I spent 10 hours trying to figure something out in vanilla, with auto start the loader when gold is put in the chest. Watched countless UA-cam videos and after I found this I was finally able to get everything sorted out and have a clean looking perfect functioning bartering farm. Loading gold and flipping a single switch is what I settled for. Thanks for the help!
if you put a piston on a constant tick moving gold ingot ore. it agros the piglins and they insta trade. they can get rid of 9 stacks in less than a second
Another update victim, the piglins pick up the gold at a drastically reduced rate. In order to sustain this particular design, you're going to need item filters that will funnel the gold that leaks through back into the input chest.
Actually, if you set up a sticky piston attached to a gold block, in view of the piglins, every time the piston moves the gold block, they trade again, so one tick trades :)
So I built 2 of these in my survival world with only 6 piglins in each of the 2 modules so 12 piglins in total. I've seen in your comments that an update made it so they aren't catching the gold every time anymore. I have a weird thing happening between my 2 modules. The 2 modules are built exactly the same except one small difference that they are mirror images of one another for uniformity in my build. So the only visible difference is that the trap doors are opened facing the opposite direction in each module. I copied my world so I could go into creative without ruining my world, and filled both modules with gold ingots in creative because I haven't built my gold farm yet. What I found was interesting, but I can't really explain the why it happened that way. The module on the left side of the doorway the trap doors open to the right side of the piglin, and after a half hour the 6 piglins missed a total of just over 4 stacks of ingots that fell into the system. In the module on the right side of the doorway the the trap doors open to the left side of the piglin, and in the same half hour the 6 piglins missed only a total of 18 ingots that fell into the system. That is a significant difference in missed ingots, and as I said it doesn't make any sense considering the only difference between the modules is the orientation of the trap doors being opposite of one another.
Still works in 1.21 on Xbox. I had to put a solid block above piglins, to get them into the chamber. W/o it, they glitched out on top of the glass. Thanks a lot
Can you please make the sorting system video? It would be so nice to things justo order themselves and a great challenge to build. Love your videos, big fan of your content ;D
So the new update has done something to how the piglins interact with the gold ingots. Before the update out of the 16 piglins I have in the farm, maybe one wouldnt pick up an ingot, now its closer to 3/4 of them dont pick up the ingots
Same! I'm replying here to hopefully get some help (although no interactions are very recent). Sometimes 2 piglins pick up gold, sometimes one, sometimes 6. And to top it all off, one dropper NEVER gets gold in it.
@@elizabethleann7809 i managed to fix it myself. Run a redstone line from the clock to repeaters facing into the hoppers with each repeater on a 4 tick delay
@@mathewdavis3129 This. The timing ends up perfect. I was getting 1 trade per 64 ingots before. After adding repeaters into the hoppers at the piglins feet, I now get 100% trade rate. Thanks for the helpful suggestion!
I was having the same issues report here post-update with the Piglins missing the gold perhaps 75% of the time... I was able to more-or-less solve this by removing the carpet on top of the hoppers. They don't catch 100% of the time, but they didn't before either with the carpet. This change has SIGNIFICANTLY improved rates after the update. Nothing else I tried improved rates, including locking the hoppers -- the Piglins just ignored the gold sitting on the carpet. Your mileage may vary but I've had good results with this change thus far.
Trapdoors are not just to keep the piglins in place, it also makes sure that the gold dispensed collides with the hitbox of the piglin. Without it the gold may hit the floor and piglins are terrible in path finding on carpet.
Jack I just built this on my testing world and I’m actually having trouble with that. One Piglin keeps missing the gold almost every other time it is dispensed, and it isn’t always the same Piglin. It looks like the gold glitches through the trapdoor and into the cell next to it. Have you experiences this or do you have any ideas?
@@Bro2189 I have built a system with a solid block in between to prevent that. I just posted a vid about it. Beware of a bug that makes piglins ignore gold blocks thrown at them. That is happening if you place blocks adjacent to the hopper the piglin stands on. I think that is a pathfinding issue and that may be what you are seeing in your test world. Very weird thing. You can prevent that by putting two hoppers on top of each other. In my vid I don't have that problem for unknown reasons. I duplicated that exact system, but turned it 180 in my survival world and the above bug kicked in. So it may even be directional.
hmm, I get the feeling this was made in creative :P is there a reason to build farms in creative? u can just "give" whatever u need to urself, or am I missing something? sincere question since I haven´t played for very long
If anyone else is losing a lot of gold into the system because it keeps missing a Piglin, here is how I fixed it: Move the droppers behind the upper body of the Piglins instead of above them. Then, using a piston push a glass block to encase the upper body of the Piglins (don’t forget to break the trapdoor). The Piglins will pick up the gold every time without fail and they will drop their items straight down so you won’t have to worry about placing blocks next to the hoppers and items getting stuck on the edge. The only problem I’ve noticed with this fix is when I log back into the game the Piglins feet glitch into the hoppers. If this happens, all you have to do is give them a little punch to get them back in position. Hope this helps!
one question and request, in this farm wouldnt it be more efficient to drop gold on adjacent block of piglin so it doesnt simply go down the storage instead of bartering, like a block higher with tap door so piglins can still pick gold up but cant throw items in that direction... if yes will there be a improved version of this farm?
You probably could, I’ll have to see if silent whisperer’s design still works. You would still need a LOT of chests for the non stackable items.. unless after you get the non stackable items that you want (enchantment books, potions, and I believe there is a netherite hoe in the bedrock loot table), you could just have the non stackable items be dispensed into lava. Probably didn’t need such a long response but anyways 😂
Yeah, good point, I actually know how to make an item filter, but in overworld, I m gonna try and do a storage for the stackable ones and then another big one for non stackable. The problem I guess is having to replace the water streams with hopper minecart on rails collenting al the loot, because I don t know how well it s gonna keep up with a bigger type of a farm.
@@Michael-McCollum the amount o items u get for this farm is just too overwhelming for just hoppers. It s going to need some sort of pusher with slime blocks beside the item filters.
I used carpet but the gold is still being sucked up for some reason Okay I got it. So if anyone else is having this problem, make sure there are no blocks surrounding the hoppers. That is very important apparently
I got 2 netherite hoes from it in less than hour of starting and couple double chests full which is great and i wanna know is there anyway to use them other than just tilling soil ??
I believe some changes to the game have made this stop working. I do intend on doing a brand new one in Season 2 of the Bedrock Guide, not sure when yet... but it wont be too long as I need blackstone and quartz.
Can someone help me on my realm sever I have no clue wat im doing wrong just things are not adding up and I’ve sat here for 30 mins trying to figure out what I missed place
No matter what i try I cant get the piglins to pop into the cage, its like the carpet is stopping them, and then when i try from above I cant place the dispenser back and when i spawn an egg all i get is babies
There is a bug if you place blocks next to the hopper (with carpet) the piglin stands on. The piglin seems to ignore any gold thrown at it. Try stacking two hoppers and it may be fixed. I suspect it is related to a path finding bug. It fixed it for me. If you want it to empty the top hopper really quick, you can stack a hopper, a hopper minecart (on rails), and another hopper.
What’s up Prowl. I just subscribed to your channel. I really enjoy your videos/tutorials. You explain the mechanics of the game well, and I like your vibe. Awesome content Prowl. Thank you.
There is a bug if you place blocks next to the hopper (with carpet) the piglin stands on. The piglin seems to ignore any gold thrown at it. Try stacking two hoppers and it may be fixed. I suspect it is related to a path finding bug. It fixed it for me. If you want it to empty the top hopper really quick, you can stack a hopper, a hopper minecart (on rails), and another hopper.
There is a bug if you place blocks next to the hopper (with carpet) the piglin stands on. The piglin seems to ignore any gold thrown at it. Try stacking two hoppers and it may be fixed. I suspect it is related to a path finding bug. It fixed it for me. If you want it to empty the top hopper really quick, you can stack a hopper, a hopper minecart (on rails), and another hopper.
I found the materials needed if anybody was wondering!
30 chests
48 hoppers
8 carpet
63 solid blocks
10 glass
8 droppers
8 trapdoors of any kind
Redstone:
14 Redstone dust
14 powered rails
1 rail
2 levers
1 hopper minecart
2 comparators
2 pistons
(Sticky if on Java)
1 Redstone block
2 repeaters
1 observer
Piglin Transport:
12 powered rails
16 solid blocks
4 levers
4 solid blocks to prevent Piglins from escaping
*Repeat this for the four other cells*
coffee trex Please do tell me if anything is inaccurate
Thank you!
Awesome!
This will be quite useful I'll be using this to prepare all my items before i start
You helped me so much bro thanks🙏🙏
I spent 10 hours trying to figure something out in vanilla, with auto start the loader when gold is put in the chest. Watched countless UA-cam videos and after I found this I was finally able to get everything sorted out and have a clean looking perfect functioning bartering farm. Loading gold and flipping a single switch is what I settled for. Thanks for the help!
Thanks for the vid, silent sent me from his vid. I liked and subbed.
great video, and i must say your mic is one of the best quality ive heard
if you put a piston on a constant tick moving gold ingot ore. it agros the piglins and they insta trade. they can get rid of 9 stacks in less than a second
Well now I know what I'm doing next in my world :)
Just use a sticky piston to move a gold block back and forth repeatedly and it will cause them to drop the Loot fast
Use navynexus ‘s design
Chang The First Methbender they patched that
Music Master did they? I didn’t hear about it. That’s a shame 😕
@@tahliaborck no they didn't
Another update victim, the piglins pick up the gold at a drastically reduced rate. In order to sustain this particular design, you're going to need item filters that will funnel the gold that leaks through back into the input chest.
Actually, if you set up a sticky piston attached to a gold block, in view of the piglins, every time the piston moves the gold block, they trade again, so one tick trades :)
Didnt know this was a thing. Thank god for prowl
So I built 2 of these in my survival world with only 6 piglins in each of the 2 modules so 12 piglins in total. I've seen in your comments that an update made it so they aren't catching the gold every time anymore. I have a weird thing happening between my 2 modules. The 2 modules are built exactly the same except one small difference that they are mirror images of one another for uniformity in my build. So the only visible difference is that the trap doors are opened facing the opposite direction in each module. I copied my world so I could go into creative without ruining my world, and filled both modules with gold ingots in creative because I haven't built my gold farm yet. What I found was interesting, but I can't really explain the why it happened that way. The module on the left side of the doorway the trap doors open to the right side of the piglin, and after a half hour the 6 piglins missed a total of just over 4 stacks of ingots that fell into the system. In the module on the right side of the doorway the the trap doors open to the left side of the piglin, and in the same half hour the 6 piglins missed only a total of 18 ingots that fell into the system. That is a significant difference in missed ingots, and as I said it doesn't make any sense considering the only difference between the modules is the orientation of the trap doors being opposite of one another.
Still works in 1.21 on Xbox. I had to put a solid block above piglins, to get them into the chamber. W/o it, they glitched out on top of the glass. Thanks a lot
Why do you need a bigger and more complex system other than for a sorting system??? But I will watch...
Works beautifully. Thank you
Can you please make the sorting system video? It would be so nice to things justo order themselves and a great challenge to build. Love your videos, big fan of your content ;D
If the new nether didn’t scare me so much, I would head over and build a gold farm and a piglin trading hall... but it does, so I won’t...
I enjoy probably every single video you have ever posted but 4 years is a long time for a bartering farm video.
So the new update has done something to how the piglins interact with the gold ingots. Before the update out of the 16 piglins I have in the farm, maybe one wouldnt pick up an ingot, now its closer to 3/4 of them dont pick up the ingots
Same! I'm replying here to hopefully get some help (although no interactions are very recent). Sometimes 2 piglins pick up gold, sometimes one, sometimes 6. And to top it all off, one dropper NEVER gets gold in it.
Glad I’m not the only one. Hoping to get a fix for this soon.
@@elizabethleann7809 i managed to fix it myself. Run a redstone line from the clock to repeaters facing into the hoppers with each repeater on a 4 tick delay
@@mathewdavis3129 thank you so much 👏🏼
@@mathewdavis3129 This. The timing ends up perfect. I was getting 1 trade per 64 ingots before. After adding repeaters into the hoppers at the piglins feet, I now get 100% trade rate. Thanks for the helpful suggestion!
I was having the same issues report here post-update with the Piglins missing the gold perhaps 75% of the time... I was able to more-or-less solve this by removing the carpet on top of the hoppers. They don't catch 100% of the time, but they didn't before either with the carpet. This change has SIGNIFICANTLY improved rates after the update.
Nothing else I tried improved rates, including locking the hoppers -- the Piglins just ignored the gold sitting on the carpet. Your mileage may vary but I've had good results with this change thus far.
Thank you! It's not the same rates as before but it's working far better now.
I was finally going to build this so appreciate the advice. I may procrastinate a bit just in case a better idea comes along
Trapdoors are not just to keep the piglins in place, it also makes sure that the gold dispensed collides with the hitbox of the piglin. Without it the gold may hit the floor and piglins are terrible in path finding on carpet.
Jack I just built this on my testing world and I’m actually having trouble with that. One Piglin keeps missing the gold almost every other time it is dispensed, and it isn’t always the same Piglin. It looks like the gold glitches through the trapdoor and into the cell next to it. Have you experiences this or do you have any ideas?
@@Bro2189 I have built a system with a solid block in between to prevent that. I just posted a vid about it.
Beware of a bug that makes piglins ignore gold blocks thrown at them. That is happening if you place blocks adjacent to the hopper the piglin stands on. I think that is a pathfinding issue and that may be what you are seeing in your test world. Very weird thing. You can prevent that by putting two hoppers on top of each other.
In my vid I don't have that problem for unknown reasons. I duplicated that exact system, but turned it 180 in my survival world and the above bug kicked in. So it may even be directional.
hmm, I get the feeling this was made in creative :P
is there a reason to build farms in creative? u can just "give" whatever u need to urself, or am I missing something? sincere question since I haven´t played for very long
Tutorials are typically done in creative to showcase how to build something
@@Prowl8413 ah ok, it was such a specific useful function, so it felt weird to never be able to use it for anything, but gotcha :)
If anyone else is losing a lot of gold into the system because it keeps missing a Piglin, here is how I fixed it:
Move the droppers behind the upper body of the Piglins instead of above them. Then, using a piston push a glass block to encase the upper body of the Piglins (don’t forget to break the trapdoor). The Piglins will pick up the gold every time without fail and they will drop their items straight down so you won’t have to worry about placing blocks next to the hoppers and items getting stuck on the edge. The only problem I’ve noticed with this fix is when I log back into the game the Piglins feet glitch into the hoppers. If this happens, all you have to do is give them a little punch to get them back in position. Hope this helps!
Item requirements would be nice
thomas dalgleish its the only thing missing
Barely anything. This took me 20 mins to build
I made one :)
I'd recommend building it in a creative world first, so you can take a note of the materials used, and also to check if the farm works or not
one question and request, in this farm wouldnt it be more efficient to drop gold on adjacent block of piglin so it doesnt simply go down the storage instead of bartering, like a block higher with tap door so piglins can still pick gold up but cant throw items in that direction... if yes will there be a improved version of this farm?
It seems like even if the ingot is even a carpet height more than a block they cant reach it
Sometimes the piglins dont catch the gold ingots can you fix that? Really like your videos btw
rearrange the system to allow the dispenser to be behind the piglan rather than on top
Made this and it's great but only my forat dropper is giving gold to piglins. The other droppers are not firing. Any help please?
Wow, last time I was this early, I was nonexistent
i made the farm but for some reason mine doesn't activat the droppers and it doesnt make the minecart move again unless i keep hitting the switch
Can u make a storage sistem filter fo this type of farm? Would be so awesome to not have all items randomly in chests.
You probably could, I’ll have to see if silent whisperer’s design still works. You would still need a LOT of chests for the non stackable items.. unless after you get the non stackable items that you want (enchantment books, potions, and I believe there is a netherite hoe in the bedrock loot table), you could just have the non stackable items be dispensed into lava.
Probably didn’t need such a long response but anyways 😂
Yeah, good point, I actually know how to make an item filter, but in overworld, I m gonna try and do a storage for the stackable ones and then another big one for non stackable. The problem I guess is having to replace the water streams with hopper minecart on rails collenting al the loot, because I don t know how well it s gonna keep up with a bigger type of a farm.
@@Michael-McCollum the amount o items u get for this farm is just too overwhelming for just hoppers. It s going to need some sort of pusher with slime blocks beside the item filters.
I'm so sad. The new update did something to how they pick up the gold. I loved this farm and it was wonderful while it lasted.
If you connect a red stone line from the clock to repeaters on 4 ticks facing into the hoppers the piglins are standing on it worjs
@@freddietobane9150 wym? could you maybe explain in details?
Super vidéo mec
Gave me 16 ender pearls in 10 seconds
1 in 7.5 TRILLION
Gotta get my gold farm going first . . .
I built Navynexus’s one on my xbox world and it’s a madness
H - B yeah my friend made that in his world and it sounds wayy op
It is also cheap..
Way to cheap that you can make it at the start of your world
1min 7 stacks of gold gone rip me
Make navynexus’s gold farm
@Jud Sta Yep, his gold farm is wicked awesome.
Jud Sta or gnembons,but its a pain in the backside to put the hopper minecart properly
Hollywoodluluu- really?
that was really easy
Namialus137 u prolly didnt even build his farm so stfu lmao
I am getting some gold back or is it them that trade it?????
No you won't get the gold back, but there are various gold farms out there that will provide you with the gold for the farm.
The gold you're dispensing is probably going down the hoppers
YAY!
I used carpet but the gold is still being sucked up for some reason
Okay I got it. So if anyone else is having this problem, make sure there are no blocks surrounding the hoppers. That is very important apparently
When is that sorter coming out?? I’m struggling to make one that can handle the output of this thing!
Look at silentwisperers designs
Mr. Choas I don’t see a Piglin bartering sorting/storage system on his channel. I just see the exploit video.
I got 2 netherite hoes from it in less than hour of starting and couple double chests full which is great and i wanna know is there anyway to use them other than just tilling soil ??
Adhm Sabbah yes, I don’t know them all, but leaves and the nether leave things (nether wart block) those are the only ones that I know of
can you do a tutorial on how to do this same farm with a sorting system?
like so he can see :))
That would be amazing
@@xxxfurleyxxxonblackops2351 i would be great i tried to do one but it was so hard without water streams i could figure how to build it
no matter what i do the hoppers pick up the gold before they can trade any reason for this
I believe some changes to the game have made this stop working. I do intend on doing a brand new one in Season 2 of the Bedrock Guide, not sure when yet... but it wont be too long as I need blackstone and quartz.
Can someone help me on my realm sever I have no clue wat im doing wrong just things are not adding up and I’ve sat here for 30 mins trying to figure out what I missed place
My piglins won't pick up any of the gold any ideas?
Can this be in overworld or does it have to be in the never
In the over world your piglins will transform into zombified piglins
CanaryBoy ok thx
Works great 2024 bedrock
Will this break if I put my world on peaceful
nope
No matter what i try I cant get the piglins to pop into the cage, its like the carpet is stopping them, and then when i try from above I cant place the dispenser back and when i spawn an egg all i get is babies
that just sounds like bad luck my friend
I have never been so early
still works in 1.20 just get rid of the carpets. everything else keep the same
I did the design (on bedrock) and it didn't work I redid it and it still didn't work (I did it on a realm if that helps)
It works perfectly fine in bedrock. Just finished it
Make sure that all of the Redstone is in the exact right place
same except not on a realm
I made the farm and added a item sorter but there are to many items and it keeps getting stuck. How do I fix this?
Sort manually lol it's a chore but it gets the job done.
Can you make a gold farm next?
Check navynexus' gold farm
That just about can’t keep up
:(
@@mattmccollam9827 then check zundappchef's lighthouse
Matt McCollam you could probably add more nether portals to it
Prowl can you make a gold farm next so we can fuel this farm
Jorge Hernandez Flores Does it 100 percent work in 1.16? Just wanting to make sure before I build it
Yes
My piglins wont even pick up the ingot if you throw it at them
Not sure
There is a bug if you place blocks next to the hopper (with carpet) the piglin stands on. The piglin seems to ignore any gold thrown at it. Try stacking two hoppers and it may be fixed. I suspect it is related to a path finding bug. It fixed it for me. If you want it to empty the top hopper really quick, you can stack a hopper, a hopper minecart (on rails), and another hopper.
A lot of gold leaks through wt should i do to fix it
My piglins won't pick up the gold any plz help!
Great tutorial but my piglins are not batering?
nice
the minecart isn't moving
This still working?
I know how to make a zero-tick gold farm so infinite piglin bartering
how
zero tick is usually used for plants or random tick based things
are you talking about portal ticking?
Can anyone tell me a material list?
What’s up Prowl. I just subscribed to your channel. I really enjoy your videos/tutorials. You explain the mechanics of the game well, and I like your vibe. Awesome content Prowl. Thank you.
The Piglins won't pick up the gold from the droppers
Turn on Mob Griefing. It happened with me
There is a bug if you place blocks next to the hopper (with carpet) the piglin stands on. The piglin seems to ignore any gold thrown at it. Try stacking two hoppers and it may be fixed. I suspect it is related to a path finding bug. It fixed it for me. If you want it to empty the top hopper really quick, you can stack a hopper, a hopper minecart (on rails), and another hopper.
Mine doesnt seem to work
There is a bug if you place blocks next to the hopper (with carpet) the piglin stands on. The piglin seems to ignore any gold thrown at it. Try stacking two hoppers and it may be fixed. I suspect it is related to a path finding bug. It fixed it for me. If you want it to empty the top hopper really quick, you can stack a hopper, a hopper minecart (on rails), and another hopper.
2nd!!!
No wait 3rd
Nobody cares.
I 169 like
17k per hour is not that good btw
So? Make a better one 🤦🏻♂️