Neil Young Harvest 50th Deluxe Boxset: Is it Really Worth The Money?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 вер 2024
- Link to Michael45 Analogue Production Webshop:
shop.michael45...
Important: Subscribe to the Newsletter at the end of the main Page!!!!
Germany:
Neil Young: Harvest 50th An. Deluxe Box amzn.to/3B8wD6Z
USA
Neil Young: Harvest 50th An. Deluxe Box amzn.to/3iBxQxr
United Kingdom
Neil Young: Harvest 50th An. Deluxe Box amzn.to/3UvTctf
Comparison Video:
• Milestones: Neil Young...
Seems as I get older, the more appreciation I develop for Neil Young. Well recorded with a great sound stage - so I ordered my Boxset !
You are awesome, Michael. Thanks so much for posting this video while still recovering! We appreciate you; I hope you are feeling back to 100% very soon.
After seeing this I'm in, always glad to see something new/old from Neil Young. He truly is quite an artist.
I received my copy yesterday and it is a beautiful box set. There is enough bonus content to make this a necessary buy even for us longtime neil fans, unlike the after the gold rush box set. I hope neil will continue this with his other albums.
One of his all-time greatest moments in music history. Still waiting for Mirrorball reissue on vinyl...my most beloved Neil Young albums alongside with Harvest and Weld.
Hey Michael, greetings from Radio Tower Records in Berlin. In 1972 I was trying to find my way in the world on my own as a very young teenager in England. To earn some money to buy records I did some strange jobs including working at a bird sanctuary. And on a rainy Sunday a guy - it’s true - asked me if I would like to listen to some music. What did he play me? Harvest of course. And throughout that year much, much more which built a foundation for my musical knolwedge. 50 years later I’m still listening to Harvest and I still have the single ‘Heart Of Gold /Sugar Mountain’.
God bless all of you that can afford all of these various box sets
This vinyl comes at the right 🎅 time.
A very nice Christmas gift.
Michael take hot tea with rum against the flu.
Off to bead and have a rest.
We need you and your time 💯 to make our dreams come true.
❤️Heike
I wish Linda Ronstadt vinyl albums could get decent remasters.
Thank you, Michael. And hope you feel better soon!
Take care of yourself Michael. Great box set, I just ordered it. Great album, Neil always top quality.
I have ordered the box, thanks for another inspiring video from. Of course I have the previous edition. Here in Norway, Harvest is twice as expensive as regular LP, but is worth it, because the quality of the paper, the design and just touching the records gives an experience. One of those album covers, in its design, that captures the music to its perfection. The box is expensive compared to what I get with another artist, I don't agree, but this is counterwork.
Personally, I especially value music with a timelessness, Neil Young and The Band's productions from this time are, in 100 years you find Harvest under a rock in Colorado, it still makes sense. In the same way as classic novel. The documentary about Harvest will be completely unique, with film frequencies from the studio. The Old man that the song is about is available as an interview subject, so the record rises so much with this material, which cannot be obtained anywhere else but the box. That's what it should be with box with this price, a whole, nothing can be removed.
It is very rewarding to see reactions from when people hear a song for the first time. There are many of these on youtube, "Old man" from Harvest hits a tender emotional spot with many (as does Dark side of the moon/Pink Floyd), it's rap artists, youth, music lovers, professional, everyone just loves Neil Young.They all say, this Neil Young I have to listen to more. He stands above the music, epic record. One of the criteria for receiving the Nobel Prize in Literature is that it must be universal, for all different cultures and eras. Not stuck in a form of cult club. Even then, the the literature can be difficult to access, but has a design that breaks down barriers between people and enhance the senses.
Vocal Coach reacts to Neil Young - Old Man
ua-cam.com/video/ppSF6JpdaKQ/v-deo.html
MrLboyd Reacts
ua-cam.com/video/rDI_9Sqe2wQ/v-deo.html
You just showed me one of my Christmas gifts. Very nice.
Aloha Michael,
First and foremost, sending positive ✨ 🙏 vibes for a speedy recovery.
Thank you ,Michael on your review of this Neil Young's Harvest Deluxe Box set.
The quality is amazing which it should be for the price. I would like to hear more of your comparison when you're fully recovered from your flu.
Michael, I always used your insights when I'm purchasing record albums for quality sound, & your recommendations hasn't steered me wrong.
Hopefully Santa 🎅 knows where Hawaii is located so he'll know who's Christmas 🎄tree to put the Neil Young Harvest Deluxe Box set under....lol
MELE KALIKIMAKA
Mahalo Ed
Mahalo Ed
Young"s catalogue is hard to top & Harvest is one of the best for sure !
It's great to see you're better now. What a beauty... amazing box. Nice Michael. Thanks for the video
A beautiful set. Got my copy for Christmas. Just watched footage of Neil Young in a LA record shop, filmed in 1972 (You Tube). He finds a bootleg of his music, walks out of the shop with it without paying for it saying "This my music". A wild time capsule, record store open at night in Los Angeles and Neil Young walks in
Yes, great clip! :)
I read on the Steve Hoffman forums that some people have experienced poor audio quality on the BBC In Concert DVD such as low frequency distortion making it unlistenable, although the UA-cam videos uploaded on the official Neil Young channel sound fine.
My all time fav Neil young's LP..."I am still searching for the heart "OG"...get well Michael..
I"ve been floating about checking channels - I've been here in the past, but the Mofi thing sucked up everything at the time and there was no way I thought I'd get a true impression of the Different Channels; yours included. So, I held off making a comment of the channel till things had cooled and returned to day-to-day experiences before MoFi. --- I'm still waiting to make a comment, but I ENJOYED YOUR SHOW and it's content and wanted to at least share that. - m.
$127 for Harvest I guess I am old school will look for old Neil in the bins but no doubt great album
Thank you for battling through the flu to deliver another fine vinyl review. Get well soon Michael and best wishes from Atlanta GA USA
Get better soon Michael. I think it’s a good idea to do a Neil Young ranking by end of year.
Great video as always Michael, I hope you feel better soon, take care, get some rest and stay well, cheers.
Why Epic is not doing the same for Donovan's "Gift From a Flower to a Garden" is beyond me. Released in '67 and '68 it was one of the first box set double records ever released. It needs the full modern treatment.
We need more donovan
Michael, in my opinion the most important thing is the music and the quality of the pressing and no packaging or the hype sticker or poster. I put a vinyl on my platter and not the box 😊
Glad you are feeling a little better.
wow, what a fantastic box set. packed with goodies :-)
might be worth your investing in some sort of overhead camera set up? I'd hate to see you drop a book or bend a page just to show us the content.
and I'm Welsh!! Home from the WC before the postcards!!!
Thanks for showing us the book!
Hope you’re feeling better now. This box set looks wonderful!
Looking forward to this. Here in the UK we’ve al had a really nasty flu, floored all of us for days.. hope you’re feeling better.
2 years ago they called that covid and treated you like an animal
Also, I do remember reading something a while back where Neil Young said something like he really didn't like the Harvest album that much. I actually really enjoy Harvest but it's really a dark album. It's also recorded super flat with a ton of bass. Neil Young is a business man and he's revisiting and digging up things to issue like the Homegrown LP that came out a few years back and now available at a major discount on websites. I purchased and played it once. It's not that good. From what I read Neil didn't like it at the time and didn't move forward and release it. That was a good decision.
Great job. Hope you feel better soon, brother. Love from Knoxville, Tennessee.
Thank you so much for your review Michael of this quality box set from this amazing album especially considering you are not well . And as you say this is the way a box set should be done in this very high standard great review and I wish you a most speedy recovery all the best cheers Carl .
I am glad your are feeling better, Michael. Thank you for the review.
I hope you get well soon, Michael!
Listening to Harvest is good for the soul but hopefully it will help with your cold too, take care of yourself
Michael take care of yourself brother!
Feel better!!
Box looks great. Will definitely be picking that up at some point. Although I don’t really feel i need the lp again. My original is great
Great episode as usual. Box sets do seem to be the vogue. They make more money than an album alone I should think. The reissue after reissue thing too is becoming passe.
It's a novelty now but a good way to own a rare lp.
Get well soon ❤
Thank you for another great review. It is always interesting to see what gets included in these anniversary boxsets.
As far as the football goes, there have been some unexpected results throughout the tournament so far and likely there will be more before the conclusion.
Wishing you a speedy recovery and resumption of normal service!
Great review Michael. Still on the fence on this one but you may have pushed me over. 😊 Feel better!
Posters are always a disappointment, impossible to get the creases out if one wants to frame it. Thanks for making this video, especially considering your health. Get well soon Michael.
Happy to support the channel by using your affiliate link, Michael, for my purchase. Thanks for all that you do!
I really kind of wonder if record collecting especially with these highly priced and climbing reissues is more like a heroin addiction
It can definitely be an addiction. I always defend that by saying at least it’s not drugs.
@taralewis9916 I think it is to a lot of people. I think these box sets are cash grabs and never worth the asking price. Booklets, posters and dvds are not that important to me. I can buy several albums for the price of this. You don't have to keep up with the Jones' do whsat you want, it's your choice and your money.
@@stephensmall4172 I agree. I did buy the single Harvest LP reissue which is all analog and sounds great. I'm done.
hope you feel better
i appreciate your dedication
The original album came with the same lyric sheet insert and also an inner sleeve that was beige/brown which matched the colour of the album cover.
Agree, it's an amazing boxset
Hi Michael. I agree with all you said. I am going way of the cd set and cannot wait to hear how it sounds. NY is a treasure and a monster musician in every way.
Feel like I've seen this all already in the movie he did in 74', Journey Through The Past....he didnt need the money, having sold his Catalog. Not sure what this was really about---we've seen all of this before with Journey Through The Past---photos, film clips, interviews,...guess its for true collectors, die hards willing to pay for it all. Love the music, not big on paying big for reissues. "Peace and Love, Lennons Goodbye"...
Nice presentation, Michael.
I bought the standard LP version, but it has a lot of surface-noise and no-fills so I’ll return it - and in the proces upgrade to this box set 😊
Hope you’re feeling better soon Michael 😊.
Great review & video.
I love the box set beautifully presented,top quality set.
Michael I messaged you in the OBC,making a few points.Just to say
It’s definitely a new cut by Chris Bellman for the 50th anniversary.New matrix numbers etc .I personally think he has re cut so it’s not his 2009 version.Take a look at both dead waxes the new harvest has a bigger dead wax compared to 2009 version & yet they are both 33rpm with the same number of songs,
Take it easy ,get better soon 🙌👍
wow .... thats interesting
@@Michael45RPM yes Michael compare the two,same information but in less grooves or grooves tighter together 😉
Wishing you get well soon. Football is a passion thing, like audio and hifi. But was odd to see Germany out so soon. And a pitty, to be honest. But the beauty of the game is, it all restarts in 4 years. 2, if you consider the Euro. And that one will take place in Germany!
A great video as always Michael , i have been very tempted to buy the box set and your video detailing and showing the content has persuaded me to order it .
With regards to the football it would be a lie from an english perspective not to have had a little smile when Germany failed to go through the group stages , although you have taken any laughs at your expense with good humour . Anyway England can't be too complacent playing Senegal tomorrow , a win for us is far from guaranteed . Keep up with the brilliant informative album videos.
Is it worth $150.00 and sounding the same as the older edition? It seems to me that these days we are invaded by deluxe sets of great albums from the past costing well North of a $100.00. Not in my honest opinion, I will not spend that money. I buy records to listen to them and not worried about stickers or other items that fill those thick enclosures. A standard jacket, if properly taken care, will last a lifetime. For that price I can buy 5-6 new records and will take the same room as that "deluxe set" with just a little over 37 minutes of music. No, not for me.
I hope you feel better, don't forget Vit. D and Zinc to boost your immune system.
I just recently bought the Original 1st pressing from 1972 and today picked up 1978 reissue in EX + condition. Going to be interesting to hear those differences in sound or mastering.
Hey Michael. Glad you're feeling better. Huge Neil fan. I streamed the bonus content and it is wonderful. I don't know if I will buy it since I have so much Neil including the Archive sets. The main draw for me is that documentary so I actually might buy the deluxe CD edition with the film. But good review and helpful to me! Be well
Nice review Michael, thanks. I will get this now, and since the After The Gold Rush box is down to around $50.00 I'll probably buy it too, not quite as bad a ripoff for an lp, a 7", and a box, as it was at the pre-order price.
Nice. Just a suggestion… wouldn’t it be easier for you to show books by editing in a segment with the book on a table and the camera overhead?
Agreed. They make special camera and light setups just to show flat art and books. They work great! I've used them with lectures.
The quality does indeed look great Michael. But the £164 price is too high. If the cds were included as well, then I would stretch and make it happen.
As it stands I'm ok with the cd box set for £48. I already have the 2009 vinyl. So it would only be the BBC live vinyl that I'd be getting, in effect, difference. I tend to get all of his live archive stuff on CD anyway. Good luck with the flu.
Oh, and feel better!
Get well soon🤘
I feel your pain, Michael. As a Belgian i was mildly devestated that we were kicked out too. But that’s football, as unpredictable as life itself. Luckily, we have all that good music to listen to.
Thanks for this vid. I decided for the CD variant, as it cost only €45. Nicely done package as well.
Hope you’ll feel better soon!
Oh that was a wild game between Croatia and Belgium. Could have gone either way. I was really impressed with how well De Bruyne played. Not surprising as he is a fantastic player... one of the best. OK, now we will continue on with the ageless Modric leading the way. Cheers!! 🇭🇷🇭🇷🇭🇷🇭🇷🇭🇷
@@terrywho22 Thanks! Unfortunately this was De Bruyne’s only good game. On top of that our now ex-coach has been trusting too long on our ‘golden generation’, while he could have used some more young talent. But unfortunately that’s the way the game went. I think Modric is an out-of-this-world player. I have never seen him play a mediocre game. I’ve always liked the Croatian team (as off 1998), i hope they go far again. Good luck!
@@musiclassica Many thanks!!! I also noticed that De Bruyne saved his best for us. That's great to hear that you've been following since the Suker/Prosinecki years. Yes, love watching Modric play. We've got some great young players like Gvardiol and Majer, but it will be very sad day when Luka retires.
@@terrywho22 I’m watching the game and rooting for you. 👍👍
And it paid off! Congratulations to CRO!
Every time I watch your videos I want to get a hair cut 👍
Just cleaned my copy and then watched your wonderful video, now to pour a drink and put the record on. Thanks, and all the best!
I really do love the earlier version with the Bellman mastering. But I just cannot buy another version of this record - there are too many other records to buy. If I didn’t already have the 2009 reissue yes the boxed set is a must have…
Hope you feel better Michael
From Ecuador here Michael 😢
Sad to see your team go so soon…
Damn that book looks great
Very Nice Micheal!! Always Loved The Cover And Art Work!!
Hope you’re feeling better soon
Ich wollte ein ähnliches Video auf Deutsch machen. Aber als ich den Preis (450€) sah, war ich draußen... Grüße aus Köln! Gutes Video.
Very cool. I was gonna pass on this one, but now I have to pick it up!
Schnelle Heilung!🙏🏻
Nice video, Michael; have just subscribed. I have dual nationality, but only one of my teams was in the World Cup. But still, I was cheering for Germany. And yes, Germany will be back.
i hope it has the rough frained paper for the album cover as it had when i first bought it.
Was once a huge fan until this AH showed us his true colors. Done with Neil for good !
Each to their own, but to me boxsets are cash grabs . I am into the music and not booklets or dvds of "the making of" To me none of the box sets add up to the price they charge, and why isnt a straight forward single album not offered?
The difference between the 2009 and the new press is the Cut by Chris Bellman is not the same, it's a new cut.
Michael, are you aware of latest krautrock reissues? I was hoping to see a review of "Cluster II" 50th anniversary release and of the upcomming Walter Wegmuller "Tarot".
Thanks for another great video
I hope he does a Landing on water deluxe. That is my favourite.
Are all your records flat? Every third I get is warped. It’s getting frustrating.
wow thats strange ..
@@Michael45RPM Do you look at the turntable or just by hand? It’s so much worse the last 6-12 months. Like everything is to stressed at the plants.
I have purchased 50 or 60 albums in the past 6 months. Almost all 180gm except for 3 200gm UHQR pressings. None were warped. A few had scuffed areas right out of the jacket, bu none warped.
I’d love to share some videos but not possible here it seems.
Ashamed to admit I have no "Neil Young " records 😕! I guess I just did, I WILL do something about that 😀!
Best way to fight illnesses is building your immune system! All this covering your face , avoiding germs , over sanitizing is detrimental to your natural defenses! You don't have to be a doctor to figure that out! This comment will probably be taken down because it contains TRUTH! UA-cam doesn't like truth! Sorry, I was hoping to avoid politics but I felt like I had to say what I felt! If anybody hates me for that, well, stand in line!
Cheers Michael - I’m holding back on this box set because I’ve more Neil Young vinyl than I’ve had hot dinners lol😂 ATGR and Harvest were my NY education [I still have my Harvest sheet music book which is in the same card] and original Harvest LP… Like the spectacles - what designer are they…?
Yes! Germany football will raise again!
Neil Young did his own unboxing video
I’m not a Neil Young fan. I’m a 45rpm fan 😊
First they release it as a reissue, then wait a bit then reissue it again as a box set. First they issue it as a UHQR as a 33RPM then wait a bit then reissue it again as a 45RPM. Then they spice it up with: buy it now or cry later. How in the heck am I going to keep up with the Jones....
You don’t even waste energy trying .
@@anthonyburke223 I know
This from Neil on his Archives website:
"We have an issue with the quality of one of the discs in HARVEST 50th. We are talking to Reprise about how to handle this so you get what you paid for. I am very sorry if you have a DVD that is not perfect. We are working on a plan with Reprise for those of you who feel the BBC DVD has a problem and we will let you know when we have something to offer you and a good method.
apologies
ny"
The sound is really distorted when he sings a little bit louder.....
By the way, all CD's that suffer from this damn "Loudness War" Mastering sound that way to me^
The live gig sounds like its worth it alone
Think the concert is available on UA-cam
Michael, did you see the second Argentinian goal against Australia? If not, have a look. That Australian goalie should never play for Australia again. Shocking.
have u heard neil's new album, world record", would like to ear your thoughts on it, maybe a video???
keep up the good work :)
Neil was writing poetry
Especially those of us who have always had jttp
It’s on a rampage for sure. I had COVID for the first time two weeks ago. Still don’t have the new Harvest though. 😢
Michael ,are a friend and dear part of the music loving community,PLEASE watch your health!You been feeling poorly for TOO long.I have lost many people I enjoy. I do NOT want you to be one of them. Doc BC
On this one, I really feel like I’ve already thrashed through this material. I feel this record is slightly overrated Nevertheless 5 copies that I have are enough
But what does it sound like? And is the pressing clean?
click the link in the videodescription
I have a Harvest original Lp that sounds better than the first cd release from the 80s. Much clearer. More punch. Will not spend more on harvest.