir6 no, some form of colorant or colored flavor has been added to it

    • @SaintShion
      @SaintShion Рік тому +62

      @@JacquelineUnderwood A lot of ppl are complaining about the color cause it looks like mold. I love Taro, it reminds me of that. I do think it could have been more purple less blue tho.

  • @gerardosuarez1451
    @gerardosuarez1451 Рік тому +261

    Everyone’s a gangsta until homie pulls out Damascus bread 💀

    • @Criggster
      @Criggster 9 місяців тому +29

      “Dough smiths, your challenge today is to take these two types of flour and create a multi layered Damascus loaf”

    • @Famedv
      @Famedv 9 місяців тому +9

      LMFAOOOO i thought she was cooking bread with mold or sum i was so confused 😭

  • @runespoon001
    @runespoon001 Рік тому +577

    Every time these pop up on my feed, it makes me want to go bake some bread

  • @Lucy-fn9rj
    @Lucy-fn9rj Рік тому +46

    seeing them side by side is really helpful! because now i know i’d prefer it to be over proofed than under proofed

  • @Mossmuncher-zm8gx
    @Mossmuncher-zm8gx Рік тому +936

    Never seen a channel make big poofy bread before... I like this!

    • @moonbitt
      @moonbitt Рік тому +11

      I think it’s called tiger bread if you want to try it!

    • @BiaRosy
      @BiaRosy Рік тому +3

      Why is it grey?

    • @Leszaire
      @Leszaire Рік тому +2

      Everything reminds me of her!

    • @eanewto1532
      @eanewto1532 Рік тому

      Poofy 😂 yes very good word

    • @Mossmuncher-zm8gx
      @Mossmuncher-zm8gx Рік тому

      How else would you describe it other than poofy?

  • @hunnybee7785
    @hunnybee7785 Рік тому +145

    I would be so extremely interested if you made a longer youtube video talking about beginner bread making tips or a beginner recipe!!! I absolutely love the shorts you post, they just always make me want to watch a longer bread video 😊

  • @yeddy_da_deddy8539
    @yeddy_da_deddy8539 Рік тому +314

    I have no idea what u just said lol

    • @Mysterious-Night
      @Mysterious-Night Рік тому +64

      A not as developed loaf looks like SpongeBob inside and a loaf that is developed too much looks like a honeycomb inside

    • @serenadingstarz
      @serenadingstarz Рік тому +8

      @@Mysterious-Night which is better?

    • @maxkurant1470
      @maxkurant1470 Рік тому +35

      @@serenadingstarz I think the point is neither is best, you want it to be in the middle. Personally I prefer overdeveloped loaves than under if I had to choose. They have more flavor usually

    • @oulafursson
      @oulafursson Рік тому +4

      @@serenadingstarz the one that you need is the best... :)

    • @justanotherhappyhumanist8832
      @justanotherhappyhumanist8832 9 місяців тому +2

      Glad I’m not the only one haha

  • @hannahm5574
    @hannahm5574 Рік тому +122

    OKAY! SO, I baked sourdough for a year and STRUGGLED so hard with fermentation and getting the proof right. I am just now realizing after giving up a year and a half ago that i was under proofing. What a simple solution that i couldn't find anywhere, thank you so much lol

    • @Johncowk
      @Johncowk 9 місяців тому +2

      Yeah sourdough needs time, much more than yeast.

  • @benjamingames1765
    @benjamingames1765 Рік тому +8

    Best way to tell if the dough is proofed well enough is to poke it and if it bounces back out it’s underproofed, if you press in and it starts collapsing below and around where you pressed it’s over proofed and if it doesn’t pop back or deflate and leaves a solid fingerprint in place it’s usually ready to go

    • @poogitypooheh
      @poogitypooheh Місяць тому

      I have heard this many times, but honestly I never found this to be true, at least for my case

  • @katiekawaii
    @katiekawaii Рік тому +6

    It would be really helpful to get a comparison that also includes a well-proved loaf as well

  • @DForDelecTable
    @DForDelecTable Рік тому +73

    Really interesting. Love your videos! 🍞💕

  • @livewithmanon6443
    @livewithmanon6443 Рік тому +25

    I like the "overproved" one😅

  • @darinakalinova2180
    @darinakalinova2180 Рік тому +5

    I just love what you do and I do admire your knowledge.

  • @rockyxbautista
    @rockyxbautista Рік тому +1

    i always love whenever surge uses the black gloves !! it’s so visually pleasing.

  • @forg5580
    @forg5580 Рік тому +1

    I love how poetic you are about bread

  • @owlrose2855
    @owlrose2855 Рік тому +5

    So interesting! The breads look amazing

  • @MistressOP
    @MistressOP Рік тому +104

    What does a good loaf look like?

    • @cz5696
      @cz5696 Рік тому +2

      Fr

    • @Pakilla64
      @Pakilla64 Рік тому

      CHONKY

    • @hibernate44
      @hibernate44 10 місяців тому +8

      Depends on what you want it for
      For sandwiches you want a tighter crumb that’s more uniform and dense
      For dipping in soup/sauces you want a nice open crumb that soaks up the juices

    • @MistressOP
      @MistressOP 10 місяців тому

      this is really good info. i wish they let you bookmark comments @@hibernate44

    • @SomethingEasty
      @SomethingEasty 9 місяців тому

      It says, "Wonderbread" on it

  • @kall_me_krazi
    @kall_me_krazi Рік тому +2

    Great tip!! Thanks for sharing!!

  • @chiaseed9683
    @chiaseed9683 Рік тому +1

    Really cool marbling effect

  • @mazzyg6186
    @mazzyg6186 Рік тому +551

    How did you get that lovely blurple color? 😍

  • @sam250291
    @sam250291 Рік тому +54

    You know you're not ready to bake your own bread when both of these look perfectly fine and amazing to you 😂

  • @andersnrregren9087
    @andersnrregren9087 Рік тому +1

    I love the baked in mold look

  • @Thingsthatexistsonoccasion
    @Thingsthatexistsonoccasion Рік тому +50

    Everytime I see the marbled bread, my brain goes "why is it moldy" or "why does it look moldy" like, I want my brain to stop, I just want to enjoy the bread 😭😭

    • @carmelitajones7779
      @carmelitajones7779 Рік тому +1

      I was thinking it looks moldy too.

    • @potxtoe
      @potxtoe 9 місяців тому

      ​@@carmelitajones7779im pretty sure that's just how sourdough bread is due to fermentation? Idk im not a bread maker

    • @tamz0309
      @tamz0309 7 місяців тому

      she added some flavoring to it.

    • @charlespartak2435
      @charlespartak2435 Місяць тому

      It's not moldy ... she took two differently flavored doughs and folded together...think marble rye .

  • @Caycee.
    @Caycee. Рік тому +7

    Now I know how Paul can tell how things are overproved just by looking

  • @MrYatesj1
    @MrYatesj1 6 місяців тому

    The Bread Whisperer :-). Love it

  • @alohatvj
    @alohatvj Рік тому +2

    The bread 🍞 looks so amazing 👏 😍.

  • @Evistopheles
    @Evistopheles Рік тому +7

    I’ll probably never reach perfection but once it gets warmer again I’ll start small and try making my first sourdough starter. Maybe I’ll actually be able to make up recipes from scratch one day! Just gotta learn the golden ratios.

    • @Yuri-hv6zl
      @Yuri-hv6zl Рік тому +1

      Try using a kitchen scale it makes a difference

    • @Evistopheles
      @Evistopheles Рік тому +1

      @@Yuri-hv6zl I always do. Using those weird measuring cups/spoon things offends my eyes and my need for perfection. One of the reasons why I haven’t tried sourdough yet is that I am too much of a perfectionist :|

  • @t.hannahxx
    @t.hannahxx Рік тому +49

    Why didn’t you show the correct loaf after showing the 2 incorrect loaves 😓😑😢

    • @MaryGraceBread
      @MaryGraceBread  Рік тому +63

      They’re not incorrect. Both are good and tasty. Proofing is a spectrum and those are closer to those two different ends of the spectrum.

    • @rwbycouch7300
      @rwbycouch7300 Рік тому

      @@MaryGraceBread
      You remind me of Colette in Ratatouille when she was explaining that,"-how good bread is without tasting it? Not the smell, not the look, but the sound of the crust. 'crunching noises' Only good bread sounds like this." Also bread can look so pretty😍 Sometimes too pretty to eat

  • @squiddies6896
    @squiddies6896 Рік тому +1

    the colour is amazing omg,, such pretty bread too??? I have an urge to bake now

  • @IDGAF999
    @IDGAF999 3 місяці тому

    I absolutely love the relating tou do with your bread. Thank you for existing in this way❤

  • @elemonade8830
    @elemonade8830 Рік тому +3

    Look, child. This is how the legend of The Bread Whisperer began.

  • @cold4123
    @cold4123 Рік тому +13

    Bread 👍

  • @justinbouchard
    @justinbouchard 10 місяців тому

    you absolutely nailed this

  • @pamelamatney6963
    @pamelamatney6963 Рік тому +1

    I absolutely love this helpful video not just for food but in life in general !!! Much Love !!! Everyone Please Be Safe & Take Time, Good Care Of Yourself & Your Loved Ones ❤ Much Love ❤️

  • @angelicsailor1st
    @angelicsailor1st Рік тому +6

    I personally like over proofed as I find it’s a bit softer which is what I prefer in all bread 😅

    • @suew4609
      @suew4609 Рік тому +1

      So, that's what makes the bread softer? Thanks, I want softer and less holes in my bread!

  • @haerin-is-life
    @haerin-is-life Рік тому +21

    I love learning about bread and I’m wondering what that grey/purple thing is In The middle?

    • @rae4166
      @rae4166 Рік тому +20

      Agree...looks like mold haha

    • @TheSarahskaninchen
      @TheSarahskaninchen Рік тому +5

      I am totally unsure. Could be food colouring, could be an added ingredient Like beets, or maybe some Kind of Special grain? Dont know for wheat, but purple corn and purple potatoes exist.

    • @rae4166
      @rae4166 Рік тому +2

      @@TheSarahskaninchen this is exactly why I'm so curious 😂 it could be many things and i wanna know which ! Haha

    • @ninjacell2999
      @ninjacell2999 Рік тому +2

      @@TheSarahskaninchen i was thinking blue corn too, as the rest of the loaf is a bit yellow?

    • @TheSarahskaninchen
      @TheSarahskaninchen Рік тому +1

      @@ninjacell2999 yes i See what you mean. But it wont be 100% corn in sourdough bread i think. More Like some wheat/rye Mix probably.

  • @veryconfused273
    @veryconfused273 Рік тому +1

    your bread always looks so good, I wish I could eat it

  • @mod_myst
    @mod_myst 11 місяців тому +1

    Both of those look good in their own way! Assuming they taste fine flavor wise.

  • @ebl36
    @ebl36 Рік тому +4

    we listen to our cakes, and now we have to analyse the crumb of our bread

  • @AlisonNevilleSOULutionist
    @AlisonNevilleSOULutionist Рік тому +5

    They both look perfect to me…

    • @mimoleta
      @mimoleta Рік тому +1

      Right ? Give me your "fails" and I'll eat them lmao no questions asked

  • @evan8463
    @evan8463 Рік тому

    This is the first video that actually explained what to look for in a crumb in a way i understand

  • @mintz276
    @mintz276 Рік тому

    THAT LOOKS SOOO GOOOD

  • @lillia2479
    @lillia2479 Рік тому +6

    My bread is soulless... completely burnt through and through... 😆

  • @scorpion_336
    @scorpion_336 Рік тому +4

    wait… why is it that color? 😅 what am I missing

  • @charlottepreston1947
    @charlottepreston1947 Рік тому

    Just WOW! Thank you for an amazing video!

  • @bananapeel7636
    @bananapeel7636 9 місяців тому

    Apparently baking bread is apart of my algorithm, I fw it.

  • @ThatTallBrendan
    @ThatTallBrendan Рік тому +3

    The uncooked bread looks kinda like that dead bird Filthy Frank was playing with that one time.. Y'all remember that?

  • @newskooter6463
    @newskooter6463 10 місяців тому +3

    bro that dough looks mouldy af

  • @emmadalton3864
    @emmadalton3864 Рік тому

    She’s so satisfying

  • @41koaw
    @41koaw Рік тому

    Ugh it's gorgeous

  • @chloewhat
    @chloewhat Рік тому +1

    Why is the only time I’ve ever heard ‘the eyes are the windows to the soul’ on Peppa pig?😂😅😂

  • @MissIsley
    @MissIsley Рік тому

    This is incredibly cool, thank you for sharing this part of your experience!

  • @dinogrl4102
    @dinogrl4102 9 місяців тому

    this bread looks amazing omg

  • @_anaflavia_
    @_anaflavia_ Рік тому

    I love making bread at home but I had no idea of this! Thank you!

  • @rayn3zart
    @rayn3zart Рік тому

    Bread is so fun to watch while it's being made

  • @ebasongaming
    @ebasongaming 9 місяців тому

    I was so focused on the bread making that I wasn't listening so I had to watch it twice lol

  • @Bllue
    @Bllue Рік тому

    They both look great to me

  • @Squidrue
    @Squidrue Рік тому

    Your videos make my day

  • @itsbreadie
    @itsbreadie Рік тому +1

    I am so down to watch around 10 hours of your videos about bread making from beginners to intermediate.

  • @teacheraprilrogers
    @teacheraprilrogers Рік тому +1

    Such good advice. I am making a new rustic Italian loaf that bakes on a pizza stone instead of the Dutch oven. I hope that it comes out good. So far it is rising beautifully. Thirty minutes and it will be in the oven.

  • @nornironniall
    @nornironniall Рік тому

    Either of those looks great to me

  • @coloredsomeone9750
    @coloredsomeone9750 Рік тому

    this looks delicious omg

  • @jenniferschoenmakers300
    @jenniferschoenmakers300 Рік тому +1

    You have a verry lovely voice i would live to have like a meditation class from you its so calming

  • @cynthiamachuga6146
    @cynthiamachuga6146 4 місяці тому

    Omg I wanna taste your bread! It looks so beautiful

  • @andrewheltne169
    @andrewheltne169 Рік тому

    Learning about how to make yummy bread more and more thanks to your videos.

  • @collingalbraith4343
    @collingalbraith4343 9 місяців тому

    See the breads soul morty, its there morty! Just look at it morty, ITS BEAUTIFUL

  • @michealwoods6771
    @michealwoods6771 11 місяців тому

    that bread is so beautiful

  • @christawarrington3795
    @christawarrington3795 Рік тому

    Very helpful, thank you

  • @lavender3082
    @lavender3082 Рік тому

    I am absolutely in love with all your lavender colored bread it’s my favorite color💜💜

  • @MSair-rd3hg
    @MSair-rd3hg Рік тому

    Until i came across your channel i just know how to eat bread but now as I am learning, i appreciate it more . Thanks 👍

  • @cheese_2002
    @cheese_2002 Рік тому

    i really love bread so much ❤️🥖

  • @griffindoe
    @griffindoe Рік тому

    that bread is so pretty omfg

  • @smithchasea
    @smithchasea Рік тому

    I’d love to have an oven like that!!!

  • @etflu
    @etflu Рік тому

    This looks so fucking tasty I love bread

  • @dtulip1
    @dtulip1 Рік тому

    they ALL look delicious

  • @zacharysherry2910
    @zacharysherry2910 4 місяці тому

    They both look good 👍

  • @barryirlandi4217
    @barryirlandi4217 Рік тому

    Brilliant

  • @apocalyptica003
    @apocalyptica003 Рік тому

    Omg I haven't baked sourdough in a couple years but cutting into that loaf for the first time to examine the crumb is one of my favorites

  • @msfistfightsvsfences
    @msfistfightsvsfences Рік тому +2

    It would be nice to see a loaf that is proofed the right amount of time for comparison.

  • @andrearc3002
    @andrearc3002 5 місяців тому

    I got into sourdough baking this winter. The weather near me has warmed considerably and I'm learning that my warmer home really speeds up the first proof. My last two batches of bread have been ovenproofed. I tried to make sourdough soup bowls and ended up making hockey pucks. I'm having a new oven installed today and will be starting a new batch of sourdough. I'll be paying extra close attention to the fermentation process to avoid overproofed sticky dough.

  • @MF-lj6se
    @MF-lj6se 3 місяці тому

    I had an overproof today, it looked exactly like you showed.

  • @Sp0ngeBob_SquarePants
    @Sp0ngeBob_SquarePants Рік тому +1

    I!!!
    NEED!!!
    THAT!!!
    B R E A D ! ! !

  • @Low-Quality-Fish
    @Low-Quality-Fish Рік тому

    It has a soul and i’ve been eating it

  • @Norimin
    @Norimin Рік тому

    beautiful

  • @redtidalwave3377
    @redtidalwave3377 Рік тому

    I like your oven! The bread is nice too..

  • @RH-cv1rg
    @RH-cv1rg 9 місяців тому

    I've never seen a bread that comes pre-baked with mold already in it. Amazing.

  • @Sir-Reborn
    @Sir-Reborn 9 місяців тому

    The over-proofed one looks softer, so that's a bonus

  • @fawshu
    @fawshu Рік тому +1

    „The souuuul“
    😱

  • @seanlee408
    @seanlee408 10 місяців тому

    The bread whisperer

  • @Ben-nf7it
    @Ben-nf7it Рік тому

    Thanks bread lady

  • @knifeturtle
    @knifeturtle Рік тому

    multicolored bread is everything to me

  • @Clv_nts.
    @Clv_nts. Рік тому +1

    :me not listening because it looks so good

  • @akizaangrorec2305
    @akizaangrorec2305 Рік тому +2

    Can u make a sourdough taro bread. Looks so similar to Chinese taro bread with the marbling.

  • @somethingcats
    @somethingcats Рік тому

    I have watched this like three times without paying any attention to your voice and just being mesmerized by the process... I also did realize by the third time that you were in fact talking lmao

  • @Uprightwatches
    @Uprightwatches Рік тому

    Yum

  • @UntamedEtherealOfficial
    @UntamedEtherealOfficial Рік тому

    Idgaf what it looks like i’m gonna eat that blue bread 😍

  • @djoraxxxxxx5412
    @djoraxxxxxx5412 Рік тому

    Bread woth cement looks nice

  • @tinkertailorgardenermagpie
    @tinkertailorgardenermagpie Рік тому

    So what’s it SUPPOSED to look like? Both those souls look delicious.