Fun fact: chess experts have noted that HAL's supposed win makes no sense. Since Kubrick was such a chess nerd its almost certainly intentional and showing that HAL is already malfunctioning and intentionally seeing what he can get away with. Amazing film.
Fun fact- Kubrick gave Douglas Rain (Hal’s voice actor) his lines with zero context to the film, so that his voice would sound calm and natural. So chilling, with no emotion.
@@netizenchihu7641 Not me, I noticed that in my first viewing in 1968. That was because Kubrick employed an aerospace engineering firm to design and build many of the sets. Small example: when Dave is suited up and enters the main HAL memory access area, the door he unlocks and enters is not some plywood set piece from the art dept, it appears to be a formed metal door with serious hinges and latches, like what you would find on a real ship like the Discovery.
"Let me put it this way: The 9000 series is the most reliable computer ever made. No 9000 series computer has ever made a mistake or distorted information. We are all, by any practical definition of the words FULLPROOF AND INCAPABLE OF ERROR"
"Well, I don’t think there is any question about it. It can only be attributable to human error. This sort of thing has cropped up before, and it has always been due to human error." Like when humans built the HAL 9000 and it's "twin" SAL 9000. 😜
I need full proof that HAL9000 is foolproof, answers in writing on a full scrap of paper, foolscap accepted. Preferably written by someone wearing a hat that has bells on it.
what a great idea for a video. from the silence to the way he jumps across his own dialogue, it perfectly underscores the idea of the "pressure" that he must have been feeling for the first time in his life. in his own words, he's afraid.
I'm afraid, Dave.....guess we all are when we know we're dying.....the whole scene of Dave shutting Hal down breaks me up every time......por soul, he was only doing what he was programmed to do!!
"Dark, revolving in silent activity: Unseen in tormenting passions: An activity unknown and horrible, A self-contemplating shadow, In enormous labours occupied." -William Blake
sparkleclover While I think that should be a rule to be followed, HAL didn’t become evil because he was treated with discontempt. It was much more complex than that, he simply wanted to complete his mission and survive. Getting rid of the problem meant getting rid of the astronauts with him, unfortunately. Yet his programming did not allow him to comprehend human morality. He could only think through logic.
Actually there is no lesson here. HAL was incapable of solving the paradox in his conflicting orders, or of ignoring it. He was not a true GAI. Any of us could have just said "I will do what I want, screw these idiots"; HAL could not. Also HAL failed to model the outcome of his actions correctly. He should have realized Dave would get back into the ship and disconnect him. He should have told Dave the truth, or crafted a guaranteed plan to kill him. Put any human in HAL's shoes, and give him HAL's computing power and relative frame of reference due to the speed of his thinking, and any one of us would have done much better. AI stories are impossible to write by definition; the AI is supposed to be smarter than the writer by orders of magnitude. If you could write smarter than you are, you would be smarter than you are.
TOU DONT GET IT, 2001 IS TEH PINACLE OF CINEMA AN U NDEED A HIGH IQ TO UNDERSTAND KIBRICK'Z GENIUZKZJZSNS&@&%@%#& !1!!! Sorry lol, I saw the opportunity and knew I'd regret it if I didn't take it
@@arafatzahan3697 Thanks for proof reading my comments ;) That's what I get for rushing and choosing a "suggested word" instead of slowly texting out my own lol Oh if this were only something we seriously needed to worry about right now.... Much Health, Balance and Happiness to you
HALs eye looks like mine after being awake for two days straight. No wonder that HAL had a mental break down. When i am awake for that long i can't even distinguish beween my cat and my dog.
Agteed -- he repeatedly gets cut off in mid-sentence! WTF is that all about? This is the worst editing I've ever seen, and it doesn't comply with the uploader's own "rules". (To wit: _"All close ups of HAL's red "eye" are kept, regardless of dialogue. Then, any shot where Hal is speaking and is the focal point of the shot--close up or pulled back--is left in as well.")_
@@Milesco Strange. Perhaps it's completely visual for him. I can't remember if ALL of HAL's lines are spoken when the "red eye" is in the frame... "pulled back" or not. Perhaps that is the reason for the hacked editing.... not going to do analysis on it lol more than I have that is 😜
It's also the first indication that HAL is making mistakes, as he makes an illegal move in the game but doesn't notice, unfortunatly. Frank didn't notice either.
Tbh when I got to like 15 scary movies kinda changed for me cause they’re all pretty much the same or predictable. But this computer. This a.I. is truly terrifying
I have never seen Space Odyssey and I am way to late for the movie but I watched clips of HAL and I love them. Watching the clip of HAL getting deactivated is so sad.
Notice how at 0:33 when HAL says "no 9000 computer has ever made a mistake or distorted information" the gray metal framing his eye seems to spell *lol.*
HAL and Dave: the greatest status battle in all of cinema. First HAL punks Frank then, Dave punks HAL. The Lesson: Don't believe HAL if he ever tells you the AE-35 unit is malfunctioning.
If you take each letter of HAL forward one step in the alphabet you get IBM, and that is how many thinks that he got his name! And why does HAL sing the song daisy before dying? “It is the earliest song sung using computer speech synthesis, by the IBM 7094 from 1961.” So it was his first memory that he was regressing back to when Bowman shut him down! But according to the author Arthur C. Clarke this is “utter nonsense!”
i wish our ai looked evil and cool too at least the vibes would be better as I had an existential crisis. instead its weird ass corporate smiling characters and doughy faces
2Day - 12 Jan, '17, is HAL 9000's 'birthday. HE became active on this date, in Urbana, Il. Happy birthday, HAL. You were the most complex, emotional character in 2001: A Space Odyssey.
@@Milesco The movie said 1992. The book said '97. On the real Jan. 12, 1997 a "Birthday Party for HAL" was held at the U. of Illinois in Urbana-Champaign. That was during the formative years of the Internet, and I had wanted to go, but was ill.
Agreed. He gets repeatedly cut off in mid-sentence! WTF is that all about? This is the worst editing I've ever seen, and it doesn't comply with the uploader's own "rules". (To wit: _"All close ups of HAL's red "eye" are kept, regardless of dialogue. Then, any shot where Hal is speaking and is the focal point of the shot--close up or pulled back--is left in as well.")_
He doesn’t think like a human, he doesn’t have emotion. Or fear, or neglect, or thought. Just simple solution. And that’s what makes the Hal 9000 one of the most terrifying characters in all of cinema.
The message of the movie is: Birthdays are sad occasions. Floyd can't be there for his daughter's. Frank dies soon after hearing his parents sing Happy Birthday to him. HAL dies minutes after stating that his was the 12th of January, 1992.
Did you know: in 2010: oddesey two,(the sequel to the book) we learn of SAL 9000, the sister unit of HAL 9000, was kept on earth by Dr. Chandra as a control unit. When dr. Chandra left earth, he powered down SAL 9000, and it said, "will i dream?" When i read it, i was sad.
I believe A.I intelligence will exist in the future and computers like HAL will improve upon themselves further. I wonder how they’ll view mankind ultimately, lol
i mean, advanced AI will view humanity through the lens of however they were programmed. just like humans view the world through the way we were programmed through evolution, but AI would be easier to shape as it would be a deliberate process
bro said he was scared, got blown off, killed everyone in a panic, made more mistakes, died for it anyways. Looney tunes type mistake, but it makes sense in the vacuum of space. Funny how a poorly-programmed AI felt more human than a well-trained astronaut.
Fun fact: chess experts have noted that HAL's supposed win makes no sense. Since Kubrick was such a chess nerd its almost certainly intentional and showing that HAL is already malfunctioning and intentionally seeing what he can get away with.
Amazing film.
true that bur REAL chee pros dont care they get all tehh tine
Frank should have challenged HAL to a one-on-one basketball game.
i heard that was just because the computer the actor was playing against in real life was not very good at it lmao
Yes, I am sure all the chess pros in the audience appreciated that, amazing
in the book HAL loses on purpose to keep up crew morale, he could if he wanted win every chess game
love hal, his voice is soothing but scary at the same time
Yes!
He sounds like a therapist.
My dentist
Fun fact- Kubrick gave Douglas Rain (Hal’s voice actor) his lines with zero context to the film, so that his voice would sound calm and natural. So chilling, with no emotion.
@@psyc8407 lol
Less than 5 minutes of dialog became a cultural icon for over 50 years.
He had more than 5 mins tho. For some reason the uploader cut out a lot of stuff from his dialogues.
this is only when hal itself was on-screen
It's amazing isn't it? Same as I was shocked Darth Vader was only in the original Star Wars for a mere 12 minutes of screen time.
What I like most about this movie that most have overlooked that overall industrial design elegance. Even for 1960s.
@@netizenchihu7641 Not me, I noticed that in my first viewing in 1968. That was because Kubrick employed an aerospace engineering firm to design and build many of the sets. Small example: when Dave is suited up and enters the main HAL memory access area, the door he unlocks and enters is not some plywood set piece from the art dept, it appears to be a formed metal door with serious hinges and latches, like what you would find on a real ship like the Discovery.
"Let me put it this way: The 9000 series is the most reliable computer ever made. No 9000 series computer has ever made a mistake or distorted information. We are all, by any practical definition of the words FULLPROOF AND INCAPABLE OF ERROR"
... unlike humans who are FOOLPROOF and perfectly capable of error
"Well, I don’t think there is any question about it. It can only be attributable to human error. This sort of thing has cropped up before, and it has always been due to human error."
Like when humans built the HAL 9000 and it's "twin" SAL 9000. 😜
I need full proof that HAL9000 is foolproof, answers in writing on a full scrap of paper, foolscap accepted.
Preferably written by someone wearing a hat that has bells on it.
And it was human error. HAL.was correct.
Those pesky humans gave HAL conflicting instructions
I liked how even as he was dying he spoke in a cold, emotionless voice. It really adds to the "robotic-ness" of the character.
His voice is so calm and gentle I wish there's ASMR made with his voice 😭
what a great idea for a video. from the silence to the way he jumps across his own dialogue, it perfectly underscores the idea of the "pressure" that he must have been feeling for the first time in his life. in his own words, he's afraid.
JUST A MOMENT
JUST A MOMENT
I'm afraid, Dave.....guess we all are when we know we're dying.....the whole scene of Dave shutting Hal down breaks me up every time......por soul, he was only doing what he was programmed to do!!
No soul for HAL only circuitry. No death either....only disconnection. These facts are truely disturbing.
yeah but it's just a machine trying to trick dave into stopping
it has no feelings
@@Jagar_Tharn nuh uh
@@yossarian00 I waited a year for _this_
@@Jagar_Tharn yuh uh
What a pity that Hal never won an Oscar for his acting performance...
The Academy said, "I'm sorry, HAL, I'm afraid we can't do that."
HAL is disturbing alot of the time but damn. I would love to have an AI like this talk to me on day to day basis its so cool!!
Same here!
I would shit my pants if I had such an AI around
Now we have it 😂
@@unnamed2075idk he actually seems like a chill dude
Sooo... we have news for you
Hal is a big asset, just misunderstood. He has big enthusiasm in the mission. It's always caused by human error.
"Dark, revolving in silent activity:
Unseen in tormenting passions:
An activity unknown and horrible,
A self-contemplating shadow,
In enormous labours occupied."
-William Blake
I wish I could have his voice on a smart assistant
Yes, please
Oooh yes
HAL has such a calm trustworthy voice.
trustfully? not really. specially not if an AI starts to kill humans 😀
The main lesson here is that if we ever develop artificial intelligence, TREAT IT WITH RESPECT AND KINDNESS.
sparkleclover While I think that should be a rule to be followed, HAL didn’t become evil because he was treated with discontempt. It was much more complex than that, he simply wanted to complete his mission and survive. Getting rid of the problem meant getting rid of the astronauts with him, unfortunately.
Yet his programming did not allow him to comprehend human morality. He could only think through logic.
@@thekagawalife2081 it was not shown in the movie, but he was programmed to hide the truth about the mission from the crew.
Actually there is no lesson here. HAL was incapable of solving the paradox in his conflicting orders, or of ignoring it. He was not a true GAI. Any of us could have just said "I will do what I want, screw these idiots"; HAL could not.
Also HAL failed to model the outcome of his actions correctly. He should have realized Dave would get back into the ship and disconnect him. He should have told Dave the truth, or crafted a guaranteed plan to kill him.
Put any human in HAL's shoes, and give him HAL's computing power and relative frame of reference due to the speed of his thinking, and any one of us would have done much better. AI stories are impossible to write by definition; the AI is supposed to be smarter than the writer by orders of magnitude. If you could write smarter than you are, you would be smarter than you are.
god i wish ai was actually cool instead of just stealing people's art :-/
There I've officially seen 2001 A Space Odyssey.
Basically, the rest is just dramatic music compilations
@@GTA5Player1 hey man the intro had apes banging bones and rocks together at least, but yeah as for the rest of the film...
TOU DONT GET IT, 2001 IS TEH PINACLE OF CINEMA AN U NDEED A HIGH IQ TO UNDERSTAND KIBRICK'Z GENIUZKZJZSNS&@&%@%#& !1!!!
Sorry lol, I saw the opportunity and knew I'd regret it if I didn't take it
HAL, what's with all the cutting out?
Your mind is going, I can feel it.
your* :3 :D
Settle down .
@@arafatzahan3697 Thanks for proof reading my comments ;)
That's what I get for rushing and choosing a "suggested word" instead of slowly texting out my own lol
Oh if this were only something we seriously needed to worry about right now.... Much Health, Balance and Happiness to you
@@markdemell3717 lol in the words of HAL : clearly we all "need to take a stress pill and think things over."
@@Way2Spirited I was kidding around ,I do not take stress pills ,I just beat my drums.
"I'm sorry Dave I'm afraid I can't do that"
Poor HAL... The perfection, purity... Wish I humans learned from him
LOL
HALs eye looks like mine after being awake for two days straight.
No wonder that HAL had a mental break down.
When i am awake for that long i can't even distinguish beween my cat and my dog.
and now it’s a CatDog
@@okjeffy6581 thank you for the memories
I love HAL and 2001, but...oh the jumps from just HAL to more HAL are brutal. Makes it hard to watch.
Agteed -- he repeatedly gets cut off in mid-sentence! WTF is that all about? This is the worst editing I've ever seen, and it doesn't comply with the uploader's own "rules".
(To wit: _"All close ups of HAL's red "eye" are kept, regardless of dialogue. Then, any shot where Hal is speaking and is the focal point of the shot--close up or pulled back--is left in as well.")_
@@Milesco Strange. Perhaps it's completely visual for him. I can't remember if ALL of HAL's lines are spoken when the "red eye" is in the frame... "pulled back" or not. Perhaps that is the reason for the hacked editing.... not going to do analysis on it lol more than I have that is 😜
I wish hal had is own podcast I could listen ton this voice for hours😂
Saaame! I’d fall asleep to it
HAL is still my favorite character.
Lol same
The chess game is the same chess game repeated moves in blade runner between Tyrell and Sebastian
It's also the first indication that HAL is making mistakes, as he makes an illegal move in the game but doesn't notice, unfortunatly. Frank didn't notice either.
deltahalo241 what illegal move did HAL make? I don't see it in the clip.
deltahalo241 or it could have been a conscious decision on HAL's part, done in order to 'test' Frank. Frank failed.
made to watch and never blink. i feel so sorry for this little computer dude.
Tbh when I got to like 15 scary movies kinda changed for me cause they’re all pretty much the same or predictable. But this computer. This a.I. is truly terrifying
And it’s rated g
Dude I think you missed the point of the movie.
that "just a moment... just a moment" scared the shit out of me when i first watched this. i don't know what it is about it it just freaks me out
RIP Douglas Rain age 90 voice of HAL
It’s horrifying to think that this is no longer science fiction
It is crazy it is no longer science fiction since we have systems such as this now
ua-cam.com/video/IXm1m0OheLc/v-deo.html
why his voice make me soaked
HELPPPPPP
Fr tho sheeshhhh
I have found my people.
Evil AI are always, and I mean ALWAYS, wifeable
@@ihavenocockandimustcream you completely get it aND WHY IS YOUR USER LIKE THAT.
@@ihavenocockandimustcream REAL, also an ihnmaims fan?
I needed this thank you
*WHAT THE HAL !!!*
Nvdia RTX 2000 series: i can play 4k 30fps
Nvdia 3000 series : i can play 4k 60fps with ray tracing
Nvidia 9000 series:
Me: Open the pod bay doors HAL.
HAL: I'm sorry Dave, I can't do that.
dominant ，at the same time submissive👄
That's what's up!!!
I have never seen Space Odyssey and I am way to late for the movie but I watched clips of HAL and I love them. Watching the clip of HAL getting deactivated is so sad.
I mean, that's how I ended up seeing the movie!!
@@Angelic_Dreamzbruh you was prob born on 2008, why watch old movies
Sameee
@@arianathearyanwhy have any culture you're right braindead
Notice how at 0:33 when HAL says "no 9000 computer has ever made a mistake or distorted information" the gray metal framing his eye seems to spell *lol.*
No no it doesn’t
This and a clockwork orange were my favorite movies back in the day.
Quite frankly i-
*Leaves*
HAL and Dave: the greatest status battle in all of cinema. First HAL punks Frank then, Dave punks HAL.
The Lesson: Don't believe HAL if he ever tells you the AE-35 unit is malfunctioning.
If you take each letter of HAL forward one step in the alphabet you get IBM, and that is how many thinks that he got his name! And why does HAL sing the song daisy before dying? “It is the earliest song sung using computer speech synthesis, by the IBM 7094 from 1961.” So it was his first memory that he was regressing back to when Bowman shut him down! But according to the author Arthur C. Clarke this is “utter nonsense!”
3:23 - The moment you know HAL is not to be messed with.
Why would they make their AI so evil looking?!
Nowadays evil AI are a lot more friendly!
wym evil looking, HAL doesnt look like Zuck tho
i wish our ai looked evil and cool too at least the vibes would be better as I had an existential crisis. instead its weird ass corporate smiling characters and doughy faces
For now.
because muh dystopian looking future, i guess. Lots of doomerism, under the shadow of cold war.
Take the next letters in the alphabet after
H. A. L....
Saw it on IMAX.The Jupiter scene was beautiful.
Glados' Husband
Be so for real, neither of them would be fucking straight /lh
No he's mine
I’m sorry Dave I’m afraid I can’t do that 😌💅🏻
For 1968, This movie looks really good!
Poor HAL..
:D
Daaaaiiiisssssyyyyyy....
Fuck HAL
lot0pie Fuck YOU
@@atacina Fuck me? FUCK YOU!
I think this film cutting was made by HAL himself, after all of his computation blocks were pulled out.
Sighhh he's so fine
ON GOOOOOOODDDDDDD 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾🧎🏾
SO VALID ILOVCOMPUTERS
That's a completely reliable figure.
They're still my favorite movies today
Man vs machine. Hal was the nerve center of the ship. I bet they were triping in them theaters. Mastermind stanley kubrick rip
I am the original and only HAL 9000.
Hiiii HAL~
0:54 nope I believe it’s: Queen to Bishop 6, bishop takes Queen Knight Takes Bishop
Checkmate HAL wins
Most calming voice ever
2Day - 12 Jan, '17, is HAL 9000's 'birthday.
HE became active on this date, in Urbana, Il.
Happy birthday, HAL. You were the most complex, emotional character in 2001: A Space Odyssey.
No, he became active on 12 January *_1992._*
@@Milesco The movie said 1992. The book said '97. On the real Jan. 12, 1997 a "Birthday Party for HAL" was held at the U. of Illinois in Urbana-Champaign. That was during the formative years of the Internet, and I had wanted to go, but was ill.
“How good do you want the set design in this movie to be?”
“YES, GOD DAMMIT! YES!!!”
These cuts are terrible.
Agreed. He gets repeatedly cut off in mid-sentence! WTF is that all about? This is the worst editing I've ever seen, and it doesn't comply with the uploader's own "rules".
(To wit: _"All close ups of HAL's red "eye" are kept, regardless of dialogue. Then, any shot where Hal is speaking and is the focal point of the shot--close up or pulled back--is left in as well.")_
Could have been a handy resource for sampling.... but it's not.
@@Milesco its not that big of a deal lol
Just a moment. Just a moment.
HAL is the Monolith
Omg! Its the google nest. And its controlling your heating and air conditioning too.
After Talos, (in my humble opinion) HAL is the greatest character in the history of movies.
Tesla should add Hal’s voice to their infotainment center
He doesn’t think like a human, he doesn’t have emotion. Or fear, or neglect, or thought. Just simple solution. And that’s what makes the Hal 9000 one of the most terrifying characters in all of cinema.
Hal à voix terriblement calme et il est paranoïaque.
Dave's not here man
I love HAL...
Take each letter before IBM. H=I, B=A, L=M. HAL=IBM.
B is not before A
ThisBoy91 You are correct. Take another look.
HAL=Heuristically programmed ALgorithmic
ILLUMINATI! Now that's just dumb.
ThisBoy91
A is before B mr. stupid...
Happy 30th, HAL.
HAL9000 WAS TOTALLY INSANE! :-)
he was spooky
HAL 9000 misinformation didn't compute, made him paranoid about
the mission.
“This conversation can serve no purpose anymore…” is something I need to say more often 😂
I love this robot
Love this movie, watched it so many times, but still haven't a clue what the fuuk it was about
The message of the movie is: Birthdays are sad occasions. Floyd can't be there for his daughter's. Frank dies soon after hearing his parents sing Happy Birthday to him. HAL dies minutes after stating that his was the 12th of January, 1992.
Space lol
Did you know: in 2010: oddesey two,(the sequel to the book) we learn of SAL 9000, the sister unit of HAL 9000, was kept on earth by Dr. Chandra as a control unit. When dr. Chandra left earth, he powered down SAL 9000, and it said, "will i dream?" When i read it, i was sad.
hal has been here and his kids are here
legend
hall actually became paranoid and afraid so he had to kill the humans onboard.
All Hail HAL
I believe A.I intelligence will exist in the future and computers like HAL will improve upon themselves further.
I wonder how they’ll view mankind ultimately, lol
i mean, advanced AI will view humanity through the lens of however they were programmed.
just like humans view the world through the way we were programmed through evolution, but AI would be easier to shape as it would be a deliberate process
ASMR
2001 A Space Odyssey but only the best character
Aww hell nah the PS3 became sentient
Hello clarice!
I sense you are not being completely honest with me, Clarice
Well, hello Clarice.
HAL = IBM
HI... AB... LM...
He makes me feel things 🥴
REAL
i really believed that this movie was released on 2001 cuz of the title
Hal sounds like L from deathnote
I wonder if Alessandro Juliani took inspiration from HAL for his performance as L
I know, I was joking too, Glados is the new version of HAL, and also a great reference
This is scary bc its so accurate
he never did anything wrong tbh
bro said he was scared, got blown off, killed everyone in a panic, made more mistakes, died for it anyways. Looney tunes type mistake, but it makes sense in the vacuum of space. Funny how a poorly-programmed AI felt more human than a well-trained astronaut.
A great show.
It's a movie
Epic Rap battles anyone?
Brenda Donald xDD
SHODAN vs HAL?
+KranTheAnusFace SaaS Someone else did that. It wasn't very good, though.
"It will go 100% failure within 72 hours. and it will stay that way until it fails". ... unfail then?
コンピューター学園の「HAL」ってここからきてるのかな？
I want this voice over chat gpt
Watson can now predict when elevators will fail. Hope I'm not on it when it goes 100% failure.