Neil Young "Heart of Gold" REACTION & ANALYSIS by Vocal Coach / Opera Singer
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 сер 2021
- Yup. "Old Man" by Neil Young hit me in the feels, and I wanted to circle back to another of his hits based on your recommendations. This song was short but emotional, and really brought me back to my days working on the orchard with my family. This resonated with me so much.
Join professional opera singer Elizabeth Zharoff, as she listens to Neil Young performing "Heart of Gold” live.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Performed by Neil Young - Words and Music by Neil Young
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I definitely recommend watching the original video without interruptions, here's the link: • Neil Young - Heart Of ...
Show Neil Young some love: / @neilyoungchannel
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WE HAVE MERCH! Check-out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎧 Elizabeth’s favorite headphones 🎧 : imp.i114863.net/zayoEM
Music Gear Questions? 🎤 See my list of recommendations: imp.i114863.net/yRyGoV
WANT MY CHAIR? I don’t blame you…and here’s a link to make it even sweeter:
secretlab.co/?rfsn=4692958.b2...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎙️Podcast: thecharismaticvoice.com/podcast/
🌐Website: thecharismaticvoice.com
📸Instagram: / thecharismaticvoice
🧑🤝🧑Patreon: / thecharismaticvoice
📺Twitch: / thecharismaticvoice
📰Our FREE Newsletter: eepurl.com/gz7Z_z
-------------------------------------COURSES------------------------------------------
🎵MUSIC APPRECIATION COURSE🎵
Want to understand how to listen to and appreciate music more? My Music Appreciation course is now live. Take a look at thecharismaticvoice.com
🎶DEMYSTIFYING SINGING🎶
My intensive 7-week course on vocal foundations includes weekly group sessions and private lessons. Learn more at thecharismaticvoice.com.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elizabeth Zharoff is an international opera singer and voice coach, with 3 degrees in voice, opera, and music production. She's performed in 18 languages throughout major venues in Europe, America, and Asia. Currently based somewhere between Los Angeles and Tucson, Arizona, Elizabeth spends her days researching voice, singing, teaching, writing music, and recording TONS. She also plays Diablo and Dungeons & Dragons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Want a free voice lesson? Sign-up to WIN at mailchi.mp/thecharismaticvoic...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#NeilYoung #Reaction #TheCharismaticVoice
-------------
We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
Here's another one for you..mind blowing song lyrics...
ua-cam.com/video/0c4v7fp5GC8/v-deo.html
This would be another great one to do..
ua-cam.com/video/_MOavH-Eivw/v-deo.html
I really want to see your eyes pop out when you listen to crazy horse. Something like down by the river, Hey Hey My My, Southern man, or Cinnamon Girl. Much harder and electric
Gordon Lightfoot is phenomenal: Wreck of the Edmund's Fitzgerald or Sundown
OR........ Southern Cross by Crosby, Stills and Nash.......🙂
My favorite Neil Young quote: “It’s more important to have an honest singing voice than a “good” one.”
During the recording of "We Are the World" the following discourse ensued between producer/musician David Foster and Neil Young:
David Foster: Hey Neil! Can we do another take on that part of yours? You're a bit off key!
Neil Young: No Dave.....it's my thing, that's my sound man!
🤣🤣🤣
Watch the movie made in heaven Neil Young does a cameo he plays a truck driver picking up a hitchhiker the Hitch-Hiker ask him where he's going. Neil Young responded if you don't know where you're going it doesn't matter what road you take. That's my favorite quote by him PS Tom Petty did a cameo and so did Ric Ocasek pretty good movie
I'd rather have both.
@@OnceAndFutureKing That's the truth
He had both what unique great voice
My favorite quote about Neil: "He doesn't sing his songs, he bleeds them".
That expresses exactly what I feel when I see him performing. You can see it in the contortions he does with his face. It's all emotion that drives it.
"Sang" is the word for "blood", in French... ;)
Neil Young was 27 when this track was released and he sang that he was growing old. He was an old soul in a young man's body even at that time. When David Crosby met Neil Young he said that he pulled up and Neil sang to him 3 or 4 of the best songs he had probably ever heard.
It was released 2 months after he turned 26. But your point was right on. He was an old soul. Listen to After the Gold Rush he was 23-24 when he recorded those songs. He was wise beyond his years.
Indeed. The genius of “Ambulance Blues.” Written when he was 24. 2 lines: “I never knew a man who could tell so many lies. He had a different story for every set of eyes. How can he remember who he’s talking to? But I know it isn’t me and I hope it isn’t you.” “You’re only pissing in the wind. You don’t know it, but you are. And there ain’t nothing like a friend who will tell you you’re just pissing in the wind.” Genius. Neil’s catalogue has been the centerpiece Soundtrack for this 65 year old’s life.
remember these were the days when we said don't trust anyone over 30. Hitting 30 was far worse than any decade I hit and I'm in my 7th decade now.
I was at a recording session with Stephen Stills and he talked about a time when CSNY met to demo new songs for an album. He said that the rest of the band had a new song. Neil had enough for the whole album. He’s just that prolific.
Remember -- 5 years earlier the byword was "don't trust anyone over 30."
I've no idea why, but I cry every time. He's always searching and never finding the heart of gold. And even at that young age, he feels time is running out. And it's so beautiful.
of course he has found love, lost it and found it again.
Spot on iris. Nobody will ever convince me that Heart of Gold is anything other than a 'lost love' song. You can feel the pain in his voice.
Each time I hear this song, tears fill my eyes. Right to the soul.
Imagine to live Your whole life with a disease that kills you in 24h if You dont take Your insulin.
definitely worth checking out "the needle and the damage done", one of the most haunting songs he ever did. and staggeringly beautiful.
I agree. I think it is closely related to this song. (See my remarks above.)
Hardly any bad tracks on the Harvest album. Needle is hauntingly 'beautiful'.
I definitely have to agree with you
Absolutely, Harvest was definitely his signature album Barr None ! I agree with you on "Needle and the Damage Done" being the BEST SONG among many on that Album !✌💯
Seconded!! Elizabeth - please react to this song, too!
"I don't know if I have charisma or not, but I know I can't sing. But it doesn't really matter. I'm around the note somewhere. I'm near it. I know it. It knows me. We've been together for a while. Not for long though. " Neil Young at his inauguration into the Canadian Songwriters Hall Of Fame, 2017. A proud Canadian.
And a fantastic naturaly beautiful voice. A gift.
He's a singer-songwriter, singing his compositions. Not an amazing singer but he got it done.
You don't have to be good to be great, man. Love that energy. I had a biology teacher that used to say "close enough is good enough" and that's become such an important phrase for me because I am a perfectionist to such a prohibitive degree.
Great lines! We'll said Neil. 👏
Neil Young released one of the greatest folk/classic rock albums ever with Harvest. Neil has a very infectious voice and the lyrics on the album are great. No wonder Dylan was jealous of it.
I'd like to think that what Neil is searching for via this song, isn,t an external heart of gold (someone else who has a heart of gold), rather he is searching within himself for a heart of gold.
My interpretation of this song has changed jarringly over the years. Here's my story . . .
I was 16 years old when the song came out and it was one of my very favorite songs of the '70s. I interpreted it as he was looking for a girlfriend that he could spend the rest of his life with who had a heart of gold. But now that I have grown and changed so has my interpretation . . .
I'm now convinced that he intended it as a song about a person searching for his or her heart of gold inside. That's tipped off by the first verse in which he says
I want to live, I want to give . . .
It's these expressions I never give
That keep me searching for a heart of gold.
In other words, he's looking for something deep inside that right now he cannot express. . . But if he can reach his own heart of gold, then he will be able to be the type of person that he longs to be.
In verse 2 he likens the great distances from Hollywood to Redwood and crossing the ocean -- to the distances he's traveling in his mind, internally, to find that Heart of Gold. Because that is where it can be found.
And the optimism, to me, comes from his unwritten implication that everyone has that Heart of Gold inside -- if they just do the work that needs to be done to access and express it.
He tricked me too. I found a woman of a heart of gold. It was my mom.
💗🏅💗
That was an excellent analysis.
How fascinating. I’d never thought of this song in the way you have now that we are older. I’m slightly younger than you. Love reading these comments!
Great interpretation. I'll think of that when I'm listening to Heart of Gold in the future.
"I'm spoiled by metal" that was the most beautiful thing I've ever heard anyone say.
I loved when she said that, too! Metal does indeed spoil you :)
Some rare artists transcend all genres and touch our collective souls at the core. This ethereal and eternal quality is this guy's life blood. And I doubt anyone would not agree...even Dylan.
cracked me up, Elizabeth...but Truth :)
@@karenwindham507 spoiled by metal lol
Godfather of Metal i see that , i quit my band when i got to practice 1 night and they were doing Nirvana , i said hell no later
It’s not Hollywood or Redwood that’s important to Neil Young - it’s what is in his mind that matters. He’s hopeful, he’s searching for a heart of gold, that’s what matters to him. And look how how he carries the whole story. He’s so skilled.
Neil Young is so underrated as a songwriter and multi-instrumentalist, even after decades I often stop in my tracks when I hear a classical chord progression or time shift. Absolutely adore his music, it has such a wide range of styles and collaborations over the years too (Buffalo Springfield, CSNY, Crazy Horse, Pearl Jam, etc...)
The pride of Canada. Neil is not only a wonderful singer, but also a prolific songwriter and musician. Thank you so much for doing this! ♥️🇨🇦🍁🎵
As good as he is, I think Rush hold that title.
A poet, I would say!
@@leofinley4144 oh believe me I love them too. I was thinking more as a solo artist. Rush are incredible. RIP Neil Peart ♥️
@@dirkkruisheer most definitely 🎶
Canada's got a lot of singers to be proud of. I am hoping for some Gordon Lightfoot, but, we'll see. :)
Linda Ronstadt singing backup on the studio version is still my favorite part.
Linda Ronstadt and James Taylor
I was just thinking that while this is a great version, I still prefer the studio because of the backup singers. I didn't know that was Linda Ronstadt, but that makes sense.
Wasn't Nicolette Larson singing backup with Linda..
Oh my my, How did I not recognise her after all these years of knowing the song. Thanks for pointing it out.
Neil Young has honestly had a very hard life. His music really reflects that.
When Neil Young hits the ball, it goes out of the park. Such a talented dude.
Nice baseball analogy 🌍🍄
I personally think that Neil Young is one of the most important musicians of the twentieth century, but his real greatness will be found only decades from now. He has been ahead of his time in many ways, you cannot understand the whole punk and grunge without understanding his influence
I agree. His music will live on, just like that of The Beatles, for millennia to come.
Neil is bad ass and always has been. Listen to all of his stuff.
So Neil Young has been one of my favorite artists/ musicians/ songwriters since I was young ironically. I’m 71 now . I remember probably being 17 or 18 and listening to his album After the Gold Rush very often.
This song Searching For A Heart of Gold is an all time classic.
In our culture we’re taught to search for the pot of gold . This song obviously focuses on a deeper meaning of life . To me it’s the real message in life finding the higher meaning of why we are here . Finding the true purpose of life . Finding that feeling that connects us to our heart that innately feels good within us . We are after all mortal and immortal beings . This time of life we have is temporary. Those who seek and find that the answer is within and oh by the way it feels great to feel that spark of the divine that is inside of us . Then life makes sense amongst so much that doesn’t make sense .
It’s a beautiful song that has an eternal message for the ages 🙏👌😊☮️
You have a bit (or more) of the poet in you. Nicely put.
I bought this as a fresh faced 15 year old hippy still at school. Harvest , the album Heart of Gold comes off , is still one of my all time favourite albums.❤️😁🤩😃
i wore out my copy long ago too
I think lyrically this is one of those songs where we bring our own perspective or baggage into it when it comes to interpretation; For me it is a song of wistful longing, an unending search for something we feel we'll never find.
This is the best comment I've ever seen on any video. Ever. Thank you, pencil necked
Agreed. The very best songwriters shape their lyrics to allow the listener to find their own life in another's words. We discover that we share these feelings with others and don't exist alone in the world.
Always loved this song. One of my favorite factoids is that, on the studio recording, the backup vocals are actually James Taylor and Linda Ronstadt, who happened to be in town for a TV spot. James was already known by then, but Linda hadn't had a single hit yet!
Linda did have hits but they were country not rock. Neil recorded this track in Nashville where Linda appeared on the Johnny Cash show
@@stormryder811 And she wasn't known yet as a solo artist but she was known for being the lead singer of The Stone Ponies.
I've always found a contrast between Neil's hopeful-sounding vocals and his plaintive harmonica solos in this piece. It's that tension that makes it for me.
Her expression says enough, she's melting by the beauty of this song.
Watching her reaction to "Old Man" and to "Heart of Gold" made me feel like I was listening to these songs again for the first time. I love her emotional reactions to both songs. Elizabeth, it would be interesting to see and hear your reaction to "Long May You Run", the best love song ever written...to a car.
Needle And The Damage Done is one of the greatest "social commentary" songs ever.
The Neil Young song to react to…”The Needle and the Damage Done.” The title, alone, pulls you in like a life preserver…that’s thrown in too late. Such a moving song on so many levels.
Neil Young is a great songwriter. He is a musical treasure. One of my all time favorites. I feel like his music resonates with a lot of people but not everybody likes him. I think Harvest saved my life. It helped me to break through a deep depression. I did find my heart of gold and we were together >45 years. I lost her in 2019.
I would suggest adding “Like A Hurricane” to the Neil to do list as well. I am just a dreamer but you are just a dream….
Yes!
Guitar playing in studio recording of Hurricane is (for me) the best I've ever listened to.
You could have been anyone to me
Neil had already had his back injury at the time of this recording. He is actually wearing a back brace at the the time of this concert tour, he references this on the Massey Hall 1971 concert recording when he drops his pick "bending over is not much fun"... this is probably why he was always hunched over in an abnormal posture during this BBC performance.
The wincing eyes and face, which most assume is emotional reaction to the lyrics, may well have been actual pain and discomfort from his injury.
Neil Young is a lyrical master. I’ve been listening to him for 45 years and he still has the gift
Neil Young is Bob Dylan to the 70's generation. Long may he run!
Neil is perfectly imperfect his voice and songs take me away from life's problems !
Neil Young is known as "the father of grunge" for his very strong influence on the West Coast emo acoustic singer songwriters of the 1990s, and their rock/metal contemporaries.
The poetic intelligence of lyrics in particular improved due to his influence, if it's not a good poem it's not often a good song.
Thats the worst thing they ever did to him , i bet most of those seatle dudes never listend to Neil
@@ricowhoo1313 Eh, I'm sure they did listen to him some. Chris Cornell was inspired by Down By the River when he wrote Burden in My Hand. I believe Pearl Jam and Neil Young also got to know each other and even played together.
The actual God father of the Grunge music movement. Neil Youngs a AMAZING musician and his career has been crazy from Motown to where he is now. Love Neil Young music.
This song is authentic and honest, yearning, a little melancholy due to the prospect of an endless search, yet hopeful because the songwriter refuses to give up in his search.
I can never decide if he’s talking about a heart of gold in others, or a heart of gold in himself…
I have always interpreted as he is looking for both, and only both will make one complete. It isn't necessarily one or the other, in my view.
@@greg967 for sure
Neil Young is the greatest singer/songwriter of all time, and a brilliant musician
Taking nothing from him, that's a bold statement.
He’s definitely more than the sum of his parts.
A Southern man don't need him around anyhow.
@@corbettmanley932 Review his life's work, the guy was a legend for three different generations.
Love Ms Zharoff with her passion and authenticity!
It is a sweet, positive song, which is something that Neil is not always about. The studio recording has Linda Ronstadt and James Taylor on backing vocals., which are amazing.
Neil Young's voice sounds the same live as he does in a studio recording. I love him. 🌹
This evokes memories of a bygone era. I'm getting so nostalgic.
Happens with AGE, doesn't it ?
@@corbettmanley932 Yes, this is what makes one realize how old one is.
Can the nostalgia be a stepping stone to understanding?
Brother Neil is either crying or dying. In the original track (on the record, Harvest), Linda Ronstadt backs him up at the end, clear as day! She's such a songbird :)
Had a day off and started to watch your takes on these songs and performances. Now I'm completely hooked and have a slight crush. 🥰😄
Left hand third finger.
@@corssecurity He said a crush, it's not a wedding proposal lol
@@imCurveee thou shalt not covet another man's wife. Heard that somewhere
Of course a duel is perfectly acceptable. To the Winer the spoils.
@@corssecurity Nobody cares man
@@imCurveee then why did you reply if you don't care.
Or maybe you are a nobody.
Ok if you say so.
But I am somebody and your wasting my time.
WHen music actually meant something, and actually conveyed something and more importantly, resonated in the heart of the listener.
It still does, it's just not "mainstream". UA-cam is a cornucopia of fine artists if you seek them out or stumble across them. Pretty much all I like about UA-cam. It's not the musicians that are lacking it's the industry and media and who they chose to promote or ignore.
I love the way he decays the last word of lines quite often. Neil always seems to sound like he's right next to you when he sings.
First time hearing it in 2021? Man am I old. I still find wisdom in this song and it still rings true today. Neil is genius at making music you can directly relate to. Now Neil and I really are old.
There are people your age that haven't heard all kinds of music. We all have different life experiences.
this is a really good song. not like my favourite super man song by the crash test dummies.
It does seem surprising if one has been exposed to this genre, especially for us who grew up in a certain time and environment. But she has been operating in different genres and has heard - and sung - a hell of a lot of great music that I (or we) have never heard, for sure. One lifetime is not enough to hear it all.
He didn’t want to be in the spotlight, yet he is on stage in a spotlight… which paradoxically makes the audience blacked out, as if he was singing only to himself.🤗
This song reminds me of my best friend who had a heart transplant at 14 and then past away at 22. He was the most amazing person and had a heart of gold.
The impression I got from this song by Neil is that he is searching for a heart of gold. . .for himself. Not that he's a "bad" person or anything, of course, but that he is striving to be what he aspires to be as a man. . .as a human being. Seeking for the truth of things; of how he can be and his potential, perhaps. And yes, this song was short but sweet 🎶👍
It is a pleasure to hear you review these classic songs by iconic artists.
I’m a first timer and glad it’s with my 2nd fave artist ever and one of his finest songs
“If it ain’t perfect- That’s perfect!”- Uncle Neil
I have always interpreted as a sad song. Someone looking for a person with a heart-of-gold to love, getting older, and not finding it.
It's amazing to see an analyzis by a professional musician on Neil Young, when she isn't familiar with his work. Neil has influenced an entire generation, if not two, through his gigantic life's work. I love him deeply.
Neil Young has long been one of my favourites. So much so that my fiancé and I will have our first dance to his 'Harvest Moon.' We're age 27 and 24, and we look forward to many more years of hearing his music. Hope to see him in person someday soon.
Neil's work covers a wide range of emotions and experiences whether in 'folk mode" as here or in rock mode with electric guitar and band. I like that Neil never shelved his early folk music roots, as we hear here. I like honest music, and Neil is always honest,. and like Dylan and Joni Mitchell his lyrics are thoughtful and often magical with mystery. Thank you Neil.
Neil is searching for the heart of gold within himself.
I was struck by Neil's look beyond the lights (3:42 Live 1971). I'm imagining he sees his older self. He's older now. He has lived. He has given us so much.
It's funny how people can hit their 30's and think "I'm getting old." Nope. just wait 30 years plus.
Now it's time for a Neil Young rocking tune. Keep on Rockin' in the Free World.
WITH with with... PEARL JAM! yayyyy
When I saw Neil Young live acoustically, he referred to Heart Of Gold as his "hit," haha.
Also of note, the live version you've chosen here pre-dates the release of the album/song. The audience was literally hearing this song for the first time.
Chances are it's from the concert I went to at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion in Hollywood/LA before the release of Harvest,I bought a boootleg of that concert shortly after at Licorice Pizza and learned to play some of the songs before the record came out and when it did my friends wanted to know how I had learned those songs Way before 😏🤫
I'm 71and have played since 15 , guess I must have been around 19+? when I bought His first solo after the Buffalo Springfield and learned to play the Loner, I've been waiting for you,Tulsa etc
I believe he was doing a solo acoustic tour because of his back issue at the time
Neil Young had a habit of performing new material live before recording it in the studio.
@@rodgerpalmer9872 this was done in England
You're probably right. I have a bootleg that was recorded around this same time and Heart Of Gold was just a bridge in the middle of A Man Needs A Maid.
I think his posture is indicative of his gentle nature and shyness.
Man, who doesn't like some Neil young...man what emotions.
One of the best Neil Young's songs in a great live performace. Anxious to watch here from Brazil!
I always found this to be a poignant song. It used to make my heart ache and bring a tear to my eyes just for the yearning in the song, but these days it evokes sadder feelings because it makes me think of special loved ones who have passed.
This song resonates with me very deeply. I'm someone who I think is probably not a bad person, but who has done some pretty rough stuff. I've definitely spent a lot of years of my life not thinking I was a good person, but wanting to be. That's what I always took from this, this desire to be a kinder person than you are but not knowing how to find that in yourself.
Keep searching, sincerly ask for guidance from HIGHER POWER, it will come.
A true heart of gold is rare and hard to find so getting old and still searching
I would have given anything to be in that intimate crowd at the BBC studios. This is one of the great performances of our time.
I appreciate you choosing a version where he just accompanies himself. He can get magical that way.
Those lines about Hollywood, redwood, and him being in his mind always kind of reminded me of that line by Hemingway, "Listen, Robert, going to another country doesn't make any difference. I've tried all that. You can't get away from yourself by moving from one place to another. There's nothing to that." But I think your interpretation was more so what Neil Young was going for.
I have been a fan of Neil Young since somewhere around the age of thirteen years. I enjoy many of his songs, including "Heart of Gold", a song of which I have always been fond. However, more recently the song has acquired a more personal significance for me, and now it tears at my heartstrings, and pulls on my tears.
A local Tucson artist, Wil Taylor, created a group of work featuring various women involved in the Tucson art scene/community. He created a portrait of each lady, and if I recall correctly, he titled each piece after a song. My girlfriend, with whom I moved to Tucson, is an artist, and she was included in this particular project of Wil's. He titled the portrait of her as "Heart of Gold".
That is why "Heart of Gold" has come to carry extra weight for me whenever I hear it . . . I was left with a enormous hole in my life when I lost her, and over twenty years later, I still have barely filled any of it. I still carry a tremendous amount of love for her, never once did I ever stop loving that heart of gold. If there ever was a "one", then she was it. Her absence still pains me. I'm growing old in my search.
I always interpreted this song as a person who is looking for a real love they can spend their lives with. It’s not about where you live or outside influences but a real connection that lasts. A live performance of “Needle and the Damage Done” by Neil Young, you will not be disappointed. Another good one is “Southern Man”….and yes just like this song the lyrics are exceptional.
The Best lyrics from Neil Young for me is "Rocking in the Free World "
You can't listen to Southern Man without following up with Lynyrd Skynyrd - Simple Man! Just saying.....The battle between the 2 is legendary in the day!
@@bernddoolmann247 When I was younger he did a version of this with Pearl Jam that I love.
@@blusbees8151 Was that not in Sweet Home Alabama?
@@blusbees8151 and they have played those 2 songs on the same stage. I believe it was a Lynyrd Skynyrd concert that they brought Neil Young in to sing. I believe there is no real bad blood...just 2 different views.
I grew up with Neil Young and CSNY. It is such a powerful thing how emotional memories are entwined with the songs of those days.
I saw them at Wembley with Joni Mitchell and The Band … fantastic concert on a beautiful day and a full stadium that was 1974 and I’m 69 now … one of my best memories.
When I grew up with Neil, he took me to places that we never thought was possible with songs like Down by the River or Cinnamon girl and his voice still haunts me to this day. I am 77 years old and love his music. He is special and followed his own interpretation of what is Neil Young, much like Eric Clapton followed his dream as a blues guitarist. It is so nice to see younger people enjoying and in awe of this kind of talent.
I've been waiting for sooooo long for this !!
This song and especially this live is so beautiful, sensitive and ... underrated !
Thank you
The studio version is really completed by perfect accompanying vocal by Linda Ronstadt in the last chorus. Amazing what she adds.
No doubt.
Harvest was and still is an incredible album.
Sometimes a song or a voice doesn’t need to be analyzed. It just needs to be appreciated for the masterpiece it is
We will search our entire lives searching for that heart of gold.
I always thought Man Needs a Maid was the classic song from that album . . . I remember driving in a group back to Aberdeen from Edinburgh in a University van. This was in the 90s and we still used cassettes in some old vans and cars. Everyone was happily talking away, when Man Needs Maid came on. It was about 6pm on a winter's evening so you can imagine the streets were already dark ....
Anyway, the whole van become deathly silent as we all focused on the same song in total unison, all of us enslaved to Neil Young's strange meaning and piercing voice. Total magic, mesmerising and literally gob-smacking.
Thank you Elizabeth for your professional interpretations, your positive responses and your heart felt postures. You, have "a heart of gold."
Harvest Moon for sure. Also Rockin' In The Free World if just for a listen for yourself to see Neil's range in vocal and musical style.
Great reaction, his music is so pure. I have all of his albums and never tire of listening to them.
Please react to more Neil Young! For me, the raw talent of his voice is very good...but what elevates it to amazing is his authenticity and "bare-your-soul" emotion. No pretentiousness. No ego. Just a man looking to share his art and pain.
Neil Young, "Old Man" is also authentic . Also,
"Only Love Can Break Your Heart" AND
" Comes a Time"
Nice reaction!
He’s still looking so …yeh he’s hopeful. He must have a heart of gold.
Awesome! Loved the breakdown. This song seems so sincere.
Authenticity, sincerity, & a sense of sweetness. -- three attributes that describe both Neil's performance, & your interpretation of it ; kudos to you both.
Ha ha, yes she's got me too!
That's funny what you said about Dylan because Neil Young has stated that hearing Dylan sing(?) was what gave him the courage to do it even with his voice. Glad that happened because I love them both.
Between this song & Old Man, same concert, his banter is really endearing. When one speaks little you really treasure the ... nuggets of gold. Hah, short songs & few words make us want more - the opposite of what a private person wants.
Ohh just such a wonderful classic I will be 59 in three weeks this has always touched me every listen........
My gosh...how could you have never heard Heart of Gold before now, lol ...makes me feel old... amazing tune... amazing artist ...amazing reaction 🔥
I get the feeling that your a Neil Young fan now.. his library is extensive and more than worth while keep up the great work
I've always heard this as he was searching for someone else who had a heart of gold. But this time with your deep dive I heard he was searching for his heart of gold. He is a miner digging inside himself searching, where is it? He knows it's there. He keeps searching. There is hope. It keeps him going.
The amazing song, guitar playing and melody makes one forget his look.
I've always thought this whole concert was brilliant. He's playing original music and doing the guitar, the harmonica and singing. And it's all good. Some of these songs from this concert are timeless classics.
Thank you for getting back to Neil Young!! "The Needle and the Damage Done" unplugged!! More solid gold!
I love when classically trained singers review the "stylized" singers... I can't express in the same musically educated terms how a lovely but specific voice can be so beautiful despite the lack of formal voice training. Thank you so much, your reflections broaden my interpretations and appreciation of songs I might have heard/played/sang 1000 times. Good work; cheers!
Two songs that we're on the charts at the same time stairway to heaven and heart of gold anytime you turn on the radio back then you them both almost equally
A song without words, yet an amazing vocal. Great Gig in the Sky. Pink Floyd. Improvised use of voice as an instrument
During the solo in Wish You Were Here was his voice as well
Yes this! I said the same thing when she did Comfortably Numb.
I love this song. My band used to cover "Rocking in the Free World", but "Heart of Gold" just hits different. I enjoy everything Neil Young, from "Sample and Hold" to "Be The Rain".
Cinnamon Girl might be my favorite song of all time🤎When I saw Neil live solo he had the whole arena singing Sugar Mountain...one of my favorite concert memories.