Lawrence on the one place where you can’t say that Trump is an indicted criminal defendant
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
- MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell analyzes the moment House Rules Committee ranking member, Jim McGovern, learned that he was in violation of the House rules for telling the truth about Donald Trump’s criminal and civil cases.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#MSNBC #Trump #criminaltrial
McGovern did not accuse or attack. He reported facts.
In upside-down world, saying anything the GOP doesn't want said meets their definition of "attack".
Just don't ask them to read that definition out loud. 😅
@@reidpinchback8850would they know adversity if it slapped them in the face? 😅😅😅 thanks, friend
@@reidpinchback8850 In fairness, most of those words were multisyllabic, which presents an undue hardship to many of the MAGA politicians.
That's what confused me about the ruling. Are they saying that it's against the rules of decorum to say that someone is currently on trial in court?
And then there's the whole farce around a presumptive nominee being treated as an official nominee, and official nominees being treated as successful. But then they need to decide if saying "The guy they want to be President is on trial" is more offensive or more of a personal attack than the incessant speculation about the actual President's mental acuity. Or how about the actual accusation from MTG that he "ordered the assassination" of the ex-President? It sounds pretty accusatory to me (one of the things the ruling said was not permitted.)
MSNBC and CNN are biased and cheap entertainment.
Bravo to Jim McGovern!
Bravo!!👏
His words are NOT stricken from the American people!!! ✊✊ GREAT JOB REP. JIM MCGOVERN!!!!!
I agree but he was only stating facts
Good for him! Speaking truth in the House is rare but welcome!
It's not rare. Democrats do it day in and day out. People just don't notice.
The only "sham" is the entire bootlicking republican party.
Absolutely true
Hey that's not fair
They also eat borscht turds 😮
🎯
We Gotta Votem Out---if they have not yet restriced voting rights in your state already!
So kind of you to say that it is "boots" that these evil Pugs are licking.
Full blown fascism on display and nobody has a clue.
No, we're all well aware of it, there's just nothing that can be done.
And can you imagine how it will be if the GOP takes back the senate?
@@Lorrddvote and help everyone and anyone to vote too!
@@Lorrddsee you in November 😂
@@Slo-rydescary just thinking about it. I can’t imagine. I never thought we would be here! Hard to imagine anything but another coup and May God helps us!
Double standards .. absolutely disgusting.. 😤🤬😤
And why is the GOP constantly yelling about censorship and editing?
The GOP complains about censorship because they ALWAYS accuse their opponents of crimes that they themselves have committed.
Because they want to do it to their opposition.
Or haven't you realized it yet?
@@PaulStSmith Of course. You always know what they did, are doing or planning to do by what they accuse or blame others for doing.
Because projection is their name. That's all they do.
HE TOLD NO LIES
If you watch MSNBC, you’re mentally disturbed person that has no clue what’s really going on in the country and enjoy being lied to. It’s amazing I come to laugh.
He did not demean or denigrate Mr Trump. Other congressmen demeaned and denigrated the courts. Yikes.
So naturally he upset the Republicans.
The funniest part is that admonishing only resulted in the clerk having to read everything he said back, which then COULDN'T be stricken from the record. DOH!
@@thejediwayThey didn't pull this out of the air yesterday.
Thank you, Jim McGovern!! We definitely need more representatives like you!! Hopefully, we Democrats will have the House back, keep the Senate and the Presidency! 💙💙💙
You think the Democrats are going to get the house back just look at the Bronx think about what’s happening in swing states and districts in for the senators and foot of course President Trump your 47th president
He’s my representative and I happily voted for him again. 💙
You are losing all three.
@@kelperdude you'll see! that's not happening 😋
Hispanics vote them D's out ahora
Wake Up People, this is scary, vote blue to save our Democracy 💙
I love that the clerk had to repeat the statement!
Welcome to what fascism actually looks like.
the U.S. has been fascist since Reagan tbh
I am from Germany: Our history is proof that fascism is worse than this. But every one of us, who was not part of this fascist regime, has the duty to do everything they can do to stop facist groups from rising.
So I want to thank you anyway. 💙
Exactly
1984, the book was a warning. Republicans are using it as their guidebook
Dictators have their political opponent arrested. Right Joe !
When facts cannot be spoken in Congress it's time to start over.
fact
💯!!
Shouldn't Congress persons at least know that Massachusetts is not pronounced MassaTUsits?
@@relax4159 That may be a speech impediment. I'm far more concerned by his aversion to SIMPLE FACTS. Nobody can govern that way. Hitler lost a war that way. May MAGA lose too. Bigly.
Jerry Lee doesn’t like words!
He must put a stop to them !
He's not speaking about personalities. He's speaking about a former President with many, many criminal counts against him.
Charges are irrelevant without a conviction.
@@TheChopf26 Well have I got news for you!
@@DjiemYT cool, it's still nothing and no one cares.
That is absolutely infuriating!
But Congressman McGovern's words not stricken from MSNBC - thank you!
And they were spoken twice!
Excellent points! Thank you!
Well, next they'll be closing those proceedings to reporters/public/video.
You can strike it from the record, but you can't strike it from the internet.
And you can NOT strike it from TRUTH
touché touché...
Actually, those with influence who control Google, which controls UA-cam can strike it from the internet.
and the dipshits can't strike it from the minds of the people
Glad the words are recorded somewhere. Glad the truth is too.
How to recognize a cult:
1. Absolute authoritarianism without accountability
2. Zero tolerance for criticism or questions
3. Lack of meaningful financial disclosure regarding budget
4. Unreasonable fears about the outside world that often involve evil conspiracies and persecutions
5. A belief that former followers are always wrong for leaving and there is never a legitimate reason for anyone else to leave
6. Abuse of members
7. Records, books, articles, or programs documenting the abuses of the leader or group
8. Followers feeling they are never able to be “good enough”
9. A belief that the leader is right at all times
10.A belief that the leader is the exclusive means of knowing “truth” or giving validation
You just described the democrats to a T.
@@TheChopf26 Bless your tiny little heart.
Well said
In the USA, telling the truth is not allowed.
Say it ain't so. We're in America.
SCARY!!!
He said absolutely nothing about the guilt or innocence of the failed former president!
He said he's on trial.
Which is a fact.
You see what you want to see and you hear what you want to hear.Its the fences many put up against enlightenment.
@@normthompson923ain't it a shame that being willfully ignorant is a right?
That's why one of my catchphrases is "Being superior is HAAAAARD..." 😅
@@librarian4life Along with an inability to properly spell simple words,gotta make momma proud.
@normthompson923 lolol yes. But also. I kinda almost get sick pleasure when someone says to me "your dumb". 😅🤣😅🤣
He's guilty. Also a fact...
Congressman McGovern spoke the truth! The American people deserve the truth!
How brave he his! Massachusetts has great representation
We have to get these totally incompetent congress people out of office.
YOU WANT THE TRUTH? REPUBLICANS CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH!🤣💙🌊
VPOTUS Burr was charged with the murder of his political opponent, never prosecuted. Truth.
@@Luked0g440 😝
"THE WORDS" - no lies, just facts.
Thank you Lawrence for recording the stricken words Jim McGovern said (not once, but twice) so I can refer to this travesty again and again in those moments that I wonder why I vote Democratic.
Give Rep McGovern a medal for standing for the American
Voice of the American people.
Lol come on..
Mexicans and Canadians will be glad to hear he represents them, along with the citizens of the United States.
And Members earn approx. $175K per annum. Were most to go into private business or legal practice (not those such as MTG or Boebert) they would earn far more.
@@markbeames7852
Unfortunately, those monies would most probably be made as a lawyer, and the Bard knows not only what we should do with lawyers, but that we have far too many, already, destroying this country for a buck.
Create and sell tee-shirts with the stricken words printed on the front & back!
Classic. The house is a clown show with maga in charge.
"The house is a clown show with [sic] BECAUSE maga IS [sic] in charge." I concur.
An insult to Bozo.
And l thought MTG and Boebert were the only ones who needed to use their fingers to follow the written word while speaking!!!!! This is disgraceful.
Every single thing that any Republican says is shockingly ignorant and illiterate.
@@ReformedRepublican for those who want term limits...this is the result.
Thank you Lawrence O’Donnell
Lawrence, thank you for making us aware of what is going on behind the scenes. Ironically, the attempt to censor these words had the opposite effect - by calling attention to them, they . . . called attention to them. A sentence that would have been passed over, instead became analyzed and repeated several times, and the _attempt_ to block them itself became an example of the shame.
MTG has said plenty about Joe Biden and Obama.
She also insulted Congresswoman Crockett!
Do you think it was appropriate for Joe Biden to shower with his teenage daughter? In her diary, she spoke of showering late at night only after her father had gone to sleep so he wouldn't join her. ---- pg 11
Yes, plenty of lies.
You have to be kidding. What's wrong with him?
The difference is every time she opens her mouth she's lying. Mcgovern spoke the truth
Jim McGovern is a giant. Wow!! Plain truth, methodically, eloquently, masterfully spoken. This is what "doing your job" looks like, House MAGA. Take note.
Yes 👍 he is. I love listening to him. And I’m listening from Europe! Americans have to recognize how smart representatives from the Democratic Party are. And look and listen what kind of stupid stuff Republicans are saying and doing. I’m shocked
MOST EXCELLENT COMMENT
@@Alma1826FIAT LUX ET VERITAS
@@Alma1826 Oh, we do listen to Trump! You can't escape him if you're a politics junkie. Don't worry, every day Republicans are leaving him. The question is, of course, whether he will "rig" the election.
Even if the MAGATS took notes they wouldn't be able to read, comprehend, or pronounce what they wrote.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻!!
🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯💯%!!!
Thank You for Reporting “THE FACTS” OF TRUTH!!!
When the truth is said it hurts
McGovern was sensational. May he be exalted everywhere!
LoL excluded
Totally
Democrats sound very angry all the time! Trump's Bronx Rally was historical Democrats and Republicans coming together. No one was left behind!
Go back home
So it's illegal to state facts in the House of Representatives?
Apparently!!! It just doesn’t make any sense!!!
apparently as long as they go contrary to 'der Trumpf'
Only about dear leader..and they will deny being fascists..
This must be stopped.
That's the verdict. However, chairperson jerry carl of Alabama stumbled over words of more than one syllable so badly, his verdict may be overturned. 🤣🤣🤣
It is most important that the maximum amount of Americans see this post Lawrence, thank you for airing that. It shows to me living in Ireland that the TRUTH doesnt matter anymore in USA. What matters are the feelings of the most despicable person on the planet. This truly is a sad state of affairs, The people of America MUST stop this foolishness in November or America is lost !!! ~sigh ~
Everyone knows he's charged, no one cares.
Right on Lawrence
Absolutely disgusting. So freaking sick of the Republican Party.
You're going to be even sicker in November. You should move to Gaza, they like people like you.
Me too!
I am sick too, sick of crime, high prices, wars we are paying for, the illegals flowing over the border, sick of Biden and his party😡
Why?
@@TDS_ExistMaga4ever
Ask David Duke
Bravo Mr McGovern, try it again tomorrow! 💙
“Unbelievable” is an understatement. 😳😱
Stricken from the official record but still on tape. And instead of it only being said by Rep McGovern, it was repeated out loud by the clerk on tape, too!
Even Jerry Lee Dummy kinda paraphrased it, as well.
Priceless...
The gop is truly off the rails.
VOTE THEM OUT!!
How pitiful that the Chair of the House can't read at a middle school level.
He follows his written script with his fingers...like a preschooler learning to read. How ridiculous!
@bumpedhishead636, that's not even middle school level reading back in my day.
Dumb as a rock.
Would somebody take over the speaker. The Democrats needs to fix this as soon as they take over, and you will, have both the house and Senate if you recognizes the black communities and listen to what they're saying. And do what's right.
This reminded me of conversations that I have with my 4 year old granddaughter.
That’s amazing that’s the truth. Why would they try to remove that from history when we know that’s the truth
this episode needs to be remembered for the farce that the Republican House has become.
When telling the truth is out of order, something is definitely out of order.
The disorder has been voted for....
The disorder has been voted for
Hmmmm ... and they will deny being fascists..
@@suehowie152 they will. And they'll even try to turn it around.
hahahahaha. I love that. thank you for making me laugh in the face of the dire circumstances.
WOW !! Powerful. Thank you for showing us the truth.
Not just unbelievable, Orwellian.
Congressmen Jim McGovern 💯% on point No lies detected
Guess you're not a lie detector, hmmm imagine that 😂
@@TDS_ExistMaga4everRichard O---You joined YT only two years ago. You're either a paid troll or a 12 year old. Please, go away. We don't need you trolling adult's trying to have an educated conversation.
Guy can't lie, he has no opinion of his own
Youre delusional @TDS_ExistMaga4ever
Holy Mother of God! Is there a single member of the GOP House that can speak, spell, or read?
Or even comprehend what the words they attempt to mouth truly mean?
Doubtful
Great question! ....um.... I can't think of one.
no. the GQP is full on idiocracy
Your guy told congress an island would tip over if more people were on it.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
They need to Say it again Tomorrow and the next day and the next.
Scary stuff
We need to get these do- nothing gop “ representatives” out. They should have to forfeit their pay.
VOTE 💙 💙 💙 💙 💙 Pro-Democracy down ballot all the way 🇺🇸⚖️ 🗽 stop the Toxicity 🎉🎉
Only the dems.
They are now FAR worse than do-nothings. They are actively working to subvert free speech and an impartial judiciary.
*Don Poorleone* stumbled into a bar...........
...........and *bankrupted* it 😂
*Don Poorleone* is better known as *Dimeless Don* nowadays.
Particularly among his myriad of attorneys 😂
ITS AGAINST THE LAW TO TALK BAD ABOUT A DICTATOR!!!
What was the Ukraine president's name again? You know the guy who just removed the election like a DICTATOR and is a close friend to Biden.
What was his name again 🤔
Love the screen name!
Yeah, but he's an _ex_ dictator...Deposed.
If you saw Ferdinand Marcos in exile in Hawaii, you're free to call him an @$$hole
Right?
YEAH, America as a branch of Russia. Cute isn't it?! V£OTE BLUE!!!
Scary!!!!!😢
Wow, just wow
What's needed is a literacy test for members of Congress.
And a Civics test on what the Congress' work actually is.
...for brain.
they cant even pass the citizenship test
And for some - not naming names Marge - an IQ test!
Hilarious great comment!! How were they voted in? Yikes!!!
That was totally illegal for the bench to do that because he was and is CORRECT.
Yup. It was outright, blatant sedition -- a crime. A crime that should get a congressturd arrested and booted from office.
Perfectly legal.
@@kelperdude I disagree.
YOU KNOW IT!!!
@@kelperdude Trump lost. More facts for you. Cope. 🇺🇸
That was very good.
That was painful
Bravo to Rep. McGovern and to you too Mr. O'Donnell for fine statements on Trump and fine interpretation of an incomprehensible Speaker's words and ruling. We will have to remember them the next time MTG or Gaetz or the rest of the MAGA crowd start railing about President Biden.
Oh that won't matter, under Republicans leadership they won't remand their own, just anyone who says things that make Dump feel bad.
Yeah, Comer goes on and on lying about President Biden committing crimes
Mr. O'Donnell's take no prisoner attitude is brilliant. Anyone who voted for the Bushes put Thomas & Alito on the SC. He is squarely blaming every single voter for the corruption & crap today from the SC. I love Mr. O'Donnell's delivery.
That won't happen. 2016 after the death of Antonin Scalia - MM No SCJ in an election year. 2020 death of RBG - MM It's all ok to seat a SCJ. The lack of shame at their two facedness is alarming.
Can this speaker ACTUALLY do ANYTHING well? I don't think he will be missed.
In a few days, he will leave Congress, and that will be perfect!!!
@@jimcannon1444 may he be followed by a great many MAGA trash representatives as well
Good ! Bye .
Thank you
The gentleman from Massachusetts is the kind of person in government that we put our faith in to run our government appropriately and correctly. I'd love to add my sarcasm in for reading correctly etc..
Joe Biden should play this clip exactly as it is in his campaign ads. EVERYWHERE
Excellent idea 🎉
Good idea.
Great idea 😁
:-)
SUEDE THE REMIX GOD!!!!!
Thank you Lawrence... for making this so public and highlighting it. Thank you.
Alabama voters send only their best to represent them in Congress.
Rep. Jerry Carl and Sen. Tommy Tuberville are shining examples of Alabama's best.
Tubervile and Carl are Alabama shining best, I would hate to see their worst.
Lawrence, you are a master Wordsmith!
I LOVE the gentleman from Massachusetts!!!👍💙
about time someone spoke THE TRUTH in the congress. UNFAIR , and YES, UNBELIEVABLE!
VOTE BLUE💙💙💙
Not to mention un- American.
This coming November 5 elect BLUE--BIDEN/HARRIS 2024.
As a former Republican it will be my honor to vote for Joe Biden in November . THIS NEEDS TO END ONCE AND FOR ALL !!!!!, 🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊
Thank you Rep.McGovern for standing up forTruth, not Lies..
McGovern - my congressman from MASS - is intelligent, competent and a fighter for the citizens in our district. He's the real deal, not like that buffoon from Alabama, who can't even read! Holy Crap!!!
Define truth - MAGA mush brain propaganda is truth now?!? LOL
Rep Jerry Carl apparently could have really benefited from some Sesame Street and Reading Rainbow
UNBELIEVABLE!!! THANK YOU, LAWRENCE AND TEAM!!!!
The press should make that speech go viral
It was fantastic !!
I posted it on my page. Share it!
The clerk adds something to it with her tone as she reads the exact words to be struck from the record.
How embarrassing. A member of the House of the most powerful country of the world cannot read better than a 6-year old.
Even more embarassing is that the former USA president has a comparable reading level.
The GOP is a disgusting disgrace.
And you can bet your bottom dollar , BOTH scream about people needing to be able to speak English if they live here .
@@reggieharper1622 You really have a point there! 🤣🤣🤣
Product of an Alabama education.
This is beyond frightening..
Leave the words UP‼️
He's stating facts about the nominee of the GOP.
He is Not yet the nominee! The speaker didnt even get that right.
So sorry, but you’re wrong. That whole song and dance concerned the PRESUMPTIVE nominee. Neither DJT nor JRB are NOMINEES yet. I’m waiting for the next MAGA rant about Joe Biden.
IS that Ole' Party Grand?
For Gods sake America, stop voting republican. If you vote for anyone with an R beside their name you’ve done something wrong. It’s that simple.
What is this? Are we, as Americans, this stupid?
Obviously yes.... 😱
So is removing the words then reading them out not the Streisand effect?
THANK YOU!!!!
PLEASE SIR! MCGOVERN,
GIVE US MORE!!!
MORE!!!!
Dear Lord! It’s no wonder why so many of the old GOP Republicans resigned or retired EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY!
Yeah, I thought I had legitimate reasons to hold Republicans in low esteem, but I know better now. I miss having a professional counterpart. Today's GOP is an absolutely transparent sanctimonious abomination.
Those few prinipled Republicans should NOt HAVE RETIRED. They should ahve used their positon to RAISE THEIR VOICES against MAGA GOP. Selfish of them to leave. But, they prbably have a ice gig waiting for them post=Congress so, they LOST NOTHING. The country NEEDS every SANE person who can RESIST fascism.
@user-cz5lj2vx1f
They probably realized 'should' t get back in they would NOT be recognized w/n the party or have any authority or would be ridiculed and would NOT be effective in helping their constitutionants.
You can only do so much when you are not part of the 'favorites'.
Almost all the good ones are gone. Just MAGAts left.
MSMBC Thank you for sharing.
How about that Bronx rally! What an event! Too big to rig!!!
Jim McGovern is seriously one of my favorite people!
Never heard of her
So I gotta ask . . . should you make it a requirement that your lawmakers can actually read and write???? ps. there was NO insult and No accusation, just a statement that he was CHARGED !
That would be a good start because their job description should require them to understand the bills they read, write and vote on.
That's the problem with electing high school dropouts and former athletic coaches to Congress.
Watching Jim McGovern's speech on the House floor was the most fun I've had watching the news in ages. Brilliant.
He argues his point brilliantly!
We love you, Lawrence. Thank you for your fabulous work to defend our democracy against GOP dictatorial intent to get Trump back to the WH.
His shows get worse each night.
@@user-sp7rr5yc7j Try speaking English
*Odorous Don* waddled into a courtroom...........
...............and *fumigated* it 😂
*Odorous Don* is of course better known as *The God Farter* these days.
For obvious and tremendously eye-watering reasons 😂
Now we know exactly why big grown men were saying "Sir....Sir..." with tears in their eyes.
There was literally *odor in the courtroom* 😂
You can’t take words down from the Internet! 💙🌊🇺🇸2024
Thank you Sir. I couldn't figure out what he was saying! Good thing he is leaving!!!
Oh dear. This minute clause could be the end of what has been the only real democracy. Please keep working. I can’t imagine life without democracy.
Orwellian.
Not anymore..Now it's called maga.
Dystopian.
Unbelievable. It is like listening to a four year old learning to read.
Thank you! I came to the comments looking for this. No grown, literate person uses his finger to point to every word he's trying, yes trying, to read! Unbelievable! And he's the leader in the House? Mispronounced words left, right and center, especially Massachusetts? Smh 😮😢
He said "Mississtippi"
Hooked on phonics must be banned in Mississippi
I've known dogs who can pronounce English better.
All he needs is a ruler to use as a guide to read...
It would be a terrible shame if those words struck from the record were put on the internet for everyone to hear...
Excellent reporting! This is appalling! I have yet come find this report any where else!
Very many thanks.
Thank you Jimmy McGovern, and Lawrence!!!!!
For?
@@TDS_ExistMaga4ever It's over your head, that's for sure.
@@TDS_ExistMaga4ever We would never know without this report by Lawrence O'Donnell. Thank you for informing us. MAGA needs to be stamped out; The cult is a threat to American freedoms, and democracy itself.
He wasn't commenting on personality. He was stating facts about a defendant in a criminal case. Not opinions about if it was a shame or not, or opinions about the judge. If they are going to be striking mentioning of Trump and his trial than it should be disallowed from both sides, not just the opposing side only.
Trump's personality is officially criminal now.
Not even mutual censorship for both parties is acceptable. That is dictatorship. Even banning republicans from calling Trump's trial a sham is dictatorship. We cannot have censorship of political opinions in the house. But this pop up clown presiding here, who desperately needs a remedial reading class before we address anything intellectual, has gone beyond SNL material here!
I find it discomforting that the Truth is prohibited on the floor of the House of Representatives.
all those people using phones and constantly moving around behind the guy talking were SO distracting.
Distracting, annoying, and downright embarrassing to this once-great country of ours.
We can't handle the truth.